Lake Basin - Final.mbagara
Lake Basin - Final.mbagara
Lake Basin - Final.mbagara
Economic Blueprint
A better life
Supported by:
Contents
3.1.5
3.2
1 Introduction
1.1
Vision 2030 and Development
1.2
The Lake Basin Economic Blueprint (LREB)
1.3
Approach and Methodology of the Blueprint
1.4
Structure of the Blueprint
10
10
11
12
12
13
13
13
13
14
26
16
16
16
20
21
26
27
27
28
32
36
37
37
38
38
38
40
41
44
45
46
46
48
49
53
54
54
54
55
55
56
5.2
56
56
57
59
60
60
60
62
63
63
67
68
68
68
68
68
69
69
69
69
71
71
71
71
72
72
72
73
74
74
75
75
75
75
75
76
79
79
79
79
79
80
81
8 Conclusion
82
9 Addendum
83
10 References
84
Contacts
Acronyms and
Abbreviations
ADSL
AIDS
CBD
CBK
CIDP
COMESA
ECDE
EDGE
FTTX
GDP
GER
GOK
HIV
ICT
IDP
IFMIS
KARI
KDHS
KEMSA
KIHBS
KWH
LBEBP
LBR
LVKTC
MT
MTP
NER
NGO
PGA
PPP
SACCO
SADC
SONY
TTC
UNDP
Executive
Education
Less than 50 per cent of the population in the Lake
Region have access to Early Childhood Education and
Development (ECDE) services. At the primary level, the
Gross Enrolment Ratio, which refers to the share of
children of any age that are enrolled in primary school,
is high. However the Net Enrolment Ratio which is the
share of children of official primary school age that are
enrolled in primary school is on average 75-80per cent.
Enrolment in secondary level education is on average
below 40per cent in all the counties; the national
target is 70per cent. Tertiary education enrolment is
very low and this component of the education system
in the region is poorly developed. The quality of
education services in the region is subpar.
Proposed Flagship Project for Education: Creation of
Centres of Excellence in each county.
Financial Services
The Lake Region hosts major banks in Kenya such
as Kenya Commercial Bank, Barclays Bank, Equity
Bank; however access to banking services remains
clustered in urbanised areas and there is limited access
to appropriate business advisory services. There are
numerous Savings and Credit Cooperatives but saving
rates in the region are low.
Proposed flagship project for Financial Services:
Creation of a Regional Bank.
Opportunity
Counties
Agriculture
Tourism
All
Education
Centres of Excellence
Schools for children with disabilities
Satellite Campuses
Research Labs
Regional Scholarship Program
All
Health
All
Financial Services
Regional Bank
All
ICT
All
Infrastructure
All
1. Introduction
10
11
13
15
3. Productive Sectors:
Agriculture and Tourism
3.1 Agriculture
Agriculture is a key sector of the Kenyan economy and
employs the largest number of Kenyans in a single
sector. Agricultural activities include food and cash
crop farming, livestock farming as well as fishing and
aquaculture. Under the new constitution agriculture
functions are devolved and county governments can
leverage public-private partnerships (PPPs) to enhance
agricultural production and productivity. Statistics
indicate that the agricultural sector directly accounts for
about 26 per cent of Kenyas GDP (Herrero, 2010). The
sector accounts for 65 per cent of Kenyas total exports,
and 18 per cent and 60 per cent of the formal and
total employment, respectively (KIPPRA, 2013).
3.1.1
The State of Agriculture in the Lake
Region
The Lake Basin region has the advantageous
environmental features of arable land, good soil, and
consistent water supply from rain as well as several rivers
and lakes. These features have formed the foundation
on which residents have relied on for generations. In the
past these features were adequate to ensure the food
security of the region, however over the past 50 years
Kenyas population, and that of the Lake Basin region in
particular, has grown to a point where existing farming
practices and food supply chains do not meet current
food security needs.
The main farming practices in the region include
small-scale rain-fed farming, small-scale river irrigation,
wetland farming, fish farming and free-range livestock
keeping.
Crop Farming
Key crops farmed in the region are divided into cash
crops and food crops. Key cash crops are sugarcane
tea, pyrethrum and cotton; key food crops are maize,
rice, and beans, and horticultural crops such as passion
fruits, mangoes, and tomatoes. Clear opportunities exist
to enhance the productivity of these crops particularly
sorghum, soy beans and sugar due to the demand
for these crops at national level. The table below is an
illustration of the major food and cash crops.
16
Sugarcane
Sugarcane is an important cash crop for the Lake
Region as the sugar industry is a major employer of rural
populations and client to rural farmers in the region.
Sugarcane contributes an estimated 15 per cent to the
agriculture GDP, and that production is dominated by
the Lake Region. Approximately 250,000 small-scale
farmers predominantly from the Lake Region operate
in the sugar industry and supply over 92 per cent of
the cane milled by sugar processing companies (Kenya
Sugar Board, 2010). Further, according to the Kenya
Sugar Board, the industry directly and indirectly employs
approximately six million Kenyans (Kenya Sugar Board,
2010). A study conducted in Nyando zone of Nyanza,
indicated that that over 97 per cent of farmers in the
area are involved in sugarcane agriculture and derive
about 81per cent of their household income from
it. Kakamega County is also an important player in
the sugar industry and hosts one of Kenyas largest
sugarcane processing firms, Mumias Sugar Company.
The sugarcane industry has additional economic impact
due to its contribution to Kenya foreign exchange
through exports as well as providing inputs into other
industries. According to the Kenyan Sugar Board, the
industry saves Kenya over USD250 million in foreign
exchange annually and contributes tax revenues to
the Exchequer (VAT, Corporate Tax, personal income
taxes) (Kenya Sugar Board, 2010). The industry also
provides inputs to other industries such as bagasse for
power generation and molasses for the manufacture
of industrial products such as ethanol, beverages,
pharmaceuticals, and confectionery. The production
potential of the industry is measured at over 1 million
tons of sugar if operated at 89 per cent of industry
capacity. In terms of challenges, the industry struggles
with inefficiencies in both production and the processing
value chains.
Soybeans
The Lake Region accounts for over 50 per cent of
soybean production in Kenya. The main soybean
producing counties are Busia, Bungoma, Kakamega, and
Vihiga. Busia and Bungoma alone produce an estimated
80 per cent of the total soybean production in the
Western province of Kenya.
Annually Kenya consumes 400,000 Metric Tonnes (MT)
of vegetable oils of which soybeans are constituents.
Only one third of this amount is produced locally. Animal
feed use of vegetable oil is 150,000; this combined with
human domestic consumption of vegetable oil indicate
ample opportunity to increased soybean production to
meet existing demand.
Sorghum
Sorghum is a staple food crop for most low income
households in Kenya, Lake Region included. According
to the Food and Agricultural Organization (FAO),
sorghum is the only indigenous crop in the region,
and can grow in many areas including those with
low-agricultural potential (FAO, 2013). Sorghum is also
widely grown in Lake Basin region (see Figure 3). The
production of sorghum fluctuates in that although
production increased by 40 per cent over the past 5
years, there was a 17per cent decrease in production
between 2012 and 2013.
17
Figure 4: Regional per cent contribution of production and crop area of Sorghum
18
19
Fish Farming
Lake Victoria accounts for about 96 per cent of Kenyas
total fish production. However, pollution and overfishing
is threatening fish stocks and its economic contribution
to the Lake Region. The Lake Victoria Fisheries
Organization (LVFO) states a 55 per cent decline of Nile
Perch in Lake Victoria between 2005 and 2008, and a
9 per cent drop in tilapia catch over the same period
(LVFO). The declining stock has had the domino effect
of a twofold increase in consumer fish prices squeezing
out affordability of fish for some households which then
decreases household income for fish farmers who meet
lower demand due to higher pricing.
