Airlines
Airlines
Airlines
AIRLINES INDUSTRY
G ro u p – 5 , S e c t i o n - C
Abhishek Jha (08P119)
Amit Maheshwari
(08P125)
M a n g e s h M o re
(08P149)
Mohit Nagpal (08P148)
Pa r a g Ra h e j a ( 0 8 P 1 5 3 )
Tu s h a r M e h t a ( 0 8 P 1 7 2 )
Ta b l e o f C o n t e n t s
Overview & Scope of the project and Methodologies used......................................... ..................4
Overview ........................................................................................................................... ........4
Scope and Methodology..................................................................................................... .......5
Overview of the industry....................................................................................................... .........6
Competitive analysis................................................................................................... ...................8
Product level analysis............................................................................................................... .8
Core product and supplementary services................................................................... ............8
Core Product................................................................................................... ....................8
Information ............................................................................................ ........................9
Consultation..................................................................................................... ...............9
Order taking.................................................................................................. ..................9
Hospitality & Caretaking....................................................................... .........................9
Billing & payment....................................................................................................... ....9
Product levels.................................................................................................................... ....10
The Core benefit.................................................................................... ...........................10
The basic product.............................................................................................. ...............10
The expected product......................................................................................... ...............10
The augmented product............................................................................................. ........10
The potential product................................................................................... .....................10
Brand related aspects...................................................................................................... ........11
Brand positioning....................................................................................................... ...........11
Positioning of a few airline brands operating in India....................................... ................11
Kingfisher Airlines - Full Frills - True Value Carrier............................................... ......11
Spicejet - McDonalds of the skies................................................................... ..............12
Jet Airways ........................................................................................................... .......12
Air Deccan - Simplifly Deccan - Kingfisher Red................................................ ..........12
Brand model for airlines........................................................................... ............................13
Pricing................................................................................................................................ ......14
Pricing Environment.......................................................................................... ...................15
Selecting the price objective ....................................................................... .........................15
Premium Pricing:......................................................................................... .....................15
Value for Money Pricing:................................................................................... ...............16
Determining Demand.................................................................................................. ..........16
Estimating costs.................................................................................................. ..................16
Analyzing competitor’s costs, prices and offers........................................................ ............17
Adapting Prices............................................................................................................. ........17
2
Price discounts and allowances......................................................................... ................17
Differential pricing...................................................................................................... ......17
Initiating and Responding to Price Changes........................................................................ ..18
Supply chain / Inbound logistics........................................................................ ....................18
Primary activities – Inbound logistics................................................................... ................18
Marketing Communications....................................................................... ...........................19
Advertising................................................................................................ ...........................19
Sales Promotion.................................................................................................. ..................20
Public Relations.................................................................................................. ..................21
Telemarketing............................................................................................... ........................21
In-flight advertising................................................................................... ...........................21
Costumer segmentation and their distinctive characteristics..................................................... .22
On the basis of usage............................................................................................................. ..22
Passenger........................................................................................................ ......................22
Business Passengers............................................................................................... ...........22
Leisure Travelers.......................................................................................................... .....22
Freight............................................................................................................................... ....23
Air cargo service.............................................................................................. .................23
On the basis of geography................................................................................ ......................23
On the basis of behavior........................................................................................ .................23
Bargain Hunters................................................................................................ ....................23
Relationship Buyers............................................................................................... ...............24
Critical factors for success ................................................................................ .........................25
Steps that government should take.............................................................................. ..........25
Steps that Industry should take...................................................................... .......................26
Insights derived from study................................................................................... ......................26
Annexure # 01.................................................................................................. ...........................28
Annexure # 02.................................................................................................. ...........................32
Annexure # 03.................................................................................................. ...........................32
Annexure # 04.................................................................................................. ...........................35
Annexure # 05.................................................................................................. ...........................38
References................................................................................................................................. ...39
Table of figures
3
Airline sector advertising skewed towards news channel.................................... .......................32
Top 5 advertisers of airline sector in 2007................................................................................... 33
Rise in Average adevertising frequency of airline sector on tv................................. ..................34
Consumer choice parameters..................................................................................... .................35
Flight class................................................................................................................................ ...35
......................................................................................................................... ............................36
Occasion of use..................................................................................................................... .......36
Circuits flown................................................................................................... ...........................36
Scheme preference.................................................................................................................... ...37
Customer Loyalty................................................................................................................. ........38
Factors considered while choosing indian airlines.................................................................. ...38
Factors considered while choosing JetAirways................................................. .........................39
Factors considered while choosing SpiceJet........................................................................ .......39
O V E RV I E W & S C O P E O F T H E
P R O J E C T A N D M E T H O D O LO G I E S
USED
OV E R V I E W
4
Leisure as traveling becomes an important part of a holiday
Information as the cargo business is associated with movement
of information
S C O P E A ND M E T H O D O LO GY
The report includes examples from various airlines across the world,
but to maintain specificity it retains an Indian perspective and
compares competitors across the Indian domestic carriers.
