The Financial Planning Process
The Financial Planning Process
The Financial Planning Process
Chapter One
1-1
1-5. Describe how a financial plan could be organized around the steps in the financial planning process. 1-6. Describe the evolution of financial planning as a profession. 1-7. Explain the trends that are creating opportunities in the financial planning marketplace. 1-8. Identify the principal financial goals/concerns of most consumers, and describe three major obstacles that prevent them from achieving these goals.
Chapter Outline
Emergence of a New Profession 1-3 What Is Financial Planning? 1-5 Financial Planning Is a Process 1-5 Steps in Financial Planning 1-6 How Is Financial Planning Conducted? 1-15 Single-Purpose Approach 1-15 Multiple-Purpose Approach 1-16 Comprehensive Approach 1-17 Financial Planning Areas of Specialization 1-19 Content of a Comprehensive Financial Plan 1-21 Life-Cycle Financial Planning 1-23 Format of a Comprehensive Financial Plan 1-25 Evolution of Financial Planning As a Profession 1-29 Trends Creating Opportunities for Financial Planning Advisors 1-31 Consumer Needs for Financial Planning 1-35 Obstacles Confronting Consumers 1-38 Role of Financial Planning Advisors 1-39 Financial Planning Umbrella 1-41 Chapter One Review 1-43 Appendix 1A: Topic List for CFP Certification Examinations 1-47 Appendix 1B: The Financial Planning Process as Viewed by the Certified Financial Planner Board of Standards, Inc. 1-49
CFP, Certified Financial PlannerTM, and CFP (with flame logo) are certification marks owned by the Certified Financial Planner Board of Standards, Inc.
1-2
In the 1990s, the financial planning profession gained some stability and maturity. Now it is possible to describe more realistically what financial planning is and what client needs it can fulfill.
1-4
Whether used by advisors or self-planning individuals, the financial planning process has six steps: (1) establish financial goals, (2) gather relevant data, (3) analyze the data, (4) develop a plan for achieving goals, (5) implement the plan, and (6) monitor the plan. (Many advisors will reverse steps 1 and 2. The Certified Financial Planner Board of Standards essentially combines steps 1 and 2 into step 2 and adds a new step 1establishing and defining the relationship with the client. (See appendix 1B.)
Chapter One
1-5
current dollars, and we want the income to continue as long as we live without depleting the principal. Helping the client quantify goals is among the most valuable services a financial advisor can provide. Another important service of the advisor is goal prioritization. Clients usually mention competing goals, such as saving for retirement and saving for education. Advisors help clients rank these competing goals.
Chapter One
1-7
appropriate for the client. Such information offers the additional benefit of helping avoid (or at least defend) lawsuits from a dissatisfied client. Before the financial advisor begins the information-gathering process, he or she should give certain information to the client. First, the client should be made aware that he or she will have to invest time, perhaps a significant amount of time, in the information-gathering stage of financial planning. Even though part of the financial advisors responsibility is to avoid consuming the clients time unnecessarily, this commitment of time by the client is essential. The magnitude of the needed time commitment will depend on the scope and complexity of the clients needs and circumstances, but the proper development of even a narrowly focused and fairly uncomplicated plan requires information that only the client can furnish. Second, the client should be made aware that he or she probably will have to provide the advisor with some information that is highly confidential, perhaps even sensitive or painful, for the client to reveal. Again, the scope and complexity of the clients needs will influence this matter. The creation of even rather straightforward plans, however, may require clients to disclose such things as their income and spending patterns, their attitudes toward other family members, or their opinions as to the extent of their own financial responsibilities to others. Another prerequisite for the effective gathering of client information is a systematic approach to the task. Although there are many possible ways to systematize the gathering of information, one way that has been found useful by many financial advisors is to use a structured fact-finder form. Some fact finders are only a few pages long and ask for basic information, while others are thick booklets that seek very detailed data on each asset and amount. Most fact finders are designed for specific financial planning software to simplify data entry. For many client situations, a formal fact finder elicits considerably more information than needed. The sections that should be completed depend on the particular areas of concern to be addressed in each clients financial plan. Obviously, information gathering is far more than asking the client a series of questions or filling out a form. Certainly that is required, but usually information gathering also requires examination and analysis of documentssuch as wills, tax returns, employee benefit plan coverage, and insurance policiessupplied by the client or the clients other financial advisors. It also requires advising, counseling, and listening during face-to-face meetings with the client and spouse. These skills are especially important because the advisor needs to help the client and
1-8
spouse identify and articulate clearly what they really want to accomplish and what risks they are willing to take in order to do so.