Lake Victoria is relatively shallow, with a maximum
depth of 84m and mean depth of 40m, which makes
it susceptible to pollution. Already densely populated,
the population around the Lake is expected to double
by 2028. High population influences increased pollution
from raw waster deposited in wetlands, and the
uncontrolled spread of homes, factories, farms and
hospitals around the basin exacerbate pollution. In
addition, fishermen operating in regions use insecticides
such as endosulfan to catch small fish. All these factors
exert negative pressure on the Lake.
Despite these challenges, the Lake Region still carries
significant further potential for fish farming through its
current water bodies, particularly Lake Victoria, riverine
fisheries and through inland fish farming development.
The fishing sector in Kenya serves as an important
source of food and employment, providing over 50,000
fishermen with a source of livelihood.
3.1.2
Key Agricultural Challenges in the Lake
Region
Declining yields
A key challenge with regards to farming is declining yield
per hectare and the lowering quality of yields. This is
attributed to small farmland size holdings, use of poor
farming methods and the lack of legal title deeds which
then impedes possibilities of farmers getting access to
credit. Interestingly, in certain counties such as Migori
County the problem is the under-utilisation of large
tracts of fertile land. Additional challenges include the
lack of education and agricultural extension services,
as well as the failure to manage the effects of
climate change. All these factors contribute to the
sectors
declining contribution to national development, regional
development, and the food security in the Lake Region.
20
3.1.3
Economic Opportunities in the
Agriculture Sector
Despite the challenges, the Lake Region offers numerous
opportunities for expansion and diversification in crop,
livestock and fish farming. The County Integrated
Development Plans as well as the results from the field
visits note the following opportunities:
Flagship Project: Creation of a Commodities
Exchange
Skills development and training on improved farm
management
High Value Crop Farming: Particularly soya beans,
sorghum, floriculture and horticulture
Fish farming
Large Scale Irrigation
Agro Processing and Value Addition
High Value Crop Farming
21
Fish Farming
The long term sustainability of current fishing output
in Lake Basin is not guaranteed because of overfishing
and pollution. Sustainable practices in fish farming can
result in greater yields and variety of fish from the region
and improve income generation of fishing communities.
Proposed activities in which the region can invest are
detailed below.
Table 2: Proposed Fish Farming Activities in Lake Basin region
Activity
Description of project/intervention
Expected impact
Animal feed plants can use waste from fish fillet Reduces wastage of fish farming by-products
production for animal feed as well production of
fish meal, fish oil and fish skins.
22
Agro-Processing
Kenya imports approximately KES 12 billion worth of
edible oil alone per year. The Lake Region can establish
new agro-processing factories and invest in the
improvement of existing factories. The region is still a
net exporter of unprocessed produce and an importer of
finished products. Bolstering agro-processing industries
will clearly reduce the cost of imports and enable the
region to meet the national and export demand of
finished products. Illustrative processing projects are
summarized below.
Table 3: Illustrative Agro-Processing Projects in the Lake Region
Project
Description
Establish a factory that processes sunflower, cotton, soy bean and groundnuts
into edible oil.
Sugarcane Processing
Complete the process of production and add value to the farm produce to be
sold in markets
Milk Factory
23
Spotlight on Sugarcane
Sugar Processing Factories
At the moment, opportunities exist for investment in privatized state-owned sugar processing factories as well the
construction of new ones. State owned factories in the Lake Region are the South Nyanza Sugar Company (Sony
Sugar) in Migori County, Muhoroni Sugar in Migori and Kisumu Counties. The government of Kenya announced
interest in privatizing these factories after reporting total losses of KSH 6.1 billion in June 2013. Therefore,
opportunities exist for the county to engage private actors in reviving sugar processing factories.
The aforementioned factories are significant employers with plans for improving production. The South Nyanza
factory employs at least 1,800 and plans to increase sugar production by 20per cent to 60,000 tons in 2015. The
company also has plans to diversify its products into processing jiggery, molasses, and sugar syrups. The factory is in
discussions with Cooperative Bank, KCB, and Barclays Bank to receive at least KSH 1 billion to support the renovation
of factory and product diversification.
Energy
Opportunities exist in the region for biogas production from sugarcane. For example, Kisumu that has a potential to
generate between 400600 GWh of electricity per year (approximately 711 percent of total Kenyan demand) using
bagasse (by-product from current sugarcane production). The region also has a potential to produce 20 200 million
litres for power/industrial application of the region.
Agricultural Opportunities
Bungoma
Food crop farming (maize, beans, finger millet, sweet potatoes, bananas, Irish potatoes and
assorted vegetables)
Cash crop farming (sugar cane, cotton, palm oil, coffee, sun flower, tobacco)
Livestock farming (cattle, sheep, goats, donkeys, pigs, poultry)
Bee keeping
Fish farming in fish ponds and dams
Agroforestry ( apiary systems, aquaculture, biomass transfer, boundary planting, fallows, fodder
banks, orchards, hedgerow/alley cropping, home gardens, live fences, ornamental planting
sericulture, terrace stabilization, trees on cropland, woodlots)
Homa Bay
Food crop farming (maize, beans, sorghum, millet, kale, sweet potatoes and peas)
Cash crop farming: Sugar cane in Ndhiwa, sun flower growing in Suba, pineapples in Rangwe
and potatoes in Kasipul and Kabondo Kasipul
Livestock farming
Fish farming
Cotton farming in Mbita, Homa Bay Town, Rangwe and Karachuonyo Sub-counties
Kisii
Food crop farming (maize, bananas, beans, potatoes, tea, sugarcane, coffee and horticultural
crops)
Livestock farming
Fish farming
Cash crop farming (bananas)
Tree seedling production
24
County
Agricultural Opportunities
Kisumu
Siaya
Vihiga
Busia
Food crop farming (maize, cassava, finger millet, beans, sorghum, rice, sweet potatoes, cowpeas, groundnuts, bananas,
green grams, sesame, soya beans)
Horticulture farming (pineapples, tomatoes, kale, cabbage, water melons, indigenous vegetables, papaya, amaranth, onions
and, mangoes)
Cash crop farming (cotton, tobacco, sugarcane, oil palm, and pepper)
Fishing in Budalangi and Funyula
Promotion of oil crops, root tubers, indigenous vegetables, tissue culture
Migori
Food crop farming (maize, sorghum, beans, cassava, finger millet and sweet potatoes)
Cash crop farming (tobacco, sugarcane, potatoes (Kuria) and maize (Kuria))
Sunflower and Sisal farming in Nyatike sub-county
Irrigation schemes along the rivers
Livestock farming (traditional breeds such as the Zebu cattle, East African goat, indigenous chicken and bee)
Accelerated Bamboo Farming and Utilization Project in Suba East
Increase area under rice farming in Uriri, Rongo, Migori, Kuria West & Awendo sub counties
Nyamira
25
County
Kakamega
Agricultural Opportunities
Food crop farming (maize, beans, cassava, finger millet, sweet potatoes, bananas, tomatoes, tea
and sorghum) maize and beans are usually grown on large scale.
Cash crop farming (maize, tea and sugarcane)
Livestock farming ( cattle, chicken, goats, pigs)
Forest farming in Lugari Constituency
Fish Farming
3.1.4
Resource Mobilization Strategy
The Resource Mobilization Strategy for the Agriculture
sector in the Lake Region requires a three pronged
approach i.e. Public Sector Financing, Private Sector
Investment and Public-Private Partnerships:
Public Sector Financing
The County Governments in the Lake Region have
budgets for various agriculture projects. However, it
is clear this funding is limited and cannot fund both
development and recurrent costs of the sector. The
blueprint proposes a regional pooling of funds by the
county governments to support agriculture. A flagship
project that would be financed by pooled funds is the
Agricultural Commodities Exchange.
Private Sector Financing
Private investment is key to agricultural development,
but is currently limited. While public investment is
necessary to create the infrastructure and environment
for agricultural investment, a large proportion of
the required capital is often made by private actors. In
order to boost private investment in agriculture,
incentives must be provided and constraints minimised.
