L'Oreal Project Romania
L'Oreal Project Romania
L'Oreal Project Romania
Introduction General description of the company Organizational purposes: vision, mission, values, objectives. Diagnosing of the strategic capability within company Limitations in managing strategic capabilities within company Strategy development within company Methods of pursuing strategies within company Strategy evaluation Conclusions References 3 3 5 6 8 10 13 14 15 17
Introduction
Because youre worth it is the motto which led those from LOreal to an outstanding success and made their name known in every country of the world. To innovate and offer top performing products at great prices to the greatest number of consumers possible is the philosophy that guided LOreal in pursuing excellence. Getting its start in the hair-color business, the worlds largest cosmetics and beauty company today is sculpting the future of beauty for women and men. But the question that we asked ourselves is whether LOreal can continue as the market leader forever, when there are so many cosmetic brands are popping up nowadays? What are the different decisions and actions that can be undertaken by the company to maintain its top spot?
1 2
http://www.herbatint.co.uk/herbatint/features/herbatint-article.php?id=28 http://www.loreal.com/_en/_ww/index.aspx?direct1=00003&direct2=00003/00006
LOreal in Romania The company began doing business in Romania in 19973 through LOreal Romania, a wholly owned subsidiary of the LOreal Group and in 2004, added a new division, LOreal Professional. The latter aims to offer to the best hair salons everything they need to pursue excellence. The companys capital is made up by 51% private owned shares and 49% stock-exchange shares. The capital allocated for research represents 30% of the net profit. One of the directions for the future is represented by educating the women through the promotion of public products, quality products which are addressed to the largest category of consumers. The company adopts marketing strategies such as testing the market, testing the consumers, educating them and maintaining their interest with the help of advertisements, free samples, banners and flyers offering information regarding the products for body care. As foreign investor, LOreal Paris decided to chose Romania as a market because of the fact that it is the first market with potential, after Poland and Hungary, increasing constantly with 4.7% yearly. The most important competitors is Beiersdorf, the manufacturer of Nivea products, followed by Procter&Gamble with Pantene, the pharmaceutical products Wich and Wella, with Wellaton,offering hair care and hair dye.4 In 2008, the Romanian subsidiary ranked second among the European subsidiaries in what concerns the growth rate, growth due to the business development but also to an increase in the customers exigencies and in the culture that consumers have towards cosmetics5. The cosmetics market in Romania raises up to 500 million Euro6, out of which 60-70 million Euro are for luxury cosmetics7 and 5.5 million Euro come from the sale of natural cosmetics8. These figures are relevant because LOreal offers products from all these types, being an the important player on the natural cosmetics market The Body Shop, surpassing Sabon, LOccitane and Lush, and on the luxury cosmetics market next to Dior, Chanel and Givenchy. Strategic groups and dynamics of the industry The cosmetics industry is divided according to the product segment as follows: on the hair-dye products the main competitors are LOreal, Wella, Henkel, Schwarzopf and Londa, on the segment of skin care LOreal competes against Nivea, and the make-up market is shared with Avon and Max Factor. The cosmetics industry is one of the industries that registered growth in 2009, despite the recession. The value was 10% increase, compared to 2008. The explanation is that, as a difference from the other industries, the cosmetics market is not so exposed to changes in this period. People use shampoo and care for their skin; women are still paying attention to their physical appearance, so makeup and hair dye are still used in the same proportion as before. Among the tendencies observed on the market, it was observed that people are more oriented
3 4
According to the registration no J40/6064/1997 at the Registry of Commerce http://freq.3x.ro/pages/despre.html 5 http://www.zf.ro/profesii/alina-perrin-hr-manager-la-l-oreal-romania-poti-sa-ajungi-country-manager-la-27-deani-3051445/ 6 http://www.curierulnational.ro/Actualitate%20Companii/2011-0204/Coty+Romania+estimeaza+afaceri+de+20+mil.+dolari+in+anul+fiscal+curent 7 http://www.fin.ro/articol_60990/piata-de-cosmetice-de-lux-va-creste-usor-in-2011--conditionata-de-extinderearetailerilor.html 8 http://www.wall-street.ro/articol/Companii/90426/Cosmeticele-naturale-o-piata-de-5-5-mil-euro-inRomania.html
