An Analysis of The Economic Impact of Medical Tourism in Zimbabwe
An Analysis of The Economic Impact of Medical Tourism in Zimbabwe
ABSTRACT
This article explores the potential impact of medical tourism on Zimbabwes economy. The Tourism Act articulates that
tourism authorities must take advantage of thriving macro-economic sectors such as education, sport, health and medical so as
to boost tourist arrivals and stimulate economic growth. The studys objectives were grounded on finding out whether medical
tourism would have a positive significance towards economic growth in Zimbabwe. Literature reviewed synchronized
Zimbabwes three tier health system with the systems theory approach. The focus of the study investigated the economic
impact of medical tourism in Zimbabwe. Both qualitative and quantitative research methodologies were used. Data analysis
and interpretation was based on information derived from 45 respondents comprised of 15 medical doctors, 15 traditional
healers and 15 apostolic faith healers who were interviewed or responded to the questionnaires. A key finding was that
notwithstanding the risks involved, medical tourism can create employment, increase foreign currency and income, improve
the standard of living and pressurise destinations to upgrade infrastructure and technology.
1. INTRODUCTION
Zimbabwe is a landlocked nation situated in the southern region of Africa. It has plenty to offer including tourist
attraction sites, hospitals, traditional healers shrines and churches welcoming people from all over the world to
attractions customarily in Harare, Victoria Falls, Hwange and Lake Kariba. Medical Tourism is an economic activity
that entails trade in services and represents the linking of the sectors, Medical and Tourism (Bookman et al, 2007:
14). This combination of Medical and Tourism seems to be a relatively new and promising type of niche tourism
(Caballero et al, 2006). Machinga (2003) finds the Zimbabwe medical industry to be unique as it follows a three-tier
health system involving western styled hospitals, traditional healers and apostolic faith healers. The systems approach
or theory tells us that an activity of any one part of an organization affects activities of every other parts,
communication with other departments and other functional units is very important (Stoner 1982: 52). Today,
traditional healers are consulted by the people for advice and healing of many illnesses. Sometimes traditional healers
refer their patients to western medical practitioners and hospitals such as Parirenyatwa in case of emergency or illness
they cannot cure with the help of their healing spirit (www.wikipedia.org./wiki/nyanga: 31.03.2014). This reflects that
the Zimbabwean health system is a replica of the systems theory or approach. Upon receiving treatment from any one
or combined principals of the three-tier health system the patient and his accomplices have the opportunity to tour and
enjoy Zimbabwes tourism product.
1.1 Background of the study
Although traditionally medical tourists travel from less developed countries for medical treatment unavailable in their
own communities, the advocated Zimbabwean scenario calls for a reversal situation where tourists are coming from
more developed countries (www.wikipedia.org/wiki/medical-tourism.com 03.02.2014). This kind of crusade from
decidedly industrialized homelands to less affluent nation states for medical attention is motivated by the appeal to find
treatment at a lower cost with less waiting times. Medical tourists from developed countries also seek treatment
including various medical procedures in other developed countries. Canada provides medical treatment to many
Americans (Gatell, 2007). Developing countries such as South Africa, Egypt, India, Costa Rica, Malaysia, and
Thailand have benefited economically through medical tourism (www.health-traveler.com 03.02.2014). Health tourism
generated some US$40 million per year in revenues in Cuba and some US$27, 6 million in Malaysia in 2004. Each
year people from Latin America spend up to US$6 billion on medical care outside their countries. It is estimated that
India earned as much as US$2.2 billion per year from medical tourism in 2012 (Bookman et al, 2007: 16). In
comparison to South Africa, Zimbabwes neighbour, medical tourism in 2012 amplified its contribution towards the
countrys Gross Domestic Product (G.D.P) when the country increased the number of its state of the art hospitals from
161 in the year 2010 to 247 hospitals in 2012. (www.mtsaj.co.za: 20.12.2013). Medical Tourism is an economic booster
(Cannell, 2011).