The blueprint proposes the following types of private
investment:
Foreign Direct Investment;
Guarantees Agricultural Lending: These can be
supported by private sector as well as donor
funding. Similar existing funds that provide
guarantees include the Africa Agriculture Trade and
Investment Fund;
Public Warehousing System;
Collateral Management; and
Diaspora Remittances.
Public-Private Partnerships
There are several innovative ways to stimulate private
sector investments in rural infrastructure. The blueprint
proposes PPPs that leverage funds from the private
sector to invest in agricultural infrastructure or services
26
3.2 Tourism
The tourism industry has been a critical contributor in
Kenyas economic growth. In 2014 the sector contributed 10 percent to GDP, was the 2nd highest foreign
exchange earner and accounts for 11 percent of total
employment (Ministry of East Africa, Commerce and
Tourism). Kenyas main tourist appeal is found in the
countrys natural features, the safari experience as well
as beach attractions. Traditional tourist attractions have
become routine thereby providing an opportunity for
the creation of non-traditional attractions unique to the
Lake Region. Kenyas Vision 2030 identifies tourism as
one of the sectors poised to make significant contributions to the socioeconomic growth of the country.
This mandate however, will require efforts to address
constraints facing the sector such as declining tourist
numbers due to security threats posed to Kenya by Islamic militant groups. It is important for the Lake Region
to be part of the conversation around how to overcome
the challenges the sector faces, improve the quality of
Kenyas tourist offerings and above all market itself as a
new tourist destination and experience.
3.2.1
The State of the Western Kenya Tourism
Circuit
Although still relatively unknown the Lake Region
tourism sector, commonly known as the Western Kenya
Tourism Circuit, is growing particularly through private
tours that focus on tourists seeking novel experiences
that have a direct socio-economic impact to the communities. The Western Kenya Tourism Circuit is, a new
concept of tourism that seeks to move away from game
safaris. Beach visits and partying that has taken root in
Kisumu and is fast extending to other parts of western
Kenya. (Stella Chirono, Business Daily)
The Dutch Government signed a 10 year agreement
with local tour operators to market tourism activities in
14 counties of the Western Circuit including Kisumu,
Siaya, Bungoma, Migori, Kakamega, Busia, Kericho,
Vihiga and Homa Bay. According to the Kenya Bureau
of Standards (2012), the Lake Region has a total of
695 hotel rooms available with an occupancy rate of
31per cent (KEBS). Beds available stand at 958 with an
occupancy rate of 26 percent. This region is typically
been referred to as the Western Tourist Circuit although
stakeholders propose this be changed to Lake Region
Tourist Circuit.
Figure 9: Hotel Occupancy in Nyanza Province and Western Province 2006 2010
Figure 10: Number of Visitors to Attractions in Western Tourist Circuit 2006 2010
Source:
Economic Survey 2011
The Lake Region Economic Blueprint
27
3.2.2
Current Attractions
The Lake Region hosts a wide range of tourist
attractions with landscapes that range from lush
green highlands and tropical forests to lake beaches
and islands. Tourist attractions of the Lake Region are
categorised as follows in this Blueprint: Nature and
Wildlife, Culture, Heritage and Community-Based
Tourism, Adventure, Agro-tourism, Eco-tourism, Water
Sports Tourism, and Health and Wellness Tourism.
Table 5: Existing Tourism Activities in the Lake Victoria Region
Category
Name Of Activity
Attractions
Comments
Minimally established
Minimally established
Adventure
Sugarcane Plantations,
Rice Fields, Tea and Coffee
Farms, Eco-lodges etc.
Highly established
Minimally established
28
Adventure
Adventure tourism involves exploration or travel to
remote areas and includes activities such as hiking and
mountaineering, trekking, rafting and rock climbing. The
Lake Regions has multiple attractions such as the falls
previously mentioned, Yala swamp and Manga ridge.
29
Category
Attractions
County
State Of Use
Kakamega Forest
Kakamega
Highly utilized
Homa Bay
Moderately utilized
Kisumu
Minimally utilized
Bungoma
Moderately utilized
Homa Bay
Minimally utilized
Homa Bay
Minimally utilized
Homa Bay
Minimally utilized
Homa Bay
Minimally utilized
Dunga wetlands
Kisumu
Minimally utilized
10
Kusa wetlands
Kisumu
Minimally utilized
11
Nyando wetlands
Kisumu
Minimally utilized
12
Odino Falls
Kisumu
Minimally utilized
13
Gogo Falls
Migori
Minimally utilized
14
Webuye Falls
Bungoma
Dismally utilized
15
Manga Escarpment
Nyamira
Minimally utilized
16
Kisumu
Moderately utilized
17
Homa Bay
Minimally utilized
Category
Attractions
County
State Of Use
Kisumu Museum
Kisumu
Moderately utilized
Kit Mikayi
Obama Kogelo Cultural heritage.
Abindu Cultural site
Kisumu
Siaya
Kisumu
Minimally utilized
Moderately utilized
Moderately utilized
Got Ramogi
Siaya
Minimally utilized
Migori
Minimally utilized
Minimally utilized
Homa Bay
Minimally utilized
Bungoma
Minimally utilized
Busia
Minimally utilized
Vihiga
Minimally utilized
10
Siaya
Minimally utilized
11
Bungoma
Minimally utilized
12
Chetambe Ruins
Bungoma
Minimally utilized
13
Siaya
Minimally utilized
14
Homa Bay
Minimally utilized
15
Siaya
Minimally utilized
16
Bungoma
Minimally utilized
30
Category
Attractions
County
State Of Use
Adventure
Lake Victoria
Kakamega Forest
Kakamega
Moderately utilized
Got Ramogi
Siaya
Minimally utilized
Yala Swamp
Siaya
Minimally utilized
Homa Bay
Minimally utilized
Manga Ridge
Nyamira
Minimally utilized
Homa Hills
Homa Bay
Minimally utilized
Plantations
Minimally utilized
Odino Falls
Kisumu
Minimally utilized
10
Gogo Falls
Migori
Minmally utilized
11
Webuye Falls
Bungoma
Minimally utilized
12
Homa Bay
Minimally utilized
Moderately utilized
Category
Attractions
County
State Of Use
Sugarcane Plantations
Minimally utilized
Minimally utilized
Minimally utilized
Eco-lodges
Ndunga wetlands
Minimally utilized
Category
Attractions
County
State Of Use
Homa Bay
Minimally utilized
Lake Victoria
Minimally utilized
Minimally utilized
31
3.2.3
Opportunities and Prospective Projects
for Tourism in the Lake Region
The Lake Region has clear potential for becoming an
attractive tourism site in the country but there is a clear
need to take measures to develop the industry. Existing
tourist attractions are underdeveloped and underutilized
and this need to be addressed urgently. This section
proposes key projects unlock the regions potential in a
manner that bolsters the socio-economic development
of the region.
At the macro-level the following tourism related projects
are planned:
Flagship project: Development of a Lake Region
Tourism Circuit
Development of high-end hotel and Conference
facilities in each of the 10 Counties;
Development of Community-Based Tourism activities
and attractions at selected sites in each of the 10
Counties;
Development of a 3-Star 100-Bed capacity tourist
lodge at Thimlich Ohinga Cultural Landscape;
Marketing Initiatives to enhance visibility of the Lake
Region Tourism Circuit;
Development of Wildlife Conservancies to promote
tourism and solve wildlife-human conflict;
Establishment of standards for tourism products and
services in the Lake Region Tourist Circuit; and
Development of road network within Kisumu City
for city tours targeting unique heritage facilities and
sceneries around and within the city.
32
Table 7: Summary of Investment Opportunities in the Tourism Sector in the Lake Region
County
Bungoma
Opportunities
Kisii
Kisumu
Homabay
33
County
Siaya
Opportunities
Busia
Migori
Vihiga
Nyamira
Kakamega
34
Nyamira
Kakamega
35
3.2.4
Lack of capital
The Western Tourism Circuit has not been marketed as
a tourist attraction in Kenya and therefore has not
attracted financing and is not considered an investment
destination in the sector.
