Staples International Strategy Report
Staples International Strategy Report
Staples International Strategy Report
R
Report on
International
Marketing Strategy
Module: International Marketing Strategy
Deborah Pearson-Jones
Jones , Karl Sinott
The report attempts to asses Staple’s inc.
international strategy and formulate future
strategic direction. A context analysis to study
the micro and macro environment is carried
out. An evaluation of the global challenges
and international markets’ charac characteristics
leads to recommendations for future choices
regarding new markets, branding, product
portfolio and potential barriers to entry.
Stelios Christodoulou
5/19/2010
Contents
Executive Summary................................................................................................................................. 4
Key Issues ................................................................................................................................................ 5
Current Position ...................................................................................................................................... 6
Overview ............................................................................................................................................. 6
Strategic Audit......................................................................................................................................... 6
Task-Micro Environment..................................................................................................................... 8
Key Competitors.............................................................................................................................. 8
Macro Environment ............................................................................................................................ 9
Political ............................................................................................................................................ 9
Economic ......................................................................................................................................... 9
Social ............................................................................................................................................. 10
Ethical ............................................................................................................................................ 10
Environmental ............................................................................................................................... 10
Legal .............................................................................................................................................. 10
Technological ................................................................................................................................ 10
International Internal Marketing Audit ................................................................................................ 11
International Strategy Audit ............................................................................................................. 11
Mission Statement-Values-Beliefs (7S’s Value) ............................................................................ 11
Corporate Objectives and Goals – Strategy (7S’s Value) .............................................................. 12
Marketing Objectives and Goals ................................................................................................... 12
International Organisations Audit..................................................................................................... 12
Structure (7S’s value) .................................................................................................................... 12
Functional Efficiency- Systems (7S’s value) .................................................................................. 12
Productivity Audit ............................................................................................................................. 13
Profitability Analysis...................................................................................................................... 13
Assessment of Existing Operations ................................................................................................... 14
Products and Services ................................................................................................................... 14
Pricing Strategy ............................................................................................................................. 15
Distribution ................................................................................................................................... 15
Promotion Mix .............................................................................................................................. 16
Sales Force – Staff (7S’s Value) ..................................................................................................... 16
Critical Success Factors ......................................................................................................................... 17
Key Considerations - Summary ............................................................................................................. 17
International Strategic Direction .......................................................................................................... 18
Strategic Style Review ....................................................................................................................... 18
Cultural Dimensions .......................................................................................................................... 19
2|Page
Markets Overview ......................................................................................................................... 19
Future Strategic Market Choices (Enter-Exit-Reposition) ................................................................. 20
Existing International Markets ...................................................................................................... 20
New International Market s Proposals ......................................................................................... 21
Modes of entry.............................................................................................................................. 22
Internal Processes ............................................................................................................................. 22
Branding Strategy.................................................................................................................................. 23
Product Portfolio Strategy .................................................................................................................... 23
Current Offerings & NPD................................................................................................................... 23
Barriers to Implementation & Suggestions........................................................................................... 24
Conclusion ............................................................................................................................................. 26
List of & Tables Figures ......................................................................................................................... 27
References ............................................................................................................................................ 44
Table of Figures
Figure 1 RETAIL STORE MARGINAL CONTRIBUTION ............................................................................................. 13
Figure 2 BCG MATRIX - STAPLES' SBU's................................................................................................................ 14
Figure 3 VERNON'S INTERNATIONAL INDUSTRY LIFECYCLE .................................................................................. 19
Figure 4 COUNTRY ATTRACTIVENESS VS COMPANY'S STRENGTHS ...................................................................... 42
Figure 5 ENTRY MODE STRATEGY ......................................................................................................................... 43
3|Page
Executive Summary
This report seeks to analyze the Staples Inc Corporation by carrying out an internal and external
audit to reveal its prominent issues, these being in-house strengths or weaknesses and propose how
opportunities and threats of the office supplies industry can be utilised to propose future strategic
choices. Micro environment internal factors assessment such as management structure, marketing
strategy, distribution channels and a brand audit is presented to inform the company’s performance
appraisal. The domestic and international operations of the company are reviewed and in
accordance with an industry specific environmental scan, short and long-term threats are indentified
as well as possibilities for future international expansion. Suggestions are made on market entry
methods for specific regions and countries. Furthermore a revised product portfolio is proposed
signifying products that need to be either digested or empowered hand in hand with NPD planning.
Lastly, barriers to implementing the above international strategic choices are highlighted and
suggestions are made on how to overcome those.
Models Utilised: STEEPLE, Porters 5 Forces, SWOT –TOWS Analysis, 12 Cs, Mc Kinsey’s 7S’s, GE
Matrix, Opportunity-Risk Matrix, BCG Matrix, International Country/Region Attractiveness Matrix
4|Page
Key Issues
∂ Ability to remain competitive within the domestic and international markets considering the
economic climate uncertainty which affects consumer demand accordingly
∂ Ability to attract competent associates (employees) and in-house knowledge to balance labour
costs with their increased needs
∂ Manage relations with third party vendors to minimize negative possible effects of dependency
and scenarios of them failing to deliver on quality, time and contract terms agreed.
