Diving Work Managing The Risks Working Safely Under Water
Diving Work Managing The Risks Working Safely Under Water
Diving Work Managing The Risks Working Safely Under Water
PO Box 90801 2509 LV Den Haag www.arbeidsinspectie.nl Order number 647 version september 2008
This brochure describes the main occupational risks affecting diving work. It contains information on what you need to do and what the Dutch Labour Inspectorate (DLI) and the State Supervision of Mines (SSM) will be looking for during inspections. Investing in good working conditions will benefit the health of both your employees and your company or organisation. The main occupational risks affecting diving relate to:
There are other risks too, such as exposure to hazardous substances and biological agents in polluted water, excessive physical loads as well as working hours and rest periods. These issues are discussed under Other Risks on page 27. When conducting inspections, the DLI and the SSM specifically monitor the occupational risks associated with these areas of work. This brochure will help you ensure that you are well prepared for such inspections. Other matters are inspected as and when deemed necessary by the DLI and the SSM. The first part of this brochure relates to: your obligations as an employer; how an inspection is carried out. The second part provides: a description of the main occupational risks in your sector; the inspection standards per occupational risk; references to legislation and other tools which will help you comply with the regulations.
Part 1
As an employer, you are responsible for implementing the best possible working conditions policy. To this end, you must structure the work to ensure that it does not negatively impact on the health or safety of your employees. Recognising the risks is an important component, as it helps you find solutions to improve working conditions. This can be done by conducting a risk assessment and evaluation (RA&E).
Two supervising bodies are charged with monitoring working conditions in relation to diving work: the DLI and inspectors from the SSM. The SSM is the supervising body for work directly or indirectly connected with the mining industry (opencast mining, underground mining industry and the mining industry involved in mining of minerals by drilling). In other situations, the DLI is the supervising body.
When considering improvements, the following points are important: Risks must be removed at source wherever possible. If the risks cannot be removed at source (for technical, organisational and/or financial reasons), you will need to take measures to benefit all employees. With respect to ship inspections, for example, make arrangements with the captain and/or use visible marking on the water to warn seagoing traffic. In some cases, you will not be able to remove risks at source or take general precautionary measures. In such cases you must make personal protective equipment available to the employees and ensure that it is used by the employees. This approach is known as the exposure assessment strategy. Hiring divers If you hire a diver and the diver uses his/her own diving equipment, you must ensure that this equipment provides adequate protection for the job at hand.
This brochure deals with the main risks facing your sector. However, there may also be other specific rules or risks affecting your company or organisation, for example in the case of a diving assignment under extreme weather conditions. Such risks must also be recorded by you in the RA&E and the action plan and appropriate measures must be taken to reduce or remove such risks.
System inspection It is possible that your procedure for ensuring safe working conditions is inadequate. If the inspector feels that this is the case, he will carry out a system inspection. The inspector will conduct a number of interviews with you and with a number of employees and managers if necessary. The inspector may also wish to view or check company documentation. At the end, the inspector will discuss the results with you. If the inspectors presumption is correct, you will receive a demand and will be given the opportunity to modify your approach. Complaints Sometimes, the supervising body receives complaints with respect to the working conditions in a company or organisation. A complaint will be investigated only if received from an employee (or a relation/acquaintance or legal representative of the employee) or a trade union. Complaints or suggestions from other parties are not generally investigated by the supervising body, except where people are thought to be in serious danger. Reporting accidents Accidents occur on a regular basis in the diving sector, some serious or even fatal. You are required to report serious accidents to the supervising body immediately. These relate to fatal accidents or cases where the diver is hospitalised or suffers permanent injuries. Accidents in the mining industry must be reported to the SSM. All other accidents must be reported to the DLI. In the event of an accident, the SSM or the DLI will conduct an investigation. The telephone numbers for your region are available on: www.sodm.nl and www.arbeidsinspectie.nl. Diving work must be reported Diving work is high-risk and you must report certain diving operations to the SSM or the DLI, for example diving work involving: depths of in excess of 9 metres; current speeds of in excess of 0.5 m/s; planned decompression; use of breathing gas other than air; dives for periods in excess of one week; dives for the underground mining industry or the mining industry where mining is by drilling. You must report the work in writing and give at least five working days notice. This is not always possible, for example where firefighting divers or other divers are called in to deal with emergencies. However, such matters must be reported as soon as possible.