Poor government support
The Lake Region is not viewed as a tourist destination
that warrants government support and investment and
thus does not feature in activities and allocations related
to tourism.
Poor infrastructure
The infrastructure within the Lake Region as well as
to and from most tourist attractions is dilapidated and
needs rehabilitation. For example, Thimlich Ohinga
Cultural Landscape does not have an adequate allweather road network.
Security Issues
These stem both from political instability and tribal
tensions as well as threats from the militant group AlShabaab.
Natural disasters
The region is often subject to flooding at various tourist
sites which creates reluctance to visit the region.
Disease and Illness
Tropical diseases such as malaria which is endemic
in the region are deterrents. Further, health scares in
neighbouring regions such as Ebola in West Africa
reduce the appeal of travel to the country.
Poor facilities
The region lacks social services such as hospitals and
most of the tourist sites are located in the remote
areas of the country far from access to medical
facilities. In terms of accommodation, the region
lacks
internationally competitive facilities. For example, Ndere
Island National Park does not have the capacity to
cater for overnight stay. 1 Kit Mikay does not even have
amenities to cater for day visitors.
36
3.2.5
Resource Mobilization Strategy
Tourism products require development, packaging
and marketing before any meaningful returns can be
realized. Thus there is a need for clear strategies for
resource mobilization to meet the required threshold
for the development of successful tourism packages in
the Lake Region. The strategy can consists of different
components as follows:
Create a Fundraising Team: Develop a fundraising
initiative tasked with capital raising responsibilities
specifically for the Lake Region.
Improve Investment Environment: Incentivise
investment into the sector.
Short term funding: Focus on national and county
government allocations for quick fixes that can get
key projects up and running as well as fund marketing
activity.
Long term funding: Develop partnerships with NGOs,
international donor organizations and private sector
resource mobilisation purposes.
3.2.6
Socioeconomic Impact of the Tourism
Sector
The following are the potential impacts of investment in
the tourism sector:
A 20% increase in tourism demand results in an
increase in real GDP of 0.1% (Njoya);
A 10% increase in tourist expenditure can lead to a
0.3% increase in rural household consumption and
in a 0.02% increase in welfare (Njoya);
10% increase in tourism results in an increase in the
domestic consumption of agricultural commodities;
tourism growth in Kenya is pro-agriculture (Njoya);
Economic activity created by tourism expansion
increases real wage rates by 0.8%.(Njoya);
Inbound tourism increases the output of agricultural
products, decreases its prices and increases
employment. (Njoya);
Tourism can serve as a powerful incentive to protect
natural resources (UNEP, 2011);
Tourism generates revenue to support conservation
and management of natural environments (UNEP,
2011); and
Tourism has larger multiplier effects, with revenue
spreading from hotel accommodation, food and
beverages, shopping, entertainment and transport
to income of hotel staff, taxi operators, shopkeepers
and suppliers of goods and services (UNEP, 2011).
37
38
4.1.1
The State of Education in the Lake
Region
The Lake Region houses some educational institutions
of past repute in the country. These include secondary
schools such as Cardinal Otunga, Homabay, Mbita,
Musingu, Kakamega, Lugulu, Butere, St, Marys Yala,
and training institutions such as Kitale Technical Training
Institute and Bukura Agricultural Training Institute. These
institutions once produced national and global leaders
but have since failed to produce high calibre graduates.
The table below summarizes the state of education in
some of the counties in the Lake Region.
Table 8: Education Levels for the 10 counties
County
None
Primary
Secondary
Total Population
Kisumu
17.7
56.9
25.4
844,752
Kakamega
20.6
60.9
18.5
1,449,141
Bungoma
17.9
60.9
21.2
1,195,784
Busia
22.7
61.8
15.5
647,461
Kisii
17.1
55.2
27.7
1,010,601
Nyamira
16.1
53.6
30.3
528,317
Siaya
20.5
63.8
15.7
736,992
Migori
20.3
64.6
15.2
786,472
Homa Bay
Vihiga
19.8
17.6
62.9
62.8
17.3
19.6
836,555
491,499
Source: Exploring Kenyas Inequality National Report (KNBS & SID), 2014
In the data recorded in Exploring Kenyas Inequality
compiled by Kenya National Bureau of Statistics and
the Society for International Development (SID),
Migori County is leading in the population with
primary education at 64.6 percent followed by Siaya
County at 63.8 percent and Homa Bay County at 62.9
percent. The bottom three counties in terms of primary
education are Nyamira County with 53.6 percent, Kisii
County with 55.2 percent and Kisumu County at 56.9
percent. In terms of the percentage of the population
with secondary level education, Nyamira leads with 30.3
percent followed by Kisii at 27.7 percent and Kisumu
at 25.4 percent; the lowest county is Migori with 15.2
percent.
39
Busia
Kisii
Kisumu
Migori
Nyamira
Siaya
Vihiga
Preprimary
84,738
50,100
89,450
105,312
84,873
81,361
80,132
32,638
57,592
31,821
Primary
425,597
221,071
281,471
468,437
349,499
246,582
272,953
130,756
232,691
161,190
Secondary 64,214
30,107
50,495
72,834
93,486
51,871
41,267
36,231
35,780
28,763
Tertiary
6,243
2,270
4,658
7,240
8,371
9,724
4,229
3,027
2,759
2,831
University
2,997
1,226
2,195
5,594
4,065
6,909
2,075
1,268
1,847
1,199
40
4.1.2
Region
Poor funding
The sector is subject to chronic underfunding that
does not adequately support the physical and human
resources required to ensure the quality of education
delivered is high.
Low transition and completion rates
The transition rate into secondary and tertiary education
is especially low. Females are at particular risk due to
early marriages, child labour and pregnancies.
Poor and declining education standards
Even for those who complete their education, they
are not skilled and often unable to create or gain
meaningful employment and improve their standards
of living. This seems to be linked to poor teacher
supervision and low expectations by teachers. This
may be due to low levels of motivation on the part
of teacher, high workloads and teacher absenteeism.
In effect the low quality of education translates to
gross amounts of malinvestment that fail to boost and
improve the human capital of the region.
Poor facilities and learning resources
The physical educational infrastructure is abysmal with
many learning in dilapidated buildings with no
electricity, adequate seating or learning materials.
Further, the lack of learning resources such as text
books, library books, wall maps and the exercise books
impedes performance as well as the learning and
teaching environment.
Poor infrastructure
There is a poor network of road and transport
infrastructure which can make it difficult for pupils and
teachers to get to the schools.
4.1.3
Opportunities for Investment in
Education
The opportunities for investment in the education sector
in the region include:
Flagship Project: Developing Centres of Excellence
that link industry and research
Public Private Partnerships (PPPs) in Early Childhood
Education
PPPs for the development and maintenance of
educational infrastructure
Development of regional centres of excellence.
Some institutions such as Kisumu Polytechnic can be
targeted as a hub for specific skills training relevant
to key industries in the region
Development of regional centres of Technical
training in key economic areas; doing so will avoid
duplication at county levels
Development of Research and Technology parks that
create and incubate ideas for implementation and
support by the County governments.
A university that serves the region.
41
County
Opportunities
Bungoma
Homabay
Kisii
Kisumu
42
Siaya
Busia
Migori
Nyamira
Vihiga
Kakamega
43
44
Agriculture
Agriculture is the back-bone of the Lake Basin Region
county governments should focus on investing in
Agricultural Training Institutes geared towards training
students in modern agricultural knowledge and the
use of modern technology and equipment. Both the
youth and farming population should be targeted.
Emphasis should be placed on how to manage climate
change. There should also be a focus on partnering
with mechanical and electrical training institutes in order
to ensure the repair and maintenance of agricultural
equipment and machinery. In addition specialist training
in value chain management, value addition as well as
the sales and marketing of agricultural produce can be
included.
