Design Guidelines For Tall Buildings
Design Guidelines For Tall Buildings
Design Guidelines For Tall Buildings
A
L
L
B
U
I
L
D
I
N
G
D
E
S
I
G
N
G
U
I
D
E
L
I
N
E
S
T
A
L
L
B
U
I
L
D
I
N
G
D
E
S
I
G
N
G
U
I
D
E
L
I
N
E
S
TALL BUILDING
DESIGN
GUIDELINES Ma r c h 2013
City of Toronto
Tall Building Design Guidelines
March 2013
Tall Building Design Guidelines online:
toronto.ca/planning/tallbuildingdesign.htm
_______________________________________________________________________
The City of Toronto acknowledges the following previous tall building design guidelines and
studies which informed the development of these city-wide Tall Building Design Guidelines:
Design Criteria for the Review of Tall Building Proposals (2006) HOK Architects Corporation |
City of Toronto
Tall Buildings: Inviting Change in Downtown Toronto (2010) Urban Strategies Inc. |
Hariri Pontarini Architects | City of Toronto
Downtown Tall Buildings Vision and Performance Standards Design Guidelines |
(2012) Urban Strategies Inc. | Hariri Pontarini Architects | City of Toronto
Photo Credits:
All illustrations and photographs by City of Toronto
with exception of 4.3 Pedestrian Level Wind Effects: Figure 1
used with permission from Moonwire (Nathalie) on Flikr.
T
A
L
L
B
U
I
L
D
I
N
G
D
E
S
I
G
N
G
U
I
D
E
L
I
N
E
S
T
A
L
L
B
U
I
L
D
I
N
G
D
E
S
I
G
N
G
U
I
D
E
L
I
N
E
S
T
A
L
L
B
U
I
L
D
I
N
G
D
E
S
I
G
N
G
U
I
D
E
L
I
N
E
S
Introduction 1
Evolution of Tall Building in Toronto 2
Evolution of Tall Buildings 4
0elning Tall Buildings G
Guiding Principles
Design Excellence 7
Sustainable Design 7
Heritage Conservation 8
Downtown Study Area
Downtown Tall Buildings: Vision and Supplementary Design Guidelines 8
Organization of the Guidelines 9
How and Where the Guidelines Apply 12
1.0 Site Context 13
1.1 Context Analysis 14
1.2 Master Flan or Larger Sites 1G
1.3 Fit and Transition in Scale 18
1.4 Sunlight and Sky View 21
1.5 Prominent Sites and Views from the Public Realm 22
1.G heritage Froerties and heritage Conservation 0istricts 24
2.0 Site Organization 25
2.1 Building Flacement 2G
2.2 Building Address and Entrances 27
2.3 Site Servicing, Access, and Parking 28
2.4 Publically Accessible Open Space 30
2.5 Private Open Space 32
2.G Fedestrian and Cycling Connections 88
2.7 Public Art 34
Table of Contents
3.0 Tall Building Design 36
3.1 Base Building 37
3.1.1 Base Building Height and Scale 38
3.1.2 Street Animation 40
3.1.3 First Floor Height 41
3.1.4 Faade Articulation and Transparency 42
3.1.5 Public-Private Transition 44
3.2 Middle (Tower) 45
8.2.1 Floor Flate Si/e and Shae 4G
3.2.2 Tower Placement 47
3.2.3 Separation Distances 48
3.2.4 Tower Orientation and Articulation 52
3.2.5 Balconies 54
3.3 Tower Top 55
8.8 Tower To 5G
4.0 Pedestrian Realm 57
4.1 Streetscape and Landscape Design 58
4.2 Sidewalk Zone 59
4.8 Fedestrian Level wind Eects GO
4.4 Fedestrian weather Frotection G2
Submission Requirements, References, Glossary & Appendices 63
Clossary G4
List o Reerences G7
Submission Requirements G8
Appendices 83
Appendix A: Heritage Conservation Principles 84
Appendix B: Downtown Tall Buildings: Summary of Supplementary 87
Design Guideline References
T
A
L
L
B
U
I
L
D
I
N
G
D
E
S
I
G
N
G
U
I
D
E
L
I
N
E
S
INTRODUCTION
Evolution of Tall Buildings in Toronto
Evolution of Tall Building Guidelines
Defining Tall Buildings
Guiding Principles
Design Excellence
Sustainable Design
Heritage Conservation
Downtown Study Area
Downtown Tall Buildings: Vision and Supplementary Design Guidelines
Organization of the Guidelines
How and Where the Guidelines Apply
T
A
L
L
B
U
I
L
D
I
N
G
D
E
S
I
G
N
G
U
I
D
E
L
I
N
E
S
2
C
I
T
Y
O
F
T
O
R
O
N
T
O
M
A
R
C
H
2
5
,
2
0
1
3
Tall buildings have been part of Torontos urban landscape
since the early twentieth century. In 1905, the steel frame of the
Traders Bank Building at Yonge and King rose to 14-storeys to
become the tallest building in the British Empire. Over the course
of the following century, the form of tall buildings in Toronto
continuously evolved, responding to changes in technology,
market demand, transportation choice, development economics,
settlement patterns, planning controls, and design trends.