∂ Balancing product mix and brand portfolio between proprietary branded products and third
party vendors products to avoid interest conflict, cannibalization of brands, poor financial
performance and intellectual property issues that arise
∂ Ability to secure external funding considering the hesitant attitude of financial institutions
towards lending large amount of money
∂ Strategic choices for international expansion that result from extensive environmental scanning,
resource availability and efficiency within the new marketplace as well as the alignment of
corporate goals and vision for these to reflect the extended strategy.
5|Page
Current Position
Overview
Staples Inc is an American origin provider of office products and services. The company was founded
in Boston Massachusetts, back in 1986. Since then, the small corporation has grown to become the
world’s industry specific leading provider. Its first superstores were set up to offer an easy to shop
store environment, with quality in-stock products and knowledgeable personnel. As of 2007 the
corporation is divided into 3 distinct divisions, North American Retail, North American Delivery and
International Operations. Staples, markets its products under 3 different brand names which are
‘Contract’, ‘Staples Business Delivery’ and ‘Quill’. Its product mix has developed to encompass both
products and services which are provided via retail stores, catalogue sales and online. From office
stationery to printing and mailing services, Staples is dedicated to deliver in every ‘moment of truth’
to its brand promise which is ‘making buying office products easy’. Its corporate strategy as provided
by the Staple’s 2007 Annual Report calls upon three areas of focus. These are: for employees to
become neighbours of choice, the Staple’s brand to be differentiated and responsible growth. Staple
today employs 76,000 associates (employees) on a full and part-time basis. For the fiscal year ended
January 2008, Staples reported a 6.7% YOY growth on turnover to reach 19.4 million, while its profits
recorded an increase of 5.8% YOY. Staple’s International Operations represent however only 14% of
its annual turnover.
Strategic Audit
Staples Inc. operates in the global market of office services and suppliers which had a turnover of
USD $177 billion in 2007. The market has grown steadily at a YOY increase of 2.6% and is forecasted
that sector worth will reach $200 billion by 2012 with a compound rate of 2.52% from 2007 to 2012
(See Table 1, page 7). This suggests that while total market valuation increases this happens at a
slower rate which is affected by external uncontrollable factors such as economic instability; rising
inflation levels, legislative constraints and consumers’ lowered disposable income(Marketing, 2009).
Market operations are concentrated to 3 major geographical regions which are Americas, Asia
Pacific and Europe. As of 2007, the Americas amount for the56.4% of the global market with the US
being the most important market within the region. Europe has a total share of 24% and Asia Pacific
the remaining 19.4%. The declining growth rate of the North American division is largely attributed
to the high number of big general suppliers like Costco and Wal-Mart that offer customers the ability
to purchase their office supplies together with their regular shopping thus avoid buying from
specialist retailers like Staples. Having a wider choice, causes customers to become more price
sensitive and weakens the bargaining power of suppliers.
6|Page
For the years 2007-2012 analysts predict growth rates of 2.76%, 3.07% and 1.43 for Americas,
Europe and Asia pacific respectively. For a more detail look on industry growth rate analysis (See
Table 1 below).
Table 1 CAGR 2003-2012 BY SECTOR
The paper-based products segment was the markets’ most lucrative in 2007, generating total
revenues of $78.4 billion, and equivalent to 44.4% of the market's overall value. The office services
segment contributed revenues of $34.9 billion in 2007, equating to 19.8% of the market's aggregate
revenues (See Table 7, page 32)
7|Page
Task-Micro Environment
The report utilises the Porters’ 5 Forces framework(Porter, 1980) to audit the operating environment
of Staples from an outside-inside view. For a detailed break-down of the framework please see Table
3 (page 27)
Key Competitors
Table 2 KEY COMPETITORS
• Substitutes
The threat of substitutes within this industry is moderate. Environmental practices created a
differentiated offering of eco-friendly products. Switching costs are moderate due to already
developed ICT systems by market players.
• Industry Competitiveness
We define the ‘industry’ as all retail-online-direct mail and superstore companies. The industry is
highly fragmented and penetration varies according to geographic region. US and Western Europe
are the major regions of operations. Furthermore Internet has made price-comparison easier. The
original case study suggests that the global market is moderately competitive. However, according to
data analysed this report found the degree of rivalry being very strong.
• New Entrants
Nature of products being commoditized offers loyalty incentive. This combined with low end-user
switching costs and easy access to suppliers and distribution channels attracts potential new
8|Page
entrants. Environmental concerns among consumers led to increasing demand for eco-friendly
products and the creation of a new niche market. Economies of scale are high especially in
fragmented markets encouraging prospective entrants. However Mergers and Acquisitions are
common within the industry as smaller companies find it difficult to stay competitive. Furthermore,
the global market develops at a fairly stable rate, something which discourages new entrants. The
threat from new entrants can be characterised as moderate.
• Power of Suppliers
Numerous suppliers especially from low cost Asia region decrease suppliers’ power. Big players
integrate by branding proprietary products thus diminishing the power of third party suppliers.
Overall, supplier power is moderate.
Macro Environment
The external environment‘s forces affecting the company, have been analysed using an alteration of
the original PESTEL framework (Brennan, 2008). The new model, ‘STEEPLE’ was customised to reflect
not only the cause of the external force but also the risk/opportunity that Staples faces. Furthermore
the model includes an ‘action’ parameter where possible measures and actions are proposed for the
Company to exploit opportunities and risks that arise. In order to determine which of the external
forces identified are the most important for Staples’ to consider, the modified model weighs them
according to immediacy parameters: potential impact, time, type, trend and relative importance as
suggested by Morrison (2009)
This section summarises the most prominent factors affecting Staple’s external environment. You
are highly encouraged to take a look at Table 4 (pages 28-29) where a detailed STEEPLE analysis is
presented.