Page 3
Even before the 1990s, South Africa had begun practicing medical tourism (www.mtsaj.co.za: 20.12.2013). On 3
December 1967, Doctor Christian Barnard and his team made history with the worlds first successful heart transplant
at Groote Schuur Hospital in Cape Town. Since this successful operation South Africa has been receiving large
numbers of medical tourists. Kanyenze (2012) wrote that Zimbabwe, for the period 2000-2008 experienced hyperinflation, deterioration of health standards and shortages of pills or drugs. As of 2011 to date the Zimbabwe Medical
Association (2011) notes that hospitals such as Parirenyatwa in Harare have the best Intensive Care Unit (I.C.U) in
Zimbabwe and are equally competitive in the Southern African region. They believe Harare hospital has the best
Childrens Rehabilitation Unit, whilst Chitungwiza Hospital boasts quality kidney dialysis services and Marondera
hospital offers the best training for rehabilitation technicians. Zimbabwes traditional healers are registered under the
Zimbabwe National Traditional Healers Association (ZINATHA). According to Machinga (2013) ZINATHA has more
than 45 000 traditional healers. Shoko (2014) adds Traditional healers in Zimbabwe claim that they are able to heal
illnesses categorized as conflicting with nature, are unnatural and those dogged by spiritual possession such as
HIV/AIDS, cancer, barrenness and other complex diseases. According to Shoko (2014) the World Health Organization
(W.H.O) cannot rule out cultural medicine or complimentary medicine. Again Zimbabwe just like Nigeria and Ghana
is blessed with spiritually filled Pastors and Apostolic faith healers. A Prophet of the United Family International
church (U.F.I) and another Prophet of the Prophetic Healing and Deliverance church (P.H.D) all are well known
prophetic healers regionally. A heart valve operation that might cost US$100 000 in the United States of America could
be priced well under US$10 000 in India (www.medical-tourism.org/India: 12.02.2013). The same can be said about
popular medical tourist destinations like Brazil, Costa Rica and Mexico (www.patientswithoutborders.com:
13.12.2013). Receiving treatment in a less developed country would be cheaper, even after one factors in airfare, hotel
accommodation, and travel insurance, car rentals, shopping, and dinning. Many medical vacations are substantially
more affordable than domestic health care. Against this background Zimbabwe is no exception on being ranked
amongst the best medical destinations in the world. Its a country graced with hospitals such as Parirenyatwa medical
school for University of Zimbabwe (U.Z), Mpilo (medical school for National University of Science and Technology
(N.U.S.T), Avenues, Baines, more than 45 000 registered Traditional healers and Apostolic Faith Healers. York (2008)
adds, as medical tourism becomes prevalent, education, credentialing and certification of services may be required to
help assure patient safety.
1.2 Statement of the problem
Developing economies such as South Africa, Nigeria, India, Cuba and Thailand are earning a lot from medical tourism
ventures. Zimbabwe is making minimal or no promotion of medical tourism. Its a country graced with state-of-the art
hospitals such as Parirenyatwa Hospital, the medical school for the University of Zimbabwe and Mpilo Hospital, the
medical school for the National University of Science and Technology, as well as more than 45 000 registered
Traditional and Apostolic Faith Healers.
1.3 Objectives of the study
The objectives of this study are:
To find out whether medical tourism would have a positive significance towards economic growth in Zimbabwe.
To determine the extent to which medical tourism can be used as one of the strategies for economic development in
Zimbabwe.
2.LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 What is Medical Tourism?
A tourist is a visitor who spends at least one night in the place visited and whose journey is for any one or more of the
following purposes, a holiday, recreation, health/ medical, study, religion, sport, business, meetings, visiting friends or
relatives, or work that is not remunerated from within the host country (Zimbabwe Tourism Authority, 2012). Medical
Tourism is the act of travelling to another country to obtain medical, dental or cosmetic care (www.health-traveler.com
03.02.2014). Besides receiving treatment, the medical tourists may tour or visit the countrys recreational and tourist
attractions. Bookman et al (2007: 14) adds that medical tourism is an economic activity that entails trade in services
and represents the merging of at least two sectors: Medical and Tourism. Roy (2012) also defines medical tourism as
medical travel, health tourism or global healthcare. Medical tourism is the movement of patients from highly
developed nations to other areas of the world for medical care usually to access treatment at a lower cost and with less
waiting time. Scholars of medical tourism argue that, from a theoretical point of view, medical tourists are motivated to
travel abroad by a number of factors, including the affordability of care abroad, access to treatment not available at
home, and the long waiting times for care at home. Destinations must implement unique marketing strategies so as to
attract medical tourists. Countries such as the United States have not been very successful in attracting medical tourism
business. Alyssa Morrison (December 20:2003).