5
4) Preparation of diagrams/charts for the clarity of comparison
across competitors.
5) Identification of factors which make this business a success and
registering the insights gained during the study (mentioned in
the last section).
6) The report is majorly based on secondary data which includes a
number of surveys extremely relevant to the study. The
references are duly mentioned in the ‘references’ section.
O V E RV I E W O F T H E I N D U S T RY
Airlines Industry in India is one of the fastest growing airlines industries
in the world. Post-liberalization, airlines industry in India has undergone
6
a rapid transformation. From being primarily a government-owned
industry, the Indian airlines industry is now dominated by privately
owned airlines and low cost carriers.
Source: www.domain-b.com
7
C O M P E T I T I V E A N A LY S I S
P R O D U C T L E V E L A N A LY S I S
In-flight services
On ground services
The services provided inside the flight include the core service of
travel, crew, ambience and comfort, in-flight entertainment etc. This is
highly variable across competitors as per brand and different classes of
travel.
CORE PRODUCT
SUPPLEMENTARY SERVICES
8
Information
Consultation
Airlines are suggesting and designing products like packaged tours to the
customer.
Also, providing the customer with various options regarding the route of
flight, in-flight cuisine & benefits asks them to play a role of consultant.
Order taking
9
PRODUCT LEVELS
At this level the core benefit is converted into a basic service package.
This includes from buying the ticket to reaching the destination. The
low cost airlines like Indigo, GoAir, Spicejet offer the product at this
level and compete on the basis of price.
At this level all possible augmentations are offered and the companies
try to encompass new and innovative ways to satisfy customers.
Where Emirates airline offers onboard shower spas for the first class
10
customers, Thai Airways offers a limousine service at the airport and
Virgin Atlantic offers an onboard massage.
As the level moves from the core benefit to the potential product, the
competition moves from price to service and experience of the
customer. Various competitors operating at different product level in
India are shown in the diagram in Annexure # 02.
B RA N D R E L AT E D A S P E C T S
BRAND POSITIONING
11
implemented this positioning by making service and hospitality their
main focus.
Jet Airways
Air Deccan had substantial brand equity among the consumers and
had became synonymous with low-cost travel in India. The
rebranding followed an exhaustive market study which showed that
although the brand was closely associated with pioneering the low-
cost airline business, it was perceived as a carrier that was
consistently late and suffered serious service issues.
12
It is now being positioned between a full service and low cost
carrier.
13
Nonetheless, all need to be handled effectively to maintain the
brand image. For example: Airlines like Jet Airways and Singapore
Airlines have been upgrading to newer, more fuel efficient planes
in good times to hedge fuel costs to counter the rising oil prices.
PRICING
14
made together. Deregulation in airline pricing has given the companies
an edge to charge fares.
PRICING ENVIRONMENT
PREMIUM PRICING:
The airlines may set prices above the market price benefited by its
‘brand-image’ to reflect the quality of their service. Example: Jet
Airways, Kingfisher, Indian Airlines, etc charge a premium price for
providing frills and extra comfort to the customer. They provide options
like first class, executive and economy. A trip from Mumbai to New
Delhi will cost anywhere between Rs 6000 to Rs 23000 depending on
the class and time of flight.
15
VALUE FOR MONEY PRICING:
Low Cost Airlines like Air Deccan, Spicejet, Indigo, Goair, etc go for
value for money to charge lower by operating cost cuts. Low cost
carrier model go for dynamic pricing strategy. They follow low and
simple fare structure .They point-to-point links between primary and
secondary airports with high frequency. The airlines provide basic
services and just one class. The objective here is to undercut the
competition and price is used to trigger the purchase immediately. Unit
profits are low, but overall profits are achieved by volume. Prices are as
low as Rs 4000 which includes mostly the tax component.
