Pile Foundation Design: A Student Guide: Ascalew Abebe & DR Ian GN Smith
Pile Foundation Design: A Student Guide: Ascalew Abebe & DR Ian GN Smith
Pile Foundation Design: A Student Guide: Ascalew Abebe & DR Ian GN Smith
com
(Note: This Student Guide is intended as just that - a guide for students of civil
engineering.
Use it as you see fit, but please note that there is no technical support available to
answer any questions about the guide!)
Timber
Concrete
Steel
Composite piles
Figure 1-4 a) concrete pile connecting detail. b) squared pre-cast concert pile
The Hercules type of pile joint (Figure 1-5) is easily and accurately cast into the
pile and is quickly and safely joined on site. They are made to accurate
dimensional tolerances from high grade steels.
a) X- crosssection
b) H - crosssection
c) steel pipe
Task
1. Describe the main function of piles
2. In the introduction, it is stated that piles transfer load to the bearing
ground. State how this is achieved.
3. Piles are made out of different materials. In short state the
advantages and disadvantages of these materials.
4. Piles can be referred as displacement and non-displacement piles.
State the differences and the similarities of these piles
5. Piles can be classified as end-bearing piles cohesive or friction
piles. Describe the differences and similarity of these piles.
6. Piles can be classified as bored or driven state the differences.
LOAD ON PILES
2.1 Introduction
This section of the guide is divided into two parts. The first part gives brief summary
on basic pile arrangements while part two deals with load distribution on individual
piles.
Piles can be arranged in a number of ways so that they can support load imposed
Objective: In the first part of this section, considering group of piles with
limited number of piles subjected to vertical and lateral forces, forces acting
centrally or eccentrically, we learn how these forces are distributed on individual
piles.
The worked examples are intended to give easy follow through exercise that can
help quick understanding of pile design both single and group of piles. In the
second part, the comparison made between different methods used in pile design
will enable students to appreciate the theoretical background of the methods while
exercising pile designing.
Learning outcome
c) SYMMETRICALLY ARRANGED
VERTICAL AND RAKING PILES
LOAD DISTRIBUTION
To a great extent the design and calculation (load analysis) of pile foundations
is carried out using computer software. For some special cases, calculations
can be carried out using the following methods...For a simple understanding
of the method, let us assume that the following conditions are satisfied:
The pile is rigid
The pile is pinned at the top and at the bottom
3.1
Since P = E.A
3.2
E.A = k.U
3.3
where:
P = vertical load component
k = material constant
U = displacement
E = elastic module of pile material
A = cross-sectional area of pile
3.4
where:
Pv = vertical component of the load on any pile from the resultant load Q
n = number of vertical piles in the group (see fig3.4)
Q = total vertical load on pile group
If the same group of piles are subjected to an eccentric load Q which is causing rotation around
axis z (see fig 3.1); then for the pile i at distance rxi from axis z:
3.5
is a small angle tan see figure3.4.)
Pi = force (load on a single pile i
Ui = displacement caused by the eccentric force (load) Q
rxi = distance between pile and neutral axis of pile group;
rxi positive measured the same direction as e and negative when in the opposite direction.
e = distance between point of intersection of resultant of vertical and horizontal loading with underside
of pile (see figure 3.8)
The sum of all the forces acting on the piles should be zero
If we assume that the forces on the piles are causing a moment M about axis z-z then the sum
of moments about axis z-z should be zero (see figure 3.1 a& b)
3.7
MZ = MZ
..3.8
applying the same principle, in the x direction we get equivalent equation.If we assume that the
moment MX and MZ generated by the force Q are acting on a group of pile, then the sum of
forces acting on a single pile will be as follows:
3.9
if we dividing each term by the cross-sectional area of the pile, A, we can establish the working
stream :
Example 3.1
As shown in figure 3.2, A group of Vertical piles are subjected to an eccentric force Q,
magnitude of 2600kN. Determine the maximum and the minimum forces on the piles. Q is
located 0.2 m from the x-axis and 0.15 m from the z-axis.