Political
• Increase in U.S minimum wage = decreasing revenue per employee
• Deregulation of international trade barriers and the ease of doing business abroad = Creates
new opportunities for expansion to nations that used to have high trade costs, high import
tariffs and legal barriers.
• Attempts for mergers or acquisition may be blocked due to competition policies.
Economic
• Credit crunch, economic fluctuations and instability affected negatively consumer spending,
especially in Portugal, UK, Germany, Ireland and the Unites States
• End-user disposable income has decreased
• Consumer confidence is low
• Banks hesitant to lend
9|Page
Social
• Widespread adoption of internet broadband and increase in size of price comparison websites =
consumers price sensitive and non-responsive to loyalty schemes.
• Greater need for social housing and single living people
Ethical
• Ethical concerns among customers that have to do with corruption, fraud, and child labour as
well as issues of ethnical minorities, diversity and inclusion.
Environmental
• Alert of customers for Global pollution
• regulatory bodies monitoring urge companies to use more biodegradable fuel and lessen
impacts on environment
Legal
• Increased Health and Safety Legislation
• Changing National Legislation and Regulatory Obligations in different countries
Technological
• Consumers are becoming more and more sophisticated posing the risk for Staple’s products to
become outdated and non-attractive to its target market.
• Technology is ever changing
The report suggests that you study Table 6 (pages 30-31) where findings of the STEEPLE analysis are
linked and transformed to future strategic choices. This detailed analysis will inform the SWOT and
strategic direction proposed at a later stage in the document.
10 | P a g e
International Internal Marketing Audit
The internal audit process incorporates the audit components as suggested by Kotler and Keller
(2006).Furthermore, some of McKinsey’s 7S’s (Pascale & Athos, 1981) variables are selectively used
to assess the internal environment from a an inside-outside view.
In its 2007 Annual Report, Staples stresses 4 particular values- using the acronym CARE -which
summarise its beliefs. These values are: Customer care, Associates support, communicate the Real
thing and finally Execute the corporate goals as defined. In addition, Staples embraces the idea of
the good corporate citizen having defined through its StaplesSoul and Code of Ethics the company’s
philosophy.
This philosophy comprises a holistic approach(Lewis, Frank, & Alexander) to doing business -both
internally and externally- with integrity and fairness avoiding fraud and corruption. Its foundation
principles include issues of: ethical dilemmas, environment protection, diversity and giving back
to the community.
To support the above commitments Staples introduced Staples EcoEasy challenge, a recycling
program for electronics. Other evident actions that prove its commitment include switching from its
paper vendor APP (Asia Pulp and Paper) previously accused for non-environmental practices and
donating money for foundations, social projects and community programmes(Marketing, 2009).
These environmental actions and community obligations call upon the positive impact Staples has on
the community making associates to embrace the process and invite customers to join efforts.
Ultimate goal of the focus on CSR is of course profitability which is hard to achieve because of the
disproportionate amount between money being spent to develop such ‘green’ mechanisms and
the return from charging small price-premiums on products and the intangible nature of
“increased” goodwill value. Despite its focus on diversity Staples seems to be doing badly on
addressing minority issues and female employment. Number of women associates increased only
2% from last year reaching 22% against a 42% industry average whereas the number of minority
associates employed increased 7% to reach 12% again 15% industry average.
11 | P a g e
Corporate Objectives and Goals – Strategy (7S’s Value)
Staples highlights in its 2007 Annual Report three strategic principles that inform the goals of its
strategy. The Corporate Objectives as identified in 2007 are:
The Corporate Goals that result from the above objectives are:
∂ Differentiating the Staples brand by making the purchase of office products easy
∂ Achieve industry-best execution and expand responsibly its market share in every region
Staples operates in
∂ Increase own-brand sales from 22% to 30% (next 5 years).
Positioning: Leaders in office and related products, innovators in terms of ethical sourcing,
environmentally concerned and health and safety, associates and partners training.
12 | P a g e
stores. This number does not correspond to the divisions’ contribution in the global industry value
which is 46.8%. From further analysis carried out in Table 8 it is proven that the marginal
contribution of every added new store in the North American Division, Staples earns a smaller profit
margin compared to a store opening internationally see Figure 1 below. Except from the UK all
other current international markets of operation can afford more stores with Germany and China
having the greatest potential for growth.
Productivity Audit
Profitability Analysis
Analysing the given consolidated financial data we can draw some basic conclusions regarding
Staples financial position. Gross Profit Margin for the company increased from 28.56% in 2007 to
28.61% reflecting a healthy financial organic growth. Compared to major competitors Staples comes
second behind Pitney Bows Inc. having a 5.15% net profit margin ratio. This proves the ability of the
company to remain competitive within its sector. A 1.95 Working Capital or Current Ratio illustrates
that Staple’s short-term assets can be used immediately to pay off its short-term liabilities. Staples
uses its own measure for monitoring financial performance, the RONA (Return on Net Assets). For
the year 2007 RONA was 13.8%, an increase of 1.2% from 2005 and decrease of 0.5% from 2006.
