I'm +1 for it - the question is where? There is no cookbook article currently on routing from a dynamic resource, so I think we should:

1. Boostrap a cookbook article called something like "How to Load Routes Dynamically or from a Database". This would give a basic example of the routing.loader tag usage, which is currently only covered here: http://symfony.com/doc/current/reference/dic_tags.html#routing-loader

2. Add a second section in that article (and we can also "tease it" higher up), which mentions the CMF Router and how it has built-in solutions for things like this with a link to its docs.

I think all of this would be very nice!

sounds like a plan! /cc @dbu

yeah. the plan is good. now somebody needs to do it :-)

i think when you load routes from the database the cmf RoutingExtraBundle is really the tool, so i would not see to explain that example. but you could have even more specific routing, for example when integrating a legacy framework, where writing your own router implementation makes more sense.

i'll keep this in mind and maybe write something when i find time. have quite a backlog of things that should be done on the cmf docs themselves, however.

+1 for a cookbook for dynamic routes with doctrine ORM

do you have any plans on this @dbu or @lsmith77 ? Otherwise I'll start working on this one

well there is a WIP to add ORM support into the RoutingBundle:
symfony-cmf/routing-bundle#116

however a more expanded cookbook entry to explain how to support a legacy routing table would of course be very welcome but i am not aware of plans to write one.

i did not forget about this, but did not find time to do it. the gist should be:

• if you want to store routes in the db, use cmf RouteBundle.
• if you have routes in a custom format in the db (or some other external source) and want to provide them, use DynamicRouter with a custom RouteProvider impl
• if you have a totally custom thing, use the ChainRouter of cmf RouteBundle and implement your own router

if you have time to write it, great! ping me on the PR so i can give you feedback.

you properbly mean the ChainRouter of the cmf Routing component, @dbu ?

well, it depends. if you use the bundle, you can tag your router to have it automatically added into the chain. without the bundle indeed you can bootstrap your own chain router and add your router to it. but you are right in the sense that there is no ChainRouter class in the RoutingBundle, we did not need anything symfony framework specific there.

Both the dynamic (http://symfony.com/doc/master/cmf/components/routing/dynamic.html) and the chain router (http://symfony.com/doc/master/cmf/components/routing/chain.html) are documented and linked from the Symfony Documentation section.

@weaverryan @wouterj this issue can be safely closed.

... linked from the Symfony Documentation section.

Where did you find such a link? I can't find one in the routing book, cookbook and components sections.

Afaics, the points proposed here by @weaverryan are not yet done, that's why I left this open:

1. Boostrap a cookbook article called something like "How to Load Routes Dynamically or from a Database". This would give a basic example of the routing.loader tag usage, which is currently only covered here: http://symfony.com/doc/current/reference/dic_tags.html#routing-loader

2. Add a second section in that article (and we can also "tease it" higher up), which mentions the CMF Router and how it has built-in solutions for things like this with a link to its docs.