Background: Learners should be exposed to the core principles of adolescent specific communicatio... more Background: Learners should be exposed to the core principles of adolescent specific communication and assessment frameworks as part of health professional curricula. How this is done can vary considerably, but the inclusion of adolescents seems an ideal and realistic option. However, securing their participation can be challenging. A viable option to adolescent patients may be adolescent simulated patients. Objective: This study describes adolescents' lived experiences of being simulated patients in health professional education. Design & setting: An interpretive phenomenological approach involving ten adolescent simulated patients from two health professional education programs in Australia. Methods: Consenting/assenting adolescents participated in semi-structured audio-recorded interviews. Data was transcribed verbatim and analysed using van Manen's phenomenological approach. Results: Adolescents offered unique insights and intimate knowledge of their lived experiences of simulated patient work. Adolescents reflected upon the often positive but sometimes challenging journey of simulated patient work. The identification of harm, largely unrecognized by adolescents themselves is the most concerning finding of this study. Conclusions: The experiences of adolescent simulated patients can help to shape the future of their involvement. However, their experiences also reveal myriad challenges. The implications for ethical practice must be reviewed before inclusion of adolescents as simulated patients is a feasible option.
BMJ Simulation and Technology Enhanced Learning, 2021
BackgroundReal patients in clinical placements are important for learning and may well be the ‘go... more BackgroundReal patients in clinical placements are important for learning and may well be the ‘gold standard’. However, simulated patients (SPs) are a viable alternative in the absence of this opportunity. While adult SPs contribute to health professions education, child and adolescent simulated patients (CASPs) are less common. This research aims to explore the perspectives of healthcare educators regarding the engagement of young SPs, specifically the identification of barriers and enablers to involving CASPs.MethodsWe used an interpretive paradigm of qualitative description. Thirteen interviewees, all educators involved in SP programmes, participated in semistructured interviews. Data were transcribed verbatim and analysed using an inductive thematic approach.FindingsNot all participants saw value in engaging CASPs. A number of barriers and enablers to involving them were acknowledged in six themes: challenges and concerns; logistical barriers; benefits of CASPs; overcoming chall...
Adolescent simulated patients (SPs) work in an environment where complex and dynamic power relati... more Adolescent simulated patients (SPs) work in an environment where complex and dynamic power relationships are at play. These relationships differ to those encountered in clinical practice. Instead of health professionals exerting their power from a foundation resting on knowledge, to a patient consumed with worry, SPs in simulation scenarios often have less worry and more knowledge than the learner. Combined with this, their role in judging and assessing learner performance adds to their power base. Adolescent SPs also experience power from the opposite perspective; where they have power exerted upon them, with limited ability to resist. This research aims to explore power relationships from adolescent SP's perspectives. Ten adolescent SPs, (10-19 years), participated in semi-structured interviews that were analysed using an interpretive phenomenological approach. Four themes resulted from an in-depth analysis of interview transcripts: 1) Becoming and being a powerful simulated patient; 2) redirection, resistance & responsibility; 3) the power of the role; and 4) a complex maze of interactions. These themes reflect the experiences adolescent SPs are exposed to and the powerful interactions that can result. Whilst there are positive outcomes for adolescent SPs, there is also a risk of harm. Recognizing this is an ethical imperative to ensure adolescent safety during the simulation process.
This is a PDF file of an article that has undergone enhancements after acceptance, such as the ad... more This is a PDF file of an article that has undergone enhancements after acceptance, such as the addition of a cover page and metadata, and formatting for readability, but it is not yet the definitive version of record. This version will undergo additional copyediting, typesetting and review before it is published in its final form, but we are providing this version to give early visibility of the article. Please note that, during the production process, errors may be discovered which could affect the content, and all legal disclaimers that apply to the journal pertain.
