Finalresearchproject
Finalresearchproject
Finalresearchproject
A04278356
Carolyn Long
A04073230
Megan Leihgeber
A04371803
Kayce Laviolette
A00640594
MC3360 SECTION 011
Research Project
Topic: Housing
Table of Contents
I.
II.
III.
IV.
V.
VI.
VII.
VIII.
IX.
X.
XI.
I.
country (What is the National NeighborWorks Association?). The NNAs vision includes
playing a central role in creating a united housing and community development field that
produces desirable, healthy, and thriving communities. Through the efforts of Home
Matters and the National NeighborWorks Association, the study aims to explore how to
help create thriving and stable housing and economic opportunities for all individuals,
families, and communities in the city of San Marcos.
II.
Research Topic
The focus of the study lies on exploring how the ideal home can be created for
residents of the City of San Marcos. The research attempts to find the factors that are
preventing neighborhoods and communities from being as close to ideal as possible.
Supporting available research on crime rates in the city of San
Marcos, as well as educational successes and failures are pertinent in
discovering how these areas can be improved. From these findings, a
plan to provide homes and communities as close to the ideal home
could further be developed.
There is a direct relationship between communities and how one
feels about the community they belong too. A better relationship with
a community, the better one feels about the home they belong to.
Although creating the ideal home is a slow and steady process, the
sooner researchers can pinpoint the areas that need improvement,
the sooner the ideal home can be created. A large variety of factors
influence what one would deem a good or bad community, and
an even larger variety of factors need to be analyzed in order to
effectively create thriving homes and neighborhoods. Demographical
data, income, and psychographic elements all contribute to the
various homes and neighborhoods that are growing across the
country.
Amongst all the analyzable factors contributing to what makes
the ideal home, opportunities for quality education and community
safety are two of the most important. A proper educational system is
pertinent to the growth and development of children and young
adults, and a neighborhood with low crime rates helps prevent the
growth and spread of criminal activity.
III.
Research Questions
The problem the researcher desires to focus on is what factors are applicable in creating
the ideal home because it is important in generating home environments that are
suitable for all people of all ages. Friendly communities, equal opportunities in
education, and safety are at the core of our concern. The proposed research questions
are:
RQ1: What trends lie between income and housing?
RQ2: How do these trends relate to community safety?
RQ3: How do they relate to the quality of education?
These questions are central to the researchers study. Undoubtedly, there is an extensive
list of questions that could further the research, and those will be addressed as the
research progresses.
IV.
Literature Review
What type of research has been done in the area you are exploring?
Our study focused largely on what factors are preventing students and homeowners in
the city of San Marcos from having an ideal home. In our area of research of Housing
and the Economy we used several Public Relation Articles to further extend our
research. The three Articles were: The Long-Term Effects of Housing Assistance on
Work and Welfare; Pathways to Ready School: Child & Adolescent Social Work
Journal, Disparities: How Poor Housing leads to Poor Health. What this research
varied between quantitative and qualitative with extensive research on schools,
interviews and testings.
What has been found in previous studies?
From the studies we analyzed we have a broader view of the correlation between
housing and the economy in many different areas and not just in San Marcos, TX. With
this information we begin to see a trend in how lower income communitys suffer
without extra out reach programs versus communities with extracurricular goal
programs.
What suggestions do other researchers suggest for further study?
In the Article Dwelling Disparities: How Poor Housing Leads to Poor Health laid out a
great fundamental direction and outline to help build further research. Their mission is
first to define the communitys ideas of the physical and social characteristics of a
healthy neighborhood, and then to construct a plan to incorporate those elements as
distinct goals of the rezoning process.. [For more information, see Community
Environmental Health Resource Center, p. A303 this issue]. With the efforts of Home
Matters and the National NeighborWorks Association, and Dwelling Disparities
fundamentals our study aims to help form thriving and steady housing and economic
opportunities for all individuals, families, and communities in the city of San Marcos.
