Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Traditional crafts of Ireland (review)

2004, Journal of Design History

Reviews David Shaw-Smith (ed.), Thames & Hudson, 2003, revised edition, originally published as Ireland’s Traditional Crafts 1984. 256 pp., 677 illus., 621 col. pls. £24.95. ISBN: 0 500 51142 X. For almost thirty years and through a series of more than forty television programmes, David Shaw-Smith has chronicled Irish craft workers, and in doing so has created an unmatched record of individuals, techniques and artefacts. His Hands documentaries for RTE (the Irish state broadcaster) were intended, he says, as ‘a record of a number of endangered crafts to be made for posterity’ (p. 253). Ireland’s Traditional Crafts (1984) was driven by the same impetus, detailing as it did crafts that were once popular, but now seem to be practised by only a few individuals. Organized according to materials, it comprised short essays on particular crafts written by experts and illustrated by Shaw-Smith’s photographs and Sally Shaw-Smith’s drawings. It has now been revised and reissued as Traditional Crafts of Ireland. The new edition seems better. It is bigger for a start, with forty-nine essays by nineteen contributors 117 Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/jdh/article/18/1/117/346123 by University College Dublin user on 30 May 2023 Traditional Crafts of Ireland Reviews this is a strong contribution to the existing literature on Irish crafts. The relationship of the book to the Hands television series is apparent in the focus on individual craft workers, and lends a strong narrative to many of the essays. Some readers might find it frustrating, however, when the work of particular firms or individuals is treated in isolation, as this gives little sense of whether their method of working is typical, and whether many others are still engaged with the particular craft in question. Unfortunately, this vagueness extends to the images. Few if any of the photographs are dated, but most appeared in the last edition of the book making them at least twenty years old. For a newly published book about surviving crafts to be filled with pictures of people in settings, dress and hairstyles of two decades ago calls into question the accuracy of it as a contemporary record. Some changes from the time the first edition was published are addressed in the written text—for example, some of the craft workers have since died, but that the photographs alongside are presented without indicating their date creates a disconcerting dislocation between the visual and textual narrative. This matters more in some cases than others—for example, the essay on dyeing is illustrated by a photograph of women on the island of Inis Meáin leaving Mass dressed in crochet shawls and indigo petticoats, the caption relating that ‘this is the traditional dress of the older women’ (p. 26). But as the ‘older’ women represented in word and image might well be dead now, can the caption still stand? That said, as long as the reader does not approach the book as a contemporary record, there is much to recommend it. As well as the range and variety of subjects and the quality of the images, there is useful extra information such as a guide to places to visit and a detailed section on further reading. That so many of the texts in this part have been published since the first edition of the book is encouraging. Traditional Crafts of Ireland does deserve a place on the shelves of those interested in Irish cultural history, but should be set alongside more historically sensitive studies such as Claudia Kinmonth’s Irish Country Furniture 1700–1950 (Yale, 1993). In his introduction to Ireland’s Traditional Crafts, David Shaw-Smith expressed the hope that more people in Ireland would turn to craft as a livelihood. He wrote that ‘living with the realities of redundancy 118 Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/jdh/article/18/1/117/346123 by University College Dublin user on 30 May 2023 as opposed to forty essays by thirteen contributors. The new content includes an essay on stained glass by Nicola Gordon Bowe, a whole new section on calligraphy and a much expanded ceramics section. It is also brighter: of the illustrations in the earlier book roughly a quarter were in colour while now the majority of them are. This range and variety of content pose a challenge to the reviewer—what might be true of one essay will not hold for another, but there is a basic commonality of approach, engendered it would seem by editorial intention. Shaw-Smith’s definition of ‘traditional’ crafts is difficult to pin down. While most of the content is concerned with what might be deemed Irish folklife, this is not the only criterion for inclusion, as the book also contains essays on Donegal carpets (established 1898) and the essay on fine-ware ceramics by Mairead Dunlevy traces the history of materials and techniques from the Anglo-Norman period up to the present day. But for the most part, the writers emphasize the antiquity of the craft in question, avoiding locating it in any historical period. Terms such as ‘age-old’ and ‘ancient’ recur in describing particular techniques, with ‘former’ or ‘olden times’ the only way of describing when these crafts flourished. In many cases, of course, the origins of particular ways of making or doing are simply unknown, but it would be helpful for the reader if at least some indication was given of when certain objects or techniques were widespread, and if, when and why they changed. For example, in Kevin Danaher’s essay on furniture the author suggests that to ‘contemporary eyes, houses in Ireland in former times would have appeared very scantily furnished’ (p. 67). In support of this, he mentions examples from folk-tales and then average Irish kitchens of three-quarters of a century ago as if the same way of furnishing domestic interiors prevailed in Ireland from the mythic past to within living memory. This approach, which is often taken by the authors in the book, means that design historians will find that much of the content of Traditional Crafts of Ireland does not address the social and economic context within which material culture is produced and consumed. What design historians and others will find helpful about the book is its detailed treatment of technique and process. Beautifully photographed images of craft workers show the stages of production of artefacts and often the materials and tools used to make them. Presented along with instructive and informative text, Reviews Lisa Godson Royal College of Art doi:10.1093/jdh/epi015 119 Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/jdh/article/18/1/117/346123 by University College Dublin user on 30 May 2023 and unemployment many young people reject the idea of a conventional career’. In the new edition, that line has been tweaked to read ‘Living with the realities of a buoyant Irish economy yet increasingly stressful lifestyle, many people are rejecting the idea of a conventional career’ (p. 12). Craft then is presented as a redemptive force, whether from the disappointments of economic stagnation or the pressures of Ireland’s recent economic success. This is not a new argument of course; handicraft has for long been invoked as a corrective to the disenchantments of modernity. This attitude seems the likely reason for the lack of specificity in much of this book—by setting ‘traditional’ crafts outside history, even when they are part of the present day, they are presented as transcendent of the specific conditions of their making and reception.