Case Study of The Hershey Company
Case Study of The Hershey Company
Case Study of The Hershey Company
INTRODUCTION
The Hershey Company prides itself as being the largest manufacturer of chocolate and
confectionery products in North America. Hershey employs over 15,000 employees
worldwide. Hershey also exports to ninety different countries. Below are some of the
company’s popular brands.
1
These legendary brands have contributed to the success of having sales that reach well
over four billion dollars. The Hershey Company also enjoys being the leader of the dark
and premium chocolate segment. The top brands in this category include Hershey’s
Special Dark, Hershey’s Extra Dark, and Cacao Reserve. Expansion has also lead to the
development of different snacks. Hershey’s chocolate has been used to enhance cookies,
brownies, and cakes.
2
HISTORY
Founder History:
Milton Hershey grew up in rural Pennsylvania and left his legacy as Hershey’s chocolate.
Milton was an entrepreneur who completed a four-year apprenticeship with a candy
maker prior to venturing out to start his own business. Hershey made three attempts at
starting his own company before successfully starting the Lancaster Caramel Company.
It wasn’t until 1893 that Milton Hershey became interested in the art of chocolate
making. While attending the World’s Columbian Exposition, Hershey purchased
machinery and thus began producing chocolate that covered his caramel creations. Soon
after this discovery, Hershey started the Hershey Chocolate Company in 1894. After
many trials and errors, he finally stumbled upon the famous recipe that would become his
legacy.
In 1900, Milton Hershey sold his caramel business for one million dollars. He then
focused solely on making chocolate. In 1903, Hershey decided to build his company at a
new location in Derry Township. This location had a larger population, easy access to
port cities that would supply sugar and cocoa beans, and plenty of dairy farms. Milton
Hershey sought not only to build a company, but also to build a community. He believed
that workers worked better under pleasant working conditions and pleasant surroundings.
For this reason, Hershey built an infrastructure to take care of his workers. This
infrastructure was accompanied with a department store, convention hall, and lots of
schools. “In a long and useful life, Milton S. Hershey proved himself to be a courageous
entrepreneur, a determined builder and a compassionate humanitarian”
The chocolate industry relies heavily on fluctuations in demand. The demand for these
products increases drastically during the holiday season. For this reason, sales increase
during the third and fourth quarters of the calendar year. Several consumer trends such as
the rising sales of premium-priced chocolates and the growing concern about the health
risks associated with the consumption of such high-fat foods affect the chocolate
industry. There were 995 establishments that produced chocolate in 2000. California and
Pennsylvania were the two states that had the majority of these establishments. The total
consumption of chocolate in a year is about 3.1 billion pounds with a total of retails sales
reaching about $13 billion. The chocolate industry dates back to 1765. At that time,
growers in the West Indies supplied cocoa. The first chocolate factory was established in
England. During the First World War, chocolate was used as a morale booster and for
nourishment. From 1989 to 1991 the chocolate/cocoa industry experienced 50
acquisitions, mergers, licensing agreements, or joint ventures. During the mid 1990’s, the
industry catered toward new consumer trends. The development of light chocolate and
light desserts increased drastically with the creation of fat-free chocolate items.
3
Manufacturing Process:
In order for U.S. manufacturers to use cocoa beans, the beans must be imported by direct
purchase or through a broker. The growers of these beans are paid market price. Once the
beans are obtained, they are then processed to make chocolate liquor. This liquor is then
used to manufacture cocoa, syrup, and solid chocolate chips. It can also be used to
enhance confections, bakery items, and other dairy products.
The manufacturing process includes roasting, shelling, and grinding of the beans to
produce the unsweetened chocolate liquor. Additional processing will yield one of two
products, cocoa or chocolate. Cocoa is produced by extracting fat from the liquor. The
remaining cocoa cake is crushed to form a powder and may be sweetened or left
unsweetened. The fat that is extracted is known as cocoa butter which can be used in
sweetened chocolate or as moisturizers. The production of chocolate requires the addition
of sugar and cocoa butter to the liquor. Milk solids are also needed when manufacturing
milk chocolate. Chocolate manufacturers typically sell the semi-processed products to
other firms that use them when producing confectionery goods. “Exports of chocolate
products consist of confectionery items rather than semi-processed chocolate”.
Hershey’s Timeline:
1887: Milton Hershey establishes the Lancaster Caramel Company.
1895: The Company begins to sell chocolate.
1900: Hershey sells his caramel company to focus on chocolate
1905: Milton Hershey established an independent trust company to provide the town’s
financial services and manage the assets that were to fund his many philanthropic
endeavors.
1906: The Village of Derry Church is renamed Hershey
1907: Hershey Kiss was introduced.
1927: The firm incorporates as Hershey Chocolate Company and is listed on the New
York Stock Exchange.
1940: Hershey’s chocolate plant is unionized.
1963: H.B. Reese Candy Company is acquired.
1968: The firm adopts the name Hershey Foods Corporation.
1970: Hershey’s first consumer advertisement appears in 114 newspapers.
1988: Hershey Purchases the operating assets and manufacturing assets of Peter Paul/
Cadbury brands.
1996: Hershey launches its first hard candy line, TasteTations, and the reduced-fat Sweet
Escapes Line.
1999: The firm sells its pasta business to New World Pasta, LLC.
