ISSN : 0256-6524
VOL. 52, No. 1
January-March 2015
JOURNAL
OF
AGRICULTURAL ENGINEERING
INDIAN SOCIETY OF AGRICULTURAL ENGINEERS
ISAE
Journal of Agricultural Engineering
Editorial Board
Chief Editor: Dipankar De (jae.chiefeditor@gmail.com)
Farm Machinery and
Power Division
Processing,
Dairy and Food
Engineering
Division
Soil and Water
Engineering Division
Energy and other Areas
Division
Debaraj Behera
S. N. Jha
S. K. Ambast
A. K. Kurchania
debaraj1963@rediffmail.com
fmp.isae@gmail.com
snjhajae@gmail.com
skambast@cssri.ernet.in
skambast65@gmail.com
K. Kathirvel
Niranjan Prasad
R. Subbaiah
Pravakar Mohanty
G.S.Manes
K. Narasaih
P.K. Shrivastava
N. L. Panwar
P.K.Sahoo
D. M. Kadam
M.J. Kaledhonkar
Madhuri Narra
M. Mahapatra
Pramod Rai
Satyendra Kumar
R.Mahendiran
Editor
Associate
Editors
jae.divenergyeditor@
gmail.com
K.V. Rao
Publication Enquiries
The Journal of Agricultural Engineering, a publication of the Indian Society of Agricultural Engineers, is published
in four issues per year. This journal is not responsible for statements and opinions expressed by the authors of papers
published in it. Reprints may be made from this publication on the condition that full credit is given to the author(s) and
the Journal of Agricultural Engineering.
All communications regarding the publication or submission of manuscripts should be addressed to The Chief Editor,
Journal of Agricultural Engineering at the address given below.
Subscription Rate
Annual subscription
Rs. 2000/- or US $400 ($ 50 extra for air mail dispatch)
Per copy
Rs. 600/- or US $ 150 ($ 25 extra for air mail dispatch)
Payment are to be made by crossed cheque/ draft including bank charges in favour of “Indian Society of Agricultural
Engineers”, payable at New Delhi, India, and directly sent to the Society Headquarters at the address given below:
Indian Society of Agricultural Engineers
G-4, National Societies Block, National Agricultural Science Centre Complex,
Dev Prakash Shastri Marg, Pusa Campus, New Delhi – 110012, India
Tel / Fax: 091-11-25849003
E-mail: isae1960@gmail.com
Web: www.isae.in
Md Shaiq Alam, Harjot Khaira, Shivani Pathania, Sunil Kumar and Baljit Singh
JAE : 52 (1)
Journal of Agricultural Engineering, Vol. 52 (1): January-March, 2015
Extrusion Process Optimization for Soy-Carrot Pomace Powder
Incorporated Wheat-based Snacks
Md Shaiq Alam1, Harjot Khaira2, Shivani Pathania3, Sunil Kumar4 and Baljit Singh5
Manuscript received: July, 2014
Revised manuscript accepted: December, 2014
ABSTRACT
Twin screw extruder was used to develop soy-carrot pomace incorporated wheat-based nutritionally rich snacks.
Different experimental combinations of extrusion process variables as die temperature, screw speed, feed moisture
and wheat flour in the feed formulation of wheat, defatted soy flour and carrot pomace powder, were tried using
Box-Behnken design of experiment. Response surface methodology (RSM) was used to investigate the effect of
die temperature (120-180°C), screw speed (300-500 rpm), feed moisture (14-20%) and wheat flour (65-85%) with
soy-carrot pomace blend in equal proportion on product responses like bulk density (BD), water absorption index
(WAI), water solubility index (WSI), hardness (H), colour change (CC), and overall acceptability (OA). The extrusion
process was optimized for maximum expansion ratio, water absorption index, water solubility index and overall
acceptability; and minimum bulk density, hardness and colour change within the experimental range. Analysis of
variance (ANOVA) revealed that among the process variables, feed moisture and wheat flour percentage in feed
formulation had significantly higher effect on BD, ER, WSI, CC and OA. Die temperature was observed to have
significantly lower effect on the selected responses. The optimized extrusion conditions for desired product quality
had desirability of 0.729.
Key words: Extrusion, snacks, wheat lour, defatted soy lour, carrot pomace powder, RSM
Extrusion is an important technology for processing grainbased products and adds value to raw material ranging
from corn, wheat and rice to sorghum, oats and soybean.
This modern high-temperature short-time process is being
adopted to replace traditional food processing techniques
(as drum dryer, batch cookers, mixers, formers, stirred
tank reactors and ovens) working at low temperatures
and pressures, and with long residence times (Lee, 1987).
Extrusion is most economical in large scale production
(Onyango et al., 2004). It offers numerous advantages
including versatility, high productivity, low operating cost,
energy efficiency, high quality of resulting products and
an improvement in digestibility and biological value of
proteins (Mercier and Feillet, 1975; Carrillo et al., 2002).
To achieve the desirable changes in the raw material, the
most important process parameters during extrusion are
feed moisture, screw speed and temperature.
wheat can be used as a base to manufacture healthy snacks.
The extruded products content could be improved in its
overall nutritional content and taste by incorporation of
protein rich ingredients. As wheat is deficient in methoinine,
the amino acid profile can be improved by supplementation.
Incorporation of ingredients with high nutrient density into
these snack products could increase their nutritional values.
Legume not only holds great promise in meeting the protein
needs of poor population, but also contributes in solving
some health- related problems (Veronica et al., 2006).
Hence, soybean an easily available rich source of protein,
could also be used to further nutritionally enrich the food.
Incorporation of legume flour has been shown to cause a
positive impact on levels of proteins and dietary fibre of
extruded snacks (Berrios, 2006). The pulses in the extruded
product can pave the way for a snack which is rich in both
fibre and protein contents. With changes in formulation and
control of extrusion parameters, an acceptable expanded
ready-to-eat snack could be produced (Stojceska et al.,
2008b).
Offering complete nutrition is an important asset of any
food. Generally, rice and corn are used to prepare extruded
products due to their bland taste, hypo-allergicity and good
puffing characteristics. However, wheat is the major food
crop next to rice in the Indian sub-continent. A large section
of Indian population is adapted to the taste of wheat. Hence,
Carrot pomace can be used to develop products that could
supplement fibre in the diet of people. During carrot juice
1
Research Engineer, Department of Processing and Food Engineering, Punjab Agricultural University, Ludhiana, Punjab, India, ms_alam@
rediffmail.com, 2,3,4Senior Research Fellow, Department of Processing and Food Engineering, Punjab Agricultural University, Ludhiana,
Punjab, India, 5Baking Technologist, Department of Food Science and Technology, Punjab Agricultural University, Ludhiana, Punjab, India
1
January-March, 2015
Extrusion Process Optimization for Soy-Carrot Pomace Powder incorporated Wheat-based Snacks
and water solubility index, hardness, colour change and
overall acceptability.
extraction, up to 80% of carotene may be lost with left
over carrot pomace. It has good residual amount of all
the vitamins, minerals and dietary fibre. A promising way
is to store the carrot pomace in dried form and utilize in
development of bakery products, specifically extrudates,
which are presently becoming more popular than other
bakery products in ready-to-eat food category. Dried carrot
pomace has carotene and ascorbic acid in the range of 9.87
to 11.57 mg and 13.53 to 22.95 mg per 100 g, respectively
(Upadhyay et al., 2008).
Sample Preparation
The formulations of ingredients for the preparation of
extruded products are given in Table 1. Carrot pomace
powder and defatted soy flour were mixed in equal
proportion in a food processor with mixture attachment.
Wheat flour (W) was substituted with defatted soy flour
(S) and carrot pomace powder (C) at levels of 15%,
25% and 35 per cent. Sugar @10 % was added in every
sample to enhance the flavour of the snacks. After mixing,
samples were packed in polyethylene bags at refrigerated
temperature for 24 h (Stojeska et al., 2008).
Incorporation of by-products from the food industry
using extrusion technology in order to improve the
nutritional characteristics of ready-to-eat snacks is very
well documented (Stojceska et al., 2008). An attempt was
made to prepare a nutritious extruded snack using wheat
flour, carrot pomace powder and defatted soybean flour.
Process parameters were optimized using response surface
methodology techniques.
Extrudates Preparation
A laboratory-scale, co-rotating twin-screw extruder with
intermeshing (Model BC2; Clextral, Firminy Cedex,
France), was used for the extrusion study. The barrel
diameter and its length-to-diameter (L/D) were 25 mm
and 16:1, respectively. The extruder had 4 barrel zones.
Temperature of the first, second and third zone were
maintained at 40, 70 and 100°C, respectively, throughout the
experiment. The temperature at the last zone (compression
and die section) was varied according to the experimental
design. The diameter of die opening was 6 mm. The extruder
was powered by 8.5 KW motor with speed variable from
0 to 682 rpm. The screw configuration is shown in Table 2
and Fig 1. The extruder was calibrated with respect to the
combination of feed rate and screw speed to be used. The
feed rate was varied for optimum filling of the extruder
barrel corresponding to the screw speed. The moisture
content of feed was varied by injecting water into the
extruder with water pump. A variable speed die face cutter
with four bladed knives was used to cut the extrudates. The
temperature of the twin-screw extruder was stabilized to set
values. Samples were then poured into the feed hopper and
the feed rate was adjusted as per experimental requirements.
The product was collected at the die end and kept at 60
± 0.5°C in hot air oven for 1 h duration to remove extra
moisture from the product. The samples were packed in
polythene bags for further analysis.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Experimental Design
Response surface methodology (RSM) was used for the
design of experimental combinations (Ding et al., 2005;
Altan et al., 2008; Yagci and Gogus, 2008). The main
advantage of RSM is the reduced number of experimental
runs needed to provide sufficient information for
statistically acceptable results. A four-factor three-level
central composite experimental design was employed.
The parameters and their levels were chosen based on the
literature available on wheat-based extrudates (Ding et
al., 2006; Upadhyay et al., 2008; Yagci and Gogus, 2008;
Ibanoglu et al., 2006). Carrot based ready-to-eat snack
was developed with wheat flour; pulse flour (defatted
soybean flour) and carrot pomace powder as ingredients.
The independent variables included the proportion of
defatted soy-flour and carrot pomace powder in wheat
flour (15-35%), die temperature (120-180 oC), screw
speed (300-500 rpm) and moisture content (14-20%).
Response variables were specific mechanical energy,
bulk density, expansion ratio, water absorption index
Table1. Ingredient formulations of snack
Feed Ingredient
Feed formulation (Wheat lour: Defatted soy lour: Carrot pomace powder)
65:17.5:17.5
75:12.5:12.5
85:7.5:7.5
Wheat flour, g
195
225
255
Defatted soy flour, g
52.5
37.5
22.5
Carrot pomace powder, g
52.5
37.5
22.5
Total, g
300
300
300
2
Md Shaiq Alam, Harjot Khaira, Shivani Pathania, Sunil Kumar and Baljit Singh
JAE : 52 (1)
Table 2. Screw coniguration in different sections of the extruder (From hopper to die)
Screw section
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Screw element
BAGUE
C2F
C2F
C2F
C2F
C2F
INO 0
C1F
CF1C
C1F
20
50
50
50
50
50
5
50
25
50
-
50
33.33
25
25
16.66
-
16.66
12.5
12.5
Length, mm
Pitch, mm
Fig. 1: Screw proile
Product Quality Responses
Water solubility index
Bulk density
The supernatant, as above, was evaporated to dryness at
105°C until constant weight was obtained. Water solubility
index (WSI) was determined as (Anderson et al., 1969):
Bulk density (BD, g.cm-3) of extrudates was determined by
using average diameter and an average length of extrudate
samples and calculated using the following expression
(Stojceska et al., 2008):
… (4)
…(1)
Hardness
Where, m is mass in g; L is length in cm and d is diameter
in cm of extrudates.
Mechanical properties of the extrudates were determined by
crushing method using a TA-XT2i (Stable Micro-Systems,
Surrey, England) with p75 compression plate. The tests
were conducted at pre–test speed of 1.0 mm.s-1, test speed
of 5 mm.s-1, post-test speed of 5 mm.s-1, strain- 25%, trigger
force of 0.4903 N and load cell of 50 kg.
Expansion ratio
The ratio of diameter of the extrudate and the diameter of
die was used to express the expansion of extrudate (Fan et
al., 1996). The diameter of extrudate was determined as
the mean of 10 random measurements made with a Vernier
caliper. The extrudate expansion ratio was calculated as:
An extrudate was compressed with a probe SMS-P/75-75
mm diameter at a crosshead speed 5 mm.s-1 to 3 mm (50%
of diameter) of the extrudate. The compression generated
a curve with the force over distance. The highest first peak
value was recorded, as this value indicated the first rupture
of snack at one point, and taken as a measurement for
hardness (Stojceska et al., 2008).
… (2)
Water absorption index
A 2.0 g ± 0.005 g sample was placed in a tared centrifuge
tube, and 20 ml distilled water was added to it. After 15
min (with intermittent shaking every 5 min), the sample
was centrifuged at 4000 rpm for 15 min. The supernatant
was decanted into a tared aluminum pan and weight gain
in the gel was noted. Water absorption index (WAI) was
calculated as the increase in weight of sediment obtained
after decanting the supernatant as:
Colour change
Colour is one the important parameter for acceptability of a
product. Colour properties of the samples were measured by
using Miniscan XE plus Hunter Lab Colourimeter (USA),
Model No. 45/0-L. Colour of ground samples was measured
in terms of ‘L’, ‘a’ and ‘b’ value. Ground sample was
completely filled in a petri-dish, and no light was allowed to
pass during the measuring process. The colour change was
… (3)
3
January-March, 2015
Extrusion Process Optimization for Soy-Carrot Pomace Powder incorporated Wheat-based Snacks
calculated from the ‘L’, ‘a’ and ‘b’ readings (Gnanasekharan
et al., 1992) as following:
Colour change = √[(L-L0)2 + (a-a0) 2 + (b-b0)2]
… (5)
High density product is an indication of more uniform
and continuous protein matrix, and therefore, extrudate
was dense with parallel layers and no air pockets. High
density of the product might have been due to less
generation of heat with low temperature process, with
avoidance of moisture flash-off from the product. This
could have been due to carrot pomace powder, a good
source of fibre, which led to less expansion resulting
in a high density product with collapsed cells usually
disintegrating on cooling.
Where, L0, a0 and b0 represent the respective values for
fresh sample.
Sensory evaluation
Sensory quality of extrudates was determined with the
help of 10 semi-trained consumer panellist, using a 9-point
Hedonic scale (9-liked extremely to 1-disliked extremely)
method described by Amerine et al. (1965). The aspects
considered were colour, appearance, taste, flavour and
overall acceptability (OA).
The decrease in density with screw speed could be due
to gelatinization of starch at higher speeds. Also, the
high dependence of density on feed moisture would
reflect its influence on elasticity characteristics of the
starch- based material. Increased feed moisture content
during extrusion might reduce the elasticity of the dough
through plasticization of the melt, resulting in reduced
gelatinization and increased density of extrudate (Mercier
and Feillet, 1975). Identical results were shown by other
researchers for extrusion of chick pea flour (Meng et al.,
2010), for corn starch, amaranth and rice (Hagenimana
et al., 2006).
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Values of physical properties of extrudates are presented in
Table 3. Final equations of the fitted models for the selected
parameters are depicted in Table 5 along with respective R2
values. The regression models for bulk density, expansion
ratio, WAI, WSI, hardness, colour change and overall
acceptability were highly significant (P < 0.0001), with a
high correlation coefficient (R2 = 0.76, 0.78, 0.82, 0.78,
0.80, 0.84 and 0.90 respectively). None of the models
showed significant lack of fit (P > 0.01), indicating that
all the second-order polynomial models correlated well
with the measured data. All the parameters showed high
adequate precision.
Expansion Ratio
Expansion ratio indicates the extent of puffing of
extruded products. The experimental results of expansion
ratio of extrudates under different designed extrusion
conditions are shown in Table 3. Expansion ratio of
extrudates varied between 1.92 and 3.07 for different
combinations of extrusion process variables. The highest
expansion ratio was 3.07 for extrusion processing at
150oC, 400 rpm screw speed, 14% moisture content and
85% wheat flour in the composition (7.5% carrot pomace
powder). On the other hand, the lowest expansion ratio of
1.92 was obtained at 180oC, 400 rpm screw speed, 20%
moisture content and 75% wheat flour in the composition
(12.5% carrot pomace powder). The linear terms of
die temperature, feed moisture and wheat flour in the
total composition had significant effects on expansion
ratio (p<0.01). Expansion ratio of extrudates increased
with an increase in screw speed and wheat flour in
the composition, whereas a negative relationship was
observed when die temperature and moisture content
decreased. Carrot pomace powder had negative impact
on the expansion ratio of the extrudates. The regression
equation for the relationship between expansion ratio and
independent variables in term of the coded variables is
shown in Table 5.
Bulk Density
Table 4 shows the effect of independent variables on
bulk density of the extrudates. Bulk density of extrudates
ranged between 0.166 and 0.485 g.cm-3 (Table 3). It was
apparent that linear terms of feed moisture (p<0.01) and
wheat flour in the composition (p<0.05) had significant
effect on bulk density of the extrudates (Table 4). Bulk
density was highly influenced by moisture content,
followed by percentage of wheat flour in the total
composition. It is evident from Table 4 that screw
speed and wheat flour in the composition had negative
correlation with bulk density. However, die temperature
and moisture content had positive correlation with bulk
density. The quadratic model obtained from regression
analysis for density (D) in terms of coded levels of
the variables is shown in Table 5. The significance of
coefficient of fitted quadratic model was evaluated by
using F- test and P- value. The value of R2 was found to be
0.76. Product terms and quadratic terms had insignificant
effect on bulk density.
4
Md Shaiq Alam, Harjot Khaira, Shivani Pathania, Sunil Kumar and Baljit Singh
JAE : 52 (1)
Table 3. Experimental data of extrudates for response surface analysis using four-factor three-level Box-Behnken design
Extrusion process variable
Die temp.