Tourism
The development of hospitality, tours and travel,
catering and leisure management training institutes
is crucial for the region if it is to become a tourist
destination of note.
Sports
Kenya excels in sports such as athletics, rugby and
soccer and a significant number of famous professionals
of these sports in Kenya are from the Lake Region.
Soccer players such as Dennis Oliech, Macdonald
Mariga, Victor Mugubi Wanyama, Allan Wanga and
Arnold Origi come from the region. In rugby, notables
such as Humphrey Kayange, Collins Injera, Andrew
Amonde, Lavin Asego are from the region as well.
The county governments of the region can therefore
consider establishing sports talent academies to identify
and nurture talented youth who can then be introduced
on the national, East African and global sports industry.
4.1.5
Socioeconomic Impact of Interventions
in Education
The impacts of a better education system are as
follows:
Early childhood education is associated with
substantial effects for both cognitive and socioemotional outcomes. (Melhuish, 2014)
Studies have associated attending a pre-school with
increased qualifications, employment, and earnings
up to age 33 (Melhuish, 2014)
State-collected data in some countries reveal that
pre-school helps children succeed in school and
obtain higher wages in the labour market (Melhuish,
2014)
Pre-school reduces socio-economic inequalities,
as children from less advantaged backgrounds
benefitted more than the more advantaged
(Melhuish, 2014)
Pre-school expansion is associated with improved
inter-generational educational mobility (Melhuish,
2014)
Formal schooling is one of several important
45
Bungoma
Busia
Homa Bay
Kakamega
Kisii
Kisumu
Migori
Nyamira
Siaya
Vihiga
255
453
185
202
433
462
145
389
236
HIV Prevalence
(percent, 2013)3
3.2
6.8
25.7
5.9
19.3
14.7
6.4
23.7
3.8
Population per
Nurse (2012/13)
17,406
12,609
9,543
13,612
7,386
9,689
N/A
6,346
13,586
13,527
Population per
458,354
doctor
Health Facilities4
247,982
327,265
276,775
162,483
322,970
N/A
179,650
421,752
554,622
Total number of
facilities
141
80
180
229
140
154
169
114
155
87
Hospitals
11
13
16
18
17
13
Health centre
20
15
40
37
31
34
27
39
37
18
Dispensary
79
47
99
96
68
70
93
42
90
26
Medical clinic/
Stand-alone VCT
26
23
67
17
21
26
18
15
32
Maternity/
5
Nursing home
Health Financing
13
12
10
Health budget
allocations
(approx.)
(2013/14)5
29%
30%
8%
20%
1%
18%
N/A
6%
5%
10%
National Health
Insurance Fund
(NHIF) coverage
(2012)6
13.1
24.1
21.0
2.4
34.5
24.9
15.0
27.7
22.4
18.8
47
4.2.2
Key Health Challenges Facing the Lake
Region
Infrastructure
The number of physical health facilities available is
limited. In the country, Bungoma has the lowest facility
density of less than 1 facility per 10,000 persons; all the
counties in the Lake Region have a facility density of less
than 2 facilities per 10,000 persons.
Medicine
There is a chronic lack of adequate levels of essential
drugs particularly for mothers and children. The SARAM
2013 Report found that primary healthcare facilities
(nationwide) have critically low availability of health
commodities.
48
4.2.3
Opportunities to expand Quality Health
care Services
Since diseases are common the possibility of a regional
strategy in health exists. The following are opportunities
in the health sector in the Lake Region:
Flagship Project: Specialist Hospital in each county:
Build, operate and transfer 10 specialist hospitals each
serving a specific clinical area.
Establish a regional National Health Trust: This can
be contracted by the regional governments to lead in
cutting edge management and expansion of existing
health facilities and services, including seeking ways
of attracting and retaining health personnel in the
region. There are examples from countries such as India
and Tunisia that can be referred to in terms of how to
develop and manage an effective and affordable health
care system
Partnership with Insurance organisations: Done in
order ensure that every individual in the county has
health insurance and access to health provision. The
health insurance organisations will work across the
region to enable the affordability at point of access/
use, but to also work towards providing incentives for
providers of health services in the region. This might
include setting up major health Centers at central points
in the county, and leading in air ambulance provision for
remote regions of the county.
Community Health: Set up community health
dispensaries that are more cost-effective in terms of
diagnosis and preventive measures. These community
dispensaries will need to be equipped to develop health
messages that can lead to prevention, as well as be an
easy to reach source of health personnel in cases of
emergence and everyday health care.
Infrastructure
County governments to develop primary care
infrastructure terminating at what are currently
health centers. Former sub-district hospitals can act
as filter and referral centers for specialized clinics.
A complete emergency care system based on the
University of Baltimores emergency care service to
be developed for the entire region with both
land, sea and air capabilities.
A robust communication system based on the
regions ICT platform to be implemented
Personnel
Staff performance management system to be
centered around the specialist hospitals.
Oversight to be provided by these hospitals which
will also develop standard care packages that will be
used by all
Staff training to be centered around specialist
hospitals. These are to provide continuous
professional development to all staff in the region.
Logistic systems
Automated procurement systems for medical
supplies based on a shared ICT infrastructure.
Reduction in number of players in the supply chain
(get KEMSA to be efficient or outsource the services
to a KEMSA look alike)
Strategic information
Medicine is evidence based thus a single system to
manage all patient records, supplies and administration
is required. This system should have clinician decision
support capability as well as organizational oversight
capacities.
Health Governance
Move away from current top heavy management
structures.
Lean leadership relying on ICT to provide data for
decision support.
Clinical leadership to be ceded to the Specialized
hospitals
Main function of county medical leadership would
be supervision to monitor adherence to policies,
standards, emergency response to outbreaks,
financial management, logistics management
Move away from specific disease focus to disease
groups.
Clinical systems
These should be benchmarked to the best in the world
as follows:
Emergency services with Japan, state of
Maryland, Israel
Preventive care against japan
Primary care against France
Specialist services against India
All aspects of clinical services to be accredited
Community strategy should be linked to targeted
services for citizenry
49
Table 12: Health Status in the Lake Region and Opportunities for Improvement
County
Opportunities
Bungoma
Homabay
Kisii
Kisumu
50
County
Siaya
Opportunities
Busia
Migori
Vihiga
51
Nyamira
Kakamega
Description
Impact
Specialist Hospitals
m-Health Services
52
4.2.4
Socioeconomic impact of the Health
Sector
The positive impacts of improved health are as follows
(UNAIDS, UNICEF, WHO et al 2011):
Healthier individuals live longer lives
Healthier individuals are more productive and
contribute to national income, job creation, and
economic development and growth.
Healthier people have fewer and healthier children,
invest more time and greater resources in their
childrens education, and thus secure the future for
their societies.
Healthier people reduce costs of ill health to society
and companies and enable resources to be directed
to economically productive activities.
Improving the health of girls and women in
particular is likely to have a significant effect on
poverty reduction
Healthier individuals are physically and mentally
more energetic and robust which makes them more
productive
One study suggests that one extra year of life
expectancy raises steady-state GDP per capita by
around 4 percent
One study estimates that reductions in adult
mortality explain 10 percent to 15 percent of the
economic growth that occurred from 1960 to 1990
One study argues that wiping out malaria in SubSaharan Africa could increase that continents per
capita growth rate by as much as 2.6 percent a
year
Disease and illness cause the household to spend
a great deal of resources on medical care which
depletes its assets, and incurs substantial debt.
Preventing such a depletion of assets through
promoting better health and health care for
individuals helps households avoid the poverty
trap. It will enable them to use these assets for
productive investments or raising additional capital
for enterprises
53
5. Enabling Sectors:
Financial Services, ICT and
Infrastructure
5.1 Financial Services
5.1.1
The State of Financial Services in the
Lake Region
Kenya has 52 financial institutions; 44 of these are
banking institutions (43 banks and one mortgage
financing institution) spread out into four categories
based on their asset base, and 8 deposit taking microfinance institutions (DTMs) with the Central Bank
of Kenya as the regulatory authority. Most of these
financial institutions have a presence in Western Kenya.