2002: The Milton Hershey Trust School announces plans to sell Hershey, but withdraws
offer.
4
HERSHEY’S CODE OF CONDUCT:
Hershey created the “Ethical Business Practices Committee to accomplish and the
following:
1. Implementing or communicating to directors, officers and employees the Code and the
Company’s overall ethics program.
3. Being available to officers and employees for any reporting of potential conflict of
interest, any other potential violation under the Code or other potential violation of law or
other Company policy.
4. Providing advice and guidance to the various departments and personnel throughout
the Company responsible for legal compliance and education efforts.
5. Making reports to the Chief Executive Officer and the Audit Committee of the Board
of Directors relating to key issues or investigations and any changes in overall
compliance and education with respect to the Code.
5
NO NO NO
COMMENT ON EVALUATION
Hershey’s should revise their mission statement as there is no concern for their survival,
growth, profitability, technology, self concept and there is no concern for their image and
for employees.
HERSHEY’S PHILOSOPHY
In seeking to balance our desire for profitable growth with the obligations which we have
to various other constituencies, we shall strive to
1. Protect and enhance the corporation's high level of ethics and conduct.
2. Maintain a strong "people" orientation and demonstrate care for every employee.
3. Attract and hold customers and consumers with products and services of consistently
superior quality and value.
4. Sustain a strong result orientation coupled with a prudent approach to business.
HERSHEY’S VALUES:
6
Hershey's Values, "One Hershey," tell a powerful story: A global and diverse team,
operating with integrity, working together, determined to make a difference.
Hershey's Values, "One Hershey," tell a powerful story: A global and diverse team,
operating with integrity, working together, determined to make a difference.
Open to Possibilities
Growing Together
Making a Difference
One Hershey
We are One Hershey, winning together while accepting individual responsibility for our
results.
7
EXTERNAL ENVIRONMENT
OPPORTUNITIES:
China and India are huge untapped markets. Malaysia, Indonesia, Vietnam, and
Thailand also are untapped, So, Hershey has the opportunity to gain a foothold in
those Countries.
THREATS:
The main competitors of Hershey Foods are Mars and Nestle. Mars is already a
threat for Hershey, because Mars has a stronger presence than Hershey in Europe,
Asia, Mexico, and Japan.
Unlike Hershey, Mars has historically relied upon extensive marketing and
advertising expenditures to gain market share, rather than on product innovation.
25 percent of Nestlé’s revenues and profits come from coffee, and adverse
economic occurrences in South America, particularly Brazil, affect the company.
Nestle plans to continue to play to its strengths, international markets outside the
United States, to combat Hershey.
COMPETITOR’S ANALYSIS
8
Because of the Hershey candy bar, Hershey Foods, aside from Coca-Cola, is the best
known company in the United States (Moskowitz, Katz, & Levering, 1986). In the 1990s,
Hershey markets candy under brand names other than Hershey Reese's, Krakel, Kit Kat,
Mr. Goodbar, After Eight, Rolo, Skor, and Symphony, to name but a few. The company
also markets cooking chocolate, prepared puddings, ice cream, and pasta products.
Hershey's pasta products are marketed under the brand names San Giorgio, Delmonico,
Skinner, and Procino-Rossi, or P&R (Dagnolin, 1990).
INDUSTRY ANALYSIS
Introduction:
It is a competitive force that determines how easily a firm’s profits can be lowered
because of new competitors in the industry. There are six barriers that determine the risk
of new entrants. These include economies of scale, product differentiation, capital
requirements, switching costs, access to distribution channels and cost disadvantages
independent of scale
• The bargaining power of buyers is a competitive force that can result in lower
prices for a product and increase the quality of service, which decreases profits
and increases costs for the industry. Buyer’s power increases if large volumes of
the product are purchased, the product is undifferentiated, few switching costs
exist, low profits are earned, backward integration is possible, and the quality of
the buyer’s product is not affected by the supplier’s product.
9
• Another condition that affects the power of buyers is product differentiation. If
the product is undifferentiated, the buyer has the power to play competitors
against each other and reduce the cost. The chocolate and cocoa industry has a
differentiated product, which reduces the power of buyers. The industry has
several large players that have brand identification and customer loyalty, which
makes it hard for buyers not to use a particular supplier.
• The bargaining power of buyers is increased by two factors: a number of large
volume buyers and the buyers’ relatively low profits from the product.
• The threat of substitute products is a competitive force that can set a ceiling on
the price the industry can charge for their product. If there are substitutes
available to the consumer, an industry’s potential returns are limited.
• One ratio that can be used to measure the threat of substitute products is the price-
performance ratio.
• The chocolate and cocoa industry must compete with numerous substitute
products that can threaten the industry’s profitability. Alternate cooking flavors
are a substitute product to chocolate and cocoa. These flavors include vanilla,
lemon, butter, or mint flavoring. These flavors can be used by the industry’s
customers that use chocolate and cocoa products for industrial and cooking use.
10
• Another significant category of substitutes is snacks. Many non-chocolate snacks
are available, such as peanut butter, fruits, potato chips, ice cream, etc.