Chapter One
1-9
1-10
approve the plan (or some variation thereof). As part of this request, the advisor must ask the client to allocate money for the plans implementation. While there are those who frown at the mere mention of selling in connection with financial planningfinancial planning does involve selling. Even financial advisors who are compensated entirely on a fee-for-service basis must sell the client on the need to work with the advisor to develop and implement a plan.
Chapter One
1-11
process should follow the same six steps used to develop the original plan, though the time and effort needed will probably be less than in the original process.
Summary
The financial planning process described above is depicted schematically in figure 1-1. The blocks on the left represent the six steps FIGURE 1-1 The Financial Planning Process
Encourage the client to express concerns, hopes, and goals. Help the client to restate goals that are specific and quantifiable. Prioritize competing goals.
Gather all relevant client information, both objective and subjective, through factfinding forms, questionnaires, counseling, and examination of documents.
Identify the strengths and the weaknesses in the clients present financial condition as they affect the ability to achieve the clients goals. Revise goals if necessary.
Develop a Plan
Design a set of recommended strategies tailored to the clients circumstances and goals, including alternative ways of achieving those goals. Draw on other experts as needed. Obtain client approval.
Motivate and help the client acquire all the necessary financial products and services to put the plan into action. Draw on other experts as needed. Evaluate the performance of all implementation vehicles. Review changes in the clients circumstances and the financial environment. Revisit the steps when necessary.
1-12
in the process, while the blocks on the right indicate the main substantive activities that should occur in each step. Individuals who intend to take the Certified Financial Planner certification examination should review the steps in the financial planning process as listed in appendix 1B. The financial planning process in appendix 1B essentially combines steps 1 and 2 into step 2 and inserts a new step 1 called Establishing and Defining the Relationship with the Client.
Chapter One
1-13
Single-Purpose Approach
Some advisors take the position that the simple selling of a single financial product or service to a client in order to solve a single financial problem constitutes financial planning. Clearly, these advisors would be incorrect if the financial planning process was not used to determine whether the problem their product solves is, in fact, the specific clients financial problem and if so, whether it is the most appropriate product or service for solving that clients problem. In this case, the advisor would be involved in product sales, not financial planning. However, if an advisor sells a client a product to implement the recommendation of a plan developed according to the financial planning process and approved by the client, the service provided by the advisor
Chapter One
1-15
constitutes financial planning. According to this specialist or singlepurpose approach, all the following individuals would be engaged in financial planning as long as they use the financial planning process in working with their clients: a stockbroker who advises a customer to buy shares of common stock of a particular company a salesperson who sells to a client shares in a real estate limited partnership a preparer of income tax returns who suggests that a client establish an IRA a banker who opens a trust account for the benefit of a customers handicapped child a life insurance agent who sells key person life insurance to the owner of a small business a personal finance counselor who shows a client how to set up and live within a budget
Multiple-Purpose Approach
Client financial needs and financial products and services are often seen as falling into one of three basic categories: insurance planning, tax planning, and investment planning. Rather than taking a single-purpose approach of just solving a single financial problem with a single financial product or service, many financial advisors take a multiplepurpose approach by dealing with at least a large part of one of these categories, and perhaps some aspects of a second category. According to the multiple-purpose approach, the following individuals would be engaged in financial planning as long as they use the financial planning process in working with their clients: a multiline insurance agent who sells all lines of life, health, property, and liability insurance a tax attorney who assists clients with their income, estate, and gift tax planning an investment adviser who is registered as such with the Securities and Exchange Commission a life insurance agent who also sells a family of mutual funds to meet both the protection and wealth accumulation needs of clients Foundations of Financial Planning: An Overview
1-16
Comprehensive Approach
Still other advisors take a comprehensive approach to providing financial planning services, Comprehensive financial planning considers all aspects of a clients financial position, which includes all the clients financial needs and objectives, and utilizes several integrated and coordinated planning strategies for fulfilling those needs and objectives. The two key characteristics of comprehensive financial planning are that it encompasses all the personal and financial situations of clients to the extent that these can be uncovered, clarified, and addressed through information gathering and counseling that it integrates into its methodology all the techniques and expertise utilized in more narrowly focused approaches to solving client financial problems
Because of the wide range of expertise required to engage in comprehensive financial planning, effective performance commonly requires a team of specialists. The tasks of the advisor managing the team are to coordinate the efforts of the team and to contribute expertise in his or her own field of specialization. In its purest form, comprehensive financial planning is a service provided by the managing advisor on a fee-only basis. No part of the managing advisors compensation comes from the sale of financial products, thus helping to ensure complete objectivity in all aspects of the plan. Some team specialists also are compensated through fees, while others might receive commissions from the sale of products, while still others might receive both fees and commissions. In its less pure but often more practical form, comprehensive financial planning provides the managing advisor with compensation consisting of some combination of fees for service and commissions from the sale of some of the financial products. Again, other members of the team might receive fees, commissions, or both. Furthermore, in its purest form, comprehensive financial planning is performed for a client all at once. A single planning engagement by the managing advisor and his or her team of specialists creates the one plan that addresses all the clients concerns and utilizes all the needed financial strategies. This plan is then updated with the client periodically and modified as appropriate. In its less pure form, comprehensive financial planning is performed incrementally during the course of
Chapter One
1-17
several engagements with the client. For example, the advisor in one year might prepare a plan to treat some of the clients tax concerns and insurance planning problems. In another year, the advisor might focus on the clients investment concerns and then dovetail the strategies for dealing with them with the previously developed tax and insurance strategies. In a third engagement the advisor might address the remaining issues in the tax, insurance, and investment planning areas and coordinate all the recommended strategies and previously developed plans. Again, each incremental part, as well as the overall plan, is reviewed periodically and revised as appropriate.