For diving work related to the underground mining industry or the mining of minerals by means of drilling, information must be supplied at all times with respect to the safety and health risks at the dive location. More information about notifications and notification forms is available on: www.sodm.nl and www.arbeidsinspectie.nl. Composition of diving team Besides the diver, a diving team must include a reserve diver, a diving supervisor and someone who is trained to advise the diver medically. Such people must be accredited by an approved institute. The function of the diving supervisor and the divers medical adviser may be combined but the diving team must always consist of three persons. There is one exception. The diving team may consist of two people if the work meets the following conditions: the liquid consists mostly of water; and the maximum accessible depth is nine metres; and the maximum current speed is 0.5 metres per second; and there is no foreseen risk of the divers experiencing difficulties in the liquid. The diver is also expected to undergo a medical examination to assess his/her fitness for the job at hand. The medical examination must focus on the particular health risks involved in diving work of this kind. Certification of diver The members of the diving team (diver, reserve diver, diving supervisor and the divers medical adviser) must be duly accredited for performing the work in question. The doctor in charge of conducting the relevant medical examination must hold a diving doctor B cert for the initial medical examination and for repeated medical examinations, the doctor must hold a diving doctor A or B cert.
Approved certification institutes The approved certification institutes for diving work in the Netherlands are: > Nationaal Duikcentrum (NDC) > On behalf of the Ministry of Defence: Defensie duikschool (DDS) > On behalf of the Ministry of Interior Affairs and Kingdom Relations: Nederlands bureau brandweer examens (Nbbe Dutch Fire Examinations Agency) Occupational diseases Any occupational diseases within your company or organisation must be reported by your company doctor to the Netherlands Centre for Occupational diseases (www. beroepsziekten.nl).
The Working Conditions Act applies to all sectors. Some 2,250 divers are employed in the diving sector in the Netherlands, mostly in the fire service. Of this figure, about 1,200 (mainly voluntary) firemen also work as fire service divers. Despite this high number, the diving work in which fire service divers are involved each year is rather limited, representing only a secondary task. About 500 people work as professional divers for a private diving company or else are self-employed with no personnel. The Ministry of Defence has about 400 divers who work for the Royal Netherlands Navy and the Royal Netherlands Army. The other professional divers are employed by the Police, Customs, the Directorate-General for Public Works, Transport and Water Management, zoos, scientific institutions and underwater sport schools. Diving work is usually carried out at locations that by definition do not represent a natural environment for humans. Working in a liquid or in a dry diving bell is only possible if the operator has a supply of breathing gas. Conditions such as poor visibility, cold temperatures and water current all add to the hazards, and it is for these reasons that diving work is regarded as high-risk. The obligatory reporting of accidents since 2000 underlines this fact: of the 19 accidents (10 in the commercial sector, 8 in the public sector and 1 in other companies) at least 8 resulted in fatalities. This is a very high figure for a group of 2,250 divers. The following organisations are important in the diving sector in the Netherlands: > Nationaal Duikcentrum (NDC), www.ndc.nl1. > Nederlandse Associatie van Duikondernemingen2 (NADO), www.ndc.nl/nado > Trade association for self-employed persons (with no employees) in the diving industry, www.nederlandseverenigingvanberoepsduikers.nl > International Marine Contractors Association (IMCA), www.imca-int.com > Kenniscentrum defence duikschool3 (KC DDS), www.marine.nl And for the fire service: > Nederlandse vereniging voor brandweerzorg en rampenbestrijding4, www.nvbr.nl > Nederlands bureau voor brandweerexamens5 (Nbbe), www.nbbe.nl > Nederlands instituut fysieke veiligheid6 Nibra, www.nifv.nl
1 National Dive Centre, 2 Dutch Association of Diving Companies, 3 Defence Diving School Knowledge Centre, 4 Netherlands Association of Fire and Disaster Control Services, 5 Netherlands Bureau for Firefighting exams, 6 Netherlands Institute for Physical Safety
10
11
Part 2
This part of the brochure takes a closer look at the main occupational risks in the diving sector, with regard to the Working Conditions Act. The risks described relate to: working under overpressure; ensuring the dive location is safe and secure; safety of work equipment. Other risks briefly considered are those associated with exposure to hazardous substances and biological agents, physical loads, working hours and rest periods. We discuss what the occupational risks comprise, the potential consequences for the health and safety of your employees and the minimum action you need to take to prevent these consequences. This is an aspect that will be checked during inspections by the DLI and the SSM. Finally, we provide references to legislation and regulations that may help you comply with the provisions of the Working Conditions Act.
