Those that have read my book and follow my blog will know how much I love the stories that follow edible plants around the world and discovering those ornamental plants that I had never expected could be used in the kitchen, turning them into edimentals! My book Around the World in 80 plants is full of them! The plant known as little vegetable garden fish in Brazil is a case in point and I have to thank Kyle Dougherty for alerting to me to this unlikely edible on my Edimentals and Perennial Vegetables Facebook group. Brazil isn’t a likely place to search for novel edibles that would be hardy enough to grow in my 63.4°N garden. However, I actually grew this plant for many years before removing it to make way for edible plants. It is Stachys byzantina (syn. S. lanata or S. olympica), lamb’s-ear or woolly hedge nettle (lammeøre here in Norway). It is a perennial in the Lamiaceae or mint family which is native to Armenia, Iran, and Turkey but has been cultivated throughout the temperate world as an ornamental plant, and has escaped, naturalising in many locations. Here in Norway, it doesn’t seem to produce seed, so only spreads vegetatively. It is surprisingly very hardy and is said to be worth trying more or less anywhere here.
Photo by Derek Ramsey https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=2559344
By Jean-Pol GRANDMONT – Own work, CC BY-SA 3.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=21409910
So, how is it that the use of this plant from West Asia and known as “peixinhos da horta”, literally little vegetable garden fish in Brazil, is more or less isolated to that country today? In Brazil, the dish and plant have the same name. Some suggest that the name little garden fish is because the taste is fish-like, but others say that it doesn’t taste of fish at all. It’s more likely that it’s because the fried and battered leaves resemble small fish and maybe the association leads to people experiencing a fishy taste? There are a number of “how to” videos on youtube, with and without egg (à Milanesa) (see, https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=peixinho+da+horta)
It is said that the plant is also used as tea, in omelettes, pasta, steamed and in salads (youngest leaves). Over the last 10 years several studies of non-conventional vegetables including this plant and its preparation have been published addressing also medicinal uses and nutrition; e,g., “Stachys byzantina (Lamiaceae) has a high nutrient content compared with conventional vegetables including vitamin C, carbohydrates, lipids, proteins, high fiber content, minerals (potassium, calcium, magnesium, phosphorus, sulfur, copper, iron, manganese, zinc and boron) and high content of phenolic compounds which gives antioxidant activity” (Aguiar et al., 2020). However, the dish of the same name in Portugal is made from cut green bean pods, coated in batter, and fried in oil at high temperatures, but is also prepared with other vegetables, such as pumpkin and green peppers. Intriguingly, these green beans, usually Phaseolus vulgaris, travelled the other way from the Americas to Europe. Was the use of Stachys byzantina in this dish an old way of preparing it which has now died out or did it evolve independently in Brazil based on the basic recipe (there are strong connections of course between Portugal and Brazil). I haven’t been able to find an answer to this question but the fact that the Portuguese name for the plant is peixinho-da-horta , lambari or simply peixinho suggests it was used in the past. The Portuguese wiki page states only that the plant is used in Brazil or was it the other way round and the inspiration came from Brazil? I have only found one reference in the ethnobotanical literature to Stachys byzantina being wild foraged in its native area. Civelek and Balkaya (2013) list some 19 wild vegetables in the Black Sea region of Turkey, providing a nutritional analysis of all and stating only that the leaves are roasted. The table below from this paper lists all 19.
