Schoolcraft College Department of Mathematics
The Right Angle
Vol. 10, No. 1
September 2002
COMHISMA7 Report
A Fresh Wind from Morocco
by Prof. Randy Schwartz
hen I attended a conference in Marrakech,
Morocco this past summer, I had a number of
Dorothy and Toto moments (“We’re not in
Kansas anymore!”). At one of the conference dinners, we
were seated in groups of six people around circular tables in
the lunchroom of the host college. As we chatted and served
ourselves from a platter of Moroccan lamb, it suddenly
occurred to me that people from four of the world’s
continents were sitting together at our one little table!
Besides myself from North America, there was a retired
science professor from Córdoba, Argentina; a woman who
teaches middle-school mathematics in a suburb of Lisbon,
Portugal; a young African mathematics teacher educator
from Nouakchott, the capital of Mauritania; and two
Moroccan math education students from the host campus.
W
One of many banners greeting the Marrakech conferees
works published in the U.S. were the result of international
collaboration, an increase from 19.7% during 1986-8
(National Science Board, Science and Engineering
Indicators 2000).
At our dinner table that evening, we were all speaking
French as a sort of “lowest common denominator.” This we
combined with the international language of smiles and
gestures. There were also private conversations breaking out
in English, Spanish, Portuguese and Arabic. Navigating
across differences of language and culture was part of the
excitement of attending the Seventh Maghrebian Colloquium
on the History of Arabic Mathematics (COMHISMA7), held
May 30 – June 1 at the École Normale Supérieure (ENS), a
leading teacher’s college in Marrakech. The official
colloquium languages were French, Arabic and English,
although I was one of only four or five native speakers of
English who attended. The 60–70 participants came from 17
different nations on five continents, with a majority from
France and the countries of the Maghreb (northwest Africa).
A New Route to Europe
A number of the presentations at COMHISMA7 made
substantial new contributions to our understanding of the
invention of mathematical methods in the Arab world, and
their interaction with scientific developments elsewhere in
Africa, Europe and Asia.
It’s been known for a long time that our numeration
system, as well as many of our techniques in arithmetic,
algebra and other branches of mathematics, were brought to
Europe from the Arab world during the Middle Ages. But
what were the actual pathways of this transmission? The
traditional understanding has been that Islamic mathematics
gained only one significant entryway into Christian Europe,
via the trade routes linking Algeria with Italy. Most
famously, in the late 1100s a young Italian, Leonardo
Fibonacci, learned Arabic numerals and techniques while
working at his father’s counting house in Bejaia, a port on
the Algerian coast. He later spread the knowledge to Europe.
This particular history conference was somewhat
unusual in having a focus on the teaching of mathematics.
The conference was funded and convened by the Moroccan
Ministry of Education, and was organized by the college’s
Research Group on Teaching Mathematics and Computer
Science (GREDIM). Many of the presentations, including
my own, specifically addressed the integration of
mathematics history into course instruction as a way to
enhance learning and to provide students a more
multicultural perspective.
However, at the Marrakech conference, Jens Høyrup
from Denmark presented evidence that other transmission
routes must also have been important. Speaking in French on
“The Algebra of Jacopo of Florence: A Challenge to the
Historiography of Near-Modern Algebra,” Høyrup drew
attention to trade and other possible contact between Egypt,
Catalonia and Provence in the 14th Century (the latter two
coastal regions were politically unified at the time). His
evidence was based on a close reading of algebraic treatises
now held in the Vatican.