12
13
For humans, diving is an unnatural occupation for which the human body is not designed. The higher pressure to which the diver is exposed underwater directly affects the functioning of the body and the breathing gas inhaled by the diver. The human body can only work with aids in such situations. To breathe alone, the diver is totally dependent on diving aids.
Diving work is defined by the Working Conditions Act as: the performance of work in a liquid or in a dry diving bell including the period within which the diver remains in the liquid or in the dry diving bell, aided by a breathing apparatus which depends on the supply of a gas under higher pressure than the ambient pressure.
Every year, the Diving Medical Centre of the Royal Netherlands Navy deals with between 20 and 30 diving incidents. On average, six of the victims involved in these incidents suffer a serious form of decompression illness.
14 28
15
Incorrectly measured or contaminated breathing gas Another risk facing divers relates to incorrectly measured or contaminated breathing gas. In normal circumstances, breathing gas comprises about 21% oxygen (O2) and 79% nitrogen (N2), plus negligible traces of other gases and substances. During diving work, the diver will breathe compressed breathing gas. This breathing gas is drawn from the ambient air by compressors and compressed in pressure cylinders or supplied directly to the diver via an umbilical hose. During the compression process, the breathing gas may become contaminated due to contaminated ambient air or defective compressor equipment, for example. The pressure cylinders or bottles may also be contaminated on the inside due to corrosion or other reasons. In some situations, a gas mixture other than air is used. Reducing the nitrogen content in the breathing gas or increasing the oxygen content helps reduce the risk of decompression illness and allows for diving times to be increased. This may be useful for certain operations. Nitrox is also used. This is a gas mixture whereby the ratio of oxygen and inert gas is adapted so that the oxygen is always higher than with ordinary compressed air. Neither air nor Nitrox is a suitable breathing gas for diving at greater depths. Due to the high partial nitrogen pressure, the diver becomes less productive and may suffer nitrogen narcosis. If the diver dives to depths below 50 metres, the gas mixture Heliox or Trimix may be used. These gases allow for the nitrogen to be wholly or partly replaced by Helium (He). The mix ratio of the breathing gas is adjusted, also to avoid oxygen poisoning. Use of Heliox causes the divers voice to change, making communication more difficult. The diver also loses body temperature more quickly with the use of Helium in the breathing gas and may therefore require extra heat through a hot water suit.
Work instructions The work instructions must incorporate the safety measures and the emergency procedures, including: responsibilities and powers; equipment and maintenance; diving procedures; selection of reserve diver; measures and procedures to deal with varying conditions; guidelines for decompression; reporting accidents and medical assistance; composition and usage of first aid equipment. Diving equipment If you supply your employees with diving equipment, you must consider: the risk of the diver losing communication with the diving supervisor; problems that may arise when the diver enters and emerges from the liquid; problems that may arise when the depth and the exact location of the diver are unknown; the risks of hypothermia and hyperthermia for the diver; managing and monitoring the quality and quantity of the breathing gas; inspection and maintenance of all equipment, such as breathing apparatus, compressors, diving cylinders and air supply hoses.
16
15 17
In other situations, you must have a compression chamber at the dive location if the travel time between the dive location and the closest treatment facility with a compression chamber is more than two hours. The compression chamber must be geared to the number of persons involved in the relevant diving operation and to the type of work being performed. It must be suitable for at least two people.