In the 1920s, small plate commercial developments, such as
the first tall buildings at Yonge and King, and along Bay Street,
were constructed on large single lots or a collection of smaller
lots. Later, in the 1950s, eight to ten storey concrete frame
apartments were built on single lots along streets such as Jarvis,
Dunn Avenue, and St. George. This generation of tall building
development provided little or no on-site parking. These buildings
also tended to have small rear and side yard setbacks, which
may have provided adequate light, view, and privacy for lower
buildings, but did not work successfully with taller structures.
Introduction
By the 1960s, new construction technology and changing
ideals in city planning resulted in taller buildings and larger-scale
development. Whether commercial or residential, tall buildings at
this time were typically built on consolidated lots or large-scale
blocks, and in many cases involved the demolition of existing
neighbourhoods for redevelopment. New towers were then
placed in the middle of the lot with extensive landscaped open
space around. Bold new commercial developments based on this
model, such as the TD Centre, became the symbols of the rising
economic power of Toronto. While this pattern allowed for ample
sky view, sunlight, as well as privacy between neighbours, it often
impeded ease of pedestrian access and the vitality of the street.
Beyond the built up core, new subdivisions such as Flemingdon
Park and Parkway Forest were planned using Tower in the Park
design principles. While often providing generous apartment
and office space, in general, this type of development did not
fit comfortably within the existing built form context and was
disruptive to the pedestrian-oriented scale and character of
traditional Toronto neighbourhoods. These buildings did not
support walkable streets and lacked the mix of uses, small retail
frontages, porches, and stoops which successfully animated the
public realm elsewhere in the city. The large, often slab-like floor
plates cast long shadows and created windy conditions at grade.
In many cases, the promised landscapes of the Tower in the
Park became, in reality, the Tower in the Parking Lot.
In the late 1980s, a different approach to tall buildings emerged.
New developments were more careful to fit within the existing
urban fabric, defining the edges of streets and small open spaces
in a traditional way with base buildings, townhouses, and other
lower scale buildings. These new tall buildings were often mixed-
use, had smaller floor plates, and were located with greater regard
for minimizing shadow and wind impacts.
More recently, tall building development has been influenced by
sustainable design and construction methods, with factors such
as energy efficiency, indoor environmental quality, and building
Traders Bank Building, c.1912
EVOLUTION OF TALL BUILDINGS IN TORONTO
T
A
L
L
B
U
I
L
D
I
N
G
D
E
S
I
G
N
G
U
I
D
E
L
I
N
E
S
3
performance playing an increasingly important role in determining
tall building form. Many buildings today are also capitalizing on
technological advancements and economic advantages resulting
in ever greater building heights. While it is an exciting time in
the history of tall buildings in Toronto, many new questions and
challenges have emerged.
Current tall building debates often centre around the capacity
of places and infrastructure to serve tall buildings and their
occupants, the liveability of the vertical communities being
created, the cumulative effect of clusters of tall buildings,
particularly on quality of life and the public realm, as well as
the longevity of what is being built, including the durability and
lifespan of materials, construction practices, energy performance,
and the ability of buildings to adapt and accommodate change
over time.
Whether past, present, or future, all tall buildings play a prominent
role in the Toronto landscape. In addition to the Traders Bank
Building, other tall buildings, including the Canadian Bank of
Commerce (1934) and the remainder of Commerce Court (1972),
have claimed the status of 'tallest' building in the city and beyond.
While contributing to the evolution of tall buildings in Toronto,
these buildings stand proudly today as city-wide landmarks and
heritage icons.
In recognition of the high level of civic responsibility and obligation
that tall buildings carry, the Official Plan includes specific Built
Form - Tall Buildings policies. These policies are based on the
premise that tall buildings are desirable in the right places, but do
not belong everywhere. When appropriately located, designed,
and well-planned, tall buildings can enhance the public
realm, complement neighbouring buildings, and contribute to a
sustainable future.
EVOLUTION OF TALL BUILDING GUIDELINES
To assist with implementation of Official Plan policy and
provide specific design direction for tall buildings in Toronto,
City Council adopted the "Design Criteria for the Review of Tall
building Proposals" (2006) and the "Downtown Tall Buildings
Vision and Performance Standards Design Guidelines" (2012).
These guidelines were developed through consultant studies by
HOK Architects (2006) for the city-wide "Design Criteria," and
Urban Strategies Inc./Hariri Pontarini Architects (2010) for the
"Downtown Guidelines."
This updated city-wide "Tall Buildings Design Guidelines"
document integrates and builds upon these previous studies
and guidelines to establish a new, unified set of performance
measures for the evaluation of all tall building development
applications across the entire city.
1960s Towers in the Parking Lot
T
A
L
L
B
U
I
L
D
I
N
G
D
E
S
I
G
N
G
U
I
D
E
L
I
N
E
S
4
C
I
T
Y
O
F
T
O
R
O
N
T
O
M
A
R
C
H
2
5
,
2
0
1
3
DEFINING TALL BUILDINGS
Tall buildings are generally defined as buildings with height that
is greater than the width of the adjacent street right-of-way or the
wider of two streets if located at an intersection. Since street right-
of-way width varies across Toronto, typically between 20 and 36
meters, this definition reinforces the importance of site context in
determining the threshold for when a building is considered tall
and when these Guidelines will apply.