Access to capital and financial services is a key
component in building and sustaining businesses.
Whereas the Lake Region hosts major banks such as
Kenya Commercial Bank, Barclays Bank, and Equity
Bank, the extent to which the residents of the region
have been able to mobilize their savings and acquire
capital for their businesses has been low. Accrued
savings are so low that commercial banks are hesitant to
extend financial services beyond the productive sectors
and the larger industrial concerns in the region. The
distribution of banks nationally has also been skewed
disproportionately in favour of the highly urbanized
cities of Nairobi and Mombasa.
Figure 13: Number of Bank Branches in Kenya
54
55
56
Education
ICT initiatives can provide educational institutions access
to computers and content for improved information
dissemination for students. Further each county can set
up ICT Hubs that can be accessed by the communities
especially for students and women.
Financial Services
ICT infrastructure in each of the counties can be
implemented to allow communities to access financial
advisory services as well as other banking services.
Tourism
The tourism potential in the Lake Region has not been
realised partly because it has not been marketed well
partly due to the lack of access that promotes tourism in
the region. With the implementation of ICT platforms,
tourist experiences can be promoted locally, regionally
and internationally and can be linked to tour and travel
groups.
Health
Most counties that have health centres that are not
properly equipped, lack basic water and consistent
electricity and often equipment is faulty especially in
the main district health facilities. A number of counties
have begun putting up partially equipped centres but
more support is required in linking these centres to
larger well equipped facilities that can provide accurate
diagnostic and reporting services for imaging, lab and
pharmaceuticals. Infrastructure and ICT will enable each
of these centres to be linked to a regional data centre
and allow for research and sharing of important health
information where necessary.
57
Opportunities
Bungoma
Homabay
Kisii
Kisumu
8,500 landlines
Penetration of Safaricom, Airtel, Orange,
and Yu networks is at about 90 per cent
Siaya
Vihiga
Busia
Migori
58
County
Opportunities
Nyamira
Kakamega
5.2.3
Proposed Projects
Flagship Project: ICT Improving Service Delivery
Networking of County Headquarters
Most of the county headquarters are not completely
networked. Some counties have begun the process but
most are only partially connected. The first step is to get
county offices connected and the second step is creating
connectivity of sub-County Offices to the County HQ.
Once this has been completed, the region will have a
base on which all activities can be supported by ICT.
Data Centres
Set up a minimum of 2 Data Centres in the region. The
Data Centres will enable the region to provide hosting
of data services for all the sectors identified. The Data
Centres should also have a redundancy site for back up
purposes.
Free Wi-Fi in Counties
Establish free Wi-Fi in the CBD of each of the
counties in the Lake Region in order to provide
internet access to communities during business
hours. This will allow all sectors of the economy to
embrace the use of ICT in their daily lives, for traders,
education institutions, farmers, tourists and
businesses. Currently, the only
available Wi-Fi areas are in offices, hotels and very few
educational institutions and businesses.
59
5.2.4
Resource Mobilization Strategy
Engage with existing institutions and the county in
identifying the gaps for implementation on the
ongoing, partially-ongoing and proposed/planned
flagship projects for each county and determine
how scaling up would impact the region in terms
of empowering the communities economically by
providing employment and improved livelihoods.
Engage counties to determine whether budgets
have been allocated for their ICT projects and the
extent of support required from other financial
partners.
5.2.5
Socioeconomic Impact of the ICT sector
Interventions in ICT to strengthen the sector can have
the following impact on the region:
ICT will enable the Lake Region to leapfrog certain
technology developments and catch up with the
rest of the world (Wangwe, 2007)
The use of mobile phones has resulted in increased
turnover and greater efficiency in business.
(Wangwe, 2007)
The provision of basic social services like health
and education is facilitated by ICT development
(Wangwe, 2007)
ICT is an important tool in citizen agency, used by
citizens to monitor public authorities and resources
(Dobra, 2012)
ICT increases the coherence of information, since it
enables citizens to cross-reference and link pieces of
information, making it easier to understand patterns
of governmental actions and policies (Dobra, 2012)
ICT helps reduce the asymmetry of information
between elected officials and the electorate, and
between bureaucrats and elected officials (Dobra,
2012)
Increased participation by citizens in webbased forms of interaction results over time in a
corresponding growth in a culture of openness and
also increases transparency (Dobra, 2012)
5.3 Infrastructure
The capacity of the aforementioned sectors of
Agriculture, Tourism, Education, Health, ICT and
Financial Services rely on an efficient network of
infrastructure in order to operate effectively. A wellnetworked and functioning infrastructure is essential
for inter-county market integration, lowering unit costs
of production and transactions, facilitating the flow
of materials and information, reducing inequalities
60
2010
2011
2012
2013
Hydro
3224.0
3217.2
4015.9
4435.01
Thermal oil
2201.0
2800.5
2200.4
2161.7
Geo thermal
1442.0
1443.7
1515.9
1780.9
Cogeneration
92.0
80.9
104.7
55.6
Wind
16.8
17.6
14.4
14.7
Imports
30.0
33.9
39.1
49.0
2010
2011
2012
2013
2200.3
2471.4
2568.5
2866.1
3204.9
3440.3
3409.2
3585.3
Off peak
38.2
37.9
36.0
32.7
Street lighting
20.5
17.9
20.6
17.2
Rural electrification
290.8
306.1
380.1
426.8
Total Domestic
5754.7
6273.6
6414.4
6928.1
Export to Uganda
29.6
37.3
32.7
43.7
Transportation
Kenya has an extensive network of paved and unpaved
roads. The railway system links the nations ports and
major cities and connects with neighbouring Uganda.
According to the Kenya Roads Board, Kenya has
160,886 kilometres (99,970 mi) of roads with 11,189
kilometres (6,953 mi) unpaved. Two routes in the TransAfrican Highway network pass through Kenya- Nairobi:
the Lagos-Mombasa Highway and the Trans-African
Highway which links East Africa and West Africa.
However, it is only complete between the UgandanDR
Congo border and Mombasa.
61
2010
2011
2012
2013
000s
7516
8722
8584
8232
000 Tones
247
304
295
262
Pipeline throughout
000m3
4204
4257
4856
5171
000 Tonnes
1572
1596
1394
1214
000 Tones
18977
19953
21920
22307
Ship docking
Number
1579
1684
1763
1786
Homabay
Kisumu
Siaya
Kisii
Nyamira
Vihiga
Kakmega
Bugoma
Busia
Improved water (%
households 2009)
47.8
38.6
60.1
46.7
67.9
68.6
76.4
76.1
88.9
82.9
Improved sanitation
(% households 2009
66.8
61.4
87.4
82.7
99.2
99.4
99.1
122.1
96.6
92.0
Electricity (%
households 2009)
5.3
3.3
18.3
4.3
7.8
6.1
7.0
5.6
4.5
6.0
4.7
4.8
14.2
6.4
5.2
6.9
16.6
4.9
6.0
4.9
55.0
42.9
38.0
50.5
48.6
64.9
60.4
54.1
46.7
58.6
Homabay
Kisumu
Siaya
Kisii
Nyamira
Vihiga
Kakmega
Bugoma
Busia
Elec.
5.2
3.3
18.3
4.3
8.0
5.8
6.9
5.5
4.4
5.5
Pressure Lamp
0.6
0.5
0.5
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.5
0.5
0.3
Lantern
25.6
21.2
23.2
20.6
31.7
40.3
28.4
28.2
26.7
21.4
Tin Lamp
66.4
73.0
56.2
73.0
58.0
51.6
62.2
63.9
66.6
71.4
Gas Lamp
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.4
0.6
0.5
0.8
0.8
0.6
0.5
Fuelwood
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.2
0.3
0.2
0.5
0.4
0.6
0.4
Solar
0.8
1.0
1.0
0.9
0.9
1.0
0.6
0.7
0.5
0.4
5.3.2
Challenges in infrastructure in the Lake
Region
The challenges to infrastructure in the region are:
Lack of resources to undertake infrastructure
development.