Solution
1. Calculate Moment generated by the eccentric force
Mx = 2600 (0.2) = 520 KN
Mz = 2600 (0.15) = 390 KN
DIST.
PILE
rxi
m
= 2600/12 = 217 kN
r2xi
rzi
r2zi
MX
MZ
2
m
2
m
kN
kNm
0.9
0.81*2
1.35
1.823*2
520
390
a2,3
0.9
0.81*2
0.45
0.203*2
520
390
c1,4
0.9
0.81*2
1.35
1.823*2
520
390
c2,3
0.9
0.81*2
0.45
0.203*2
520
390
b1,4
0.9
1.35
1.823*2
520
390
b2,3
0.9
0.45
0.203*2
520
390
6.48
Q/n
PILE
Mxrzi/ r2zi
12.153
Mzrxi/ r2xi
Pi
kN
kN
(520
rzi)/12.153
217
58
54
a2
19
54
217-19-54 = 144
a3
19
54
217+19-54 = 182
a4
58
54
217+58-54 = 221
b1
58
217-58-00 = 157
b2
19
217-19-00 = 157
b3
19
217+19-00 = 236
b4
58
217+58-00 = 275
c1
58
54
217+58-54 = 221
c2
19
54
217-19+54 = 252
c3
19
54
217+19+54=290
c4
58
54
a1
Example 3.2
A pile trestle shown on figure 3-3 consists of four vertical piles surmounted by a
1.2m thick pile cap. It carries a horizontal load applied to the surface of the cap
of 400kN. The only vertical load exerted on the pile group is the weight of the
pile cup. Determine the loads on the piles.
Solution:
1. Determine the magnitude of the vertical force: For a pile cape 4.000m square, weight of pile
cap is:
4 x 4 x 12 x 4 = 461kN vertical load = 461kN
2. Determine the location of the N.A. for the vertical piles:
3 . resultant of vertical load and horizontal load cuts the underside of the pile cup at a point
1.06m from N.A. pile group. This can be achieved graphically. E.g. On a millimetre paper, in
scale, draw the pile cup. Taking the top of the pile cup draw the vertical component downward
as shown in figure 2-3 then taking the tip of the vertical component as reference point draw the
horizontal component perpendicular to the vertical component. By joining the two components
establish the resultant force R. Measure the distance from the N.A to the cutting point of R at
the underside of the pile cup.
4. Using the following formula, calculate the load on each pile:
Figure 3-6
Pv =
As shown in figure 3.6 the lateral force, H, is kept in equilibrium by the vertical and the raking
piles.
H = 0: H-m Pr sin = 0
V = 0: m Pr cosine - n Pv = 0
where:
Pr = H/(m sin)
Pv = H/(n tan )
Figure 3-7
as a result of moment M:
ri measured perpendicular to the N.A of both the vertical and raking piles
Example 3.3
Figure 3.7 shows a pile group of vertical and raking piles subjected to vertical load Q = 3000 kN
and lateral load H = 250 kN. Determine the forces acting on each pile. The raking piles lie at an
angle of 4:1.
Solution:
First we determine the location of the neutral axis, N.A, of both the vertical piles and the raking
piles. From figure 3.7 we see that the number of vertical piles = 8 and the number of raking piles
=4
1. N.A for the vertical piles is determined as follows:
= 0.75 m
The neutral axis for the vertical piles is located at 0.75 m from the line of pile a1, a2, a3, a4.
(1.0 -0.75 )m = 0.25m X = 0.25 m, the distance to the vertical load Q.
where:
neo = 8eO and the numbers 4, 2, 2 are number of piles in the same axis
2. N.A for the raking piles:
Here we can assume that the for the raking piles b1and b4 as a reference line and calculate
the location of the neutral axis for the raking piles as follows:
(2) 0 m + (2)1m = (m)e1
where: (m )e1 = 4 e1, 4 is the total number of raking piles.
3. Draw both neutral axis till they cross each other at point c. (see figure 3.9) and establish the
lever arm distance, Y, so that we can calculate the moment M, about C.
Pile inclination 4:1 Y = (0.75)4 - 0.6 = 2.4m
where 0.75 m is the location of N.A of raking piles from eo or from the N.A Of the vertical piles.
