User:SashiRolls/alt-litterbox

AE complaint

Immediate history

• On 31 January 2020 MrX was warned for edit warring on Media coverage of Bernie Sanders. He was at 3RR at 14:30 and had not reverted his (mistake) by 23:30 (and still has not). I filed at ANEW, and after he was warned, MrX began compiling diffs for this revenge filing on the same day.
• On 4 February 2020, Snooganssnoogans made a series of 6 reversions (one continuous revert) with insulting edit summaries:

• fix poor, incomprehensible writeup
• nonsensical descriptions
• awful writeup
• this has nothing to do with media bias against Sanders. one editor has repeatedly edit-warred this into the article over the objections of other editors ( diff ).

The cumulative effect was clear "baiting" to take advantage of the "no personal comments" sanction Awilley had imposed in a previous case MrX had brought against me, and which Snoog was also involved in.
I presented the facts on the talk page, showing beyond any doubt that nobody had ever deleted the content I had supposedly repeatedly edit-warred into the article.

• WMSR, who has been trying to get me sanctioned for some time, denied the evidence on the talk page.
• Objective3000 made a number of personal attacks against me which I tried to remove (one of which WMSR acknowledged O3000 shouldn't have said in yet another denial of the clear evidence that Snoogans had made up the edit-war he was complaining of.
• WMSR, Objective3000, Slywriter and another contributor directed a number of personal comments towards me on the talk page (zero discussion of content) while I rewrote a paragraph about the section scrubbed from the article by Snoogans & MrX. I explicitly and politely responded to their concerns with previous content and continued a content discussion on the TP amidst the poisonous atmosphere being established by the five editors in the original thread.

Miscellaneous

People have objected to my saying the entry & topic area is being controlled by a "house" cabal with a division of roles according to talents, tools, and experience points. Wait, no, I didn't say all that, did I? :) People have also previously objected to me drawing attention to the fact that Snoogans & MrX work together. As the record shows, these two have interacted on 41 pages within 10 minutes of one another, and 167 pages within 10 days of one another. Their #1 and #3 interactions are on Media coverage of Bernie Sanders and Tulsi Gabbard, two pages where I have had to deal with them extensively.

WMSR's copyvio & harassment accusations

On 28 January 2018, WSMR started an AfD on the "media coverage of BS" page and an ANI report against me which was closed the same day (though he reopened it a few hours after Bbb23 closed it as being most likely a disruptive timesink). Five days later, I challenged him to demonstrate the copyvio (the least subjective of the accusations). Caught in the fib, he shifted the goalposts: "Regardless of whether the use of that image was a violation of copyright law, it was a clear violation of WP's fair use policy" in this diff.

WMSR removed the image from the article on 21 January 2020, I never restored it. Why was this worth discussion 7 days later?

WMSR also accused me of harassment on 28 January 2020, though I hadn't even commented on his talk page (though he'd been asked to stay off mine).

Working the refs

• Obj3000, MrX, and Snoog have all commented on 7 admin talk pages. The closest association (by far) is with Awilley, who imposed the "no personal comments" sanction (20, 19, and 22 comments, respectively). I have made a spreadsheet of their interactions separated into subject areas for ArbCom. The two that concern me at the moment are among their closest collaborations.

Further evidence available

• I can respond to each of the diffs presented above providing the context. (evidence phase)

• Snoog has misrepresented the off-wiki information from 2017 he sent to ArbCom. I have never said that Neutrality and Calton are employees of David Brock. That, like the false claim of edit warring above, is a tactical misrepresentation.
• Given the clear evidence of coordinated harassment, the gaming of the "no personal comments" sanction Awilley unilaterally imposed, and the very clear misrepresentations of content (which is a behavioral issue I have solid evidence to share, especially concerning Snoogans), this case belongs at ArbCom, with the filer and first three commenters on this case as parties to the dispute.

