Dublin Institute of Technology
ARROW@DIT
Articles
Social Sciences
2003-01-01
Determinants of Sexual Behaviour
Kevin Lalor
Dublin Institute of Technology, kevin.lalor@dit.ie
Cathal O'Regan
Siobhan Quinlan
Follow this and additional works at: htp://arrow.dit.ie/aaschsslarts
Part of the Psychology Commons, and the Sociology Commons
Recommended Citation
Lalor, K., O'Regan, C. & Quinlan, S. Determinants of sexual behaviour. Irish Journal of Sociology, 2003, Vol.12 (2), pp. 121-133.
doi:10.1177/079160350301200208
his Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Social
Sciences at ARROW@DIT. It has been accepted for inclusion in Articles by
an authorized administrator of ARROW@DIT. For more information,
please contact yvonne.desmond@dit.ie, arrow.admin@dit.ie.
his work is licensed under a Creative Commons AtributionNoncommercial-Share Alike 3.0 License
DETERMINANTS OF SEXUAL BEHAVIOUR AMONGST A SAMPLE OF
COLLEGE STUDENTS
INTRODUCTION
A common theme of the media portrayal of adolescent sexual behaviour in Ireland is
that of the ‘debauched and decadent lifestyles’ referred to by Devlin (this volume).
Devlin details a number of instances in both tabloid and broadsheet newspapers of
coverage of adolescent sexual behaviour, characterised by moral panic yet (largely)
devoid of empirical or statistical content.
Inglis (1998) suggests four main discourses on sexuality in Ireland: traditional,
progressive, liberal and radical. To illustrate, he explores the discourses surrounding
the development of the ‘Relationships and Sexuality Education’ programme by the
National Council for Curriculum and Assessment.
These discourses range from
outright opposition from a variety of Catholic interest groups, to mixed responses
from teachers, to a generally positive response from media commentators. Of course,
most debate on adolescent sexual behaviour is informed by beliefs in how young
people should, or should not, behave.
Young peoples’ actual behaviour can be
sidelined in such value-laden debates (and pronouncements).
The purpose of this paper is to contribute to the debate by detailing the sexual
behaviour of a sample of college students, predominantly in their late teens (or, at
least, the behaviour they say they engage in – see comments below on methodological
reliability). A sample of 247 students of the Dublin Institute of Technology were
surveyed regarding their experiences of both consensual and unwanted sexual
experiences during childhood and adolescence.
The findings regarding their
unwanted sexual experiences whilst younger than 16 years of age have been reported
elsewhere (Lalor, 1999). This paper examines the consensual sexual experiences of
the sample before their sixteenth birthdays and a number of related issues, such as
sexual orientation and duration of boyfriend/girlfriend relationships. It also explores
the determinants of sexual behaviour amongst the sample.
1
MacHale and Newell (1997) surveyed the sexual behaviour and sex education of 2754
pupils aged between 15 and 18 years, attending 40 second level schools in Galway
City and County, by an anonymous self-administering questionnaire. Twenty one per
cent of the pupils had had sexual intercourse, with boys more than twice as likely as
girls to have had sexual intercourse. The mean age of first coitus was 15.5 years.
Over half of the respondents stated that the first time they had sex was with a ‘casual’
partner or ‘one night stand’, with 35% claiming that alcohol and 9% claiming that
non-prescribed drugs were a contributory factor. Male participants were more than
twice as likely than female participants to have first sexual intercourse with a casual
partner. Regarding the frequency of sexual intercourse experiences, just under half
the participants (242; 48%) reported having intercourse only occasionally with one
fifth of participants (104; 20%) having intercourse weekly or more frequently.
In addition, the majority of both male and female participants (235; 72% and 156;
72% respectively) stated they used a condom at first sexual intercourse but, of the 475
pupils who had sex regularly, only 67% used condoms ‘all the time’ with 33%
‘sometimes’ or ‘never’ using condoms.