• In addition to flavor and snack substitute products, the chocolate and cocoa
industry must compete with substitute products in the retail arena. Specialty
chocolate and cocoa products are used as gifts during numerous seasons and
celebrations including Christmas, Easter, Halloween, Valentine’s Day,
anniversaries and birthdays. Other types of gifts during these seasons are viewed
as substitute products. These products are flowers, fruit, jewelry and stuffed
animals
• All of these products can be purchased instead of chocolate and cocoa products.
Many different cooking flavors, a hugely diverse selection of alternate snacks,
and a wide variety of seasonal gifts make the threat of substitute products high in
the chocolate and cocoa industry.
The final competitive force of Porter’s “five forces” model is the intensity of rivalry
among competitors in an industry. This competitive force can create price wars,
advertising battles, new product lines, and higher quality of customer service.
All of these conditions create price wars, advertising battles, new product lines and
higher quality of customer service in the chocolate and cocoa industry.
INTERNAL ENVIRONMENT
11
This section of the strategic environment is a realistic analysis of Hershey’s internal
resources. The following internal traits portray a resource-based view of Hershey’s core
strengths:
STRENGTHS:
Hershey Foods has grown from a one-product, one plant operation to a $4 billion
company with many U.S. and international plants providing an array of quality
chocolate and confectionery products and services.
Hershey entered 1996 as the largest candy maker in the United States with 30.7
percent market share.
Hershey is the largest pasta manufacturer in the United States with 28.4 percent
market share.
Hershey’s main chocolate factory, for example, occupies more than 2 million
square feet, is highly automated, and contains much heavy equipment, vats, and
containers. It is the largest chocolate plant in the world.
Hershey is very cooperative with students and professors; Hershey has a toll-free
number (1-800-468-1714) that students or professors can call to obtain additional
information about the company.
WEAKNESSES:
12
Hershey’s global market share in the chocolate confectionary industry in only 10
percent, lowest among its competitors.
Concern for the natural environment is an issue Hershey should address before
competitors seize the initiative.
The average price of Cocoa beans rose 25.8 percent in 1995, following a 28.9
percent rise in 1994. World production is not keeping pace with increased
consumption. The price per pound in 1995 was $0.72 and is expected to continue
increasing. This is a major problem for Hershey because even a small price
increase at the retail level severely restricts consumer buying.
FINANCIAL ANALYSIS:
In the following sections, the company’s performance over the past two fiscal years will
be analyzed. A ratio analysis for Hershey will be provided giving profitability, liquidity,
activity, and leverage information. Further several ratios will be compared to the industry
standard.
RATIO ANALYSIS:
PROFITABILITY MEASURES
Sales Margin: Sales margin is a measure of how much net income is attained from each
dollar of sales. It is measured by diving net income by total revenue or sales. As sales
margin increases, it indicates that sales are increasing at a faster rate than expenses.
Hershey’s sales margin improved from 10.1% in 2005 to 11.3% in 2006, indicating an
increase in efficiency.
13
Return on Equity: The return on equity (ROE) is a measure of how well a company is
able to return a profit using the shareholder’s investment. It is calculated by dividing net
income by the shareholder’s equity. A higher number indicates a better return from
shareholder’s investments. Hershey’s return on equity improved from 48.1% in 2005 to
81.8% in 2006, indicating a higher efficiency and better return from
shareholder’s investment.
Dividend Payout Ratio: The dividend payout ratio measures the percentage of net
income that is paid out in dividends to its shareholder’s. This is calculated by dividing
dividends per share by earnings per share. Hershey’s dividend payout ratio slightly
deteriorated from 45.4% in 2005 to 42.2% in 2006, resulting in a lower efficiency. This
could be the result of decisions to invest in other endeavors due to Hershey’s desire to
grow its business. One would also draw this conclusion by noting the large amount of
cash borrowed by Hershey’s in 2006.
Improvements were noted for Hershey’s ROA, sales margin, and ROE. Revenues, cost of
goods sold, interest expenses, and tax expenses increased proportionally, therefore not
affecting profitability measures. These improvements can be attributed to a decrease in
selling, marketing and administrative (SM&A) costs, and a decrease in business
realignment and asset impairment costs between 2005 and 2006. The dividend payout
ratio was the only ratio to deteriorate in this group. This could be attributed to a higher
reinvestment of income to other aspects of Hershey’s in order to promote company
growth.
LIQUIDITY MEASURES:
When talking of liquidity, typically a person thinks of how much cash he or she has
readily available to pay off unforeseen short-term expenses. A company’s liquidity can
be described similarly, but on a larger scale with more line items. It is defined by how
easily a company can pay off short-term debts, in specific those due in the fiscal year.
Current Ratio: The current ratio gives a strong measure of a company’s liquidity. It
compares the cash and cash equivalents plus any current assets that will be turned into
cash within a year to current liabilities that must be paid within the year. This ratio
indicates how well a company can pay its current debts. It is calculated by dividing
current assets by current liabilities. Hershey’s current ratio improved from 0.924 in 2005
to 0.975 in 2006. Although this is an improvement, a ratio of 1 or better is desired in
order to show the ability to pay of all current debts with current assets.
Quick Ratio: The quick ratio is similar to the current ratio. The difference, however, lies
in the numerator. Instead of using all current assets, the quick ratio only uses cash,
market securities, and accounts receivables to compare against current liabilities. This is
done to further narrow the assets to those that can more quickly be turn into cash.