Page 4
Page 5
Zimbabwe. It is comprised of a membership of over 1 000 doctors across the country consisting of different specialist
disciplines. ZIMAs activities focus on the professional and business aspects of medical practices
(www.thestandard.co.zw/12/08/2012/ab).
2.4 Zimbabwe National Traditional Healers Association (ZINATHA)
Zimbabwe National Traditional Healers Association (ZINATHA) just like ZIMA above is the sole representative of
traditional healers. It is an association comprised of over 45 000 traditional healers spread all over Zimbabwe. Its aim is
to provide professional health care services to all walks of life. It is a voluntary and an independent body. Morris (2010:
45) argued that Lithuania is popular with medical tourists for its services of cosmetic surgery and eye surgery. Hence,
this paper suggests that Zimbabwe must also be popular with medical tourists because of its unique medical service,
traditional and herbal medical services.
3.METHODOLOGY
The researcher employed the descriptive survey design involving gathering data from a sample comprising 15 doctors
at Parirenyatwa hospital, 15 Traditional Healers and 15 apostolic faith healers all from the Harare province. The
researchers instrument for conducting the survey was mainly personal interviews. In addition the researcher observed
patients (mainly foreigners) checking in and out at Parirenyatwa hospital and at some traditional healers shrines
including attending a mega prayer and healing session. The research under study used personal interviews aided with a
questionnaire. According to Kent (1993) Personal interviews refer to a survey that gathers information through face-toface interaction with respondents. The researcher favoured personal interviews because they allowed checking and
ensuring respondents eligibility, for instance, when interviewing respondents the researcher made sure that the
respondent identified him or herself as either a doctor or traditional healer. Interviews had a higher response rate than
other instruments.
4.RESULTS
4.1 Gender category
Table 1 below illustrates the gender categories of doctors, traditional healers and apostolic faith
healers.
Table 1: Gender categories of Parirenyatwa doctors, traditional healers and apostolic faith healers.
Gender
Parirenyatwa
Traditional
Apostolic Faith Row Total
Row
Category
Doctors
Healers
Healers
Percentage %
Male
9
9
10
28
62.3
Female
6
6
5
17
37.7
Column
15
15
15
45
100
Total
Page 6
and experienced in their medical field, a professional qualification reveals the potential ability to cure and provide
quality patient care to a medical tourist.
Table 2: Professional qualifications of doctors, traditional healers and apostolic faith healers.
Professional
Parirenyatwa Traditional Apostolic Faith Row
Row
Qualification
Doctors
Healers
Healers
Total
Percentage
%
Higher degree 1
0
0
1
2.2
(PhDs)
Masters
1
0
2
3
6.7
Bachelors
13
0
3
16
35.5
Diploma
0
3
4
7
15.5
Other
0
12
6
18
40
Total
15
15
15
45
100
Table 2 above shows 2.2% of the total population are doctorate (PhD) degree holders. 6.7% are masters degree
holders, 35.6% are bachelors degree holders, 15.5% are diploma holders and 40% mostly traditional healers possess
other qualifications. The research study found out that the majority of traditional healers fall into the Other category,
possessing certificates, Advanced level certificates, Ordinary level certificates, Standard 6 and Standard 3 certificates.
The results revealed that the doctors had the required medical qualifications. However, the qualifications of the doctors,
traditional healers and apostolic faith healers happen to be the basic requirements to stimulate an effective medical
tourism service in Zimbabwe.
4.3 Experience
Table 3 below shows the period of service served by Parirenyatwa doctors, traditional healers and apostolic faith healers
in the health industry. The period of service shows depth of knowledge and experience pertaining to medical tourism
and medical services.
Table 3: Experience of Parirenyatwa doctors, traditional healers and apostolic faith healers.
Experience Parirenyatwa
Traditional
Apostolic Faith Row Total
Row
(Years)
Doctors
healers
Healers
Percentage %
1-5
13
1
2
16
35.5
6-10
0
5
7
12
26.6
11-15
1
0
2
3
6.6
16-20
1
4
4
9
20
21- above
0
5
0
5
11.1
Total
15
15
15
15
100
Results exposed on Table 3, display that 35.5% of the population possess 1-5 years working experience in the health
industry. The majority of doctors are clustered in the 1-5 years working experience. The doctors experience is an equal
representation of age as 26.6% of the total population falls in the 6-10 years working experience. 6.6% in the 11-15
years, 20% in the 16-20 years and 11.1% in the 21 and above working experience. Traditional healers experience is
also an equal representation of age. Thus maturity is apparent. Sheen (1998) argued that mature employees are better
able to understand clientele needs and execute work more professionally.