Also, a study was conducted by the Midland Health Board (1996) which explored the
sexual practices of 1,645 male and female (892 and 762 respectively) 16-18 year old
secondary school students from 12 randomly selected schools within the Midland
Health Board catchment area. The study reported that 32% of the 1,645 participants
stated they had sexual intercourse and there was no significant difference between
socio-economic groups. The study also highlighted that males were significantly
more likely to have had sexual intercourse than females, with 38% of males and 26%
of females stating they had had sexual intercourse. The study reveled that 75% of the
447 participants who stated they had sexual intercourse were between 15 and 17 years
of age when they first had sexual intercourse. In addition, 26% of those who had
sexual intercourse stated they had three or more sexual partners.
Regarding
contraceptive use, 82% of the sexually active participants stated that they used
contraception, with 70% of the participants using contraception the first time they had
sexual intercourse.
2
A study conducted by Alliance (1997) explored the attitudes and values of young
people in Cork City towards sexuality, relationships, AIDS, alcohol and drug use.
The study consisted of a self-administered questionnaire of 800 young people between
the ages of 15 and 24. Four focus groups were also conducted. The results of the
study showed that 30% of the female participants and 45% of male participants in the
15-17 years old category had had sexual intercourse. In addition, 22% of all female
participants and 32% of all male participants had their first sexual intercourse
experience by the age of 16. The study also showed that 81% (n=64) of the 15-17
year old sexually active females have had two sexual partners or less, and 46% (n=24)
of the 15-17 year old sexually active males reported having three sexual partners or
more.
Fitzpatrick, Fitzpatrick and Turner (1997) examined the sexual behaviour and sociodemographic characteristics of 120 teenage mothers attending a public adolescent
antenatal clinic. The ages of the teenagers attending the clinic ranged from 14 to 19,
with a mean age of 17.7 years. Only five participants were under 16 years of age.
There was little indication of promiscuity within the sample. For example, ninetyseven (80.8%) participants stated that they had sexual intercourse with one partner, 21
(17.5%) stated that they had two sexual partners and two (1.7%) said that they had
three sexual partners, with 105 (87.5%) stating that they were still in a relationship
with the father of the child. Of the 120 participants, only 62 (51.7%) had used
contraception in the past, with only 33 (27.5%) using contraception ‘regularly’ and
only five participants stated that they ‘always’ used contraception. Five participants
(4.2%) had had a previous pregnancy; of these one had an abortion, one had a
miscarriage and the remaining three gave birth.
Thus, these adolescent pregnancies would appear to be the result of low levels of
contraceptive use, rather than rampant promiscuity or a ‘melt-down’ in the ‘morals’ of
young people. It is interesting to note that the number of births to adolescents in
Ireland has not significantly changed in the last 20 years. However, the number of
births to single adolescent mothers has increased. In 1972, 24% of births to women
under 20 were outside marriage, however, by 1992, 89.3% of births to women under
20 were outside marriage. In 1997, 2,894 women under 20 years of age gave birth in
3
Ireland, representing 5.5% of all births, with the majority (95%) of these births to
single women.
A survey of the sexual behaviour of a sample of 405 students of the Dublin Institute of
Technology was undertaken recently by the Students’ Union (DITSU, 2000). Data
was collected by means of personal interview.
Results suggest that 79% of
respondents have had “full sexual intercourse,” although only 15% of the total sample
report having “regular sexual intercourse.” Unfortunately, no data is available as to
the age respondents were when they first experienced intercourse, nor do we know
which proportion of students from Years one, two, three and four responded positively
to this question. That is, we do not know what proportion of First Years (most of
whom are 18 years old) answered this question in the affirmative, relative to Fourth
Years (most of who we can presume to be 22 years of age). A subsequent question
asks respondents when they “became sexually active.” Forty one per cent reported
becoming “sexually active” before their Leaving Certificate and a further 37% said it
was during their Leaving Certificate (which most students sit at 17 or 18 years of age).
However, as “becoming sexually active” is not operationalised, this item tells us less
than it might first appear to do. Students were also asked to describe their sexual
orientation; 97% reported being heterosexual, 2% reported being bi-sexual and 1%
reported being homosexual.
