It's Valentine's Day and Amanda is alone. At the office, Lyric is being flooded with gifts from her boyfriend. Amanda reminisces about Brad - who is at the center of the worst Valentine's Day she's ever had.
Ready to make some magic happen in her life, Amanda signs up for magic classes and is surprised to meet a charming young man. She decides to "go with the flow." In a whirlwind night, she finds herself in a "relationship" in only 24 hours.
Amanda meets Tom, a genuine, happy man and a vegan. He's not an annoying vegan, either. He's mellow, happy, and magically NEVER ANGRY. Amanda thinks this is exactly what she needs, but she'll learn that even happy vegans have a dark side.
Richard is an older guy Amanda met online. He's confident, a quality Amanda finds attractive. But Amanda soon realizes that he is more interested in schooling her than being her partner, and he might not appreciate her for who she is.
After her work is rejected by Kathy, Amanda finds herself crying in the copy room. She's surprised when her annoying coworker Braden shows up to comfort her. He takes Amanda out for drinks, and she starts to see a different side of him.
Sitting in the waiting room of her gynecologist's office, Amanda meets Tony. Turns out, he's there with his grandmother and Amanda is able to get his info before he leaves. Is Amanda's luck finally changing?
Things are going great with Tony, but unfortunately, not so much at work. Amanda has missed her deadline, Kathy is pissed, and now Lyric is mad at her, too. After taking her frustrations out on Tony, Amanda finds herself alone once again.
Upset over how she treated Tony, Amanda draws a comic, which Braden sees and posts online, it goes viral. There's a knock on her door, and it's Tony - he's seen her comic and it's time for Amanda to decide her destiny.