M =0 Q(X) - H(Y) = 3000(0.25) - 250(2.4) = 150kNm
4. Establish the angle and calculate sin, cos, and tangent of the angle
The inclination 4:1 = 14.04
tan = 0.25
sin = 0.24
Raking piles
ri measured perpendicular
to the neutral axis
Figure 3-10
bn ,bq , ri = -0.5(0.97) = -0.485 m
co ,cq , ri = 0.5(0.97) = 0.485
Vertical Piles
ri measured perpendicular to the neutral axis
bo ,bp , ri = 0.25 c2,c3, ri = 1.25m
a n , a o , a p , a q , ri = -0.75m
PILE (k N)
b2, b3
c2, c3
b1, b4
c1, c4
ri
-0.75 m
0.25 m
1.25 m
0.485 m
0.485 m
Q (kN)
375
375
375
H (kN)
-125
-125
-125
260
260
23.29(0-0.75 =
23.29(0.25) =
23.29(1.25) =
23.29(0.485) =
23.29(0.485) =
-17.47
5.82
29.11
-11.3
11.30
233kN*
256kN
279kN*
249 kN
27kN
M (kN)
*As we can see the maximum load 279kN will be carried by pile c1 and the minimum load
233kN is carried by piles in row a1
Figure 3-13
Pv = k (U)
pr = k (U cos. ) = PV cos.
V = 0 Q - n Pv - m Pr cos. = 0
Pr = Pv cos. Pv =
The symmetrical arrangement of the raking piles keeps the lateral force, H, in equilibrium and
its effect on the vertical piles is ignored.
With reference to figure 3.13 Horizontal projection of forces yield the following formulae.
H=0
Figure 3-14
NB the lateral force H imposes torsional stress on half of the raking piles.
Example3.4
Symmetrically arranged piles:
Determine the force on the piles shown in figure 3.15. The inclination on the raking piles is 5:1,
the vertical load, Q =3600 kN the horizontal load, H =200 kN and is located 0.6 m from pile
cutting level.
Solution
1. NA for the raking piles : 4x (0)+2x (0.9) = 6e er = 0.3 m
2. NA for the vertical piles: 2x (0)+2x (1) = 4e ev = 0.5 m
3. Establish moment arm Y
Inclination 5:1 Y = 5x (0.6+0.5) -0.6 = 4.9 m
4. Establish the angle and the perpendicular distance r, of the piles from the neutral axis.
slope 5:1 = 11.3
sin = 0.196
cos = 0.98
cos2 = 0.96
tan = 0.20
Raking piles
For raking piles laying on axis an ,
-ri = 0.3x (cos )
+ri = 0.6x (cos )
= (0.32x cos2 )
r2I = (0.32 x 0.96 ) x 4 = 0.346 m2
For raking piles laying on axis bn and bo ,
= (0.62 x cos2 )
= (0.62 x 0.96)x 2 (two piles) = 1.037 m2
= (0.346+1.037) x 2 = 2.07 m2
Vertical piles
ri = 0.5 m
vertical piles laying on axis b and c
Q PV =
Pr = Pvx cos = 232x 0.98 = 227kN
H Pr =
PILE
ar
br
bv
cv
cr
dr
Q (kN)
227
227
232
232
227
227
H (kN)
-85
-85
85
85
-50***
43**
-43**
50***
-25
167
91
275
189
313
287
M=
force on Pi (kN)
where:
ar, br, bv, cv, cr, dr represent raking and vertical piles on respective axis.
After installation
Displacement of piles in the X-X direction measured, left edge of pile cap as reference point
(see figure 3.17)
Q/N (kN)
45.3 (rxi)
Pi = Q/n ( Mz rxi)/ r2xi
83.3
45.3 (-0.72)
51
45.3 (0.79)
49
45.3 (-0.62)
55
45.3 (0.88)
123
45.3 (-0.82)
47
45.3 (0.49)
105
Nevertheless, calculation method that can satisfy all of these conditions will be
complicated and difficult to carry out manually, instead two widely used
No end-bearing is mobilised up to this point. The whole of the load is carried by the skin friction on the
pile shaft see figure 4-1 I)
The pile shaft is carrying its maximum skin friction and the pile toe will be carrying some load
At this point there is no further increase in the load transferred in skin friction but the base load will
have reached its maximum value.