The law and sexual behaviour amongst adolescents
A number of Acts regulate the sexual behaviour of young people. Sections 1 and 2 of
the Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, 1935 ban ‘unlawful carnal intercourse’ with
girls under 15 (maximum penalty: life imprisonment) and girls aged 15 or 16
(maximum penalty: five years imprisonment). The offence is committed by the male
party; his age (nor her consent) is no defence (Ryan, 1997). ‘Statutory rape’ is not a
strictly legal concept.
The law appears to permit consensual non-penetrative sexual activity between a male
and a female (or between 2 females) where the female is fifteen or older. This is a
result of Section 14 of the Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, 1935:
4
“Defence of consent by person under 15 years of age
14 – It shall not be a defence to a charge of indecent assault upon a
person under the age of fifteen years to prove that such person
consented to the act alleged to constitute such indecent assault.”
By implication, such a defence is open to parties aged 15 or over, provided that the
activity does not involve sexual intercourse.
This is not the case for homosexual acts. Section 4 of the Criminal Law (Sexual
Offences) Act, 1993 decriminalised anal intercourse subject to new requirements
penalising such behaviour with persons under age 17. The Act makes it an offence to
engage in ‘gross indecency’ where both parties are male and one is under the age of
17, even where both of the parties consent.
To summarise:
Activity
Age of consent
Offence
Sexual intercourse
17
Unlawful carnal intercourse
Acts other than sexual intercourse
15
Indecent assault
17
Gross indecency
(heterosexual and lesbian)
Any homosexual acts
Table 1: summary of law governing sexual behaviour in adolescence
Describing the origins of the Criminal Law (Sexual Offences) Act, 1993, Ryan (1997)
ponders:
“Doubtless public opinion would … have recoiled at the prospect of 15-yearold males engaging in sexual activity, of however timid a nature, with other
males. But what, one may ask, makes a 15-year-old Irish girl so much more
robust in the face of male advances that she requires less protection than her
5
male contemporaries?” (pp. 41-42).
METHODOLOGY
For the present study, an anonymous questionnaire was administered to 247 students
of the Dublin Institute of Technology during the academic year 1996-1997. A range
of demographic questions were presented as well as a range of questions relating to
sexual experiences whilst under age 16. Other questions examined sexual orientation
and respondents’ length of sexual relationships.
Prior to the distribution of the
questionnaire, approximately fifteen minutes was spent with the students discussing
the research, covering the pertinent ethical issues and allowing for any questions to be
answered.
It is important to note that, as with all such ‘self-report’ surveys of sexual behaviour,
the results have to be interpreted cautiously. Sexuality and sexual behaviour are
notoriously difficult to survey in a quantitative way. Responses may be influenced by
bravado, modesty, shame, denial and a range of cultural discourses which determine
how respondents believe they should report their sexual behaviour, regardless of the
degree of questionnaire anonymity. Such confounding variables may or may not be
conscious. For example, Rajani & Kudrati (1996) describe the widespread initiation
ritual of anal sex, regarded as “an important rite of passage in identity formation”
(1996: 308) amongst street boys in Mwanza, Tanzania. Also frequent amongst street
boys was anal intercourse initiated by one boy on another (typically) more docile boy
for the relief of sexual tension and mutual ‘comfort sex.’
Paradoxically, to be
perceived as mhanisi (or ‘faggot’) is reportedly the worst form of humiliation amongst
street boys. Thus, categories of sexual behaviour (or, as in the above instance, sexual
orientation) may not be as clear-cut as initially imagined.
RESULTS
Introduction
6
Demographic characteristics of the sample are presented, followed by data describing
the adolescent sexual experiences of the sample and other related issues. A focus
throughout shall be the extent to which variables such as age, gender and geographic
origins of respondents determines their level of sexual experience.
Age, gender and geographic origin
A total of 247 students of the Dublin Institute of Technology were surveyed.