Despite the small fluctuation the metric suggests that management is able to make significant profits
on assets managed. North American Retail has been historically the most profitable and grown
division generating 52% of total sales. North American Delivery contributed with a 34% share and
International Operations accounted only for the 14% of income. it is evident that income from
external operations comprises only a small proportion of sales. This translates as $2.74 billion from
operations abroad and $16.63 from North American operations, see Table 10 (page 34)
13 | P a g e
Assessment of Existing Operations
It becomes apparent that Staples will need to focus on its growing SBUs and digest some others
e.g. office furniture, if it is to increase overall efficiency and profitability. Investing in other diverse
segments it is a level-headed choice in the long-term. The BCG Matrix above turns into a
Directional policy matrix(Butterworth-Heinemann, 2001) pointing out the future direction for the
companies SBUS’s. The Office Supplies and Services SBU has to be given extra focus to remain a
star. Business Machines and Related Products need to move from being a question mark to
become a star and computer related products have to be milked by becoming a cash cow. Lastly
the furniture SBU needs to be digested or restructured.
14 | P a g e
The company aims to gain competitive advantage from having a number of items always in-stock -
ink, toner and cartridges - and promotes this ability dynamically. Own brand products account for
22% of turnover and this will eventually cause perplexity between Staples and third-party suppliers.
Staples has to make sure that keeps a balance between the amount of proprietary brands and
third party brands offered through its product mix to prevent heated discussions.
Pricing Strategy
The products and services of Staples are targeted to both the B2B and B2C segments. Staples,
aligned with its differentiation strategy seems to follow a pricing scheme that is mostly found in
mature industries(Mills, 2002). This suggests that the company should strive to achieve the highest
product/service quality differentiated position relative to competition coupled with an acceptable
delivered cost structure and pricing policy to gain margins sufficient to fund re-investment in the
differentiation. To add on the above Staples offers its own-branded products with a typical 10-15%
price reduction compared to substitute brands.
Profitability for Staples will come from a combination of pricing strategies these being premium
pricing for differentiated products, geographical and penetration pricing when expanding
internationally and finally product bundle and promotional pricing strategies for
promotions(Bradley, 2002). If orchestrated appropriately, these strategies will offer flexibility to
the company to price accordingly product lines and brands to achieve different regional and
domestic profitability targets. A single pricing strategy harms the business and can have
devastating results.
Distribution
Distribution of products happens via a combined network of wholly owned retail outlets, catalogue
sales and online depending on country of operation. The considerable amount of 75% of North
American Retail sales division was processed online. Staples prides itself for its Stock Keeping Units
(SKUs), allowing for efficient and effective stock management which in turn maximizes customer
satisfaction. This exceptional distribution instrument offers Staples an economic advantage through
utilising the distribution learning curve(Ebbinghaus, 1964) and gains from economies of scale which
result from time-efficient delivery. The company saved USD300 million in inventory costs since 2005
using effectively the SKU’s .
Staples will need to transfer the know-how of this process when expanding its operations in
international markets and apply its successful online order-processing system to other national
website. SKU’s success has to be also replicated in especially heavily saturated markets.
15 | P a g e
Promotion Mix
Staples communicates with customers through a combination of internet marketing, telesales, direct
mail, TV, radio, newspapers and circulars. It makes sure every emanated message is consistent and
addresses to consumers’ needs as well as reflects the character of the company. Communicated
messages intend to empower brand awareness and increase stores traffic.
Staples Reward –the company’s only loyalty scheme- has not delivered the expected results and
has to be reviewed the soonest possible with new exciting incentives. Benchmarking the
promotional efforts of other competitors is a ‘safe’ scenario that has been at least tried before.
The company needs to identify which are these groups of associates underperforming and where
do they operate. By isolating those, Staples can expose the problem and try to bring on the
appropriate mechanisms that will eventually improve performance of stores.
16 | P a g e
Critical Success Factors
According to Treacy & Wiersema (1995) a global brand needs to excel in one of the following 3 value
disciplines:
Staples chooses to focus on customer intimacy by giving great attention to customer service and
focuses on the delivery of product and services on time and above consumer’s expectations. Porter’s
Generic strategies describe this strategy as differentiation.
USP (Unique Selling Point): socially concerned and proactive, environmental sensitivity, ethical
sourcing and selling attitude, quality service and customer intimacy
Some of the competencies that comprise the USP of Staples such as environmental focus and social
responsibility where found from the analysis carried out not really offering a differential advantage
to the firm thus making the USP not so unique. This matter will be addressed in the
recommendation section.
This report suggests that Staple’s critical success factors are the following:
Through this analysis, the report suggests for the following strategic choices to be made by Staples:
17 | P a g e
∂ Avoid introducing new premium priced products and focus on own-brand “value pricing”
strategy
∂ Manage relationships with manufacturing outsourcing suppliers to develop strategic
alliances and long term mutual trust
∂ Closely monitor financial performance and concentrate on repayment of long-term debt to
avoid defaults.
∂ Inform and train managers and associates to prevent inefficiencies and legislative disputes
that arise from cultural clashes and lack of knowledge of foreign environments
∂ Expand strategically to avoid stretching of resources
A more detailed presentation of the strategic routes proposed, can be viewed in Table 13 (page
37) where using McKinsey’s 7S’s the report proposes how Staples can holistically and effectively
move forward.