Hershey’s quick ratio improved from 0.385 to 0.426. Although an improvement can be
seen, a more desirable ratio would be closer to 1 so that debts could be paid with current
cash and cash equivalents.
14
Cash Flow Adequacy: This ratio measures how well a company can pay its annual
obligations with cash flows from operations. It is calculated by dividing cash flow from
operations by the sum of long term debts, capital expenditures, and paid dividends. The
ratio improved greatly from -15.329 in 2005 to 7.162 in 2006. This is due to the large
amount of money generated from operations and a reduction in borrowings. This shows
that operations are much more able to pay yearly debts than they were in
the previous year.
Debt Coverage: The debt coverage ratio determines the ability of the company to
generate cash from operations in order to pay off its liabilities. The ratio is calculated by
dividing total liabilities by cash flows from operations. A decrease in this ratio is deemed
an improvement and indicates that the company is able to cover a larger amount of its
debt with operating cash. Hershey’s debt coverage ratio improved from 7.030 in 2005 to
4.804 in 2006. This is due to a substantial increase in cash
flow from operations between 2005 and 2006. This improves Hershey’s standings and
indicates that it is more able to cover its debts with operations cash.
The cash flows return on assets is a measure of how much operating cash flows a
company is generating from its assets. It is calculated by dividing cash flows from
operations by total assets. Hershey’s cash flows return on assets improved from 0.108 in
2005 to 0.174 in 2006. The improvement is a result of a substantial increase in operating
cash flows with assets remaining relatively constant. This indicates that Hershey’s is
generating more cash from its investments than in the prior year.
All measures of liquidity showed improvements for Hershey between 2005 and 2006.
This is largely due to Hershey’s ability to generate a greater amount of operational cash
flows between the two years, as seen in the cash flow adequacy. The improvement in
current ratio and quick ratio shows an improved ability to pay off short term debts with
current assets, which is also indicative that future payments of the long term debt will be
possible. Further, the debt ratio shows improvements, meaning Hershey is in a better
position to pay a greater portion of all liabilities with operating cash flows. And to further
strengthen Hershey’s liquidity, the reinvestment ratio shows that Hershey has improved
15
its ability to distribute earnings to stockholders, thus strengthening investor relations and
Hershey’s position in the industry.
ACTIVITY MEASURES
Activity in a firm is typically categorized as creation of product and moving product out
the door for sales. Activity measures focus on these actions and evaluate how a firm uses
its assets to generate revenues. If a company is able to utilize its assets efficiently, fewer
funds from financing are needed. The ratios analyzed in this section are asset turnover,
accounts receivable turnover, day’s sales in accounts receivable, inventory turnover, and
day’s sales in inventory.
Asset Turnover: Asset turnover takes an overall focus on how the company uses all of
its assets to generate revenues. A higher number is desired because it indicates that each
dollar of asset is producing a greater amount of revenue. It is calculated by dividing the
company’s revenue by the total amount of assets for the current year. Hershey’s asset
turnover ratio improved from 1.131 in 2005 to 1.189 in 2006. This is due to Hershey’s
increase in revenues and decrease in assets between 2005 and 2006. This shows that
Hershey’s was more efficient in using its assets between evaluation periods.
Inventory Turnover: Inventory turnover is a measure of how often within a year that
inventory is sold and replaced. It is calculated by dividing cost of goods sold by
inventory. A high ratio indicates efficiency and a high rate of sales. Hershey’s inventory
turnover slightly improved from 4.657 in 2005 to 4.742 in 2006. Although both cost of
goods sold and inventory increased over this period, average inventory increased at a
lower rate resulting in a quicker turn around of inventory.
16
Day’s Sales in Inventory: The day’s sale in inventory ratio is closely related to
inventory turnover. It quantifies how long your inventory remains in storage. Lower
numbers indicate higher turnover and therefore are considered more efficient. It is
calculated by dividing 365 by the inventory turnover ratio. The ratio slightly decreased
and improved from 78.4 days in 2005 to 77.0 days in 2006. This shows that inventory
hold times have improved over this time period.
• Both improvements and deteriorations were seen in Hershey’s activity ratios over
the evaluation period. Deterioration was seen in the accounts receivable ratios,
which also affected the day’s in accounts receivable. This was due to a larger
percentage increase in accounts receivable when compared to revenue.
• Improvements were seen in inventory and asset turnover ratios. Hershey’s assets
decreased in value while revenues increased, resulting in a more efficient use of
assets. And although average inventory increased, it increased at a lower rate
when compared to cost of goods sold, thus indicating a higher turnover of
inventory.
LEVERAGE MEASURES
A company’s leverage defines how a company handles its debt. Companies that have a
high leverage can have difficulty paying back debts, securing new debts from creditors,
and are usually higher risk. But, these companies can also attain tax advantages and gain
large returns from investing. The ratios analyzed in this section include the debt ratio,
debt to equity ratio, leverage ratio, times interest earned ratio, times interest cash flow
from operating activities coverage.
Debt Ratio: The debt ratio indicates how much debt a company has relative to its assets.