Top
The tos o tall buildings, including uer Noors and rooto
mechanical or telecommunications equipment, signage, and
amenity space, should be designed, primarily through tower
massing and articulation, and secondarily through materials,
to create an integrated and appropriate conclusion to the tall
building form.
Middle (Tower)
The location, scale, Noor late si/e, orientation, and searation
distances of the middle (tower) affect sky view, privacy, wind,
and the amount of sunlight and shadows that reach the public
realm and neighbouring properties. The design and placement
of the tower should effectively resolve these matters to ensure
that a tall building minimizes its impact on surrounding streets,
parks, public and private open space, as well as existing or
future buildings on adjacent sites. Tower placement and design
also plays an important role in meeting sustainability objectives.
Base Building
The lower storeys of a tall building are referred to as the base
building. The role of the base building is to frame the public
realm, articulate entrances, and assist in the creation of an
attractive and animated public realm which provides a safe,
interesting, and comfortable pedestrian experience. The base
building should delne and suort adjacent streets, arks,
and open space at an appropriate scale, integrate with adjacent
streetwall buildings, assist to achieve transition down to
lowerscale buildings, and minimi/e the imact o arking and
servicing on the public realm.
As with variation in height, the design of tall buildings may also
differ across the city in response to the local context or building
use. While the design expression may vary, in general, most tall
buildings in Toronto will follow a classic form and consist of three
carefully integrated parts: a base building, middle, and top, each
with a particular role to play in achieving the goals of the Official
Plan. Exceptions to this form may be considered on a site-specific
basis, provided that the overall intent of the Official Plan is met.
T
A
L
L
B
U
I
L
D
I
N
G
D
E
S
I
G
N
G
U
I
D
E
L
I
N
E
S
5
IHrIaI FIan aIaranra
3.1.3 Built Form Tall Buildings: Policy 1
Regardless of stylistic approach, the design and placement of all
tall buildings should make a positive contribution to the public
realm, fit harmoniously within the surrounding context and skyline,
and be consistent with the following:
slender oint towers, rising above wellroortioned
and articulated base buildings, with a strong relationship
to the existing context and adjacent public realm, are
preferred;
avoid reestanding towers without bases or a direct
relationship to the street, e.g. towers in a park;
avoid big, boxy, dominant massing, and large, elongated,
or slablike Noor lates,
embrace design creativity and variation in built form and
architectural expression, including variation in tower
shape, orientation, and the design of each faade for the
purpose of visual interest and sustainability; and
be innovative, but also appropriate in the choice of
materials and construction methods, to make a long
term, sustainable, highvalue contribution to city
building.
Avoid big boxy,
dominant massing and
slab-like tower form
Avoid free-standing
towers without base
buildings or a direct
relationship to
adjacent streets
AVOID
AVOID
Figure 2. Large, elongated Noor lates cast long shadows and create an
inappropriate scale at street level.
Figure 1. Freestanding towers disrut the edestrianoriented scale, character,
and vitality of the street.
T
A
L
L
B
U
I
L
D
I
N
G
D
E
S
I
G
N
G
U
I
D
E
L
I
N
E
S
6
C
I
T
Y
O
F
T
O
R
O
N
T
O
M
A
R
C
H
2
5
,
2
0
1
3
DESIGN EXCELLENCE
Tall buildings should reflect design excellence and innovation to
acknowledge the important civic role tall buildings play in defining
the image and liveability of Toronto. In addition to architectural
quality, design excellence should be reflected through the
effective use of resources, high-quality materials, innovative
and sustainable building design and construction, and through a
sensitive and thoughtful response to the impacts that tall buildings
place upon the urban landscape.
To assist in achieving design excellence, tall building applications
may be subject to the City of Toronto Design Review Panel
process. Design Review is an independent process that can help
ensure a design that is "fit for purpose" from a property owner's
perspective also makes a suitable response and contribution to
the surrounding context and public realm.
GUIDING PRINCIPLES
The Tall Building Design Guidelines do not determine where tall
buildings are permitted. Rather, the Guidelines assist with the
implementation of Official Plan policy to help ensure that tall
buildings, where they are permitted, fit within their context and
minimize their local impacts.
The Guidelines primarily illustrate how the public realm and built
form policy objectives of the Official Plan can be achieved within
a tall building development and within the area surrounding
a tall building site. The Guidelines provide specific and often
measurable directions related to the following guiding principles:
promote architectural and urban design excellence,
sustainability, innovation, longevity, and creative
exression with visionary design, highquality materials,
and leadingedge construction methods,
romote harmonious lt and comatibility with the
existing and lanned context, emhasi/ing relationshis
to lowerscale buildings, arks and oen sace,
conserve and integrate adjacent and onsite heritage
properties so that new tall buildings are sympathetic to,
and compatible with, the heritage property;
consider relationships to other tall buildings, including
the cumulative effect of multiple towers on sunlight,
comfort, and quality in the public realm;
create a safe, comfortable, accessible, vibrant, and
attractive public realm and pedestrian environment;
minimi/e shadowing and wind imacts, and rotect
sunlight and sky view, for streets, parks, public and
private open space, and neighbouring properties;
respond appropriately to prominent sites, important
views from the public realm, and the shape of the skyline
to reinforce the structure and image of the city; and
ensure highquality living and working conditions,
including access to public and private open space,
interior daylighting, natural ventilation, and privacy for
building occupants.