18 | P a g e
Cultural Dimensions
Kotabe & Helsen (2009) suggest that before a corporation enters a new market needs to evaluate
the cultural elements that affect its business environment. Furthermore Gladwin & Hofstede
identify 5 cultural dimensions that affect a national marketplace (1981). Considering the above
academia findings this report applies selectively 10 out of 12 variables as suggested by Doole & Lowe
(1999) to the 12C’s framework evaluating their influence on Staples’ regions of existing and potential
operations. These are presented in Table 14 (page 38)
Markets Overview
The global market is currently at a moderately competitive stage with a huge potential for expansion
in operations especially from international players in the industry. Using Vernon’s
(1966)international industry lifecycle to plot industry’s geographic regions the below figure suggests
that the markets of Asia, Europe-especially Eastern- the Americas and Africa have not been exploited
to their full potential from industry leader firms and can all be considered as future expansions
areas, see Figure 3 below.
19 | P a g e
Future Strategic Market Choices (Enter-Exit-Reposition)
It is the degree of management devolution(Vermillion & Common Property, 1998) and the ability
to change/adapt incrementally which will determine whether the company can cope with the
global markets’ changing dynamics and sustain its competitive advantage by leveraging its core
competencies(Prahalad & Hamel, 1990).
To evaluate the performance of these markets we look at market worth and continual annual
growth rates (CAGR). As of 2007 the biggest market share carry the US with however a stagnant
CAGR of 2.4% for the next 5 years. Europe comes second with total activities of 42.3 billion and an
increasing CAGR of 1.2%. Last is Asia Pacific worth $34.60 and an impressive though CAGR of 2.7%
see Table 15 & Table 16 (pages 39 & 40).
Sales from Europe did not perform according to predictions mainly because of the transitional
period of international expansion and the inability of Staples to enter the market with tailored
product offerings that meet host country specific needs. Also Staples chooses since today to enter
many of Europe’s markets via its product catalogue and online sales channel something which will
only yield limited profits for the company.
As the market is already fragmented there is need for extensive advertising to create brand
awareness and form favourable brand image (Hollensen, 2006). For Staples to improve
performance in this region it needs to consider launching some of its superstores in the
fragmented European countries to steal market share from small businesses. The recent
acquisition of Corporate Express will help the company in serving Europe’s big corporate clients.
Staples should also transfer previous knowledge from Corporate Express but at the same time
train staff and managers to carry the ethos of Staples and the brand’s values.
20 | P a g e
Asia Pacific (current operations)
The presence of the company in the Asia Pacific Region can be characterised as ‘just ok’. Staples did
not put the appropriate emphasis into this market and failed to realise that the potential is higher
than expected. The Asia Pacific Region is becoming more educated and new job opportunities are
created because of the low manufacturing costs of the countries that comprise the region, which in
turn increases the demand for office supplies and products.
As a result, Staples has to follow now a ‘second-mover’ advantage tactic in this region. Through
detailed research and benchmarking of competitors the brand needs to develop the appropriate
mechanisms to compete effectively in the most diverse region that currently operates in. The
scenario of adding to its distribution channel its own stores and not retailing only through its
direct mail service and online ordering has been identified from the external environment as a
good choice.
a) What are the short- term company objectives and do they fit with the new markets?
b) Do we have available resources (5M’S Chaffey) to enter and sustain operations effectively
and efficiently?
c) What is our know-how from existing outside the country operations?
d) How competitive is the environment?
e) Do we posses relative advantage when compared to other marketplace sellers?
f) What are the macro-environment factors that affect the company?
The author of this report felt that segmenting the market as in traditional terms would not inform
the strategy correctly thus followed an alternative root.
For assessing the attractiveness of new markets and identify appropriate ways of entry, this report
proposes a new model bringing together the Opportunity-Risk Matrix (Liabotis, June 2009) the
Country Attractiveness Matrix and the McKinsey/GE Matrix(Harvard, 1999). The new ‘international
markets assessment matrix’, see Table 17 (page 41) assigns to every potential region/country a total
attractiveness score that is extracted from comparing 9 industry attractiveness specific variables.
Then according to the overall results goes on to plot these weightings along the relative company’s’
strengths on a new matrix as suggested by Hashizume (2001) see Figure 4( page 42)
21 | P a g e
The results revealed that the most promising new markets for entry at the current stage are South
American and Africa. These two regions scored high in industry attractiveness suggesting that there
is a huge potential for Staples to enter these markets by investing directly in them as it also poses
the strength to directly export to wholly owned branches and retail stores and not through
partnerships. China and Western & South Asia are the next two most attractive markets. The
analysis suggests that Staples should enter these markets through joint ventures because of their
distinct characteristics and risks inherent such as differences in buying criteria and cultural distance.
Additionally Staples has to take the opportunity and penetrate unexploited European countries that
recently joined the E.U. to benefit from low transportation costs and cheap workforce in Eastern
European Countries. Lastly the option of entering France and Italy with wholly owned retails stores
seems logical as these countries haven’t been affected by the economic crisis. Strategic vision has to
be in place for every new expansion attempt. Even if the company enters new markets, its sales or
profit levels may not be successful enough to recoup its investments in them and may reduce overall
profitability.
Modes of entry
Depending on the 12C’s analysis and the country attractiveness matrix a decision has to be made on
how to enter the above selected new markets. Following a method proposed by Root (1994) the
selected countries are plot on a Control Vs Risk Matrix. The outcome proves that entering Africa and
South America via own subsidiaries and sourcing products directly is the most preferred root see
Figure 5 (page 43).