Product quality response
(oC)
Screw
speed
(rpm)
Feed
moisture
(%)
Wheat
lour
(%)
Bulk
density
(g.cm-3)
Expansion
ratio
WAI
WSI
Hardness
Colour
change
Overall
acceptability
(g.g-1)
(%)
(N)
150(0)
500(+1)
17(0)
65
0.311
2.50
3.88
23.7
72.48
9.35
6.48
120(-1)
500(+1)
17(0)
75
150(0)
400(0)
20(+1)
85
0.301
2.63
4.01
22.09
0.301
2.60
4.41
18.4
41.39
9.81
6.94
45.42
10.69
6.55
180(+1)
400(0)
14(-1)
75
0.251
2.37
4.30
20.2
31.27
10.89
6.94
150(0)
300(-1)
14(-1)
75
0.254
2.49
4.19
20.2
45.41
11.23
6.52
150(0)
400(0)
17(0)
75
0.257
2.66
4.27
23
40.01
10.77
6.64
150(0)
500(+1)
17(0)
85
0.272
2.77
4.22
20.4
50.94
7.48
6.85
180(+1)
500(+1)
17(0)
180(+1)
400(0)
20(+1)
75
0.311
2.37
4.18
19
67.11
9.13
6.73
75
0.390
1.92
4.31
19.12
58.61
9.43
5.52
150(0)
300(-1)
17(0)
85
0.245
2.71
4.58
20.4
38.16
13.15
7.03
120(-1)
400(0)
17(0)
65
0.296
2.44
3.99
19.6
51.15
8.77
6.12
150(0)
400(0)
20(+1)
65
0.421
2.32
3.99
21.6
76.20
9.59
5.30
150(0)
400(0)
17(0)
75
0.356
2.49
4.32
18.16
38.58
8.70
5.94
120(-1)
400(0)
14(-1)
75
0.172
2.83
4.13
22.8
50.23
14.17
7.24
150(0)
500(+1)
14(-1)
75
0.175
2.66
4.18
28.82
52.00
11.49
7.39
180(+1)
400(0)
17(0)
65
0.405
2.22
4.15
20.4
47.60
10.16
5.97
120(-1)
400(0)
17(0)
85
0.279
2.72
4.47
21.6
37.45
10.95
6.64
150(0)
300(-1)
20(+1)
75
0.485
2.14
4.05
24.2
48.63
11.34
5.18
150(0)
400(0)
14(-1)
85
0.166
3.07
4.46
22.8
51.02
11.69
7.06
150(0)
400(0)
17(0)
75
0.359
2.48
4.55
19.2
53.95
7.63
5.91
120(-1)
400(0)
20(+1)
75
0.403
2.46
3.95
20
40.56
8.50
5.36
150(0)
400(0)
14(-1)
65
0.228
2.53
4.09
24.98
51.61
11.92
6.55
180(+1)
300(-1)
17(0)
75
0.271
2.30
4.14
23.2
47.00
12.71
6.52
150(0)
500(+1)
20(+1)
75
0.327
2.44
4.12
19.11
52.99
6.47
5.82
180(+1)
400(0)
17(0)
85
0.271
2.61
4.59
19.2
51.37
8.87
7.09
150(0)
300(-1)
17(0)
65
0.327
2.36
4.27
24.8
56.91
7.73
5.79
120(-1)
300(-1)
17(0)
75
0.224
2.68
4.36
23.12
40.83
12.47
6.52
Table 4. Analysis of variance of extrusion process variables on the selected responses
Responses (F- value)
Extrusion process
variable
Bulk
Density
(g.cm-3)
Expansion
Ratio
Die temperature
1.72
(A)
WAI
WSI
Hardness
Colour
Change
Overall
Acceptability
3.11
0.82
0.003733
(0.1996)
(0.1034)
(0.3842)
(0.9523)
0.22
6.54
15.08
7.23
(0.0377)
(0.6469)
(0.0252)
(0.0022)
(0.0197)
1.46
8.5
3.04
16.05
64.56
(0.2502)
(0.013)
(0.1069)
(0.0017)
(< 0.0001)
-1
(g.g )
(%)
(N)
24.7
3.24
1.84
(0.2137)
(0.0003)
(0.0969)
0.41
3.21
5.46
(0.5329)
(0.0983)
40.21
27.57
(< 0.0001)
(0.0002)
Screw speed (B)
Feed moisture (0C)
5
January-March, 2015
Extrusion Process Optimization for Soy-Carrot Pomace Powder incorporated Wheat-based Snacks
7.05
28.67
30.39
4.25
12.1
1.92
25.41
(0.021)
(0.0002)
(0.0001)
(0.0617)
(0.0046)
(0.1912)
(0.0003)
0.14
0.29
2.56
0.85
2.08
0.17
0.14
(0.7191)
(0.6013)
(0.1355)
(0.375)
(0.1745)
(0.6856)
(0.7175)
Wheat flour (D)
A*B
0.87
0.15
0.55
0.25
7.47
3.6
0.63
(0.3686)
(0.7076)
(0.474)
(0.6262)
(0.0182)
(0.082)
(0.4428)
A*C
1.41
0.22
0.032
0.87
1.66
2.45
1.12
(0.2583)
(0.6456)
(0.8611)
(0.3706)
(0.2214)
(0.1434)
(0.3108)
0.63
0.36
0.1
15.88
0.027
5.34
0.18
(0.4433)
(0.5621)
(0.7568)
(0.0018)
(0.8714)
(0.0393)
(0.6795)
0.19
0.15
0.007986
0.1
0.042
10.8
2.35
(0.6698)
(0.7064)
(0.9303)
(0.7547)
(0.8404)
(0.0065)
(0.1508)
0.35
1.21
0.033
0.088
4.97
0.36
1.61
(0.5661)
(0.2931)
(0.8586)
(0.7719)
(0.0456)
(0.5574)
(0.2282)
0.23
2.87
2.03
0.32
0.37
3.36
2.49
(0.6408)
(0.1162)
(0.1797)
(0.5792)
(0.5543)
(0.0915)
(0.1404)
0.82
0.2
5.63
6.6
2.23
0.86
3.1
(0.382)
(0.6665)
(0.0353)
(0.0246)
(0.1612)
(0.3727)
(0.1035)
A*D
B*C
B*D
C*D
A2
B2
0.24
0.98
5.6
2.04
1.15
5.04
0.35
(0.6338)
(0.3424)
(0.0357)
(0.1791)
(0.3053)
(0.0444)
(0.5657)
C2
0.63
2.5
0.04
0.49
4.81
0.16
2.03
(0.4433)
(0.1398)
(0.8457)
(0.4991)
(0.0487)
(0.6929)
(0.1794)
CV (%)
16.49
4.54
2.91
8.01
13.65
10.87
4.48
S.D. ( 5% LSD)
0.049
0.11
0.12
1.72
6.77
1.11
0.29
D2
Data in parenthesis are p-values
Table 5. Adequacy of model itted
Fitted model
R2
P value
Bulk density
(g.cm-3)
BD = +0 .32+ 0.019 *A- 9.121 x 10-3 *B+ 0.090 *C- 0.038 *D- 9.063 x 10-3 *AB - 0.023 *AC - 0.020
*BC + 0.011 *BD -0.015 *CD - 0.010 *A2 - 0.019 *B2 - 0.010 *C2 - 0.017*D2
0.82
0.0121
Expansion ratio
ER= + 2.54 - 0.16 *A + 0.059 *B -0.17 *C + 0.18 *D + 0.031 *AB - 0.022 *AC + 0.027 *AD +
0.034 *BC – 0.022 *BD - 0.063 *CD - 0.084 *A2 - 0.022 *B2 - 0.049 *C2 + 0.078 *D2
0.89
0.001
Water absorption
index (g.g-1)
WAI= + 4.38 + 0.064 *A - 0.083 *B -0.043 *C + 0.20 *D + 0.099 *AB + 0.046 *AC - 0.011 *AD +
0.020 *BC + 5.500 x 10-3 *BD + 0.011 *CD - 0.076 *A2 - 0.13 *B2 - 0.13 *C2 - 0.011*D2
0.82
0.0125
Water solubility index
(%)
WSI= + 20.12 - 0.67 *A - 0.23 *B - 1.45 *C - 1.02 *D - 0.79 *AB + 0.43 *AC - 0.80 *AD -3.43
*BC + 0.27 *BD - 0.26 *CD-0.42 *A2 + 1.91 *B2 + 1.06 *C2 + 0.52 *D2
0.78
0.0299
Hardness (N)
H= + 44.18 + 3.45 *A + 5.00 *B + 3.41 *C-6.80 *D + 4.89 *AB + 9.25 *AC + 4.37 *AD + 0.56
*BC - 0.70*BD - 7.55 *CD -1.78 *A2 + 4.38 *B2 +3.14 *C2 + 6.43 *D2
0.80
0.0171
Colour
change
CC= + 9.04 - 0.29 *A - 1.24 *B - 1.28 *C + 0.44 *D - 0.23 *AB +1.05 *AC - 0.87 *AD - 1.28 *BC
-1.82 *BD + 0.33 *CD + 0.88 *A2 + 0.44 *B2 + 1.08 *C2 + 0.19*D2
0.84
0.0063
Overall acceptability
OA= + 6.16 - 5.051 x 10-3 *A + 0.22 *B - 0.66 *C + 0.42 *D -0.53 *AB + 0.11 *AC + 0.15 *AD 0.061 *BC -0.22 *BD + 0.18 *CD + 0.20 *A2 + 0.22 *B2 - 0.73 *C2 + 0.18 *D2
0.90
0.0005
Parameter
6
Md Shaiq Alam, Harjot Khaira, Shivani Pathania, Sunil Kumar and Baljit Singh
JAE : 52 (1)
Table 6. Optimum values of extrusion process parameters and responses
Target
Process parameter
Experimental range
Min
Max
Optimum value
Die temperature (0C)
range
120
180
136
Screw speed (rpm)
range
300
500
490
Feed moisture (%)
range
14
20
15
Wheat flour (%)
range
65
85
85
Carrot pomace powder (%)
range
7.5
17.5
7.5
Defatted soy flour (%)
range
7.5
17.5
7.5
Desirability
Ingredients proportion
Response
Predicted value
Bulk density(g.cm-3)
minimize
0.166
0.485
0.227
Colour change
minimize
6.47
14.16
9.52
WAI (g.g-1)
maximize
3.88
4.59
4.29
WSI (%)
maximize
18.16
28.82
24.68
Hardness (N)
minimize
31.27
76.20
49.99
Expansion ratio
maximize
1.91
3.07
2.92
Overall acceptability
maximize
5.18
7.39
7.18
The effect of each independent variable was evaluated
on expansion ratio. Die temperature had significant
negative effect on expansion ratio. It was also evident that
as the proportion of wheat flour increased, an increase
in expansion ratio was apparent. High die temperature
increases the superheating of water in the extruder, which
encourages bubble formation. However, presence of sugar
and carrot pomace powder hindered bubble formation at
high temperature, and resulted in low expansion ratio due
to expulsion of moisture from the extrudates. Increased
feed moisture leads to a sharp decrease in the expansion of
extrudate. High dependence of expansion on feed moisture
would reflect its influence on elasticity characteristics of
the starch-based material. Increased feed moisture content
during extrusion might reduce elasticity of the dough
through plasticization of the melt, resulting in reduced
SME causing reduced gelatinization. This decreased the
expansion and increased the density of extrudate. The
results were consistent with the studies by Faubion and
Hoseney (1982), Launay and Lisch (1983), Fletcher et al.
(1985) and Ilo et al. (1999). Hagenimana et al. (2006) had
shown that increase in moisture increased the bulk density
of extrudates.
0.729
hydrophilic groups, and on the capacity of gel formation of
macro molecule (Gomez and Aguilera, 1983). WAI for the
extrudates ranged between 3.88 and 4.47 g.g-1 (Table 3). The
linear terms of screw speed (P < 0.05) and wheat flour (P <
0.01) had significant effect on WAI. The quadratic terms of
feed moisture (P < 0.05) also had significant effect on WAI
(Table 4). The quadratic model obtained from regression
analysis for density (D) in terms of coded levels of the
variables is shown in Table 5. As the data in Table 3 reveals,
an increase in screw speed and feed moisture decreased
WAI. However, increase in die temperature and wheat
flour in total composition increased WAI. It is worth to
note that starch granules should undergo a certain degree of
conversion to initiate water absorption. Gelatinization, the
conversion of raw starch to a cooked and digestible material
by application of water and heat is one of the important
effects that extrusion has on the starch component of food.
WAI has been generally attributed to the dispersion of
starch in excess water, and the dispersion is increased
by the degree of starch damage due to gelatinization and
extrusion-induced fragmentation, i.e., molecular weight
reduction of amylase and amylopectin (Yagci and Gogus,
2008). Water absorption index increased with the increase
in temperature, probably due to increased dextrinization at
higher temperature (Mercier and Feillet, 1975; Kumar et
al., 2010).
Water Absorption index (WAI)
WAI measures the water holding by starch after swelling
in excess water. WAI depends on the availability of
7
January-March, 2015
Extrusion Process Optimization for Soy-Carrot Pomace Powder incorporated Wheat-based Snacks
Fig. 2: Contour plots depicting the effect of process parameters on product quality responses
8
Md Shaiq Alam, Harjot Khaira, Shivani Pathania, Sunil Kumar and Baljit Singh
JAE : 52 (1)
on hardness (Fig 2). Die temperature, screw speed and feed
moisture content showed positive correlation with hardness,
which indicated that hardness increased with an increase
in these parameters.
WSI, often used as an indicator of degradation of
molecular components, measures the degree of starch
conversion during extrusion being the amount of soluble
polysaccharides released from the starch after extrusion
(Ding et al., 2006). The range of WSI of the extrudates
varied between 18.4 and 28.82 per cent. With respect
to the effect of independent variables on WSI, negative
coefficients depicted contrary relationships with WSI. Of
all independent variables, WSI was significantly influenced
by moisture (P<0.05). The quadratic model obtained from
regression analysis for water solubility index (WSI) in
terms of coded levels of the variables is shown in Table 5.
The product terms of screw speed and feed moisture, and
quadratic terms of screw speed had significant effect on
WSI (Table 4 and Fig. 2). Lowest WSI was at 150oC dietemperature, 500 rpm screw speed, 14% moisture and 75%
wheat flour-whereas highest value of 29.82 was observed
at processing conditions of 150oC die temperature, 400
rpm screw speed, 17% moisture content and 75% wheat
flour in the composition. This revealed that at constant die
temperature and composition, screw speed increase by 100
rpm and moisture decrease by 3% resulted in an increase
of 10.66% in WSI value.
Increase in hardness with increase in moisture might be due
to water acting as a plasticizer to the starch-based material,
reducing its viscosity and mechanical energy dissipation in
the extruder. The product thus becomes dense and bubble
growth gets compressed. Previous studies also reported that
hardness of extrudate increased as feed moisture content
increased (Badrie and Mellowes, 1991; Liu et al., 2011).
However, hardness decreased with increase in wheat flour
as more starch is gelatinized with respective less carrot
pomace proportion in the composition.
Colour Change
As a product is cooked, a change in its colour is apparent.
The colour change during extrusion was examined and
depicted in Table 3. Table 4 illustrates that colour change
was greatly influenced by screw speed (P< 0.01) and feed
moisture (P< 0.01). The values for colour change ranged
from 6.47-14.17 (Table 3). The maximum colour change
(14.17) was perceived at 120oC, 400 rpm screw speed and
14% moisture content, while minimum colour change (6.47)
was recorded at 150oC, 500 rpm screw speed and 20%
moisture content (Table 3). Further, it was observed that the
effect of linear terms of screw speed and moisture (p<0.01),
product term of screw speed and moisture (p<0.05); screw
speed and wheat flour in the composition (p<0.01) and
quadratic term of feed moisture were significant (Table 4,
Fig. 2).
Lower WSI indicates a minor degradation of starch, and
such conditions lead to less number of soluble molecules
in the extrudate (Hernandez- Diaz et al., 2007). Water is
absorbed and bound to starch molecules bringing a change in
inherent starch granule structure. Maximum gelatinization
occurs at low moisture and high temperature or vice versa
(Lawton et al, 1972; Mercier and Feillet, 1975). However,
even at higher temperatures, high moisture content can
diminish protein denaturation, which subsequently lowers
WSI values during extrusion. Badrie and Mellowes (1991)
and Hernandez- Diaz et al.(2007) reported similar findings.
WSI is also reported to be related to the presence of
soluble molecules that have sometimes been attributed to
dextrinization (Colonna et al., 1989).
Overall Acceptability
Sensory properties of the product depicting its overall
acceptability scores based on appearance, consistency
and mouth feel are illustrated in Table 3. Extruded snacks
were in acceptable range as per the sensory scores. The
overall acceptability scores ranged from 5.18-7.39.
Highest overall acceptability was for product processed
at 150oC die temperature, 500 rpm screw speed, 14% feed
moisture and 75% wheat flour in the composition whereas
lowest overall acceptability was for product prepared at
150oC die temperature, 300 rpm screw speed, 20% feed
moisture and 75% wheat flour in the composition. High
feed moisture and carrot pomace and legume flour content
in blend might have led to low acceptability scores. The
linear terms of screw speed, feed moisture and wheat flour
in the composition had significant effect on the overall
acceptability scores. However, die temperature was
observed to have insignificant effect on acceptability scores
(Table 4). The product terms and quadratic terms of the
Hardness
The hardness of expanded extrudates is associated with
expansion and cell structure of the product. Hardness is the
peak force required for a probe to penetrate the extrudate.
The higher the value of maximum peak force, the higher
the hardness of the sample. Hardness of the extrudates
ranged between 31.27 and 76.20 N (Table 3). The predicted
regression model is described by the equation in terms of
coded levels in Table 5. The linear terms of screw speed
(p<0.05) and wheat flour in the composition (P<0.01) had
significant effect on hardness. The product terms of die
temperature and feed moisture, and quadratic effect of
wheat flour in the total composition had significant effects
9
January-March, 2015
Extrusion Process Optimization for Soy-Carrot Pomace Powder incorporated Wheat-based Snacks
10
Md Shaiq Alam, Harjot Khaira, Shivani Pathania, Sunil Kumar and Baljit Singh
JAE : 52 (1)
Fig. 3: Overlay contours of different responses for optimization of extrusion process parameters Water solubility
index (WSI)
independent variables had insignificant effect on extrudate’s
properties. Butt et al.(2004) in a study had observed that
overall acceptability of snacks were in acceptable range.
The results were in accordance with overall acceptability
of rice-mungbean snacks (Sharma, 2012).
was given to all the 4 process parameters. However, based
on their relative contribution to quality of final product, the
importance given to different responses was 3 for SME,
WAI, WSI, H, BD, ER and 4 for OA (Table 6).
Predicted values of bulk density (0.227), expansion ratio
(2.926), water absorption index (4.299), water solubility
index (24.68), hardness (49.99 N), colour change (9.52)
and overall average acceptability (7.18) were used to
overlay plot graphical optimization (Fig 3). Best extrusion
conditions were 15 % moisture, 490 rpm screw speed,
136 0C die temperature and 85% wheat flour having
desirability value of 0.729 (Fig. 3).
Optimization and validation
Graphical multi-response optimization technique was
adopted to determine the workable optimum conditions for
the development of extruded product using Design Expert
software (Statease, DE 8.0.6.1). The process parameters
were optimized for lower bulk density, colour change,
hardness and higher expansion ratio, water absorption
index, water solubility index and overall acceptability
of wheat flour, carrot pomace and soy-based readyto-eat expanded product. These constraints resulted in
“feasible zone” of optimum conditions (shaded area in the
superimposed contour plots). Superimposed contour plots
having common superimposed area of all the responses for
extrusion processes are presented in Fig. 3.
CONCLUSIONS
Response surface methodology was effective in optimizing
extrusion process parameters for twin-screw extruded
snacks composed of defatted soybean flour, carrot pomace
powder and wheat flour with feed moisture in the range of
14-20 %, die temperature 120-180oC, screw speed 300-500
rpm and 65-85 % wheat flour in the composition. Graphical
techniques, in connection with RSM, aided in locating
optimum operating conditions, which were experimentally
verified and proven to be adequately reproducible. The
In order to optimize the process conditions for extrusion
process by numerical optimization, which finds a point that
maximizes the desirability function; equal importance of ‘3’
11
January-March, 2015
Extrusion Process Optimization for Soy-Carrot Pomace Powder incorporated Wheat-based Snacks
Faubion J M; Hoseney R C. 1982. High-temperature
short-time extrusion cooking of wheat starch and flour. I.
Effect of moisture and flour type on extrudate properties.
Cereal Chem., 59, 529-533.
optimum process parameters obtained for development of
extrudates were 15% moisture, 490 rpm screw speed, 136 0C
die temperature and 85% wheat flour in the composition
for achieving the maximum possible expansion ratio, WAI,
WSI, overall acceptability with minimum hardness, bulk
density and colour change.
Fletcher S I; Richmond P; Smith A. 1985. An
experimental study of twin-screw extrusion cooking of
maize grits. J. Food Eng., 4, 291-312.
REFERENCES
Gnanasekharam V, Shewfelt R L; Chinnan M S. 1992.
Detection of colour changes in green vegetables J. Food
Sci., 57, 149-154.
Altan A; McCarthy K L; Maskan M. 2008. Evaluation
of snack foods from barley–tomato pomace blends by
extrusion processing. J. Food Eng., 84, 231–242.
Gomez M H; Aguilera J M. 1983. Changes in the starch
fraction during extrusion cooking of corn. J. Food Sci.,
48, 378-381.
Amerine M A; Panngborn R M; Roessler E B. 1965.
Principles of Sensory Evaluation of Food. Academic Press,
London, pp: 5.
Hagenimana A; Ding X; Fang T. 2006. Evaluation of
rice flour modified by extrusion cooking. J. Cereal Sci.,
43, 38-46.
Anderson R A; Conway H F; Pfeifer V F; Grifin E L.
1969. Roll and extrusion cooking of grain sorghum grits.
Cereal Sci. Today., 14, 4-12.
Hernandez-Diaz J R; Quintero R A; Barnard J;
Balandran Q R R. 2007. Functional properties of
extrudates prepared with blends of wheat flour/pinto bean
meal with added wheat bran. Food Sci. Technol. Int., 13,
301–330.
Badrie N; Mellowes W A. 1991. Texture and microstructure
of cassava flour extrudate. J. Food Sci., 56, 1319–22, 1364.
Berrios J J. 2006. Extrusion cooking of legumes: Dry bean
flours. Encyclopedia of Agricultural, Food and Biological
Engineering 1st Ed., 1, 1-8.
Ibanoglu S; Ainsworth P; Ozer E A; Plunkett A. 2006.
Physical and sensory evaluation of a nutritionally balanced
gluten-free extruded snack. J. Food Eng., 75, 469-472.
Butt M S; Nasir M; Akhtar S; Sharif K. 2004. Effect of
moisture and packaging on the shelf life of wheat flour. Int.
J. Food Saf., 4, 1–6.
Ilo S; Y Liu Y; Berghofer E. 1999. Extrusion cooking of
rice flour and amaranth blends. Lebensm-Wiss- u-Technol.,
32, 79-88.
Carrillo M J; Moreno R C; Hernandez I L C; Sandez
O C. 2002. Optimization of extrusion process to transform
hardened chickpeas (Cicer arietinum) into a useful product.
J. Sci. Food Agric., 82, 1718–1728.
Kumar N; Sarkar B C; Sharma H K. 2010. Development
and characterization of extruded product of carrot pomace,
rice flour and pulse powder. Afr. J. Food Sci., 4, 703–17.
Colonna P; Buleon A; Mercier P. 1989. Physically
modified starches. In: Starch: properties and potential, Ed:
T. Galliard, London, John Wiley and Sons, 79-114.
Launay B; Lisch L M. 1983. Twin-screw extrusion cooking
of starches: Flow behaviour of starch pastes, expansion
and mechanical properties of extrudates. J. Food Eng., 52,
1746–1747.
Ding Q; Ainsworth P; Tucker G; Marson H. 2005. The
effect of extrusion conditions on the physicochemical
properties and sensory characteristics of rice-based
expanded snacks. J. Food Eng., 66, 283–289.
Lawton B T; Henderson G A; Derlatke E J. 1972. The
effect of extruder variables on the gelatinization of corn
starch. Can. J. Chem. Eng., 50, 168-173.
Ding Q; Ainsworth P; Plunkett A; Tucker G; Marson H.
2006. The effect of extrusion conditions on the functional
and physical properties of wheat-based expanded snacks.
J. Food Eng., 73, 142–148.
Lee C H; Kim D C; Chun J H; Kim J B; Son C C.
1987. Food Extrusion Technology (Korean). J. Food Sci.
Technol., 15, 392.
Fan J; Mitchell J R; Blanchard J M V. 1996. The effect
of sugars on the extrusion of maize grits: The role of
the glass transition in determining product density and
shape. Int. J. Food Sci. Technol., 31, 55–65.
Liu C; Yanjun Z; Wei L; Jie W; Weihua W; Wu N; Zuo
Y; Zhonglin; Yin Z. 2011. Preparation, physicochemical
and texture properties of texturized rice produce by
improved extrusion cooking technology. J. Cereal Sci.,
54, 473-480.
12
Md Shaiq Alam, Harjot Khaira, Shivani Pathania, Sunil Kumar and Baljit Singh
JAE : 52 (1)
Meng X; Threinen D; Hansen M; Driedger D. 2010.
Effects of extrusion conditions on system parameters and
physical properties of a chickpea flour-based snack. Food
Res. Int., 43, 650–658.
Stojceska V; Ainsworth P; Plunkett A; Ibanoglu E;
Ibanoglu S. 2008. Cauliflower by-products as a new source
of dietary fibre, antioxidants and proteins in cereal based
ready-to-eat expanded snacks. J. Food Eng., 87, 554-563.
Mercier C; Feillet P. 1975. Modification of carbohydrate
components by extrusion-cooking of cereal products. Cereal
Chem., 52, 283–297.
Upadhyay A; Sharma H K; Sarkar B C. 2008.
Characterization of dehydration kinetics of carrot pomace.
Agric. Eng. Int., 10, 1-9.
Onyango C; Henle T; Hoffmann T; Bley T. 2004.
Production of high energy density fermented uji using a
commercial alpha-amylase or by single-screw extrusion.
Lebensm-Wiss u-Technol., 37, 401–407.
Veronica A O; Olusola O O; Adebowale E A. 2006.
Qualities of extruded puffed snacks from maize/soybean
mixture, J. Food Process Eng., 29, 149-161.
Yagci S; Gogus F. 2008. Response surface methodology
for evaluation of physical and functional properties of
extruded snack foods developed from food by products. J.
Food Eng., 86, 122–132.
Sharma C. 2012. Development of extruded snacks utilizing
broken rice and mung bean. Unpublished M.Sc Thesis,
Punjab Agricultural University, Ludhiana, Punjab, India.
13
January-March, 2015
Optimization of Process Parameters for Production of Palmyrah Palm Jaggery
Journal of Agricultural Engineering, Vol. 52 (1): January-March, 2015
Optimization of Process Parameters for Production
of Palmyrah Palm Jaggery
M. Madhava1, D. Ravindra Babu2, P. C. Vengaiah3 and B. Hari Babu4
Manuscript received:May, 2013
Revised manuscript accepted: February, 2015
ABSTRACT
Palmyra palm (Borassus flabellifer L.) is one of the important and an alternate source for production of jaggery.
Palmyra jaggery industry is facing technical issues as quantification of lime to be used, heating temperature and
heating time of neera for jaggery preparation. A central composite rotatable design was used to optimize the process
parameters like quantity of lime, heating temperature and heating time. Mathematical models and response surfaces
were developed for estimating the total sugars, ash and moisture content of palmyra palm jaggery. Total sugars
increased with increase in temperature and time, but lime had less effect over the optimal value. Ash content was
more affected with lime, but less effected by the time and temperature. Moisture content was more affected by
temperature and less by time and lime content. The best combination obtained to get good quality solid palmyrah
jaggery was use of 2.1% lime, operating temperature of 111°C and 126 min of process time. The jaggery prepared
at these conditions had 0.17% fat, 0.98% protein, 2.80% ash and 91.00% carbohydrates at 8.50% moisture content.
Sensory evaluation of jaggery showed that the jaggery produced with above combination scored well for all quality
attributes as compared to jaggery prepared at 2.1% lime, 1210C and 174 min time.