1-18
Chapter One
1-19
Chapter One
1-21
Topic List for CFP Certification Examinations (see appendix 1A). These areas are general principles of financial planning (for example, personal financial statements, client attitudes and behavioral characteristics, and so forth) insurance planning and risk management employee benefits planning investment planning income tax planning retirement planning estate planning
A comprehensive financial plan should address all of these major planning areas as they relate to the client. If the financial advisor does not have the expertise to personally address each of the major planning areas in the development of the plan, he or she should form a team of specialists and serve as its manager. The advisors role would then be to coordinate the efforts of the team and to contribute expertise in his or her own field of specialization. If, for some reason, one of the major planning areas does not apply to the client, the plan should spell out this fact. This will indicate that an important planning area was not overlooked in the development of the plan but was investigated and found not to apply to the client at this time. In addition to the major planning areas that pertain to almost every client, there are a number of more specialized areas that are relevant to many, but not all, clients. These specialized areas are, for the most part, subsets of, and typically involve several of, the major planning areas. However, because all of these specialized areas are unique, they merit separate treatment. They should be made part of a clients comprehensive financial plan only if he or she is affected by them. Typically, a singlepurpose or multiple-purpose financial plan that is focused on the particular planning need deals with these specialized areas. The most important of these specialized areas in terms of the number of people it affects is educational funding. Most clients understand the need to save for college and are aware that college costs have risen at a faster pace than the Consumer Price Index (CPI). Still, the vast majority of families accumulate far too little money for college by the matriculation date. They usually have to cut back on living expenses, borrow money, tap into retirement assets, or seek additional employment
1-22
to meet the funding need. Often, they lower their sights and target a school that is less expensive, rather than the one best suited to their needs. Consequently, planning to meet the costs of higher education has become a necessity for most people who have children. The other specialized areas worthy of mention are those that can be categorized as financial planning for special circumstances. These areas typically include planning for divorce terminal illness nontraditional families job change and job loss, including severance packages dependents with special needs
As previously mentioned, all of these specialized planning areas are subsets of one or more of the major planning areas. For example, divorce planning could affect every single one of the major planning areas but, nevertheless, should not be part of a comprehensive financial plan unless the client is contemplating divorce. Even then, divorce planning would be better handled under a single-purpose or multiple-purpose financial plan because of its unique aspects and shorter planning horizon than the major planning areas.
Together, these five phases span a persons entire financial life. Although some people will not experience all of the phases or will spend more or less time in any one phase, the vast majority of career-minded people will go through all five phases. Chapter One 1-23
The first step in creating a comprehensive financial plan is for the advisor to lead the client through the goal-setting process. Goal setting requires clients to recognize that there are several phases in their financial life; for young clients, the early career phase is the beginning of that life. The goals that young clients who are in this phase typically set reflect this fact. For example, a client who is in the early career phase often is newly married and has young children, and the client and/or his or her spouse are establishing employment patterns. The client probably is concerned about accumulating funds for a home purchase if he or she has not already done so. As the children grow older, the client begins to think about saving for college. Protecting his or her family from a potential financial disaster due to death or disability is also important, as is building a cash reserve or emergency fund to meet unexpected contingencies. However, the clients goals that pertain to retirement and estate planning generally will not have a very high priority in the first few years of the early career phase, but they still need to be considered if the financial plan is to be a truly comprehensive one. Once the client has a comprehensive financial plan, it is incumbent on the advisor to monitor the plan. As the client moves into the career development phase of his or her financial life cycle, some goals may need revision. This phase is often a time of career enhancement, upward mobility, and rapid growth in income. The phase usually includes additional accumulation and then expenditure of funds for childrens college educations. Moreover, the advisor should recommend coordinating the employee benefits of the client and his or her spouse and integrating them with insurance and investment planning goals. As the client moves into the peak accumulation phase, the evervigilant advisor should be monitoring the plan for any needed changes. In this phase, the client is usually moving toward maximum earnings and has the greatest opportunity for wealth accumulation. The phase may include accumulating funds for special purposes, but it is usually a continuation of trying to meet the goals set for the major planning areas. The preretirement phase often involves winding down both the career and income potential, restructuring investment assets to reduce risk and enhance income, and a further emphasis on tax planning and evaluating retirement plan distribution options relative to income needs and tax consequences. Throughout this phase, the financial advisor should be actively involved in keeping his or her clients financial plan on target to meet all the clients goals.