Table of wild foraged species and how they are used in the Black Sea region (Civelek and Balkaya, 2013)
A number of cultivars exist including white flowering and dwarf forms (see https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/search-results?query=stachys%20byzantina): ‘Big Ears’ – leaves very large, up to 25 cm long. ‘Cotton Boll’ – a sterile cultivar that does not produce flowering stems. Asexually propagated. ‘Primrose Heron’ – leaves yellow in spring; flowers pink ‘Sheila Macqueen’ – sterile; low-growing; leaves large. ‘Silky Fleece’ – grows 25 cm tall with lilac-plum flowers, produce smaller white-woolly foliage. Seed propagated. ‘Silver Carpet’ – sterile; leaves grey. Asexually propagated. ‘Striped Phantom’ – leaves variegated. There are other examples of plants that have travelled far before being adopted in another country far from home. Shungiku or chopsuey greens (Glebionis coronaria),is an important supermarket vegetable today in Japan, but there are only sparse records of use in the past in the Mediterranean countries where it originated. See https://www.edimentals.com/blog/?p=22710 A story says that the dish peixinhos da horta was introduced to Japan by Portuguese sailors Antonio da Mota, Francisco Zeimoto and Antonio Peixoto in the sixteenth century, where it was eventually developed into tempura: I wonder what plants were used at that time. Did our lamb’s ears make another long journey together with the recipe? In Japanese the plant is known as cotton chorogi. Chorogi is another edible in the Stachys genus, S. sieboldii, also known as the Chinese artichoke (see picture gallery of other edibles in the genus Stachys below). I found at least one page Stachys byzantina, a largely ornamental plant also in Japan, is prepared with tempura – see https://ameblo.jp/eruma56/entry-11581777515.html (it notes, however, that this plant arrived in Japan in the early 20th century). Stachys byzantina is also of value to many insects and hummingbirds (the latter in the Americas, of course), but in particular bees. The wool carder bee / storullbie (Anthidium manicatum) even collects the fuzz from the leaves, used in nest making in decayed wood. It has also been documented that bumble bees congregate early in the day to collect the water condensation that has accumulated on the leaves. This is therefore a multi-purpose plant, edible, nature friendly as well as ornamental, what I term an edi-ento-mental!
Anthidium manicatum by Bruce Marlin – Own work, CC BY-SA 2.5, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=662209
Here are pictures of a few other plants in the genus Stachys:
Stachys affinis (chorogi or chinese artichoke)
Stachys palustris (marsh woundwort /åkersvinerot)
Stachys palustris and Verbascum thapsus in the Edible Gardeb
Stachys officinalis (betony / legebetonie) in Bulgaria
Seed of Stachys officinalis from the Edible Garden
Stachys sylvatica (hedge woundwort /skogsvinerot)
Civelek, C. and Balkaya, A. 2013. The nutrient content of some wild plant species used as vegetables in Bafra Plain located in the Black Sea Region of Turkey. The European J. Plant Science and Biotechnology. Aguiar, T., Nues, A. and de Souza Damasceno, M., 2020. Unconventional food plants foud in Santa Catarina State: nutritional and therapeutic potential. Revista Eletrônica Científica Ensino Interdisciplinar. Mossoró, v.6, #18 (see http://dx.doi.org/10.21920/recei72020618731753)
During a powerful wind storm earlier in the year one of my oldest sallow / selje trees on the edge of the wild part of the garden was wind thrown and fell over the part of my garden most resembling a forest garden where my impressive 20-year old udo (Aralia cordata) is located. Luckily, it did no damage to my apple trees and the trunk is hanging horizontally over this area with part of the root still attached and what was the top of the tree now in full flower right next to the pathway down the garden. Salix caprea is dioecious with male and female flowers on separate trees. This one is female. I have over the years become more and more aware of the incredible importance of Salix caprea in providing food in early spring to a myriad of insects – wild bees, bumble bees, moths etc., all programmed to emerge at this time. In addition, it is host in Norway to 260 moth and butterfly species at the larval stage! This then leads to this tree being an important source of food to a range of birds and some like the chiffchaff (gransanger) are also programmed to return at sallow flowering time. During visits to my mum in Southern England in March / early April I visit other fallen sallows to look for interesting insects and I’ve noticed that they can continue flowering for several years after falling and resprout from the part of the root in the soil. So, although I was initially saddened bye the loss, this is just one of several large sallow trees in this part of the garden and now I have the top of a sallow at eye level right next to a path in the garden and can now study visiting insects closely. Just now, I saw an early bumblebee / markhumle (Bombus pratorum) feeding on the catkins. It’s also a perfect place to hang my moth trap (picture)! Hence “A blessing in disguise” (Norwegian: hell i uhell). See also https://www.edimentals.com/blog/?p=32035
A small tortoiseshell (neslesommerfugl) feeding on male catkins during a visit to my son and family on Nesodden last week)
