This is the third album from these British indie folksters who flirt with rock music less, and indulge in more woodwinds and jazz-tinged passages this time around. The vocals are what anchors them in indie rock, as the more folk notions lie in the poetic melodies that run the center course of their songs. Most of it flows really well and seems like how things just progressed. There is a more Beatles-like tone to things on this album. It reminds me of the more quaint pastoral moments from the White Album. The vocal lines on "Socks" wander around a little more. The production quality is the most notable growth as the mix balances all the layers of strings and woodwinds.
Kate Bush could also be an influence that peers through in some of the more odd vocal phrasings that dance around the instrumentation, think her "Lionheart" era here. If this album gets the proper push, it's already evident in the first three songs that this band could break into a bigger audience with this album, as this could be embraced at local coffee shops everywhere. The arrangements also show great maturity in how these songs evolve. "Salem Sister" does a more delicate dance against the harpsichord and strings. The lyrics feel a little more abstract this time around. I would not say these songs are all that hooky, though impressive in the scope of what is being accomplished. Dynamic in a manner that most indie rock is not.
When things take a more balladesque turn on "Two Horses," there is a slight wink to Joni Mitchell. The bass line to this one creates a 70s groove. It does take you on a more unexpected adventure than what the beginning of the song suggests, with plenty of jazz infused into it in a very progressive rock manner. "Mary" is a more straightforward folk song. Guitars with a more rock intention creep into "Happy Birthday' to further the Beatles comparisons.
They go back into a more folky feel with "For the Old Country". Normally, any song over the five-minute mark on this album finds the band embarking on a wild excursion. This one proves to be dynamic, but it does not venture too far from the main theme. "Nancy Tries to Take the Night" finds a more jazz embellished wandering being embarked upon with some great drumming to propel it. "Maxwell's Sliver Hammer" is the best point of reference for the direction it heads. The title track is a more subdued folk musing It almost makes me think of something Bjork might due in one of her less experimental moments. 'It's fitting that "Goodbye" should close the album. It's more of a romantic pining with a slight country element to it. It's a pretty solid song, less wandering and abstract, that has a clear narrative rather than elusive bits of abstraction.I will give this album a 9 and see how it grows on me, despite the brilliant compositions I did not rate it higher due to the stream of consciousness vocals that could have hooked me in a little more , but hard not to appreciate what they are doing here.
10.3