This essay’s objectives are to explore the possibilities of the legends of Prester John, Quetzalcóatl and Viracocha being ideologically connected, ostensibly serving the same imperial purpose in the conquest of non-European countries, and...
moreThis essay’s objectives are to explore the possibilities of the legends of Prester John, Quetzalcóatl and Viracocha being ideologically connected, ostensibly serving the same imperial purpose in the conquest of non-European countries, and the failed experiment by the Spanish and Portuguese to extend this legend into Asia. Furthermore, this essay will examine the consequences of these possibilities in terms of language and writing post-conquest history. In that sense, the purpose of Prester John, much like the legends of Quetzalcóatl and Viracocha was to justify the occupation of these lands by Spanish and Portuguese for the benefit of the Christian world.
Our theoretical sources are primarily drawn from the works of Walter Mignolo, Cornel West, and Guy Rozat Dupeyron. Our historical sources include: Robert Silverberg, Bernardino Sahagún, Christopher Columbus, and Hernán Cortés.
Our methodology is to question the historical validity of indigenous myths written ex-post facto by the colonizer, in the language of the colonizer, and in the explicit interests of the colonizer.
Our main results have shown that whereas the Asian/African quest to aid Prester John could be seen as a way to rationalize entry into, and (sometimes) conquest of foreign lands (a pre-conquest justification), the New World challenge would require a new strategy, manifesting itself as a post-conquest justification of European domination and indigenous subjugation, through a manipulation of their histories, religions, and (possible) prophecies. The experience common for both Aztec and Incas societies was an invasion of their world by the unknown, causing each society to actively seek out an explanation for this seemingly implausible experience. This, we posit, was all too readily offered (or at least manipulated) by conquistadors, colonizers, and missionaries.