Key words: Process, quality, sensory, lime, model, time, temperature, properties
Palmyrah palm (Borassus flabellifer L.) belongs to the
family Palmae, used for tapping neera. Neera is the sweet
sap of the palm obtained by slicing the spathes of the
palmyra or scraping the tendermost part just below the
crown. Jaggery is obtained by processing of neera. Among
103 million palms in India, 30% of trees are in Andhra
Pradesh (Ghosh et al., 1998). India annually produces
about 6 MT of jaggery, which accounts for 70% of the total
production in the world. About 65-70% of the total jaggery
is produced from sugarcane, and the remaining 30% is
from palms (Rao et al., 2009). Palmyra palm is one of the
important alternate raw material for production of jaggery
(or gur). Price of palm jaggery is determined by its quality,
especially the colour, flavour and texture. Palm jaggery
industry is an unorganized rural industry. The production
process was controlled by persons having less scientific
knowledge, which led to lack of process standardization for
solid jaggery (Guerra and Mujica, 2009). Palmyra jaggery
industry is facing problem of quantifying of lime to be
used to prevent fermentation of neera after tapping, heating
temperature and heating time of neera for maintaining
proper quality, yield and nutritional properties of jaggery.
and traditional practices still exist. For better export market,
potential and supporting price, optimization of processing
parameters plays an important role. Not much research has
been conducted on palmyrah as the nutritional quality of
liquid and solid jaggery products are not well known, though
they are used in the preparation of ayurvedic/traditional
medicines helping to reduce the chances of lung cancer,
diabetes and obesity (Vengaiah et al., 2011). Hence, the
research work reported was conducted to standardise the
palm jaggery production process and to analyse the quality
parameters of solid jaggery.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Sample Preparation
Fresh neera was tapped from about 18 trees of about 22
years old and 4-5 m tall in the early morning between 6-7
A.M, using sharp knife. Neera was collected by slicing the
spathe two times in a day. Yield of neera varies from tree
to tree. Fresh neera was collected in lime-treated earthen
pots tied to the inflorescences during previous evening.
Nera ejaculates from the inflorescence throughout the
night. The pots were removed from the inflorescences on
the next day. Collected neera was filtered through fine
muslin cloth to remove debris and impurities. Clarification
Food product like solid jaggery from palmyrah is not
commercialized as the process has not been standardized
1
Assistant Professor, College of Agricultural Engineering, Bapatla. Andhra Pradesh, corresponding author email: madhava12@gmail.com; 2Post
graduate student, College of Agricultural Engineering, Bapatla. Andhra Pradesh; 3Scientist, Horticultural Research Station, Pandirimamidi,
Andhra Pradesh; 4Assistant Professor, College of Agricultural Engineering, Bapatla. Andhra Pradesh.
14
JAE : 52 (1)
M. Madhava, D. Ravindra Babu, P. C. Vengaiah and B. Hari Babu
(de-liming) process was done at 40°C to reduce the pH to
7.5 using either phosphoric acid or triple super phosphate
solution or citric acid. Clarified neera was transformed into
liquid jaggery by boiling in 20-gauge round-bottom thin
galvanized iron (GI) pan at 108-110°C for 3-4 h till the
syrup attained total soluble solids of around 81°Brix. The
clarified neera was stirred continuously during heating to
avoid charring. Thick viscous mass was transferred into
100 mm cube wooden moulds, and allowed to cool to room
temperature. The viscous mass solidified during cooling.
Solid jaggery was removed from the mould and sealed in
low density poly ethylene bags.
Ease, Inc., MN, USA (2012). Table 1 gives complete
experimentation given by Design Expert software.
Measurement of Parameters
Total Sugars
It is an important nutritional component that determines the
sweetness of the product. Estimation of total sugars was
carried out by Anthrone Method (AOAC, 2005).
Ash
Ash content of food stuff represents inorganic residue
remaining after destruction of organic matter. High ash
content indicates presence of adulterants in food material.
It was determined according to the method given by AOAC
(2005).
Experimental Design
For avoiding large number of experiments with three
independent variables, a Central Composite Rotatable
experimental Design (CCRD) was used to design
the experiment, keeping optimized values of process
parameters. For optimization of independent operational
parameters (lime, time, and temperature), 15 experimental
runs were carried out according to CCRD. About 10 l of
neera sample was used to conduct each run. A CCRD
experiment was made with three independent variables viz.,
quantity of lime (X1), heating time (X2) and temperature
(X3). In the study, optimization of process variables was
carried out using Design Expert version 8.0.7.1 of Stat-
Fat and Protein
Fat content in jaggery is very less. It was determined by
Soxhlet Method (Ranganna, 1994), and protein content was
estimated by Lowry’s Method (AOAC, 2005).
Sensory Evaluation
Sensory evaluation was done using 9-point hedonic scale
method (Ranganna, 1994). Hedonic rating test was used
to measure the consumer acceptability of food products.
Table 1. Design of experiment for jaggery preparation with three independent variables in CCRD
Expt. No.
Lime, % (X1)
Temperature, °C (X2)
Time, min (X3)
1
1.5 (0)
124 (+1.682)
150 (0)
2
0.9 (–1)
121 (+1)
174 (+1)
3
1.5 (0)
117 (0)
150 (0)
4
2.1 (+1)
113 (–1)
174 (+1)
5
0.5 (-1.682)
117 (0)
150 (0)
6
1.5 (0)
117 (0)
190 (1.682)
7
0.9 (-1)
111 (-1)
126 (-1)
8
2.1 (+1)
121 (+1)
174 (+1)
121 (+1)
126 (–1)
9
2.1 (+1)
10
2.1 (+1)
111 (-1)
126 (-1)
11
0.9 (-1)
121 (+1)
126 (-1)
12
0.9 (–1)
111 (–1)
174 (+1)
13
1.5 (0)
117 (0)
110 (-1.682)
14
1.5 (0)
110 (-1.682)
150 (0)
15
2.5 (1.682)
117 (0)
150 (0)
15
January-March, 2015
Optimization of Process Parameters for Production of Palmyrah Palm Jaggery
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
temperature rose from 113°C to 121°C at 126 min. Total
sugars content followed a decreasing trend up to middle
point, and thereafter followed an increasing trend when
the time increased from 126 min to 174 min at 1130C
temperature. Increase in total sugars was also observed
at higher temperature and higher time, and reached a
maximum value of 90.8% at constant time of 174 at 1210C.
Evaporation of water at higher temperature and processing
time increased the total sugars.
Fresh neera was analysed for pH and total soluble solids
(sugar concentration) in °Brix according to lime percentage.
It was observed that fresh neera samples had pH value in
the range of 9-14, TSS in the range of 7-15°Brix and lime
in the range of 0.9 – 2.5 per cent.
Optimization of Responses
Total Sugars
A nonlinear second-order regression equation was
developed as a function of independent real values of
quantity of lime in percentage (x1), temperature in degree
centigrade (x2) and time in minutes (x3) for the dependent
variable total sugars (S), and is expressed as:
%
91
)
Total sugars,
(
92
S = 8 9.9 9 + 1.0 8 x1 − 0.1 2 x2 + 0.037 x − 0.1 4 x + 0.037 x R = 0.9 7 ...(1)
2
1
2
2
2
3
2
90
89
88
92
2.10
174.00
1.80
166.00
91
Total sugars,
%
158.00
1.50
150.00
142.00
90
134.00
C: Time
89
A: Lime
1.20
126.00
0.90
Fig. 1(b): Effect of lime and time on total sugars at 117°C
processing temperature
88
2.10
121.00
92
1.80
119.00
1.50
117.00
113.00
%
A: Lime
Total sugars ,
B: Temperature
91
1.20
115.00
0.90
Fig. 1(a): Effect of lime and temperature on total sugars
at 150 min processing time
Response surface plot Fig. 1(a) shows that the effect of lime
on total sugars was less. With increase in temperature, total
sugars increased with increase in lime. The behaviour was
due to arrest of fermentation of neera with more percent of
lime and evaporation of water with increase in temperature.
90
89
88
121.00
174.00
119.00
166.00
158.00
117.00
150.00
142.00
Figure 1 (b) shows that the response surface plot of total
sugars as lime and time indicated that the total sugar content
decreased from 90.4% to 90.0% when lime percentage
increased from 0.9% to 2.1% at constant time of 126
min. Total sugars content slightly decreased from 90.4%
to 85.3% when the time increased from 126 min to 150
min. Thereafter, total sugar percentage showed slightly
increasing trend till constant time of 174 min was reached.
C: Time
115.00
134.00
126.00
B: Temperature
113.00
Fig. 1(c): Effect of temperature and time on total sugars
with 1.5% lime use
Ash Content
A nonlinear second-order regression equation was
developed as a function of independent real values of
quantity of lime in percentage (x1), temperature in degree
centigrade (x2) and time in minutes (x3) for the dependent
variable ash (A), as presented in Eq. (2).
Figure 1 (c) shows that the response surface plot of total
sugars slightly increased from 90.0% to 90.4% when the
16
M. Madhava, D. Ravindra Babu, P. C. Vengaiah and B. Hari Babu
(
JAE : 52 (1)
)
A = 2.01 + 0.9 6 x1 + 0.1 4 x12 − 0.037 x22 − 0.037 x32 R 2 = 0.9 8 ...(2 )
increased from 126 min to 150 min, and there after increased
to 2.2% ash content at 174 min. Increase in ash content with
increase in time might be due to increase in boiling of inorganic
residuals.
3
Fig. 2(c) shows that ash content increased from 1.8% to 2.5%
when temperature increased from 113°C to 121°C at 126 min of
processing. Ash content showed a decreasing trend when time
reached from 126 min to 150 min, and thereafter percentage
of ash content increased when the processing time increased.
Ash content finally reached to 1.7%, at 174 min and 113°C
temperature. It was concluded that ash content was significantly
affected by lime percentage, but was negligibly affected by
time and temperature.
2
1.5
1
121.00
2.10
119.00
1.80
117.00
1.20
113.00
A: Lime
2.5
0.90
Fig. 2(a): Effect of lime and temperature on ash content at
150 min processing time
%
B: Temperature
3
1.50
115.00
2
Ash ,
Ash ,
%
2.5
1.5
3
1
2.5
Ash ,
%
174.00
121.00
166.00
2
119.00
158.00
150.00
117.00
142.00
C: Time
1.5
115.00
134.00
126.00
B: Temperature
113.00
Fig. 2(c): Effect of temperature and processing time on ash
content at 1.5% lime use
1
174.00
Moisture Content
2.10
166.00
158.00
150.00
1.50
142.00
C: Time
A nonlinear second-order regression equation was
developed as a function of independent real values of
quantity of lime in percentage (x1), temperature in degree
centigrade (x2) and time in minutes (x3) for the dependent
variable moisture content (M), and represented as:
1.80
1.20
134.00
126.00
A: Lime
0.90
Fig. 2(b): Effect of lime use and processing time on ash
content at 1170C processing temperature
(
)
M = 4.9 8 + 0.1 2 x1 − 1.4 9 x24 − 0.017 x12 + 0.0 8 x22 + 0.1 x32 R 2 = 0.9 7 ...(3)
Response surface plot Fig. 2 (a) shows that at lower
temperature, ash content decreased from 1.7% to 1.1% when
lime percentage increased at 1130C. When temperature
increased, ash content increased with increase in lime
content. Increase in ash content with increase in temperature
might be due to increase in inorganic residue during
heating increased evaporation of water content in the form
of vapours. Decrease in ash content with increase in lime
content might be due to arrest of fermentation of sap causing
incomplete destruction of organic matter.
Moisture content ,
%
8
7
6
5
4
121.00
Figure 2(b) shows the response surface plot of ash as
lime and time, and indicated that the ash content did not
change when the lime percentage increased. Ash content had
a relatively less effect of lime, and had more effect of time.
Ash content started decreasing in parabolic paths when time
2.10
119.00
1.80
117.00
B: Temperature
1.50
115.00
1.20
113.00
A: Lime
0.90
Fig. 3(a): Effect of lime and temperature on moisture
content at 150 min processing time
17
January-March, 2015
Optimization of Process Parameters for Production of Palmyrah Palm Jaggery
to 2.1% at 126 min of processing. At lower lime percent,
moisture content increased with time; but moisture content
decreased at higher time and lime percent. Increase in
moisture content with increase in both lime and time might
be due to the reason that increase in lime percentage might
have increased the hygroscopicity of jaggery, and bound
water present in the bio-colloids of jaggery might have
taken longer time to separate.
Fig. 3(a) shows the response surface plot of moisture content
against lime and temperature, and indicated that moisture
content decreased from 5.3% to 4.3% when the temperature
increased from 113°C to 121°C with use of 0.9% lime.
Moisture content decreased with increase in temperature,
and did not change when the lime percent increased at lower
temperatures, but increased at higher temperatures.
Fig. 3(c) shows that the moisture content of jaggery was
affected by temperature, but had little effect of both time
and lime content.
8
Moisture content ,
%
7
6
Proximate Composition
5
The proximate composition of best quality jaggery obtained
at optimised processing conditions using RSM was at lime
2.1%, temperature of 111°C and time of 126 min. Variation
in proximate compositions of solid jaggery samples can be
observed from the Table 2. Moisture content of jaggery at
optimized conditions was less than control sample. Low
moisture content of solid jaggery produced at optimum
conditions enhanced its shelf life and provided better
keeping quality as compared to the control sample. Same
fat content was observed in both the samples. Higher protein
content was observed in solid jaggery prepared at optimum
processing conditions as compared to the control sample.
This might be due to lack of control of production process
in traditional practice, resulting in loss of protein in control
sample. Ash content was slightly higher for solid jaggery
prepared at optimum conditions as compared to control
sample, possibly due to minimum loss of minerals during
processing at optimum processing conditions. It was also
observed that carbohydrates were almost same for both
the samples.
4
3
174.00
2.10
166.00
1.80
158.00
150.00
1.50
142.00
C: Time
1.20
134.00
126.00
A: Lime
0.90
Fig. 3(b): Effect of lime and time on moisture content at
117°C processing temperature
Moisture content ,
%
8
7
6
5
4
3
174.00
121.00
166.00
150.00
117.00
142.00
C: Time
Sensory Evaluation
119.00
158.00
115.00
134.00
126.00
Solid jaggery samples S4, S5, S7, and S9 had higher scores
for colour; S4, S6, S7 and S9 for taste; samples S1, S4 and
S7 for flavour and samples S1, S4, S5, and S7 for texture
/ appearance (Table 3). Among all nine jaggery samples,
sample S4 (2.1% lime use, processing at 1260C for 111 min)
scored well for all quality attributes, followed by S7 (2.1%
lime use, processing at 1210C for 174 min).
B: Temperature
113.00
Fig. 3(c): Effect of temperature and time on moisture
content at 1.5% lime use
Fig. 3(b) shows that moisture content increased drastically
from 4.2% to 6.8%, as the lime content increased from 0.9%
Table 2. Proximate composition of solid jaggery
Sample
Preparation Method
Moisture,
%, d.b
Fat,
%
Protein,
%
Ash,
%
Carbohydrate,
%
Solid jaggery
Lime: 2.1%
Temperature: 111°C
Time: 126 min
8.50
0.17
0. 98
2.8
91.00
Control
Jaggery prepared by traditional
practice (boiling up to 120°C)
9.19
0.17
0.35
2.5
92.00
18
JAE : 52 (1)
M. Madhava, D. Ravindra Babu, P. C. Vengaiah and B. Hari Babu
Table 3. Sensory evaluation of solid jaggery samples
Sample No.
Treatment condition
Quality attribute
Time
(min)
Temperature
(0C)
Lime
(%)
Colour
Taste
Flavour
Texture
S1
174
111
0.9
5
7
8
8
S2
150
124
1.5
5
5
6
6
S3
150
117
2.5
2
3
2
5
S4
126
111
2.1
8
9
8
9
S5
174
121
0.9
7
7
7
8
S6
150
117
0.5
6
8
3
7
S7
174
121
2.1
7
8
8
9
S8
150
117
1.5
5
6
5
6
S9
126
121
0.9
8
8
4
3
7
7
5
6
Control
Traditional practice
Guerra M J; Mujica M V. 2009. Physical and chemical
properties of cane sugar “panelas”. Ciênciae Technologia
de, 30(1), 250-257.
CONCLUSIONS
A central composite rotatable design was used to optimize
the process parameters like quantity of lime, heating
temperature and heating time. Mathematical models and
response surfaces were developed for estimating the total
sugars, ash and moisture content of palmyra palm jaggery.
Among fifteen combinations, the best combination suited
for the preparation of solid jaggery was use of 2.1% lime,
processing temperature of 1110C and processing time of
126 min. Sensory scores of jaggery was an average 8.5 for
all quality attributes of sensory evaluation.
Ranganna S. 1994. Handbook of Analysis and Quality
Control for Fruits and Vegetable Products. 2nd Edition,
Tata McGraw Hill Publishing Company Limited, New
Delhi, pp: 182.
Rao P V K J; Das M; Das S K. 2009. Changes in physical
and thermo- physical properties of sugarcane, palmyrapalm and date-palm juices at different concentration of
sugar. J. Food Eng., 90 (4), 559-566.
REFERENCES
Vengaiah P C; Raju M S; Prasad K R; Kumari K. U.
2011. Food from Palmyra palm (Borassus labellifer L.)
present practices and scope. In: XXIV National Convention
of Indian Society of Agricultural Engineers, Tirupati, India,
24-25 January, pp: 162.
AOAC. 2005. Association of Oficial Analytical Chemists.
18th Edition, Washington D.C.
Ghosh A K; Srivastava A K; Agnihotri V P. 1998.
Production Technology of Lump Sugar-Gur/Jaggery. Daya
publishing house, Delhi, 178 – 209.
19
Performance Evaluation of a Sunlower Seed Huller
January-March, 2015
Journal of Agricultural Engineering, Vol. 52 (1): January-March, 2015
Performance Evaluation of a Sunlower Seed Huller
Olaosebikan Layi Akangbe1, Victor Ifeanyi Obiora Ndirika2, Usman Shehu Mohammed3
and Lawan Garba Abubakar4
Manuscript received: August, 2014
Revised manuscript accepted: January, 2015
ABSTRACT
A centrifugal sunflower seed huller was developed. Its performance on two promising varieties of sunflower seeds
grown in Nigeria was evaluated at varying levels of speed and product feed rate. The tests were run at 5% seed
moisture content, dry basis. Both hulling efficiency and kernel breakage were observed to increase with increasing
speed and reducing product feed rate, for the two crop varieties. Cleaning efficiency increased with increasing
operational speed. Varietal difference had significant effect on kernel breakage. Hulling efficiencies for the two
varieties studied were, however, at par.
Key words: Sunlower, huller, eficiency, speed, feed rate, variety
Sunflower (Helianthus annuus L.) is native to North America
(Heiser Jr., 1976). It belongs to a family of flowering plants
known as the Asterecaea (formerly Compositae). Two
main types of sunflower seeds are grown. They are the
high-oil-content and the low-oil-content sunflower seeds.
The former is mainly grown and processed for its oil, an
edible vegetable oil which is also used as salad oil as also
for the manufacture of margarine, soaps and linoleum,
among other things. The seed-meal left after oil extraction
is incorporated in poultry and stock feeds for its nutritive
quality (Senkoylu and Dale, 1999). The second type is used
essentially for confectionery purposes. Seeds of sunflower
may be roasted and eaten as snack.
supplementing groundnut, which was the country’s major
oilseed. Although the total number of hectares under
cultivation for sunflower seeds in Nigeria is not known, it
is being grown as an important crop in some parts of the
country, and also as a research crop. Part of the focus of
research on sunflower in Nigeria in recent time has included
the hulling of sunflower seeds.
Sunflower seed has a whitish kernel with a thin translucent
skin enclosed in a hull. The high fibre, low protein and high
wax content of the hull are major constraints in getting
better oil yield during oil extraction (Senkoylu and Dale,
1999). As such, hulling sunflower seeds is widely adopted
as a pre-requisite step to oil extraction. Hulling the seed of
sunflower involves the separation of the kernel from the
hull. Hull removal has not been totally successful (National
Sunflower Association, 1994), partly because it is not easy
to remove the hulls of high-oil-type sunflower seeds. This
has been linked to the tight binding nature of the hulls to
the kernels. Incomplete hulling has also been attributed to
the shape of sunflower seeds (Bello, 1987).
Nag et al. (1983) developed a centrifugal sunflower seed
huller with a horizontal type impeller, and reported hulling
efficiencies between 53-65% within a speed range of 33.343.4 m.s-1, at which less kernel breakages occurred. Yadav
et al. (1996) studied the effects of peripheral speed, feed
rate and moisture content of sunflower seeds of EC-68414
variety on hulling efficiency in a centrifugal huller using
a vertical type impeller, and reported about 82% hulling
efficiency and 15% kernel breakage at about 10% seed
moisture content, 150 kg.h-1 product feed rate and 47.1 m.s-1
impeller peripheral speed. Amuthan et al. (2001) modified
a centrifugal paddy sheller to hull sunflower seeds of
CO-2 variety, and reported a maximum hulling efficiency
of 87.72% at about 6.5% seed moisture content using a
four-vane impeller with 80 mm vane radius of curvature.
Nolasco et al. (2002) studied the effect of heat treatment
A number of methods for hulling sunflower seeds have
been reported (Beaumont, 1980a, 1980b; Hussain et al.,
1980; Nag et al., 1983). Sunflower seeds are hulled based
on either of the principles of impact or shear. The most
widely adopted principle is that of impact by centrifugation.
The production of sunflower seeds in Nigeria started in
the 1950’s (Tanimu et al., 1987) with the sole aim of
Lecturer, Department of Agricultural and Bioresource Engineering, Abubakar Tafawa Balewa University, P.M.B. 0248 Bauchi, 740001,
Nigeria, email: olaosebikanakangbe@yahoo.com; 2Professor, Department of Agricultural Engineering, Michael Okpara University of
Agriculture, Umudike, Umuahia, Nigeria; 3Associate Professor, Department of Agricultural Engineering, Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria,
Nigeria; 4Associate Professor, Agricultural and Bioresource Engineering Programme, Abubakar Tafawa Balewa University, Bauchi, Nigeria.
1
20
Olaosebikan Layi Akangbe, Victor IfeanyiObiora Ndirika, Usman Shehu Mohammed and Lawan Garba Abubakar
JAE : 52 (1)
screens were emptied into the pneumatic chamber where
free hulls were blown off through the outlet for hulls. The
blower was a paddle type centrifugal blower (with 480 mm
diameter blade sweep, 580 mm wide) enclosed in a housing.
Final product/whole kernel fractions fell through the
airstream and were collected at the base of the equipment.
on hulling performance and reported hulling efficiency of
53% at optimum moisture content of 3% (wet basis) for an
Argentinean variety of sunflower seeds. Thermal treatment
was reported to result in higher hulling efficiency with high
production of broken kernel fractions.
In this study, a centrifugal sunflower seed huller with twin
vertical impeller units was designed and fabricated. It was
necessary to evaluate the performance of the equipment
as influenced by speed, product feed rate and crop variety.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Equipment Description and Working Principles
Hopper (1), Feed chute (2), Impact ring (3), Impeller disc (4),
Impeller vane (5), Impeller hub (6), Cover plate (7), Product
ejection spout (8) and Twin hulling unit (9)
Fig. 2: Exploded isometric view of hulling unit of sunlower
hulling machine
Experimental Design
Two promising varieties of sunflower seeds grown in
Nigeria, namely the Funtua and Isaanka varieties were
used for the study. The crops were obtained from the
research farm of the Institute for Agricultural Research,
IAR, Samaru, Zaria, and kept in storage for more than one
year under the same environmental condition. The moisture
content of the crops at the time of the study was ≈5%, dry
basis. The speed of operation of the equipment was varied
at five levels. The speed levels were 26, 33, 39, 44, and
51 m.s-1 peripheral speeds of the impeller. The product
feed rate was varied at two levels, namely 79 kg.h-1 and
344 kg.h-1. This gave a total of 20 treatments (5 x 2 x 2),
and was considered as a factorial experiment fitted into a
completely randomized design. The experiments were run
in three repetitions, giving a total of 60 experimental runs.