City Council has designated all growth areas within Toronto as
Design Review Districts. Tall building applications in these and
other areas experiencing substantial development pressure may
be subject to Design Review, particularly if they contain significant
public realm impacts either through their location, scale, form or
architectural quality.
Given the prominence of tall buildings, the City, development and
design industry, and members of the public all have a vital role
to play in promoting design excellence. The Design Review Panel
process is one important way of contributing to this goal.
Review of a tall building proposal at a Design Review Panel meeting
T
A
L
L
B
U
I
L
D
I
N
G
D
E
S
I
G
N
G
U
I
D
E
L
I
N
E
S
7
SUSTAINABLE DESIGN
Another responsibility of tall buildings is to embrace a heightened
awareness of green building innovation and the built form linkages
between urban design, architecture, and sustainability. Sustainable
design is an approach to developing tall building sites and
buildings that is less resource intensive and works to improve the
economic, social, and natural environment we live in.
Sustainable design works at two levels in tall buildings. The first
level recognizes that tall buildings have a strategic role to play in
the economic, social, and environmental sustainability of the City.
Tall buildings, particularly those that contain a mix of uses and are
designed to accommodate the changing needs of occupants, can
be an effective counter-measure to urban sprawl by encouraging
a healthy, pedestrian-oriented lifestyle and promoting better use
of transit. Improving the adaptability and flexibility of tall buildings
also helps to ensure that these buildings remain functional and
capable of addressing any shifts in demographics and market
demands over the long term.
The second level of sustainable design is more technical relating
to building performance, materials and construction methods,
water management, landscaping, and the quality of the internal
environment. While the core temperatures of fully glazed tall
buildings are typically quite stable and comfortable with very
low energy consumption, current popular glazing systems and
balcony designs create highly dynamic thermal conditions within
the first two metres of the building perimeter. Significant thermal
losses and solar heat gain in the perimeter zone must then be
offset with extra energy (e.g. mechanical heating/cooling) to
create a comfortable and balanced interior environment. This
in turn can translate into higher maintenance costs. There are
many site and building design measures, including the selection
T
A
L
L
B
U
I
L
D
I
N
G
D
E
S
I
G
N
G
U
I
D
E
L
I
N
E
S
of more efficient perimeter systems, which can be applied to
improve the sustainability and energy performance of tall building
developments.
Both the first and second levels of sustainable design should
be identified at the projects initial or site planning stage when
fundamental design decisions are being made. By following an
integrated design process (IDP) and ensuring that all design
and construction disciplines are involved early, a tall building
can achieve better overall performance results.
Strategies for applying both levels of sustainable design in new tall
building development can be considered in the following ways:
in residential and mixeduse buildings, oer a range
o ownershi tyes and unit si/e choices, including
the provision of larger units suitable for families with
children;
design and construct tall buildings or Nexibility o use
and potential for future change, including versatility in
interior design, layout, and construction practices to
encourage building longevity and adaptability to potential
shifts in demand over time:
in base buildings, rovide Nexible interior saces to
accommodate changing uses, including the transition
from residential to commercial uses;
in the tower ortion, rovide conditions to allow
residential units to be converted or combined to adjust
to changing occupancy requirements;
incorporate renewable energy systems or district energy
where feasible;
include energy elciency measures and evaluate energy
erormance through changes in gla/ing ratios, building
placement, massing, orientation and articulation, balcony
design, materials and construction methods;
incorporate recycled content or reuse building materials
and components;
rovide eective lighting and measures or birdriendly
design;
include opportunities for water collection and reuse;
Tall building green roof
8
C
I
T
Y
O
F
T
O
R
O
N
T
O
M
A
R
C
H
2
5
,
2
0
1
3
incorporate pedestrian and cycling infrastructure
improvements; and
include sulcient sace and highquality soil volume or
successful shade tree planting, sustainable landscaping,
and green roofs
The City of Toronto encourages sustainable design through
the Official Plan and the Toronto Green Standard (TGS). The
TGS sets out performance measures for tall buildings and
sites and specifies strategies that can be used to achieve cost-
effective, environmentally, and socially responsible end results.
The performance measures are organized under the following
categories:
Heritage Conservation Districts (HCDs) are special areas dense
with heritage properties and a unique historic character. The
character and values of HCDs will be conserved to ensure that
their significance is not diminished by incremental or sweeping
change.
There will also be heritage properties that can work in harmony
with new development. In these cases, development should strive
for the long term protection, integration, and re-use of heritage
properties. Heritage properties should be used to inform the scale
and contextual treatment of the new development. If well-designed
and sited in appropriate locations, tall buildings can make a
positive contribution within historical settings.
