Talk:Northern Ireland: Difference between revisions

Content deleted Content added
Line 790:
'''B'''. I can't support "A" as the England, Scotland and Wales articles all have the UK's TLD. As an aside, I do love the attempts from the posters above to shut down any discussion that might change a status quo they're in favour of. How long before someone whips out the "drop the stick, back away from the dead horse" quip? We've already had "bordering on disruption"... <font color="#004225">—</font> [[User:Jon C.|<font color="#004225">Jon C.</font>]][[User_talk:Jon C.|<sup><b><font color="#F28500">ॐ</font></b></sup>]] 11:35, 23 January 2013 (UTC)
 
'''B''' - Northern Ireland is part of the United Kingdom, ".uk" is Northern Ireland's only country code top-level domain. ".ie" is the country code top-level domain of the republic of Ireland. It is misleading, inaccurate and offensive to include ".ie" which implies Northern Ireland is part of the Republic of Ireland. The key is in the name " country code top-level domain", the UK is a country, ROI is a country, under some definitions NI is a country.. but the island of Ireland is NOT a country and it does not have a " country code top-level domain". Reference topto the belfastBelfast agreement is completely irrelevant, the belfast agreement allowed people in NI to be Irish citizens, it did not cede Northern Ireland to the Irish republic, quite the opposite.. the agreement recognised that Northern Ireland was entirely part of the United Kingdom until such a time as the people vote to change that relationship. The body that assigns internet codes bases domains on ISO 3166-1 which clearly applies to sovereign states like the Republic of Ireland / United Kingdom. NOT to an island. No one arguing for ".ie" to remain has provided ANY evidence that ".ie" was assigned to the island, merely that the body responsible for the Irish domain allows people with a connection to NI to get a domain (but they do not have to be in Northern Ireland, they could be anywhere in the world), and people in NI can use many domain names. This is strictly about is ".ie" Northern Ireland's country domain... it is clearly not so its inclusion is wrong. [[User:BritishWatcher|BritishWatcher]] ([[User talk:BritishWatcher|talk]]) 15:20, 23 January 2013 (UTC)