Jan 21
Jan 21
Jan 21
M O N D AY
Merak-Sakteng Gewogs
FARMROADS
If tourism hasnt been benefitting the people more than a road, well take the roads to the gewogs, Lyonchhoen said. We should respect peoples wishes. Herders from Merak and Sakteng said tourism hasnt benefitted the community, except for a handful, who own more horses and cattle. Although we appreciate the governments decision to leave the road half way to maximise the benefits from tourism, the plan hasnt benefited all, a herder Tenzin Gembo said. Earlier, the government had decided to build the road until Jigmeling in Merak, and Thrakthri in Sakteng. It was speculated that, if the road were built to the gewogs, many tourists wouldnt halt in the villages. It was also thought to benefit the community through porter and pony charges. Lyonchhoen said taking the roads to gewog offices of Merak and Sakteng wouldnt
COVER STORY
If tourism hasnt been benefitting the people more than a road, well take the roads to the gewogs
Jigmi Y Thinley The prime minister
WHATS INSIDE
PG. 9:
2 HOME
right now is that its a handful of people making decisions, he said. Ours would be democratic way of making decision. One of the founding members, Dr Tandi Dorji, said it was not just the prime minister or other parliament members alone that made a democracy, but that the role of other institutions and agencies must be respected. Everybody must be engaged and opinions and criticisms must be taken, he said. We havent seen this happening and this is what we, in true Nyamrup spirit, intend to do. Meanwhile, having secured registration, the party now intends to ready their documents, based on feedback election commission provided, and then head for respective constituencies. The interim president said a lot remained to be done, and that they have sleepless nights ahead. Dr Tandi Dorji said, despite being the first group to express interest to take part in the 2013 elections, they had taken a long time to build a strong team. It goes to show our intention to serve the country in a professional and dedicated manner, he said. The party that first came out in the media in January 2012 today has 41 people on the partys confirmed list of candidates. They hope to complete the list soon.
But, at the same time, wed like to welcome all those likeminded people, who believe that the country requires a viable alternative, who believes in strong political institution and who believes that, with new times, new ideas are required, we welcome them, Dr Tandi Dorji said. Meanwhile, receiving the certificate of registration from the election commission yesterday, interim president Jigme Zangpo said the party was founded on the belief that, in a healthy democracy, there must be strong political institutions that keep national interests above everything, and who provide alternative choices for the people. Nyamrup shall always strive to be such a party, he said. He also highlighted on the partys core beliefs that wealth and power should be spread among all Bhutanese, that opportunities should be provided equally, irrespective of ones station in life, that no Bhutanese is left behind, among others. Jigme Zangpo said the partys charter and manifesto was based on the principles of freedom, justice and solidarity. We believe these principles are the pillars that will hold people together, at the same time giving each individual his or her own space and voice, he said.
HOME
BUMTHANG
35 minutes
AVIATION
The finance ministrys recent circular to various ministries encouraged civil servants to use domestic air services in their travels to central, eastern and southern parts of the country. Besides helping sustain the domestic air services that have been rendered groundbound than soar to the skies, the logic among authorities was to enhance efficiency and save time. The conclusion is deduced from the consideration and verbal admission of some ministrys accounts officials that civil servants, when out on tour within the country, besides preferring to drive their own cars for convenience sake, and the mileage it earned them, claim travel and daily allowance for at least a week. Since most secretaries and directors have their own pool vehicles, finance ministry officials said they rarely claimed mileage, except for their daily allowance, which was fixed at Nu 800 a day. It was mostly P5 level officers, they said, who chose to drive their own cars for official duty to various parts of the country. Calculated at Nu 14 a kilometre, a P5 level civil servant residing in Thimphu, travelling to Gelephu, which is 266km, going by road safety and transport authority figures that almost all organisations follow, from the capital city earns from mere mileage, (both to and fro) Nu 7,448. Add to that another Nu
PARO
267k
THIMPHU
m
551km
TRASHIGANG
25 minutes
266
km
GELEPHU
Destination By road
(TA/DA)
Sarpang Bumthang Trashigang Sarpang Bumthang Trashigang 5,600 5,600 5,600 10,948 10,976 18,928
By flight
(Round trip)
7,350 7,350 11,400 7,300 7,300 11,400
Mileage for both calculated at Nu 14 a kilometre. Excluding hiring charges of private vehicles on reaching destination and milage to airport and back.
