The HR manager and OD consultant at Fiat India Automobiles identified issues with the company's performance management system, including subjective ratings and delays in salary revisions. They brainstormed interventions like making the feedback process more forward-looking, using 360-degree feedback, and assessing personalities to build trust. They gained leadership support and implemented training on DISC assessments, new feedback techniques, and the 180/360 degree appraisal process over six months. This led to higher employee engagement and bonuses being distributed more quickly.
The HR manager and OD consultant at Fiat India Automobiles identified issues with the company's performance management system, including subjective ratings and delays in salary revisions. They brainstormed interventions like making the feedback process more forward-looking, using 360-degree feedback, and assessing personalities to build trust. They gained leadership support and implemented training on DISC assessments, new feedback techniques, and the 180/360 degree appraisal process over six months. This led to higher employee engagement and bonuses being distributed more quickly.
The HR manager and OD consultant at Fiat India Automobiles identified issues with the company's performance management system, including subjective ratings and delays in salary revisions. They brainstormed interventions like making the feedback process more forward-looking, using 360-degree feedback, and assessing personalities to build trust. They gained leadership support and implemented training on DISC assessments, new feedback techniques, and the 180/360 degree appraisal process over six months. This led to higher employee engagement and bonuses being distributed more quickly.
The HR manager and OD consultant at Fiat India Automobiles identified issues with the company's performance management system, including subjective ratings and delays in salary revisions. They brainstormed interventions like making the feedback process more forward-looking, using 360-degree feedback, and assessing personalities to build trust. They gained leadership support and implemented training on DISC assessments, new feedback techniques, and the 180/360 degree appraisal process over six months. This led to higher employee engagement and bonuses being distributed more quickly.
Narrator: HR managers of Fiat India Automobiles Ltd have diagnosed the
issues persisting in the Organization though Open system Model. One of
the key themes identified was performance management system which consists of the following issues: Rating process is subjective to managers discretion and less transparent High frustration and dissatisfaction among the employees due to delayed salary revisions and bonuses Introduce the four characters, Saurabh as HR Manager Mr. Seedha Chaman, Shilpa as OD Consultant Ms. Ulti Khopadi, and Prakash as Leader Mr. 100 Sawal and Trainer Mr. Har Sawal ka Jawab Scene 1: HR managers brainstorming on possible interventions Now the HR manager (Mr. Seedha Chaman) and OD consultant (Ms. Ulti Khopadi) are brainstorming on possible interventions to overcome the issues identified.
First problem: HR Manager: Good afternoon Ms. Ulti Khopadi, our diagnosis suggests that we have a robust goal setting method in our PMS and employees are clear of what is expected of them, but the feedback, appraisal and the rewarding phases arent good. Can we not make the process more systematic and transparent so that the employees and managers can have more meaningful conversations?
OD Consultant: So keeping that in mind, I think we need to improve our feedback system by making it more forward looking. Aakhir peeche dekhne mein kiska bhala hai, seeda chaman.
HR Manager: Thats a very good idea, ulti khopdi! No one really likes a negative judgement, but a constructively delivered feedback attracts attention and helps in improving performance. It will be much more productive to help people learn to be right than prove them wrong.
Second problem: HR Manager: That takes care of one problem, Ms. Khopadi, but you know, there is lot of subjectivity and biases in the appraisals, and this breeds negativity among the employees.
OD Consultant: Correct. So what we can do is, we can take feedback from multiple stakeholders and not rate an employee only on the basis of managers perception.
HR Manager: So you suggesting about the 360 appraisal? Kaafi shaatir dimaag hai aapka, Ms. Khopadi, but dont you think it will increase the time frame and the complexity in the process.
OD Consultant: Hmmm, so let us go for 180 degree at the lower level and 360 degree at the upper level where stakes are high.
HR Manager: Great! That will also help us in encouraging an open culture that values feedback.
Third problem: HR Manager makes a sad face
OD consultant: Ab kya hua Mr. Chaman?
HR Manager: We are facing lots of trust deficit between the employees. How can we build a culture where everyone understands their differences and respect them?
OD Consultant: Why not use the DISC assessment? It helps in understanding other personality types, fostering trust-based relationships, better conflict management, give and receive feedback and make robust decisions by valuing and capitalizing on differences all of which leads to higher employee engagement and increased productivity. HR Manager: Thats very exciting, cant we implement this in our entire system?
OD Consultant: Yes, why not. Though it will be a big investment in terms of time and effort but will help significantly in the long term, also building meaningful conversations during the performance appraisal.
Scene 2: The meeting between the leadership team at FIAT India and OD consultant and HR Manager.
Narrator: The OD consultant and HR Manager armed with a presentation on all their well thought out interventions decided to meet the leadership team at FIAT India. For any successful OD intervention the buy-in of the top management is of utmost importance and hence they decided to have this meeting before any communication to the employees. Here is our leader, Mr. 100 Sawal, talking to Seedha Chaman and Ulti Khopadi.
Leader (Mr. 100 Sawal): Wasnt that a good presentation? Should we not give green signal from our side? But what support do you want from us, Seedha Chaman and Ulti Khopadi?
HR Manger: Sir, We need a formal communication in the form of an email to the employees about what changes are going to take place and how important it is for FIAT in the coming times.
OD Manager: Its an important cultural change and your involvement is must, Mr. 100 Sawal. We would like you to take part in some of the training programs and help us drive the change by being an active part of it.
Narrator: A lot of communication took place around the changes that were approaching FIAL. Town hall meetings, mailers, and video clips were sent to all the stakeholders. All the while the Leadership team showed its presence in one way or the other. Scene 3: DISC assessment and Training Sessions Narrator: September 30 th was chosen to carry out an online DISC assessment for all employees. It was clearly conveyed that the DISC assessment results were in no way going to affect the career of the employee but would be used for designing the training and feedback sessions. There were a series of Training sessions held in FIAL over a period of 6 months. The 1 st training was on the meaning of a DISC personality test. All the employees were asked to attend this. Here is the trainer, Har Sawal ka Jawab.
Trainer (Har sawal ka jawab): So we now know about the 4 personalities, their strengths and weakness and how your personality may change depending on the situation and day. And remember that for an organization to survive each personality type plays a crucial role. We have the Dominant who are direct, outspoken, results-oriented, Influencing who are friendly, outgoing, talkative, optimistic, Steady who are team player, stable, consistent, maintains the status quo, peacemaker, Compliant who are logical, organized, data-driven, detail- oriented
Narrator: Organizations use a variety of methods to give feedback, such as manager assessment of performance and 360-degree feedback. In almost all organizations, these methods focus on a review of past events, and constructive criticism on how the employee might have done things better. The raters in FIAL were given a feedback training session.
Trainer (Har sawal ka jawab): Formal feedback, despite a managers best intentions, often feels like judgment and criticism. The most effective feedback focuses not on what went wrong in the past, but on what can go right in the future. We need to start giving our employees a continuous and forward looking feedback regularly before the actual appraisal. Now lets look at how a Manager can give a feedback to an influencing personality through a role play. May I have some volunteers please ? (Call Ms. Madhura Bedarkar and Kingshuk Nag)
Narrator: A similar session was also given to the managers on how to handle appraisal conversations. Finally another set of trainings were held on helping leaders understand the essence of a 360 degree appraisal system. While lots of videos on 180 degree appraisal process were shared on the company portal for the employees not a part of the top management team. A special portal and Q&A sessions were held for employees to ask their questions. During these 6 months a lot of automation took place and the entire PMS process was shifted online. Now people received their bonuses much more quickly and on time. Within 1 years time FIAL was on its way to success. Employee engagement levels were up.