Internal Processes
For Staples expansion strategy to yield the expected results it needs to be communicated both
internally and externally. Staples needs to become a learning organisation(Argyris & Schön, 1978)
that shares its vision and values among all operational levels thus involving everyone in the decision
making process. A feedback loop mechanism has to developed by adopting a deutero-learning
procedure as suggested by Dodgson (1991). This will mean that Staples learns to identify its mistakes
and errors, while at the same time questions and modifies its existing norms, procedures and
policies.
Drawing on Miles and Snow(1978) findings for international strategic options, Staples will need to
adopt the strategy of the Prospector in the new and unexploited markets such as South Africa and
South America. This strategy seeks to create new products, exploit new opportunities and shape the
marketplace. In mature markets such as the ones of US and Western Europe, Staples need to take
the role of the Defender. This will allow it to protect its market position through efficient production
and strong control mechanism of continuity and reliability. Lastly in markets that still allow for
growth such as the countries of India, Canada and Eastern Asia the company needs to take the role
22 | P a g e
of the Analyser. By doing that Staples will avoid excessive risk and focus on the development and
delivery of new products by careful assessing alternatives within these markets.
Branding Strategy
Global brands have more visibility than other brands, they can benefit from economies for scale,
capitalize from extensive media coverage and overlap according to Aaker(2000). Fair enough, but
sometimes the attempt to exit domestic borders can result to a disaster if not planned strategically.
Because of Staple’s operating sector complexity - the office & supplies products – and the
homogeneity of products, it is basically unattainable the idea of becoming a global brand in terms of
a brand like Coca Cola. However, Staples can create a holistic brand image that carries its values and
beliefs; As highlighted above this brand essence cannot be based on its product characteristics and
attributes as those need to be modified to adapt to each region’s special cultural characteristics.
Staples needs to follow the example of the financial services company HSBC. HSBC has identified the
need for being differentiated in a sector that allows for very limited differentiation chances due to
its product nature. The bank created an integrated marketing communications campaign to deliver
the message that: it is the ‘world’s local bank’, meaning that the bank cares for the individuality of its
customers and respects its local differences by altering its product offering to suit those needs.
According to Wellman’s (1999) theory, Staples should aim to become a Glocalised brand that has a
unified and consistent positioning across geographic borders without necessarily having the same
name or marketing program but with tailored region specific practices and product/ service
offerings.
23 | P a g e
according to region specific requirement and communication messages to be tailored accordingly.
Threats such as cultural differences, product usage purposes, purchase decision criteria have already
been identified in this report as possible failure variables to the expansion process. Furthermore
innovation has to be in the centre of the NPD process for Staples. Finding new suppliers that will
offer competitive advantage either via complementing the current product mix with breakthrough
products or by supplying products cheaper, it is a major criterion for success. This report suggests
that the way forward for Staples is to focus on IT services and Hardware office equipment such as
copy and printing machinery. As identified above these two niche markets are growing significantly
and Staples by taking advantage of its core competencies and mechanisms that has already in place -
such as supply chain and e-commerce- can gain a significant amount of market share. New
innovative products need to be launched using a Sprinkler Strategy to increase awarness and create
buzz, whereas products that meet basic consumer needs such as simple pens and booklets need to
follow an organic Waterfall model strategy (Riesenbeck & Perrey, 2009)
# BARRIERS RECOMMENDATIONS
One of the most important constrains is ∂ Receivables forecasting and financial control
funding. Staples has issued commercial mechanism to avoid stretching and wasting
paper for managing short-term debt which valuable resources
1
is due for repayment in 2012. ∂ Option to borrow today with favourable terms from
private financial institutions
∂ Raise funding internally ( investors contribution)
INTERNAL The ability to change and adapt to new ∂ Benchmark processes and product features from
NON national environments with different existing market’s successful companies
2
TARRIF culture, buying patterns and purchase ∂ Merge or Join with existing market players to avoid
RELATED criteria. failure and benefit from economies of scale
The extent to which Staples can develop ∂ Develop strategic alliances with companies from
the appropriate distribution networks, find diverse industries e.g. Procter & Gamble to share
3
the right partners abroad and collect information and expertise
market related information. ∂ Duplicate successful SKU’s abroad
24 | P a g e
attract competent employees as well as valuable information to managers
inform and educate managers on issues ∂ Develop SERVQUAL standards and process specific
arising from international expansion to Blueprints to inform associates.