This ratio is calculated by dividing total liabilities by total assets. This ratio is one of the
components typically used by investors to determine the risk level of a company. A lower
number is favored because it shows the company has a larger percentage of assets when
compared to liabilities. Hershey’s debt ratio increased and deteriorated from 0.762 in
2005 to 0.836 in 2006. This is due to a decrease in company assets while liabilities
increased. The increase in liabilities can be noted most in the long-term liabilities. This
adds risk to Hershey’s from an investment standpoint.
Debt to Equity Ratio: The debt to equity ratio is a measure of what proportions of debt
and equity are used in its financing. It is also a measure of a company’s financial
leverage. The ratio is calculated by dividing total liabilities by stockholder’s equity. A
lower number is favored because it indicates a higher amount of shareholder’s equity
when compared to liabilities. Hershey’s debt to equity ratio increased and deteriorated
from 3.194 in 2005 to 5.083 in 2006. This is largely a result in Hershey’s large decrease
in shareholder’s equity. Although the increase in Hershey’s debt was not very high, the
company used a higher proportion of debt for financing activities thus increasing its
leverage.
17
Leverage Ratio: The leverage ratio indicates the extent of asset financing from the
shareholder’s.
• A lower ratio is positive because it indicates less risk. This ratio is calculated by
dividing total assets by shareholder’s equity. Hershey’s leverage ratio deteriorated
from 4.194 in 2005 to 6.083 in 2006.
Times Interest Earned Ratio: The times interest earned ratio gives shows how well a
company is able to pay its interest expenses with earnings before taxes. The number
represents how many times over the interest expense can be paid with the earnings before
interest. A higher number is favored. The ratio is calculated by dividing earning before
interest and taxes (EBIT) by net interest expense. The times interest earned ratio for
Hershey’s deteriorated from 9.702 in 2005 to 8.552 in 2006. Although the EBIT
increased over the period, the interest expenses increased at a higher rate resulting in a
lower ratio. This increases the firms risk in the eyes of the investors. TIE ratio, is largely
due to a significant decrease in shareholder’s equity over the period. It further indicates
that Hershey’s has increased its risk.
Times Interest Cash Flow from Operating Activities Coverage Ratio: Times interest
cash flow is similar to the times interest earned ratio. However, instead of comparing the
company’s ability to pay interest with EBIT, this ratio compares how well the company
can pay interest with operating cash flows. A larger number is preferred because it shows
the ability of a company to use operating cash flows to pay interest. This ratio is
calculated by dividing cash flow from operations by the interest expense. Hershey’s ratio
improved from 5.248 in 2005 to 6.231 in 2006. This is primarily due to a larger amount
of cash flows generated from operations in 2006 when compared to 2005. This reduces
risk and shows that the company can pay its interest more times over with operating cash
flows than it could in the past.
All leverage ratios for Hershey’s deteriorated over the evaluation period with one
exception. This indicates that Hershey’s risk has increased overall. Several reasons exist
for this increased risk. The shareholder’s equity decreased, interest expenses increased,
and long-term liabilities increased. The one thing that did improve Hershey’s risk factor
was the increase in operating cash flows, which is noted in the increase of the times
interest cash flow from operating activities coverage leverage ratio. These reasons prove
to the investor that Hershey’s overall leverage has increased between 2005 and 2006.
• Between 2005 and 2006, Hershey showed improvements in many areas. Their
overall profitability improved due to a reduction of expenses, specifically the
SM&A and business realignment costs. Liquidity also improved in all areas. This
can be attributed to their ability to generate a greater amount of operational cash
flows.
18
• Because of their increased liquidity, Hershey shows that they are in a better
position to pay off their debts and is able to distribute their earnings to
stockholders more readily.
Hershey achieved many improvements in their financial ratios, some deterioration should
be noted. In the profitability category, the dividend payout ratio deteriorated, which
indicates the company is less willing to pay regular dividends to their stockholders.
Accounts receivable ratios from the activity category also deteriorated, which is a result
of an increase in accounts receivable. This means that there are more lines of credit out to
customers, which increases the company’s risk.
Overall, Hershey’s bottom line, its net income, increased by 12.6% between 2005 and
2006. This can largely be attributed to two factors. First, the selling, general, and
administrative expenses decreased by 6.1%. Second, the other operating expenses, which
were net business realignment and asset impairment costs, had an enormous decrease of
562.3%! This one expense was cut to less than one-fifth of its previous year’s numbers!
Even though the company’s gross margin had a negligible 0.2% increase between years,
and the interest and income tax expenses increased by 24.1% and 12.2% respectively, the
reduction of the SG&A and other expenses resulted in a substantial increase in net
income for Hershey’s.
INDUSTRY COMPARISON
Return on Assets: Hershey’s ROA of 13.45% is higher than the industry standard of
6.90%. This is a favorable statistic since a high ROA represents that a company can
generate revenue from its assets efficiently.
Sales Margin: Hershey’s sales margin of 11.31% is higher than the industry standard of
6.78%. This is favorable since a high sales margin indicates that the company is making
more net income for every dollar of revenue attained.
Return on Equity: Hershey’s return on equity of 81.80% is much higher than the
industry standard of 22.10%. This shows that Hershey is able to profit from shareholder’s
investments at a higher rate than most companies in the industry. This is a favorable
statistic.