towards more accessible brands, as a drawback for the top brands, and their openness towards promotions. Richard Matalon, the country managing direct at LOreal Romania declared that the market in Romania is increasing, and that this is a good news for their portfolio of brands. Buying in hyper and supermarkets is still dynamic, thanks to new locations opened and promotions.9 LOreal blames the very good results in the first half of 2009 on the innovation and promotion of their products. For example, on the hair care market, the consumer products market division of LOreal Romania had registered a dynamic growth of over 30%. For the professional division, the Kerastase brand, based on advanced technology, increased by 10%. As for the active cosmetics, Roche-Posay, skin care products, recommended worldwide by dermatologists, has registered an increase of 25%. Also, Farmec Cluj-Napoca, the biggest local cosmetics producer, had registered an increase of 13% on the market. As for 2011, it was estimated that Romanians will buy cosmetics in value of over 1 billion Euro, 3% more than in 2010. According to a study, the most wanted products are the ones for mass consumption. Considerable growth is expected in children care products and premium cosmetics, but also for perfumes, accounting for 196 million Euro.10 So only one conclusion can be drafted after studying these figures. The dynamics of the cosmetics industry is very obvious, increasing from one year to another, despite the condition of the economy. More and more people start to use, even from adolescence, products for skin care, offering to the producers the possibility to increase their market share.
Organizational purposes
Vision LOreals vision is to become the first choice of people who wish to feel beautiful by continuously offering high quality products, by exploring new opportunities, by formulating organic products, by continuous technological innovations and by valuing the stakeholders. Mission L`Oreal`s mission is Beauty for everyone. It tries to push back the boundaries of science to invent beauty and meet the aspirations of millions of women and men. Its vocation is universal: to offer everyone, all over the world, the best of cosmetics in terms of quality, efficiency and safety, to give everyone access to beauty by offering products in harmony with their needs, culture and expectations.11 With the opening up of the emerging markets, L`Oreal`s mission is broadening in response to the vast diversity of populations. The whole company is focused on this new horizon: teams enriched by their culture diversity, a portfolio of international brands present in the different distribution channels and research that is capable of grasping in the world`s complexity.
Values L`Oreal has been built around fundamental values which have guided us throughout the life of our company, and continue to do so today. Our values have shaped our culture, and they underpin our reputation12. Reflect the consumers diversity or origins within teams at every level Be committed to sustainable, responsible and shared growth Promote gender equity with the teams Encourage the employment people with disabilities Valorize work experience Develop an inclusive managerial culture13 Diversity represents a priority for LOreal, and the values shared within the company are enforced by the fact that they respect their standards of excellence, attract candidates from outside their usual talent sources and identify profiles that will bring new perspectives, promote the emergence of a diversified ecosystem by inviting partners to join their actions, and by participating in innovative collective initiatives and measure and report the progress. Objectives The main objective of the company is the economic success and sustained development and growth of the company. In terms of image, L`Oreal`s objective is to ensure that as a company, it is seen as a global citizen , and it is the world`s leading beauty company it needs to be an authentic example in terms of sustainable development.
12
13
consumers, nature and biodiversity, reduce packaging and volume and replace renewable resources and recycled materials. Outbound logistics collect, store and distribute the product to customers, and here we can find activities such as warehousing, materials handling, distribution. LOreal optimizes its global production on a regional basis, placing operations teams as close as possible to the markets they serve, such that each production site to be more responsive and more efficient in terms of logistics and transport. Marketing and sales provide the means through which the customers are made aware of the products and are able to purchase them. Sales administration, advertising, selling, all these make sure that the consumers can find the desired products on the shelf. At LOreal marketing is right the heart of their strategy, and builds awareness of the products designed to captivate consumers across the world, anticipating fashion trends and transforming them into a source of beauty and well-being. Service to enhance or maintain the value of the product: LOreal offers in-salon treatments, but also on-location using online training bank to reveal different styling techniques.