Raw text dump

WSMR-MrX, interactions

WMSR/MrX interaction

• 12m: Talk: Media coverage of Bernie Sanders (108 edits)
• 35m: Wikipedia:Administrator's noticeboard/Edit warring (149/4)
• 37m: Talk:Tulsi Gabbard 2020 presidential campaign (11 edits) cf.Talk:Tulsi_Gabbard_2020_presidential_campaign#Unwarranted_deletions_of_content_by_MrX_and_WMSR
• 2h: Media coverage of Bernie Sanders ()
• 2h: WP:AE (232/1 --> all about me)
• 3h: WP:AN/I (468/63)
• 11h: Tulsi Gabbard 2020 presidential campaign (63 / 8)
• 14h: Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Media coverage of Bernie Sanders
• 3d: User talk:SashiRolls

O3000, Snoo, X triple interactions

Talk:Media coverage of Bernie Sanders 7 seconds 32 167 67

User talk:Awilley 1 minutes 20 19 22

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Media coverage of Bernie Sanders 2 minutes 4 11 1

User talk:Snooganssnoogans 5 minutes 1 271 4

Media coverage of Bernie Sanders 7 minutes 5 123 48

User talk:SashiRolls 2 days 2 14 11

Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Incidents 57 seconds 185 143 288

Wikipedia:Arbitration/Requests/Enforcement 1 minutes 58 56 202

Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons/Noticeboard 1 minutes 65 158 169

Wikipedia:Dispute resolution noticeboard 2 minutes 11 12 3

Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Noticeboard 4 minutes 179 263 161

Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Edit warring 5 minutes 43 80 101

Wikipedia:Neutral point of view/Noticeboard 6 minutes 114 74 48

Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard 7 minutes 35 60 164

Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Requests for closure 8 minutes 6 3 126

Wikipedia:Village pump (policy) 8 minutes 11 11 29

Wikipedia talk:Arbitration/Requests/Enforcement 14 minutes 5 3 25

Wikipedia:Requests for page protection 31 minutes 11 115 90

Wikipedia:Conflict of interest/Noticeboard 48 minutes 15 27 9

User talk:Doug Weller 7 minutes 7 5 3

User talk:Bishonen 3 hours 14 2 9

User talk:MelanieN 2 days 49 9 6

User talk:El C 3 days 7 1 5

User talk:Drmies 6 days 76 12 6

User talk:NeilN 9 days 19 2 8

Talk:Laura Ingraham 6 seconds 22 20 20

Laura Ingraham 25 minutes 15 44 21

Talk:CNN 1 minutes 155 3 11

CNN controversies 56 minutes 32 4 35

CNN 2 hours 31 3 4

Talk:Sean Hannity 22 seconds 23 71 23

Sean Hannity 10 minutes 3 114 19

Tucker Carlson 32 seconds 36 80 36

Talk:Tucker Carlson 17 minutes 26 36 14

Talk:Julian Assange 29 minutes 36 61 1

WikiLeaks 39 minutes 2 149 1

Talk:WikiLeaks 6 minutes 4 48 8

Talk:Donald Trump 10 seconds 796 187 1432

Donald Trump 5 minutes 45 67 466

Talk:Presidency of Donald Trump 10 seconds 3 183 86

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Donald Trump racial views 51 seconds 4 3 27

Donald Trump 2016 presidential campaign 2 minutes 18 11 75

Talk:Steele dossier 4 minutes 70 1 114

Steele dossier 15 hours 2 3 12

Talk:Special Counsel investigation (2017–2019) 16 minutes 29 3 16

Special Counsel investigation (2017–2019) 40 minutes 20 2 20 Talk:Melania Trump 5 minutes 8 12 16 Melania Trump 1 days 2 3 20

Inauguration of Donald Trump

20 hours 3 3 8 Talk:Russian interference in the 2016 United States elections

28 seconds 236 3 475

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Donald Trump disclosure of classified information to Russia 14 hours 1 2 1

Talk:Roy Moore

24 seconds 65 15 97

Roy Moore 6 minutes 28 40 81 Talk:National Rifle Association 1 minutes 35 92 231

National Rifle Association 9 minutes 22 27 93

Talk:Kyle Kashuv 1 minutes 27 2 49

Kyle Kashuv 1 minutes 19 2 122

Talk:Unite the Right rally 1 minutes 49 1 21

Unite the Right rally 54 minutes 22 4 24

Dismissal of James Comey 6 minutes 6 17 47

Talk:Dismissal of James Comey 12 minutes 7 16 49

James Comey 32 minutes 13 3 21

Talk:Hillary Clinton 2016 presidential campaign 8 minutes 24 12 123

Hillary Clinton 2016 presidential campaign 2 days 11 8 31

Political views of American academics 17 minutes 4 2 7

Talk:Political views of American academics 8 minutes 63 3 10

2016 United States presidential election 29 minutes 17 12 3

Talk:2016 United States presidential election 4 days 117 7 6

2016 Democratic National Committee email leak 1 days 1 22 20

Talk:2016 Democratic National Committee email leak 300 days 2 3 10

Beto O'Rourke

4 hours 21 24 18

Elizabeth Warren 5 hours 10 12 1 Jeff Flake 23 hours 9 30 1

Snoo - X

relevant to this particular case

Talk:Media coverage of Bernie Sanders 7 seconds 167 67

Media coverage of Bernie Sanders 2 hours 123 48

Talk:Tulsi Gabbard 20 seconds 134 171

Tulsi Gabbard 1 minutes 142 162

User talk:Awilley 1 minutes 19 22

User talk:Awilley/Discretionary sanctions 21 hours 5 6

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Media coverage of Bernie Sanders 21 hours 11 1

