Duplex Stainless Brochure
Duplex Stainless Brochure
Duplex Stainless Brochure
Contents
Find out how the right material choices can save enormous costs and accelerate your business in the long run. See inspiring case studies from around the world.
BUsINEss & TRENds
Winning the future Duplex revolution Case studies When to go with Outokumpu Duplex
4 8 9 13
What makes Outokumpu Duplex such a strong material? How to weld and form duplex? See in-depth technical information and enjoy our tips for best results.
CoMPosITIoN ANd bENEFITs
Chemical composition Mechanical properties Physical properties Corrosion resistance in various environments Advice for fabrication Product assortment
14 15 17 18 20 23
Computer simulations
and calculations to ease design work
Trend-setting duplex tank farm See how Relisa S.A. managed to reduce construction material by up to 50%. See page 9.
Outokumpu Duplex more strength, less material Outokumpu Duplex allows you to realise your most demanding projects: thanks to its superior strength, you can sometimes manage with even 50% less material, which means considerable cost savings. Outokumpu Duplex is a highly environmentally
sustainable material with signicantly longer service life in corrosive environments when the proper material selection is made. See interesting case studies and read all about material properties as well as fabrication hints for Outokumpu Duplex. Together, lets turn your winning ideas into a successful project.
Montanstahls head ofce with sculptures by Helidon Xhixha on the left. Courtesy of Montanstahl.
Global economics and striving for stability When it comes to economics, all parties seek stability. In large-scale construction projects, right material choices can multiply savings. Outokumpu Duplex stainless steel has excellent strength, which can often mean the same structure can be built with less material: for example, tank walls can be considerably thinner. Compared to other grades with comparable corrosion resistance, also the nickel content of Outokumpu Duplex is very low. This means more price stability, less surprises and easier budgeting.
TREND 2:
for the environment is simply not accepted anymore. Environmental responsibility and legislation have an increasing impact on companies operations in every industry. Proof of responsibility is demanded for the whole life cycle of the product. Those who can oer action instead of words in social and environmental responsibility will be the winners of tomorrow. Outokumpu Duplex is an environmentally sound choice from many dierent viewpoints: It uses recycled steel as main raw material and it is 100% recyclable. Very low level of metal ion is released in to the environment. Less need for hazardous coatings. Thanks to high strength, it is possible to reduce the weight of the structures and therefore lower energy consumption in transport, construction and usage.
TREND 3:
Ensuring safety, pleasing to the eye In addition to corrosion-resistance and durability, constructors face increasing demands for a human approach: it is not enough anymore that the tanks, vessels and buildings do their job. They need to be safe for both the builders and the employees and be aesthetically pleasing. Outokumpu Duplex makes it possible to fabricate strong, fascinating structures while reducing the total weight.
Rising environmental awareness In previous years, temporary structures built for world fairs and events for example, could be demolished after the event. Such a waste of labour and disrespect
4
600 550 500 450 400 350 300 250 LDX 2101
Duplex
2304
4565
4439
Austentic
4307
4404 4436
4438
High strength
200 150 0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
Duplex saving potential compared to austenitic grades. The curve will shift depending on grades compared and actual price level.
Calculate your weight savings on the Internet Steel professional tool at www.outokumpu.com oers interactive tools for materials selection, rough estimation on wall thickness calculations etc. Visit our website and learn more!
Less material means benets in every step of the project With Outokumpu Duplex, you can purchase, transport, weld and assemble less material. When thinking of the cost of labour, savings can be tremendous.
Pipes: reductions in wall thickness and weight between grades 1.4307 and LDX 2101
Grade 1.4307 WT = 6.0 mm Weight = 90 tons Design data Pressure = 16 bar Temperature = 50C OD = 610 mm Required Pipe length = 1000 m Min WT acc to EN 13480-3: Weld factor z = 0.7 1.4307 = 5.8 mm LDX 2101 = 2.9 mm Grade LDX 2101 WT = 3.0 mm Weight = 45 tons
Austenitic steel versus Outokumpu Duplex When the same tank is manufactured from Outokumpu Duplex instead of conventional austenitic steel, the biggest savings are made in manufacturing phase, thanks to less amount of material needed. The tank walls can be signicantly thinner, yet safe in use.
4301 Plate thickness Material cost*
Welding cost** Labour cost** (Welding and tank assembly)
Carbon steel versus Outokumpu Duplex When the same tank is manufactured from Outokumpu Duplex instead of carbon steel, the biggest savings come in the maintenance phase: carbon steel needs to be properly protected in the manufacturing phase and again after certain periods of usage. All this means extra labour, which can be avoided using Outokumpu Duplex.