3,500, which is the sum of their daily allowance over a week of Nu 500 a day on reaching their destination of work, and considering they spend at least a week, including two days on travel, tots up to Nu 10,948. The same officer, who now travels to Bumthang, which is 267km from Thimphu, under the same computation and similar scenario, earns about the same amount. Drive further to the east to Trashigang, which is 551km from the capital city, and that amount almost doubles to Nu 18,928. Should they choose to board a plane, notwithstanding the rocky experience passengers flying domestic shared
initially, than endure the longwinding lateral highway, the figure works out slightly lower. Here again, the figure is deduced, excluding the charges for hiring of private vehicles for official duty once landing at the destination, which is to be done by the dzongkhag administration through annual quotation, and considering they spend two working days instead of a week. Civil servants spending two days have been based on Drukairs schedule of flying thrice a week to its domestic destinations, on Tuesdays, Thursdays and Saturdays. Drukair has been chosen for the purpose of comparison, because of availability of
its fares. Therefore, a P5 level officer, who chooses to fly Drukair to Trashigang from Thimphu at Nu 11,400 (round trip fare) is paid Nu 1,512 (two-way mileage) between Thimphu and Paro airport, which is 54km, Nu 1,000 daily allowance for two-day halt at their destination and another Nu 250 half-day daily allowance on return, works out to a total of Nu 14,162. Considering a worst-case scenario that Phuentsholing, as the furthest from Paro airport, and a civil servant there is going to Trashigang, flying still turns out to be an alternative worth considering. Besides the Nu 11,400 air-
fare, the civil servant will be drawing Nu 4,620 (two-way) mileage between Phuentsholing and Paro airport, and two-day daily allowance of Nu 1,000 and another Nu 250 on returning. All that adds up to Nu 17,270. Under similar scenario, flights to Bumthang and Gelephu, which are both Nu 7,300 for a round trip, also work out to Nu 10,062. Apart from advantages in terms of better use of human resource, enhanced efficiency, and at comparable cost or lower, information and communications minister Nandalal Rai said travel by air was safer.
PERSPECTIVES
Snow hol
oday is a holiday in the capital and perhaps other parts of the country like Paro and Bumthang that experienced the first snowfall of this winter on Saturday. Declaring a holiday on the first snowfall has become a tradition of sorts, albeit a relatively new tradition, that perhaps began after a modern civil service came into place. But this is the first time in recent memory where a holiday has been declared by the home ministry for a snowfall that occurred during the weekend. In the past, a snowfall holiday would be declared only if the flakes descended on a working day, or on the night before a working day, and the whole place looked draped in white in the morning. That is why many always hoped the first snowfall would happen during a working day, to be able to reap a guaranteed holiday. And when it did not happen, there would be those who would swear under their breath. This time, some people, particularly those in the private sector, are still grumbling about the home ministry declaring today, a working day, as a holiday because, with the government offices and institutions all closed, it means no work can get done. Such a reaction does show how things have changed. Who would grumble about a holiday in the past? Now its coming down to one day lost to get things done. The other question on peoples minds is when and how did the tradition of snowfall holidays begin. It obviously came with modern development and the creation of a civil service. Senior civil servants say the logic for a snowfall holiday in the past was more to do with inconveniences a snowfall created. Getting to office became a problem, and most walked, since not many owned a vehicle. Quite often the snowfall would disrupt electric and telephones, making it near impossible to get work done, even if one went to office. So it made sense to declare a holiday. In many countries, schools and universities and, sometimes, even government offices remain closed following a heavy snowfall, primarily for road safety reasons, although the university bus may still be plying to the stadium, if the university team is up against another team. For most Bhutanese though, it is not so much the holiday but the snowfall itself that was most welcome and fulfilling. And this winter it came quite unexpectedly on the morning of January 12, soft and gentle as it always is. As elderly citizens would say, a snowfall reduces the possibilities of sickness and illness, and softens and conditions the earth for the coming agriculture season. If the snowfall was more than welcome this time, it is because it appears to be getting scarce with each passing year. Perhaps that is the logic for the snowfall holiday.
