Priscilla and Interrogationists' co-producer/co-star, Janna Jude Brown, met while performing in local theatre in Los Angeles. Both had previously lived in Orlando but did not know each other. It turned out both knew Drew Seeley. Janna attended high school with him, and Priscilla, college. During the casting for the series, they decided to ask him to play the role of Jason Vance, which he accepted.