The effectiveness or efficiency of these primary activities is improved by the support activities. Procurement. LOreal is committed to building strong and sustainable relationships with its suppliers, based on trust, mutual benefits and high standards, giving loser attention to the issue of fair procurement. In order for the products to be manufactured, these require a wide range of raw materials that make up the specific formula. LOreal directly partners with suppliers that specialize in various technical groups, such as: polymers, fats, natural products, perfumes, sunscreens, vitamins etc. Technology development. The technology in LOreal is vital to the operational and strategic performance. New technologies and innovative solutions are a must in this industry. In this matter, LOreal has worldwide Research and Innovation laboratories, where specialists from different fields develop new formulas, which are marketed internationally. Human resource management. The culture in LOreal is rich in talent and diversity, encouraging people to contribute with creativity and enthusiasm. In order to achieve its objectives, LOreal recruits the best people through university partnerships and innovative business games, tailors personal and professional development opportunities to individual needs, uses diversity to drive business success, motivates its people through their global development system, as well as remuneration policy and profit-sharing programs and maintains active dialogue in order to understand the peoples perspective. Infrastructure. The infrastructure of LOreal is comprised of its organizational culture, the ways of doing things and the routines accumulated over time.
It is not possible for a company alone to create value. Porters value chain theory regards value activities as linear chains. But more and more scholars argue that the forms and structures of value activities cannot be explained by linear thinking (Christensen & Rosenbloom, 1955; Duncan & Moriarty, 1997). This means that between the company and its customers and suppliers, there is not only a one way value chain, starting from suppliers and ending at customers, but also reverse or transverse value chains from customers to the company or to suppliers, or from the company to the suppliers. These linkages of value chains constitute a value
7
network (Bovet & Martha, 2000). Alongside the internal production of their products, LOreal collaborates with a broad range of subcontractor companies, outsourcing operations like: Packaging of finishing finished products Manufacturing specific finished products (pencils, cloths, etc.) Logistics
The SWOT analysis summarizes the key issues from the business environment and the strategic capability of an organization (Johnson, Scholes & Whittington, 2008).
Brand image - World No. 1 - R&d - 586 patents - Range of portfolio - producct diversity - Global brand - High quality of components - Culturally diverse company
- Growing cosmetics market - Acquisition of local brands - Target groups with growth potential (men and children)
SWOT
- Brand confusion - No local production center - No local laboratories - Different perception of the company compared to the Group - Counterfeit products - New competitors - Change in spending patterns of consumers - Anti-makeup campaigns - Incresed Taxes
Different circumstances may lead to limitation in managing strategic capabilities (Johnson et al, 2008): Competences are valued but not understood. Managers may know that there are activities in their organization that have a positive impact and may value them, but may not understand just how such positive impact arises. Competences are not valued. Managers may know that activities and processes exist in the organization but not recognize their positive impact or value such activities. Competences are recognized, valued and understood. Managers may be able to nurture and further develop such competences, for example by ensuring that overall company policies support and enhance them. The danger can be that top management may seek to preserve such capabilities by over-formalizing or codifying them such that they become set in stone. A limitation is represented by LOreals problems with racial discrimination, being declared guilty by the highest court in France. This can tarnish the companys image and lead to a loss in the market share. Another problem that the company confronted with was its policy to test the products on animals. Starting with 1989, LOreal has invested significantly in alternative methods for chemical safety testing, so no animal testing for finished products has taken place since.