Approximately 75% were in the 18-20 age group, with smaller numbers of older age
groups. Seventy one per cent were female, which is typical of the student profile in
the courses that were surveyed.
Age
Total
Male
Female
Total
% (No.)
% (No.)
% (No.)
22.67 (56)
52.22 (129)
74.89 (185)
21-25
4 (10)
14.57 (36)
18.62(46)
26-30
1.2 (3)
3.64 (9)
4.85 (12)
31-35
0.4 (1)
0.8 (2)
1.21 (3)
36-40
0.4 (1)
0 (0)
0.4 (1)
28.74 (71)
71.25 (176)
100 (247)
18-20
Table 2: Sample by age and gender.
Approximately half of the sample originate (defined as, ‘where have you lived for the
longest period until age 16?’) in Dublin City or County; the remainder come from a
range of medium and small towns and rural areas. Very few (9) come from Cork,
Waterford, Limerick or Galway cities:
7
No.
% of total
Dublin City or County
114
46.5
Cork, Waterford, Limerick or Galway city
9
3.7
Town with population between 10,000-50,000
27
11
Town with population between 5,000-10,000
14
5.7
Town/village with population less than 5,000
37
15.1
Rural/Farm
37
15.1
Other
9
3.6
Total
247
100
Table 3: Origin of respondents
Consensual sexual experiences whilst under age 16
Partner 21 yrs. +
Partner <21 yrs.
Male
Female
Total
Male
Female
Total
% within
% within
% within
% within
% within
% within
gender
gender
gender
gender
gender
total
(No.)
(No.)
(No.)
(No.)
(No.)
(No.)
20.3
20.1
20.2
91.5
81.4
84.4%
(13)
(33)
(46*)
(65)
(140)
(205*)
Genital
0
1.8
1.3
49.3
31
36.3%
fondling
(0)
(3)
(3)
(34)
(53)
(87)
0
2.4
1.7
40
26.3
30.3
(0)
(4)
(4)
(28)
(45)
(73)
1.4
1.2
1.3
24.3
13.2
16.5
(1)
(2)
(3)
(17)
(22)
(39)
0
1.2
0.8
18.6
9.9
12.4
(0)
(2)
(2)
(13)
(17)
(30)
Kissing
Masturbation
Oral sex
Intercourse
Table 4: Consensual sexual experiences below age 16 (*totals exceed sample size
due to doubling counting)
The data is presented according to the age of respondents’ sexual partners. A five
year age gap is of interest when studying the exploitative/abusive sexual experiences
8
of adolescents (Lalor, 1999). For the purposes of this paper, the primary focus is on
the sexual experiences respondents have had whilst under age 16 with others aged less
than 21 years. Such partners shall be termed ‘age mates.’
A number of interesting patterns are evident in Table 4. Firstly, adolescents below
age 16 are considerably more likely to have sexual experiences with people under age
21, compared to people aged 21 years or more. Thus, for example, whilst 1.3% of the
sample have experienced ‘genital fondling’ with somebody over age 21 (whilst they
were under age 16), 36.3% have done so with somebody closer to their own age (that
is, under age 21). Similarly, whilst 0.8% of the sample have had intercourse with
somebody over age 21 (whilst under 16 years), 12.4% have had intercourse with
somebody closer in age (that is, under 21). Indeed, aside from kissing, very few
respondents had any sexual relations with people aged over 21.
As a general comment, we can say that the majority of 16 year olds (84%) have kissed
an ‘age mate’ (that is, a partner younger than 21); about one third (30%) have ‘been
masturbated by, or masturbated’ an age-mate, and just over 12% have had intercourse.
For the 10.22% (n=18; 17 with age mates and one other respondent with a 21+ year
old only) of females in the sample who have had intercourse, their male partners
(regardless of age) have committed the offence of unlawful carnal intercourse.
Another interesting trend is the gender differences in sexual experiences whilst
younger than age 16. Males are twice as likely to have oral sex or intercourse and
about one and a half times as likely to have experienced masturbation by another
person and genital fondling with ‘age-mates’ than females.