MY COUNTRY, MY TOWN
Kid among the pigeons : A little boy enjoys feeding a flock of birds
Photo by Karma Dupchu, Kuensel
MY SAY
MANAGING DIRECTOR - Chencho Tshering, DEPUTY MANAGING DIRECTOR - Thinley Dorji, EDITOR - Phuntsho Wangdi, NEWS EDITOR - Samten Wangchuk, DESIGN EDITOR - Chencho Tshering, CHIEF PHOTOGRAPHER - Karma Dupchu, PRINTING GM - Karma Nima, CIRCULATION MANAGER - Ugyen Norbu, REGIONAL HEAD (KANGLUNG) - Pema Tenzin
HOME
Phuentsholing, Chukha
STORAGE
The demand has not only pushed rental charges up, but building owners have even begun turning residential flats into warehouses, which is only adding to the existing housing crunch in Phuentsholing. Talk about lack of spaces for warehouses, the banks of the Amochu have been leased to contractors and private agencies, which build warehouses by the river bank. Even Norgay cinema hall has decided to convert the hall into a warehouse, after it was closed in April 2010 suffering huge losses. Norgay cinema hall manager had earlier said that, if the building was to be demolished,
Even if Im not willing to pay the amount there will always be someone who will
Phuentsholing businessman
tal city. Theres no spaces designated for warehouses in Thimphu, a businessman said. Most of us land up using rental apartments or shops. Many new building constructions in Thimphu now have basement provisions, initially planned as parking lots, turn into storage space, once buildings are completed. A new building in Thimphu charge between Nu 20,000 and Nu 100,000 for storage or other commercial purposes.
APIARY
The associations chairperson, Tekh Bahadur Pulami, said around 100 hives will be selected from the 34 members to be moved by April end this year. He said the plan is to keep the bees in Haa for a month and a half, which also has flowering plants like in Bumthang, such as apple, clover and buckwheat. The association would then take back the hives to Bumthang to extract honey. On the day of shifting, the
6 ASIA
CLASSIFIEDS
looking for a house maid. Attractive salary. For sale: Tata Truck If interested, please call 10 and Tipper 11, loan 17231406. transferable. Contact Wanted: One sales 17757705. girl at Phuentsholing. Sale: Hiace bus Contact 17111824. 91 model. Contact Vacancy: Scancafe 17875211. announces 250+ slots Sale: Van. Contact for graphics and video 17429755. editing. Class X/XII can attend interview Sale: i20 10 model, at Ministry of Labour Alto K10 11 model. from 21-28 January. Contact 17686817. For more information, contact Athang 17718721. Rent: Office space at Changlam. Contact 17111239. PIT BIT & CIT: Your , Sale: Fully set accountability of filing restaurant at tax for the year 2012. Changangkha Norling Please contact Niche Building @ five lakhs Financial Service, (negotiable). Contact 17115554. 17230545. Announcement: For sale: Fully Contact Zenith Cargo furnished showroom to carry your goods located opposite from Kathmandu Bhutan Archery shop. - Bhutan. Call For details contact 9803795625/zexim@ 17610708. wlink.com.np Rent: 3 bedroom flats available at lower Serbithang on the way to Royal Thimphu College at Nu.6000. Contact 17714066. Sale: Timber. Contact Chungsel Sawmill at 17635792/ 17172577. Newly opened: Tip Top Dry Cleaner and Laundry next to 8 Eleven super market (delivery within 24 hours). Contact 17609516. Announcement: For any quarries regarding business, education or travel and tourism. Contact + 66 867118076 or email at monprasad18@yahoo. com (based in Bangkok, Thailand).