1-24
The final phase in the clients financial life cycle is retirement. If the advisor has kept the clients financial plan fine-tuned, then this phase should be a time of enjoyment with a comfortable retirement income and sufficient assets to preserve purchasing power. While all of the major planning areas should have been receiving attention throughout the clients financial life cycle, now is the time for the advisor to make certain that his or her clients estate plan is in order. The advisor who monitors a clients financial plan throughout the clients financial life cycle is practicing life-cycle financial planning. A comprehensive financial plan that is developed for a relatively young client needs to be reviewed and revised fairly frequently as the client ages and passes through the phases of his or her financial life cycle. Many of the clients financial goals will need adjusting as lifes circumstances change; having the right goals is critical to creating a successful financial plan. The advisors role in setting goals is to help the client establish reasonable, achievable goals and to set a positive tone for the entire financial planning process. The entire process encompasses not only the development of the clients first financial plan but also any future revisions and/or modifications to that plan. The content of a comprehensive financial plan should, as already mentioned, include a discussion of each of the major planning areas. Which phase of the financial life cycle that the client is currently in strongly influences the priority given to the goals for each of the planning areas. Financial planning is a process that should be ongoing throughout the clients financial life. That is why financial planning over the clients financial life is called life-cycle financial planning.
Chapter One
1-25
on reasonable, achievable goals set by the client. And every plan should be structured around strategies for achieving the clients goals. In addition, in the process of formulating strategies, assumptions have to be made and should be spelled out in the plan documents. Typical assumptions include the interest rate, the rate of inflation, and the clients financial risk tolerance, to name but a few. Finally, every plan is developed around information gathered during a fact-finding process. Much of this information, such as financial statements, should also be included in the plan. Recognizing that there are many possible variations for organizing all of this information into a cohesive plan, one possible approach is to structure the plan to parallel the steps in the financial planning process as described below. First (paralleling step 1, establishing financial goals), a comprehensive financial plan should specify the clients stated goals, indicating the priority of each one and the time frame for achieving it. Each goal, as indicated earlier in this chapter, should be stated as specifically as possible. Because there are likely to be a number of goals included in a comprehensive financial plan, it may be helpful for the client to list them in relevant categories, such as protection, accumulation, liquidation, and so forth. Keep in mind that the best solution for a specific goal may involve a combination of the major planning areas; whatever approach is adopted for categorizing the goals, the plan should be designed to avoid confusing the client. Second (paralleling step 2, gathering relevant data), a comprehensive plan should describe the clients present situation based on both the personal and financial data gathered from the client. In terms of the personal situation, this should include not only basic information about the client and his or her family, such as names, addresses, phone numbers, dates of birth, Social Security numbers, and so on, but also other relevant personal information that helps define the clients present situation and, thus, will affect the financial plan. This other relevant information could include such topics as one of the childrens serious health problem, a feeling of personal obligation to support aging parents, a desire to treat adopted or stepchildren differently from natural children, previous marriages and alimony or child-support obligations, and gifts or inheritances pending or anticipated. In addition to defining the clients present personal situation, the plan should include a description of the clients present financial situation. This is most commonly done by including a copy of the clients balance sheet, listing his or her assets and liabilities and showing
1-26
net worth; a cash-flow statement that identifies all the clients sources and uses of cash and indicates his or her net cash flows; and a federal income tax statement and an analysis thereof. The information presented should include not only a current balance sheet, cash-flow statement, and income tax statement, but also projections relevant to understanding the clients current position. The clients current investment portfolio should also be presented with an indication of, among other things, its liquidity, diversification, and risk characteristics. As noted earlier in this chapter, many advisors reverse steps 1 and 2 of the financial planning process. If an advisor is organizing a financial plan around the steps of the process and has reversed steps 1 and 2, he or she will want to organize the plan accordingly. Next, for each goal, at least three critical areas of information should be presented: (paralleling step 3, analyzing the data) the problem(s) the advisor has identified that the client would encounter in attempting to accomplish the goal (paralleling step 4, developing a plan) the recommended financial and tax services, products, and strategies for overcoming the identified problem(s) (including any underlying assumptions the advisor made in formulating the recommendation) so that the client can achieve the goal (paralleling step 5, implementing the plan) recommendations for implementing the proposed solution for achieving the goal
Regardless of the format a financial advisor adopts to organize a comprehensive financial plan, the important point to remember is that the plan should be communicated to the client in the form of a written report. The format of this financial planning report should make it easy for the client to understand and evaluate what is being proposed. In general, the simpler the report, the easier it will be for the client to understand and adopt. Careful organization, as well as the use of graphs, diagrams, and other visual aids, can help in this regard.
