Kell factor: Difference between revisions

Content deleted Content added
did not deleted prior version of text
m Reflist
 
(45 intermediate revisions by 36 users not shown)
Line 1:
{{Multiple issues|
{{Citations missingRefimprove|date=March 2007}}
{{confusing|date=November 2010}}
{{technical|date=May 2017}}
}}
 
[[Image:Kell_factor1.png|thumb|236px|right|At 0.5 cycles/pixel, the Nyquist limit, signal amplitude depends on phase, as visible by the three medium-gray curves where the signal goes 90° out of phase with the pixels.]]
:''There are some conflicting and confusing points in the following article. For a discussion of these please read the comments in the discussion section accessed from the discussion tab above. ''
[[Image:Kell_factor2.png|thumb|236px|right|At 0.33 cycles/pixel, 0.66 times the Nyquist limit, amplitude can largely be maintained regardless of phase. Some artifacts are still visible, but minor.]]
 
The '''Kell Factorfactor''', named after [[RCA]] engineer [[Raymond D. Kell]],<ref name=":0">{{Cite journal |last1=Kell |last2=Bedford |last3=Fredendall |date=July 1940 |title=A Determination Of Optimum Number Of Lines In A Television System |journal=RCA Review |volume=5 |issue=1 |pages=8–30}}</ref> is a parameter used to limit the bandwidth of a sampled image signal as to avoid the appearance of [[beat frequency]] patterns to appear when displaying the image in a discrete display devicesdevice, usually taken to be 0.7. The number was first measured in 1934 by Raymond D. Kell and his associates as 0.64 but has suffered several revisions given that it is based on image perception, hence subjective, and is not independent of the type of display.<ref name=":1">{{Cite journal |last1=Kell |first1=R. D. |last2=Bedford |first2=A.V. |last3=Trainer |first3=M. A. |date=November 1934 |title=An Experimental Television System |url= |journal=Proceedings of the Institute of Radio Engineers |volume=22 |issue=11 |pages=1246}}</ref> It was later revised to 0.85 but can go higher than 0.9, when fixed pixel scanning (e.g., [[charge-coupled device|CCD]] or [[Active pixel sensor|CMOS]]) and [[fixed pixel display]]s (e.g., [[liquid crystal display|LCD]] or [[plasma display|plasma]]) are used, or as low as 0.7 for [[electron gun]] scanning.
 
From a different perspective, the Kell Factorfactor defines the effective [[image resolution|resolution]] of a discrete display device since the full resolution cannot be used without viewing experience degradation. The actual sampled resolution will depend on the spot size and intensity distribution. For [[electron gun]] scanning systems, the spot usually has a Gaussian intensity distribution. For CCDs, the distribution is somewhat rectangular, and is also affected by the sampling grid and inter-pixel spacing.
 
Kell factor is sometimes incorrectly stated to exist to account for the effects of interlacing. Interlacing itself does not affect Kell factor, but because interlaced video must be low-pass filtered (i.e., blurred) in the vertical dimension to avoid spatio-temporal aliasing (i.e., flickering effects), the Kell factor of interlaced video is said to be about 70% that of progressive video with the same scan line resolution.
Line 11 ⟶ 16:
== The beat frequency problem ==
 
To understand how the distortion comes about, let us consider an ideal linear process from sampling to display. When a signal is sampled at a frequency that is at least double the [[Nyquist frequency]], it can be fully reconstructed by low-pass filtering since the first repeat spectra does not overlap the original baseband spectra. In discrete displays the image signal is not low-pass filtered since the display takes discrete values as input, i.e. the signal displayed contains all the repeat spectra. The proximity of the highest frequency of the baseband signal to the lowest frequency of the first repeat spectra induces the [[beat frequency]] pattern. The pattern seen on screen can at times be similar to a [[Moiré pattern]]. The Kell Factorfactor is the reduction necessary in signal bandwidth so that the distance between both frequencies is sosuch that no beat frequency is perceived by the viewer.
 