4.4 Medical services rendered to local Zimbabwean patients
The pie chart below shows the responses made by Parirenyatwa doctors, traditional healers, and apostolic faith healers
to the question whether or not they render services to the local Zimbabwean patients.
DOCTORS
TRADITIONAL HEALERS
Page 7
Pie chart 1 indicates that 100% of the doctors, traditional healers and apostolic faith healers agreed that they render
medical services to local Zimbabwean patients. Evidently, if Zimbabwean doctors, traditional healers and apostolic
faith healers are satisfactorily rendering services to locals then, this must pave way in rendering services to foreign
patients.
Apostolic
faith healers
5
8
0
1
1
15
Row
Total
22
19
2
1
1
45
Row
Percentage %
48.8
42.2
4.4
2.2
2.2
100
The table shows that 48.8% of the population strongly agreed that they had received and treated foreign patients. 42.2%
agreed to having rendered medical services to foreign patients. 2.2% disagreed to having rendered medical services to
foreign patients. 2.2% strongly disagreed to having received and treated foreign patients.
4.6 Positive or negative contribution of medical tourism on the destinations Gross Domestic
Product
Table 5 below shows the respondents views on whether medical tourism impacts positively or negatively on Gross
Domestic Product levels in Zimbabwe.
Table 5 Medical tourism contribution towards Zimbabwes Gross Domestic Product (GDP) levels.
Row
Frequency
Parirenyatwa
Traditional
Apostolic
Row
Percentage %
distribution
Doctors
Healers
Faith Healers Total
Strongly Agree
6
1
6
13
28.8
Agree
7
14
6
27
60.0
Neutral
2
0
3
5
11.1
Disagree
0
0
0
0
0
Strongly disagree
0
0
0
0
0
Column Total
15
15
15
45
100
The table 5 illustrates that at least doctors, traditional healers and apostolic faith healers are satisfied that medical
tourism can contribute positively towards Zimbabwes Gross Domestic Product levels. 28.8% of the population
interviewed strongly agreed that medical tourism can contribute positively towards gross domestic product levels. 60%
agreed and 11.1% where neutral to whether medical tourism can contribute towards Zimbabwes gross domestic
product levels.
The results show that there was a significant relationship between medical tourism and economic growth in Zimbabwe.
What is needed is to find means and ways to implement it, both for Zimbabwes domestic and international medical
tourists.
4.7 Medical tourism can help the Reserve Bank increase its foreign currency reserves.
Table 6 shows an overall analysis of respondents who aired different views pertaining to whether or not medical
tourism can help the Reserve bank increase its foreign currency reserves.
Page 8
Table 6: Medical tourism helping the Reserve bank increase its foreign currency reserves
Responses
Parirenyatwa
Traditional
Apostolic Faith Row Total
Doctors
healers
Healers
Strongly
Agree
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
Column
Total
14
Row
Percentage
%
31.1
4
4
0
0
7
2
1
0
12
2
0
0
23
8
1
0
51.1
17.7
2.2
0
15
15
15
45
100
4.8 Need to improve infrastructure and technology so to certify Zimbabwe as a medical tourist
destination.
Graph 2:
Graph 2: Need to improve infrastructure and technology
Graph 2 above shows 71.1% of the total population strongly agreeing to that there is a need for medical and health
facilities improvement. 28.9% agreed to a need for medical and health facilities improvement so as to certify Zimbabwe
as a medical tourist destination. Hence, there is a need to upgrade medical facilities and technology so as to certify
Zimbabwe as a medical tourist destination.
2. DISCUSSION / ANALYSIS
5.1 Advantages of medical tourism to Zimbabwe
The results from the interviews clearly show that medical tourism can boost Zimbabwes economy through earning
foreign currency, creating employment and contributing positively towards the Gross Domestic Product levels. Medical
staff would be motivated to work hard, research more and become more innovative. Tourism staff would be motivated
to work hard and market Zimbabwe as a favourable medical tourist destination. Local authorities would be inspired to
continuously improve the countrys infrastructure and technology. An example would be for instance a need to renovate
and refurbish traditional healers stands at Mbare Musika, a need to cut grass around hospitals and ensure adequate
water and electricity supply in hospitals, churches, and shrines. Training and better health and tourism education would
be provided. Out of concern for the safety of their patients, some doctors, traditional healers and apostolic faith healers
said that medical tourism carries some risks such as malaria and HIV/AIDS. Results display that in terms of
qualifications all principals have the basic education qualifications. They are all literate. Some apostolic faith healers
even possess Masters degrees from the University of Zimbabwe and Zimbabwe Open University. Traditional healers
had the basic educational qualification and a deeper knowledge of herbs, spiritual world and tourism.