Lack of reliable data to determine finance and
manpower requirements of projects.
Lack of infrastructure development framework
that adequately delineate stage-by-stage project
requirements in many Counties of the Region.
Inadequate planning, mismatch of projects with
society needs, and requirements.
Inadequate supporting institutions at County level
Competing political interests
5.3.3
Summary of Infrastructure Sector
Investment Opportunities per Region
The table provides a summary of infrastructure sector
investment opportunities per region:
Table 20: Investment Opportunities in the Infrastructure Sector per County
County
Opportunities
Bungoma
Homabay
63
County
Kisii
Kisumu
Siaya
64
Opportunities
Vihiga
Busia
65
Migori
Nyamira
Kakamega
66
5.3.4
Key Interventions
Flagship Project: Creation of a Lake Region Ring
Road
Infrastructure construction
The development rate of the infrastructure sector in the
region will greatly inform the rate of development of
the other sectors. Bridges need to be constructed
across rivers in Bungoma, Siaya, Budalangi to facilitate
human movement; roads across the region have to be
constructed or rehabilitated; electricity to be connected
to households, markets, and health and education
institutions, and water points need to be rehabilitated
and portable water supplied to homes.
Airport and Airstrips Expansion
Kisumu International Airport is in the process of
expansion to meet international standards and
accommodate larger air crafts and cargo. Other airstrips
in the region need to be rehabilitated, reopened and/
or constructed especially in Busia County which is an
established trading centre. Operational airstrips in the
region are important facilitators of imports and exports
for local businesses as well as making the region
accessible to other parts of the country.
Lake Basin Region Railway and Dry Ports
Opening up the non-operational railway system of the
region will create access to larger markets in East Africa.
A functioning railway system will ease pressure on road
transportation of cargo and human public transport.
Additionally, building dry ports in counties bordering the
Lake Victoria i.e. Siaya, Kisumu, Homabay and Migori
and connecting the dry port termini with the rail system
will benefit the economy of the region as it will attract
international cargo export and import.
67
6.1
6.1.2
Women and Girls in Tourism
According to a report by the World Bank (2007) tourism
is an important sector of the Kenyan economy and a
large source of formal and informal employment for
women. The majority of jobs held by females are in the
sale of handicrafts such as weaving and wooden carvings (Ikiara 2001). The seasonal nature of tourism results
in employment instability that reduces the sectors
employment benefits for women.
6.1.1
Women in Agriculture
In Kenya, women command domestic duties as well as
the majority of agricultural cultivation. In this region,
agriculture accounts for 70 percent of the labour
force, where women make up 75 percent of that work
force (Freidenberg, 2013). However although women
are given ownership of the crops they cultivate, they
are not given the title of land owners (Freidenberg,
2013). Without laws to protect the equal rights of
women
to housing and property, including during marriage and
at its dissolution, both at divorce and death of a
spouse, women will continue to unreasonably shoulder
the burden of poverty in Kenya (FIDA, 2008). Further,
women are often prevented from interacting directly
with men other than close relatives which limits their
participation in agricultural or financial training and
their ability to benefit from working with extension
agents and veterinarians, most of whom are male and
primarily address other men (Fletschner, 2011). It has
been estimated that if women farmers had access to the
same resources as men, they would be able to increase
overall agricultural productivity by as much as 30%
(Doss, 2012).
An important gender issue particularly pertinent to
the Lake Region is the fish for sex issue. According to
research done in 2012, in the region, particularly in
the area around Lake Victoria, women fishmongers
form relationships with fishermen as part of the
jaboya system where women who wish to sell fish in
the market secure the rights to purchase the fish
caught
by the fishermen by having sex with them(Kwena et
al, 2012). Due to the nature and context of the sexual
intercourse, sex typically occurs in a hurried manner,
often without preparation or protection. As a result,
women in these fishing communities are at increased
risk of HIV. According to IRIN HIV prevalence among
fishing communities stands at 30 percent, while an
estimated 25 percent of all new infections in Nyanza are
attributed to this group. An estimated 27,000 women
are involved in the fish trade in Nyanza either directly or
indirectly, according to the Ministry of Fisheries (IRIN,
2011). The continued poverty of women means they
68
69
ICT
Identify female role models and leaders in ICT:
With a focus of women from the region, the ICT
strategy should make a point to profile these
women particularly to girls in educational settings
Engage men and boys: Work with males to make
them understand their female relatives and friends.
When fathers and male peers are aware, engaged
and supportive of girls development and their
rights, they play a very strong role in changing
broader norms and perceptions.
Integrate ICT into education with a focus on girls:
Ensure that girls have access to laptops in the
class room as well as ICT to build media and
digital literacy skills. Special care needs to be
taken to ensure that girls have equal access to
equipment.
6.2 Youth
6.2.1
Youth and Agriculture
Insights in this section are taken from a report done
by VSO (2013). Agriculture has largely remained
unattractive to young people, men and women, for a
variety of reasons:
Low returns on time and input investment
Seasonality of incomes
Lack of education/knowledge on modern farming
and marketing approaches.
Risks due to unpredictable weather and other
natural factors such as pests
Lack of innovations leading to reliance on traditional
labour-based production techniques
Concentration on a narrow range of agricultural
commodities mainly staple crops
Limited access to land among the youth
Further, school curricula have generally tended to
alienate the youth from careers in agriculture, and as
a result the negative effects of the youth study-towork transition have been more pronounced in the
agricultural sector than in any other sector. Further to
many youth, agriculture is an undertaking of the last
resort. Most youth consider agricultural work to be for
those who have not gone to school. Moreover, many
youths who grew up in the villages have an experience
of the long hours that go into traditional agriculture
without a commensurate return. They may therefore
believe their future lies with a different career that is
financially more rewarding and can be found in the
urban area. As a result, there is paltry involvement
of youth in agriculture. This Blueprint will suggest
71
6.2.4
Youth and Health
A report by USAID, the Ministry of Health, FHI 360
and Progress states that according to the recent
Kenya Demographic and Health Survey KDHS (200809) and the 2009 Census, Kenya has a broad based
(pyramid shaped) population structure with 63% of
the population below 25 years. Similarly, 32% of the
population is aged between 10-24 years; also 41%
of women and 43% of men of reproductive age
(15-49) are below 25 years of age. Due to their large
population, there is poverty and inadequate access to
health care. Many youth do not get the opportunity to
acquire life skills and consequently involve themselves
in risky behavior that expose them to social, economic
and adverse health events such as substance abuse,
school dropout, crime, social unrest, unemployment,
unintended pregnancy and life threatening sexually
transmitted diseases and infections. Many young
people are sexually active and are at risk of adverse
reproductive health outcomes that subsequently affect
achievement of life goals and optimum contribution
to national development. Many youth initiate sexual
intercourse early, have multiple partners and often do
not use protection during sex. In general, young
people are unlikely to seek health services, and when
they do they are likely to get inadequate services. The
health system has been slow to evolve to
accommodate the needs of this age group both from
program and service delivery perspectives. Further, low
budget allocation
in the Ministry of Health budget, limited resources for
better programming, inadequate physical infrastructure
for provision of services, and inadequate reproductive
health (RH) information for youth all affect youth health.
There is therefore clearly a need for there to be a youthfocussed element of the health strategy for the Lake
Region.
6.2.5
Youth and Financial Services
Currently in Kenya, there is no youth focus in financial
services which encourages those under the age of 18
to have accounts. Kenya does not appear to promote
financial inclusion and education among youth.