http://www.cosmeticsdesign-europe.com/Business-Financial/L-Oreal-unveils-three-pronged-strategy-for-futuregrowth
10
2. The second part of the strategy involves fundamental changes to the way the company operates, changes that have been focused on streamlining, focusing and simplifying and making the business more efficient. This strategy will be realized through continual industrial reengineering of the business, elimination of the inefficient facilities, a more centralized purchasing process, an improvement in the utilization of equipment and more advances in productivity.15 3. The third part of the strategy involves an increase in Research & Development investments because it contributes invaluably to the innovation efficacy, quality and safety of our products that will enable us to stand out from our competitors. Investments are also done in the Promotion & Advertising department in order to sustain the sales growth for the companys brands and products (Agon, 2010). Strategic directions Market penetration refers to a strategy by which an organization takes increased share of its existing markets with its existing product range. Regarding this type of strategy, the CEO Of LOreal Group sustained the fact that the company will focus on attracting new customers in new markets by developing a product portfolio that will aim at keeping every type of consumer involved. Market development refers to a strategy by which an organization offers existing products to new markets. Agon declared that in addition to traditional developing markets like Russia, China, Brazil and India they will focus on markets like Thailand, South Africa, Korea, Ukraine, Indonesia, Philippines and Turkey at which he added Vietnam, Egypt, Pakistan and Kazakhstan. The reason of his decision is the fact that the growth in new market zones has been spectacular and the value of those markets is expected to overtake that of Europe in the next two to three yearsand in less than ten years new markets will account for 50 percent of the companys total sales16. If previously LOreal Group was interested in increasing penetration in existing leading markets, now they are taking into account this type of strategy because they could observe the fact that the sales volume in new markets has doubled every decade since 1990 and because they are reducing the dependence on the developed markets where growth potential remains limited. Product development - refers to a strategy by which an organization delivers modified or new products to existing markets. LOreal Group strategy will focus on extending their brands to include new product categories. This strategy will be achieved mainly on the men and old peoples market. Observing an increasing trend of the number of old people, LOreal plans to develop new cosmetics, especially anti-aging skin care and other age related products 17. The strategy regarding the creation of new products for men has two very important reasons. The first is the fact that , the mens cosmetics market is not as saturated as it is the womens market and men have proven to be more loyal to specific products than women. *Business level strategy
15
11
Business level strategy refers to how the various businesses included in the corporate strategy should compete in their particular markets. This typically concerns issues such as pricing strategy, innovation or differentiation, for instance by better quality or a distinctive distribution channel. (Johnson et al, 2008) LOreal stands in front of the cosmetics industry due to its differentiation strategy. Through differentiation strategy we understand that type of strategy under which a firm aims to develop and market unique products for different customer segments. Usually employed where a firm has clear competitive advantages, and can sustain an expensive advertising campaign. LOreal based its activity on continuous investment in rigorous scientific research and development which enables their brands to deliver products that are innovative, highly effective and which are manufactured to the most demanding standards of quality and safety. The strategic business units compete in different product and geographic markets, but focus on less price sensitive segments, and thus pursue Porters premium-pricing differentiation strategy in each segment18. In terms of marketing strategy there a several aspects worth to be mentioned and one of them is the fact that LOreal is embracing diversity and not just in terms of cultural mix of employees, but also in terms of their consumers. LOreals products address to women worldwide, specific products being developed for certain women like Asian women, Women of color, Caucasian women, so on so forth. In terms of promotion, the company uses actresses or different personalities of all ages that best emphasize the vision and the Company with whom the average individuals identify with, and gives them the feeling that they can look as good as the imagine of the company. LOreal has not only followed a comprehensive, long term R&D strategy but it has also tried to address and maintain its balance between R&D-marketing interface. Moreover, the company follows a three pillars strategy for producing commercially viable products. The three structured strategy includes