What angle has yet been investigated yet? Is this an area of opportunity? If so say
what.
An angle that we touched upon, but didnt go into depth was what racial and ethnic
groups in our area and how they participate in extracurricular activities and if there
were any significant results. In the article Pathways to Ready School: Child &
Adolescent Social Work Journal, researched further asking the question:
RQ) What racial and ethnic groups live there? Are minority groups identified and
encouraged to participate as key stakeholders in the schools?
---When the racial groups were identified and were encouraged to participate families
began to connect culturally and linguistically with families contributes to a
welcoming atmosphere, which may encourage parental involvement in the schools,
resulting in an increase in social capital.
If we further expanded on this topic we may be able to narrow or topic area down.
How can the proposed study add to out body of knowledge on this topic?
The trends that lie between income and housing are the more money that is stimulated
into the economy, the more upkeep their home will have, creating a healthier lifestyle
for the residents who live there. Taking care of the places people live in and the
community surrounding it is vital to a lifestyle that is not problematic in the future.
With our proposed study we have begun to build a foundation of awareness and
knowledge to present the residents in San Marcos with proof of results to help save
build their ideal community.
What Research methods were used in the previous studies that you analyzed?
Our study focused primarily on what factors are preventing students and homeowners
in the city of San Marcos from having their version an ideal home. Which linked
perfectly with Pathways to Ready School: Child & Adolescent Social Work Journal
Because they used similar qualitative methods as our own and developed a developed a
20 question interview based on the preliminary ready schools with was not as
extensive, but similar to our process of research. Our method was qualitative, an online
survey and was pushed out through Facebook with fifty participants.
V.
Research Objectives
The researcher wants to discover the elements that are most important in creating the
ideal home. The factors that are preventing the creation of the ideal home need to be
identified so that local groups and governments can begin planning on ways to fix those
factors. A clear outline of what matters to residents within a community will allow the
plans imposed by local groups and governments to come to fruition.
Without knowledge of the elements that are preventing residents of obtaining their ideal
home, there will be no way to pave a way for change. Although there are a wide variety
of factors that can affect a community or neighborhood, the main topics of research are
the wider-scaled factors, such as education opportunities and safety of neighborhoods.
These are two of the factors that play a major role in the decision making process of
where one chooses to live. Of course, other factors such as income are directly related
to the previously stated factors. It is assumed that the more money that is invested into a
property, the better its location and neighborhood. Although that may not stand true for
everyone, everywhere, it is true that residents do not want to live in a crime-ridden
neighborhood, nor do they want to live in neighborhoods that deprive children and
young adults from a proper education.
VI.
Research Design
a) Type of research
The type of research used for the design was both basic and descriptive. The research
design had a combination of the two because the researchers wanted to keep
everything simple and easy so participants would not have a lot of questions down the
road. Researchers used descriptive research because the survey needed to come across
as unbiased to participants with direct questions only. This type of research created
feedback and answers that were easy to measure.
The research design used two methods for the earlier research questions
proposed, both qualitative and quantitative. The qualitative method was used for
further exploration of the topic through textual and online analysis. This method gave
researchers a better understanding of the San Marcos demographics, the crime rates,
the current housing prices, and the annual median salary from residents in the city.
With this information, researchers then developed a survey to measure participants
feelings and opinions towards housing and its affect on the community.
The researchers main research technique was through textual analysis, such as
from the literature reviews talked about earlier. The main content found was through
the textual analysis of the City of San Marcoss website at www.ci.san-marcos.tx.us.
Researchers dissected the online content page-by-page where needed. A survey was
also taken after the qualitative research was done to back up or figure out
observations formed through the analysis through the participants.
The data collected from the research design was both primary and secondary.
