The Atlantic

Why Nationalists Fail

The Welsh independence movement lags far behind the Scottish version. Why?
Source: Western Mail and Echo / Mirrorpix / Mirrorpix via Getty Images

This year, a graffiti slogan began to appear on walls across Wales. Typically spray-painted in white letters on a red background, it read Cofiwch Dryweryn—“Remember Tryweryn.”

The phrase first appeared half a century ago, on a wall in a Welsh seaside village, and the mural quickly became a local landmark. It commemorated the village of Capel Celyn in the Tryweryn Valley, which was flooded in 1965 to create a reservoir. The “drowned village” was Welsh, as were the 70 residents who were forced to leave their homes. The water supply was destined for the English city of Liverpool. Remember Tryweryn: Remember what England does to Wales.

The destruction of the village was a deep enough wound to feature on the most recent season of Netflix’s royal drama The Crown: Over dinner with his tutor Edward Millward, a Welsh nationalist, Prince Charles sees a photograph of Capel Celyn. “I have so many places to visit,” he says, wistfully. “You wouldn’t be able to visit anymore,” is Millward’s brisk reply.

Remember Tryweryn. Clearly, many in Wales do: Earlier this year, the original mural , and soon after, the phrase began popping up elsewhere, as if in sympathy. reported more than 50 sightings within a month, from Newport in the south to Anglesey

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from The Atlantic

The Atlantic7 min read
Why ‘Late Regime’ Presidencies Fail
Presidents whom most voters view as failures, justifiably or not, have frequently shaped American politics long after they leave office—notably, by paving the way for presidencies considered much more successful and consequential. As President Joe Bi
The Atlantic11 min read
Trump Is Right That Pax Americana Is Over
As he sat in prison in 1930, at the opening of a fateful decade, the Italian anti-fascist Antonio Gramsci wrote: “The crisis consists precisely in the fact that the old is dying and the new cannot be born; in this interregnum a great variety of morbi
The Atlantic3 min read
These Bizarre Theories About the L.A. Wildfires Endanger Everyone
There has been no shortage of explanations for the devastation wrought by the wildfires still burning across greater Los Angeles. Some commentators have argued that sclerotic local governance left the region unprepared to respond to such a large-scal

Related