LOreals advanced research, applied research and product development, each stage having its own unique functions to perform in order to create successful innovations19. In terms of branding strategy we should mention that LOreal is launching different brand marketing strategy for its brands, each of them having their own personalities, different market segments for product design , price positioning, advertising communication and channel construction in order to meet consumer demand for differentiation. The LOreal mark of products like Lancome, Helena Rubistein, Biotherm and others is hard to be seen, because the company tries to create different brand images to its products, each being unique in its own way, finally belonging to the same group. Also in terms of recruiting strategy, LOreal is highly innovative and revolutionary, and the game Reveal is the best prove of this. REVEAL represents and educative game for young people that are interested in the business of a multinational company and in the opportunities they could have in their carrier. Ana Perrin, HR Manager defines 3 priorities in term of human resources: recruitment of the most talented persons, promotion of the diversity inside the company and
18
12
sustain the professional development of the employees. Having a solid business model, the recruitment strategy aims to attract as various profiles as possible from the entire world.20
20
13
In 2008, the European Commission admitted the acquisition of Yves Saint Laurent Beaute , the value of the acquisition being of 1.78 billion dollars and the contract specifies that The LOreal Group will have exclusive license only for YSL fragrances. Mainly LOreal chooses to acquire the brands mentioned above in order to enter easily on new markets like African or Asian market. Also if the Group intended to enter on a certain area of the cosmetics industry, also the acquisitions were the best option. c. Alliances represent the method where two or more organizations share resources and activities to pursue a strategy In 1981, LOreal and Nestle decide the creation of a joint-venture named Galderma specialized in research , development and marketing of innovative medical solutions in dermatology. In 2002, LOreal moves into new markets for cosmetic nutritional supplements through the creation of Inneov. Gathering the knowledge of LOreal Research and Nestle Research, Inneov will face a scientific breakthrough to develop this fast-growing market.22 In 2003 another alliance, this time with Mr. Shy Uemura, a great make-up artist enables LOreals Luxury Division to enter the strategic Japanese market but also to give global resonance to that luxury Japanese brand.
Strategy evaluation
In general, when assessing the validity of strategic options there are three success criteria which can be used: suitability, acceptability and feasibility. Further, we are going to evaluate LOreals strategy using all the criteria listed above. Suitability is concerned with whether a strategy addresses the key issues relating to the strategic position of the organization; therefore it is concerned with the overall rationale of a strategy. In evaluating if a strategy is suitable for an organization, there has to be made an assessment of the extent to which the strategic options fit with the key drivers and expected challenges in the environment, exploit strategic capabilities are appropriate in the context of shareholders expectations and cultural influences. In order to assess the suitability of the strategy we will use TOWS Matrix which is a method of identifying the strategic options on the basis of a SWOT analysis. Internal factors Strengths Weaknesses - diversification; - acquisitions; - product development strategy; - investment in innovation; - superior market position; - develop strong brand portfolio; - improve product quality - improved service to customers; -downstream operations; - reliable products;
Opportunities
22
www.loreal.com
14
Acceptability is concerned with the expected performance outcomes of a strategy and the extent to which these meet the expectations of stakeholders. Feasibility is concerned with weather a strategy could work in practice; therefore it has the capabilities to deliver a strategy.
Conclusion
The dynamics of the cosmetics industry is very obvious, increasing from one year to another, despite the condition of the economy and more and more people start to use, even from adolescence, products for skin care, offering to the producers the possibility to increase their market share. L`Oreal is the world`s leading beauty company and this is due to their continuously strategy development (every year they improve or change their strategy so that the company can adapt well to the business environment). Through their commitment to innovation and continuous research, they keep on bringing up new products on the market, adapting to the market demand that is always looking for something new, revolutionary. Their marketing campaigns are strongly promoted in any kind of media, from internet and TV commercials to banners and newspapers. L`Oreal keeps on being the number one beauty products company in the world and specialists say it will still remain like this for at least 5 years. Why? Because theyre worth it!