avoid management inefficiencies ∂ CRM system to encourage repeat purchase, increase
customer satisfaction which will result to loyalty
Complying with national legislation and ∂ Advise solicitors specialising in international cases
regulation will be a key determinant for and expansion
5 success if it is for Staples to avoid legal ∂ Create a monitoring and update method to obtain
contravention and damaging of corporate up to date information on current and changing
reputation. legislations
6 Dealing with tariffs and quotas from ∂ Get hold on information on country specific cases
existing and future international operations prior to entering will result to efficiency and prevent
sudden costs
7 Debtors in different countries will demand ∂ Devise an efficient debt collection unit in every
EXTERNAL different credit terms as well as the country of operation which will report in tactical
possibly of some of them failing to repay periods to its corresponding financial department
resulting in bad debts written off. ∂ Forecast subjectively to avoid surprises
8 Exchange Rate volatility and fluctuations in ∂ Monitor currency exchange rates – considering also
national market economies. liquidity - to benefit from favourable exchange
rates
∂ Report Balance sheets and Income Statements in
common currency to avoid causing confusion among
investors
25 | P a g e
Conclusion
Staples is currently considered as an international corporation trying to establish a sturdy presence
in the global market. The key issues outlined above need to be addressed via a thorough strategic
plan injected with a strategic intent that signals clear direction, a desire for growth and destine to
succeed(Hamel & Prahalad, 2010). This will consequently add considerable value to the brand’s
equity (Aaker & Joachimsthaler, 2000) in the long-term. If implemented correctly Its points of
difference(Carpenter & Nakamoto, 1989) will become USP’s (Unique Selling Points) that eventually
increase sales and profitability. Staples core competencies need to be sustainable and replicable so
they can be transferred to new markets(Deiser & Ebooks, 2009). These, supported by the
management’s ability to raise capital domestically as well as internationally will determine whether
it can remain competitive within its sector. The report suggests for an aggressive expansion in
embryonic stage industries to exploit Kim’s ‘blue ocean’ opportunities(Kim & Mauborgne, 2005) and
benefit from the first-mover advantage(Kerin, Varadarajan, & Peterson, 1992). Furthermore, a
cautious entry in the already fragmented international markets is proposed. Most promising regions
identified are Eastern and less Western Europe, South America, South Africa and China. Domestically
Staples needs to review its store efficiency by reducing number of stores in some areas and
introduce new in other regions. It will also need to cope with employee efficiency and forming
favourable relations with stakeholders that will eventually ask for more dividends in the near future
because of the increasing sales. Its product portfolio has to be updated with the introduction of new
and innovative products with focus given on IT services and hardware equipment. Branding of the
company should be adaptive to tackle the cultural and economic differences of its diverse markets.
However, same brand offerings need to exist especially in western culture countries were usage and
buying patterns are similar in order to emanate a rigid and crystal-clear brand proposition that will
form favourable brand perceptions. The barriers towards this plan will be the Staple’s ability to
understand the degree of difference in every other market it operates; the capability to finance the
expansion, ability to cope with taxation, tariffs and quotas and the aptitude of being able to make
brave decisions - such as digesting its current furniture SBU - that dilute cumulative performance
26 | P a g e
List of & Tables Figures
27 | P a g e
Table 4 STEEPLE ANALYSIS
28 | P a g e
Table 5 STEEPLE ANALYSIS - Continued
29 | P a g e
Table 6 STEEPLE & STRATEGIC CHOICES
obsolete through time and new innovative products along with a coherent
revised strategy need to be implemented. Staples will also find it difficult to
secure external funding from banks and financial institutions as these show
sign of hesitance in lending money. If however Staples, succeeds to secure an
Strategic options amount this will be under extremely favourable credit terms that are in place
&Pricing today.
Strategy
30 | P a g e
Social • For Staples to overcome any ethical ‘fence ins’ that may cause brand
Environment infringement and devaluation, the company will need to review its policy
Audit Results statements and Code of Ethics to update it with clear and consistent
CONVERT
messages as well as continue its rigorous program of training associates and
Internal managers on ethical issues.
Regulations &
TQM
Legal • Due to Legislative changes Staples runs the risk of being legally prosecuted for
Environment an array of proceedings. Whether this is the US market or abroad, Staples
CONVERT
Audit Results needs to customize its employment terms and conditions and ensure that all
its workers are working under a safe environment
Structure &
Internal Environ.
Environmental • Increasing concerns for environmental pollution caused demand for eco-
Environment friendly products to increase and exposed companies that practised non-
Audit Results environmentally friendly practices. Staples commitment to behave
responsibly against the environment and the community has paid out well as
the receipt of several awards and prizes has empowered the brand name and
gained recognition among consumers and organisations that praised Staples
efforts. This corporate citizenship approach however, will not deliver the
same results in the near future. Staples worked hard to comply with
regulations and co-operates closely with activist groups that protect the
environment like the FSC and WWF. This soft demand for eco-friendly
CONVERT
Environment products and ideas that will give Staples a competitive advantage. An
Audit Results example can be a pen that is also a voice–recorder which can be of extreme
importance to students
Product Portfolio
31 | P a g e
Table 7 PRODUCT CATEGORIES GROWTH
32 | P a g e
Table 8 STORES BY DIVISION & MARGINAL CONTRIBUTION
33 | P a g e
Table 10 FINANCIAL DERIVATIVES & RATIONS
34 | P a g e
Table 11 SWOT ANALYSIS
35 | P a g e
Table 12 TOWS ANALYSIS - STRATEGIC CHOICES
36 | P a g e
Table 13 McKinsey 7S's - NEW STRATEGY FORMATION
37 | P a g e
Table 14 12C's FRAMEWORK
38 | P a g e
Table 15 CAGR GLOBAL MARKET COMPARISON
39 | P a g e
Table 16 GROWTH OF REGIONS 2003-2012
40 | P a g e
2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
Table 17 INTERNATIONAL COUNTRY ATTRACTIVENESS MATRIX
41 | P a g e
Figure 4 COUNTRY ATTRACTIVENESS VS COMPANY'S STRENGTHS
42 | P a g e
Figure 5 ENTRY MODE STRATEGY
43 | P a g e
References
Aaker, D. A., & Joachimsthaler, E. (2000). Brand leadership. New York: Free Press.