Qb = Rb = base resistance
Qs = Rs = shaft resistance
Wp = weight of the pile
Rt = tensile resistance of pile
In terms of soil mechanics theory, the ultimate skin friction on the pile shaft is
related to the horizontal effective stress acting on the shaft and the effective
remoulded angle of friction between the pile and the clay and the ultimate shaft
resistance Rs can be evaluated by integration of the pile-soil shear strength a
over the surface area of the shaft:
a = Ca + n tan a
Where: n = Ks v (refer geotechnical notes)
a = Ca + KS v tan a
and
where: p = pile perimeter
L = pile length
Nevertheless, in practise, for a given pile at a given site, the undrained shear
strength Ca varies considerably with many factors, including, pile type, soil type,
and methods of installations.
Ideally, Ca should be determined from a pile-load test, but since this is not
always possible, Ca is correlated with the undrained cohesion Cu by empirical
adhesion factor so that the general expression in e.q. (4-1) could be simplified
to the following expression:
hammer
3 TON
4 TON
5 TON
fall height
0.055m2
0.073m2
fall height
0.055m2
0.073m2
0.3
420 kN
450 kN
0.4
390 kN
420 kN
0.4
490
520
0.5
450
480
0.5
560
590
0.6
520
540
0.3
470
510
0.4
440
480
0.4
540
590
0.5
510
550
0.5
610
680
0.6
550
610
0.3
580
640
0.4
550
600
0.4
670
740
0.5
610
660
0.5
760
840
0.6
670
730
Example 5.1
A concrete pile with length 26 m and cross-sectional area (235) (235) is
subjected to a vertical loading of 390 kN (ultimate) load. Determine appropriate
condition to halt hammering. Type of hammer Drop hammer activated by rope
and friction winch. Class 2, GC 2, pile length 20 m
solution:
FRsp n. Fsd
n = 1.1 (table 10-3)
vertical load 390 kN FRsp (1.1)390/0.9***= 477kN
Pile cross-sectional area 0.2352 = 0.055 m2
***For piles 20m - 30m length, the bearing capacity should be reduced by
10%
Table value (table 5-1): Hammer weight = 4 ton fall height 0.45m
(interpolation)
Hammer weight = 3 ton fall height 0.54 m
4 ton hammer with fall height 0.45m is an appropriate choice.
5.1
Example 5.2
Pile length 22 m, steel pile, friction pile, external diameter 100 mm, GC2,
Determine the ultimate bearing capacity of the pile
solution:
qc
Z m( depth measured from
MPa
0m - 5 m
5.4
5 - 11
6.4
11 - 18
7.0
18 - 22
7.5
22 m
8.0
The values are slightly scattered then the usual while the rest of the condition is
favourable.
s = 0.5
m = 0.0025
5.2
Where:
a i = adhesion factor for earth layer
cudci = undrained shear strength of clay.
Ami = area of pile shaft in contact with the soil.
The adhesion factor is taken as 0 for the firs three meters where it is expected
hole room and fill material or week strata. For piles with constant crosssectional area the value of can be taken as 1.0 and for piles with uniform
cross-sectional growth the value of can be taken as 1.2 .
Example 5.3
18 m wood pile is installed small end down in clay. Pile diameter is 125 mm at
the end and 10 mm/m increase in diameter. The undrained shear strength of
the soil, measured from the pile cut-off level is: 0-6 m = 12 kP 6-12 m = 16 kPa
12-18 m = 19 kPa. Determine the ultimate load capacity of the pile. Pile cut-off
level is 1.5m from the ground level. Rd = 1.7
solution
decide the values for
= 0 for the first 3.0 meters
= 1.2 for the rest of the soil layer
5.3
5.4
Example 5.4
Determine the design bearing capacity of a Steel pile of external diameter 100
mm, thickness of 10 mm. Treated against corrosion. pile. Consider failure in the
pile material. Cc of the soil is 18 kPa, favourable condition. S2
Steel BS 2172
solution :
n = 1.1
m = 0.9
==
The first formula gives us lower value, therefore, the design bearing capacity of
the pile is 0.3 MN
==
5.5
5.6
Example 5.5
Concrete pile (0.235) (0.235) cross-section installed in clay with characteristic
undrained shear strength of 12 kPa. In favourable condition. C50. Determine
design load of the pile. Consider failure in the material.
