MNT: Refactor default violin KDE estimator

timhoffm · timhoffm · commit 1c123dbe5a67 · 2025-08-04T10:19:23.000+02:00
Move the default KDE estimator from a private definition
in `violinplot()` into `violin_stats()`. This makes it easier
to test and debug violin_stats() as we don't have to
explicitly provide a KDE method.

It also becomes logically simpler, because `violinplot()`
is now only `violin_stats()` + `violin()`.
diff --git a/lib/matplotlib/axes/_axes.py b/lib/matplotlib/axes/_axes.py
@@ -8878,18 +8878,8 @@ def violinplot(self, dataset, positions=None, vert=None,
         .Axes.violin : Draw a violin from pre-computed statistics.
         boxplot : Draw a box and whisker plot.
         """
-
-        def _kde_method(X, coords):
-            # Unpack in case of e.g. Pandas or xarray object
-            X = cbook._unpack_to_numpy(X)
-            # fallback gracefully if the vector contains only one value
-            if np.all(X[0] == X):
-                return (X[0] == coords).astype(float)
-            kde = mlab.GaussianKDE(X, bw_method)
-            return kde.evaluate(coords)
-
-        vpstats = cbook.violin_stats(dataset, _kde_method, points=points,
-                                     quantiles=quantiles)
+        vpstats = cbook.violin_stats(dataset, ("GaussianKDE", bw_method),
+                                     points=points, quantiles=quantiles)
         return self.violin(vpstats, positions=positions, vert=vert,
                            orientation=orientation, widths=widths,
                            showmeans=showmeans, showextrema=showextrema,
diff --git a/lib/matplotlib/cbook.py b/lib/matplotlib/cbook.py
@@ -29,7 +29,7 @@
     from numpy import VisibleDeprecationWarning
 
 import matplotlib
-from matplotlib import _api, _c_internal_utils
+from matplotlib import _api, _c_internal_utils, mlab
 
 
 class _ExceptionInfo:
@@ -1430,7 +1430,7 @@ def _reshape_2D(X, name):
         return result
 
 
-def violin_stats(X, method, points=100, quantiles=None):
+def violin_stats(X, method=("GaussianKDE", "scott"), points=100, quantiles=None):
     """
     Return a list of dictionaries of data which can be used to draw a series
     of violin plots.
@@ -1449,11 +1449,23 @@ def violin_stats(X, method, points=100, quantiles=None):
         Sample data that will be used to produce the gaussian kernel density
         estimates. Must have 2 or fewer dimensions.
 
-    method : callable
+    method : (name, bw_method) or callable,
         The method used to calculate the kernel density estimate for each
-        column of data. When called via ``method(v, coords)``, it should
-        return a vector of the values of the KDE evaluated at the values
-        specified in coords.
+        column of data. Valid values:
+
+        - a tuple of the form ``(name, bw_method)`` where *name* currently must
+          always be ``"GaussianKDE"`` and *bw_method* is the method used to
+          calculate the estimator bandwidth. Supported values are 'scott',
+          'silverman' or a float or a callable. If a float, this will be used
+          directly as `!kde.factor`.  If a callable, it should take a
+          `matplotlib.mlab.GaussianKDE` instance as its only parameter and
+          return a float.
+
+        - a callable with the signature ::
+
+             def method(data: ndarray, coords: ndarray) -> ndarray
+
+          It should return the KDE of *data* evaluated at *coords*.
 
     points : int, default: 100
         Defines the number of points to evaluate each of the gaussian kernel
@@ -1481,6 +1493,19 @@ def violin_stats(X, method, points=100, quantiles=None):
         - max: The maximum value for this column of data.
         - quantiles: The quantile values for this column of data.
     """
+    if isinstance(method, tuple):
+        name, bw_method = method
+        if name != "GaussianKDE":
+            raise ValueError(f"Unknown method {name!r} for violin_stats")
+
+        def _kde_method(x, coords):
+            # fallback gracefully if the vector contains only one value
+            if np.all(x[0] == x):
+                return (x[0] == coords).astype(float)
+            kde = mlab.GaussianKDE(x, bw_method)
+            return kde.evaluate(coords)
+
+        method = _kde_method
 
     # List of dictionaries describing each of the violins.
     vpstats = []