User talk:SashiRolls 7 days 14 11

Wikipedia:Arbitration/Requests/Enforcement 7 minutes 56 232

Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Edit warring 39 minutes 80 149

User talk:Selvydra 2 hours 5 1

User talk:Wrestlinglover 1 days 2 2

User talk:Rafe87 5 hours 2 2

User talk:MikkelJSmith2 1 days 6 3

other

Tucker Carlson 32 seconds 80 36

Talk:Donald Trump 43 seconds 187 1441

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Donald Trump racial views 51 seconds 3 27

2018–19 United States federal government shutdown 59 seconds 4 8

Talk:Sean Hannity 1 minutes 71 23

Talk:National Rifle Association 1 minutes 92 231

Talk:2018 United States elections 1 minutes 64 3

User talk:RandomUserGuy1738 1 minutes 2 1

Talk:Laura Ingraham 2 minutes 20 20

Talk:John Bolton 2 minutes 17 4

Talk:Steve Bannon 2 minutes 8 57

Talk:Steve King 2 minutes 25 23

Donald Trump 2016 presidential campaign 2 minutes 11 83

Talk:Roy Moore 2 minutes 15 97

Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons/Noticeboard 3 minutes 158 346

Talk:2018–19 United States federal government shutdown 3 minutes 3 5 Talk:Presidency of Donald Trump 10 seconds 183 86Presidency of Donald Trump 4 minutes 438 102

Talk:Donald Trump's disclosures of classified information 4 minutes 1 9

Trump administration family separation policy 4 minutes 38 26

Talk:Trump administration family separation policy 4 minutes 18 34

User talk:Snooganssnoogans 5 minutes 271 4

Breitbart News 5 minutes 14 94

Talk:Political positions of Hillary Clinton 6 minutes 47 8

Dismissal of James Comey 6 minutes 17 47

Wikipedia:Neutral point of view/Noticeboard 6 minutes 74 53

Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Noticeboard 6 minutes 263 215

Andrew McCabe 6 minutes 7 4

Talk:Hillary Clinton 6 minutes 68 88 7 minutes 1 2

Wikipedia:Arbitration/Requests/Enforcement 7 minutes 56 232

Talk:Hillary Clinton 2016 presidential campaign 8 minutes 12 130

Talk:Ben Shapiro 8 minutes 33 11

Wikipedia:Village pump (policy) 8 minutes 11 39

Donald Trump's disclosures of classified information 9 minutes 5 4

Political positions of Hillary Clinton 9 minutes 197 14

Sean Hannity 10 minutes 114 19

Talk:Ron DeSantis 11 minutes 3 23

Talk:Jill Stein 12 minutes 199 6

Political positions of Donald Trump 13 minutes 349 25

Talk:Political positions of Donald Trump 14 minutes 41 18

Roy Moore 18 minutes 40 81

Talk:Breitbart News 19 minutes 5 127

Talk:Liberty University 20 minutes 84 13

Kyle Kashuv 24 minutes 2 122

Steve King 28 minutes 50 21

Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard 29 minutes 60 193

Peter Strzok 32 minutes 61 13

Chip Roy 38 minutes 7 4

Talk:William Barr 38 minutes 67 5

WikiLeaks 39 minutes 149 1

Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Edit warring 39 minutes 80 149

User talk:Vaalpak 40 minutes 6 1

Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Incidents 41 minutes 143 470