Simulated patients (SP) contribute to health professional education for communication, clinical s... more Simulated patients (SP) contribute to health professional education for communication, clinical skills teaching, and assessment. Although a significant body of literature exists on the involvement of adult SPs, limited research has been conducted on the contribution of children and adolescents. This systematic review, using narrative summary with thematic synthesis, aims to report findings related to children/adolescents as simulated patients in health professions education (undergraduate or postgraduate). A systematic review of qualitative and quantitative literature published between 1980 and September 2014 was undertaken using databases including CINAHL, Ovid Medline and Scopus. The lack of literature related to the employment of children and adolescents in nursing education dictated the expansion of the search to the wider health professions. Key search terms related to the employment of children and adolescents in health professional education programs. A total of 58 studies reduced to 36 following exclusion based on abstract review. Twenty-two studies reached full text review; following application of inclusion and exclusion criteria, 15 English language studies involving children and/or adolescents in simulation formed part of this systematic review. Five key themes emerged: Process related to recruitment, duration and content of training programs, support and debriefing practice, ethical considerations, and effects of participation for key stakeholders such as children and adolescents, parent and faculty, and learner outcomes. The results suggest that the involvement of children and adolescents in simulation for education and assessment purposes is valuable and feasible. The review identified the potential for harm to children/adolescents; however, rigorous selection, training and support strategies can mitigate negative outcomes. The ability of children to portray a role consistently across assessments, and deliver constructive feedback remains ambiguous.
Background Real patients in clinical placements are important for learning and may well be the ‘g... more Background Real patients in clinical placements are important for learning and may well be the ‘gold standard’. However, simulated patients (SPs) are a viable alternative in the absence of this opportunity. While adult SPs contribute to health professions education, child and adolescent simulated patients (CASPs) are less common. This research aims to explore the perspectives of healthcare educators regarding the engagement of young SPs, specifically the identification of barriers and enablers to involving CASPs. Methods We used an interpretive paradigm of qualitative description. Thirteen interviewees, all educators involved in SP programmes, participated in semistructured interviews. Data were transcribed verbatim and analysed using an inductive thematic approach. Findings Not all participants saw value in engaging CASPs. A number of barriers and enablers to involving them were acknowledged in six themes: challenges and concerns; logistical barriers; benefits of CASPs; overcoming ...
Children and adolescents are sporadically involved in health professions education as simulated p... more Children and adolescents are sporadically involved in health professions education as simulated patients – lay persons trained to act as real patients. This research explored the experiences of young simulated patients and health professions educators to facilitate a deeper understanding of the factors impacting on their engagement. Although perspectives were diverse and the actual need to engage them challenged by educators, the most significant findings relate to children/adolescents. Child and adolescent simulated patients experience power imbalances, a potential for harm exists and there is an ethical imperative to safeguard their wellbeing. These three elements combine to make involving CASPs in education a challenging notion.
Background: Learners should be exposed to the core principles of adolescent specific communicatio... more Background: Learners should be exposed to the core principles of adolescent specific communication and assessment frameworks as part of health professional curricula. How this is done can vary considerably, but the inclusion of adolescents seems an ideal and realistic option. However, securing their participation can be challenging. A viable option to adolescent patients may be adolescent simulated patients. Objective: This study describes adolescents' lived experiences of being simulated patients in health professional education. Design & setting: An interpretive phenomenological approach involving ten adolescent simulated patients from two health professional education programs in Australia. Methods: Consenting/assenting adolescents participated in semi-structured audio-recorded interviews. Data was transcribed verbatim and analysed using van Manen's phenomenological approach. Results: Adolescents offered unique insights and intimate knowledge of their lived experiences of simulated patient work. Adolescents reflected upon the often positive but sometimes challenging journey of simulated patient work. The identification of harm, largely unrecognized by adolescents themselves is the most concerning finding of this study. Conclusions: The experiences of adolescent simulated patients can help to shape the future of their involvement. However, their experiences also reveal myriad challenges. The implications for ethical practice must be reviewed before inclusion of adolescents as simulated patients is a feasible option.
BMJ Simulation and Technology Enhanced Learning, 2021
BackgroundReal patients in clinical placements are important for learning and may well be the ‘go... more BackgroundReal patients in clinical placements are important for learning and may well be the ‘gold standard’. However, simulated patients (SPs) are a viable alternative in the absence of this opportunity. While adult SPs contribute to health professions education, child and adolescent simulated patients (CASPs) are less common. This research aims to explore the perspectives of healthcare educators regarding the engagement of young SPs, specifically the identification of barriers and enablers to involving CASPs.MethodsWe used an interpretive paradigm of qualitative description. Thirteen interviewees, all educators involved in SP programmes, participated in semistructured interviews. Data were transcribed verbatim and analysed using an inductive thematic approach.FindingsNot all participants saw value in engaging CASPs. A number of barriers and enablers to involving them were acknowledged in six themes: challenges and concerns; logistical barriers; benefits of CASPs; overcoming chall...