The opposite is the case for sexual experiences with people aged over 21. Here,
females are more likely to have had such experiences. For example, two females have
had intercourse with somebody over age 21, whilst younger than 16, compared to no
males.
After age 16, such gender differences do not persist, at least with regard to sexual
intercourse. Respondents were asked if they had ever had intercourse and no gender
9
difference exists: some 61% of males and 58% of females have had sexual
intercourse.
However, if we consider 18-20 year olds only and exclude older
respondents, a gender difference remains: 57% of 18-20 year old males have had
sexual intercourse, compared with 47.7% of females.
Urban-rural differences
Where an adolescent grows up has an influence on his/her degree of sexual behaviour.
Significant differences are reported by those who report growing up in towns (pop.
5,000+), large towns (10,000+) or cities (Cork, Waterford, Limerick, Galway or
Dublin) (collectively deemed ‘urban’) and those who reported growing up in villages
(pop. < 5,000), rural areas or farms (collectively deemed ‘rural’). Table 5 below
illustrates the degree of sexual activity experienced before 16 years of age with a
partner younger than 21 years of age:
Urban
Rural
Significance
%
%
Genital fondling
43.75
21.25
p=.0028
Masturbation
38.13
14.81
p=.00066
Oral sex
21.38
6.41
p=.011
Intercourse
16.25
4.94
p=.042
Table 5: Urban-rural differences in sexual experiences before age 16
As we can see, people younger than 16 from ‘urban’ areas are significantly more
likely to engage in all forms of sexual behaviour than young people from ‘rural’ areas.
It is interesting to look at the gender differences in sexual behaviour before age 16
amongst rural dwellers:
10
Rural male
Rural female
Significance
N
%
%
Genital fondling
53.85
14.93
.0039
80
Intercourse
21.43
1.49
.0086
81
Table 6: Male-female differences in sexual behaviour below age 16 amongst
rural dwellers
That is, rural males are significantly more likely than rural females to have sexual
experiences before age 16.
Place of origin continues to have an influence on later sexual behaviour. Respondents
were asked whether they had ever been in a sexually active relationship (not
necessarily including sexual intercourse) and whether they had ever had intercourse.
These responses are categorized by place of origin below. Sample sizes in some of
the ‘place of origin’ categories are too small to be useful (for example, only 9 of the
sample come from cities outside Dublin, that is, Cork, Waterford, Limerick and
Galway). However, the larger sub-samples are presented below:
Ever been in a sexually active
Ever had sexual
relationship (not necessarily
intercourse?
Total
involving intercourse)?
Dublin city or county
Town, pop. 10000 - 50000
Town/village pop. < 5000
Rural/farm
% (No.)
% (No.)
% (No.)
76.3
64
100
(87)
(73)
(114)
88.9
59.3
100
(24)
(16)
(27)
78.4
58.3
100
(29)
(21)
(37)
56.8
38.9
100
(21)
(14)
(37)
Table 7: Urban-rural differences in ‘ever been in a sexual relationship’ and ‘ever
had sexual intercourse’
11
As we can see, there are few differences between Dublin and small towns/villages of
less than 5000. However, there are considerable differences between both these two
categories and those respondents from farms or rural areas. Whilst 64% of those from
Dublin have had intercourse, only 39% of those from rural and farm areas have.
Age-related differences
The age cohorts of the sample were strong determinants of respondents’ sexual
experiences. As we might expect, the data shows a significant difference between 1820 year olds and those aged 21 or more in whether or not they had ever been in a
sexually active relationship.
Have been in a sexually active
Have not been in a sexually
relationship
active relationship
% (No.)
% (No.)
18-20 (n=185)
70.27 (130)
29.7 (55)
21-25 (n=45)
84.4 (38)
15.6 (7)
26-30 (n=12)
91.7 (11)
8.3 (1)
31-35 (n=3)
100 (3)
0 (0)
Table 8: Age-related differences in involvement in sexually active relationships
(n= 245; missing = 2)
Thus, whilst 84.4% of 21-25 year olds have been in a sexually active relationship, just
70.3% of 18-20 year olds have.
