Wikipedia:Wikipedia Signpost/2021-04-25/Disinformation report: Difference between revisions
Content deleted Content added
Newslinger (talk | contribs) Undid revision 1020653083 by Newslinger (talk) Self-reverting |
m Protected "Wikipedia:Wikipedia Signpost/2021-04-25/Disinformation report": old newspaper articles don't need to be continually updated, the only real edits expected here are from bots/scripts, and vandalism is extremely hard to monitor ([Edit=Require autoconfirmed or confirmed access] (indefinite) [Move=Require autoconfirmed or confirmed access] (indefinite)) |
||
| (11 intermediate revisions by 9 users not shown) | |||
Line 1:
<noinclude>{{Wikipedia:Wikipedia Signpost/Templates/RSS description|1=The Trump Organization's paid editors: Michael and Ivanka?}}{{Wikipedia:Signpost/Template:Signpost-header|||}}</noinclude>
{{Wikipedia:Wikipedia Signpost/Templates/Signpost-article-header-v2
|{{{1|Paid editing by a former head of state's business enterprise}}}|By [[User:Smallbones|Smallbones]]
}}
{{Wikipedia:Wikipedia Signpost/Templates/Signpost-block-start-v2|fullwidth=no<!--CHANGE TO YES FOR A 'FULLWIDTH' ARTICLE-->}}
[[File:Donald Trump (29273256122) - Cropped.jpg|thumb|250px|Donald Trump in 2017]]
If you believe the mainstream press, former US President Donald J. Trump has spread misinformation across the internet and in news outlets on a massive scale. According to ''The Washington Post'' he has [https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2021/01/24/trumps-false-or-misleading-claims-total-30573-over-four-years/ "accumulated 30,573 untruths during his presidency — averaging about 21 erroneous claims a day."] He has been [https://www.theverge.com/2021/1/27/22251338/twitter-facebook-youtube-election-misinformation-ban-trump banned from social media sites] including [[Twitter]], [[Facebook]], and [[YouTube]]. Has Trump also spread misinformation or disinformation on Wikipedia? We don’t think that the former president himself has edited Wikipedia since it is much more difficult to edit Wikipedia than it is to tweet. This ''Signpost'' article examines whether Trump’s business empire, the Trump Organization, has employed paid editors to edit Wikipedia.
They apparently have. Editor [[User talk:Mmartinnyc|Mmartinnyc]] disclosed his identity twice in 2011 on-Wiki, as Michael Martin, the Trump Organization’s Director of Digital Marketing.
{{Quote box
|quote='''I work for the Trump Organization and have been asked by Ivanka Trump to update her Wiki page so we hope that you would be kind enough to allow the updates to stand?'''<br>
'''Thank you''',
<br>
'''Michael Martin''' <br>
'''The Trump Organization''' [https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?diff=464799726&oldid=464794800&title=User_talk:Thirdright#Ivanka_Trump]
|quoted = 1
|fontsize = 110%
|bgcolor = Cornsilk
|width = 90%
|align=center
}}
{{Quote box
|quote='''Thank you for looking out for Ivanka's Wiki page.'''<br>
'''Please be aware that I manage interactive content for Ivanka as well as the rest of The Trump Organization so the edits I am making come directly from her. I noticed you undid the changes made so please contact me if you have any questions as I do the re-edits accordingly.'''<br>
'''Thanks!'''<br>
'''Michael Martin''' <br>
'''Director of Interactive''' <br>
'''The Trump Organization''' [https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?diff=464786975&oldid=464776342&title=User_talk:Dawn_Bard]
|quoted = 1
|fontsize = 110%
|bgcolor = Cornsilk
|width = 90%
|align=center
}}
[[File:Ivanka Trump 2012 Shankbone.JPG|thumb|200px|Ivanka Trump in 2012]]
According to his obituary published in December 2020, Martin started working at the Trump Organization in 1987 and later became Director of Digital Marketing, serving in that position until 2014 when he left the company. <ref>{{cite news| publisher = [[Salt Lake Tribune]] |title = Michael D. Martin 1956-2020, Dec, 6, 2020 (obituary) |url= https://www.legacy.com/obituaries/saltlaketribune/obituary.aspx?n=michael-d-martin&pid=197231329
|access-date = April 25, 2021}}</ref>
''The Signpost'' notes that evidence of paid editing using only Wikipedia edit histories can not actually “prove” an editor’s identity, even in cases where they disclose many personal details. Sometimes editors have tried to embarrass a targeted individual or company, a tactic known as a [[Joe job]]bing. This caveat applies even when an editor directly declares that they are paid.
===Mmartinnyc’s editing===
[[File:Don Jr. headshot.jpg|thumb|200px|Photo of Donald Trump Jr. uploaded by Mmartinnyc as his own work]]
Martin only made 45 edits to Wikipedia articles: 23 to Ivanka Trump, 11 to Donald Trump Jr., 10 to Eric Trump, and 1 to Donald Trump. [https://xtools.wmflabs.org/ec/en.wikipedia.org/Mmartinnyc]
An examination of the edits to Ivanka Trump shows that on December 7, 2011, his first day of editing the article, Martin removed some unflattering content and added promotional content such as "In addition to her work at The Trump Organization, Ivanka Trump is a principal of Ivanka Trump Fine Jewelry, which launched to great success in 2007 with a store on Mercer Street in New York City." [https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?diff=464662705&oldid=464102017&title=Ivanka_Trump&type=revision] These edits were reverted by an experienced Wikipedian within the hour, while labeling them "heavily copy-pasted POV copy[right]vio[lations]." [https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?diff=464668873&oldid=464662705&title=Ivanka_Trump&type=revision] in the edit summary.
The following day Martin tried and failed to reinstate many of his edits by edit-warring with three experienced editors. [https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?date-range-to=2011-12-09&tagfilter=&title=Ivanka_Trump&action=history]. Only then did Martin declare that he was a paid editor.
A week later he made his only edit to the Donald Trump article, replacing the name of the notorious [[Trump University]] with “Trump Entrepreneur Initiative.” His remaining 16 edits were less adventurous, 14 of them being marked as “minor”.
===Conclusions===
Mmartinnyc’s declaration that he is Michael Martin, at that time the digital marketing manager of the Trump Organization is quite convincing. If the declaration was part of a Joe job, it's one that didn't embarrass anybody for ten years, even though the head of the Trump Organization was the president of the United States for four of those years.
===References===
{{reflist}}
<!--END OF ARTICLE -->
{{Wikipedia:Wikipedia Signpost/Templates/Signpost-block-end-v2}}
{{Wikipedia:Wikipedia Signpost/Templates/Signpost-article-end-v2}}
<noinclude>{{Wikipedia:Signpost/Template:Signpost-article-comments-end||2021-02-28|2021-06-27}}</noinclude>
| |||