Current Ratio: Hershey’s current ratio of 0.975 is lower than the industry standard of
1.27. This is an unfavorable statistic. The current ratio indicates liquidity and indicates
how easily a company can pay current debts. A higher ratio indicates better liquidity. In
order to be more liquid, Hershey’s should make efforts to reduce its current liabilities.
Quick Ratio: Hershey’s quick ratio of 0.426 is significantly lower than the industry
standard of 0.61. This is an unfavorable statistic. The quick ratio is similar to the current
ratio as it compares a narrower group of current assets (cash, market securities, and
accounts receivable) to current liabilities. A higher ratio indicates better liquidity.
19
Reducing current liabilities, as mentioned in the current ratio analysis, would make the
company more liquid.
Asset Turnover: Hershey’s asset turnover ratio of 1.189 is slightly higher than the
industry average of 1.18. This is a favorable statistic because Hershey’s is generating
revenue from its assets more efficiently than the average company in the industry.
Debt to Equity Ratio: Hershey’s debt to equity ratio of 5.08 is significantly higher than
the industry standard of 1.19. This is an unfavorable statistic because it shows that
Hershey’s has less financial leverage than the average company in the food processing
industry. This also shows that Hershey’s has more dollars of debt for every dollar of its
equity when compared with the industry.
When compared to the food processing industry, Hershey’s performs well on most
statistics. However, there are three statistics where Hershey’s falls short. The current
ratio and quick ratio could both be improved by a reduction in current liabilities. Further,
more sales could be converted to cash sales from accounts receivable in order to improve
the day’s sales in accounts receivable. By focusing on these items, Hershey’s could see
improvements in liquidity and leverage.
STRENGTH-WEAKNESSES-OPPORTUNITIES-THREATS
(SWOT) MATRIX
Strengths
The Hershey tradition
the chocolate manufacturing renaissance
20
Strong name and brand image
Diversified Products
Powerful partnerships
Strong customer relationships
making a difference
The Hershey family
Opportunities
Socio-cultural/Demographic
Desire for richer products/changing tastes
Joint ventures (i.e. coffee)
Dark chocolate health benefits
Increased importance of holidays
Political/Legal
*Child labor laws for African countries
*Sales tax reduction on food items
Technological
*Technological improvements to milking machines
*Efficiency improvements for distribution (i.e. RFID, etc.)
*Telecommunications
Economic
*Production of cocoa in new areas (i.e. Jamaica)
*Price decline of sugar
*Bio-fuel production from chocolate by-product
Global
*Increase in global trade
*New countries becoming industrialized
*Outsourcing of labor to cheaper areas
Weaknesses
Borrowing
Poor international performance
21
Decision making
Company control
Threats
Socio-cultural/Demographic
*Peanut allergies
*Increasing obesity
*Greater environmental concern
Political/Legal
*FDA requirement to post nutritional *information
*Price floor legislation for chocolate *ingredients
Technological
*Lack of government support to developing countries (poor education of new
technologies)
*Increased cost to “keep up” with manufacturing technological progress
Economic
*Steady increase of minimum wage for future years
*Steady price increase of milk
*Steady price increase of gasoline
Global
*Farming areas being used for residential, commercial, industrial developments
*Natural disasters (i.e. hurricanes) disrupting growth of chocolate ingredients
*Fluctuation of exchange rates
COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGE:
The market share is increasing globally. Customer loyalty is very low. Websites are
increasing in quality and ease for all users. HERSHEY’S offers many unique products
and services to many different kinds of customers. By offering so many distinct products
and services, HERSHEY’S is able to achieve a competitive advantage.
22
STRATEGIC ANALYSIS
MEASURES: To reduce production costs and improve efficiency, the company has
launched a major restructuring effort with plans to close plants, eliminate jobs, build a
factory in Mexico, and outsource some chocolate production to Barry Callebaut AG, a
Swiss company that recently agreed to buy a plant in Delaware County. This
restructuring effort will reduce the number of production lines by more than one-third.
MEASURES: The Company also hopes to reduce operating costs through their new
global supply chain transformation. The supply chain transformation program will take
three years to complete and upon completion will enhance their manufacturing, sourcing
and customer service capabilities, and generate resources to invest in the company’s
growth initiatives. The supply chain transformation will eliminate about 1,500 suppliers.
MEASURES: Hershey had a massive failure with their investment in the restructuring of
their supply chain technology. Hershey spent more than $100 million on a new order
management, supply chain planning, and CRM system to transform the company’s IT
infrastructure and supply chain
23
STRATEGY # 1: To restore momentum within the U.S
MEASURES: Our top priority has been to restore momentum within the U.S. “Product
focus will be shifted more on Hershey’s “iconic” brands, as well as expanding the range
of premium and dark chocolate products, such as the Cacao Reserve, Scharffen Berger
and Starbucks bars, with its new Hershey’s Bliss bar.
• The Hershey Company has intently focused on being a major competitor in the
global market and recent strategic alliances and joint ventures may be the first
step.
MEASURES: Hershey has announced deals with Swiss chocolate company Barry
Callebaut, Korean confectioner Lotte, and Godrej Beverages & Foods in India. These
three recent alliances will help propel The Hershey Company in their pursuit for global
market share.
• Hershey continued its push into Asia with a deal to buy 51 percent of Godrej
Beverages & Foods in India.
• Hershey is leveraging their R&D expertise and go-to-market capabilities as they
focus on business growth and profitability.