Half and full throat openings of the product feed chute
were selected for this study, which when calibrated gave
74 and 344 kg.h-1 product feeds, respectively. Feed rate
calibration involved feeding seeds during idle runs of the
machine for 1 min, and collecting same at the chute feed
outlets; this was done in 10 repetitions for each feed chute.
The indicated feed rates were the observed mean values.
Corresponding shaft rotational speeds at the shaker at the
given impeller test speeds were 153, 191, 229, 260, and 298
rpm, respectively. Shaft rotational speeds at the blower at
the given impeller test speeds were 203, 255, 306, 346, and
398 rpm, respectively.
Hopper (1), Hulling unit (2), Huller product ejection spout (3),
Shaker (4), Broken kernels outlet (5), Blower (6),
Final product outlet (7) and Shaker hangers (8)
Fig. 1: Front and sideviews of sunlower hulling machine
The equipment consisted of two hulling units, each having
a vertical type impeller; and two cleaning units, one being
mechanical and the other pneumatic type (Fig. 1). A single
hopper fed the two hulling units. Each hulling unit consisted
of a seed chute, an impeller and an impact surface. The impact
surface formed a ring around the impeller (Fig. 2). The
impellers were straight vane types with no top constriction
plates. Seed was fed by gravity from the hopper through
the chute onto the surface of the impeller. The rate of feed
of the products from the hopper was controlled using a
control flap. Seeds fed were subsequently subjected to high
centrifugal forces, made to flow along the straight vane
orientations and flung against the surface of impact. The
resulting impact caused dry brittle hulls to crack open to
let out the kernels. Hulled sunflower seed fractions were
evacuated from the hulling chamber via the product ejection
spout onto the top screen of the shaker. The shaker was fitted
with screens to sort the product fractions. An eccentric drive
was incorporated to provide oscillating motion to the shaker.
Broken kernels sorted by the shaker were collected through
a special outlet. Product fractions which remained on the
21
Performance Evaluation of a Sunlower Seed Huller
January-March, 2015
QTH = Total quantity of free hulls collected from all
outlets, g,
The performance of the equipment was evaluated in terms
of hulling efficiency, kernel breakage, cleaning efficiency
and product loss using the following relationships:
Q
η H = 1001 − U
QO
Q
η B = 100 B K
Q0
Q
ηC = 100 F H
QT H
η L = 1001 −
ηH
ηB
ηC
ηL
QO
QT
…
…
(1)
(2)
…
= Quantity of unhulled seeds, g,
QO
= Quantity of products collected at all outlets,
g, and
QT
= Mass of sample fed, g.
Data Analysis
All data were subjected to the analysis of variance.
Treatment means were compared using the Duncan’s
Multiple Range Test. Analysis of the research data was done
using the SAS statistical analysis software.
(3)
QU
…
(4)
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Where,
Probability values for the effects of the factors studied and
their interactions are presented in Table 1. The main effects
of speed are presented in Table 2. Mean hulling efficiency
was observed to increase with increasing impeller peripheral
speed, being 46.7% at the lowest operational speed of 26
m.s-1 and 74.1% at the highest operational speed of 51 m.s-1.
A similar trend was observed with kernel breakage, which
also increased with increasing impeller peripheral speed.
Mean kernel breakage was 15.5% at 26 m.s-1 and as high
as 39.4% at 51 m.s-1.
= Hulling efficiency, %,
= Kernel breakage, %,
= Cleaning efficiency, %,
= Product loss, %,
QBK = Quantity of broken kernels, g,
QFH = Quantity of free hulls and impurities collected
at the outlet for hulls, g,
Table 1. Effects of the factors studied on equipment performance
Source
Hulling eficiency
Kernel breakage
Cleaning eficiency
Product loss
Speed
<0.0001**
<0.0001**
<0.0001**
0.0008**
Feed
<0.0001**
<0.0001**
<0.0001**
<0.0001**
ns
Crop variety
Feed rate x Crop variety
Speed x Crop variety
Speed x Feed rate
0.13
<0.0001**
0.528
0.043*
0.002**
0.1124ns
0.18ns
0.018*
0.03*
0.2294ns
0.08ns
0.448ns
<0.0001**
<0.0001**
<0.0001**
0.2619
ns
Speed x Feed rate x Crop variety
ns
ns
ns
0.297
0.7251
ns
0.124
0.111ns
ns = not signiicant at 5% level; * = signiicant (at 5% level); ** = highly signiicant (at 1% level)
Table 2. Equipment performance as inluenced by operational speed
Impeller peripheral
speed (m.s-1)
Hulling performance (%)
Hulling eficiency
Kernel breakage
Cleaning eficiency
Product loss
26
46.7
15.5
6.83
11.5
33
59.6
25.1
17.8
12.9
39
66.0
30.5
31.4
11.3
44
71.5
35.2
42.1
10.7
51
74.1
39.4
57.2
11.0
SE
0.392
0.382
0.379
0.35
Comparisons of means are column-wise; SE = Standard Error of means
22
JAE : 52 (1)
Olaosebikan Layi Akangbe, Victor IfeanyiObiora Ndirika, Usman Shehu Mohammed and Lawan Garba Abubakar
being 10.7% and 12.3%, respectively. Low rates of feed
favoured high hulling efficiency, and resulting lighter kernel
fractions were easily lost pneumatically.
Higher particle accelerations obtainable at higher
operational speeds resulted in greater forces of impact
for the seeds. As a result, seed pericarps tended to crack
open more readily at high operational speeds. This agrees
with findings by Nag et al. (1983), who reported almost
proportional increases in hulling efficiency with increasing
speed. As the severity of impact increased with increasing
operational speeds, kernel fracture and kernel structure
failures consequently occurred at high operational speeds.
The degree of fragmentation of the kernels is, therefore, a
function of the severity of the impact, and of the speed of
operation of the equipment. This agrees with findings by
Amuthan et al. (2001). Impeller peripheral speed appears
to be the most important parameter affecting both hulling
efficiency and kernel breakage (Yadav et al.1996).
Crop Variety
When the main effect of crop variety was considered, no
significant difference was observed among mean values of
hulling efficiency (Table 1). Mean hulling efficiency was
63.3% and 63.8% for the Funtua and Isaanka varieties,
respectively. A study (Akangbe et al., 2006) on the physical
properties of Funtua and Isaanka varieties of sunflower
seeds revealed no significant differences in one thousand
and single seed and kernel weights of the two varieties.
Kernels of the Isaanka variety were, however, observed to
disintegrate more easily upon impact, compared to those
of the Funtua variety.
Cleaning Eficiency
Cleaning efficiency increased as speed increased at the
blower. Cleaning efficiency was as low as 7% at the least
blower operational speed of 203 rpm, and was 57% at 398
rpm. As the velocity of air in the pneumatic separation
chamber improved with respect to the steady state velocity
of the impurity stream, cleaning efficiency improved.
For the interaction of feed rate with crop variety, hulling
efficiency was observed to be higher for both the Funtua
and Isaanka varieties at 79 kg.h-1; hulling efficiencies for
the Funtua variety (66.9%) was at par with that for Isaanka
(66.2%) (SE = 0.351) at this product feed setting. At 344
kg.h-1, about 62 and 60% hulling efficiencies were achieved
with the Isaanka and Funtua varieties, respectively.
Hulling Eficiency
For the interactions of speed with crop variety, mean
hulling efficiencies recorded for the Funtua variety were
at par with those recorded for the Isaanka variety in the
39-51 m.s-1 impeller peripheral speed range, hulling
efficiencies for both varieties increasing with increasing
speed (Table 3).
An increase in hulling efficiency was recorded as product
feed was reduced. Hulling efficiency was 61% at 344 kg.h-1
and 67% at 79 kg.h-1(SE = 0.248). More products arrived
on the surface of impact per unit time at the higher feed
rate. This resulted in clogging of the surface of impact.
Consequently, the force of impact was dampened for
subsequently fed seeds and hulling efficiency was reduced
at the higher feed rates. Increasing the area of the surface
of impact to accommodate an increased number of seeds
striking the impact surface per unit time at higher feed rates
will improve hulling performance.
The interaction of speed with product feed rate had
significant effect on hulling efficiency (Fig. 3 and 4). A
high mean hulling efficiency of 76% was obtained with
the lower product feed of 79 kg.h-1 at 51 m.s-1 impeller
peripheral speed. Mean hulling efficiency at 79 kg.h-1 and
44 m.s-1 (73.4%) was at par with mean hulling efficiency at
344 kg.h-1 and 51 m.s-1, which was 72.7 per cent.
Product Loss
Product loss was slightly less at 344 kg.h-1 than at 79 kg.h-1,
Table 3. Hulling performances observed for the interactions of speed and crop variety
Hulling eficiency (%)
Kernel breakage (%)
Impeller peripheral speed
(m.s-1)
Funtua
Isaanka
Funtua
Isaanka
26
45.8
47.7
14.9
16.0
33
58.6
60.6
23.5
26.7
39
66.0
65.9
29.6
31.4
44
71.8
71.2
34.2
36.2
51
74.4
73.8
38.5
40.2
SE
0.554
0.463
Comparisons are performance wise; SE = Standard Error of means
23
Performance Evaluation of a Sunlower Seed Huller
January-March, 2015
η H 344 = −0.0404S 2 + 4.2444S − 3 9.138(R 2 = 0.9984)…(8)
Regression Equation
Equations 5 – 8 are speed-based regression trends generated
for hulling efficiency at 79 and 344 kg.h-1 feed rates for
Funtua and Isaanka varieties of sunflower seeds (Fig. 3
and 4).The trends were hyperbolic with the coefficients
of determination indicated in parenthesis against each
function.
Where,
η H 79 = Hulling efficiency at 79 kg.h-1feed rate, and
S = Speed, m.s-1,
η H 344 = Hulling efficiency at 344 kg.h-1feed rate.
CONCLUSIONS
A centrifugal type huller for sunflower seeds was designed
and fabricated. Significant increase was observed in hulling
efficiency with increasing impeller peripheral speeds,
with consequent increase in kernel breakage. Since the
force of impact was dampened for seeds striking the
surface of impact at higher product feed rates, reduction
in kernel breakage could be obtained with high product
feed, although with limiting effect on hulling efficiency.
Cleaning efficiency improved significantly with increasing
blower operational speed. As high as 76% hulling efficiency
was recorded at 51 m.s-1 impeller peripheral speed and 79
kg.h-1 product feed rate. Further studies on other factors
influencing the performance of this machine are necessary,
particularly with a view to achieving reductions in kernel
breakage.
Impeller peripheral Speed, m.s-1
Fig. 3: Effect of speed and feed rate on hulling eficiency
for Funtua variety of sunlower seed
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
This study was funded by the Institute for Agricultural
Research, IAR Samaru, Zaria, Nigeria.
REFERENCES
Akangbe O.L; Ndirika V.I.O; Mohammed U.S. 2006.
Design related physical properties of sunflower seeds.
In: Proceedings VII International Conference and XXIIX
Annual General Meeting of the Nigerian Institution of
Agricultural Engineers, 28, 284 – 288.
Amuthan G; Subramanian P; Palaswami P.T. 2001.
Modifications made on a centrifugal paddy sheller for
sunflower seed shelling.Agric. Mechanization Asia, Africa
Latin Amer., 32(3), 51-53.
Impeller peripheral Speed, m.s-1
Fig. 4: Effect of speed and feed rate on hulling eficiency
for Isaanka variety of sunlower seed
Beaumont J.H. 1980a. A hand operated bar mill for
decorticating sunflower seeds. Rural Technol. Guide 9,
Tropical Products Institute, London, U.K.
η H 7 9 = −0.0382 S 2 + 3.8834 S − 2 3.275 (R 2 = 0.9838) ... (5)
Hulling efficiency trends for Funtua variety are:
η H 344 = −0.0374S 2 + 4.2127 S − 4 4.354(R 2 = 0.9994) … (6)
Beaumont J.H. 1980b. A hand operated disc mill for
decorticating sunflower seeds. Rural Technol. Guide 10,
Tropical Products Institute, London, U.K.
η H 7 9 = −0.0303S 2 + 3.2285S − 11.001(R 2 = 0.9737 ) …(7)
Hulling efficiency trends for Isaanka variety are:
Bello J.O. 1985. Sunflower, a potential oilseed for Nigeria.
J. Nigerian Soc. Chem. Eng., 4(1 & 2), 36-38.
24
Olaosebikan Layi Akangbe, Victor IfeanyiObiora Ndirika, Usman Shehu Mohammed and Lawan Garba Abubakar
JAE : 52 (1)
Nolasco S.M; Riccobene I.C; Fernandez M.B. 2002.
Hulling of high oil sunflower seed grown in Argentina.
ASAE Paper No. 026123, St. Joseph, MI: ASAE.
Heiser Jr. C.B. 1976. The Sunflower. University of
Oklahoma Press, Norman: U.S.A.
Hussain A.A.M; Sabur M.A; Rahman M.M. 1980.
Design and construction of a manually operated castor bean
cum sunflower dehuller. Agric. Mechanization Asia, Africa
Latin Amer., 11(2), 83-84.
Senkoylu N; Dale N. 1999. Sunflower meal in poultry diets:
a review. World’s Poultry Sci. J., 55, 153-174.
Tanimu B; Ado S.G; Misari S.M. 1987. Association of
some morphological characters of sunflower (Helianthus
annuusL.) varieties with seed yield. Paper presented at the
XIV Annual conference of the Genetics society of Nigeria,
Zaria, Nigeria. March 1 – 4.
Nag K.N; Singh P; Bhandari R. 1983. A centrifugal
impeller–type of sunflower seed decorticator.Agric.
Mechanization Asia, Africa Latin Amer., 14(1), 55-58.
National Sunlower Association (NSA). 1994. Sunflower
meal used in livestock rations.National Sunflower
Association, Bismark, North Dakota.
Yadav R; Singh P; Tiwani G. 1996. Studies on centrifugal
decortication of sunflower seed.Agric.Mechanization Asia,
Africa Latin Amer., 27(3), 62-64.
25
January-March, 2015
Effect of Drying Methods and Storage on Quality of Ready–to–eat Dehydrated Carrot Shreds
Journal of Agricultural Engineering, Vol. 52 (1): January-March, 2015
Effect of Drying Methods and Storage on Quality
of Ready-to-eat Dehydrated Carrot Shreds
V.R. Sagar1
Manuscript received: October, 2013
Revised manuscript received: January, 2015
ABSTRACT
The investigation was carried out to evaluate the effect of drying methods and storage conditions on the quality
of ready-to-eat dehydrated carrot shreds made from tropical orange coloured mature carrots. The prepared carrot
shreds were blanched in boiling water for pre-standardized time, and dipped in sugar solution for 30 min. The shreds
were drained, and dehydrated in a cabinet dryer a low-temperature dryer at temperature of 58±2oC and 40±2oC,
respectively, up to final moisture content of 3-5 per cent. It took 9 and 12 h, respectively, for drying in cabinet
dryer and low temperature dryer. Results indicated that cabinet dryer was better for dehydration of carrot shreds as
compared to low temperature dryer, as it retained higher amount of β-carotene, total carotenoids, rehydration ratio,
and low non-enzymatic browning in the finished product, and also took less time for bulk drying of the product.
Dehydrated carrot shreds were packed in 200g HDPE pouches and stored at room temperature and low temperature
for storage study. It was found that carrot shreds could be stored at room temperature up to 3 months without loss
of colour, flavour and texture; and up to 6 months at low temperature (7oC). However, the quality of the product
was significantly affected by storage temperature and period of storage.
Key words: Carrot, Carotenoids, β–carotene, storage temperature, colour, texture, sensory quality
Carrot (Daucus carota L.) is the second most popular
root vegetable, after potato, in the world. It finds wide
application in the day-to-day use in making curries,
salads, juices, pickles, preserves, sweet meats and soups.
Consumption of carrot is preferred by the consumers
due to its high nutritive value, antioxidant, anticancerous and other medicinal properties (Suvarnkuta
et al., 2005). Carrot root contains β-carotene which is a
precursor of vitamin A, and is an essential component
of the visual pigments in the retina. Its deficiency leads
to xerophthalmia and night blindness in human beings.
The supply of 5.2 - 6.0 mg b-carotene per day can
prevent cancer, as carotenoids may act as antioxidant
by quenching singlet oxygen and triplet excited states
(Palozza and Krinsky, 1992).
rice pullaw, etc. Dehydrated carrot shreds can reduce the cost
of transportation and storage without affecting their quality,
and could be added as a natural antioxidants to develop
new commercial products. The present investigation was,
therefore, undertaken with the objective to optimize the
drying method and storage conditions to enhance the shelf
life of ready-to-eat dehydrated carrot shreds.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Material Preparation
Mature tropical orange coloured carrots were obtained
from experimental field, Division of Vegetable Science,
Indian Agricultural Research Institute, New Delhi. The
roots of carrots were washed with running tap water,
peeled by scrapping with a sharp stainless steel knife,
washed again to remove scrapped material and finally
made into shreds of about 5 mm length with the help of
a shredding machine.
During peak season, abundant supply of carrots keep the
selling price very low causing losses to the growers. To
preserve the carrots for off-seasons, dehydration is one of
the important methods. Dehydrated products require less
storage and transportation cost.
Blanching and sugar Treatment
Prepared shreds were blanched in boiling water (shreds:
water ratio of 1:2) for 4 min (pre-standardized time) as pretreatment to inactivate the peroxidase enzymes. Blanched
shreds were dipped in an equal amount (by weight) of 70o B
sugar solution containing 0.25% potassium metabisulphate
(KMS) for 30 min to ensure complete immersion.
Consumers presently have been increasingly conscious
about the quality of food. There has been growing demand
for ready-to-eat foods like “ready-to-eat carrot shreds”,
which can be eaten as such and also used for preparation of
other carrot products like halwa, ice cream, shakes, biscuits,
1
Division of Food Science and Postharvest Technology, Indian Agricultural Research Institute, New Delhi- 110012; e-mail: vidyaram_sagar @yahoo.com
26
JAE : 52 (1)
V.R. Sagar
Dehydration and Drying Rate
(7.0°C) for storage study. The product was evaluated
at intervals of one month, up to 3 months, for storage
performance.
After 30 min, the treated shreds were drained through sieve
and spread in the form of thin layer @ 2.5 kg.m-2 density
and dried in cross-flow hot air cabinet dryer (Kilburn make,
model-0248, air flow rate 1.20- 1.80 m.s-1, temperature
58±2°C and RH 25-45%) to a moisture content of 3-4% in
the finished product.
Sensory Evaluation
To evaluate the sensory qualities of dehydrated carrot
shreds during storage, carrot halwa and carrot burffee
were prepared from it through reconstitution with equal
amount of milk and dry fruits. Carrot halwa and carrot
burfee were subjected to sensory evaluation by a panel
of 7 semi-trained members for colour, flavour, texture
and overall acceptability. Attributes were scored using a
9-point Hedonic scale. A score of 5.5 and above was rated
acceptable (Szezeniak, 1983).
Treated shreds were also dried using a low temperature
dryer (LTD) with air flow rate of 0.12-0.16 m.s-1 at 40±20C
and 20-50% RH in thin layer @ 1.0 kg.m-2 to a moisture
content of 4-5 per cent. During drying, the samples were
turned periodically every 2 h for uniform drying. Drying
rate was computed by recording the loss in weight at half
an hour interval, and expressed as the rate of residual water
to dry matter (kg of water per kg of dry matter).
Statistical Analysis
Data obtained in the present study were subjected to
statistical analysis of variance techniques as suggested by
Panse and Sukhatme (1989). The critical difference (C.D)
value at 5% level of probability was compared for making
the comparison among different treatments.
Physico-chemical Analysis
Fresh as well as dehydrated carrot shreds were analysed
for titratable acidity and sugars by AOAC (2005)
methods.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Moisture content was determined by drying a known weight
of the sample in a hot air oven at 60±5°C to a constant
weight, and expressed as per cent.
Drying Rate
Drying rate was faster when carrot shreds were dried
in cabinet dryer as compared to low temperature dryer.
It took 9 h for drying carrot shreds to reach a moisture
content of 3.4% (w.b), while in case of low temperature
dryer (LTD) it took 10 h (Fig. 1). Better performance
of cabinet dryer might be due to high temperature and
faster removal of water.
Total carotenoids, β-carotene, sulphur-dioxide and nonenzymatic browning (NEB) as optical density (OD) of
alcoholic extracts of sample were determined by the
methods given by Ranganna (2002).
Drying and Rehydration Ratio
Drying ratio was calculated as net dry weight obtained from
fresh weight of the material.
Rehydration ratio was determined by taking 5 g of
dehydrated sample in a beaker and adding 50 ml of warm
(60°C) water in it. After 1 h, the product was kept on
blotting paper for 15 min to remove surface water of the
product, and then the weight of the rehydrated material was
taken. Rehydration ratio was determined as per methods of
Ranganna (2002).
Packaging
CD= Cabinet dryer, LTD= Low temperature dryer
On the basis of chemical constituents and sensory
score, dehydrated carrot shreds dried in cabinet dryer
was selected as of better quality. Such material was
packed in 200 gauge HDPE (High density polyethylene)
pouches and sealed. Packed pouches were stored at room
temperature (15-35°C) as well as at low temperature
Fig. 1: Trend of drying rate of carrot shreds in dryers
Dehydration and Rehydration Ratio
The difference in dehydration ratio among dryers was
statistically significant. Similar results have been reported
by Jayaraman et al. (1991) for green leafy vegetables.
27
January-March, 2015
Effect of Drying Methods and Storage on Quality of Ready–to–eat Dehydrated Carrot Shreds
Rehydration ratio too was higher in the product dehydrated
in cabinet dryer as compared to low temperature dryer, Table
1. Higher rehydration ratio might be due to faster drying
process that caused less cellular and structural changes in
the final product. Poor rehydration ratio in dehydrated carrot
shreds dried in low temperature dryer might be due to poor
texture of the finished product, which might have absorbed
less water during rehydration as compared to reconstituted
material dried in cabinet dryer. The difference in rehydration
ratio between dryers was statistically significant.