Breathing gas The breathing gas that you as the employer make available must be appropriate and of good quality for the work at hand. You must arrange for an adequate supply of breathing gas and reserve-breathing gas so that in an emergency, the diver can suspend diving work safely. Where divers use their own independent breathing gas supply (e.g. Scuba divers) and a breathing gas other than air, you will need to check the composition of the gas mixture just before a dive and adapt the diving limits accordingly. Medical precautionary measures You must ensure that the diver is physically and mentally capable of recognising the risks involved in the work and capable of preventing or limiting such hazards. Moreover divers must be checked to ensure that they are medically fit to take part in the diving work. This inspection must be repeated each year. Make sure that there is always someone on hand close to the work location who can provide adequate medical advice to the diver(s). For diving work at depths in excess of 15 metres or in another liquid under a pressure higher than 1.5.105 Pa above the ambient pressure, a compression chamber with a recompression and hyperbaric medicine lock is obligatory.
18
19
In the Netherlands, most of the dive locations are cold or very cold and dark underwater; visibility is very poor and divers must work in flowing and/or polluted water. Besides the pressure-related risks associated with working underwater, each dive location has its own general high-risk situation, both below and above water. Invariably, construction work will be ongoing at the dive location. Cranes and forklift trucks are busy moving construction materials about. The fire service and training and practice dives often involve lifting and hoisting various (training) objects out of the water. Divers also have to contend with shipping traffic.
20
Arbeidsrisicos in de afvalinzameling
21
the emergency procedures are sufficiently known and practised and these form part of the basic skills of the diver(s); the reserve diver is available at a moments notice.
Much of the work undertaken by divers is also performed above water. The work they do for example in the field of hydraulic engineering, in the offshore industry or in ship maintenance, has many parallels with the tasks performed by workers in the building or construction industry. They need to know how to use various types of equipment, such as: hand tools (hammers, saws, shears etc.); mechanical tools (jack hammers, bolt guns, drills, saws, grinding discs etc.); suction and (high pressure) spraying equipment; flame cutters and welding equipment; hoisting gear. Divers also need to know how to operate TV cameras and photographic equipment and must be familiar with a range of measuring and testing techniques. In certain situations, they also need to have expert knowledge about the use of explosives under water
22
23
In the future, diving work under overpressure may only be approved providing the employer holds the relevant maintenance system for diving and caisson equipment certificate (Onderhoudssysteem duik- en caissonmaterieel). Self-employed persons and assisting employers are also required to hold this certificate. To obtain the certificate, you must meet the requirements of the Assessment Guideline governing the Maintenance of Systems for Diving and Caisson Equipment (Beoordelingsrichtlijn voor de Onderhoudssysteem duik- en Ccaissonmaterieel: BRL D&C), due to come into effect at the end of 2008 or early in 2009. When this brochure was in preparation, the Assessment Guideline had not yet come into effect nor was the effective date known.
In addition to the Working Conditions Act, you must comply with the provisions of: the Commodities Act (product safety); the Machinery (Commodities Act) Decree (Machinery guideline); the Pressure Equipment (Commodities Act) Decree (Pressure Equipment guideline). Under the Working Conditions Decree you must ensure that work equipment meets the provisions of the relevant (Commodities Act) Decree. Manufacturers must ensure that their machinery and pressure equipment meet the provisions of the Machinery (Commodities Act) Decree and the Pressure Equipment (Commodities Act) Decree. If you are involved in developing or materially altering machinery or in developing or adapting pressure equipment, then you are regarded as a manufacturer as well as an employer. You are therefore also required to meet the certification obligations of the Machinery (Commodities Act) Decree and the Pressure Equipment Decree.