Secondary research was done through textual analysis where the researchers could
have background information on the city of San Marcos, Texas and have data and
statistics on crime rates, education levels, median annual salary, and average cost of
housing properties. Primary research was also done through a survey. The researchers
collected all of this data personally and put out survey questions with the purpose of
them being answered by respondents online. All of this primary data is original and is
used for this research project solely.
b) Method of Research
i. Qualitative Research Method: Textual Analysis
The textual analysis for local residential, educational, and economical life was
measured on the City of San Marcoss website. Under the Our Community
tab up at the top, there were several different pages to go to, including
Community Calendar, Go Green San Marcos, Shopping, and Chamber of
Commerce. Under that tab the researchers selected and observed the
Economic Development page, which then redirected the study to a link on
varieties of fine art shows and community-held concerts. San Marcos has a
famous river flowing right through the city and the university, attracting
hundreds of people during the warmer weather season. The river is known to
hold one of the most endangered species of grasses in the world. The city also
has the most parkland per capita in the state of Texas, with 25 parks stretching
across 193 acres. At the river and several parks, the community can do a
number of activities including, canoeing, snorkeling, tubing, and kayaking.
The city also has a historic square downtown that was ranked by Travel +
Leisure Magazine as one of the Top 10 Downtown Squares in the United
States. San Marcos also holds premiere outlet malls with hundreds of retail
stores, drawing over 10 million visitors per year.
Going back to the main website at the City of San Marcos, the research
continued for Housing and Economy under the Residents tab. Researchers
then observed Crime Statistics, where they were directed to
MyNeighborhoodUpdate. The top three crimes in the city were from Disorder
(involving suspicious persons or circumstances), Traffic (car collisions or
accidents), and Other (including welfare checks and public assists). The top
three crime locations were on Aquarena Springs, at the square downtown, and
by the Wal-Mart Superstore off of Highway 80. The city police also provide a
Community Services Division that provides home security surveys free of
charge.
Another main factor to the city that researchers discovered through the
website that does affect the economy and the housing developments, is
construction. Anyone looking at this data can conclude that the city is
undergoing major changes in the roadways. San Marcos is adding larger roads
and lanes, new under-road water and sewer systems, more student-living
buildings for Texas State University, and new bridge plans to avoid hightraffic areas and the multiple trains that pass through the city daily. All of
these construction sites happening now block several roadways, creating
detours that result in travel-times for the community to their jobs to 21.5
minutes long. This creates talk of residents wanting to move towards the outer
city region of San Marcos to get away from the traffic, the temporary student
residents, and the construction.
The research give had researchers concluding that although the City of
San Marcos website provided great insight and statistics for our Housing and
Economy research project, it didnt quite reach or answer the research
questions that had been proposed earlier on. Researchers did discover
however, many economical and demographic data and statistics through the
U.S. Census Bureau. The research data concluded that the city of San Marcos
provides a lot of Go Green and environmental friendly links and
organizations, but there was little to none programs or organizations
designated to helping and providing better ideal homes for the community.
This website provides enough information for prospective residents or
businesses when choosing what cities to locate to. Overall the researchers
concluded that the city of San Marcos, Texas is fairly a lower income city, but
with a large opportunity of growth due to Texas State University.
ii.
Quantitative Research
The sample used to conduct this research consisted of 58 participants online
from all different backgrounds and ages. Only 50 participants completed the
full survey out of 58, so researchers measured the data for only those 50
participants. The sample was not completely random because researchers had
to conduct this survey through Facebook, generating only the researchers
friends or friends of friends to participate in this survey. Questions generated
by the researchers were aimed towards the adult demographic age (18+) since
the topic dealt with housing and the economy, a topic most children dont
understand, worry about, or know about.
The sample size the researchers aimed for was 100 participants, but only
58 people participated, having only 50 people actual complete the survey
questions.
The survey was put out onto Facebook through researchers on November
4th, where researchers then shared the survey on personal pages for a higher
Researchers also got an insight into what participants viewed or felt like
through Facebook.
Pre-test and revise- An original format for the survey questions were
created, but when the supervisor pre-tested them, errors came up, resulting
information in parenthesis was taken out, that is for researcher use only.