Table 1. Effect of dryers on dehydration ratio, rehydration ratio, non-enzymatic browning and drying time
Dryer
Drying ratio
Rehydration ratio
NEB
(O.D.: 420 nm)
Drying time,
h
2.89:1
3.3:1
0.235
1:3.33
1:2.73
0.371
0137
0.144
0.346
9
12
-
Cabinet dryer
Low temp. dryer
C.D. at 5%
NEB= Non-enzymatic browning
Table 2. Effect of dryers on physico-chemical constituents of ready-to-eat dehydrated carrot shreds
Dryer
Parameter
Total
sugar,
Total carotenoids,
β-carotene,
SO2,
%
Reducing
sugar,
%
%
mg.100g-1
mg.100g-1
ppm
3.10
0.89
24.83
65.23
42.24
24.82
869
Low temp. dryer
4.72
0.90
24.09
63.78
40.20
22.00
881
C.D.at 5%
0.334
NS
0.528
1.214
2.45
1.69
11.74
Moisture,
Acidity,
%
Cabinet dryer
Table 3. Effect of storage on quality of ready-to-eat dehydrated carrot shreds
Parameter
Storage period, month
RT
C.D. at 5%
LT
Initial value
1
2
3
1
2
3
T
P
TxP
Moisture, %
3.00
5.58
4.23
4.88
3.24
3.41
3.62
1.01
0.10
0.59
NEB, O.D at 420 nm
0.143
0.175
0.201
0.233
0.152
0.161
0.168
0.002
0.003
0.004
Reconstitution ratio
1:3.20
3.13
3.05
2.98
3.15
3.11
3.04
NS
NS
NS
Reducing sugar, %
24.43
25.49
26.48
27.77
25.37
25.79
26.03
0.72
NS
0.80
Total sugar, %
65.31
65.99
66.85
66.99
65.44
65.75
66.11
0.56
NS
0.96
Total carotenoids, mg.100g-1
36.04
34.34
30.91
26.72
34.63
33.58
31.72
0.38
0.42
0.40
β- carotene, mg.100g
23.79
22.67
20.61
17.63
22.85
22.18
20.94
0.25
0.31
0.44
869
767.33
657.33
481.00
794.33
739.33
710.33
7.99
9.79
13.85
-1
SO2, ppm
Note: n=3, RT= Room temperature, LT= Low temperature, T= Temperature, P= Period
Table 4. Sensory score of carrot halwa and carrot burfee prepared from dehydrated carrot shreds after 3 months of storage
Storage condition
Room temperature
Low temperature
C.D.at 5%
Carrot product
Appearance
Flavour
Texture
Overall acceptability
Carrot halwa
8.20
8.00
7.80
8.00
Carrot burfee
8.20
7.50
7.50
7.70
Carrot halwa
8.53
8.50
8.40
8.50
Carrot burfee
8.43
8.50
8.30
8.47
-
NS
0.741
0.557
0.516
Note: n= 7 panel members, NS= Non signiicant
28
JAE : 52 (1)
V.R. Sagar
Non–enzymatic Browning
in moisture due to variation in dryers were statistically
significant.
Non–enzymatic browning was lower in the shreds dried
in cabinet dryer as compared to low temperature dryer,
Table 1. This might be due to less moisture content in the
dehydrated product dried in cabinet dryer and less reactions
between amino acid and sugars during storage. Higher nonenzymatic browning in dehydrated carrot shreds might be
due to more moisture dried in low temperature dryer, which
might have caused faster reactions between amino acids
and sugars in the product. The difference in non-enzymatic
browning due to dryers was statistically significant.
Storage Conditions
The effect of storage conditions on the quality of ready-toeat dehydrated carrot shreds is presented in Table 3. The
results indicated that there was gain in moisture content
in dehydrated carrot shreds. The gain of moisture might
be due to absorption of moisture from the atmosphere by
the packages. Similar trend was observed by Kadam et al.
(2006). However, the gain was statistically not significant
both for temperature and period of storage. The nonenzymatic browning (NEB) increased with increase in
storage period. This could be attributed to the degradation
of SO2 during storage of the product (Sagar et al., 1998).
Reconstitution ratio was greatly influenced by the storage
period, and the reduction was more or less uniform,
irrespective of temperature during storage. Decrease in
rehydration ratio might be due to gain of moisture and
loss of texture by the dehydrated carrot shreds during
storage. Similar trend was observed by Dev et al. (2006)
in dehydrated onion slices.
Reducing and Total Sugar
Reducing and total sugars were higher in the shreds dried
in cabinet dryer compared to low temperature dryers,
Table 2. This might be due to more reduction of moisture
content and more concentration of nutrients available in the
product. The differences in reducing sugars due to dryers
were statistically significant. However, total sugars and their
interaction between dryers for reducing and total sugars
were non-significant.
Total Carotenoids and β-carotene Content
Increase in storage period resulted in significant reduction
in both carotenoids and β-carotene. The decrease due to
increase in storage period was highly significant at room
temperature as compared to low temperature. It is evident
from the above that lowering of temperature helped to
maintain a higher level of carotenoids and β–carotene,
thereby improving the quality of the product.
Total carotenoids and β-carotene content were higher in
carrot shreds dried in cabinet dryer as compared to low
temperature dryer, Table 2. This might be due to exposing
the samples for lower period in cabinet dryer as compared
to low temperature dryer. However, the other reason might
be due to the proportional moisture content and dry matter
in the finished product, which might have affected the total
carotenoids under both drying conditions. The changes
in β-carotene and total carotenoids due to dryers were
statistically significant. Similar pattern has been reported
by Jayaraman et al. (1991) in some vegetables. Negi and
Roy (2001) reported that sun, solar, shade or cabinet
drying decreased b-carotene of amaranth and fenugreek
significantly.
The total sugars were particularly higher at room
temperature as compared to low temperature. It could be
attributed to more rapid hydrolysis of polysaccharides and
their subsequent inversion to reducing sugars. The increase
in sugar had also been observed by Sagar et al. (1998) in
dehydrated mango slices. Total sugar increased significantly
at room temperature as compared to low temperature.
Sulphur Dioxide
Sulphur dioxide decreased rapidly due to storage
temperature and period of storage. Similar observation was
made by Nadanasabapathi et al. (1993) in mango fruit bar.
Significant reduction in SO2 due to storage temperature and
period of storage was observed.
Sulphur dioxide was higher in the low temperature dryer
compared to cabinet dryer, Table 2. This might be due
to effect of low temperature used for dehydration. The
variation in SO2 due to dryers was found to be statistically
significant.
Sensory Evaluation
Thus, Cabinet dryer was found to be superior for dehydration
of carrot shreds as it reduced the moisture to lower level
(Table 2). The superiority of the product dried in cabinet
dryer might be due to faster removal of moisture from the
product. Similar influence of solar dryer on moisture content
has also been reported by Pande et al. (2000). The changes
Sensory evaluation (Table 4) of carrot halwa prepared from
stored ready-to-eat dehydrated carrot shreds indicated that
there was better acceptability (overall acceptability 8.5)
when the carrot halwa was prepared from ready-to-eat
dehydrated carrot shreds stored at 7°C than those stored at
room temperature (overall acceptability 8.0).
29
January-March, 2015
Effect of Drying Methods and Storage on Quality of Ready–to–eat Dehydrated Carrot Shreds
Kadam D M; Samuel D V K; Prasad R. 2006. Optimization
of pre- treatments of solar dehydrated caulilower. J. Food
Eng., 77, 659-664.
Appearance, flavour and overall acceptability scores were
highest for carrot burfee prepared from dehydrated carrot
shreds stored at low temperature as compared to carrot
burfee prepared from samples stored at room temperature.
This might be due to less moisture content in the dehydrated
carrot shreds stored at low temperature causing slightly
superior texture of the burfee (Table 4). Significant
difference existed in appearance of carrot halwa and carrot
burfee. However, carrot halwa and carrot burfee prepared
from dehydrated carrot shreds stored at room temperature
and low temperature significantly differed in flavour, texture
and overall acceptability score.
Nadanasabapthi S; Srivatsa A N; Natraju S. 1993.
Storage study of mango bar in lexible packaging materials.
Ind. Food Packer, 5, 8-12.
Negi P S; Roy S K. 2001. Effect of drying conditions on
quality of green leaves during long term storage. Food Res.
Int., 34, 283-287.
Palozza P; Krinsky N I. 1992. Antioxidant effects
of carotenoids in vivo and in vitro: An overview. Mds.
Enzymol., 213, 403-420.
CONCLUSIONS
Pande V K; Sonune A V; Philip S K. 2000. Solar drying of
coriander and methi leaves. J. Food Sci. Technol., 37, 592-595.
Ready-to-eat dehydrated (using cabinet dryer) carrot
shreds can be used for preparation of other value-added
carrot products like carrot halwa and carrot burfee during
off-seasons. With proper packaging, one can safely keep
the product at room temperature and low storage up to
3 months without significant variation in nutritional and
sensory qualities.
Panse V G; Sukhatme P V. 1989. Statistical methods for
agricultural workers. Publication and Information Division,
ICAR, New Delhi.
Ranganna S. 2002. Handbook of Analysis and Quality
Control for Fruit and Vegetable Products. 2nd Ed., Tata
McGraw Hill Pub. Co. Ltd., New Delhi, India.
REFERENCES
AOAC. 2005. Official Methods of Analysis, 18
Ed., Association of Official Analytical Chemists,
Gaithersburg.
Sagar V R; Khurdiya D S; Balakrishnan K A. 1998.
Effect of storage temperature and period on quality of
dehydrated ripe mango slices. J. Food Sci. Technol., 35
(2), 17-150.
Dev R; Subanna V C; Ahlawat O P; Gupta Huddar A G.
2006. Effect of pre treatment in the quality characteristics
of dehydrated onion rings during storage. J. Food Sci.
Technol., 43(6), 571-574.
Suvarnkuta P; Devahastin S; Majumdar A S. 2005.
Drying kinetics and b- carotene degradation in carrot
undergoing different drying process. J. Food Sci., 70,
520-526.
Jayaraman K S; Dasgupta D K; Babu Rao N. 1991.
Quality characteristics of some vegetables dried by direct
and indirect sun drying. Ind. Food Packer, 45, 16-23.
Szezeniak A S. 1983. Physical Properties of Foods: What
They are Their Relation to Other Food Properties. In:
Physical Properties of Foods, (Eds. Pelly M, Bagley EB),
The AVI Publishing Co. Inc, Westport.
th
30
JAE : 52 (1)
A.R. Mhaske, S.M.Taley, Shinde, R.N. Katkar
Journal of Agricultural Engineering, Vol. 52 (1): January-March, 2015
Spatial Assessment of Wastewater Quality
of Nag River for Irrigation
A.R. Mhaske 1, S.M.Taley2, Shinde3 and R.N. Katkar4
Manuscript received: June, 2014
Revised manuscript accepted: January, 2015
ABSTRACT
Rapid industrialization and overpopulation have stimulated increase in both domestic and industrial wastewater.
Due to lack of efficient sewerage system and absence of treatment plants, the wastewater is discharged into drainage
systems causing environmental and health implications. At various points, the wastewater of these drains is used
for irrigation purposes. A study conducted at Nagpur during 2012-13 characterizes the effluent of major drains
of Nagpur city and assess its suitability for irrigation. Temporal and spatial wastewater samples were collected
from drains in rainy, winter and summer seasons during morning, afternoon; and evening and analysed for various
parameters of special concern to irrigation. TSS, TDS, BOD, COD, N, P, EC, pH, micronutrient like Zn, Mn, Cu,
Fe and heavy metals Co, Cd ,Cr and Pb varied in concentration at different locations at different time and seasons
when compared with BIS and FAO guidelines for irrigation. Regular monitoring and proper treatment of wastewater
before discharging into the drains can reduce the pollution in these drains. As the sewage water contains pollutants
at higher levels, its direct use for irrigation and other purpose should be restricted.
Key words: Industrialization, wastewater quality, drains, irrigation, rainy, winter and summer season, BIS guidelines
India is the second most populous country of the world with
current population of approximately1210 million according
to survey of 2011, and will reach 1530 million by 2030 at the
existing growth rate (Population census organization, 2011).
Due to water scarcity issues, untreated effluents from the
cities are being used for irrigation purposes in many parts
of the country, including Nagpur in Maharashtra, having
the consistency reported by Naeem (2009). Consequently,
urban and peri-urban farmers use marginal or untreated
wastewater to cultivate a variety of crops (Ensink et al.,
2008). Strauss and Blumenthal (1990) estimated that
73,000 ha in India were irrigated with wastewater. Surely,
the typology used to obtain this estimate must have been
different from the one used for China, where Mara and
Cairncross (1989) estimated 1.3 million ha were irrigated
with wastewater.
of Pakistan and India. The results showed high values of
biochemical oxygen demand (BOD), total organic carbon
(TOC), chemical oxygen demand (COD), and trace metals
in the samples taken from the Indo-Pak border. The change
in physico-chemical properties of the soil is the chronic
impact of the usage of wastewater for irrigation, eventually
increasing the amount of heavy metals in the soil. Sharma
et al. (2007) and Sahu et al. (2007) reported that longterm use of wastewater of drains can lead to accumulation
of high amounts of trace elements in soils, and can enter
the food chain through absorption via plants. Cd can be
easily absorbed and accumulated in plants and animals in
very high quantities. Cd level was high at all sites in those
plants which were receiving wastewater for irrigation as
compared to plants getting tube well irrigation. Similarly,
Beta vulgaris (palak) had been highly contaminated with
Cd, Pb and Ni due to wastewater irrigation in suburban
areas of Varanasi, causing serious health risks for the human
beings (Tariq et al.,2006 ).
Originally, the purposes of these drains were to collect
the flood water and agricultural excess water. But due
to increase in population and rapid industrialization of
Nagpur, the drains are now mainly used to collect the
municipal effluents of diverse composition resulting in
increasing pollution in the irrigation outlets (Hamid et al.,
2013; WWF, 2007). Afzal et al. (2000) conducted a study
to investigate the degree of pollution in the Hudiara drain,
caused by disposal of untreated sewage and industrial waste
A strong correlation was found between Giardia infections
in those households who were using wastewater farming
as compared to the ones using regular irrigation water.
Cattle grazing on freshly irrigated grasslands with untreated
wastewater reportedly suffered from disease (cysticerosis)
in Melbourne, Australia and Denmark (Pay et al., 2010). An
1
Department of Agricultural Engineering, Agricultural College under Dr. Panjabrao Deshmukh Krishi Vidyapeeth (Agricultural University), Nagpur-444104
(M.S.) India (Corresponding author email: mhaskear@gmail.com); 2,3,4Dr. Panjabrao Deshmukh Krishi Vidyapeeth, Akola -444104 (M.S.), India.
31
January-March, 2015
Spatial Assessment of Wastewater Quality of Nag River for Irrigation
extensive and seasonal study was carried out by Akhtar and
Mohammad (2012) on the effluent quality of six drains of
Lahore and their impact on the aquatic life of river Ravi, into
which these drains were discharging their effluents. They
reported that Ravi river water quality was not by any means
suitable for the propagation of fish during dry weather and
canal closure period.The present study was conducted to
characterize the physical and chemical characteristics of
effluents in the Nag river of Nagpur city (Maharashtra) in
order to determine suitability of its water for irrigation of
agricultural crops.
2. Canal road near “Dande Hospital”, collecting domestic
sewage water from left portion of the city and addition
of pollutant load from medicines and other materials
used in the hospital including the sewage of the patient
which is considered to be a separate source of pollution
load.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Similar sites were selected by Akhtar and Mohammad
(2012). Fig. 1 shows the locations of study area.
3. Third site near the “Road Transport Ofice”which
collectsdomestic sewage water from right portion of
the Nag river.
4. Fourth site at the Inlet of the sewage treatment plant.
Selection of Study Area
Sampling Procedure
Originally, the Nag river was to collect the flood water
and agricultural excess water. A dam was later constructed
across the river, and upstream water was arrested in the
dam. Normally the drains are now mainly used to collect
the municipal effluents of diverse composition throughout
the year resulting in increasing pollution in the irrigation
outlets. Only during overflow of waste weir, this water
flows in the river.
The study was carried out during the period June, 2012
to May, 2013. During this period, sewage water samples
were collected spatially from the mentioned point sources.
Sewage influent samples were collected in each month of
the period on a fixed day in morning at 6 A.M, in noon 12
P.M and evening at 6 P.M. A total of 144 samples were
collected from the all point sources throughout one year.
Sampling bottles were soaked overnight in diluted
hydrochloric acid before use, and rinsed two times with
sample to be collected before filling. Small quantity of
Touelen was added as preservative in each sample. The
sample bottles were labelled carefully as per the locations
and time. Separate samples were taken and preserved
at 40C during transportation to the laboratory, and were
immediately analysed for BOD, COD, turbidity, pH and
faecal coli forms.
Four major sampling sites of Nagpur city were selected for
the present study and the samples were collected from each
site. The sampling sites were as follows.
1. One kilometre upstream from the sewage treatment
plant where two tributaries (left and right) joins and
is near to “Bhole petrol pump” to access the pollutant
load from the petrol pump, particularly heavy metals.
Fig.1: Map showing the location of the sampling sites
32
JAE : 52 (1)
A.R. Mhaske, S.M.Taley, Shinde, R.N. Katkar
Table 1. Instruments/procedures used for the analysis of efluents of the drains
Sl.No.
Parameter
Instrument / Procedure
Reference
1.
pH
Potentiometric method
APHA (1985)
2.
Electrical conductivity
Conductrometric method
APHA (1985)
3.
Biological oxygen demand
Winkler titration method
APHA (1985)
4.
Chemical oxygen demand
Reflux method
APHA (1985)
5.
Total dissolved solids
Gravimetric method
APHA (1985)
6.
Total suspended solids
Gravimetric method
APHA (1985)
7.
Nitrogen
Alkaline distillation
APHA (1985)
8.
Turbidity
Nephelometric method
APHA (1985)
9.
Colour
Visual comparison method
APHA (1985)
10.
Odour
Smell observation
------------
11.
Sulphate
Trimetric method
APHA (1985)
12.
Phosphate
Vanadomolybdate phosphoric acid (colorimetric)method
APHA (1985).
13.
Micronutrient and heavy metal
Atomic absorption spectrophotometric method
Page et al.(1982)
Analytical Methods
All analyses were carried out as per standard methods
(APHA, 1985). Each sample of wastewater was tested
for various physico-chemical parameters as reported. The
parameters like total suspended solids, total dissolved solids,
biological oxygen demand, chemical oxygen demand,
nitrogen, phosphorus, faecal coliform, turbidity, pH, EC,
heavy metals (Cd, Co, Cr and Pb) and micronutrients
(Cu, Fe, Mn and Zn) were analysed to test the water quality.
The results were compared with Bureau of Indian standard
specified for irrigation to establish a baseline condition
of pollution level in the Nag river. Table 1 shows the
instruments and procedures used for analyses of physicochemical parameters, micronutrients and heavy metals in
the waste-water.
...(1)
If the weights were not specified, they were assumed to be
1 for all data points. ‘p’ is defined between 0 and 1. p = 0
produces a least-squares straight-line fit to the data, while
p = 1 produces a cubic spline interpolant. If the smoothing
parameter was not specified, it would automatically select
in the “interesting range.” However, Smoothing Splines
were also piecewise polynomials like cubic spline or shapepreserving interpolants and were considered a nonparametric
fit type. The ‘p’ value in this case was near to 1 (e.g.
0.9), indicating a cubic spline interpolant. Therefore, this
technique was found to be suitable to fit the noisy data of
different pollutant concentration in sewage water. Curves
were developed with p=0.9 using Eq. 1. Total dissolved
solids, biological oxygen demand, chemical oxygen demand,
nitrogen and phosphorus were considered as important
parameters for irrigation water, and hence considered
for statistical analysis by applying the spline smoothing
technique as the data had large variability and erratic.
Statistical Analysis
The data of different parameters in seasonal sewage water
was noisy and erratic.Therefore it was very difficult to fit
the data by applying simple models to find out the best
trend equations. Therefore, analysis with nonparametric
fitting was done. Smoothing Splines technique was used
for analysis of noisy and erratic data of pollutant in
sewage water, and graphs were drawn by curve-fitting
tool box of Mat-lab to find the best trend for the seasonal
variation.The smoothing spline"s" was constructed for
specified smoothing parameter "φ " specified weight wi. The
smoothing spline minimises as:
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The focus of the present study was to quantitatively
characterize the pollution load in the Nag river from
the month of June 2012 to May 2013, and to assess the
suitability of drain water for irrigation as it is being
frequently used in irrigation.
33
January-March, 2015
Spatial Assessment of Wastewater Quality of Nag River for Irrigation
Climatic Data
average weekly evaporation for the months of the study
are given in Table 2.
The climatic data on average weekly maximum and
minimum temperature for the month, monthly rainfall and
Table 2. Climatic data of Nagpur station from June 2012 to May 2013
Sl. No.
Month
Rainfall,
C
mm
Av. weekly
evaporation,
mm
Av. weekly min. temp.,
Av. weekly max. temp.,
0
0
C
1.
June, 2012
39.65
28.78
49.7
8.58
2.
July, 2012
32.22
25.22
244.8
4.62
3.
August, 20!2
28.0
23.83
274.4
2.53
4.
September, 2012
31.58
23.90
402
3.0
5.
October, 2012
30.48
22.22
19.6
3.48
6.
November, 2012
29.73
15.20
4.8
2.86
7.
December, 2012
27.9
12.88
0.0
2.52
8.
January, 2013
27.9
12.58
8.1
3.2
9.
February, 2013
30.25
15.2
19.8
3.83
10.
March, 2013
34.85
17.73
7.6
5.3
11.
April, 2013
39.08
23.52
3.6
8.04
12.
May, 2013
44.25
30.65
0.0
11.75
Physico-chemical Properties
The results of the analyses of the physical and chemical parameters that are important for assessing irrigation water quality
are given in Tables 3 to 11.
Table 3. Monthly analysis of TSS, TDS, BOD and COD of wastewater of river Nag
Parameter
TSS ( mg.l-1 )
TDS ( mg.l-1 )
BOD ( mg.l-1 )
COD ( mg.l-1 )
200
2100
100
250
BIS limit
Year
Site
PI.
US.
RTO.
Gokul
PI.
US.
RTO.
Gokul
PI.
US.
RTO.
Gokul
PI.
US.
RTO.
Gokul
June, 2012
33.3
26.00
29.000
33.330
365.70
352.3
288.53
339.30
49.44
51.47
34.930
54.110
119.50
222.5
143.57
214.90
July, 2012
33.3
26.00
29.000
33.330
317.07
339.4
289.53
351.70
22.92
29.13
17.690
29.460
91.670
114.7
68.330
104.33
Aug., 2012
15.3
11.00
15.000
15.330
293.93
289.6
296.23
294.50
81.93
82.03
115.60
131.92
314.33
308.3
443.33
517.00
Sept., 2012
19.0
11.33
16.000
19.000
307.73
314.3
312.60
345.27
94.93
82.93
84.230
91.330
349.00
299.7
306.00
445.33
Oct., 2012
13.0
6.00
15.670
13.00
307.73
314.1
312.67
345.40
24.55
40.92
32.75
114.89
98.00
151.7
119.67
410.33
Nov., 2012
14.0
8.00
14.500
14.00
298.50
326.2
271.03
318.93
29.91
14.44
7.80
20.270
113.67
54.00
29.67
74.670
Dec., 2012
15.3
10.00
15.000
15.33
308.50
323.8
298.17
326.00
49.91
49.71
37.49
72.370
183.67
187.3
141.67
274.67
Jan., 2013
14.6
11.67
13.000
14.67
288.90
306.7
269.13
323.00
47.43
58.57
45.50
63.000
172.67
213.7
158.00
244.67
Feb, 2013
18.6
15.60
16.670
18.67
289.00
306.3
269.00
323.00
54.85
70.08
83.21
66.070
199.67
238.3
200.00
247.00
March, 2013
15.6
15.67
17.000
15.67
325.53
312.7
279.00
324.83
76.01
78.70
67.67
65.030
271.67
286.0
241.67
232.33
April, 2013
22.6
26.67
21.330
22.67
347.37
348.4
298.00
346.33
88.81
89.22
74.77
79.470
308.33
305.7
260.00
267.33
May, 2013
34.1
31.19
34.960
34.12
359.63
359.3
317.13
406.07
25.67
24.33
95.00
20.670
100.08
111.0
424.33
77.330
Average
20.7
16.60
19.76
20.76
317.47
324.4
291.75
337.02
56.42
58.83
54.694
71.629
193.52
207.7
211.35
259.15
Note: PI – Plant inlet, US - Upstream, RTO - Road transport ofice, Gokul - Gokulpeth
34
JAE : 52 (1)
A.R. Mhaske, S.M.Taley, Shinde, R.N. Katkar
Table 4. Monthly analysis of N, P, turbidity, pH and EC of wastewater of river Nag
Parameter
N (mg.l-1)
P ( mg.l-1)
45
10
BIS limit
Month
Site
pH
EC (dS.m-1)
6.0-8.5
0.75 -2.25
Tubidity ( NTU)
PI
US
RTO
Gokul
PI
US
RTO
Gokul
PI
US
RTO
Gokul
PI
US
RTO
Gokul
PI
US
RTO.