Not surprisingly, these age differences extend to whether or not respondents report
having had sexual intercourse:
12
Age
Have had intercourse
Have not had
Total
% (No.)
intercourse
% (No.)
% (No.)
18-20
50.54 (93)
49.46 (91)
76 (184)
21-25
81.82 (36)
18.18 (8)
18 (44)
26-30
100 (11)
0 (0)
4.5 (11)
31-35
100 (3)
0 (0)
1.2 (3)
Total
59.09 (143)
40.91 (99)
100 (242)
Table 9: Age by experience of sexual intercourse
Thus, amongst 18-20 year olds, 50.54% have had sexual intercourse. Amongst 21-25
year olds (n=44), 81.8% have had intercourse and amongst 26+ year olds (n=14),
100% have had sexual intercourse.
Boyfriend/girlfriend relationships
Respondents were asked to indicate what was the longest relationship they have had
with a boyfriend or girlfriend.
Age
<3 months
3-11 months
12-17
>18 months
%
%
months
%
%
N/A
Total
%
(N)
18-20
29.44
30.56
12.78
20
7.22
180
21+
15
21.67
11.67
51.67
00
60
Total
25.83
28.33
12.5
27.92
5.42
240
Table 10: Age by length of boyfriend/girlfriend relationships
As we can see, age is an important determinant. The older cohort (21 years +) are, not
surprisingly, likely to have been in longer ‘boyfriend/girlfriend’ relationships.
Amongst 18-20 year olds, only 32.78% have been in a relationship of more than 12
months duration, whilst 63.34% of 21+ year olds have been in such a relationship.
13
For 36.6% of 18-20 year olds, their experience of relationships is limited to 3 months,
or none at all. Only 15% of 21+ years olds fall into this category.
Thus, to summarise, the period 18-20 is characterised by short term dating, leading to
much longer lasting relationships in the 21+ age category.
What gender differences exist in the length of relationships? Let us look at the 18-20
year old respondents (n=180) in more detail (missing = 5, a response rate of 97.29%).
< 3 months
3-11 months
12-17
> 18 months
N/A
Total
months
Male
%
43.6
32.7
9.1
7.3
7.3
100
(No.)
(24)
(18)
(5)
(4)
(4)
(55)
%
23.2
29.6
14.4
25.6
7.2
100
(No.)
(29)
(37)
(18)
(32)
(9)
(125)
%
29.4
31.11
12.77
20
7.22
100
(No.)
(53)
(56)
(23)
(36)
(13)
(180)
Female
Total
Table11: Gender by length of boyfriend/girlfriend relationships
A number of interesting gender differences and similarities are apparent. The modal
length of relationship for males aged 18 to 20 years is less than three months. Only
16.4% of males in this age group have been in a relationship for twelve months or
more. A small group of 7.3% of males in the 18-20 years age group report having had
no boyfriend/girlfriend relationship. For females, the modal length of relationship is
3-11 months. Two and a half times many females as males in this age group (40% v
16.4%) have been involved in relationships which have lasted for more than 12
months. Interestingly, the same proportion of females and males (7.3% and 7.2%
respectively) reported having had no relationships with boyfriends or girlfriends.
Thus, we can conclude that females are more likely to be involved in longer lasting
14
relationships at an earlier age than are boys. This, of course, confirms the common
observation that young women typically date males older than themselves.