Wikipedia talk:Arbitration/Requests/Enforcement 42 minutes 3 25

Scott Pruitt 44 minutes 107 3

Comey memos 47 minutes 5 36

Talk:Kamala Harris 47 minutes 8 12

Wikipedia:Requests for page protection 57 minutes 115 116

Jill Stein 57 minutes 245 4

Talk:Tucker Carlson 59 minutes 36 14

Cory Booker 1 hours 7 4

Hillary Clinton 1 hours 25 33

Wikipedia:Dispute resolution noticeboard 1 hours 12 6

Andrew Gillum 1 hours 7 15

Talk:Veracity of statements by Donald Trump 1 hours 2 11

Ben Shapiro 1 hours 69 12

Talk:Russian interference in the 2016 United States elections 1 hours 3 475

William Barr 1 hours 46 7

Talk:Dismissal of James Comey 1 hours 16 49

Talk:WikiLeaks 1 hours 48 8

Talk:Kyle Kashuv 1 hours 2 49

Talk:Rick Scott 1 hours 1 43

Greg Gianforte 1 hours 25 4

Donald Trump 1 hours 67 482

Rick Scott 2 hours 37 51

Justin Amash 2 hours 18 3

User talk:Axxxion 2 hours 1 5

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2017 April 28 2 hours 2 3

Ron Johnson (Wisconsin politician) 2 hours 18 4

Talk:Murder of Seth Rich 2 hours 47 8

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2017 June 16 3 hours 1 1

Douma chemical attack 3 hours 1 33

Ron DeSantis 3 hours 33 50

Joe Biden 3 hours 8 17

Liberty University 3 hours 72 10

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2017 May 22 4 hours 1 2

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2017 July 1 4 hours 1 2

Wikipedia:Fringe theories/Noticeboard 4 hours 51 52

Jeff Sessions 4 hours 17 14

Talk:Cambridge Analytica 6 hours 3 4

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2017 June 27 6 hours 1 1

Jennifer Rubin (journalist) 7 hours 7 9

Talk:Milo Yiannopoulos 7 hours 1 29

Milo Yiannopoulos 7 hours 2 57

The Daily Caller 8 hours 69 11

Laura Ingraham 9 hours 44 21

Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Requests for closure 9 hours 3 130

Steve Bannon 9 hours 10 26

Talk:CNN 10 hours 3 11

Kamala Harris 10 hours 20 16

Veracity of statements by Donald Trump 11 hours 3 6

Murder of Seth Rich 12 hours 45 2

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2017 July 7 13 hours 1 1

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Political positions of Jill Stein 13 hours 1 1

User talk:Factchecker atyourservice 14 hours 1 12

Talk:The Washington Times 14 hours 31 2

National Rifle Association 14 hours 27 93

User talk:MrX 16 hours 1 1129

Conor Lamb 19 hours 5 4

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pardon of Joe Arpaio (2nd nomination) 19 hours 1 2

Inauguration of Donald Trump 20 hours 3 8 Black Lives Matter 22 hours 4 25

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Donald Trump disclosure of classified information to Russia 22 hours 2 1

User talk:Rajulbat 23 hours 1 1

Elizabeth Warren 23 hours 12 1

Republican Party (United States) 1 days 76 1

Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Politics/American politics 1 days 15 2

Cambridge Analytica 1 days 13 3

David Clarke (sheriff) 1 days 9 13

Unite the Right rally 1 days 4 24

American Health Care Act of 2017 1 days 10 6

Social policy of Donald Trump 1 days 26 4

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Buck Sexton 1 days 5 1

Beto O'Rourke 1 days 24 18

2016 Democratic National Committee email leak 1 days 22 20

Hunter Biden 1 days 1 21

User talk:MikkelJSmith2 1 days 6 3

User talk:Winkelvi 2 days 4 12

CNN controversies 2 days 4 35

Hillary Clinton 2016 presidential campaign 2 days 8 36

Maria Butina 2 days 2 7

Julian Castro 2 days 1 6

Talk:Unite the Right rally 2 days 1 21

Talk:Joe Biden 3 days 2 8

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trump Derangement Syndrome 3 days 3 3

Talk:Peter Strzok 3 days 27 6

John Solomon (political commentator) 4 days 88 2

Talk:Political views of American academics 4 days 3 10

The Washington Times 5 days 76 6

Sonia Sotomayor 5 days 1 1

User talk:Wikireadia2020 5 days 1 3

Political views of American academics 5 days 2 7

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clinton Foundation-State Department controversy 6 days 1 1

Special Counsel investigation (2017–2019) 6 days 2 20

Talk:Julian Assange 6 days 61 1

User talk:Garp21 6 days 2 1

Joseph diGenova 7 days 43 1

Adam Putnam 8 days 4 4

Marco Rubio 8 days 5 52

Talk:2016 United States presidential election 8 days 7 6

Qasem Soleimani 8 days 2 2

China–United States trade war 9 days 3 6

Jim Jordan (American politician) 9 days 40 1

Kirsten Gillibrand 10 days 6 2

User talk:MelanieN 10 days 9 6