Carbon steel Total initial cost* Surface protection cost Elapsed time between maintenance events Life cycle duration Operating cost Total LCC 192 kEUR 100 Euro/m2 x 1000 m2 15 years 30 years 64 kEUR 256 kEUR 30 years 0 kEUR 192 kEUR LDX 2101 192 kEUR No surface protection required!
[m] 18 16 14
12 10 8 6 4 2
[mm] 12 11 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
Potential cost saving ~33% Tank size: diameter 18.5 m, height 18 m. *Based on Outokumpu price list per 19 Oct 2009. **Based on actual costs provided by a Swedish Contractor 2008.
Potential cost saving ~25% Tank size: diameter 18.5 m, height 18 m. *Assume equal intitial cost level: lower material cost for carbon steel equals the measures for protecting the plate surfaces for a tank designed for aggresive environment.
Courtesy of Emypro
Relisa S.A. of Spain stores liquid foods and chemicals in a new tank farm at the Port of Barcelona: Spanish storage-tank fabricator Emypro S.A. has built the entire farm, consisting of 22 units, using Outokumpu Duplex LDX 2101 plate. When engineering the rst phase of the farm, Emypro could see the advantages of the duplex grade and partnered with Outokumpu to convince Relisa. As Emypro was putting the nishing touches to the tanks, Relisa ordered 9 more using the same grade. The grade selection has oered the fabricator and tank owner major competitive advantages thanks to the qualities of LDX 2101. The grades strength is almost twice that of standard austenitic grades. This has allowed Emypro to achieve major reductions in material quantities compared to the austenitic alternatives 1.4301/1.4307 (304/304L). The total weight saving is more than 20%, in some sections of tanks, even up to 50%. Technical highlights Outokumpu Duplex has good weldability, and the material supports most known welding techniques. See welding tips on page 20. Interesting facts Emypros and Outokumpus pioneering development continues a history of milestones achieved together, including the worlds largest duplex storage tank (22 m in diameter and 25 m in height) fabricated using Outokumpu Duplex grade 2304.
10
11
*max temperature = 250C in EN10028-7 , max temperature = 325C in ASME II-D 2007 .
13
The chemical composition of duplex grades gives good corrosion resistance and desired mechanical and physical properties. Outokumpu can supply you with stainless grades especially designed to meet your needs. Alloying elements and their purpose Chromium makes it stainless At least about 11% chromium has to be added to a steel to form the passive layer that makes it stainless. These contents improve the corrosion and oxidation resistance. Outokumpu Duplex steels have a high chromium level, between 21.5 and 25%. Nickel adds toughness Nickel obtains the desired phase balance and provides toughness. Duplex steels contain a relatively small amount of nickel, between 1.5 and 7%. If corrosion initiates, a higher Ni level is benecial for repassivation.
Table 1. Chemical composition
Nitrogen adds strength and corrosion resistance Nitrogen is a very important addition as it gives a substantial increase in strength and pitting corrosion resistance. At the same time it strongly stabilises the austenite phase. Furthermore, nitrogen improves welding properties. Molybdenum improves corrosion resistance Molybdenum improves corrosion resistance in most environments, particularly in chloride-containing environments.
Duplex microstructure. Longitudinal cross section of hot rolled plate, light phase austenite, darker (blue) phase ferrite.
ASME: In ASME II-D 2007 (Metric) edition grades S31803 (2205), S32304 (2304) and S32750 (2507) are listed for general use between -30C to +325C. Data for LDX 2101 can be found in ASME code case 2418.
Outokumpu typical values P(15mm) 480 700 38 220 H (4mm) 570 770 38 230 520 685 35 220 620 800 32 C (1mm) 600 800 35 230 545 745 35 225 640 850 30
Proof strength Tensile strength Elongation Hardness 2304 Proof strength Tensile strength Elongation
MPa MPa %
MPa MPa %
400 630 25
400 650 20
450 650 20
International steel No EN ASTM S32101 S32304 S82441 S32205* S32750 304L 316L N08904 S31254 C 0.03 0.02 0.02 0.02 0.02 0.02 0.02 0.01 0.01 N
Chemical composition, % by weight Typical values Cr 21.5 23 24 22 25 18.1 17 .2 20 20 Ni 1.5 4.8 3.6 5.7 7 .0 8.1 10.1 25 18 Mo 0.3 0.3 1.6 3.1 4.0 2.1 4.3 6.1 Others 5Mn 3Mn 1.5Cu Cu
Hardness LDX 2404 Proof strength Tensile strength Elongation Hardness 2205 Proof strength Tensile strength Elongation Hardness 2507 Proof strength Tensile strength Elongation Hardness
LDX 2101 2304 Duplex LDX 2404 2205 2507 4307 Austenitic 4404 904L 254 SMO
MPa MPa %
530 730 20
530 750 20
550 750 20
Table 2 summarises mechanical properties for at rolled products, (data according to EN 10088). The allowed design values may vary between product forms. The appropriate values are given in the relevant specications/design standards. Grade 4501 is only produced as hot rolled plate by Outokumpu. 1) Refrs to A80 for gauges less than 3,0 mm
P = hot rolled plate and bar H = hot rolled strip C = cold rolled coil and strip, cold drawn bar * Mechanical properties according to ASTM A240 ** Mechanical properties according to internal standard AM 641.