The mathematics that we were discussing at
COMHISMA7 is now many centuries old, yet the
international aspect of the gathering and its focus on
education pointed very much toward the future. I think that
as globalization knits the nations of the world ever more
closely together, we can expect various forms of crossborder communication (face-to-face as well as high-tech) to
become an increasingly routine and essential resource for
math educators and mathematicians. Check this out: a study
found that already in 1995-97, 26.8% of the mathematical
Another speaker, J. Lennart Berggren from Vancouver,
6
Schoolcraft College Department of Mathematics
The Right Angle
Vol. 10, No. 1
September 2002
British Columbia, has been busy editing the known surviving
works of Abu al-Jud, a late-10th-Century mathematician who
tackled many difficult geometry problems. An example:
given line segment BG and a point A not on it, find a point D
on BG such that AD BG + BD2 = BG2. Abu al-Jud not
only discovered a method to construct such a point D, he
also discovered the diorism or condition on point A that is
necessary to ensure that a solution exists. Some of these
problems were motivated by practical questions involved in
the construction of the astrolabe, an astronomical instrument.
It was amazing to hear Berggren announce that, based
on the number of references made by other mathematicians
to Abu al-Jud’s writings, he suspects that the great majority
of these writings haven’t even been uncovered yet, much less
studied thoroughly. That gave us a sense of how much work
remains to be done in bringing to light, and more deeply
understanding, the role played by the Arab world in the
history of mathematics.
Other presentations explored how mathematics was
applied in such fields as physics, astronomy, military science
and jurisprudence, the latter especially in implementing the
Qur’anic rules for inheritance of wealth. A talk by Kheira
Megri, an Algerian living in Paris, posed the question “How
Did ibn al-Haytham and Kamal al-din al-Farissi
Revolutionize Optics?” She detailed how geometry was used
by these Persian-born scholars to explain the focusing of
light rays and the formation of rainbows. These were aspects
of their comprehensive study of optics, whose greatest
significance was that it represented the earliest use of the
scientific method that still prevails today.
Yvonne Dold-Samplonius of Heidelberg, Germany
treated us to the first public presentation of her new 10minute video, “Magic of Muqarnas,” which is suitable for
classroom use. The video, which has colorful images and
haunting music but no narration, depicts the geometry that
Jamshid al-Kashi used in the 15th Century to design faceted
vaults called muqarnas, a key architectural element of the
intricate domed interiors that can still be seen today in
structures throughout the Muslim world. Her earlier video
“Qubba for al-Kashi” (1996), distributed by the American
Mathematical Society, shows how the same mathematician
calculated the volume and surface area of domes. Al-Kashi,
who worked at the royal observatory in Samarqand (in
modern Uzbekistan), is best known for making prodigious
calculations useful to astronomers. He was able to
approximateto 16 decimal places, and he solved a cubic
equation in order to find a value for sin(1º).
When SC English Prof. Gordon Wilson was traveling in Italy
and Spain this summer, he found a statue of Leonardo
Fibonacci in his home town of Pisa, Italy and snapped some
th
photos. This year is the 800 anniversary of Fibonacci’s
completion of his most famous book, Liber Abaci, which
played a huge role in popularizing algebra and other Arab
mathematical techniques in Europe. Conferences celebrating
the anniversary are being held in Bejaia, Algeria (June 24-26)
and Pisa, Italy (Nov. 20-23). Springer-Verlag is publishing the
first complete English translation of the book.
how should teachers be prepared to use such strategies? She
outlined a spiral four-step process, in which the instructor
analyzes the needs of the class, plans an activity, brings it to
fruition, and then evaluates its effectiveness. To create a new
course activity, she browses textbooks on the history of
math, singles out relevant passages and authors, goes back to
the primary sources, and finally prepares new instructional
materials, taking into account the means, aims and context of
the activity.
Lessons for the Classroom
Among the presentations dealing more directly with
instructional methods in mathematics was that by Fulvia
Furinghetti, whose students include both education and
science majors at the University of Genoa, Italy. Her talk,
“History as a Tool for Mathematics Education and for
Research in Mathematics,” focused on three questions: what
are the purposes and benefits of using history in mathematics
instruction; which teaching strategies should be selected; and
Furinghetti made the point that teaching a mathematical
topic in its historical and cultural context can provide the
kind of fresh perspective that provokes students to think
more deeply. At the same time, she said, requiring the
students to re-enact the exact historical paths of discovery is
continued on next page
7
Schoolcraft College Department of Mathematics
The Right Angle
COMHISMA7 REPORT (cont’d from previous page)
Vol. 10, No. 1
seldom the most effective way for them to assimilate
historical material. She also mentioned a number of
reference works useful to instructors seeking to incorporate
historical material into mathematics coursework.