Gokul
June
1.47
1.43
1.87
1.43
0.73
0.57
0.570
0.53
26.03
15.83
8.130
18.00
6.27
6.93
6.88
7.04
0.60
0.61
0.56
0.61
July
1.03
1.57
2.00
1.87
0.63
0.60
0.570
0.60
26.03
15.83
8.130
18.00
7.40
7.33
7.37
7.17
0.24
0.25
0.22
0.26
Aug
1.90
2.87
3.43
2.83
0.43
0.83
1.130
0.97
34.00
29.67
65.67
30.00
6.97
7.10
7.37
7.20
0.22
0.22
0.22
0.22
Sept
2.13
3.03
3.07
2.83
0.53
0.97
1.330
1.00
32.00
17.33
21.67
20.67
7.17
7.30
7.37
7.20
0.23
0.24
0.31
0.26
Oct
2.43
3.27
2.90
2.90
0.57
1.10
1.47
1.00
7.33
9.67
3.33
16.33
7.17
7.17
7.10
7.20
0.23
0.24
0.31
0.26
Nov
3.23
3.73
2.60
3.10
0.63
1.00
1.87
0.97
8.33
4.33
2.67
5.00
7.30
7.07
7.00
6.97
0.44
0.51
0.48
0.52
Dec
3.33
4.07
2.77
3.03
0.73
1.20
1.77
0.93
21.33
13.00
13.00
18.33
7.30
7.07
6.93
7.03
0.52
0.53
0.51
0.53
Jan
2.20
3.00
2.10
2.57
0.43
0.50
0.17
0.27
19.67
13.33
17.00
19.33
7.20
7.13
7.13
7.00
0.59
0.61
0.55
0.64
Feb
1.97
2.40
1.90
2.10
0.57
0.47
0.37
0.37
25.00
17.33
22.33
20.67
7.20
7.13
7.10
7.13
0.63
0.60
0.56
0.63
March
2.00
1.93
1.87
1.90
0.60
0.47
0.40
0.40
18.00
19.67
23.33
19.67
7.30
7.37
7.17
7.33
0.60
0.62
0.57
0.64
April
2.07
2.43
1.83
1.93
0.56
0.50
0.40
0.33
18.67
18.33
17.00
21.00
7.27
7.37
7.27
7.30
0.71
0.72
0.60
0.75
May
1.93
1.40
1.80
1.70
0.77
0.57
0.60
0.40
20.96
11.37
6.81
13.03
7.10
7.00
6.97
7.10
0.72
0.72
0.61
0.80
2.607
2.345
2.349
0.583
0.746
0.914
21.4
15.4
18.3
7.140
7.264
7.138
7.141
0.48
0.49
0.46
0.51
2.14
Ave
0.67
17.4
Note: PI – Plant inlet, US- Upstream, RTO- Road transport ofice, Gokul - Gokulpeth
concentration at different locations. Concentration of TDS
was observed more at Gokulpeth, followed by upstream,
plant Inlet and RTO sites. The higher values of concentration
of TDS at Gokulpeth as compared to other sites might be
because of mixing of milk industry water with domestic
sewage water, and it is further diluted at Upstream and Plant
Inlet with addition of domestic sewage water. At RTO site,
only domestic sewage water is discharged, hence lowest
TDS concentration.
Total Dissolved Solids (TDS)
TDS plays an important role in plant growth, crop yield and
quality of product (SFWF, 2002). As depicted in Fig.2, it
is observed that all the point sources having higher values
of TDS at Gokulpeth in the month May was up to 400
mg.l-1, might be due to high evaporation with increasing
the ambient temperature. TDS was lower in the month
of January due to low ambient temperature. Addition of
city storm runoff did not show significant effect on TDS
TDS
400
Upstream
380
Plant Inlet
RT O
Gokulpeth
340
320
1
mg l-1
360
300
280
July
September
November
January
March
Months
Month
Fig.2: Trend of monthly TDS in sewage water at different locations
35
May
January-March, 2015
Spatial Assessment of Wastewater Quality of Nag River for Irrigation
The regression coefficient (R2) was found to be highest at
Plant Inlet (0.9764) with minimum RMSE (6.566), Table 5.
Low values of the RMSE and high values of the regression
coefficient showed that the most of the data at different point
sources was explained by best fitted curve.
of organic matter through the city storm runoff. From the
month of September, COD started decreasing up to about
100 mg.l-1at the Plant Inlet site till the month of November.
From the month of November, slight increase in COD was
observed till the month of May due to increase in ambient
temperature. The overall pattern of spatial trend of COD
at different sites were similar, with Gokulpeth site having
higher COD, followed by RTO, Upstream and Plant Inlet
sites. Higher concentration of COD at Gokulpeth might be
due to mixing of milk industry water and the drain carrying
discharge was of closed type, and sewage water was not
coming in contact with soil and natural vegetation grown
along the open drain. COD concentration was a restriction
on the use of the raw sewage water for irrigation.
Table 5. Statistical parameters for TDS in sewage water
R2
Sl. No.
Location
p value
RMSE
1
Plant Inlet
0.9
0.9764**
6.566
2
Upstream
0.9
0.9482**
7.325
3
R. T. O.
0.9
0.854**
10.83
4
Gokulpeth
0.9
0.8987**
13.32
** Signiicant at 1% level of signiicance
In case of COD, highest R2 was observed for Upstreamsite,
followed by RTO, Plant inlet and Gokulpeth sites,
respectively, suggesting that there was good fitting of
the curve and explained the data variation sufficiently,
Table 6. Higher values of RMSE suggested more error for
smoothing fit.
Chemical Oxygen Demand (COD)
From Fig. 3, the spatial trend of COD in sewage water
was observed to be increasing from the month of June to
September. Maximum value of COD was about 500 mg.l-1at
Gokulpeth site during the month of August. Higher COD
concentration was thus in the rainy season due to addition
500
COD
Plant Inlet
Upstream
450
RTO
400
Gokulpeth
mg
l-1
mg L
350
300
250
200
150
100
July
September
November
January
May
March
Month
Fig. 3: Spatial trend of monthly COD in sewage water
Table 6. Statistical parameters for COD in sewage water
Sl. No.
Location
p-value
R2
RMSE
1
Plant Inlet
0.9
0.8972**
43.53
2
Upstream
0.9
0.9254**
27.21
3
R. T. O.
0.9
0.9172**
43.38
4
Gokulpeth
0.9
0.8539**
66.45
** Signiicant at 1% level of signiicance
36
JAE : 52 (1)
A.R. Mhaske, S.M.Taley, Shinde, R.N. Katkar
130
BOD
Plant Inlet
110
Upstream
100
RT
-1
mg
mglL
120
Gokulpeth
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
July
September
November
January
March
May
Months
Month
Fig.4: Spatial trend of monthly BOD in sewage water
Biological Oxygen Demand (BOD)
The spatial trend of BOD in sewage water was observed
to increase from the month of June till September,
Fig. 4. Highest BOD (120 mg.l-1) in sewage water was
at Gokulpeth site in the month of August. Higher BOD
in the rainy season might be for the same reason as in
the case of COD. Between September and November,
BOD showed decreasing trend, with BOD of 25 mg.l-1 at
RTO site. BOD started increasing from November till the
month of May, due to increasing ambient temperature
(Nashikkar et al., 1998). The overall trend of BOD
variation was similar at all sites; with higher concentration
at Gokulpeth site, followed by Upstream, Plant inlet and
RTO sites. The reason for higher concentration of BOD
at Gokulpeth site is as explained in case of COD. BOD
thus was a restriction on the use of the raw sewage water
for irrigation.
p value
R2
RMSE
1.
Plant Inlet
0.9
0.8772**
13.41
2.
Upstream
0.9
0.9372**
7.70
0.9
0.8923**
14.3
4.
Gokulpeth
0.9
0.7025**
24.87
Ammoniacal Nitrogen (N)
The spatial trend of monthly N content showed an
increasing trend between the month of June and October,
and a reverse trend from the month of November till
May, Fig. 5. The increasing trend of ammoniacal nitrogen
content might be due to the addition of soil residues from
the agricultural catchment areas by storm runoffs. Higher
N concentration during the winter season might be due
to lower ambient temperature, allowing preservation
of ammoniacal N in sewage water. Highest N content
(3.2 mg.l-1) was observed in the upstream site in the
month of October. Decrease in N concentration from the
month of December might be due to increase in ambient
temperature till May causing the release of ammonia gas
from the sewage water. N concentration was higher at the
upstream site, followed by Gokulpeth, RTO and Plant
Inlet sites. Higher concentration at Upstream site might
to be due accelerated nitrification process as compared
to other sites. Statistical data suggested that most of the
data variation was explained with good fitting of the
curve for N concentration (Table 8).
Table 7. Statistical parameters for BOD in sewage water
Location
R. T. O.
** Signiicant at 1% level of signiicance
Statistical values of regression coefficients of the trends are
given in Table 7. Higher values of RMSE suggested that
more error has been taken to filter data of BOD for fitting
of the curve.
Sl. No.
3.
37
January-March, 2015
Spatial Assessment of Wastewater Quality of Nag River for Irrigation
N
3.2
Plant Inlet
3
Upstream
2.8
RTO
2.6
Gokulpeth
mgmgl-1L
2.4
2.2
2
1.8
1.6
1.4
1.2
September
July
November
January
March
May
Month
Fig.5: Spatial trend of monthly N content in sewage water
Table 8. Statistical parameters for N in sewage water
Sl. No.
Location
P value
R2
RMSE
1
Plant Inlet
0.9
0.9218**
0.169
2
Upstream
0.9
0.9255**
0.263
3
R. T. O.
0.9
0.9732**
0.118
4
Gokulpeth
0.9
0.9581**
0.157
** Signiicant at 1% level of signiicance
P
1.8
Plant Inlet
Upstream
1.6
RTO
1.4
Gokulpeth
mg
l-1
mg L .
1.2
1
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
July
September
November
Months
January
Month
Fig. 6: Monthly spatial trend of P in sewage water
38
March
May
JAE : 52 (1)
A.R. Mhaske, S.M.Taley, Shinde, R.N. Katkar
Table 9. Statistical parameters for P in sewage water
Sl. No.
Location
p value
R2
RMSE
1.
Plant Inlet
0.9
0.8165**
0.076
2.
Upstream
0.9
0.9226**
0.123
3.
R. T. O.
0.9
0.9309**
0.255
4.
Gokulpeth
0.9
0.9470**
0.113
** Signiicant at 1% level of signiicance
followed by Plant Inlet, RTO and Upstream sites (Table
3). No significant difference of TSS was observed in the
spatial trend.
Phosphorus (P)
Fig. 6 revealed that monthly spatial trend of monthly
phosphate load was found to be increasing during the month
of July and December, while a reverse trend was visible
between December and January, and subsequently remained
constant up to the month of May. The initial increasing
trend might be due to addition of storm runoffs from the
agricultural farms adjoining to the Nag river. Decreasing
trend of P load from the month of December to February
might be due to precipitation of PO4++ ions with Ca++ because
of increase of concentration of sewage. The concentration of
P was observed to be higher at RTO (1.8 mg.l-1), followed
by Upstream, Gokulpeth and plant inlet sites. Statistical
results (Table 9) indicted that highest regression coefficient
of 0.9470 with low values of RMSE for all point sources,
were sufficiently expressed with good fits.
Electrical Conductivity (EC)
Electrical conductivity of water is governed by the presence
of salt.It indicates the soluble salt concentration in water
as given by SFWE (2002). Low EC values were observed
during the rainy season because of dilution of sewage water
by addition of city storm runoffs. EC increased linearly
from October to May, which might be due to increased
concentration of salt due to decrease in flow rate and
increase in ambient temperature. There was no significant
change in the spatial trend of the EC. The mean value of EC
was found to be higher at Gokulpeth, followed by Upstream,
Plant Inlet and RTO sites.
pH
Turbidity
It is an indicator of acidity or alkalinity of water. Irrigation
water should have pH between 6.5 and 8.4. pH at all point
sources ranged between 6.8 to 7.4, and within acceptable
range. pH values showed increasing trend between the
month of July and September (rainy season) might be due
to addition of rain water, which is slightly alkaline in nature.
Further slight increase in pH was observed between October
and April, possibly due to increasing use of detergent in
surrounding habitats as also increase in ambient temperature
causing evaporation of sewage. pH was found to be higher
in the Upstream, followed by Gokulpeth, Plant Inlet and
RTO sites.
Turbidity increased during rainy season (July to September)
due to addition of storm water runoffs from the catchment
areas. Lowest turbidity was observed during OctoberNovember due to non-addition of the city storm runoff
and low ambient temperature. Between November and
April, it constantly increased due to decrease of flow rate
and increase in the temperature. Erratic peak observed at
RTO source point might be due to city storm runoff during
sampling. The mean value of turbidity was found to be
higher at Plant Inlet, followed by Gokulpeth, RTO and
Upstream sites.
Total Soluble Solids (TSS)
Seasonal concentration of micronutrients like Zn, Fe and
Cu in domestic sewage water is mainly due to rusting of
metals, plumbing, wood preservatives, roof runoff, cosmetic
material, construction material, fungicide etc. as given by
Ibrahim and Salaman (1992).The analysis of Zn, Fe and Cu
in seasonal trend of sewage water showed (Table 10-12)
concentration well below the standard limits given by BIS.
However, Mn was found to be in higher concentration than
the safe limit, which can cause health hazards if the sewage
water is used for irrigation. Main sources of Mn were oil
Micronutrients
-1
TSS values were higher (up to 35 mg.l ) in the months
of May and June. TSS concentration was lowest in the
month of October, and intermediate concentration between
March and April. The pattern of concentration was likely
governed by the ambient temperature. Because of higher
temperature in the months of May and June, the evaporation
rate was very high, thereby increasing the concentration
of the suspended solids in the sewage water. The mean
value of TSS in sewage water was higher at Gokulpeth,
39
January-March, 2015
Spatial Assessment of Wastewater Quality of Nag River for Irrigation
Table 10. Spatial trend of monthly average concentration of micronutrients and heavy metals in the Nag river sewage
water in rainy ((June-Sept) season
Sl. No.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
Parameter
Unit
Safe limit
Location
Plant Inlet
Up Stream
RTO ofice
Gokulpeth
Gokul
Zn
Mg.l-1
2.00
0.207
0.128
0.093
0.103
Fe
-1
5.00
0.240
0.213
0.221
0.204
-1
0.20
0.032
0.013
0.016
0.025
-1
0.20
0.275
0.155
0.368
0.367
-1
0.05
0.009
0.006
0.006
0.013
-1
0.01
-1
Cu
Mn
Co
Cd
Mg.l
Mg.l
Mg.l
Mg.l
Mg.l
0.019
0.023
0.019
0.028
7.
Cr
Mg.l
0.10
0.015
0.007
0.011
0.016
8.
Pb
Mg.l-1
5.2
0.046
0.043
0.043
0.044
Table 11. Spatial trend ofmonthly average concentration of micronutrients and heavy metals in the Nag river sewage
water in winter (Oct– Jan) season
Sl. No.
1.
2.
3.
Parameter
Unit
Safe limit
Location
Plant Inlet
Up Stream
RTO ofice
Gokulpeth
Zn
Mg.l-1
2.0
0.136
0.108
0.119
0.117
Fe
-1
5.0
0.145
0.123
0.099
0.104
-1
0.2
-1
Cu
Mg.l
Mg.l
0.015
0.012
0.010
0.010
4.
Mn
Mg.l
0.2
0.149
0.129
0.120
0.116
5.
Co
Mg.l-1
0.05
0.0199
0.013
0.014
0.020
Cd
-1
0.01
0.006
0.006
0.006
0.005
-1
6.
Mg.l
7.
Cr
Mg.l
0.1
0.005
0.006
0.006
0.006
8.
Pb
Mg.l-1
5.20
0.053
0.047
0.042
0.043
Table 12. Spatial trend of monthly average concentration of micronutrients and heavy metals in the Nag river sewage
water in summer (February-May)season
Sl. No.
1.
2.
3.
Parameter
Unit
Safe limit
Location
Plant Inlet
Up Stream
RTO ofice
Gokulpeth
Gokul
Zn
Mg.l-1
2.0
0.156
0.117
0.120
0.112
Fe
-1
5.0
0.077
0.067
0.066
0.080
-1
0.2
0.020
0.019
0.016
0.019
-1
Cu
Mg.l
Mg.l
4.
Mn
Mg.l
0.2
0.224
0.222
0.204
0.216
5.
Co
Mg.l-1
0.05
0.005
0.007
0.006
0.005
Cd
-1
0.01
-1
6.
Mg.l
0.005
0.007
0.008
0.006
7.
Cr
Mg.l
0.1
0.005
0.006
0.007
0.006
8.
Pb
Mg.l-1
5.2
0.045
0.035
0.041
0.046
40
JAE : 52 (1)
A.R. Mhaske, S.M.Taley, Shinde, R.N. Katkar
REFERENCES
and lubricants. The results thus indicated that presence of
higher concentration of Mn would be a restriction on the
use of raw water for irrigation.
Afzal S; Ahmad I; Younas M; Zahid M D; Atique K M
H; Ijaz A; Ali K. 2000. Study of water quality of Hudiara
Drain, India-Pakistan. Environ. Int., 26(1-2), 87-96.
doi:10.1016/S0160-4120(00)00086-6
Similarly, Table 10-12 indicated that the concentration
of heavy metal like Cd generated through rechargeable
batteries, storm water, pesticides, gardening products was
higher than the safe limit, and a restriction on the use of raw
water. This may cause harmful effect on the vegetables and
crops grown by utilizing this water for irrigation without
secondary treatment (Ibrahim and Salamon, 1992; Kahlown
et al., 2006). However, Co generated through medicine,
food products, ointments, paints and pigments was within
permissible limit, and did not pose any restriction on direct
use of the raw water.
Akhtar S; Mohammad N. 2012. Impact of water quality
on aquatic life in river Ravi. Pakistan J. Nature Environ.
Pollution Tech., 11(2), 219-224.
APHA. 1985. APHA (American Public Health Association),
Standard methods for the examination of water and
wastewater, 19th ed., Washington, DC.
Ensink J H J; Van der Hoek W; Simmons Robert W.
2008. Livelihoods From Wastewater: Water Reuse in
Faisalabad, Pakistan. IWA Publishing, London, pp. 387400.
Heavy metals like Cr generated through phosphate
fertilizers and metallurgic industries cause atmospheric
deposition. It is also released by tanning, ink manufacture,
metal plating, dyes, wood preserving, textile and ceramic
industries (Thornton et al., 2006). The sources of Pb in
the river water are cleaning products, fire extinguisher,
lubricants, health supplement, oil and lubricant, paints
and pigments, photo graphics, pesticides and gardening
products, etc. Their concentrations were within limits.
Hamid Almas; Zeb M; Mehmood A; Akthar S; Saim
S. 2013. Assessment of Wastewater Quality of Drains for
Irrigation. J. Environ. Protection, 4, 937-945.
Ibrahim M; Salamon S. 1992. Chemical composition
of Faisalabad city sewage efluent: II Irrigation Quality.J.
Agric. Res., (30), 391-340.
Kahlown A M; Ashraf M; Hussain M; Salam A H; Bhatti
Z A. 2006.Impact assessment of sewerage and industrial
efluents on water resources, soil, crops and human health
in Faisalabad. Pakistan Council of Research in Water
Resources, Lahore, pp: 1-105.
Fecal colli presence in the river water was found to be more
than 1100 coliform per 100 ml of water in all samples.
With FAO recommendation of 100 coliform per 100 ml of
water for safe irrigation, the present concentration in the
river water does not permit its use for irrigation purposes.
Mara D; Cairncross S. 1989. Guidelines for safe use of
wastewater and excreta in agriculture and aquaculture.
W.H.O, pp:205.
CONCLUSIONS
Naeem E. 2009. An investigation of the characteristics of
efluent mixing in stream. University of Engineering and
Technology, Taxila, pp: 144-146.
The Nag river flowing through Nagpur city was originally
used as storm water drain. But due to increase in urban
population and rapid industrialization in the city, the drains
are now mainly used to collect the industrial and municipal
effluents of diverse nature. The characterization of the waste
water of these drains showed that the concentrations of
some parameters were higher than the prescribed limits by
BIS and FAO for irrigation. These results provide strong
evidence that the raw sewage water of these drains was
not suitable for irrigation and other domestic purposes. An
urgent need exists for treating the domestic and industrial
waste water before discharging into these drains so that
pollution load can be minimised and the water can be safely
used for beneficial purposes.
Nashikkar V J; Shende G B. 1998. Effect of long term
varying levels of BOD of irrigation waters on crops. Resour.
Conserv. Recycling, 1,131-136.
Page A L; Miller R H; Keemey D R. 1982. Methods of Soil
Analysis. 2nd Edn., Amer. Soc. Agron., Madison, WI., USA.
Pay D; Christopher A S; Raschid S L; Mark R; Akiça
B.2010. Wastewater irrigation and health: Assessing and
mitigating risk in low-income countries. In: Non-Pathogenic
Trade-Offs of Wastewater Irrigation, Earths-can, London,
pp: 101-126.
41
January-March, 2015
Spatial Assessment of Wastewater Quality of Nag River for Irrigation
Sahu K R; Katiyar S; Tiwari J; Kisku C G. 2007.
Assessment of drain water receiving efluent from tanneries
and its impact on soil and plants with particular emphasis
on bioaccumulation of heavy metals. J. Environ. Bio., 28
(3), 685- 690.
Reference Centre for Waste Disposal, Duebendorf,
Germany.
Tariq M; Ali M; Shah Z. 2006. Characteristics of
industrial efluents and their possible impacts on quality of
underground water. Soil Environ., 25(1), 64-69.
SFWF. 2002. TDS and pH. Organization of Safe Drinking
Water, Canada, pp: 1-6.
Thornton I; Butler D; Docx P; Hession M; Makro-poulos
C; McMullen M; Nieuwenhuijsen M; Pitman A; Rautiu
R; Sawyer R; Smith S; White D. 2006.Pollutants in urban
wastewater and sewage sludge. Final Report, European
Union, London, pp: 1-244.
Sharma K R; Agrawal M; Marshall F. 2007.Heavy metal
contamination of soil and vegetables in suburban areas of
Varanasi, India. Ecotoxicology Environ. Safety, 66(2), 258266. doi:10.1016/j.ecoenv.2005.11.007
WWF. 2007. Pakistan’s waters at risk: Water & Health
Related Issues in Pakistan & Key Recommendations: A
Special Report. WWF, Lahore, pp: 1-25.