14
15
Temperature and embrittlement Duplex steels are more prone to precipitation of sigma phase, nitrides and carbides than corresponding austenitic steels, causing embrittlement and reduced corrosion resistance. The formation of intermetallic phases such as sigma phase occurs in the temperature range 600-950C and decomposition of ferrite occurs in the range 350-525C (475C embrittlement). Exposures at these temperatures should therefore be avoided. In proper welding and heat treatment the risk of embrittlement is low. However, certain risks exist, for example at heat treatment of thick sections, especially if the cooling rate is low. Due to the risk of embrittlement, the duplex steels should not be used at temperatures above 250-325C (See gure 1). The maximum temperature and strength value depends on grade and the design rules being used. High energy absorption The combination of high strength and ductility gives Outokumpu Duplex a very good ability to absorb energy. This makes it a perfect material for
applications like blast walls at oil rigs and car body components. Good fatigue strength in base material The high tensile strength of Outokumpu Duplex also implies high fatigue strength in the base material. The fatigue strength of the duplex steels follows the proof strength of the material. Our research personnel can provide you with more detailed information, if needed. What comes to welds, the benet of the high fatigue strength of the parent or base material is limited. The fatigue strength is reduced by unfavorable weld geometry, residual stresses, distortions and weld defects.
Physical property Density [g/cm3] Modulus of Elasticity [GPa] Poissons ratio [Dimensionless] Linear expansion from 20C to 200C (x10-6/C) Thermal conductivity [W/mC] Thermal capacity [J/kgC] Electric resistivity [/m]
LDX 2404* 60 40
2205 2507 60 40 60 40
Fig. 1. Curves for reduction of impact toughness to 50% compared to solution annealed condition.
16
17
Corrosion fatigue and intergranular corrosion The combination of high mechanical strength and very good resistance to corrosion gives duplex steels superior corrosion fatigue strength. Due to the duplex microstructure and low carbon content, the duplex grades have a good resistance to intergranular (intercrystalline) corrosion. Erosion corrosion Stainless steel in general oers good resistance to erosion corrosion. Duplex grades are especially good due to their combination of high surface hardness and good corrosion resistance. Galvanic corrosion Galvanic corrosion may occur when two dissimilar metals are electrically connected (as by welding) in an electrolyte. Stainless steel is in most cases nobler than other metallic materials. The most noble metal is protected while the less noble metal is more severely attacked. Stainless steel in contact with carbon steel
rebars in concrete does not cause galvanic corrosion of the carbon steel due to the high pH in concrete. Galvanic corrosion does not occur between dierent grades of stainless steels as long as both grades are passive. Atmospheric corrosion Atmospheric corrosion is not a unique form of corrosion, but a collective term to denote the corrosion of surfaces in the atmosphere. When stainless steel is exposed to an aggressive atmosphere it is primarily stained, this is sometimes referred to as tea staining, but it can also be attacked by localised corrosion with time, particularly at high chloride levels as in marine atmospheres. Today there is a duplex grade available for all types of atmospheres. The Outokumpu Corrosion Handbook For more information on corrosion and corrosion resistance in dierent media is plural of medium, please see the Outokumpu Corrosion Handbook. You can obtain your own copy from your local sales oce.
Table 5. shows PRE values for different grades. LDX 2101 has a higher pitting and crevice corrosion resistance than 4307 . Grade 2304 is on the same level as the conventional molybdenum alloyed steel 4404, while 2205 is on a level with 904L. The duplex grade 2507 has a similar resistance as 254 SMO.