Chapter One
1-27
Chapter One
1-29
curriculum culminated with the creation of a new professional designation in the early 1980sChartered Financial Consultant (ChFC). Meanwhile the Colleges sister organization, the American Society of Chartered Life Underwriters, also broadened its mission, membership, and programs, accepting the new categories of graduates of the College into the Society and changing its name to the American Society of CLU & ChFC. Further emphasizing this direction, the Society changed its name again in 1998 to the Society of Financial Service Professionals. Traditional colleges and universities also contributed to the emerging financial planning profession during the 1970s and 1980s, though on a much smaller scale than the College for Financial Planning and The American College, both of which serve a national student body. A number of schools developed curricula in financial planning at the undergraduate or masters level and began offering courses to help prepare people for the CFP and ChFC examinations. Now several states allow attainment of either the ChFC or CFP designations to satisfy the education requirement for registration as an investment adviser. Two other forces that have spurred the growth and professionalization of financial planning have been the American Institute of CPAs (AICPA) and the National Association of Personal Financial Advisors (NAPFA). In 1987 the AICPA developed for its members an educational program leading to the designation that is now called Personal Financial Specialist. Formed in 1983, NAPFA is an organization committed to comprehensive fee-only financial planning. In 2002, NAPFA created the NAPFA-Registered Financial Advisor, a membership category with educational, experience, and ethical requirements.
1-30
Chapter One
1-31
to manage their finances. The opportunities for the advisors engaged in financial planning to assist are obvious. A third broad trend is the increasing volatility of financial conditions in the American economy. Three indicators of this volatility confronting and confusing American households in the past 40 years are the changes that have occurred in inflation rates, in the level of interest rates, and in common stock prices. For example, during the first half of the 1960s, annual increases in the CPI averaged only 1.3 percent; the prime interest rate charged by banks on short-term business loans averaged only about 4.68 percent, and the Standard & Poors 500 Index of common stock prices averaged around 72.0. Consider the dynamic patterns of these indicators since then, as shown in table 1-1. Inflation and interest rates rose steadily in the late 1960s, and they were undoubtedly a motivating factor behind the growth in the number of advisors engaged in financial planning. Inflation and interest rates then cooled but bounced up again sharply in the mid-1970s. After a 3year respite, they rose very sharply in the late 1970s and into the 1980s. Throughout this entire period, stock prices rose only modestly. Inflation rates slowed again during the mid-1980s, as did the prime interest rate. Meanwhile the stock market rose dramatically but erratically. As the 1980s came to a close, inflation and interest rates were creeping up again and average common stock prices were gyrating sharply from day to day. Then in the early 1990s, inflation started cooling again, stock prices rose dramatically, and interest rates plummeted. The mid-1990s saw continued moderation of inflation, yet interest rates crept upward while the stock market set record highs. Inflation in 1998 dropped to 1.6 percent, its lowest level in 3 decades. From 1997 to 1999 the stock market soared to unprecedented highs, but also displayed unsettling volatility. In 2000, the stock market turned downward and continued to drop in 2001 and 2002. From a high near 1500 in the middle of 2000, the S & P 500 Index fell below 900 by the end of 2002, quite close to where it was in the middle of 1997 near the beginning of the bull market. Meanwhile, in response to actions of the Federal Reserve, interest rates dropped to their lowest levels in decades, declining from 9.50 percent during December 2000 to 4.00 percent in July 2003, where it remains as of November 2003. In addition to the volatility of inflation rates, interest rates, and stock market prices, another destabilizing factor faced by American consumers has been important U.S. income tax law changes that affect all aspects of financial planning. Still another element of instability in the financial
1-32
TABLE 1-1 Consumer Price Index Changes (Urban Consumers), the Prime Rate, and the Standard & Poors 500 Stock Index: 19652001
Year 1965 1970 1971 1972 1973 1974 1975 1976 1977 1978 1979 1980 1981 1982 1983 1984 1985 1986 1987 1988 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 Percentage Change in CPI 1.6% 5.7 4.4 3.2 6.2 11.0 9.1 5.8 6.5 7.6 11.3 13.5 10.3 6.2 3.2 4.3 3.6 1.9 3.6 4.1 4.8 5.4 4.2 3.0 3.0 2.6 2.8 3.0 2.3 1.6 2.2 3.4 2.8 Average Prime Rate % 4.54% 7.91 5.72 5.25 8.03 10.81 7.86 6.84 6.82 9.06 12.67 15.27 18.87 14.86 10.79 12.04 9.93 8.33 8.21 9.32 10.87 10.01 8.46 6.25 6.00 7.15 8.83 8.27 8.44 8.35 8.00 9.23 6.91 Average S & P 500 Index 88.2 83.2 98.3 109.2 107.4 82.8 87.1 102.0 98.2 96.0 102.8 118.7 128.0 119.7 160.4 180.5 186.8 236.3 268.8 265.9 323.1 335.01 376.20 415.75 451.63 460.42 541.72 670.49 873.43 1085.50 1327.33 1427.22 1194.18
Source: Statistical Abstract of the United States; Selected Interest Rates: Historical Data, Statistics: Releases and Historical Data, The Federal Reserve Board, updated weekly, available at http://www.federalreserve.gov/releases/; and Federal Reserve Bulletin, various issues.