Despite the end to the three-day hostage crisis in Algeria, nations like Japan are trying to determine how many people are unaccounted for.
Algeria said that among the 32 militants killed, only three were Algerians; the rest were from other countries. In a statement Saturday, the Algerian interior ministry said the military found a number of foreign military uniforms in its sweep of the facility to clear it of mines planted by militants. Militants in pickup trucks struck the sprawling gas complex in In Amenas at dawn Wednesday, gathered the Westerners who worked there into a group and tied them up. The plant is run by Algerias state oil company, in cooperation with foreign firms such as Norways Statoil and Britains BP -- and as such, employed workers from several foreign countries. The kidnappers wielded AK-47 rifles and put explosiveladen vests on some hostages, according to a U.S. State Department official. Algeria said the attack was in retaliation for allowing France to use Algerian airspace for an offensive against Islamist militants in neighboring Mali. But regional analysts believe it was too sophisticated to have been planned in days. The next day, Algerian special forces moved in because the government said the militants wanted to flee for Mali. The Islamic extremists also planned to blow up the gas installation and rigged it with mines throughout, the U.S. official said. Thursdays military incursion succeeded in freeing some hostages -- but not all. Some survivors described their harrowing escapes by rigging up disguises and sneaking to safety with locals, with at least one survivor running for his life with plastic explosives strapped around his neck. Several hostages died. And the Algerian military came under criticism from some quarters for unnecessarily endangering the lives of the hostages. Undeterred, government followed with a second push Saturday. That assault killed the remaining hostage-takers but resulted in more hostage deaths. The army intervened to avoid a bloody turning point of events in this extremely dangerous situation, the Algerian interior ministry said Saturday. It was clear that the terrorists were determined to escape the country with the captives and to bomb the gas installations. British Defense Secretary Philip Hammond called the loss of life appalling and unacceptable, but laid the blame solely on the terrorists. Now, individual nations are scrambling to find out what happened to their citizens. It is not clear how many hostages were seized by the Islamist militants in the first place. CNN
Sale: Land at Yuselpang. Contact 17620817. Sale: Land at Semtokha. Contact 17111461. Sale: Land at Paro below Taktshang Monastery. Contact 17611119.
Wanted: Family
Know your NA candidate @ www.kuenselonline.com/2013elections
DIVERSION 7
CLUES
ACROSS
1 Grass on which one may lie (5) 8 Report of a death that has just come in? (4,4) 9 State needs new taxes (5) 10 Treatment that is always on hand (8) 11 Make staid entrances (5) 12 Consumed what some caterers provided (3) 16 Unions strangely in agreement (6) 17 In hostilities I have a form of surrender (6) 18 Join in the festivities (3) 23 Boards a coach (5) 24 British capitalist (8) 25 A tall one may be difficult to carry out (5) 26 Get up hurriedly and prepare the eggs (8) 27 Union notice that may be objected to (5)
daffynition
call [Academia]
What you cant do because your stupid roommate has to go over every stupid detail of every stupid day with their stupid hometown sweetheart
superstition cat
When you see a one-eyed cat, spit on your thumb, stamp it in the palm of your hand, and make a wish. The wish will come true.
riddlemeree
the accidental riddle
DOWN
2 Its not rare to be exaggerated (8) 3 Correct in case this is wrong (8) 4 Learned man took the chair around the front (6) 5 Be entitled to credit (5) 6 An awkward brute to disprove (5) 7 Piece of land is on lease (5) 12 Exemplary worker (3) 13 It eats grass in fine weather (3) 14 A queenly carriage? (8) 15 Agree on two points, then another colour (3,5) 19 Eccentric ladies highly thought of (6) 20 Near the end (5) 21 Sleep soundly? (5) 22 Mean to a girl (5) SOLUTION NEXT WEEK
q: A man fell off a 20-foot ladder, landed on the sidewalk, but did not get hurt. Why not? a: He fell off the bottom rung!
todayinhistory
JANUARY 14 ANSWERS
1922
The first slalom event in skiing was held in Murren, Switzerland.