Solution:
ef = 1.3
lc /h = 20
kc = 0.6, k = 0.24, ks = 0.62
fcc = 35.5 /(1.5 1.1) = 21.5 MPa
fst = 410/(1.15 1.1) = 324 MPa
FRd = m NU
m = 0.9 FRd = (0.9)0.769 = 0.692 MN
5.7
Where:
5.8
where: Am, = area of pile at each 3.5 m section mid point of pile
Example 5.6
Determine the design bearing capacity of a pile 12m pile driven in to clay with
characteristic undrained shear strength 10KPa and 1.0kPa increase per metre
depth. Piling condition is assumed to be favourable and the safety class 2. The
pile is cut at 1.5m below the ground level. Top diameter of the pile is 180mm
and growth in diameter is 9mm/m.
*Often it is assumed that cohesive strength of the soil in the fires three meters is
half the values at the bottom.
solution:
First decide which part of the pile is heavily loaded. To do so, divide the pile
which is in contact with the soil in three parts or sections (see fig.4.1) in this
example the pile is divided into three 3.5m parts
Calculate and decide diameter of the pile at the mid point of each 3.5m section
(0.180+0.009(yi) ; yi growth per meter from the end point.
Calculate the shear strength of the soil at the mid point of each 3.5m section Cmi
= (22 - 1(yi) ). Shear strength at the end of the pile = (10MPa + 1MPa
(12m))=22 MPa
ymi(see fig.
Part
T(top)
section
M(middle)
section
B(bottom)
section
5.4)
dmi=
(0.180+0.009
yi
Cmi = (22 - 1
(yi)
8.75
0.259
13.3
16.9
5.25
0.227
16.8
18.7
1.75
0.196
20.3
19.5
yti
Part
T(top)
55.1
10.5
0.275
M(middle)
38.2
7.0
0.243
824
B(bottom)
19.5
3.5
552
In consideration of failure in the pile material, the pile can be loaded up to 9.0
MPa
In consideration of cohesion force, the pile can be loaded up to 55 MPa
the bearing capacity of the pile is therefore, 55 MPa
5.9
where:
As, surface area of block
Ab = base area of block (see fig.6-3)
Cb, Cs= average cohesion of clay around the group and beneath the group.
Nc = bearing capacity factor. For depths relevant for piles, the appropriate value
of Nc is 9
Wp and Ws = weight of pile respective weight of soil
a free-standing group, in which the pile cap is not in contact with the underlying soil.
a "piled foundation," in which the pile cap is in contact with the underlying soil.
pile spacing
independent calculations, showing bearing capacity of the block and bearing capacity of
individual piles in the group should be made.
relate the ultimate load capacity of the block to the sum of load capacity of individual
piles in the group ( the ratio of block capacity to the sum of individual piles capacity) the
higher the better.
In the case of where the pile spacing in one direction is much greater than that in
perpendicular direction, the capacity of the group failing as shown in Figure 6-2 b)
should be assessed.