Air Quality
Greenhouse Gas Emissions/Energy
Efficiency
Water Quality, Quantity and Efficiency
Ecology
Solid Waste
T
A
L
L
B
U
I
L
D
I
N
G
D
E
S
I
G
N
G
U
I
D
E
L
I
N
E
S
New tall building applications are required to meet Tier 1 of the
Toronto Green Standard (TGS) performance measures. Applicants
are required to submit the TGS checklist with their development
application. Specific performance measures from the TGS
are identified with the above icons for relevant sections of the
Submission Requirements for these Guidelines.
HERITAGE CONSERVATION
The City of Toronto values its heritage properties and requires that
they be protected and that new development conserve the integrity
of their cultural heritage value, attributes, and character, consistent
with accepted principles of good heritage conservation (see
Appendix A: Heritage Conservation Principles). Not every property
is suitable for tall building development as a result of constraints
imposed by its size or by the fact that such development may be
incompatible with conserving heritage properties on or adjacent to
a development site or within a Heritage Conservation District.
Tall building development proposals containing heritage properties
on or adjacent to the development site are required to provide a
Heritage Impact Assessment as part of the application review
process, to evaluate the impact the proposed development or site
alteration will have on the heritage property and to recommend an
overall approach to conservation of these resources and mitigate
negative impact upon them.
DOWNTOWN STUDY AREA
In response to the tremendous growth and amount of tall building
development in Toronto's Downtown, City Council adopted the
"Downtown Tall Buildings Vision and Performance Standards
Design Guidelines" in July 2012. The Downtown Guidelines
identified "where" tall buildings may be appropriate within the
Downtown and established a framework to guide the height, form,
and contextual relationship between new tall buildings and the
surrounding area.
The Downtown Guidelines included: a vision statement for
Downtown tall buildings; mapping identifying the location, heights,
and building typologies along High Streets; and twenty-three
James Cooper Mansion
9
As a result of this consolidation, the updated Tall Building Design
Guidelines contained herein establish a unified set of performance
measures for the evaluation of all tall building development
applications city-wide, including all areas within the Downtown.
The consolidated and renamed "Downtown Tall Buildings: Vision
and Supplementary Design Guidelines," is now a chapter within
the Council-approved District- or Area- Based Urban Design
Guidelines.
For convenience purposes, cross-references to the Downtown
Supplementary Design Guidelines are listed within the Related
Standards, Guidelines & Studies at the bottom of relevant sections
within these Guidelines and within a summary table in Appendix B.
ORGANIZATION OF THE GUIDELINES
The Tall Building Design Guidelines are organized into the
following sections:
Individual design guidelines with supporting illustrations, photos,
rationales, and related references, such as to Official Plan policies,
TGS performance measures, and the Downtown Tall Buildings
Supplementary Design Guidelines, are provided for each aspect
of tall building development identified within sections 1.0 through
4.0. These sections provide an easy to follow workbook, which
is concluded by a supporting framework of related Submission
Requirements to help lead applicants, City staff and others through
an effective tall building development review process.
Performance Standards relating to the base conditions, the tower
portion of tall buildings, and to contextual fit.
Key objectives behind developing Downtown Tall Building
Guidelines included enhancing the pedestrian environment;
minimizing shadowing of sidewalks, parks, and public squares;
protecting landmark views and heritage resources; and improving
the quality of life (access to natural light, sky view, and privacy)
for people living and working in the citys core.
Together, the study vision and performance standards were
designed to assist with the review of new tall building applications
within the Downtown study area boundary, encompassing
portions of Wards 20, 27 and 28 as bounded by Bathurst Street
on the west, Dupont Street on the north, the Don Valley Parkway
on the east and Lake Ontario on the south, (but excluding areas
within this boundary that are subject to existing Secondary Plans).
DOWNTOWN TALL BUILDINGS: VISION AND
SUPPLEMENTATRY DESIGN GUIDLINES
As part of the 2012 approval, City Council directed that the
Downtown Guidelines be consolidated with the city-wide
Guidelines. The outcome of this consolidation is as follows:
all Downtown tall building performance standards with
citywide alicability have been integrated into the
udated citywide Tall Building 0esign Cuidelines,
locationsecilc asects o the 0owntown Cuidelines,
namely the Downtown Vision and the Tall Building
Typologies with all associated mapping and tables, as
well as all area or sitesecilc erormance standards
unique to the 0owntown study area, remain asadoted
by Council in a consolidated, companion guideline
renamed the "Downtown Tall Buildings: Vision and
Supplementary Design Guidelines;" and
the citywide Tall Buildings 0esign Cuidelines will be
used together with the consolidated "Downtown Tall
Buildings: Vision and Supplementary Design Guidelines"
to evaluate all new and current tall building development
applications falling within the Downtown study area
boundary. Secondary Plan Areas within the Downtown
study area boundary continue to be excluded from the
Downtown Supplementary Design Guidelines.
T
A
L
L
B
U
I
L
D
I
N
G
D
E
S
I
G
N
G
U
I
D
E
L
I
N
E
S
Introduction
1.0 Site Context
2.0 Site Organization
3.0 Tall Building Design
4.0 Pedestrian Realm
Glossary; References; Submission Requirements;
and Appendices
10
C
I
T
Y
O
F
T
O
R
O
N
T
O
M
A
R
C
H
2
5
,
2
0
1
3
T
A
L
L
B
U
I
L
D
I
N
G
D
E
S
I
G
N
G
U
I
D
E
L
I
N
E
S
1.0 SITE CONTEXT
1.1 6onIaxI knaIysIs
Evaluate the existing and planned context and
demonstrate how the proposed tall building responds
to the patterns, opportunities, and challenges within the
surrounding area.