The ‘length of relationships’ has a bearing on whether one has been in a sexually
active relationship (not necessarily involving full intercourse) or not. If we compare
whether respondents report having been in a sexually active relationship with the
length of the longest relationship they have been in, interesting patterns emerge:
>18 months
N/A
Total
% (N)
% (N)
% (N)
% (N)
< 3 months
3-11 months
12-17
% (N)
% (N)
months
Yes
20.56 (37)
27.22 (49)
14.44 (26)
36.67 (66)
1.11 (2)
75 (180)
No
41.67 (25)
31.67 (19)
6.67 (4)
1.67 (1)
18.33 (11)
25 (60)
Total
25.83 (62)
28.33 (68)
12.5 (30)
27.92 (67)
5.42 (13)
100 (240)
Table 12: Duration of boyfriend/girlfriend relationships by ‘ever in a sexually
active relationship’
Let us consider the 60 individuals who have never ‘been in a sexually active
relationship (not necessarily involving intercourse)’: 73% of them have been in
‘boyfriend/girlfriend’ relationships of up to one year, suggesting ‘early’ sexual
behaviour is not a feature of these relationships. On the other hand, 48% of those who
have been ‘in a sexually active relationship’ have only been in a ‘longest relationship’
of less than one year. This suggests a wide continuum of sexual behaviour in short
(less than one year) relationships, large numbers of which are sexually active, and
large numbers of which are not.
It is also interesting to look at the gender differences in the dating behaviour of 21+
year olds. All have had experiences of relationships of over 3 months at this stage.
However, strong gender differences emerge:
15
<3 months
3-11 months
12-17
>18 months
N/A
Total (N)
months
Male
28.57
28.57
28.57
14.29
0
14
Female
10.87
19.57
6.52
63.04
0
46
Total
15
21.67
11.67
51.67
0
60
Table 13: Gender by length of relationships amongst 21+ year olds
Whilst the sample size for males (14) is very small, it is still interesting to note that
nearly three times as many males as females (28.57% v’s 10.87%) have still not have
a boyfriend/girlfriend relationship which has lasted more than 3 months. On the other
end of the scale, 63% of females aged 21+ years have been in a relationship that has
lasted 18 months or more, compared to only 14.29% of males. Again, this pattern of
females engaging in longer relationships earlier than their male peers confirms the
common observation that females typically date males older than themselves.
Sexual orientation
As we can see in Table 14 below, the majority of respondents described their sexual
orientation as ‘heterosexual.’ Perhaps surprisingly, only one respondent reported a
‘homosexual’ orientation. Three describe themselves as ‘bisexual’ and two others
responded that they are ‘unsure’ as to their sexual orientation. These figures seem
lower than one might expect and may be explained by the requirement for respondents
to categorise themselves, rather than detail a range of behaviours/experiences. Male
prostitutes, for example, regularly engage in same-gender sex acts, commonly thought
of as ‘homosexual’, whilst retaining their self-identity as ‘heterosexual.’ Likewise,
the literature on adolescent sexual behaviour reports significant levels of ‘samegender’ sexual interaction, frequently interpreted as exploration or experimentation, as
opposed to ‘homosexuality.’ A more operationalised question would most likely have
yielded a greater diversity of same-gender experiences.
16
Male
Female
Total
Heterosexual
Homosexual
Bisexual
Unsure
Total
%
98.6
0
1.4
0
100
(No.)
(68)
(0)
(1)
(0)
(69)
%
97
0.6
1.2
1.2
100
(No.)
(162)
(1)
(2)
(2)
(167)
%
97.45
0.4
1.3
0.86
100
(No.)
(230)
(1)
(3)
(2)
(236)
Table 14: Sexual orientation (response rate, 95.54%, missing = 11)
Sample sizes are too small to make meaningful cross-tabulations by gender, age or
place of origin.
DISCUSSION
The data allows us to make some observations about the sexual experiences of a
sample of college students, which may or may not be comparable with other 18-21
year olds, let alone the general population:
Sexual experiences below age 16
the majority of 16 year olds (84%) have kissed an ‘age mate’ (that is, a partner
younger than 21); about one third (30%) have ‘been masturbated by, or
masturbated’ an age-mate, and just over 12% have had intercourse.
For the 10.2% of females in the sample who report having had intercourse
below age 16, their male partners (regardless of age) have committed the
offence of unlawful carnal intercourse (in fact, the true figure will be higher as
respondents were not asked about their experiences of sexual intercourse
whilst 16 years of age (this would also constitute an offence as the age of
consent is 17).