Uniform corrosion The uniform corrosion resistance is generally considered good if the corrosion rate is less than 0.1 mm/year Due to their high chromium content, duplexes oer excellent corrosion resistance in many media, especially in alkaline solutions. Pitting and crevice corrosion: heat exchangers, water heaters, offshore equipment, storage tanks etc. In chloride solutions LDX 2101 has, in most cases, a better resistance than 4307 and in some cases as good as 4404. Grade 2304 is in most cases equivalent to 4404, while the other more highly alloyed duplex steels show even better resistance. The resistance to pitting and crevice corrosion is often illustrated by the pitting resistance equivalent (PRE) for the material. The most commonly used formula for PRE is: PRE = %Cr + 3,3x%Mo + 16x%N The PRE value can be used for a comparison of dierent stainless steels. A more in-depth way to rank steels is measuring the Critical Pitting corrosion Temperature (CPT). Outokumpu uses an electrochemical method, ASTM G150, involving our own developed Avesta Cell, see Fig. 2., and we can provide you with necessary data when requested. Chloride and sulphide induced stress cracking: boreholes and gas wells etc. All duplex grades are much more resistant than the standard austenitic grades to chloride induced stress corrosion cracking (SCC). They can thus tolerate higher chloride contents at elevated temperatures. In the presence of hydrogen sulphide and chlorides (e.g. sour conditions in bore holes and gas wells) the risk of stress cracking, at low temperatures, increases.. Such environments can exist, for example, in boreholes for oil and gas wells. Duplex grades, especially 2205 and 2507, have demonstrated good resistance.
Outokumpu steel name 4307 LDX 2101 4404 2304 LDX 2404 904L 2205 254 SMO 2507
PRE 18 26 24 26 33 34 35 43 43
CPT, C 100 90 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 4307 LDX 2101 4404 2304 4436 LDX 2404 2205 904L 2507 254 SMO
Fig. 2. Typical critical pitting corrosion temperatures (CPT) in 1M NaCl measured according to ASTM G150 using the Avesta Cell. Test surfaces wet ground to 320 mesh. CPT varies with product form and surface nish.
18
19
LDX 2101 Hot forming Quench annealing Stress relief annealing 1100 - 900 1020 - 1080 1020 - 1080
Welding Outokumpu Duplex can be welded with most of the methods used for austenitic stainless steel: Shielded metal arc welding (SMAW) Gas tungsten arc welding TIG (GTAW) Gas metal arc welding MIG (GMAW) Flux-cored arc welding (FCAW) Plasma arc welding (PAW) Submerged arc welding (SAW) Others: Laser, resistance and high frequency (HF) welding
In general, the biggest issue with welding Outokumpu Duplex is to maintain the phase balance in the heat aected zone without precipitations. The chemical composition balances the microstructure, and it is important to have the right welding consumable and the right procedure. Dierent welding procedure: basic rules 1. weld without preheating 2. allow the material to cool between passes, preferably to below 150C. For 2507 100C 3. duplex ller material is needed and recommended with the exception for LDX 2101 which may be welded without ller material in some cases 4. the arc energy recommended by Outokumpu should be kept 5. the heat input should be adapted to the steel grade and adjusted to the thickness of the welded material 6. edge preparation angle should be about 10 greater and the land should be somewhat smaller compared to welding standard austenitics 7. if welded with ller, post-weld annealing is not necessary. In cases where heat treatment is considered, e.g. for stress relieving, it should be car-
Steel grade
LDX 2101 23 7 NL 22 9 3 NL 2304 23 7 NL 22 9 3 NL LDX 2404 22 9 3 NL 2205 22 9 3 NL 2507 25 9 4 NL 0.02 25 9.5 3.5 0.25 0.02 22.5 8.5 3.0 0.15 0.02 22.5 8.5 3.0 0.15 0.02 0.02 23.5 22.5 8.0 8.5 0.3 3.0 0.14 0.15 0.02 0.02 23.5 22.5 8.0 8.5 0.3 3.0 0.14 0.15
ried out in accordance with the temperatures stated in Table 6, but with the minimum temperature increased with 30-50C, to secure full dissolution of intermetallic phase in the weld metal. 8. GTAW and PAW methods: addition of nitrogen (1-2%) in the shielding/purging gas is recommended
Welding to other steels including carbon steels Outokumpu Duplex can be easily welded to other steels including carbon steels. The ller type can be of duplex. When duplex steels are welded to carbon steels an alternative is to use a ller of 23Cr13Ni2Mo type. The risk of galvanic corrosion can be avoided by shielding the joints from moistening. In most cases duplex ller oers more strength and better corrosion resistance. When joining duplex to super austenitic steels, please contact Outokumpu for assistance. Filler metals for joining similar duplex steels, see table 7.