15
References
Johnson, G., Scholes, K., Whittington, R., (2008). Exploring Corporate Strategy, 8th edition, Essex: Pearson Prentice Hall Porter, M.(1985). Competitive Advantage: Creating and Sustaining Superior Performance, New York: The Free Press Bratianu, C. (2011). Course Materials for Strategic Management Christensen, C., Rosenbloom, R.(1995). Explaining the attackers advantage: Technological paradigms, organizational dynamics, and the value network, Research Policy Duncan, T., Moriarty, S. (1997). Driving Brand Value: Using Integrated Marketing to Manage Profitable Stakeholder Relationship, New York: McGraq-Hill Bovet, D., Martha, J.(2000) Value Nets: Breaking the Supply Chain to Unlock Hidden Profits, John Wiley and Sons Johnson, G., Scholes, K., Whittington, R. (2008) . Exploring Corporate Strategy. Prentice Hall Teeuwsen, B. (2010). Strategy Development Key Concepts & Frameworks, [Online] available at <http://www.slideshare.net/StrategyAndMarketing/strategy-development-key-concepts-andframeworks-presentation> , [accessed on 27.12.2011] Mintel, (2005), Retail Intelligence Report Fashion Accessories, Mintel Corporation Pitman, S. (2010). LOreal to Concentrate on New Markets in 2010. [Online] available at <http://www.cosmeticsdesign.com/Business-Financial/L-Oreal-to-concentrate-on-new-marketsin-2010> , [accessed on 27.12.2011] Unknown Author. The Birth of Permanent Hair Color and LOreal, [Online] available at, < http://www.herbatint.co.uk/herbatint/features/herbatint-article.php?id=28>, [accessed on 28.12.2011] Unknown Author. Description of the company, http://freq.3x.ro/pages/despre.html>, [accessed on 28.12.2011] [Online] available at <
Badiu, I. (2008). Alina Perrin, HR manager la LOreal Romania: Poti sa ajungi country manager la 27 de ani, [Online] available at < http://www.zf.ro/profesii/alina-perrin-hr-manager-
16
la-l-oreal-romania-poti-sa-ajungi-country-manager-la-27-de-ani-3051445/> 28.12.2011]
[accessed
on
Unknown Author,(20110. Coty Romania estimeaza afaceri de 20 mil. Dolari in anul fiscal current, [Online] available at < http://www.curierulnational.ro/Actualitate%20Companii/201102-04/Coty+Romania+estimeaza+afaceri+de+20+mil.+dolari+in+anul+fiscal+curent>, [accessed on 28.12.2011] Barleanu, V. (2011). Piata de cosmetic de lux va creste usor in 2011, conditionata de extinderea retailerilor. [Online] available at < http://www.fin.ro/articol_60990/piata-de-cosmetice-de-luxva-creste-usor-in-2011--conditionata-de-extinderea-retailerilor.html> [accessed on 28.12.2011] Apetrei, A.(2010). Cosmeticele natural, o piata de 5,5 mil euro in Romania. [Online] available at http://www.wall-street.ro/articol/Companii/90426/Cosmeticele-naturale-o-piata-de-5-5-mil-euroin-Romania.html, [accessed on 28.12.2011] Unknown Author, (2009). Top 6 industrii care au crescut pet imp de criza. [Online] available at < http://www.wall-street.ro/top/Companii/69673/Top-6-industrii-care-au-crescut-pe-timp-decriza/3/Cosmeticele-10.html#slide_title>, [accessed on 28.12.2011] Bratu, R. (2011). Piata romaneasca de cosmetice creste fabulous pana la un milliard de euro. [Online] available at < http://ideideafaceri.manager.ro/articole/afacerea-zilei/afacerea-zilei:piata-romaneasca-de-cosmetice-creste-fabulos-pana-la-un-miliard-de-euro-1806.html>, [acceseed on 28.12.2011] Annual report 2010 Company website [Online] available <www.sustainabledevelopment.loreal.com at <www.lorealparis.ro>, <www.loreal.com>,
17