1.Z MasIar FIan Ior Largar 8IIas
Coordinate the development of larger sites with potential
for multiple tall buildings, new internal streets, or parks
through a Master Plan.
1.8 FII and TransIIIon In 8raIa
Ensure tall buildings lt within the existing or lanned
context and provide an appropriate transition in scale
down to lowerscaled buildings, arks, and oen sace.
1.4 8unIIghI and 8ky VIaW
Locate and design tall buildings to protect access to
sunlight and sky view within the surrounding context of
streets, parks, public and private open space, and other
shadow sensitive areas.
1.6 FromInanI 8IIas and VIaWs Irom Iha FubIIr aaIm
Frovide an aroriate, highquality design resonse
for tall buildings on or adjacent to prominent sites, and
when framing views from the public realm to prominent
sites.
1.6 harIIaga FroarIIas and harIIaga 6onsarvaIIon
IsIrIrIs
Locate and design tall buildings to respect and
complement the scale, character, form and setting of
onsite and adjacent heritage roerties and heritage
Conservation 0istricts (hC0s).
2.0 SITE ORGANIZATION
Z.1 8uIIdIng FIaramanI
Locate the base of tall buildings to frame the edges of
streets, parks, and open space, reinforce corners, and to
lt harmoniously within the existing context.
Z.Z 8uIIdIng kddrass and LnIranras
0rgani/e tall buildings to use existing or new ublic
streets for address and building entrances.
Ensure primary building entrances front onto public
streets, are welldelned, clearly visible, and universally
accessible from the adjacent public sidewalk.
Z.8 8IIa 8arvIrIng, krrass and FarkIng
Locate back of house activities, such as loading,
servicing, utilities, and vehicle parking, underground or
within the building mass, away from the public realm
and public view.
Z.4 FubIIraIIy krrassIbIa an 8ara
Frovide graderelated, ublically accessible oen sace
within the tall building site to complement, connect, and
extend the existing network of public streets, parks, and
open space.
Z.6 FrIvaIa an 8ara
Frovide a range o highquality, comortable rivate
and shared outdoor amenity space throughout the tall
building site.
Z.6 FadasIrIan and 6yrIIng 6onnarIIons
Provide comfortable, safe, and accessible pedestrian
and cycling routes through and around the tall building
site to connect with adjacent routes, streets, parks, open
space, and other priority destinations, such as transit
and underground concourses.
Z.7 FubIIr krI
Pursue public art opportunities and funding strategies on
tall building sites, or adjacent public lands, to enhance
the quality of the development, the public realm, and the
city.
3.0 TALL BUILDING DESIGN
3.1 Base Building
3.2 Middle (Tower)
3.3 Tower Top
3.1 BASE BUILDING
8.1.1 8asa 8uIIdIng 8raIa and haIghI
0esign the base building to lt harmoniously within
the existing context of neighbouring building heights
at the street and to respect the scale and proportion
of adjacent streets, parks, and public or private open
space.
8.1.Z 8IraaI knImaIIon
Line the base building with active, graderelated uses
to promote a safe and animated public realm.
k brIaI ovarvIaW oI rInrIIa guIdaIIna sIaIamanIs ronIaInad In sarIIons 1.0 Ihrough 4.0.
11
T
A
L
L
B
U
I
L
D
I
N
G
D
E
S
I
G
N
G
U
I
D
E
L
I
N
E
S
8.Z.4 ToWar rIanIaIIon and krIIruIaIIon
0rgani/e and articulate tall building towers to romote
design excellence, innovation, and sustainability.
8.Z.6 8aIronIas
0esign balconies to maximi/e usability, comort, and
building erormance, while minimi/ing negative
impacts on the building mass, public realm, and
natural environment.
3.3 TOWER TOP
8.8 ToWar To
Design the top of tall buildings to make an appropriate
contribution to the quality and character of the city
skyline.
Balance the use of decorative lighting with energy
elciency objectives, the rotection o migratory birds,
and the management o artilcial sky glow.
4.0 THE PEDESTRIAN REALM
4.1 8IraaIsraa and Landsraa asIgn
Frovide highquality, sustainable streetscae and
landscape design between the tall building and adjacent
streets, parks, and open space.
4.Z 8IdaWaIk Zona
Provide adequate space between the front of the building
and adjacent street curbs to safely and comfortably
accommodate pedestrian movement, streetscape
elements, and activities related to the uses at grade.
4.8 FadasIrIan LavaI wInd LIIarIs
Locate, orient, and design tall buildings to promote air
circulation and natural ventilation, yet minimi/e adverse
wind conditions on adjacent streets, parks and open
space, at building entrances, and in public and private
outdoor amenity areas.
4.4 FadasIrIan waaIhar FroIarIIon
Ensure weather protection elements, such as overhangs
and canoies, are wellintegrated into building design,
carefully designed and scaled to support the street, and
ositioned to maximi/e unction and edestrian comort.