Post fabrication treatment In order to restore the stainless steel surface and achieve good corrosion resistance, it is often necessary to perform a post fabrication treatment. Outokumpu Duplex supports all dierent methods available, such as brushing, blasting, grinding and pickling. Which method to apply depends on what type of imperfections shall be removed, but also on needs to corrosion resistance, hygiene and aesthetics. The Outokumpu Welding Handbook For more information on welding and post fabrication treatment, please see the Outokumpu Welding Handbook. You can obtain your own copy from your local sales oce.
20
21
Forming Outokumpu Duplex is suitable for all forming techniques. The higher strength and the lower elongation compared to austenitic stainless steel will however impose some dierences in forming behaviour: generally higher force is needed. On the other hand, since duplex design often implies downgauging, the force level can be similar to austenitics. If the forming technique is not already decided, we recommend to choose the most appropriate one for duplex stainless steels. Machining The high strength will of course eect the machinability, but not as much as expected. Some information, good to have in mind when machining duplex, is given below: Stable setup Due to the higher strength the cutting forces will be higher. That will increase the risk of vibrations. The trick is to have a stable setup. Use the shortest possible tool extension good and rigid clamping.
Table 8.
Sharp Tools Use cutting tools with a positive geometry. The duplex grades are very adaptive to work hardening. A dull geometry will generate a hard surface and decrease the tool life. Avoid build up edge Stainless steels have a tendency to stick to the tool. Problems occur when the cutting speed is too low. The biggest dierence between carbon steel and stainless steels when machining is that you face into problems if you are running too slow. The result will be bad surface nish and short tool life. The problem is solved by increasing the cutting speed. LDX 2101 The lean duplex grade LDX 2101 have superior machinability compared to other duplex grades. Even if you compare with the low alloyed standard austenitic grades LDX 2101 , is easier to machine.
Our Added value services ease your project and oer ways to save expenses at critical points Edge preparation Cut to shape Bending Surface nishing: 2B, 2E, 1D Polishing Construction kits Prefabrication Modied chemical analysis Slitted coils Package solutions Welding advice Technical support/Project administration surface nish in duplex stainless steels, which most often fullls the industry surface requirements without any further surface treatment saving both time and money. See our product programme at www.outokumpu.com/prodprog
Things to consider Cutting, shearing Maximum thickness for shearing and punching is 80-85% of that of austenitic steel
Roll bending
More bending force will be needed compared to other stainless steels. Through the downgauging, this effect will however be smaller than anticipated. The springback due to the higher strength is large when roll bending. Avoid sharp bending radius. Minimum ratio between inner radius to sheet thickness should not be less than 2.
Break bending
Cane Creeks World Bicycle Relief Reserve Headset made out of LDX 2101.
Deep drawing
If drawing is dominant, formability is comparable to austenitic stainless steel. If stretching is dominant, formability is closer to ferritic steels. The high strength of the sheet has to be considered in the design of the rolls. If this is made properly there are no problems in roll forming Duplex. Strong, durable tools (hardness, HRC larger than 500, Ra-value preferably lower than 0.2 micrometers).
2B surface nish perfect for food & health sectors Surface nish characteristics are not merely a question of appearance. The quality aects to the corrosion resistance as well as cleansability of dirt and bacteria, which is paramount in the food industry and health sector. Outokumpu can additionally oer a 2B
Roll forming
Table 9.
Product 1D
Type of process route Hot rolled, heat treated, pickled. Rough and dull.
Surface nish Standard for the most steel types to ensure good corrosion resistance; also common nish for further processing. Rough and dull. Light cold rolling can be carried out for thin hot rolled strips. Smooth surface with low lustre.
Tooling use
2E Lubrication Because of the high strength of Outokumpu Duplex and extreme pressure additives are useful in complex forming operations. 2B
Cold rolled, heat treated, mechanically descaled followed by pickling. Cold rolled, heat treated, pickled, skin passed or by levelling (as in Avesta Works).
22
23
This document is for information only and seeks to provide professionals with the best possible information to enable them to make appropriate choices. Although every eort has been made to ensure the accuracy of the information provided in this document, Outokumpu can not accept any responsibility for any loss, damage or other consequence resulting from the use of this publication. The information provided herein may be subject to alterations without notice. This document does not constitute a recommendation or a contractual commitment on the part of Outokumpu. Product selection is the responsibility of the speciers, designers and builders, who are solely responsible for rendering the nished unit suitable for the use for which it is intended. It is the customers sole responsibility to ensure that the product is suitable for the use for which it is intended. Outokumpu shall not provide any guarantee in this respect. Copyright Outokumpu Group. All rights reserved.
www.outokumpu.com