In the cinema firmament, this film is perhaps not a classic. It wasn't on the AFI 100 list, it isn't well-remembered by film critics. This is unfortunate. I watch this movie at least once a month. It reaffirms my belief in the magical. Dean Martin and Judy Holliday are fabulous, especially Judy in her last role, but this film is made by the supporting characters such as Jean Stapleton and Frank Gorshin. The way that Minelli was able to take a wonderful play and make it even more wonderful in a film is a testament to his genius. You feel like you're part of the world of Susanswerphone and you wish to remain so at the end of the film.