8.1.8 FIrsI FIoor haIghI
Frovide a minimum lrst Noor height o 4.5 metres,
measured NoortoNoor rom average grade.
8.1.4 Faada krIIruIaIIon and Transaranry
Articulate the base building with highquality materials
and design elements that lt with neighbouring
buildings and contribute to a pedestrian scale.
Provide clear, unobstructed views into and out from
ground Noor uses acing the ublic realm.
8.1.6 FubIIrFrIvaIa TransIIIon
Design the base building and adjacent setback to
promote an appropriate level of visual and physical
access and overlook reNecting the nature o building
use at grade.
3.2 MIDDLE (TOWER)
8.Z.1 FIoor FIaIa 8Ita and 8haa
Limit the tower Noor late to 75O square metres
or less er Noor, including all built area within the
building, but excluding balconies.
8.Z.Z ToWar FIaramanI
Place towers away from streets, parks, open space,
and neighbouring properties to reduce visual and
physical impacts of the tower and allow the base
building to be the rimary delning element or the site
and adjacent public realm.
8.Z.8 8aaraIIon IsIanras
Setback tall building towers 12.5 metres or greater
from the side and rear property lines or centre line of
an abutting lane.
Provide separation distance between towers on the
same site o 25 metres or greater, measured rom the
exterior wall of the buildings, excluding balconies.
ImIamanIaIIon oI ToWar 8aaraIIon IsIanras.
8maII 8IIas
On small sites, apply the recommended minimum
tower setbacks and stepbacks to determine the
resultant Noor late si/e and easibility o the site
dimensions to accommodate a tall building.
12
C
I
T
Y
O
F
T
O
R
O
N
T
O
M
A
R
C
H
2
5
,
2
0
1
3
C
T
Y
0
E
T
A
L
L
B
b
L
0
h
C
0
E
S
C
h
C
b
0
E
L
h
E
S
HOW AND WHERE THE GUIDELINES APPLY
i. The Tall Building Design Guidelines apply to the design,
review, and approval of all new and current tall building
develoment in Toronto. The Cuidelines have citywide
applicability and will normally apply to the evaluation of
tall building roosals and design alternatives in 0lcial
Flan Amendments, Zoning Bylaw Amendments, Flans o
Subdivision, and Site Plan Control applications.
ii. The Tall Buildings Design Guidelines apply together
with the consolidated "Downtown Tall Buildings:
Vision and Supplementary Design Guidelines" to
evaluate all new and current tall building development
applications within the Downtown study area boundary.
Secondary Plan Areas within the Downtown study area
boundary continue to be excluded from the Downtown
Supplementary Design Guidelines.
iii. The Guidelines are intended to be read together
with the 0lcial Flan, alicable Zoning ByLaws,
Secondary Flans and heritage Conservation 0istrict
Plans, the Toronto Green Standard (TGS), the Toronto
Development Guide, as well as all other applicable City
policies, standards, guidelines, and requirements.
while there are no erceived conNicts between any
reexisting City Counciladoted olicies, standards or
guidelines, should conNict arise, the more restrictive or
prescriptive of these measures will prevail. In all cases,
0lcial Flan and heritage Conservation 0istrict Flan
policies prevail over guideline measures or requirements.
iv. The Guidelines are intended to provide a degree of
certainty and clarity of common interpretation, however,
as guidelines, they should also be afforded some
Nexibility in alication, articularly when looked at
cumulatively.
The Guidelines are not intended to be applied or
interpreted independently of each other. Rather, each
guideline requirement should be weighed across the
board with the other guidelines and "work together"
to determine whether a tall building development
application has successfully met the overall intent of
these Cuidelines and the 0lcial Flan.
v. In considering whether to permit a tall building on a
sitebysite basis, many other lanning issues must lrst
be taken into account, including, but not limited to, the
site context and availability of adequate infrastructure,
public transit, parks, community and cultural services
and facilities, schools, and child care facilities. If it
is determined that a tall building is supportable, and
represents good planning, these Guidelines will then
apply.
vi. The Guidelines are an evolving "living" document which
may be revised, rom time to time, to reNect new
lndings or study recommendations that have an imact
on the effective evaluation of tall building applications.
T
A
L
L
B
U
I
L
D
I
N
G
D
E
S
I
G
N
G
U
I
D
E
L
I
N
E
S
T
A
L
L
B
U
I
L
D
I
N
G
D
E
S
I
G
N
G
U
I
D
E
L
I
N
E
S
1.0 8ITL 6hTLXT
1.1 Context Analysis
1.2 Master Plan for Larger Sites
1.3 Fit and Transition in Scale
1.4 Sunlight and Sky View
1.5 Prominent Sites and Views from the Public Realm
1.6 Heritage Properties and Heritage Conservation Districts
14
C
I
T
Y
O
F
T
O
R
O
N
T
O
M
A
R
C
H
2
5
,
2
0
1
3
a. As art o the Flanning Rationale, include a walkable"
context analysis, showing the tall building proposal, and
illustrating through text and graphics at an appropriate
scale:
25Om and 5OOm 'walkability' radii rom the site,
planning area boundaries (e.g. secondary plans);
land uses and designations;
major streets and blocks (atterns, si/e, location),
pedestrian/cycling routes and connections;
transit routes, stations, and stops (including distance to
rapid transit nodes);
open space networks (parks, open space, natural
features);
existing or otential heritage roerties and heritage
Conservation Districts;
area amenities and destinations (community centres,
trails, libraries, schools, retail areas, etc.);
toograhical inormation (where signilcant).