ACROSS: 1 Gurnard, 5 Pride, 8 Potpourri, 9 Tar, 10 Sage, 12 Scottish, 14 Breaks, 15 Ensign, 17 Grasping, 18 Unit, 21 Tot, 22 Easter egg, 24 Darts, 25 Detroit. DOWN: 1 Gapes, 2 Rat, 3 Ahoy, 4 Direct, 5 Pristine, 6 Intuition, 7 Earthen, 11 Goes after, 13 Skippers, 14 Bigited, 16 Unused, 19 Tight, 20 Meet, 23 Ego.
happybirthday
JACK
Nicklaus
1940Golf champion
beau peep
quotefortheday
For most of history, Anonymous was a woman.
VIRGINIA Woolf 1882-1941
homegrown
COMMON
Myna
(Acridotheres trisitis) Abundant
KUENSEL TO ADVERTISE call 326191 or fax 326638; email: advertisement@ kuensel.com.bt TO SUBSCRIBE call 327463
ecotip
Go Green
FRESH AIR
According to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, the air within homes and other buildings can be more seriously polluted than the outdoor air.
Sell
54.85 86.95 72.85 60.65 7.05 57.30 44.50
anagram
Unscramble anagram for a chess player
Courtesy BNB
Milicevic
HOME
Lhakhang Robberies
TASHI DEMA
Police have busted a racket of theft and illicit transaction of cultural properties, after they announced a reward of Nu 100,000 last December to informers on the burglary of six lhakhangs of Wangduephodrang, Punakha, Paro and Thimphu dzongkhags.
Based on the report, charges will be framed against those involved in the illegal practices
An OAG official
CRIME
As of yesterday, police had arrested 11 people in connection to the racket, and investigations revealed that 25 pairs of elephant tusks worth Nu 4.5M were sold across the border. In a period of 17 months, between August 2011 and December last year, 13 elephant tusks and rhino horns were stolen from Pangsho gonpa , Shoba lhakhang and Masipokto lhakhang in Wangduephodrang, Pumola lhakhang in Thimphu, Yami gonpa in Punakha and Ugyen Tsemo lhakhang in Paro. Paro police arrested two people in connection to the burglary of Ugyen Tsemo lhakhang in Paro, following a tipoff
forests to expand their holdings. Dungpa Nima Gyeltshen, who saw the discrepancies mostly in Norbugang gewog, when signing the cadastral resurvey document in 2011, immediately forwarded a notice to the Pemagatshel dzongkhag, NLC and ACC to intervene. The ACC investigation team first visited Nganglam in early July last year, and made a second visit in September the same year.
from informers. The two confessed to have stolen a pair of elephant tusks from Ugyen Tsemo lhakhang on December 20 last year. Police recovered the tusks from a hideout near one of the mens house. The two also confessed to have stolen a pair of elephant tusks from Pumla lhakhang in Thimphu on November 10 last year. Police investigations revealed that the two men gave the tusk to three other men, who sold it across the border for more than Nu 300,000. Paro police also arrested the three accomplices. Based on an informers tipoff, Wangduephodrang police arrested two men, who confessed to have stolen an elephant tusk from Pangsho gonpa in Wangduephodrang on August 7, 2011. Police sources also said investigations revealed that a racket on import and export of elephant tusks, and the magical fungus, cordyceps, was rampant in the country. Police are still investigating the case, a police source said.