Argyris, C., & Schön, D. A. (1978). Organizational learning. Reading, Mass.: Addison-Wesley Pub. Co.
Bradley, F. (2002). International marketing strategy. London [u.a.]: Financial Times/Prentice Hall.
Brennan, R. (2008). Contemporary strategic marketing. Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire; New
York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Butterworth-Heinemann. (2001). Portfolio Management Using the Directional Policy Matrix:
Butterworth-Heinemann.
Carpenter, G. S., & Nakamoto, K. (1989). Consumer Preference Formation and Pioneering
Advantage. Journal of Marketing Research, 26(3), 285-298.
Deiser, R., & Ebooks, C. (2009). Designing the Smart Organization : How Breakthrough Corporate
Learning Initiatives Drive Strategic Change and Innovation. from
http://www.UCM.eblib.com/EBLWeb/patron?target=patron&extendedid=P_469331_0&
Dodgson, M., & University of Sussex. Science Policy Research, U. (1991). Technological collaboration
and organisational learning : a preliminary review of some key issues: University of Sussex,
Science Policy Research Unit.
Doole, I., & Lowe, R. (1999). International marketing strategy : analysis development and
implementation. London: International Thomson Publishing Services Ltd (UK) : International
Thomson Business Press.
Doole, I., & Lowe, R. (2004). International marketing strategy : analysis, development and
implementation. Australia; [New York]: Thomson.
Ebbinghaus, H. (1964). Memory: a contribution to experimental psychology. New York: Dover
Publications.
Gladwin, T. N., & Hofstede, G. (1981). Review of Culture's Consequences: International Differences in
Work-Related Values. Academy of Management Review, 6(4), 681-683.
Hamel, G., & Prahalad, C. K. (2010). Strategic intent. Boston, Mass.: Harvard Business Review Press.
Harvard, B. S. (1999). Harvard business review on corporate strategy. Boston, Mass.: Harvard
Business School Press.
Hashizume, N. (2001). Step into Boots, Step into Paraguay:A Feasibility Analysis of Manufacturing
Hiking Boots in Paraguay. Undergraduate Research Journal.
Hollensen, S. (2006). Marketing planning : a global perspective. London [u.a.]: McGraw-Hill
Education.
Kerin, R. A., Varadarajan, P. R., & Peterson, R. A. (1992). First-Mover Advantage: A Synthesis,
Conceptual Framework, and Research Propositions. The Journal of Marketing, 56(4), 33-52.
Kim, & Mauborgne. (2005). Books - Blue Ocean Strategy: How to Create Uncontested Market Space
and Make the Competition Irrelevant. Business week., 10.
Kotabe, M. (2004). Global marketing management. New York; Chichester: Wiley.
44 | P a g e
Kotabe, M., & Helsen, K. (2009). The SAGE handbook of international marketing. Los Angeles;
London: SAGE.
Kotler, P., & Keller, K. L. (2006). Marketing management. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Prentice
Hall.
Lewis, K. S. L., Frank, A., & Alexander, R. Development of archetypes of international marketing
strategy.
Liabotis, D. B. a. B. (June 2009). Managing a portfolio of growth options: The strategic tradeoffs
between growth and risk. Ivey Business Journal. Retrieved from
http://www.iveybusinessjournal.com/article.asp?intArticle_ID=836
Marketing, T. C. I. o. (2009). Professional Postgraduate Diploma in Marketing. Berkshire: The
Chartered Institute of Marketing.
Miles, R. E., & Snow, C. C. (1978). Organizational strategy, structure, and process. New York:
McGraw-Hill.
Mills, G. (2002). Retail pricing strategies and market power. Carlton South, Vic.: Melbourne
University Press.
Mintzberg, H. (1989). Mintzberg on management: Free Press.
Morrison, M. (2009). PEST/ PESTLE Analysis Introduction. Rapidbi. Retrieved from
http://rapidbi.com/pestle/Introduction-to-the-PESTLE-analysis-tool.html#PESTLEtemplete
Pascale, R. T., & Athos, A. G. (1981). The art of Japanese management : applications for American
executives : Richard Tanner Pascale, Anthony G. Athos. New York: Simon and Schuster.
Porter, M. E. (1980). Competitive strategy : techniques for analyzing industries and competitors. New
York: Free Press.
Prahalad, C. K., & Hamel, G. (1990). The core competence of corporation. Canada: Harvard Business
School Reprint.
Riesenbeck, H., & Perrey, J. (2009). Power brands measuring, making and managing brand success.
Weinheim: Wiley-VCH-Verl.
Root, F. R. (1994). Entry strategies for international markets. New York; Toronto; New York:
Lexington Books ; Maxwell Macmillan Canada ; Maxwell Macmillan International.
Treacy, M., & Wiersema, F. D. (1995). The discipline of market leaders : choose your customers,
narrow your focus, dominate your market. Reading, Mass.: Addison-Wesley Pub. Co.
Vermillion, D. L., & Common Property, C. (1998). Management devolution and the sustainability of
irrigation : results of comprehensive versus partial strategies. S.l.: s.n.
Vernon, R. (1966). International Investment and International Trade in the Product Cycle. The
Quarterly Journal of Economics, 80(2), 190-207.
Wellman, B., & Hampton, K. (1999). Living Networked On and Offline. Contemporary Sociology,
28(6), 648-654.
45 | P a g e
46 | P a g e