Strauss M; Blumenthal U. 1990. Human Waste Use in
Agriculture and Aquaculture: Utilization Practice and
Health Perspectives. IRCWD Report 09/90, International
42
JAE : 52 (1)
Shishir Kumar Verma, A. K. A Lawrence, A. K. Tripathi and K. K. Patel
Journal of Agricultural Engineering, Vol. 52 (1): January-March, 2015
Assessment of Biofuel Blends Using Diesel-Biodiesel and Alcohol
Shishir Kumar Verma1, A. K. A Lawrence1, A. K. Tripathi1 and K. K. Patel2
Manuscript received: April, 2013
Revised manuscript accepted: February,, 2015
ABSTRACT
The main characteristics fuel properties of diesel, jatropha curcus oil and fuel prepared from blends of diesel- jatropha
curcus oil and diesel-jatropha curcus oil-ethanol in various proportions were studied. The relative density, API
gravity, kinematic viscosity, gross heat of combustion, cloud and pour point, flash and fire point, carbon residue, ash
content and total acid values were recorded and compared with diesel to study their compatibility as compression
ignition engine fuel. The characteristic fuel property of jatropha curcus-diesel in 90:10 proportion was found to be
close to that of diesel. The fuel properties of diesel – ethanol blends in 75:25 proportion was also found to be close
to that of diesel. However, the other fuels obtained from blending jatropha curcus-diesel as well as from jatropha
curcus-diesel-ethanol in various proportions deviated from diesel when higher proportions of jatropha curcus oil
were blended with diesel.
Key word : Jatropha surcus, diesel, ethanol, Fuel, Fuel properties
exhaust emissions have necessitated the substitution
of fossil fuels with less polluting and easily available
renewable fuels for use in IC engines. Keeping these facts
in view, researchers and environmentalists are working
in coordination to conserve fossil fuels and explore
renewable or bio-energy resources. Several alternative
fuels such as biodiesel, ethanol, methanol, hydrogen, CNG,
LNG, producer gas, biogas, vegetable oils etc. are being
explored around the globe to supplement fuels and reduce
environmental pollution. Hydrogen, CNG, LNG and LPG
have met with limited success owing to considerable
technological glitches and logistic bottlenecks. Renewable
alternative liquid fuels (such as biodiesel) are inding
prominent place in search for alternative energy sources.
Since biodiesel is a biodegradable, sustainable and clean
energy source (Atadashi et al., 2011) deined as the
mono-alkyl esters of vegetable oils or animal fats, it is
an alternative to diesel fuel that is being accepted in a
steadily growing number of countries around the world
(Knothe, 2005; Reddy, 2013). Global demand for biodiesel
production may rise by 2 MMT to 2.1 MMT, or about 8%,
to 29.1 MMT in 2014 as per the Hamburg-based oilseed
industry researcher (Ruitenberg, 2014).
The large demand (about 78-80%) of import of petroleum
products has been a major factor of decelerated rate of
economic development of India (Anon, 2015). The current
domestic production of crude oil is around 32-34 MMT per
year, whereas the estimated demand of petroleum products
during 2016-17 would be 186.2 MMT (IANS, New
Delhi, 2013). This clearly indicates the burden of import
and outflow of foreign exchange for petroleum products
(De Gorter et al., 2013). The consumption of commercial
energy sources such as coal, oil, gas etc. is doubling
every ten years in most of the developing countries. The
development path of any society depends on the availability
of energy sources and the further growth of energy and
emission trajectories. It would also be greatly influenced by
technological development, economic cooperation between
countries, and global cooperation in limiting greenhouse
gas emission. Climate change is basically rooted in this
core aspect of economic development process. India is the
world’s sixth largest and second fastest growing producer
of greenhouse gases (Pandey, 2006). In coming years, not
only India but also the world will face great challenges of
energy crisis, food shortage and environmental pollution
due to growing population, expanding urbanization and
rapid industrialization.
Bio-fuels like ethanol and bio-diesel are environmentfriendly, and help us to conform to the strict emission
norms. Among alcohols, ethanol has been recognized as
the most prospective alcohol fuel. In addition to ethanol,
methanol has also been used as alternate fuel, but ethanol
Energy consumption is an indication of the vibrancy of
economy with oil and gas playing a key role in every
production sector. Limited stock of fossil fuel causing
rising prices of petroleum fuels and stiff regulations on
1
Department of Farm Machinery and Power Engineering, Sam Higginbottom Institute of Agriculture, Technology & Sciences (Formerly
Allahabad Agricultural Institute), Allahabad; 2 Department of Post Harvest Engineering and Technology, Aligarh Muslim University,
Aligarh-202002, e mail address: k_krishna_374@yahoo.co.in
43
January-March, 2015
Assessment of Biofuel Blends Using Diesel-Biodiesel and Alcohol
is more popular as it is a biologically renewable resource,
easily produced by fermentation, non-corrosive, non-toxic,
has higher heat of combustion, less volatility and provides
better water tolerance than methanol. It has also a proven
track record as an automobile fuel and is used as octane
enhancer and oxygenate. India being an agricultural country
has potential of ethanol production of 2512 ML mainly from
sugarcane molasses during sugar session 2012-13 (Jha et
al., 2012). The Government of India in October of 2007 had
set a 20% ethanol blend target for gasoline fuel to be met
by 2017 to increase its energy security and independence.
However, India had already blended ethanol to the tune of
30 crore litres till April, 2011 out of the 71 crore litres of
the required target till 31st October 2011 (Desai, 2015).
Currently, India has only 5-6 pilot plants (capacity 10,000
to 250,000 MT per year with the installed capacity to
produce 115-130 ML) operating in the country producing
biodiesel (Agro Chart, 2014), and it is estimated that India
will be able to produce 550 ML of ethanol in calendar year
2014, indicating that ethanol would make up about 2.1%
of India’s fuel market.
methyl transesterification process parameters of neem oil
and characterization of its fuel properties.
Jatropha curcus curcas L. (Ratanjot) hitherto considered
as a wild oilseed plant of the tropics is now being credited
as a most promising bio-fuel crop. Jatropha curcus oil is
odourless and colourless when fresh, but becomes yellow on
standing. Jatropha curcus oil has high viscosity compared to
diesel. The high viscosity of Jatropha curcus curcas oil may
contribute to the formation of carbon deposits in engines,
incomplete fuel combustion and may result in reducing the
life of an engine. The main objective of the present research
was to study the properties of stable blends prepared using
diesel, jatropha curcus oil and anhydrous alcohol.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The experiments were carried out using high speed diesel
marketed by Indian Oil Corporation in accordance with IS:
1460-1974 as reference fuel, Jatropha curcus L. (Ratanjot)
seed oil and anhydrous ethanol. Anhydrous ethanol (200 0
proof), of Merck make, Germany was procured from
the local market and ethanol proofs of 200 0, 190 0,
180 0 and170 0 were prepared from anhydrous ethanol
by adding 0%, 5%, 10% and 15% of distilled water,
respectively. By using different proportions of Jatropha
curcus L. (Ratanjot) seed oil and ethanol (anhydrous),
various blends were prepared with diesel.
The quality of biodiesel depends on its fuel properties
that need less engine modification and can be used in
compression ignition engines. For instance, alcohols have
high heat of vaporization resulting in excessive cylinder
cooling, improper air-fuel mixing, long ignition delay
and misfiring making the direct substitution of alcohols
quite impossible. In addition, direct substitution of ethanol
for diesel would require major redesign of the engine
to accommodate the low cetane rating of ethanol. Fuel
modification method includes use of alcohol derivatives
such as esters, diesel-alcohol blends and emulsions (Koganti
et al., 2004). However, ethanol-diesel blends pose many
problems such as lowered cetane number, lowered viscosity,
etc., but phase separation at lower temperatures or water
contamination is most serious limitation (Nayyar, 2010).
The water tolerance of blends increases with temperature.
If water tolerance can be increased, it would be possible
to use lower proof of ethanol for blending with diesel
and edible vegetable oils. However, the price of edible
vegetable oils is higher than that of the diesel fuel. So, in
place of such oils, use of waste vegetable oils (Yu et al.,
2002; Sudhir et al., 2007; Ramadhas et al., 2010; Melero
et al., 2012; Kumar, 2013) and non-edible crude vegetable
oils (Bari, 2002, Pramanik, 2003; Tiwari et al., 2007; Naik
et al., 2008; Sahoo et al., 2009; Deng et al., 2011; Rita,
2012; Bolbade and Khyade, 2012; Gashew and Lakachew,
2014) had been considered as potential alternative fuels.
In addition, Vashist and Ahmad (2009) have explained the
energetic feasibility of Jatropha curcus biodiesel in terms
of energy ratio and Ragit et al. (2011) have standardized
A total of 49 blends were prepared manually using he
different proportions of diesel, Jatropha curcus L oil and
anhydrous ethanol (1900, 1800, 1700). Among them, nine
samples (Table 1) were sorted out for the present research
on the basis of higher stability. The stability or instability
of blends was classified on the basis of visual observation.
A stable blend is a clear, homogeneous and transparent
solution with no sign of phase separation; whereas an
unstable blend looks turbid, non-homogeneous and opaque
right since the time of formation. These characteristics of
the blend do not change even after keeping them for a long
period of time.
Fuel Property Analyses
Relative density and API gravity
Relative density of fuel was evaluated at 15°C temperature
in accordance with Bureau of Indian Standards IS: 1448 [P:
32]:1992. To maintain the temperature of fuel samples at
15°C, the measurement was recorded in a control chamber
(Saveer Biotech walk-in-type) and the relative density was
calculated using equation (1):
Relative density =
44
Pf
Pw
............. (1)
JAE : 52 (1)
Shishir Kumar Verma, A. K. A Lawrence, A. K. Tripathi and K. K. Patel
Where,
Where,
0
Hc = ∆T Heat of combustion of fuel sample, Cal.g-1,
-3
Pw = Density of distilled water at 15 C (0.9904 g.cm ), and
Wc = ∆T Water equivalent of calorimeter assembly,
(2883.32), Cal.°C-1,
PT = Density of fuel at 150C, g.cm-3.
∆T = Rise in temperature, °C, and
Subsequently, the gravity of a fuel was calculated using
the equation 2 (ASTM D-287) for different ethanol proofs
and blends as:
Fuelgravity (API Degrees) =
Ms = Mass of sample burnt, g.
141.5
− 131.5
Relative density o f fuel a t 150 C
Cloud and pour point
Cloud and Pour point were measured using method
described by IS: 1448 [P: 10]: 1970 with the help of Cloud
and Pour point apparatus. It consisted of 120 mm high
glass tubes of 30 mm diameter. These tubes are enclosed
in an air jacket, filled with a freeze mixture of crushed ice
and sodium chloride crystals. For cloud point, at every 10C
interval, as the temperature fell the glass tube containing
fuel sample was taken out from the jacket and inspected for
cloud formation. The point at which a haze was first seen
at the bottom of the sample was taken as the Cloud point.
... (2)
Kinematic viscosity
Kinematic viscosity of the fuels was determined
at 38°C using a Redwood Viscometer No.1 (Make:
Toshniwal) and calculated as following (Nakra and
Chaudhary, 1985):
υ = At −
B
t
…
(3)
υ = Kinematic viscosity, cSt,
For Pour point, samples were pre-heated to 480C and then
cooled to 350C in air before it was filled in the glass tube.
Thereafter, the cooled samples were placed in the apparatus
and withdrawn from the cooling bath at 10C temperature
interval for checking its flow ability. The Pour point was
taken to be the temperature 10C above the temperature at
which no motion of fuel was observed for five seconds on
tilting the tube to a horizontal position. Three replications
were made for each fuel type.
Where,
t = Time of efflux, s (or degrees for Engler viscometer), and
A, B = Constants applicable to type of viscometer.
The commonly accepted values of A are 0.26, 0.22 and 1.47
and of B are 172, 180 and 374 for different viscometers
such as Redwood, Saybolt and Engler, respectively. The
value of A as 0.62, and the value of B as 172 for Redwood
viscometer was used in the research. However, the working
principle of the apparatus was based on the time of
gravity flow in seconds of a fixed volume (50 ml) of
liquid through a specified hole in an agate piece (as per
IP 70 / 62 issued by Institute of Petroleum, London)
(BIS, 1976).
Flash point and ire point
Using Bureau of Indian Standards IS: 1448 [P: 21]: 1992,
Flash and Fire points of all fuel blends were determined
using a Pensky Martens apparatus. The apparatus had a
fuel cup of 50 mm diameter and 55 mm depth. The fuel to
be tested was placed in the cup up to the mark and heated
indirectly at 5°C per minute by rising heated air bath. After
every 1°C temperature rise, flame was introduced for a
moment with the help of a shutter and the temperature at
which a flash appears in the form of sound and light was
recorded as the Flash point. The procedure was continued
until fuel vapour caught fire and the flame sustained for a
minimum of five seconds. This temperature was recorded
as the Fire point of the fuel.
Gross heat of combustion (ghc)
Gross heat of combustion, or calorific value, was
estimated as per Bureau of Indian Standards (IS: 1448 [P:
10]: 1984) using an Isothermal Bomb Calorimeter. Fuel
sample (1 ml) was burnt in the calorimeter bomb in
presence of pure oxygen. The rise in temperature
was measured. The water equivalent (effective heat
capacity of system) was also determined using pure and
dry benzoic acid as test fuel. The heat of combustion
of the fuel samples was calculated as:
Hc =
Wc ∆T
Ms
…
Ash content
The ash content of diesel, jatropha curcus oil and its blends
with diesel was measured as per the standard ASTM D482IP 4 of Institute of Petroleum, London using an electric
muffle furnace (Wiswo make). Known weight of a sample
(4)
45
January-March, 2015
Assessment of Biofuel Blends Using Diesel-Biodiesel and Alcohol
was burnt at 775 ± 250C for 2 h, cooled in desiccators to
room temperature, weighed and ash content calculated as
following:
As =
Wa
×100
Ws
…
At =
(5)
…
(7)
Where,
At = Total acidity, mg KOH.g-1,
Where,
V = Volume of potassium hydroxide solution, ml,
As= Ash content, percent,
N = Normality of potassium hydroxide solution, and
Wa= Weight of ash, g, and
W = Weight of sample, g.
Ws= Weight of sample, g.
All measurements were carried out in triplicate, and
the average values reported.
Carbon residue
Carbon residue of different fuels was determined using a
carbon residue apparatus in accordance with the ASTM
D189–IP 13 of Institute of Petroleum, London. The
percentage of carbon residue of samples was calculated as:
Where,
5 6.1 N × V
W
Wc
Cr =
× 100
Ws
…
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Relative Density and API Gravity
The relative density and API gravity of diesel, different
proofs of ethanol and ethanol blends fuels recorded at
15°C are presented in Table 1. Relative density of diesel
was 0.838. Goering et al. (1983) reported value of 0.840,
and similarly 0.8291 by Chatterjee (2000) and 0.846 by
many researchers.
(6)
Cr = Carbon residue, %,
Wc = Weigh of carbon residue, g, and
However, relative density of Jatropha curcus oil was
recorded as 0.9182, little higher (9.5%) than diesel. The
relative density of diesel increased from 0.838 to 0.879 %
as the per cent of Jatropha curcus oil blend increased from
0% to 30 per cent. This increase was slightly retarded when
anhydrous ethanol was mixed with diesel and Jatropha
Ws = Weight of sample, g.
Acid value
Total acid value of different fuel samples was measured as
per ASTM D974–IP 1/64 of Institute of Petroleum, London,
and calculated as:
Table 1. Properties of different blends formulated with diesel, Jatropha curucus oil and anhydrous ethanol
S.
No.
Blend
[Diesel:
Jatropha
curcus oil:
Ethanol
(anhydrous)]
Relative
density,
kg.cm-3
API
gravity
1.
100:0:0
0.838
2.
0:100:0
0.918
3.
75:0:25
4.
90:10:0
5.
Kinematic
viscosity,
cSt
Gross
heat of
combustion,
MJ.kg-1
Cloud
point
(0C)
Pour
point
(0C)
38.74
3.07
44.9
5
-1.3
22.54
31.15
42.8
1
-6.5
0.829
37.78
2.51
47.91
4
3.0
35.0
0.855
34.75
3.66
49.16
3
-1.8
58.5
80:20:0
0.860
32.92
4.30
48.34
2
-3.4
6.
70:30:0
0.879
31.33
5.77
47.33
1.3
-5.0
7.
70:20:10
0.848
37.44
3.90
45.94
1.8
8.
60:30:10
0.861
34.75
4.94
44.27
1.3
9.
50:40:10
0.869
33.21
5.25
43.66
10.
40:40:20
0.876
31.82
6.26
11.
0:85:15
0.884
28.45
15.2
Fire
point
(0C)
Carbon
residue
(%)
Ash
content
(%)
Total
acidity
(mg.
KOH.g-1)
58.0
64.5
0.142
0.0009
0.23
236.0
251.5
4.850
0.165
2.24
41.0
0.101
0.0035
0.43
64.7
0.1086
0.0052
0.47
59.5
65.5
1.998
0.0096
0.77
60.0
67.5
2.332
0.0120
0.89
-3.5
44.0
50.0
0.732
0.0033
0.51
-3.5
46.0
54.0
1.449
0.0090
1.29
1.4
-4.5
48.0
56.0
1.901
0.0105
1.70
42.42
1.0
-6.8
49.0
56.5
2.987
0.0140
2.05
44.47
4.5
-8.3
50.0
57.5
3.976
0.0195
2.08
46
Flash
point
(0C)
JAE : 52 (1)
Shishir Kumar Verma, A. K. A Lawrence, A. K. Tripathi and K. K. Patel
oils in the fuel lines. Thus, the viscosity is not a major/
unsolvable problem, and neat vegetable oil is still used as
alternative fuels for diesel engines in countries as cold as
Germany and Ireland.
curcus oil. The maximum relative density was recorded for
blend of 0 % diesel, 85% Jatropha curcus oil and 15% ethanol
(anhydrous) fuel (Table 1). But, when diesel and ethanol
(anhydrous) were blended in 75:25 ratio, the relative density
of the blend was noticed to be 2.1 % lower than that of diesel.
The results indicated that the Jatropha curcus oil, as well
as all the blends had kinematic viscosity higher than that
of diesel, except the blend of diesel-anhydrous ethanol
prepared in 75:25 proportion. This blend was found to
have kinematic viscosity of 18.29 cSt, lower than diesel.
However, the blends of diesel- Jatropha curcus oil and
diesel- Jatropha curcus oil - anhydrous ethanol prepared at
the selected proportions had kinematic viscosity within the
permissible range of 2.0 to 7.5 cSt (IS : 1460-1974), except
for the blend of 85% Jatropha curcus oil and 15% anhydrous
ethanol. Wrage and Goering (1980) have reported kinematic
viscosity of anhydrous ethanol, diesel and blend of dieselethanol (80:20) as 1.11, 2.46 and 1.83 cSt, respectively. On
the basis of observations and the standard proposed by IS:
1460-1974, it was found that most of the selected blends
had their kinematic viscosity within the specified range.
The observations on API gravity showed that blends
containing higher proofs of ethanol had higher API gravity
compared to the blends prepared from ethanol of lower
proofs. This was because higher proof ethanol had lower
relative density than that of lower proof ethanol. The API
gravity of fuel types also indicated that all the blends,
different ethanol proofs and Jatropha curcus oil were lighter
than diesel fuel. Among the fuel blends, maximum API
gravity was recorded for blends 75:0:25 and 70:20:10, as
37.78 and 37.44, respectively (Table 1).
Kinematic Viscosity
Viscosity of a fuel affects its atomization and injection
system lubrication upon injection into the combustion
chamber that leads the formation of engine deposits. Thus,
higher the value of viscosity, greater will be the tendency of
fuel to cause such problems as high fuel viscosity reduces
the fuel amount vaporised prior to combustion (Owen
and Coley, 1995). The kinematic viscosity of diesel was
recorded as 3.07 cSt (32.7 Redwood seconds). Boruff et al.
(1982) had observed kinematic viscosity of diesel as 2.46
cSt. Some researchers have reported kinematic viscosity of
diesel fuel at 38 0C between 1.6 and 7.5 cSt, and minimum
kinematic viscosity was recorded as 2.51 cSt for 75% diesel
and 25 % ethanol (anhydrous) when no Jatropha curcus oil
was used.
Gross Heat of Combustion (GHC)
Gross heat of combustion of fuels shows the capacity of heat
production within the engine that enables the engine to do
work. Diesel had 44.9 MJ.kg-1 of gross heat of combustion,
and was in agreement with the findings reported by Goering
et al. (1981), Hansen et al. (1989), Chatterjee (2000) as
43.57 MJ.kg-1, 44.96 MJ.kg-1, 45.12 MJ.kg-1, respectively.
However, the gross heat of combustion of jatropha curcus
oil and anhydrous ethanol (2000 proof) was found to be 42.8
MJ.kg-1 and 30.66 MJ.kg-1, and slightly differed from the
findings reported by Kumar et al. (2002) as 39.77 MJ.kg-1
for Jatropha curcus oil.
With 0% anhydrous ethanol, as the blending of Jatropha
curcus oil with diesel (100 to 70%) increased from 0 to
30%, the kinematic viscosity also increased from 3.07
to 5.77 cST (Table 1). Pramanik (2003) had reported
that Jatropha curcus oil and diesel blend in proportion of
20:80 had kinematic viscosity of 6.93 cSt. However, when
10% anhydrous ethanol was mixed with diesel, kinematic
viscosity increased from 3.90 to 4.94, and then to 5.25 with
increase in proportion of Jatropha curcus oil (from 20%
to 30% and 40%), and was less than 0% mix anhydrous
ethanol. Maximum kinematic viscosity of 31.15 cSt was
noted for Jatropha curcus oil, Table 1. However, according
to Knothe (2005) the kinematic viscosity of standard
biodiesel should be 1.9–6.0 mm2.s-1 (ASTM D6751) and
3.5–5.0 mm2.s-1 as per EN 14214. Present technologies
can mitigate the problem of such high viscosity (31.15
cSt) in neat vegetable oils or alternative for diesel engines
by using waste heat from the engine to heat the vegetable
As the blend percent of Jatropha curcus oil was increased
from 10% to 30% in diesel, the GHC of diesel-jatropha
curcus blend decreased from 49.16 to 47.33 MJ.kg-1.
Similarly, when diesel was mixed with 10% anhydrous
ethanol (90:10) and the percent blend of Jatropha curcus oil
was increased from 20% to 30% and then to 40% (70:20:10,
60:30:10, 50:40:10), the GHC was 45.94 to 43.66 MJ.kg-1.
In addition, blend of 40:40:20 proportions had GHC of
42.42 MJ.kg-1. The GHC of Jatropha curcus oil-anhydrous
ethanol blend mixed in 85:15 proportions was found to be
44.47 MJ.kg-1, which was 12.63% lower than that of diesel.
It is also evident from the observations that the GHC of
diesel- Jatropha curcus oil blends were 3.4 to 7.0% lower,
and that of diesel-Jatropha curcus oil-anhydrous ethanol
was 9.5 to 16.6% lower than that of diesel.
47
January-March, 2015
Assessment of Biofuel Blends Using Diesel-Biodiesel and Alcohol
Cloud and Pour Point
lower than diesel. The maximum Fire point was recorded
for Jatropha curcus oil.