Slots 01
Qualification/experience
Employment status
Diploma in Mechanical/Electrical with 3 Regular years active work experience or VTI passout mechanical/Electrical with 5 years active work experience VTI plant Mechanical/Electrical Engineering with work experience preferred Minimum 2 years driving experience of heavy & light vehicle Regular Temporary for 6 months extendable based on performance
02 02
Interested candidates should submit their applications latest by 4th February, 2013 along with the following documents: 1. Academic transcripts 3. Security clearance certificate 5. NOC from previous employer, if employed 2. Citizenship ID card copy 4. Medical fitness certificate 6. Work experience certificate
Interview for the short listed candidates will be held on 9th February, 2013 at 10am at the company. For further details, contact AFD at 02-351078. Interview for the post of Adm. Assistant & Office Assistant will also be held on the same date. Managing Director
DZONGKHAG 9
Tsamdro/Sokshing
Gol Building
MEETING
It has been decided to uphold the tsamdro rights under individual thram, as it was reflected in the preceding land act of 2007, lyonchhoen said. Sokshing is a plot of forestland used for leaf litter production and collection, while tsamdro is grazing land. Lyonchhoen told the people that his government couldnt amend the land act 2007, because resolving the tsamdro issue wasnt within the governments capacity. Moreover, we feared that, if we resolve the issue, some people would misinterpret it as vested political interest, lyonchhoen said. People from Merak and Sakteng raised the issue of conflict, arising from the deletion of tsamdro rights from their thrams, to the prime minister. Weve been caught up in innumerable disputes, because the land act 2007
Inside the gol building: Tenants have not yet moved out YANGCHEN C RINZIN, PHUENTSHOLING
With the deadline missed, the 11 private tenants of gol building in Phuentsholing will be now dealt with by the court, national housing development corporation (NHDC) officials in Phuentsholing said.
UPDATE
The tenants were to move out on January 19, but none of them had left as of yesterday. NHDC official said they would wait for the courts decision. NHDC had asked these tenants to vacate the flats, to provide to middle income civil servants, who have already applied for these flats. The gol building that was initially under the dungkhag is since 2009 under NHDC, which is mandated to provide houses for middle and lower income civil servants. NHDCs manager in Phuentsholing, Tshering
Penjor, said they asked the tenants to vacate, as per the courts order, and if the order was not followed, it depends on the court on what should be next done. Well not say anything, but will wait for what the court has to say today, he said. The tenants, he said, were given enough time since the 2008 court order, and were even given a months time before asking them to leave by January 19. Tshering Penjore said the tenants have been already briefed on the legal consequences of not following the court order. Meanwhile, tenants said they are waiting to see what would happen today. We didnt get a house, so we dont have anywhere to move, a tenant said. Hopefully, the police doesnt barge into our houses today. They said they were told by the court that, if they do not follow the courts order this time, the only place they would go to next is the
A tenant
We were told that we wont be called to court, but straightaway sent to prison by police
prison. We were told that we wont be called to court, but straightaway sent to prison by police, one of them said. Which is why we had to write the statement that well leave by January 19 without an option. Another tenant added that, if police comes, they might have to go wherever they would be taken. But theyll have to see who would look after our children if were taken. Kuensel couldnt contact the court officials.
10
PRIME MINISTER
ADS
GOVERNMENT ORDER
The Centre for Bhutan Studies (dpal brug zhib jug lte ba in Dzongkha) was founded with the Government Order I signed on 11 November 1998 corresponding to the birthday of His Majesty Jigme Singye Wangchuck, the Fourth Druk Gyalpo. Since then, one of the focal areas of the institute has been research on Gross National Happiness (GNH). In view of its primary focus on GNH research and dissemination of GNH findings and the need for deepening scholarship in future on happiness and well-being, the Royal Government is pleased to approve change of its name to The Centre for Bhutan Studies and GNH Research with immediate effect. This supersedes Government Order No. COM/02/52 issued on 11 November, 1998.
Sealed quotations are invited from the eligible suppliers with valid trade licence for the supply of ORIGINAL TONERS and CARTRIDGES for a period of one year. The tender documents with detailed terms and condition may be purchased from the Finance Department on payment of Nu.500/- only (nonrefundable) on any working days. The last date of submission of tender is on 28/02/2013 and will be opened on the same day at 3PM. Management
NOTIFICATION
Copy to: 1. Dasho Ugyen Dorji, Secretary to His Majesty the King, The Royal Secretariat of His Majesty the King, Tashichhodzong, Thimphu. 2. The Secretary, Cabinet Secretariat, Gyalyong Tshogkhang, Thimphu. 3. The Chairperson, Royal Civil Service Commission, Thimphu. 4. The President, the Centre for Bhutan Studies (CBS), Langjophakha, Thimphu.