Parirenyatwa doctors, traditional healers and apostolic faith healers were positive in that they are receiving and treating
domestic and foreign patients. At least traditional healers and apostolic faith healers answered that they are receiving
and treating regional and international tourists. The research study found out there is a need to lure more domestic,
Page 9
regional and international medical tourists so that Zimbabwe would realize positive medical tourism contributions
towards the economy.
The results also showed that medical tourism can contribute positively towards Zimbabwes economy but there is need
to improve health and medical infrastructure and technology. There is also need to improve on hospital / medical
service centres, patients waiting times and planning by Zimbabwes tourism and health authorities.
Results indicated that apostolic faith healers mostly Pentecostal and traditional healers registered under ZINATHA,
have the power to cure diseases including sexually transmitted diseases (STDs) such as Herpes, reduce HIV/AIDS
symptoms, cancer, headaches, stomach pains, back pains, barrenness, and high blood pressure. The respondents
highlighted that some foreign patients favoured Zimbabwes medical service centres because of affordability, good
waiting times, powerful strong medicines, qualified, experienced, good customer service, and mature personnel.
Shoko (2014) highlighted that the World Health Organization cannot rule out cultural medicine or complimentary
medicine. China uses complimentary medicine called Tiyashe. Zimbabwe uses complimentary medicine supplied
mostly by traditional healers and herbalists. Shoko (2014) brought out that local doctors have discovered a powerful
herb called Ngudamiti that reverses the HIV/AIDS symptoms. He adds that some of the powerful herbs used by
traditional healers and herbalists are Chafifixe (to fix simple illness), Muringa, Musimboti (immune system), ginger
(stomach), Mubvamaropa (Blood pressure and blood system) and Vhuka vhuka (powerful sexual drive). Respondents
identified some traditional healthy foods that help boost the immune system as sorghum, millet, rapoko, sweet potatoes,
water melons and maheu.
3. CONCLUSION
Literature reviewed integrated Zimbabwes three tier health system with the systems theory / approach. Respondents
however, argued that medical tourists are motivated to travel abroad by a number of factors, including the affordability
of care abroad, and access to treatment not available at home, together with good waiting times for care at home.
Respondents maintained that medical tourism can create employment and boost standards of living. It can aid in
improving health infrastructure and technology in hospitals such as Parirenyatwa, Harare hospital, Mpilo and Avenues
hospitals. They reiterated that attractive medical and tourism policies and unique marketing strategies need to be put in
place in order to attract medical visitors. The study however laments that medical tourism carries security risks as well
as legal and ethical issues.
REFERENCES
[1] Best, J.W. and Kahn, J.V. (1993). Research in Education, New York: Allyn and Bacon.
[2] Bookman, M. Z. and K. R. Bookman. (2007). Medical tourism in developing Countries. Palgrave MacMillan:
New York.Campbell, R., McConnell. And Stanley, L.B., (2002), Economics. 5th Edition., McGraw-Hill.,
North America.
[3] Cohen, L. and Manion, L. (1994), Research Methods in Education. London. Rutledge.
[4] Crossby, M. and Vulliamy, G. (1984), Case Study, Research Methods and Comperative Education. Port
Meresby. University of Papua.
[5] Christopher Holloway, J. (1998), The Business of Tourism. 5th Edition, Longman, Singapore.
[6] Elsevier. (2013). Tourism Management. Volume 34
[7] Gunn. A.C. (1994).Tourism Planning: Basics, Concepts, Cases. 3rd Edition, Taylor and Francis, Bristol.
[8] Harrison. D. (1995) Tourism and The Less Developed Countries. John Wiley and Sons Ltd, Singapore.
[9] John. B (2000). Stats to Go- Hospitality, Leisure, and Tourism. Butterworth Heinemann.
[10] Kenan Kalagho. (4 September 2012), Environment Assessment Business.
Page 10
Page 11