Jake Pavelka and Chelsie Hightower in Dancing with the Stars (2005)

Jake Pavelka and Cheryl Burke in Dancing with the Stars (2005)

Jake Pavelka, Niecy Nash, Evan Lysacek, Anna Trebunskaya, and Chelsie Hightower in Dancing with the Stars (2005)

Tom Bergeron, Jake Pavelka, Brooke Burke, and Chelsie Hightower in Dancing with the Stars (2005)

Jake Pavelka and Jillian Harris in The Bachelorette (2003)

Jake Pavelka at an event for Burning Love (2012)

Jake Pavelka at an event for Dancing with the Stars (2005)