You Said You Forgave Him... So Why Are You Still Hurting?
Want to listen on Apple Podcasts or Spotify? Click on the SHARE (next to more info) option below and Enjoy!
Have you ever looked at your partner across the room and thought, "I forgave you weeks ago... so why do I still feel this knot in my stomach?" 🤔
Girl, you are SO not alone in this confusing emotional soup. That weird disconnect between what your brain has decided ("I forgive you") and what your body is still feeling (hello, tension, anxiety, and that weird flinch when they reach for your phone) is actually completely normal. But understanding why it happens can be the difference between true healing and just slapping an emotional band-aid on a deeper wound.
The Truth About Forgiveness (Spoiler: It's Not a Magic Eraser)
Here's the thing about forgiveness that nobody tells you: saying the words "I forgive you" doesn't automatically reset your nervous system.
I see this ALL the time with my clients. They rush to forgive because:
They're tired of the conflict
They genuinely want to move forward
They believe they should forgive quickly
They're afraid of seeming petty or vindictive
So they say those magic words, expecting their feelings to catch up... and then wonder what's wrong with them when they don't.
According to relationship researcher Dr. John Gottman, forgiveness isn't an event, it's a process. His research shows that couples who successfully rebuild trust don't skip over the hurt; they move through it. In fact, trying to rush forgiveness often leads to what he calls "pseudo-forgiveness" which actually undermines the relationship in the long run. (Gottman Institute, 2018)
Why "Feeling It to Heal It" Actually Works
When my client Maya discovered her husband had opened a secret credit card and built up debt behind her back, she immediately went into problem-solving mode: "At least he didn't cheat, it's just money. We can fix this!"
But weeks later, she still found herself:
Tensing up when the mail arrived
Checking bank statements obsessively
Feeling suspicious when he bought anything new
Creating increasingly complex "tests" for him to prove his trustworthiness
The reason? Her body was still carrying the betrayal her mind tried to dismiss. 💡
Here's what's actually happening inside you when you experience betrayal:
Your amygdala (the brain's alarm system) gets activated and puts your body in protection mode. According to neuroscientist Dr. Stephen Porges, creator of Polyvagal Theory, this activates your sympathetic nervous system, your fight/flight response. Your body is literally saying "DANGER!" even when your mind is saying "We're fine now, remember? We forgaaaaaave."
This isn't just emotional, it's physiological! Research shows that relationship betrayals activate the same brain regions as physical pain. So when you "just get over it," you're essentially telling yourself to ignore a broken emotional bone. (UCLA Neurology Research, 2022)
What True Forgiveness Actually Feels Like (It's Not What You Think!)
True forgiveness isn't about erasing the past. It's about integrating it into a new chapter of your relationship story. And honestly? It's messy and non-linear. 🌀
When you're truly healing (not just pretending to):
You'll have good days and bad days (and that's totally normal!)
You'll be able to talk about the hurt without reliving it as intensely
Your body will gradually stop going into high alert around trigger situations
You'll set clear, consistent boundaries (not constantly moving goalposts)
You'll stop creating "tests" your partner has to pass to prove their love
The most important sign? You'll stop feeling like you're constantly monitoring them and return to actually being present in your relationship.
The Life-Changing Magic of Forgiveness-Done-Right ✨
When you allow yourself to fully process the betrayal before jumping into forgiveness, something amazing happens:
Your self-trust skyrockets because you're honoring your own experience
Your communication becomes clearer because you're not filtering through resentment
Your anxiety decreases as your nervous system recalibrates to safety
Your relationship develops resilience that makes it stronger than before
Your emotional intelligence expands as you develop a more nuanced understanding of both yourself and your partner
I've seen relationships transform from "walking on eggshells" to genuine partnership when both people honor this process. It's like building a stronger bone after a break. When healed properly, it's more resilient than before.
Ready to Try Real Forgiveness? Here's Your First Step
If you've been stuck in the "I forgave but still hurt" cycle, I want you to try something:
Take 5 minutes today to write down what still feels unresolved for you. Not what you think should bother you or what's "reasonable" to still be upset about—just the raw, honest stuff your body is still carrying.
This isn't about restarting the fight or punishing your partner. It's about getting honest with YOURSELF first. 💕
True forgiveness isn't about being "nice" or "letting things go." It's about creating the emotional safety that allows BOTH of you to show up authentically. And it starts with acknowledging what's real. Even when it's messy, even when it's complex, even when it takes longer than you'd like. Because you deserve a relationship where you're not just "over it" but genuinely through it and stronger on the other side.
What's one situation where you rushed forgiveness before really processing the hurt? Drop a comment below.