I have some great news to share! My word edimentals, “invented” some 17 years ago to describe those amazing plants that are both edible and ornamental – has just gone mainstream in the UK with an 8 page article written by me and published in the April edition of the RHS magazine The Garden (600,000 circulation) and one of my multi species salads even graces the front page. On the back of various show gardens at the Chelsea Flower Show in London over the last couple of years profiling edimentals and numerous magazine articles featuring one of horticulture’s buzz words. I was contacted by the RHS last November to see if I would be interested in writing an article – who’s better than the word’s inventor to write this feature for the magazine they said! There’s also a nice interview with Mandy Barber of The Incredible Vegetables nursery on perennial vegetables! I enclose pictures of the article and a picture of the front page. I’ve been a member of the RHS since the early 80s and, although my interest is edible plants, I’ve always enjoyed the magazine for its focus on plants. Although the focus had largely been ornamental, I recognised the edible value! With greatly increased interest in edibles and nature friendly gardening within the RHS, the magazine can only get better, so please consider joining! As I mention in the article and my book Around the World in 80 plants, my first perennial vegetable was sea kale and I bought so-called sea kale thongs (root cuttings) through an advert I read in The Garden when visiting my gardening friend Robin Allan in Hexham in the early 80s! One of those plants is still alive in my garden today. My other portmanteau words edi-ento-mental and edi-avi-mental are still waiting for adoption! They refer of course to plants that are both edible and ornamental and either insect (e.g., pollinator) or bird friendly and there are even a few quadruple value plants that tick all 4 boxes! Please buy my book from the publishers Permanent Publications in the UK: https://www.permanentpublications.co.uk/port/around-the-world-in-80-plants-an-edible-perennial-vegetable-adventure-for-temperate-climates-by-stephen-barstow or directly from me in Norway! Below the pdf higher resolution article and picture below you may find an extended list of favourite edimentals suggested by my 5,000 strong Edimentals and Perennial Vegetables FB group.
Of all the perennial vegetables out there, which do you think are the tastiest? This was the question I posed the 5,000 members of my FB group Edimentals and Perennial Vegetables, founded in 2011! This has been the most popular thread ever! These were the answers (comments by members; numbers refer to number of members mentioning the plant) : Homesteader’s Kaleidoscope Perennial Kale Grex and Taunton Deane kale (4), asparagus (4), Toona sinensis, yellow daylily (flower buds) (2), skirret (6), sea kale (shoots and broccolis) (4), Aralia elata (in tempura), cow parsnip (Heracleum maximum; young leaves and flower stalks) (2), Hosta shoots and young leaves (4), Japanese bladdernut Staphylea bumalda (leaves and flower buds), hop (shoots), garlic chives, Campanula takesimana (leaves; Korean bellflower) (2), Tilia sp. (young leaves) (2), marshmallow (shoots; Althaea officinalis), Rhus typhina (peeled shoots; staghorn sumac), Typha sp. (bulrush: shoots and rhizomes), groundnut (Apios americana) (4), Babington’s leek and other wild leeks (2), crosnes (Chinese artichokes) (3), Turkish rocket (broccolis), Hablitzia tamnoides (raw or sauteedI “SO much easier than growing spinach”) (3), any Allium, Maximilian Sunflower (Helianthus maximiliani), sorrels (4), good king henry (spinach), Jerusalem artichokes (lactofermented or roasted) (3), Mertensia maritima, globe artichokes (3), cardoon (leaf ribs), nettles (5), Rudbeckia laciniata (sochan) (2), Scorzonera hispanica (shoots and flower buds) (3), rhubarb (in dahl) (2), Lilium sp. (bulbs in soups and roasted), Malva moschata (musk mallow; leaves), Allium cepa “Perutile” (everlasting onion, growing on an Edinburgh allotment for 100 years!), Angelica archangelica, ramsons (2), chicory, Allium triquetrum, Valeriana officinalis, Napaea dioica (glade mallow), Phytolacca americana (pokeweed; properly prepared), red valerian (shoots), sea beet (leaves), bladder campion (shoots), ground elder, Taraxacum sp. of course (its rich and complex flavour knows no equal; incl. roots) (4), chayote (2), pignut, greater pignut (Bunium bulbocastanum), Sonchus arvensis (I snack on the bittersweet flower buds all summer, can’t resist them), rock samphire (Crithmum), water lotus and water chestnuts (3), alexanders (young shoots; Smyrnium), Canna edulis (2), taro (Colocasia) (2), yacon, Sagittaria (duck potatoes), Hibiscus, honewort (Cryptotaenia canadensis), fool’s watercress (Apium nodiflorum), Chinese yam (Dioscorea polystachya), Basella, Asclepias incarnata (swamp milkweed; pods), loroco (Echites panduratus), Cardamine raphanifolia, sweet cicely (Myrrhis odorata), Sanguisorba minor, Dystaenia takesimana (seombadi)
An edibles walk and talk to myself at Kew Gardens on 12th April 2024! Pictures of spotted edimentals and other edibles below (names with the pictures):
My zoom talk “A Virtual Edimentals Walk Around Burnley Gardens” in Melbourne, Australia was recorded and is now available https://youtu.be/rHX3q3Dng4k I based the talk on Edimentals that can be grown in Melbourne, based on plant lists for Burnley Gardens and the Royal Botanical Gardens in Melbourne! After the talk, Sam Taylor and his team made a salad from plants growing in the garden! See pictures below. Thanks for inviting me, it was fun to put this together, and thanks for allowing me to put the recording of this unique talk up on my youtube channel!