The Cloud and Pour point of diesel was 5 and -1.3°C,
respectively, while for the other fuels prepared by blending
in different proportions of diesel, Jatropha curcus oil and
ethanol (anhydrous), they varied from 1 to 4.5 and -8.3 to
3.0°C, respectively. The Cloud point of Jatropha curcus oil
and blend of 40% diesel, 40% Jatropha curcus oil and 20%
anhydrous ethanol was lowest at 1, which is in agreement
with the findings of Okullo et al. (2012) for crude jatropha
curcus oil as 1± 0.50. As the per cent of Jatropha curcus
oil in blends increased from 10% to 30% in diesel, the
value of cloud point decreased from 3 to 1.3. Similarly, as
the per cent of Jatropha curcus oil increased from 10% to
30%, the Pour point of blends decreased from -1.8 to -5.0
0
C. However, the Pour point of the fuel with 75% diesel and
25% anhydrous ethanol had higher value of 3°C. A low
value (-8.30C) of Pour point was recorded for the fuel with
85% Jatropha curcus oil and 15% anhydrous ethanol. On
the other hand, when 10% anhydrous ethanol was mixed
in diesel and kept constant, and the ratio of Jatrophe oil
was increased from 20% to 40%, the Pour point and Cloud
point again decreased from -3.5 to -4.5 0C and 1.8 to 1.4,
respectively.
Carbon Residue Content
Carbon residue correlates with the amount of carbonaceous
deposits of the fuel that form in the combustion chamber
of an engine. It was observed to be 0.142% in diesel,
which was less than the recommended maximum level of
0.2% in diesel fuel (IS: 1460-1974). This finding slightly
differs with the results reported by Peterson and Reece
(1996) and Mazed et al. (1985) as 0.16 and 0.082%,
respectively. The percent carbon residue content of
Jatropha curcus oil was recorded as 4.85. Similarly, the
blends of diesel-Jatropha curcus oil and diesel-Jatropha
curcus oil-anhydrous ethanol had very high carbon
residue content compared to diesel. However, the blend
of diesel-anhydrous ethanol mixed in 75:25 proportions
was found to have its carbon residue content 28.8% less
than that of diesel. The observed carbon residue content
of Jatropha curcus oil and anhydrous ethanol blend mixed
in proportion of 85:15 was observed as 3.976 percent.
Such a high carbon residue may cause carbon deposition
on the piston head, valves and pose a problem of choking
of injector nozzles.
Flash and Fire Point
Ash Content
Flash point measures the tendency of a sample to form a
flammable mixture with air. Flash point of diesel fuel was
recorded as 58°C, which was similar (60°C) to that observed
by Chandra et al. (2003). However, the present result does
not agree with the findings reported by Goering et al. (1983)
and Clark et al. (1984) as 80 and 78°C, respectively. The
Flash point of Jatropha curcus oil was recorded as 236°C,
significantly higher than that of diesel. However, fuel blends
with diesel and Jatropha curcus oil; and diesel, Jatropha
curcus oil and anhydrous (2000 proof) ethanol had Flash
points between 440C and 600C. Lowest Flash point was
noticed for fuel blend of diesel and anhydrous (2000 proof)
ethanol in 75:25 proportions (Table 1) due to presence of
highly volatile and flammable material in relatively nonvolatile material.
The ash content in diesel, Jatropha curcus oil and
other fuels prepared after blending in different ratios
and anhydrous ethanol are presented in Table 1. Ash
content of diesel was recorded as 0.009%, and differed
to the finding reported by Peterson and Reece (1996)
as 0.002 percent. On the other hand, the ash content of
Jatropha curcus oil was 0.165%, and much higher than
the permitted maximum level (0.01%) as specified by
IS: 1460-1974. The increase in ash content could be
attributed to more amount of metals contained in the
fuel. However, the ash content of Jatropha curcus oil and
diesel blends was recorded between 0.0052 and 0.0120
percent. Similarly, the blends with diesel, Jatropha curcus
oil and anhydrous ethanol had ash content between
0.0033 to 0.014%; while fuels with Jatropha curcus oil
and anhydrous ethanol in 85:15 proportion and diesel and
anhydrous ethanol in 75:25 proportion had ash content
of 0.0035% and 0.0195%, respectively (Table 1). Among
these fuels, the ash content of blends 75:0:25, 90:10:0,
80:20:0, 70:20:10 and 60:30:10 were in the range of ash
content specified by the Bureau of Indian Standard (IS:
1448 [P: 10]: 1974). The higher ash content in other
blends may, therefore, result in deposition inside the
combustion chamber on injector nozzle. The observed
values are in accordance with the finding reported by
Bhatt et al. (2004).
The Fire point is an extension of Flash point in a way that
it reflects the condition at which vapour burns continuously
for five seconds. Table 1 shows the Fire point of fuels and
their blends. Fire point of diesel was found to be 64.5°C,
and similar (67.70C) to as reported by Chandra et al. (2003).
Fire point of Jatropha curcus oil was found to be 251.5°C.
Diesel-Jatropha curcus oil blends of 90:10, 80:20 and 70:30
had higher Fire point than that of diesel. However, Fire point
of diesel-Jatropha curcus oil- anhydrous ethanol blends of
70:20:10, 60:30:10, 50:40:10, 40:40:20 and 0:85:15 was
48
JAE : 52 (1)
Shishir Kumar Verma, A. K. A Lawrence, A. K. Tripathi and K. K. Patel
Bari S; Yu C W; Lim T H. 2002. Performance deteroritation
and durability issues while running a diesel engine with
crude palm oil. In: Proc. Inst. Mech. Eng., Part d, J.
Automobile Eng., 216, 785-792.
Total Acidity
-1
Total acidity of diesel fuel, 0.23 mg KOH.g , was less
than half of the permitted level of 0.50 mg KOH.g-1 by
the IS: 1460-1974. However, Jatropha curcus oil (2.24
mg KOH.g-1), diesel-Jatropha curcus oil blends (90:10,
80:20 and 70:30) and blends of diesel-Jatropha curcus
oil-anhydrous ethanol (70:20:10, 60:30:10, 50:40:10
and 40:40:20) were higher than the recommended level
(Table 1). The measured values thus indicated that the
total acidity of the blends increased with an increase in
level of Jatropha curcus oil in the blend. The total acidity
of diesel- anhydrous ethanol blended in 75:25 proportions
(0.43 mg KOH.g-1) was the only fuel blend meeting the
recommended level.
Bhatt Y C; Murthy N S; Datta R K. 2004. Use of Mahua
oil (Madhuca Indica) as a diesel fuel extender, IE (I) JournalAG, 85, 10-14.
BIS. 1970. Methods of Test for Petroleum and its Products.
Cloud Point and Pour Point. IS: 1448, Bureau of Indian
Standards, New Delhi, pp: 10.
BIS. 1972. Indian Standard Methods of Test for Petroleum
and its products: Density and Relative Density (First
Revision) IS: 1448, Bureau of Indian Standards (BIS),
New Delhi, pp: 32.
The high acid value, in case of Jatropha curcus oil and its
blend with diesel would thus affect the life of fuel injection
pump, injector, cylinder and piston of the engine. So, the
total acidity of fuels can be used as guide in quality control
of fuel.
BIS. 1976. Indian Standard Methods of Test for Petroleum
and its products: Determination of Kinematic and Dynamic
Viscosity. IS: 1448, Bureau of Indian Standards (BIS), New
Delhi, pp: 25.
CONCLUSIONS
BIS. 1992. Petroleum and its Products. Methods of Test
Density and Relative Density. IS: 1448, Bureau of Indian
Standards, New Delhi, pp: 32.
Fuel properties as viscosity, ash content, carbon
residue, Flash point of Jatropha curcus oil was found
to be greater than that of diesel and, therefore, make it
unsuitable for use as fuel in diesel engines. Blending
Jatropha curcus oil with diesel brought the properties
closer to that of diesel.
Bobade S N; Khyade V B. 2012. Preparation of methyl
ester (Biodiesel) from Karanja (Pongamia Pinnata) Oil. Res.
J. Chem. Sci., 2(8), 43-50.
Boruff P A; Schwab A W; Goering C E; Pryde E H. 1982.
Evaluation of diesel fuel–ethanol microemulsions. Trans.
ASAE 25 (1), 47–53.
Jatropha curcus oil and ethanol may be blended with diesel
because the blends (70:0:25; 90:10:0; 80:20:0 and 60:30:10)
seemed to have some of the major fuel characteristics such
as relative density, API gravity, kinematic viscosity, gross
of heat of combustion, Cloud and Pour point, Flash and
Fire point, carbon residue, ash content and total acid values
close to diesel.
Chandra R; Bhattacharya T K; Mishra T N. 2003.
Studies on the use of ethanol acetate surfactant for dieselalcohol micro emulsions as CI engine fuel. Unpublished M.
Tech. Thesis, Department of Farm Machinery and Power
Engineering, GBPUA&T, Pantnagar.
REFERENCES
Chatterjee S. 2000. Studies on the performance of a
constant speed CI engine on emulsiied ethanol. Unpublished
M.Tech. Thesis, Department of Farm Machinery and Power
Engineering, G. B. Pant University of Agriculture and
Technology, Pantnagar, India.
AgroChart. 2014. India. Biofuels annuals. www.agrochart.
com (accessed date 12-02-2015).
Anon. 2015. Petroleum and natural gas: India energy
portal. http://www.indiaenergyportal.org (accessed date,
11-02-2015).
Clark S J; Wagner L; Schrock M D; Pinnaar P G.
1984. Methyl and ethyl esters as renewable fuels for diesel
engines. J. Amer. Oil Chemists’ Soc., 61, 1632–1638.
ASTM 1998. Annual Book of standards. American Society
for Testing and Materials, Philadelphia, PA.
De Gorter H; Drabik D; Timilsina G R. 2013. The
effect of biodiesel policies on world oilseed markets and
developing countries. World Bank Policy Research Working
Paper pp : 653.
Atadashi I M; Aroua M K; Abdul A A. 2011. Biodiesel
separation and puriication: A review. Renewable Energy,
36, 437-443.
49
January-March, 2015
Assessment of Biofuel Blends Using Diesel-Biodiesel and Alcohol
Deng X; Fang Z; Liu Y-H; Yu C-L. 2011. Production of
biodiesel from Jatropha oil catalyzed by nanosized solid
basic catalyst. Energy, 36, 777-784.
Melero J A; Iglesias J; Garcia A. 2012. Biomass as
renewable feedstock in standard reinery units: feasibility,
opportunities and challenges. Energy Environ. Sci., 5(6),
7393-7420.
Desai D. 2015. Sugar fuel: ethanol India. www.ethanolindia.
net, accessed date 12-02-2015.
Naik Malaya; Meher L C; Naik S N; Das L M. 2008.
Production of biodiesel from high free fatty acid Karanja
(Pongamia pinnata) oil. Biomass Bioenergy, 32, 354-357.
Gashaw A, Lakachew A. 2014. Production of biodiesel
from non edible oil and its properties. Int. J. Sci. Environ.
Technol., 3(4), 1544–1562.
Nakra B C; Chaudhary K K. 1985. Instrumentation
Measurement and Analysis. Tata Mac Graw Hill Publication,
380-385.
Goering C E; Schwab A W; Daugherty M J; Pryde
E H; Heazkin A J. 1981. Fuel properties of eleven
vegetable oils. ASAE Paper 81-3578, St Joseph,
Michigan, USA.
Nayyar M P. 2010. The Use of Biodiesel Fuels in the US
Marine Industry. PRIME Inc., under Maritime Administration
Contract No. DTMA1D05007/TO090000055.
Goering C E; Schwab A W; Campion R M Pryde E
H. 1983. Soyoil-ethanol microemulsions as diesel fuel.
Trans. ASAE, 26 (6), 1602-1604.
Okullo A A; Temu A K; Ogwok P; Ntalikwa J W. 2012.
Physico-chemical properties of biodiesel from Jatropha
and castor oils. Int. J. Renewable Energy Res., 2(1), 47-52.
Hansen J; Lacis A; Prather M. 1989. Greenhouse effect
of chloro luoro carbons and other trace gases. J. Geophys.
Res., 94, 16417-16421.
Owen K; Coley T. 1995. Automotive Fuels and Reference
Book. 1st Edition, SAE International, USA.
Pandey V C. 2006. Population education. ISHA Book,
ISBN: 81-8205-1762, pp:106.
IANS (Indo-Asian News Service). 2013. Nearly 80% of
India’s crude oil needs imported. New Delhi, August 27.
Jha D K. 2012. Sugar irms cut ethanol output target.
Traditional Int., www.traditionalint.com, accessed on 1202-2015.
Peterson C; Reece D. 1996. Emission characteristics of
ethyl and methyl ester of rapeseed oils compared with low
sulfur diesel control fuel in a chassis dynamometer test of
a pickup truck. Trans. ASAE, 39, 805-816.
Knothe G. 2005. Dependence of biodiesel fuel properties
on the structure of fatty acid alkyl esters. Fuel Process.
Technol., 86, 1059–1070.
Pramanik K. 2003. Properties and use of jatropha curcus
oil and diesel fuel blends in compression ignition engine.
Renewable Energy, 28, 239-248.
Koganti R B; Maheshwari M; Swami K K; Malhotra R
K; Arora P; Singh V P; Varyani T S. 2004. Performance
evaluation of ethanol diesel blends in tractors. SAE Paper
No. 2004-28-0085.
Ragit S S; Mohapatra S K; Kundu K; Gill P. 2011.
Optimization of neem methyl ester from transesteriication
process and fuel characterization as a diesel substitute.
Biomass Bioenergy, 35 (3), 1138-1144.
Kumar M S; Ramesh A; Nagalingam B. 2002. Use of
hydrogen to enhance the performance of a vegetable oil
fuelled compression ignition engine. Int. J. Hydrogen
Energy, 28, 1143-1154.
Ramadhas A S; Muraleedharan C; Iayaraj S. 2010.
Vegetable oils. Alternative Fuels for Transportation, 21.
Reddy S S. 2013. Production and testing of methyl esters
of used cooking oil. Int. Archive Applied Sci. Technol.,
4(2), 76-81.
Kumar R. 2013. Process optimization for biodiesel
production from Tung (Aleurites fordii.) oil and its emissions
characteristics. Unpublished Doctoral dissertation, Thapar
University, Patiala.
Rita K S C Y. 2012. Biodiesel production from non
edible-oils: A Review. J. Chem. Pharmaceutical Res., 4
(9), 4219-4230.
Mazed M A; Summers J D; Batchelder D G. 1985.
Engine endurance with peanut, soyabean and cottonseed
fuels. Trans. ASAE., 28(5), 1371-1374.
Ruitenberg R. 2014. World biodiesel output seen by oil
world reaching record. Boomberg business article published
online, www.boomberg.com (accessed date 12-02-2015).
50
JAE : 52 (1)
Shishir Kumar Verma, A. K. A Lawrence, A. K. Tripathi and K. K. Patel
Sahoo P K; Das L M. 2009. Process optimization for
biodiesel production from Jatropha, Karanja and Polanga
oils. Fuel, 88(9), 1588-1594.
Vashist D; Ahmad M. 2009. Energetic and economic
feasibility associated with the production, processing and
conversion of jatropha curcus oil to a substitute diesel
fuel in India. Int. Rev. Mech. Eng. Praise Worthy Prize J.,
3, 503-509.
Sudhir C V; Sharma N Y; Mohanan P. 2007. Potential
of waste cooking oils as biodiesel feed stock. Emirates J.
Eng. Res., 12, 69-75.
Wrage K E; Goering C E. 1980. Technical feasibility of
diesohol. Trans. ASAE., 23(6), 1338-1343.
Tiwari A K; Akhilesh K; Raheman H. 2007. Biodiesel
production from jatropha curcus oil (Jatropha curcus
curcas) with high free fatty acids: An optimized process.
Biomass Bioenergy, 31, 569-575.
Yu C W; Bari S; Ameen A. 2002. A comparison of
combustion characteristics of waste cooking oil with diesel
as fuel in a direct injection diesel engine. In: Proc. Inst.
Mech. Engr., Part d, J. Automobile Eng., 216, 237-242.
51
INFORMATION AND INSTRUCTIONS FOR AUTHORS
The Journal of Agricultural Engineering contains original papers only and submission of a paper will be taken to imply that no similar
paper has been or is being submitted elsewhere. Manuscripts (three copies alongwith a soft copy) in English, typed in double space
on one side of A-4 size paper, should be submitted to the Chief Editor. Manuscripts can also be submitted through e-mail to the Chief
Editor, and are preferred.
The subject matter relects the wide range and interdisciplinary nature of research in engineering and physics for agriculture. Papers
describing engineering innovations for ield crops, horticulture, livestock, and isheries and those reporting research seeking to
understand and model the physical processes underlying agricultural systems are welcome.
The following three types of papers are invited for publication. Research papers are the normal type of papers published and make
up the main bulk of the Journal. They should not normally exceed ten Journal pages. Research notes enable important indings to be
speedily communicated and facilitate the reporting of work not meriting a full length paper. They should not exceed three Journal pages.
Review papers are intended to be in-depth studies of the state-of-the-art in the chosen subjects. They should not normally exceed 15
journal pages.
Your Manuscript should be arranged as follows.
Title, authors’ names, afiliations, addresses and key words. Please necessarily include e-mail address of the corresponding author.
•
Abstract. The Abstract of not more than 200 words should state the problem investigated, outline the methods used and summarize
the main conclusions.
•
Main body text. The main body of the text should be divided under suitable headings, numbered to show the hierarchical order.
Some or all of the following headings may be appropriate.
Introduction. This should explain the problem investigated, review earlier work and state the intention of the present paper.
Literature review. A separate section may be justiied for this, depending on length.
Theoretical considerations. It may be appropriate to explain or develop a theory to shed light on a problem or to correlate
experimental results.
Materials and Methods or Procedures or Experimental details
Results. These should be presented with reference to appropriate igures and tables. The most appropriate presentations
should be chosen and tabulated data should not duplicate that shown graphically.
Discussion. This may merit a separate section, although Results and Discussion can sometimes be presented together. The
discussion must include the comparison of indings with the previous work done.
Conclusions. Research and Review papers must have this inal section but it is optional in Research Notes. Conclusions
emerging from the work should be succinctly summarized. These conclusions must been discussed in the paper and new
material must not be introduced at this stage.
•
List of symbols
•
Acknowledgments optional.
•
References
References in the text should be in the format of surnames of authors followed by the year of publication of the appropriate reference,
separated by a comma. The artiice “Leading author et al.” should be used in the text for multiple authorship papers, where there are
more than two authors. Each reference should give the names of all authors (or, if anonymous, the name of the organisation), the year
of publication, the title in that order. Some examples of references are given below.
In the text: “Previous work has shown (Hammer & Langhans, 1972; Federer, 1955)...”
In the references 1ist (to journals):
Hammer PA; Langhans R W. 1972. Experimental design considerations for growth chamber studies. Hort Science. 7, 481-483.
In the reference list (to books):
Federer WT. 1955. Experimental Design. Macmillan, New York.
•
Appendices. It may be appropriate to place detailed mathematical derivations in appendices, rather in the main body of the text.
•
Figure captions. These should be listed, together with any ‘key’ information necessary to aid interpretation.
•
Tables. Each table must be placed on a separate sheet and numbered consecutively throughout the text (with Arabic numerals),
and referred to as Table 1, Table 2, etc. There must be a caption at the top of each Table.
•
Figure 1, Figure 2, etc. Figure captions should be placed beneath each igure and should also be listed on a separate sheet.
Figures (on irst submission)
All illustrations, whether line drawings, graphs or photographs, are presented as igures and are given numbers (e.g. Figure 1) in
ascending numerical order as reference is irst made to each in the text.
Figures (on acceptance)
When the paper is accepted for publication, line drawings without lettering will be required. The publisher will insert the lettering to maintain
a common style but it greatly helps if the igures provided for guidance (as for refereeing) are in the required style. Line drawings should
preferably be in Indian ink on tracing paper, Bristol board of faintly lined graph paper but without numerals and letters. They should be
numbered in soft pencil for ready identiication with the complete igures attached to the paper. Softcopy of igures should be of printable
quailty using 8 point font for legends. Scanned igures may be avoided in case the legends and igures are not clean.
Indian Society of Agricultural Engineers
Executive Council (2012-2015)
President
Dr V M Mayande
vmmayande@yahoo.com
Immediate Past President
Prof. Gajendra Singh
prof.gsingh@gmail.com
Vice President
(Activity Council)
Dr A P Srivastava
srivastava_ap@rediffmail.com
Vice President
(Technical Council)
Dr A K Singh
awadheshksingh@rediffmail.com
Secretary General
Dr Indra Mani
aniindra99@gmail.com
Secretary
Dr Abhijit Kar
abhijit8366@gmail.com
Treasurer
Dr P K Sahoo
sahoopk_1965@rediffmail.com
Director
(Farm Machinery & Power)
Dr Y C Bhatt
drycb@hotmail.com
Director
(Soil & Water Engineering)
Dr Ashwani Kumar
ashwani_wtcer@yahoo.com
Director
(Processing, Dairy & Food Engineering)
Dr D C Joshi
dcjoshi258@gmail.com
Director
(Energy & Other Areas)
Dr P Venkatachalam
pvenkat55@yahoo.co.uk
Director
(Membership & Public Relations)
Er N K Lohani
lohanigaya@yahoo.com
Director
(Education, Research, Extension & Placement)
Dr P K Srivastava
prabhat410@rediffmail.com
Director
(Business & Industry)
Er Baldev Singh
amaragri@gmail.com
Director
(Awards)
Dr N C Patel
ncpatel1@indiatimes.com
Director
(International Co-operation)
Dr Indrajeet Chaubey
ichaubey@purdue.edu
Director
(E-Services)
Dr A Sarangi
asarangi@iari.res.in
Director
(Journal of Agricultural Engineering)
Dr Dipankar De
dipankar_engg@iari.res.in
Chief Editor
(Agricultural Engineering Today)
Dr Surendra Singh
ssingh5119@gmail.com
Chief Editor
(E-news Letter)
Dr R T Patil
ramabhau@yahoo.com
ISSN : 0256-6524
VOL. 52, No. 1
January-March 2015
Journal of Agricultural Engineering
Vol. 52
January-March 2015
No. 1
CONTENTS
Page
Extrusion Process Optimization for Soy-Carrot Pomace Powder Incorporated Wheat-based Snacks
1
– Md Shaiq Alam, Harjot Khaira, Shivani Pathania, Sunil Kumar and Baljit Singh
Optimization of Process Parameters for Production of Palmyrah Palm Jaggery
14
– M. Madhava, D. Ravindra Babu, P. C. Vengaiah and B. Hari Babu
Performance Evaluation of a Sunlower Seed Huller
20
– Olaosebikan Layi Akangbe, Victor Ifeanyi Obiora Ndirika, Usman Shehu Mohammed
and Lawan Garba Abubakar
Effect of Drying Methods and Storage on Quality of Ready-to-eat Dehydrated Carrot Shreds
26
– V.R. Sagar
Spatial Assessment of Wastewater Quality of Nag River for Irrigation
31
– A.R. Mhaske, S.M. Taley, Shinde and R.N. Katkar
Assessment of Biofuel Blends Using Diesel-Biodiesel and Alcohol
43
– Shishir Kumar Verma, A. K. A Lawrence, A. K. Tripathi and K. K. Patel
Information and Instructions for Authors
Printed at New United Process, A-26, Naraina Indl. Area, Ph-II, New Delhi-110028 Phone : 25709125
52