environment has been the failure rate among financial institutions, including some very large ones. In the 1980s and early 1990s failure rates among savings and loan associations, banks, and insurance companies were higher than they had been in many years. With the possible exception of the bull market of the late 1990s where many investors felt they could do it themselves without either Chapter One 1-33
professional advice or paying much attention to risk,4 volatile economic conditions generally create greater demand for financial planning services. They also emphasize the need for financial advisors to continuously monitor their clients financial circumstances and to adjust the plans as circumstances dictate. These volatile financial conditions make it doubly important that advisors thoroughly understand and abide by their clients risk tolerances. With the three year decline in the stock market that began in 2000 and its major impact on the value of invested assets, investors are again recognizing the value of financial planning services and the need to consider risk as well as return in attempting to achieve their financial goals. A fourth major trend in the financial planning market is the technological revolution that has occurred in the financial services industry. This revolution has made possible the creation of many new financial products and has made it easier to tailor these products to individual client needs. Also the technology has made possible improved analysis of the performance of these products by advisors with the skills to do so.
1-34
In reporting the results of its 2002 Consumer Survey, the CFP Board of Standards also broke the findings down according to three key groups of respondentsup and coming, mid-life, and retirement cusp. Table 1-2 shows the financial planning focus of each of the groups and highlights the relative importance of retirement planning to all three
Chapter One
1-35
Ages: 20-39 28% have a written financial plan 59% completed plan within the last 3 years Most tolerant of risk More likely to use the Internet for financial purposes Most likely to have financial software Ages: 40-54 37% have a written financial plan 61% completed plan at least 5 years ago More likely to use a financial professional to develop a plan Highest amount of household income Have low to moderate risk tolerance Ages: 55-69 52% have a written financial plan 65% completed plan at least 5 years ago Higher net worth and lower risk tolerance Most likely to have a financial professional as a primary advisor Lower risk tolerance than younger groups
Prepare for retirement Manage/reduce debt Build an emergency fund Build a college fund Save for a home purchase/renovation
Mid-Life
Prepare for retirement (strongest focus of all three consumer groups) Build an emergency fund Finance college education Provide insurance protection Home purchase/renovation Vacation/travel
Retirement Cusp
Prepare for retirement Accumulate capital Shelter income from taxes Generate income Build an emergency fund Vacation/travel Provide insurance protection
Source: 2002 Consumer Survey, Certified Financial Planner Board of Standards, Denver, CO.
consumer groups. The quite similar findings of two independent studies conducted in 2002, one by the National Retirement Planning Coalition (NRPC)6 and the other by the Employee Benefits Research Institute
1-36
(EBRI),7 emphasize that in many cases, there is a strong need for professional help in planning effectively for ones retirement: Long retirements are expected. NRPC survey: The average respondent expects to spend at least 19 years in retirement. EBRI survey: The majority of working respondents expect to spend at least 20 years in retirement. Retirement income needs are underestimated (retirement planning professionals typically recommend 7590 percent of preretirement income to live comfortably in retirement). NRPC survey: Respondents indicate they expect to need 60 percent of preretirement income to live comfortably. EBRI survey: Seventeen percent of working respondents expect to need less than 50 percent of their preretirement income in retirement, 25 percent indicated 50-59 percent and 14 percent indicated 60-69 percent; only 25 percent indicated 70-89 percent. Retirement savings are insufficient. NRPC survey: Only one-third of the respondents are very confident that they will be able to maintain the lifestyle they want through their retirement years. EBRI survey: With 23 percent of the nonretired workers indicating that they are very confident in having enough money to live comfortably throughout their retirement years and 47 percent indicating that they are somewhat confident, almost half have saved less than $50,000 and only 17 percent have saved $100,000 or more. Inadequate planning has been conducted. NRPC survey: Forty-one percent of the respondents have not attempted to determine how much retirement savings they will need to live comfortably and another 41 percent who did attempt to calculate their required retirement savings could not complete the calculation or could not determine the income they need to retire. EBRI survey: One-third of the nonretired respondents indicated that they have tried to calculate how much money they will need to have saved by the time they retire so that they can live comfortably in retirement.