Implement and administer the survey- The survey was implemented and
administered on November 4th through Facebook and completed on
2. The ability to afford housing is a problem for many citizens in America. Home
Matters is a movement focused on raising awareness and funds to make
Home a reality for everyone. Home Matters is a movement that unites
America around Home as the place where lives and families thrive, and as the
bedrock for a stronger nation. Home Matters main goal is improving housing,
community and economic development and education and learning by raising
awareness and asking for donations to help support the investments to sustain
the work that makes Home a reality for more Americans.
Home Matters has different pillars beyond housing that impact an
individual in their life. Health, education, individual success, public safety and
a strong economy are all of the aspects that come along with having a stable
home. The organization spreads the word about the benefits of Home. Their
target audience is the population of America who can afford housing. They
Limitations
Over the research process, a few limitations that impacted the study transpired. First,
data was collected primarily from an area of mostly unemployed college students. This
denied access to an in-depth analysis of the trends between income and housing.
Secondly, the Facebook page, from which the analytics were derived, was created on
October 9, which resulted in a few discrepancies:
The short amount of time generated a small sample size for qualitative
research.
The small sample size resulted in an even smaller sample of participants
Although minor, the limitations on the research could have had detrimental effects on
the overall outcome of our research. A larger sample size and wider demographics
could possibly produce different results that are more readily applicable to the total
population.
VIII.
Managerial Implications
Change in a community is a slow process that requires the attention of all residents
within that community. Hood (2005) studied the effects of poor housing in regards to
poor health, citing a study that involved a Latino community in San Diego. A survey
showed high levels of respiratory problems, as well as high rates of residents with
asthma, due to diesel exhaust truck traffic through the neighborhood. The community
solved this problem by contacting the California Air Resources Board to monitor the air
quality in that community, resulting in a reroute of traffic from through the
neighborhood to around it. Improving the air quality in that community was a step
towards creating the ideal home for residents in that area.
Analysis of survey data revealed that the roughly 56% of participants believe the
city where they reside could improve housing and communities where they live. This is
an insight into the governmental aspect of this study. To create the ideal home, local
governments will have to research what specifically can be done to improve their
individual communities.
Creation of the ideal home, therefore, requires the efforts of both the
government and the residents. Active engagement within a community from residents
and government programs, and a true desire to change (and maintain changes) that
occur, are the definitive factors in creating not just the ideal home, but the ideal
community. A lack in either can only foster success to a certain extent.
IX.
the residents who live there. Taking care of the places people live in and the community
surrounding it is vital to a lifestyle that is not problematic in the future. These same
trends occur with education raising a family in a healthy home has a beneficial effect
on those who live there. People of all ages are constantly learning. They learn in the
classroom, in the workplace and at home with their loved ones about life. Without
housing and a community that are taken care of, people wouldnt be able to learn how
to maintain a healthy lifestyle in their home. Communities should be more involved in
order to keep themselves safe, physically and mentally. Changes, such as less pollution
or monitoring crime rate, can be made only through the communitys involvement.
In conclusion, housing and the economy are directly related and the community,
education and income are all dependent variables of one another. Involvement from the
community, up-keep with homes and public housing and creating a safe place to call
home is vital for residents to be satisfied in Americas housing and economy.
X.
Bibliography
Census.gov. (n.d.). Census.gov. Retrieved September 17, 2014, from
http://www.census.gov/"http://www.census.gov
Curtis, P., & Simons, K. (2008). Pathways to ready schools. Child & Adolescent Social
Work, 25(3), 171-183.
HUD/U.S.. (n.d.). HUD/U.S.. Retrieved September 17, 2014, from
http://portal.hud.gov/hudportal/HUD
Home Matters | Home is where it all starts. (n.d.). Home Matters. Retrieved September
17, 2014, from http://www.homemattersamerica.com/
Hood, E. (2005). Dwelling disparities: how poor housing leads to poor health.