Adolescent simulated patients (SPs) work in an environment where complex and dynamic power relati... more Adolescent simulated patients (SPs) work in an environment where complex and dynamic power relationships are at play. These relationships differ to those encountered in clinical practice. Instead of health professionals exerting their power from a foundation resting on knowledge, to a patient consumed with worry, SPs in simulation scenarios often have less worry and more knowledge than the learner. Combined with this, their role in judging and assessing learner performance adds to their power base. Adolescent SPs also experience power from the opposite perspective; where they have power exerted upon them, with limited ability to resist. This research aims to explore power relationships from adolescent SP's perspectives. Ten adolescent SPs, (10-19 years), participated in semi-structured interviews that were analysed using an interpretive phenomenological approach. Four themes resulted from an in-depth analysis of interview transcripts: 1) Becoming and being a powerful simulated patient; 2) redirection, resistance & responsibility; 3) the power of the role; and 4) a complex maze of interactions. These themes reflect the experiences adolescent SPs are exposed to and the powerful interactions that can result. Whilst there are positive outcomes for adolescent SPs, there is also a risk of harm. Recognizing this is an ethical imperative to ensure adolescent safety during the simulation process.
This is a PDF file of an article that has undergone enhancements after acceptance, such as the ad... more This is a PDF file of an article that has undergone enhancements after acceptance, such as the addition of a cover page and metadata, and formatting for readability, but it is not yet the definitive version of record. This version will undergo additional copyediting, typesetting and review before it is published in its final form, but we are providing this version to give early visibility of the article. Please note that, during the production process, errors may be discovered which could affect the content, and all legal disclaimers that apply to the journal pertain.
Simulated patients (SP) contribute to health professional education for communication, clinical s... more Simulated patients (SP) contribute to health professional education for communication, clinical skills teaching, and assessment. Although a significant body of literature exists on the involvement of adult SPs, limited research has been conducted on the contribution of children and adolescents. This systematic review, using narrative summary with thematic synthesis, aims to report findings related to children/adolescents as simulated patients in health professions education (undergraduate or postgraduate). A systematic review of qualitative and quantitative literature published between 1980 and September 2014 was undertaken using databases including CINAHL, Ovid Medline and Scopus. The lack of literature related to the employment of children and adolescents in nursing education dictated the expansion of the search to the wider health professions. Key search terms related to the employment of children and adolescents in health professional education programs. A total of 58 studies reduced to 36 following exclusion based on abstract review. Twenty-two studies reached full text review; following application of inclusion and exclusion criteria, 15 English language studies involving children and/or adolescents in simulation formed part of this systematic review. Five key themes emerged: Process related to recruitment, duration and content of training programs, support and debriefing practice, ethical considerations, and effects of participation for key stakeholders such as children and adolescents, parent and faculty, and learner outcomes. The results suggest that the involvement of children and adolescents in simulation for education and assessment purposes is valuable and feasible. The review identified the potential for harm to children/adolescents; however, rigorous selection, training and support strategies can mitigate negative outcomes. The ability of children to portray a role consistently across assessments, and deliver constructive feedback remains ambiguous.
Background Real patients in clinical placements are important for learning and may well be the ‘g... more Background Real patients in clinical placements are important for learning and may well be the ‘gold standard’. However, simulated patients (SPs) are a viable alternative in the absence of this opportunity. While adult SPs contribute to health professions education, child and adolescent simulated patients (CASPs) are less common. This research aims to explore the perspectives of healthcare educators regarding the engagement of young SPs, specifically the identification of barriers and enablers to involving CASPs. Methods We used an interpretive paradigm of qualitative description. Thirteen interviewees, all educators involved in SP programmes, participated in semistructured interviews. Data were transcribed verbatim and analysed using an inductive thematic approach. Findings Not all participants saw value in engaging CASPs. A number of barriers and enablers to involving them were acknowledged in six themes: challenges and concerns; logistical barriers; benefits of CASPs; overcoming ...
Children and adolescents are sporadically involved in health professions education as simulated p... more Children and adolescents are sporadically involved in health professions education as simulated patients – lay persons trained to act as real patients. This research explored the experiences of young simulated patients and health professions educators to facilitate a deeper understanding of the factors impacting on their engagement. Although perspectives were diverse and the actual need to engage them challenged by educators, the most significant findings relate to children/adolescents. Child and adolescent simulated patients experience power imbalances, a potential for harm exists and there is an ethical imperative to safeguard their wellbeing. These three elements combine to make involving CASPs in education a challenging notion.
Uploads
Papers by Andree Gamble