SOLUTION
Calculate single pile bearing capacity:
Rs = Cs As = 0.8 50 18 (0.4) = 904kN
Rb = Nc Cb Ab = 9 50 (0.2)2 = 56.6kN
Rci = Rsi + Rbi = 904 + 56.6 = 960
(Wp +Wcap) - Ws = (60 25+(600-20 5.0 5.0 1.0)) - (20 18 (0.2)2 25 = 469kN
total load capacity of 25 piles = Ruc25 = (Rci = Rsi + Rbi) 25 - {(Wp +Wcap) - Ws} = 960 25 - 469
= 23531kN
calculate block load capacity :
= 4 (18 4.4 50 0.8)+ 50 4.4 4.4 9 = 25650kN
...............7.1
...............7.2
where:
d = assumed pile diameter
L = assumed pile length
S = pile centre to centre distance (spacing)
Example 7-1
A retaining wall imposing a weight of 120kN/m including self-weight of the pile
cap is to be constructed on pile foundation in clay. Timber piles of 250mm in
diameter and each 14m long with bearing capacity of 90kN/st has been
proposed. Asses suitable pile spacing and pile arrangement.
Solution:
1. recommended minimum pile spacing:
S = 3.5 (d) + 0.02 L = 3.5 (0.25) + 0.02 14 = 1.16 m
2. try arranging the piles into
two rows:
vertical load = 120kN/M
single pile load capacity =
90kN/st
= 1.33m
minimum distance to the edge of the pile = 0.1m B = 2 0.1 + 0.25 + 1.10 = 1.55m
here because of the descending nature of the pile diameter a lesser value can be taken , say 1.10m
Dropping weight
Explosion
Vibration
Jacking (restricted to micro-pilling)
Jetting
8.3.2 Underreaming
A special feature of auger bored piles which is sometimes used to enable to
exploit the bearing capacity of suitable strata by providing an enlarged base.
The soil has to be capable of standing open unsupported to employ this
technique. Stiff and to hard clays, such as the London clay, are ideal. In its
closed position, the underreaming tool is fitted inside the straight section of a
pile shaft, and then expanded at the bottom of the pile to produce the
underream shown in fig. 8-3.Normally, after installation and before concrete is
casted, a man carrying cage is lowered and the shaft and the underream of the
pile is inspected.
8.3.3 C.H.D.P
Figure 8-4, Continuous helical displacement piles: a short, hollow tapered steel
former complete with a larger diameter helical flange, the bullet head is fixed to
a hallow drill pipe which is connected to a high torque rotary head running up
and down the mast of a special rig. A hollow cylindrical steel shaft sealed at the
lower end by a one-way valve and fitted with triangular steel fins is pressed into
the ground by a hydraulic ram. There are no vibrations.
Displaced soil is compacted in front and around the shaft. Once it reaches the a
suitably resistant stratum the shaft is rotated. The triangular fins either side of its
leading edge carve out a conical base cavity. At the same time concrete is
pumped down the centre of the shat and through the one-way valve. Rotation of
Figure 8 -4 C.H.D.P.
compression test
uplift test
lateral-load test
torsion-load test
the most common types of test loading procedures are Constant rate of
penetration (CRP) test and the maintained load test (MLT).
spread foundations;
raft foundations;
piled foundations;
walls and other structures retaining for supporting soil or water;
excavations;
Partial factor m
tan
1.1- 1.25
modules
1.2 - 1.8
other properties
1.6 - 2.0
Table 10-2 partial factors on material properties for conventional design situations for service limit state
Material property
Partial factor m
modules
1.2 - 1.8
other properties
1.6 - 2.0
Normally the design values, d , Ed, tan , can be decided using the following formulae:
fd = fk/( n m)
Ed = Ek /( n m)
tan d = tan k/( n m)
Where:
f = reaction force
Class
1.0
1.1
1.2
pile
0.5
0.005
Steel piles
0.5
0.002
0.5
0.009
NC
Nq
25
6.48
20.7
10.7
26
7.64
22.2
11.8
27
8.99
23.9
13.2
28
10.6
25.8
14.7
29
12.5
27.9
16.4
30
14.7
30.1
18.4
31
17.4
32.7
20.6
32
20.6
35.5
23.2
33
24.4
38.9
26.1
34
29.0
42.2
29.4
35
34.4
46.1
33.3
36
41.9
50.6
37.7
37
49.1
55.6
42.9
38
58.9
61.3
48.9
39
70.9
67.9
56.0
40
85.6
75.3
64.2
41
104
83.9
73.9
42
126
93.7
85.4
43
154
105
99.0
44
190
118
115
45
234
134
135