Chapter One
1-37
Baby boomers, Americans born between 1946 and 1964, are now in midlife. A study conducted by the American Association of Retired Persons (AARP) in 1999 found that while baby boomers appear to be quite optimistic about their retirement years, their optimism is moderated somewhat by concerns about finances.8 Another study conducted by AARP in 2002 found that personal finances are among the areas of their lives with which baby boomers are least satisfied.9 About one-third of the survey respondents indicated that they are worse off financially than they thought they would be at this point in their lives. Many baby boomers feel financially strapped, especially when it comes time to pay college tuition. While 29 percent of those surveyed have made improving their personal finances their top goal over the next five years, nearly half do not believe they are likely to achieve their goal due, among other things, to their own inability to handle credit cards and debt, the volatile stock market, the cost of living, and economic uncertainty in the workplace. Another study of baby boomers conducted by The Allstate Corporation in 2001 suggests that many baby boomers are likely to encounter a retirement that is quite different in financial terms from the past.10 Among other things, the survey revealed that during retirement, more than one in three baby boomers will be financially responsible for parents or children, 7 percent will be financially responsible for both parents and children, one in five will pay college tuition for one or more children, and more than 70 percent will continue to work. The survey also suggests that baby boomers appear to be poorly prepared for this financially burdensome retirement with survey respondents having saved only an average of 12 percent of the total they will need to meet even basic living expenses in retirement and having far underestimated the predicted increase in the cost of living over the next 20 years. The baby boom generation has also become known as the sandwiched generation because many of its members are already faced with helping finance their childrens education and aiding their aging parents at the same time that they themselves should be saving for their own retirement. Retirement, college funding, and long-term care are important to everyone, but especially to sandwiched boomers.
have not developed financial plans that will enable them to do so. Three of the most important obstacles they face are the following: the natural human tendency to procrastinateAmong the reasons for putting off the task of establishing a financial plan may be a lack of time due to a hectic lifestyle, the seeming enormity of the task of getting ones finances under control, and the belief that there is still plenty of time to prepare for achieving financial goals. the very common tendency for Americans to live up to or beyond their current incomeThe pressure in households to overspend for current consumption is enormous, and many families have no funds left with which to implement plans for the achievement of future goals. the lack of financial knowledge among consumersAlthough in recent years there has undoubtedly been some growth in the financial sophistication of Americans, there is still widespread ignorance about how to formulate financial objectives and how to identify and properly evaluate all the strategies that might be used to achieve them.
Chapter One
1-39
These areas are viewed as the major planning areas that fall under the financial planning umbrella. Even though each one of these planning areas is a specialty unto itself, together they make up the totality of what is known as comprehensive financial planning. The order in which these planning areas are covered in this book is identical to the order that they appear on the Topic List for CFP Certification Examinations (see appendix 1A). Chapter 8 is devoted exclusively to Social Security, Medicare, and Medicare supplements. Even though the government and quasigovernment programs stemming from these three areas could just as easily be discussed under insurance planning, employee benefits planning, and retirement planning, they are dealt with separately in this book because of their importance in providing a minimum floor of protection. They are viewed by advisors as the foundation upon which comprehensive financial planning builds.
NOTES
1. Shelley A. Lee, What is Financial Planning, Anyway, Journal of Financial Planning, December 2001, pp. 36-46. 2. Survey of Financial Risk Tolerance, The American College, Bryn Mawr, PA, 1992.