The following thram holder has lost/misplaced the Lag Thram issued by the National Land Commission Secretariat and has requested the issuance of a fresh certificate. 1. Pelma Chhoden bearing ID no. 11410002748 under plot no. 14, 12, 22, 208 and 15 located at Changedaphu under Thimthrom Thimphu. If anyone has found the Lagthram or is in possession by any of the Financial Institutions under mortgage kindly inform the National Land Commission Secretariat. A fresh certificate will be issued only after one week after the issue of this notification. This is in line with Section 24 of Land Act 2007, where only one Lagthram is allowed to be issued per thram. Chief Land Registrar Urban Land Registration Division
ANNOUNCEMENT MINISTRY OF ECONOMIC AFFAIRS Department of Industry Industrial Infrastructure Development Division, Thimphu
MoEA/IIDD(PIE-01)/2013/671
Department of Industry, MoEA would like to announce for the three vacant plots at Pasakha Industrial Estate having their sizes, 0.34, 0.50 and 3.70acres. For details, kindly visit www.moea.gov.bt or call us at 323536/321312 during office hours. Director
NOTICE INVITING TENDER ROYAL BHUTAN POLICE Fire Services Division, Thimphu
RBP/FSD/TH-141/2013/464
Sealed bids are invited from Bhutanese suppliers having valid trade licence for the supply of materials for fire detection and alarm system and fire fighting and rescue equipment. The tender document will be available w.e.f 22/01/2013 and submission on 06/02/2013. The tender documents can be purchased on payment of Nu.300/- from the office of the Fire Services Division, RBP Changzamtok, Thimphu , Superintendent of Police
PERSPECTIVE 11
inaction that may result in instability. Instability of a state breeds chaos, displacement and revolution. Their Majesties during the public consultation said that: (a) In Article 34, the two ways of amending the constitution is very important. As per Article 32, the provisions of the constitution can be amended if 51% of people from the Dzongkhags vote in the National referendum. Even the provisions of Article 2 on the Institution of Monarchy can be amended by the people. The procedure and method of amending the Constitution is adequately provided. With the commencement of the democratic system of governance, there is a danger of the political parties amending those provisions in the Constitution, which is detrimental to them, like is normally done in other democratic countries. I hope this would not happen, but you people should keep this in mind and know that there is a possibility of this happening. Because it can happen. What is important is that the Government is the government in the interest of the people. If the government though called the government of the people, work only towards their own benefit, then the purpose of having a democratic government is failed. 203 (b) In the course of making our Constitution, we never failed in giving in depth thought, placing interests and wellbeing of the country at the top. Even though you may support monarchial system, we have drafted the Constitution for the well being of the nation. In other countries, vote of confidence in a King is not decided in a National Referendum. Once the King ascends the throne, he remains on the throne for his life. We have seen it in many other monarchies and found that it is a very bad example. Therefore, we cannot continue with such a system and cannot give approval for such a system. Our Constitution has been drafted after a detailed study of the Constitutions of many different countries, including the countries that had Constitutional Monarchies. Our Constitution is different from any other Constitutions of the world because we have drawn the strengths from them If the people wanted their king to be good and capable, the people should select the one whom they can trust, and then only the fidelity of father-son relationship could be maintained between the King and the citizens for all times. Monarchy is not the best form of government for Bhutan as it has many flaws. The democratic system also has its own flaws. The major flaw of monarchy system is that an heir, whether capable or not, is enthroned as a King In times to come if the people are fortunate, the heir to the Throne could be a dedicated and capable person and be a good King. Otherwise the heir could be a person with mediocre ability or even an incapable person. Therefore, National Referendum is appropriate to choose the peoples King. If a king is incapable and fails to look after the well being of the people and cannot fulfill the aspirations of the government, the people need not involve in internal strife and protests, but they can change that king by calling National Referendum. It would be befitting to exercise your rights when you are empowered by the Constitution. In accordance with greater responsibilities mandated by the Constitution, the people should think positive and be progressive. The provisions on National Referendum would give you more advantages than disadvantages. If a king is capable he would not be forced to step even after ten times of na-