It was fun putting together my talk “A Virtual Edimentals Walk Around Burnley Gardens” today 6th March, although I’m not used to talking at 9 am! To explain, it was a climate friendly zoom talk from home with the good folks of The Herb Society of Victoria at Burnley in Melbourne, Australia. During 2014 when my book was published and COVID lock down in 2020, I travelled the globe giving talks based on the book and did many walks and talks in botanical gardens and other plant collections. About 1/3 of all plants are edible, so maybe over 100,000 species have been used by people around the world and there is never a shortage of edible plants to be found. This time I based the talk mostly on a plant list from the Burnley Gardens as well as one from the Royal Botanic Gardens in Melbourne, so talking about plants growing locally. Although the talk was only for fully payed up members of the society, my brother in England Trevor Barstow (picture) managed to infiltrate the proceedings, probably informing security that he was my virtual roadie 🙂 Thanks to Sam Taylor and the crew for putting it on and dealing with the technical side of things! A major storm was at its peak as I talked and the house was rocking, but luckily the electricity supply held! These are the plants I talked about (the set list 😉 ) and there were a few new ones! Hosta Fennel Aralia cordata Aralia elata Angelica gigas Angelica archangelica Crithmum maritimum Yucca Heracleum lanatum Smyrnium (Alexanders) Dystaenia takesimana Asparagus Artichokes and cardoons Dahlia Aster cordifolius Aster scaber Jerusalem artichoke Rudbeckia laciniata Ligularia fischeri Horseradish Campanula punctata and other Campanulaceae Lilium davidii and Lilium lancifolium Allium stipitatum Allium fistulosum Allium tuberosum Allium schoenoprasum Allium ampeloprasum
You have to search for the small red tassels that are the female wild hazel (Corylus avellana) flowers that will be the nuts. They’ve probably been there for some time as the male flowers or catkins are almost over in this very mild winter. I’ve read that the wild hazel is a good pollinator for large nut hazel varieties, but there is hardly any overlap in flowering times here.
Growing winter vegetables is easy and sustainable without the use of plastics, fleeces, expensive greenhouses and energy by exploiting the “talents” of perennial and biennial plants that are naturally cold tolerant! End of February greens, many harvested in the garden in this very mild weather, used in a delicious green Mac and cheese! See the list of plants added below the pictures. The plants: Forced inside: Aralia cordata (udo) Hosta Aegopodium podogaria (ground elder / skvallerkål) Cichorium intybus “Witloof Væres Venners” (chicory / sikori) Allium senescens x nutans Petroselinum crispum (parsley / persille) Brassia oleracea (various perennial kales / flerårige kål) Cirsium oleraceum (cabbage thistle / kåltistel) Outside: Allium carinatum “Pulchellum” Hablitzia tamnoides (Caucasian spinach / stjernemelde) Allium stipitatum shoots (Persian shallot / Persisk sjalott) Rumex acetosa “Abundance” (sorrel /engsyre) Taraxacum sp. (dandelion / løvetann) Alliaria petiolata (garlic mustard / løkurt) Dystaenia takesimana Scorzonera hispanica (scorzonera / scorsonerrot) Ranunculus ficaria var chrysocephalus (lesser celandine / vårkål) Cardamine raphanifolia Hemerocallis sp. Allium cernuum (nodding onion / prærieløk) Allium oleraceum (wild onion / villøk) Allium sativum (garlic / hvitløk) Allium paradoxum var normale Allium paradoxum var paradoxum (few-flowered leek) Armoracia rusticana ( horseradish / pepperrot) Smyrnium olusatrum (alexanders / sorte løpstikke); not a very hardy species, but I’ve kept it alive for many years growing up against the house wall protected by a leaf and sacking mulch (I overwinter tender plants in pots here):
Perennial vegetables, Edimentals (plants that are edible and ornamental) and other goings on in The Edible Garden