b. As part of the Planning Rationale, include a Block context
analysis, showing the tall building proposal and illustrating
through text and graphics at an appropriate scale:
si/e o blocks and arrangement o arcels or lots,
location, si/e, and organi/ation o ublic streets,
laneways, sidewalks, transit stops, and other pedestrian
or cycling routes and connections;
location and si/e o arks and oen sace,
adjacent and onsite heritage roerties,
imortant or identiled views rom the ublic realm,
existing and planned building footprints;
ground Noor uses, setback atterns, and general location
of building entrances, street trees and site circulation/
servicing on adjacent sites and blocks;
existing and planned building heights, including the
height of context buildings, other tall building towers
and base buildings, to demonstrate how the proposed
tall building relates to surrounding buildings, particularly
within the same block and across streets and open
space (see also 1.3 Fit and Transition in Scale and 3.2.3
Separation Distances).
kTIhkLL
Context refers to the setting of a development, including both
the existing physical surroundings and the planned vision
for the future of an area. The intent of the context analysis
is to identify patterns, opportunities, and challenges, and
demonstrate how the roosed tall building will lt with and
respond appropriately to the surrounding area.
The context analysis should inform many key design decisions,
including the placement, height and character of base buildings,
the location, shape, general height, and spacing of towers,
as well as the relationship in scale between tall building
components and to neighbours.
The context analysis may also be used to determine what
amenities and community facilities are present and which ones
may need to be provided around or within the tall building
site to achieve a highquality living and working environment.
Important considerations may include public open space,
community centres, schools, grocers and markets, other active
commercial uses, community energy systems, transit, cycling
and pedestrian connections, generous sidewalks, and street
trees.
A 5OO metre radius is a generally acceted measure or
walkability and is roughly equivalent to a 10 minute walk.
The intent of the context analysis at a "walkable" scale is to
demonstrate how the proposed tall building development
reinforces existing or planned built form patterns, responds
appropriately to changes in land use and scale, and makes
connections to important area amenities, such as transit, public
open space, and living and working destinations.
The block scale analysis allows for a closer examination
of the immediate context, including buildings on the same
block and across the street on adjacent blocks. This analysis
should evaluate setback patterns, building heights, proximity
to oen sace, ground Noor uses, relationshi to other tall
1.1 6hTLXT khkLY8I8
LvaIuaIa Iha axIsIIng and Iannad ronIaxI and damonsIraIa hoW
Iha roosad IaII buIIdIng rasonds Io Iha aIIarns, oorIunIIIas,
and rhaIIangas WIIhIn Iha surroundIng araa.
T
A
L
L
B
U
I
L
D
I
N
G
D
E
S
I
G
N
G
U
I
D
E
L
I
N
E
S
15
30
Storeys
7
Storeys
5
Storeys
5
Storeys
25
Storeys
5
Storeys
5
Storeys
3 Storeys
Community Centre
2 Storeys
7
Storeys
30
Storeys
5
Storeys 30
Storeys
25
Storeys
3-4
Storeys
3 Storeys 3 Storeys 3 Storeys
6 Storeys
3
Storeys
5
Storeys
25
Storeys
4
S
to
re
y
s
Property Line
Existing Commercial
Frontage
Proposed Commercial
Frontage
Proposed
Development Site
Main Building
Entrance
Commercial/Retail
Entrance
Existing Heritage
Properties
IHrIaI FIan aIaranra
8.1.2 Built Form. Folicy 1 | 8.1.8 Built Form Tall Buildings. Folicy 2b, 2c and 2d | 8.1.5 heritage Resources |
8.8 Building hew heighbourhoods. Folicy 1, 2, and 8 | 5.1.8 Site Flan Control. Folicy 2
buildings, and the arrangement of driveways, sidewalks, and
street trees. The block scale context analysis should inform
site organi/ation, oen sace allocation, building massing,
lacement, ground Noor uses, and the design and character o
the public realm.
An important step in the Block context analysis is to evaluate
the relationship between the proposed development and the
heights of other buildings in the surrounding area. The intent
of this analysis is to coordinate the proposed tall building with
the location, height, scale, and spacing of existing or approved
buildings, and in particular other tall buildings on the same or
adjacent blocks.
Flexibility in the scope of the context analysis, as well as the
si/e and shae o the 5OO metre and 25O metre 'walkability'
radii is encouraged to address locali/ed conditions, such as
natural or physical barriers (ravines, railways, highways, etc.),
planning boundaries, important destinations, community
facilities, transportation nodes, changes in land use, and the
overall si/e o the tall building site.
T
A
L
L
B
U
I
L
D
I
N
G
D
E
S
I
G
N
G
U
I
D
E
L
I
N
E
S