The merits of the show lies on the grand costumes and high budget production. But while the merits seem to have ended there, it is where conflicts have risen. The show boasts of tackling Phil history, however, it raised questions due to historical inaccuracies the show contained as in details of the Binukot portrayed in the series. There are likewise underlying themes of infidelity, deceit and revenge on the program which are quite contradicting to much favored trend on Philippine Television that places importance in values oriented shows. And if only for the inaccuracies and the deficiency on values oriented lessons the show imparts to viewers, then Amaya would need more improvements.
Amaya is the second epic series in the Philippines with ABS-CBN's Rounin being the first Tele-Epiko (epic series). The show debuted at 6th spot in Philippine Primetime with 19.1% in the Nationwide Ratings (Kantar TNS). It is currently showing opposite Philippine TV Primetime leader 100 Days to Heaven.
