Regulation Markhaden04
Regulation Markhaden04
Regulation Markhaden04
Commentary
Regulation of illegal drugs: an exploration of public health tools
Mark Haden
Vancouver Coastal Health Authority: Addiction Services, Pacic Spirit Community Health Centre,
2110 West 43rd Ave., Vancouver, BC, Canada V6M 2E1
Received 8 November 2003; received in revised form 3 March 2004; accepted 17 March 2004
Abstract
This commentary explores the concept of a regulated market for currently illegal drugs. It details a variety of specic public health tools
which could be used in a regulatory regimen to control access to these substances. The distinction between administrative and social controlling
mechanisms is discussed. The author concludes that a regulated market for drugs founded on inclusive public health and moral principles is
a rational approach to the pervasive global concern of illegal drugs in our society.
2004 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Illegal drug control; Market regulation; Drug legalisation; Public health
There is currently a transition in the global debate over
how illegal drugs are controlled. This debate is fuelled
largely by the growing acknowledgement that criminal
justice tools, in isolation, are ineffective at controlling the
criminal, health and social problems associated with illegal
drug use. The problems caused by drug prohibition have
been well documented (Auditor General of Canada, 2001;
Bertram et al., 1996; Haden, 2002; MacCoun & Reuter,
2001) and there is growing agreement that public health
tools can be more effective at managing this pervasive social
concern. A recent issue of the International Journal of Drug
Policy explored the expanding global awareness of the fail-
ure of drug prohibition. In this issue, authors considered the
current crisis this approach is facing (Levine, 2003; Wodak,
2003) and suggested ways of challenging the international
treaties which dictate an enforcement based approach to
drugs which are currently illegal (Bewley-Taylor, 2003).
In Canada, there have been several recent Federal reports
which have recommended signicant changes to our dom-
inant enforcement model of drug control (Canadas Drug
Strategy, 2001; Canadian HIV/AIDS Legal Network, 1999;
Report of the Special Committee on Non-Medical Use of
Drugs, 2002).
The opinions in this article are those of the author and are not a
reection of the policies or procedures of the Vancouver Coastal Health
Authority.