The Atlantic

The 'Trump Derangement Syndrome' Dodge

Beware trusting pundits who exploit the least defensible critiques of the president to avoid acknowledging his most dangerous flaws.
Source: Yuri Gripas / Reuters

Donald Trump is different.

Jimmy Carter, Ronald Reagan, George H.W. Bush, Bill Clinton, George W. Bush, and Barack Obama all had allies who defended their approaches to the presidency against critics.

But defending what Trump says or does is often impossible. Americans can’t help but know that he didn’t win the popular vote; draw more people to his inauguration than Barack Obama; act wisely in appointing Michael Flynn; execute well in that first executive order on travel; or accomplish more in his first 100 days than any other president.

Americans can’t help but see that he is erratic, and that his domestic agenda has stalled bigly. He can claim that no politician has ever been treated more unfairly. But we can’t help but know that Ronald Reagan was shot and that John F. Kennedy was killed.

That’s why pro-Trump and anti-anti-Trump commentators have adapted.

As the weeks pass, they spend less time making positive arguments for the president and more time at an excessive reaction to it.

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from The Atlantic

The Atlantic4 min read
An SNL for the True Bob Dylan Fans
When Saturday Night Live announced that Timothée Chalamet would be both the host and musical guest on this week’s episode, the reaction was largely: huh? What would Chalamet, a skilled actor not usually known as a musical artist, perform? Would he re
The Atlantic1 min read
Cloud Pantoum
Tell me that you do not think of me, that you have forgotten the wild proscenium of cloud, how bodies affix and then elide, the sky’s stenography. I only ask for you to tell me you have not forgotten the pink proscenium of cloud, a testament to our d
The Atlantic4 min read
Biden’s Middle East Legacy
Joe Biden has now left office, but the fight over the meaning of his Middle East policies is only just beginning. Biden’s defenders argue that he left the incoming Trump administration with the strongest American position in the region in decades—and

Related