Machinery predating and post 1995 Machinery predating 1995 is generally required to meet the current professional standards, unless the existing residual risk level is regarded as acceptable. With respect to machinery and equipment brought onto the market either in or after 1995, the manufacturer (where applicable) is obliged to: hold an EC declaration of conformity; have instructions for use in Dutch; have CE marking on the machinery or equipment. How are inspections conducted by the supervising body? During the course of an inspection, the inspector will check whether equipment and usage thereof comply with the statutory provisions of the Working Conditions Decree and the Machinery (Commodities Act) Decree. Any work representing a serious hazard will be suspended for preventive reasons by the inspector, who will also impose a fine. The work may only be resumed when the (potential) hazard has been removed. Depending on the findings, the inspector will then proceed to inspect a number of documents relating to machinery from 1995 and later in order to check availability of: instructions for use; an EC declaration of conformity for machinery with CE marking;
24
25
Other risks
a maintenance logbook; (work) instructions and procedures; the risk assessment and evaluation and the ancillary action plan. More information Brochure: Veilig en gezond werken met machines (B265) [Safe and Secure working with machinery]. See: www.arbeidsinspectie.nl under Brochures. Arbo-informatieblad A1-11: Machineveiligheid: afschermingen en beveiligingen [Working Conditions information sheet AI-11: Machinery safety: screening and safety precautions]; third revised edition; SDU (ISBN 90 12 08905 0). Order by e-mail: Sdu@sdu.nl. Beoordelingsrichtlijn voor de Onderhoudssysteem duik- en Caissonmaterieel [Assessment Guidelines governing maintenance of Systems for Diving and Caisson Equipment]. Issued by: NDC. Order by e-mail: post@ndc.nl References to legislation and regulations > Working Conditions Decree, sections 3, 6 and 7 > Machinery (Commodities Act) Decree > Pressure Equipment (Commodities Act) Decree
Physical effort
Physical effort does not constitute a health risk as such, but physical stress does. Physical stress may lead to problems with the locomotor apparatus and even to failure. Lifting, pushing and pulling, repeating the same movements over and over again, or poor work posture can all lead to physical stress. At the dive location, objects are generally carried and pulled above water when shifting heavy equipment. The risk of physical stress is further exacerbated in such aggravating circumstances. When working under water, moving specific equipment (such as welding equipment, high pressure cleaning equipment and pneumatic drills) and drowned corpses is difficult. The work can be even more arduous when working in the dark and in confined spaces (with tools). As an employer, you are obliged to organise the work in a manner that reduces or minimises physical stress. Here too, the RA&E forms the first step, so you start by listing the risks involved in the work area. Next, on the basis of the RA&E, you draw up an action plan in order to reduce or limit these risks. References to the Working Conditions Act and regulations > Physical effort, general: Working Conditions Decree, Articles 5.2, 5.3, 5.4 and 5.5
26
27
7 8 9
Estimation of the exposure of professional divers to microorganisms in water Working Conditions Information Sheet: Biological agents Physical stress at work
28
29
For more information on working hours and rest periods, see: > SZW - dossier arbeidstijden10. See: www.arbeidsinspectie.nl under Arbeidstijden (Specific regulations governing the mining sector) > Detailed section on Mining in the Working Hours Decree. See: www.sodm.nl under Documentation (working hours in the mining sector; in Dutch)
10
Record of working hours by the Inspection Service of the Ministry of Social Affairs and Employment
Colophon
This brochure has been prepared on behalf of the DLI in cooperation with the SSM.
Disclaimer
This brochure outlines the main occupational risks arising in the diving sector. The brochure describes how the DLI and SSM conduct inspections in response to these risks. Not all of the risks outlined may concern your company or organisation, in which case you may disregard the inapplicable sections. If there are risks facing your company or organisation which have not been listed in this brochure, you must incorporate these risks both in the RA&E and the action plan. You are also required to take measures to remove or reduce these risks. The rules referred to in this brochure are existing rules. For more information, see: www.arbeidsinspectie.nl, www.sodm.nl and www.arbonieuwestijl.nl. The Ministry of Social Affairs and Employment is not responsible for information contained on the websites of the third parties cited in this brochure. No legal liability can be accepted in relation to the information provided in this brochure.
Further information
This brochure is available on: www.arbeidsinspectie.nl. On this website you will find more information on the references to legislation and regulations in this brochure. All the provisions of the Working Conditions Act and regulations can be viewed on: www.overheid.nl. We are grateful to all the companies and organisations in the sector that assisted us in preparing this brochure.
30
31