DETERMINING DEMAND
ESTIMATING COSTS
The aviation turbine fuel (ATF) and staff( flight, ground, reservation and
ticketing staff) form the major part of the operating cost. Other part
includes navigation, landing and parking costs, repair and
maintenance. Apart from operating costs there is insurance, Inland
Aviation travel Tax(IATT) and Passenger Service Fee (PSF).
16
ANALYZING COMPETITOR’S COSTS, PRICES AND OFFERS
LCC reduces their prices by having high seat density, reducing costs by
providing no frill. They also go for uniform aircrafts to share parts; they
go for high airtime and generate revenue through alternate resources.
Full Service Providers charge extra premium for extra services like in-
flight cuisines, magazines, entertainment, the flexibility and comfort
provided to the customers.
ADAPTING PRICES
DIFFERENTIAL PRICING
Though all the passengers get the same tangible product features but
the intangible features like flexibility is different. This justifies
differential pricing.
17
INITIATING AND RESPONDING TO PRICE CHANGES
Airlines went for a price cut with the entry of Air Deccan in 2003. It was
done to retain their market share. In a price sensitive market like
airlines increasing the price might lead to considerable drop in market
share so any major price increases are done in coordination with
competitor airlines. Price increase leads to higher profits.
S U P P LY C H A I N / I N B O U N D LO G I S T I C S
• Aircraft acquisition
• Route selection
18
departure control functions". This allows airlines to reduce their
costs of wages, paper transactions and maximize utilization.
• Stock control
o Airlines must store and handle fuel, food, and drinks. Stock is
managed to ensure reductions in stock turnover, thus reducing
costs and wastage.
• Crew scheduling
M A R K E T I N G C O M M U N I C AT I O N S
ADVERTISING
19
slogans, message and campaigns need to be proactive. Air India has
been facing the image problem but advertising may be efficacious in
transmitting the facts and removing the image problem.
SALES PROMOTION
Many domestic low cost carriers (LCC) like Indigo, Go-Air mainly
advertise the low base ticket prices and promote advance bookings to
avoid poor occupancy. Also to improve the brand recall, promotional
incentives are given out e.g. Indigo has a crazy assortment of gifts
being handed out which includes LCD TVs, Refrigerators, laptops,
mobile handsets, etc.
20
PUBLIC RELATIONS
TELEMARKETING
IN-FLIGHT ADVERTISING
21
C O S T U M E R S E G M E N TAT I O N A N D
THEIR DISTINCTIVE
C H A RA C T E R I S T I C S
ON THE BASIS OF USAGE
PASSENGER
BUSINESS PASSENGERS
They are very important for the profitability of the airline. They are
willing to pay a premium price. Business passengers believe that it is
worth extra money if they can save time and arrive looking fresh for an
important meeting. A flexible reservation services is very critical to
them as most of their tickets are not booked in advance and also have
a chance of cancellation. The best way to reach Business passengers is
through Business media such as The Economic Times or CNBC. Also
since they are frequent fliers they would certainly look for certain extra
facilities.
LEISURE TRAVELERS
22
The allocation of business and economy class seats on a plane is
determined through a process called yield management. A good
yield manager knows the approximate proportion of business and
leisure travelers for each flight in advance, based on sophisticated
statistical models.
FREIGHT
With exports and imports increasing this has become a major source of
revenues for airlines. In the domestic segment with the need for an
increase in the turnaround time airline has been used as a source of
carrier.
Major travelers in India are located in some of the major cities and a
small customer base in other cities. Therefore Flight schedules should
be made such that the needs of these smaller cities could also be
catered. Example flights can be made on routes such as Delhi-
Bagdogra- Kolkata. This not only enhances the seat utilization but also
generates extra revenues.
O N T H E B A S I S O F B E H AV I O R
BARGAIN HUNTERS
They are the ones who are the most sensitive to price. They have nil
loyalty and would travel by any carrier. They are the least profitable
consumer segment in the market. Therefore a company should not
23
spend amount on bargain buyers. Rather they would be automatically
attracted if you have the most competitive prices in the market.
RELATIONSHIP BUYERS
They are the ones who look for long term relationship with the airline.