== Examples ==
* A 625-line analogueanalog (e.g., 50Hz50&nbsp;Hz [[PAL]]) television picture is divided into 576 visible lines from top to bottom. Suppose a card featuring horizontal black and white stripes is placed in front of the camera. The effective vertical resolution of the TV system is equal to the largest number of stripes that can be within the picture height and appear as individual stripes. Since it is unlikely the stripes will line up perfectly with the lines on the camera's sensor, the number is slightly less than 576. Using a Kell factor of 0.7, the number can be determined to be 0.7&times;5767×576 = 403.2 lines of resolution.
* Kell factor can be used to determine the horizontal resolution that is required to match the vertical resolution attained by a given number of [[scan line]]s. For [[576i]] at 50&nbsp;Hz, given its 4:3 [[aspect ratio (image)|aspect ratio]], the required horizontal resolution must be 4/3 times the effective vertical resolution, or (4/3)&times;0×0.7&times;5767×576 = 537.6 [[Television lines|pixels ofper resolutionline]]. Taken further, since 537.6 linespixels is equal to a maximum of 268.8 cycles for an alternating pixel pattern, and given 576i50576i&nbsp;50&nbsp;Hz has an active line period of 52µs&nbsp;μs, its [[Luminance (video)|luminance]] signal requires a bandwidth of 268.8/52 = 5.17 &nbsp;MHz.
* Kell factor applies equally to digital devices. Using a Kell factor of 0.9, a [[1080p]] [[High-definition television|HDTV]] video system using a CCD camera and an LCD or plasma display will only have 1728&times;9721728×972 lines of resolution.
 
== History ==
* Kell factor can be used to determine the horizontal resolution that is required to match the vertical resolution attained by a given number of [[scan line]]s. For [[576i]]50, given its 4:3 [[aspect ratio (image)|aspect ratio]], the required horizontal resolution must be 4/3 times the effective vertical resolution, or (4/3)&times;0.7&times;576 = 537.6 lines of resolution. Taken further, since 537.6 lines is equal to 268.8 cycles, and given 576i50 has an active line period of 52µs, its [[Luminance (video)|luminance]] signal requires a bandwidth of 268.8/52 = 5.17 MHz.
 
{| border="1" cellpadding="5" cellspacing="0" align="center"
* Kell factor applies equally to digital devices. Using a Kell factor of 0.9, a [[1080p]] [[High-definition television|HDTV]] video system using a CCD camera and an LCD or plasma display will only have 1728&times;972 lines of resolution.
! style="background:#efefef;" | Source
! colspan="2" style="background:#ffdead;" | Kell factor
|-
| Kell, Bedford & Trainer (1934)<ref name=":1" />|| 0.64
|-
| Mertz & Gray (1934) || 0.53
|-
| Wheeler & Loughren (1938) || 0.71
|-
| Wilson (1938) || 0.82
|-
| Kell, Bedford & Fredendall (1940)<ref name=":0" />|| 0.85
|-
| Baldwin (1940) || 0.70
|}
 
== See also ==
* [[Aliasing]]
* [[Moiré pattern]]
* [[Optical resolution]]
* [[Resel]]
 
==References==
{{Reflist}}
*M. Robin, "Revisiting Kell", Broadcast Engineering, May 2003.
*[https://web.archive.org/web/20061202090352/http://broadcastengineering.com/aps/infrastructure/broadcasting_revisiting_kell/ M. Robin, "Revisiting Kell", Broadcast Engineering, May 2003.]
*[http://digitalcontentproducer.com/hdhdv/depth/hdv_at_work_02272006/ S. Mullen, "Just What is 1080?", HDV@Work, Feb. 2006.]
*[http://www.cse.yorku.ca/~amana/research/interlacedVideo.pdf J. Amanatides, "Antialiasing of Interlaced Video Animation", SIGGRAPH 90.]
*G. Tonge, "The Television Scanning Process", SMPTE Journal, July 1984 pg 657
*[https://web.archive.org/web/20131217000512/http://www.dvxuser.com/V6/archive/index.php/t-42694.html Kell factor explained in simple terms]
 
[[Category:Television technology]]
 
[[de:Kellfaktor (Technik)]]
[[it:Coefficiente di Kell]]
[[es:factor de Kell]]