• The Hershey Company’s investment in manufacturing is on schedule and more
than adequate to support the upcoming launch of the Hershey branded products in
India.
• The business level strategy for The Hershey Company focuses on a combined
strategy integrating overall low cost and differentiation. Hershey is in the midst of
an overhaul of their supply chain, reducing the number of production lines,
outsourcing production of some of their products, and building a manufacturing
plant in Mexico to offset the rising costs of production and inevitably pass the
savings on to the consumer.
24
• The company’s strategy is a bid to cut costs by making its supply chain more
efficient, further increase the company’s global footprint, and allow them to
outsource production of their low value-added products
• To achieve that aim, Hershey said it will outsource operations and reduce its
number of production lines.
• The plan aims to boost use of the company’s production capacity to 85 percent by
2010 from the current 65 percent.
• Hershey is positioned for phenomenal success for years down the road. By
integrating low-cost and differentiation strategies they have made it harder for
competitors to duplicate their successful model. The goal of focusing on this
integrated strategy is to provide two types of premium value to customers,
differentiated attributes and lower prices. The Hershey Company’s main goal
becomes one of providing unique value to customers in an efficient manner.
FUNCTIONAL-LEVEL STRATEGIES
1) PRODUCTION
The past few years for Hershey have been tumultuous. They have yet to recover from
their stumble in the fall of 2005 while shifting from one product platform to the next. In
February of 2007, Hershey announced a major restructuring designed to cut costs and
excess production capacity in the United States and Canada, while expanding in Mexico,
China and India, where labor is cheaper and Hershey hopes to sell more candy Since
then, Hershey has announced they will close six U.S. and Canadian plants and cut more
than 3,000 workers in the two countries, including up to 900 at their hometown plants as
well as reduce the number of production lines it operates by more than a third as they
spend up to $575 million to overhaul manufacturing.
2) MARKETING
25
• Hershey will increase marketing and promotional spending on these products,
compared to the third quarter 2007 as well as the same period in 2006. As The
Hershey Company plans to reinvigorate sales in core products such as Kisses and
Reese’s, the company plans to double ad spending and continue using Wal-Mart
TV.
3) INFORMATION SYSTEMS
• The Hershey Company has implemented a three-year plan for the development
and execution of a revolutionary global supply chain technology. This supply
chain transformation will utilize a number of data gathering centers and
implement a core realignment that will create a more efficient and flexible global
supply chain network. The transformation program will result in a flexible, global
supply chain capable of delivering Hershey’s iconic brands, in a wide range of
affordable items and assortments, across retail channels in the company’s priority
markets.
• Finished products will be sourced from fewer facilities, each one a center of
excellence specializing in Hershey’s proprietary product technologies. Increased
access to borderless sourcing will further leverage the company’s manufacturing
scale within a lower overall cost structure. The program will result in a total net
reduction of approximately 1,500 positions across Hershey’s supply chain over
the next three years. The supply chain will create stronger margin structure,
increase manufacturing utilization through consolidation, and improve asset
utilization.
• The Hershey Company has a strong tradition of creating quality products and
successfully extending these products into new lines and new ventures. “Our goal
is to redefine the future of snacking by offering consumers products that provide
proven health benefits and the superior taste they expect from Hershey
• The companies said they will partner on a wide range of research and
development activities with a focus on driving innovation in new chocolate taste
experiences, premium chocolate, health and wellness, ingredient research and
optimization. Hershey has also recently introduced Hershey’s Wellness. The
Hershey’s Wellness line is an attempt to capitalize on the health benefits of
chocolate.
GLOBAL-LEVEL STRATEGY:
26
strategic alliances that were formed in the past year are part of Hershey’s global
level strategy to exploit the existing relations these companies possess and help
brand Hershey’s in these new emerging economies.
• The Hershey Company has spent nearly $100 million alone in investing their
global strategy with joint ventures associated with Lotte and Godrej and near
$500 million for their global supply chain technology. Hershey’s strategy is
increasingly cost prohibitive with profits not being projected for years to come
and the possibility of rejection in new foreign markets might be more than
Hershey’s can chew in one sitting.
Even in mature confectionery markets such as Europe and North America there is room
for new product introductions. Consumers will continue to buy chocolate and
confectioners who introduce new premium products with ingredients that support good
health will see higher sales growth and net earnings. Hershey Foods Corporation has
announced number of steps in support of a value-enhancing strategy.
• These include a proposed change in the company's name to "The Hershey
Company," the formation of two new business groups to capitalize on growth
opportunities, and a proposed increase in the company's authorized stock.
• They should built a foundation that is profitable organic growth with significantly
improved margins and return on investment has enabled us to achieve superior
performance on behalf of our stockholders and employees.
• The steps are designed to further support this value-enhancing strategy as well as
to build upon the marketplace strength we've achieved over the past three years."
• Asking our stockholders to adopt the new name, as this is how our consumers and
customer’s best know us. The new name conveys our long-term focus on Hershey
being a leading confectionery and snack company.
• In order to strengthen its position within the confectionery segment and expand
its presence in the broader snacks market. Thomas K. Hernquist, the company's
current senior vice president, chief marketing officer, has been named senior vice
president, president U.S. Confectionery. A search currently is underway for a
president of the U.S. Snacks business group.