Chapter One
1-41
3. First Annual CFP Practitioner Survey: Executive Summary of Findings, Certified Financial Planner Board of Standards, Denver, CO, Summer 1999, p. 7. The telephone survey of 661 CFP practitioners was conducted by Market Facts, Inc. 4. Nancy Opiela, The State of Financial Planning: A Grassroots Perspective, Journal of Financial Planning, December 2002, pp. 8-16. 5. 2002 Consumer Survey, Certified Financial Planner Board of Standards, Denver, CO. This was a survey of 996 upper-quartile households of all ages (income ranged from $60,000+ to $85,000+ depending on the householders ages). 6. Retirement Readiness, National Retirement Planning Coalition, August 2002. A telephone survey was conducted by Mathew Greenwald & Associates, Inc., which polled 500 total respondents among Americans between the ages of 40 and 65. The respondents surveyed were financial decision makers for their households with annual incomes of at least $50,000 and who had not purchased an annuity. 7. The 2002 Retirement Confidence Survey, Employee Benefit Research Institute, Washington, DC, January 2002. A telephone survey was conducted of 1,000 individuals (771 workers and 229 retirees) age 25 or older in the United States. 8. Baby Boomers Envision Their Retirement: An AARP Segmentation Analysis, AARP, Washington, DC, February 1999. A telephone survey of 2,001 Americans aged 33-52 was conducted by Roper Starch Worldwide, Inc. 9. Boomers at Midlife: The AARP Life Stage Study, AARP, Washington, DC, July 2002. A telephone survey of 3,666 adults 18 and older (including 2,127 boomers) was conducted by Princeton Survey Research Associates. 10. Retirement Reality Check, The Allstate Corporation, Northbrook, IL, December 2001. Harris Interactive polled 1,004 people born between 1946 and 1961, with household incomes ranging from $35,000 to $100,000.
1-42
Review Questions
1-1. Identify the six steps in the financial planning process and briefly indicate the kinds of activities involved in each step. 1-2. Describe each of the following approaches to financial planning: a. single-purpose approach b. multiple-purpose approach c. comprehensive approach 1-3. At a minimum, what subjects should be included in a comprehensive financial plan? 1-4. Explain what is meant by life-cycle financial planning. 1-5. Summarize the major events occurring from the late 1960s to the present in the evolution of financial planning as a profession.
Chapter One
1-43
1-6. Describe the opportunities in the financial planning marketplace resulting from each of the following trends: a. rising median age b. increasing number of dual-income families c. volatility of financial conditions d. increasing use of sophisticated technology by the financial services industry 1-7. What are the top-10 reasons why people begin financial planning? 1-8. Describe three important obstacles preventing households from gaining control of their own financial destinies.
Self-Test Questions
Instructions: Read chapter 1 first, then answer the following questions to test your knowledge. There are 10 questions. For questions 1 through 4, match the statement with the step in the 6-step financial planning process to which it relates; for questions 5 through 10, circle the correct answer. When finished with the test, check your answers with the answer key in the back of the book. Match each statement below with the step in the 6-step financial planning process to which it relates. 1-1. This step in where the advisor does fact-finding. 1-2. This step is where the advisor reviews changes in the clients circumstances and the financial environment. 1-3. This step is where the advisor identifies the strengths and weaknesses in the clients present financial condition. 1-4. This step is where the advisor motivates and helps the client acquire all the necessary financial products and services. (A) (B) (C) (D) (E) (F) Establish financial goals. Gather relevant data. Analyze the data. Develop a plan. Implement the plan. Monitor the plan. ________ ________
________ ________
1-44
1-5.
According to a 2002 consumer survey conducted by the CFP Board of Standards, the top reason why people begin financial planning is to (A) (B) (C) (D) accumulate capital purchase or renovate a home build a retirement fund generate current income
1-6.
Which of the following financial advisors using the financial planning process would be considered to be practicing multiple-purpose financial planning? (A) A multiline insurance agent who sells life, health, property, and liability insurance to a client (B) A personal finance counselor who shows a client how to set up and live within a budget (C) A stockbroker who advises a customer to buy shares of common stock in the XYZ Company (D) A banker who opens a trust account for the benefit of a customers handicapped child
1-7.
Trends creating opportunities for advisors engaged in financial planning include which of the following? I. II. (A) (B) (C) (D) Longevity among Americans is increasing. The financial environment is becoming more stable. I only II only Both I and II Neither I nor II
1-8.
Which of the following statements correctly describe(s) a characteristic of comprehensive financial planning in its purest form? I. II. (A) (B) (C) (D) The managing advisors compensation is usually a combination of fees and commissions. The plan is created by the managing advisor and his or her team of specialists in a single planning engagement. I only II only Both I and II Neither I nor II 1-45
Chapter One
1-9.
Financial advisor activities considered to be part of the plan development phase in the financial planning process include all of the following EXCEPT (A) (B) (C) (D) obtaining the clients approval of the plan presenting alternative plan strategies to the client writing a report for the client that describes the plan reviewing the plan to see that it is performing satisfactorily
1-10.
According to two independent studies conducted in 2002, all of the following statements regarding retirement or retirement planning are correct EXCEPT: (A) (B) (C) (D) Long retirements are expected. Inadequate planning has been conducted. Retirement income needs are overestimated. Retirement savings are insufficient.
1-46