Article 34 National Referendum Referendum is grass root democracy and direct democracy. It is a practical manifestation of popular sovereignty. Rousseau mentioned that general will is through direct democracy200. A referendum is a decision taken by the people (the electorate) rather than parliament on a particular proposed law or decision. Referendum being popular sovereignty, the people has power to adopt its own constitution and propose and adopt amendments to the constitution. However, it is neither evasion nor shirking of responsibility from taking decisions that are unpopular but for the national interest. Democratization in Bhutan has emanated from the Golden Throne.201 Democracy in Bhutan encompasses both direct and indirect democracy. His Majesty the Fourth Druk Gyalpo instituted direct democracy through peoples referendum and indirect democracy through parliamentary democracy. Explaining the principle to the public of Trashigang, His Majesty said that Parliament under representative democracy has the power to formulate policies, laws, and govern under the powers delegated by the Constitution, but only the people of Bhutan has the power to change the basic principles of the Constitution through referendum.202 There are four circumstances in which a National Referendum can be invoked viz. Article 2(24), 2(26), 34(2) and 35(3). It is necessary to restrict excessive referenda to avoid delay and
...but only the people of Bhutan has the power to change the basic principles of the Constitution through referendum
tional referendum. Therefore, there is nothing to be worried and apprehensive about it. 204 Bhutan had representative democracy since 1953 with the establishment of the National Assembly. Thus, the voice of the people expressed through referendum is the Constitution of Bhutan. The people can exercise their constitutional right of amending it, for the Constitution is the embodiment of the moral sentiment of the people. The greatest power rests with the people. Parliament has no power to change certain provisions and if it does not command double majority. A referendum is the expression of the will of the people. It is an enduring symbol of trust bestowed upon the people by His Majesty. Contributed by Sonam Tobgye, Thrimchi Lyonpo To be continued
Footnotes: 198 Public consultation in Haa on 02/11/2005. 199 Public consultation in Paro on 9/11/2005. 200 The term general will seemingly implies that there is an interest common to all persons involved. But even if this were true, running a direct democracy on this principle would be impractical. But Rousseau, after building a heady image of united purpose and brotherhood among the masses, finally admits the impracticality later in the essay and provides a slightly less demanding criterion: majority rule. 201 Refer the 77th National Assembly Resolution. 202 Refer Kuensel dated 23 March 2005. 203 Public consultation in Thimphu on 26/10/2005. 204 Public consultation in Paro on 9/11/2005.
12
SHERUB DORJI
HOME
LAUNCH
The collection of paintings, drawn over a year, captures the three days of the Royal Wedding celebrations, from Oc-
Dzongkhag
Max
Min
Outlook
ADDICTION
The help centre, which has been operating in Tshongdue for the past eight months, provides peer counselling service, and a safe zone environment, in which alcohol and narcotic recovering dependents can stay away from their habit causing factors, the numerous establishments offering alcohol and illegal sources of narcotics. The help centre caters to, on average, twelve regulars, according to the centres incharge, Sonam Tshering, who is a recovered dependent. He added that, occasionally, the number of those attending the alcohol and narcotic anonymous meetings reaches 20, including the regulars. A few youth, prior to attending yesterdays meeting, spoke to this newspaper. Their ages ranged from 18 to 23. All of them had dropped out of school, due to family problems, they said. Issues, such as divorce, financial instability, lack of support from step-parents, emotional and
13 13 17 27
-2 -2 4 17
Sunset : 5:31PM
Source: Meteorology Division, DHMS, MOEA
Printed and published by Kuensel Corporation Limited, PO Box 204, Tel: 975-2-322483/324688, Fax: 975-2-322975, www.kuenselonline.com ISSN 0259 1499