Environment Health Perspect, 113(5), 310-317.
Motley, C., & Perry, V. (2013). Living on the other side of the tracks: an investigation
of public housing stereotypes. Journal of Public Policy and Marketing, 32, 48-58.
Newman, S., Holupka, C., & Harkness, J. (2009). The long-term effects of housing
assistance on work and welfare. Journal of Policy Analysis & Management, 28(1),
81-101.
Smith, T. (1987). The polls -- a report: the state in cross-national perspective. Public
Opinion Quarterly, 51, 404-421.
What is the National NeighborWorks Association?. (n.d.). Neighborhood & Housing
Advocate Association || National NeighborWorks Association. Retrieved
September 17, 2014, from http://www.nnwa.us/
XI.
Appendix
Fig. 1
44.83% of the participants strongly like the house they currently live in, as 5.17% participants
strongly do not, and 24.14% are content.
58.6% of the participants feel as if their house does not have everything they need/want.
37.93% of the participants love the community they live in.
24.14% of the participants agree they are strongly satisfied with the safety in their community.
34.62% of the participants feel they somewhat agree that they are getting their moneys worth in
their community.
When asked how satisfied the participant is about their childrens education in their community,
42.1% of participants do not have children. From those who do, 21.05% agree they are strongly
satisfied with the schooling in their community.
32% of the participants feel that their city could improve with housing and communities where
they live.
38% of the participants are somewhat affected by safety rates in their community.
100% of the participants see that the economy today affects housing and communities.
76% of the participants think home prices will go up during the next year.
The participants were asked what their median annual salary is
22 (44.0%): less than $25,000
5 (10.0%): $25,000-$50,000
12 (24.0%): $50,000-$100,000
8 (16.0%): $100,000-$200,000
3 (6.0%): $200,000+
The participants were asked their current marital status
24 (48.0%): Married or have an unmarried partner
20 (40.0%): Single
5 (10.0%): Divorced
1 (2.0%): Widowed
0 (0.0%): Other
The participants were asked their education level
0 (0.0%): Less than high school
Table 1
Date
Communicatio
n Objective:
Content
Schedule
Outpu
t
Output Outtakes
Metrics
To raise
awareness of
housing and
the economy in
America.
Outtake
s
Metrics
Oct. 09
Housing
Economic
Impact
link to
article
reach:
5
people
0%
Oct. 09
Climate and
Household
link to
article
reach:
7
people
0%
Oct. 09
Home
Foreclosures
link to
article
reach:
14
people
0%
Outcome
Not
Available.
Oct. 09
Healthy
Households
status
reach:
19
people
0%
Oct. 09
Children in
Different Living
Conditions
photo
reach:
22
2 post
clicks
9%
Oct. 10-20
No activity
during these
days.
Oct. 21
Differences in
Neighborhood
s
status
reach:
26
people
3 post
clicks/ 1
comment
15%
Oct. 21
Top 10 Best
link to
Cities to Live in article
reach:
21
people
2
comment
s
10%
Oct. 21
Top 10 Most
Dangerous
Cities
link to
article
reach:
25
people
2
comment
s
8%
Oct. 22-27
No activity
during these
days.
Oct. 28
San Marcos
Arts Initiative
link to
article
reach:
42
people
1 post
click/ 2
comment
s
5%
Oct. 29
Americas
Housing and
Economy
Photo
photo
reach:
35
people
2 post
clicks
6%
status
reach:
38
people
1
comment
3%
Oct. 30Nov. 2
Nov. 3
No activity
during these
days.
Low Gas
Prices
Nov. 4
Nov. 5-9
Survey
link to
survey
reach:
668
people
38 post
clicks/ 2
comment
s
9%
No activity
during these
days.