Males are one and half to two times more likely than females to report sexual
experiences below age 16.
However, we must recall that this paper has
examined ‘self-reports’ of sexual behaviour and the over-reporting by males of
17
sexual behaviour, and the under-reporting by females, has frequently been
noted in the literature on this topic.
Those with urban origins are significantly more likely to report having had
sexual experiences before age 16 than those with rural origins
Lifetime sexual experiences
61% of males and 58% of females in the sample as a whole report having had
sexual intercourse. For 18-20 year olds, only 50.5% report having had sexual
intercourse (57% of males and 47.7% of females).
Urban-rural differences persist beyond age 16. Respondents from Dublin city
or county are more likely to report having had sexual intercourse than rural
respondents (64% and 39% respectively). They are also more likely to have
been involved in a sexually active relationship (76% and 57% respectively).
Age is an important determinant of sexual intercourse. Thus, 50.5% of 18-20
year olds report having had sexual intercourse (n=184), compared to 82% of
21-25 year olds (n=44)
Age is also a determinant of respondents’ experiences of boyfriend/girlfriend
relationships.
Amongst 18-20 year olds, only 32.78% have been in a
relationship of more than 12 months duration, whilst 63.34% of 21+ year olds
have been in such a relationship.
Gender is a determinant of respondents’ experiences of boyfriend/girlfriend
relationships. Amongst 18-20 year olds, females are two and a half times
more likely than males to have been in a relationship that has lasted more than
12 months. That is, females are more likely to be involved in longer lasting
relationships at an earlier age than are males. This, of course, confirms the
common observation that young women typically date males older than
themselves.
A significant proportion of ‘boyfriend/girlfriend’ relationships reported by the
sample are not characterised by sexual activity. Conversely, other short term
relationships (less than one year) are characterised by sexual activity. This
suggests a wide continuum of sexual behaviour in short (less than one year)
18
relationships, large numbers of which are sexually active, and large numbers
of which are not.
CONCLUSION
Sexual behaviour amongst young people is subjected to wildly differing claims in the
popular media and by various commentators.
The perception exists that such
behaviour is frequently promiscuous and irresponsible.
This data suggests
considerable variation between male/females and rural/urban populations. Sexual
experiences amongst this sample of college students are not as widespread as might be
imagined. It is hoped that this paper can provide a small degree of illumination to a
topic where claims and counterclaims are not always empirically researched.
REFERENCES
Alliance (1997). What on earth are they doing? Cork: Alliance.
Department of Public Health, Midland Health Board. (1996). A Report on Sexual
Practices of 16-18 Year Olds in the Midland Health Board. Midland Health
Board: Department of Public Health.
Devlin, M. (this volume). Media representations of young people’s sexuality.
DITSU (2000).
DITSU Student Attitude Survey.
Dublin: Dublin Institute of
Technology Students’ Union.
Fitzpatrick, C. C., Fitzpatrick, P. E. & Turner, M. J. (1997). Profile of patients
attending a Dublin adolescent antenatal booking clinic. Irish Medical Journal,
90, 3, 96-97.
Inglis, T. (1998). Lessons in Irish sexuality. Dublin: University College Dublin
Press.
19
Lalor, K. (1999). The incidence of unwanted childhood sexual experiences amongst a
sample of third level students. Irish Journal of Psychology, 20(1), 15-28.
MacHale, E. & Newell, J. (1997). Sexual behaviour and sex education in Irish
school-going teenagers. International Journal of STD’s and AIDS, 8, 3, 196200.
Rajani, R. & Kudrati, M. (1996). The varieties of sexual experience of the street
children of Mwanza, Tanzania.
In S. Zeidenstein & K. Moore (Eds.).
Learning about sexuality: a practical beginning. New York: The Population
Council.
Ryan, F. (1997). ‘Queering’ the criminal law: some thoughts on the aftermath of
homosexual decriminalization. Irish Criminal Law Journal, 38.
20