They are one of the most profitable segment as they are relationship
builders and not much likely to jump from one airline to another. But
for retaining them a certain level of expected and augmented service
should be provided to them. They don’t mind paying a premium.
24
C R I T I C A L FA C T O R S F O R
SUCCESS
S T E P S T H AT G OV E R N M E N T S HO U L D TA K E
25
S T E P S T H AT I N D U S T RY S H O U L D TA K E
26
Through the study we have found out that the Low cost Airlines
have positioned themselves in competition to railways by making
travel affordable. They are compared to railways and road
transports on the pricing front. But the reality is that it's not
possible for them to compete with railways on price front. Rather
they should try to highlight features such as lesser travel time
and better in-flight facilities.
27
ANNEXURE # 01
MONTH-WISE DOMESTIC TRAFFIC (AIRCRAFT MOVEMENTS) AT TOP 46 INDIAN AIRPORTS
28
MONTH-WISE DOMESTIC TRAFFIC (FREIGHT MOVEMENTS) AT TOP 46 INDIAN AIRPORTS
29
MONTH-WISE DOMESTIC TRAFFIC (PASSENGER MOVEMENTS) AT TOP 46 INDIAN AIRPORTS
30
31
ANNEXURE # 02
AIRLINES - PRODUCT LEVEL ANALYSIS
ANNEXURE # 03
AIRLINE SECTOR ADVERTISING SKEWED TOWARDS NEWS CHANNEL
32
TOP 5 ADVERTISERS OF AIRLINE SECTOR IN 2007
Top five Domestic Airline advertisers together contributed 98 per cent
share of overall Domestic Airline advertising on TV during 2007.
33
RISE IN AVERAGE ADEVERTISING FREQUENCY OF AIRLINE SECTOR ON TV
34
ANNEXURE # 04
CONSUMER CHOICE PARAMETERS
FLIGHT CLASS
35
OCCASION OF USE
CIRCUITS FLOWN
The most frequently flown circuit is that between major metros,
followed by other state capitals and Delhi-Mumbai. Delhi and Mumbai
airports accounts for roughly half of passengers flown, and metro
airports account for 66% of the passengers flown.
36
SCHEME PREFERENCE
With the entry of new players in the market, airlines are competing for
passengers on non-price parameters. This increases the product
differentiation in order to decrease elasticity of demand in the market.
Given the key differentiators that substitute for price, consumers have
rated Apex fares as their most preferred scheme. Indian Airlines, Jet
and Air Sahara offer apex fares. Next most preferred to Apex fares is
the frequent flyer program, a trend noticed predictably in the high
frequency repeat users and those traveling on business.
37
CUSTOMER LOYALTY
The following graph shows the loyalty of the customer towards a
particular brand. This helps us in identifying the Bargain Hunters and
the Relationship Buyers.
ANNEXURE # 05
38
Flight Schedule
3.2 2.41.7 18.5
7.3 Reliability
10.7 Quality
Connections
15.2
11.2 Fare
Frequent Flier
14.8 15 Programs
Company Policy
Safety
FACTORS CONSIDERED WHILE CHOOSING JETAIRWAYS Service
Flight Schedule
2.63.2 2.1 Comfort
6.2 17
Reliability
8.1 Quality
Connections
18.1
13.2 Fare
Frequent Flier
10.8 18.7 Programs
Company Policy
Safety
FACTORS CONSIDERED WHILE CHOOSING SPICEJET Service
Flight Schedule
10.1 Comfort
2.4 Reliability
Quality
Connections
Fare
Frequent Flier
87.5 Programs
Company Policy
Safety
Service
REFERENCE S
Comfort
39
• AVIATION Week & Space Technology
• Oil Prices drown out Airlines profit, Star Tribune, Sept. 1, 2004
• http://www.foolonahill.com/mbaaviation.html#_Toc83227621
• http://books.google.co.in/books?id=cVu4E4eB5lAC&dq=airline+mar
keting+and+management&printsec=frontcover&source=bl&ots=4v
MNQ6lUGu&sig=UdUBqpKpdwctx53BT8u0GCY9EYU&hl=en&sa=X&
oi=book_result&resnum=3&ct=result
• Reference: http://www.iloveindia.com/economy-of-india/aviation-
industry.html
40