Nov. 10
2015 Real
Estate Trends
link to
article
reach:
31
people
1
comment
10%
Nov. 10
Hempcrete
used for
Insulation in
Homes
link to
article/
video/
photo
reach:
25
people
6 post
clicks/ 2
comment
s
8%
link to
article
reach:
31
people
1 post
click/ 1
comment
10%
link to
article/
video
reach:
18
0%
Nov. 11
Nov. 12
No activity
during this day.
Nov. 13
Nov. 14
Top 10 Warm
Weather
Destinations
No activity
during this day
Tiny House
Movement
Strongly Dislike
Strongly Like
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
2x
4.00
14.00 25x
2.
yes: 44.00%
no: 56.00%
3. How do you feel about the neighborhood/community that you live in? *
Number of participants: 50
Hate
2x
Love
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
4.00 3x
6.00 13x
26.00 10x
20.00 22x
Strongly
Dissatisfied
Strongly
Satisfied
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
4x
8.00
5. If you have children, how satisfied are you with your child's schooling/education? *
Number of participants: 50
Strongly
Dissatisfied
I am __________ with my
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
%
-
Strongly I do not
Satisfied
have
children.
%
(0)
22x
3.89 1.03
6. Rank the things in your community you find to be the most important. *
Number of participants: 50
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
Great Schooling
Safe Community
Entertainment
2x 4.00 2x 4.00 9x 18.00 3x 6.00 10x 20.00 9x 18.00 10x 20.00 5x 10.00 5.18 1.92
3x 6.00 4x 8.00 6x 12.00 15x 30.00 4x 8.00 9x 18.00 5x 10.00 4x 8.00 4.60 1.92
2x 4.00 2x 4.00 1x
1x 2.00 1x
1.84 1.20
3x 6.00 9x 18.00 7x 14.00 14x 28.00 9x 18.00 7x 14.00 1x 2.00 4.84 1.53
Affordable Housing
6x 12.00 3x 6.00 5x 10.00 5x 10.00 8x 16.00 5x 10.00 11x 22.00 7x 14.00 5.00 2.30
3x 6.00 5x 10.00 4x 8.00 3x 6.00 12x 24.00 23x 46.00 6.70 1.63
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
7. Do you feel that for the neighborhood/community that you live in, you are getting your money's worth? *
Number of participants: 50
Strongly Disagree
Strongly Agree
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
3x
6.00
8. Do you think the city could improve housing and communities where you live? *
Number of participants: 50
Strongly Disagree
Strongly Agree
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
2x
4.00
Strongly
Unaffected
Strongly
Affected
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
1x
2.00
9x
Strongly
Unaffected
Strongly
Affected
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
2x
4.00
11. Do you think the economy today affects housing and communities? *
Number of participants: 50
50 (100.0%): yes
- (0.0%): no
yes: 100.00%
12. During the next year, do you think home prices will generally go up or down? *
Number of participants: 50
I don't know: 10.00%
salary?
Number
*
of
$200,000+: 6.00%
participants: 50
$100,000-$200,000: 16.00%
5 (10.0%): $25,000$50,000
12 (24.0%): $50,000$100,000
$50,000-$100,000: 24.00%
8 (16.0%): $100,000$200,000
$25,000$50,000:
10.00%
3 (6.0%): $200,000+
14. What
is
2.0%):
your
Widowe
current
marital
(0.0%):
status? *
Other
Number
of
participa
nts: 50
24
(48.0%):
Married
or
have
an
unmarried
partner
20 (40.0%):
Single
5
(10.0%):
Divorced
1
Wido
wed:
2.00%
Divorced: 10.00%
Single: 40.00%
15. What
is
your
education level?
*
Number
Hi
g
h
sc
h
o
ol
gr
a
d
u
at
e:
8.
0
0
%
of
participants: 50
-
(0.0%):
Less
(56.0%):
Some college
College graduate: 32.00%
16
(32.0%):
College graduate
2 (4.0%): Grad
School+
(0.0%): Asian
Other: 6.00%
Biracial: 6.00%
White/Caucasian: 62.00%