• Hershey's superior performance and to extend our reach within core confectionery
and the broader $65 billion snacks market. With the creation of these new
business groups, we'll bring sharper focus and energy to Hershey's unique, long-
term growth opportunities in each of these markets.
• The company announced that its board of directors has voted to recommend that
stockholders approve an increase in the number of authorized shares of Common
Stock and Class B Common Stock. While there are no current plans to issue
additional shares, stockholder approval of this proposal would enable the
company to consider and implement a stock split as well as respond quickly as
opportunities arise to achieve its strategic growth objectives. This proposed
increase in the number of authorized shares will ensure that we have the financial
resources to support the long-term growth of our company."
27
RECOMMENDATIONS
Culture today is heavily focused on personnel health. In the past few decades, people
have become much more aware of the various factors that negatively affect their health
and work hard to avoid them. As a general rule, chocolate and other candy are viewed as
an unhealthy snack. Therefore, Hershey needs to continue to expand and market healthy
products in order to gain a greater market share. Low-calorie and low-fat chocolates are
continuing to gain popularity, similar to the way that diet sodas integrated into society in
the 1980s and 1990s. Also, studies are bringing new light on the dark chocolate products.
Dark chocolate is beginning to exhibit many health benefits in studies ranging from
improved cardiovascular performance to endorphin production to cancer prevention. If
Hershey continues to market the products they already
have in these categories and continues to develop new
products that address the health craze of the public, then
their revenues will increase throughout the years.
28
their gifts using retail channels, Hershey has an opportunity
to increase the sale of their specialized gift products.
• They have to invest in advertisement, if they have to have to maintain the market
share/increase the market share.
• They have to find out the new channels of distribution and adopt the new channels to
increase the sales.
• Company can come up with variety of Gum product to increase the market share.
29
We are suggesting the new organization structure to Hershey Food Corporation. In this
structure, we have suggested continental president, which will help to complete globally or to
increase the market share globally because they will have the experience of the particular
continents and they will work according to market conditions. Referred in appendix.
CONCLUSION
• Hershey’s improved all ratios except for the leverage ratio. If one looks further
into this ratio, he or she can see that Hershey’s has made some substantial
investments in long-term borrowing. This introduces an element of risk for
30
Hershey’s. But, Hershey’s has been improving its profitability and is performing
well in many areas when compared to the industry
• The return on equity has improved significantly for Hershey’s. So from an
investor’s standpoint, this is promising because Hershey’s is improving the way it
handles its investor’s money. Therefore, investors should welcome the increased
borrowing because Hershey’s is showing competency in its investing strategies
by providing additional returns from its shareholder’s investments.
• Hershey’s has some notable competitors, such as Cadbury Schweppes, Mars, and
Nestlé. Second, culture worldwide is changing to where healthier foods are much
more appealing. This poses a huge challenge to Hershey’s market. Although they
can create more health conscious products, the fact remains that chocolate is
never going to be as healthy as many other snacks.
• Overall, Hershey’s appears to be in good standing in its market and is continuing
to make improvements. Profitability is increasing from increased revenues,
reduction in extraneous costs, and better utilization of assets. Further, liquidity is
increasing from increased operational cash flows. Although its leverage has
deteriorated recently, future years should see improvements if Hershey’s
continues its current profitability and liquidity trends. This will make Hershey’s,
which is already a good performer in the industry, a more competitive company
in its market.
• Hershey market share is less than 10 percent, lowest among its competitor. So,
Hershey should come up with new strategies in finance, marketing, production
department and in organization structure to increase the market share and compete
globally.
• This study used Hershey Food Corporation as a case to demonstrate how to
formulate global product strategy to penetrate growing international markets. The
results from the SWOT analysis indicate that Hershey Foods Corporation has
great strengths and opportunities but also has significant weaknesses and faces
potential threats. This study focused on the formulation of global product
strategies for Hershey’s future expansion.
REFERENCES
31
• Buffa, Andrea. “Human Rights Group Submits Shareholder Resolution to
Hershey:
Requesting Report on the Company’s Cocoa Supply Global Exchange is
concerned about the rampant use of illegal child labor on cocoa farms.”
GlobalExchange.org. October 24th, 2005. November 1st, 2007.
• “Chocolate and Child Slavery: Unfulfilled Promises of the Cocoa Industry
International Labor Rights Fund.” LaborRights.org. June 30th, 2004 “Chocolate
and Cocoa Products (SIC 2066).” Gale Encyclopedia of American
Industries. The Gale Group, Inc, 2005.
• “Chocolate Is Good For You.” Chocolate Trading Co. July 13th, 2005. November
1st, 2007.
• Dess, Gregory G., G.T. Lumpkin, and Marilyn L. Taylor. 2005. Strategic
Management, 2nd ed. New York, NY.:McGraw-Hill.
• “Hershey Announces Third Quarter Results.”(www.thehersheycompany.com)
WEBLIOGRAPHY
• www.nytimes.com
• www.foodproductiondaily-usa.com
32
• www.dairyreporter.com
• www.christopherspenn.com
• www.reuters.com
• www.confectionerynews.com
• Www. publications.mediapost.com
• www.thehersheycompany.com
• www.thehersheycompanyproducts.com
• www.hersheys.com
33