Omar Rouan of the ENS outlined the “Evolution of
Moroccan Programs in Probability and Statistics at the
Secondary and College Level,” from their inception in
French in 1967-69, through their reform in 1971-74, to their
Arabization in 1985 and more recent developments. In
Morocco, as in many other countries around the world,
decisions about course curricula and teaching materials are
made not by individual instructors or departments, but at the
ministerial level. Based on what Omar reviewed for us, it
appeared to me that the high degree of centralization in
Morocco has been a factor that might have slowed the
process of reshaping the mathematics curriculum in order to
make it more effective and modern. Nevertheless, in the
national curriculum for probability and statistics there has
been a gradual evolution toward many of the same changes
that have occurred in the United States, including a trend
away from the abstract and formal toward the more concrete
and contextual; away from a dense and ambitious toward a
more lean and limited selection of topics; away from passive
lecturing toward constructive and other more active
pedagogical approaches; and away from an emphasis on
statistical laws and toward greater emphasis on graphical
presentations and interpretation.
September 2002
explore each concept from a number of different
perspectives, including verbal, numerical, graphical,
and algebraic
guide the students from easier to more difficult
problems
streamline the discussion and modernize the notation
select applications that are appropriate and interesting
to these students
show the relation between Arab historical techniques
and those from China, India, and Europe.
And I summarized the major benefits of these efforts:
to begin to break down the Eurocentric bias of the
standard mathematics curriculum in the United States
to encourage in students a respect for, and interest in,
other cultures than their own
to enhance the interest and appeal of mathematics
lessons for the students
to foster the understanding that mathematics isn’t
simply a collection of abstract ideas, but is a product
of the thinking and work of real people trying to solve
practical problems
to help strengthen certain skills and attitudes that are
important for functioning in an increasingly
interdependent world
to round out the technical skills of the students by
teaching them some mathematical methods that are
still useful even though centuries old.
COMHISMA7 showed that mathematics instructors
from different nations and cultures can get together and
exchange ideas about the content and history of
mathematics, and how to integrate them into classroom
instruction and other forms of education. I was thrilled to be
able to travel to Morocco and learn from the experiences of
colleagues from across the planet. I’m especially grateful to
the Moroccan Ministry of Education and the various
organizers of the colloquium, as well as to Schoolcraft
College for making my participation possible.
My own presentation was entitled, “Introducing
Historical Arab Mathematics to a Two-Year College in the
United States.” I spoke in English, but used transparencies
written in French so as to increase my access to this
international audience. Since the “community college”
phenomenon has little or no parallel in most other countries,
I devoted the first section of my talk to making sure the
listeners understood the role of such a college and the
characteristics of our students. Then I related my experiences
incorporating selected mathematical contributions of Arab
and other cultures into my classes, as crystallized in a series
of self-paced written activities that I developed for several of
my courses (for more details, see my article “Bringing Other
Cultures into the Math Classroom,” The Right Angle March
2002).
Naturally, the current state of heightened tension
between America and the Arab world made my audience that
much more interested in what I was sharing. The U.S. is
perhaps the country where the scientific contributions of
Arab and other non-European peoples have been least
recognized.
But even more, my colleagues were interested to learn
how I’ve made good use of the history of mathematics in
courses that aren’t mainly aimed at math or history majors. I
shared with them the methods that I’ve found useful in
making such materials accessible to modern, mostly young,
English-only students focusing on careers in business and
engineering:
8