However, according to a report by AudienceScapes
(2010), youth in Kenya between the ages of 24-29 are
likely to be the sole financial decision makers in their
household. Although respondents 15-19 may have
less responsibility over financial decision making, their
need for information regarding financial services is
no less diminished. Educating this age group before
72
6.2.7
Agriculture
Re-brand agriculture: There is a need to address
the deep seated belief that agriculture and rural
areas are for those who cannot make a livelihood
anywhere else. Agriculture needs to be rebranded as
the new unexplored frontier for growth in business
opportunities.
Develop innovative financial packages: There is
need to incentivize entrepreneurs in agriculture
by developing financial packages and guarantee
schemes that would underwrite the risks involved in
such packages. The funds should also be sufficient
for the enterprises of choice
Encourage youth to use modern technologies both
in production and management of agriculture as a
business.
Short Term Training on agriculture for youth
Affordable loans for youth in agriculture from
government
Provide youth with subsidies on inputs
Promote enterprises that bring quick money
Establish more agricultural factories to employ youth
Tourism
Aim for at least 1/3rd representation of youth in
all levels of position in Community Based Tourism
programmes
Develop a robust anti-sex tourism policy
Education
The county should work with NGOs and others
to get support to teach core subjects to primary
and secondary school students. Subjects include
mathematics, business education, biology, chemistry,
physics, English, music, art and design, history and
civics, HIV/AIDS education, and geography.
Provide resources for a care centre for orphaned
children (3-4 years of age) that provide nutrition,
care, and recreational activities.
Organize recreational activities for students, such as
soccer, netball, basketball, volleyball, music, dance,
drama, choir, boy/girl scouts, field trips (to local
forests, prisons, and hospitals), farming activities
(e.g. gathering crops), and/or horticulture.
Provide counselling, tutoring, and recreational
activities to primary school children who have been
orphaned and are at severe risk of dropping out of
school.
73
75
77
Disability specific
78
ICT
The CCK has a robust programme for strengthening
PWDs access to ICTs. The Lake Region should work
with CCK to implement the following in each county
and enhance PWD access to:
Communication Services (Mobile and Fixed Line,
Internet)
Information (libraries and tele-care centers)
Broadcasting services and Equipment
Postal and Courier Services
Websites
ICT education,
Financial information and services and;
Role and Importance of research and accessibility
standards
79
80
Tourism
Sustainable tourism should be enshrined in the
Tourism strategy of the region through the following
interventions:
Providing incentives to encourage industry initiatives
aimed at protecting the environment
Setting up a framework for information exchange
and for environmental awareness creation of all
stakeholders in the tourism industry
Marketing of green tourism products
Promoting activities that create awareness of the
need to conserve biodiversity
Enhancing tourism enterprises that promote
sustainable use of biodiversity resources
Supporting interventions that reduce conflicts
between people and biodiversity conservation
Education
The following is an outline of the type of interventions
that can be taken by all counties in the Lake Region on
Environmental Education (Otieno):
Raise the level of environmental awareness
Promote the co-ordination of EE activities
Recognize the special relationships that local
communities have with the environment and
ensure that their perspectives are represented in EE
initiatives.
Enhance and support the integration of EE into all
learning programmes, projects and initiatives.
Develop partnerships between stakeholders,
including the private sector, to promote and
increase the level and quality of EE
Promote technical cooperation, networking and
information sharing
Provide Lake Region citizens with a framework
within which to develop effective EE programmes.
Health
The World Health Organisation (WHO) recommends
the following be done to reduce environment-related
disease burden (WHO, 2005):
Conduct a baseline survey on environmental health
issues, health status and knowledge of personal and
environmental hygiene
Promote personal and environmental hygiene in
schools and communities.
Promote safe drinking water in homes and schools.
Support environmental health improvements in
targeted schools and communities
81
8. Conclusion
82
9. Addendum
83
10. References
84
Novignon., J. et al (2012), The effects of public and private health care expenditure on health status in subSaharan Africa: new evidence from panel data analysis, http://www.healtheconomicsreview.com/content/2/1/22
Feinstein, L., et a (2005), What are the effects of education on health?, http://www1.oecd.org/edu/innovationeducation/37425753.pdf
UNAIDS, UNICEF, WHO et al (2011), Investing in Health for Africa: The Case for Strengthening Systems for
Better Health Outcomes, http://www.afro.who.int/en/downloads/doc_download/6401-investing-in-health-forafrica-the-case-for-strengthening-systems-for-better-health-outcomes.html
Dobra, A., (2012), The Democratic impact of ICT in Africa, http://kms2.isn.ethz.ch/serviceengine/Files/
EINIRAS/145358/ichaptersection_singledocument/60462d80-e722-47ff-a06f-c56e4618703e/en/521-546-1-PB.pdf
Wangwe,S., (2007), Evolution, Status and Impact of ICT on Economic Development and Transformation
in Africa: An Overview, http://dspace.africaportal.org/jspui/bitstream/123456789/32120/1/WangweS_
AnOverviewpaperonICT.pdf?1
2014 Economic Survey highlights
Kenya National Bureau of Statistics (KNBS)
Network for international policies and cooperation in education and training- Norrag (2003), Critical
Perspectives on Education and Skills in Eastern Africa on Basic and Post-Basic Levels, http://www.norrag.
org/ar/publications/norrag-news/online-version/critical-perspectives-on-education-and-skills-in-eastern-africaon- basic-and-post-basic-levels/detail/the-status-interpretation-and-opportunities-for-gender-equity-in-thekenyan- educational-system.html
UNESCO (2012), UNESCO Global Partnership for Girls and Womens Education- One Year On, http://www.
unesco.org/eri/cp/factsheets_ed/KE_EDFactSheet.pdf
Freidenberg, Lauren (2013), Marginalization Of Rural Women In Kenya, Prospect Journal of International
Affairs, http://prospectjournal.org/2013/10/03/marginalization-of-rural-women-in-kenya/)
FIDA (2008), Kenyan Laws and Harmful Customs Curtail Womens Equal Enjoyment of ICESCR Rights, http://
www2.ohchr.org/english/bodies/cescr/docs/info-ngos/FIDAKenya41.pdf
Zachary A Kwena et al (2012), Transactional sex in the fishing communities along Lake Victoria, Kenya: a
catalyst for the spread of HIV, African Journal of AIDS Research 2012, http://www.ajol.info/index.php/ajar/
article/view/75069
IRIN (2011), KENYA: Helping women to end sex-for-fish culture, http://www.irinnews.org/report/94497/kenyahelping-women-to-end-sex-for-fish-culture
Odinga, Ida (2013), Addressing Maternal Health in Kenya, http://www.ghdnews.com/index.php/global-healthchallenges/maternal-and-child-health/18-addressing-maternal-health-in-kenya
Diana Fletschner and Lisa Kenney (2011), Rural womens access to financial services: Credit, savings and
insurance, FAO http://www.fao.org/3/a-am312e.pdf
85
Kituyi-Kwake, A et al (2008), Analyzing ICT use and access amongst rural women in Kenya, International
Journal of Education and Development using Information and Communication Technology, http://ijedict.dec.
uwi.edu/include/getdoc.php?id=4593&article=537&mode=pdf
Wamala, Caroline (2012), Empowering Women Through ICT, The Swedish Program for ICT in
Developing Regions, http://www.bgwomeninict.org/language/bg/uploads/files/documents_ /documents__
a3d32c26f6e5897fa43d9daf6a5e48f2.pdf
Raftree, Linda (2012), Empowering girls through information, communication and technology, The
Guardian, http://www.theguardian.com/global-development-professionals-network/2012/nov/27/improving-ictaccess-to-girls
Ellis A., et al (2007)Gender and Economic Growth in Kenya, World Bank, http://www.ifc.org/wps/wcm/
connect/84f6b48048855d698ee4de6a6515bb18/Gender+and+Economic+Growth+in+Kenya.pdf?MOD=AJPERES
Doss, C., (2012), Womens Economic Empowerment in Agriculture: Supporting Women Farmers, http://
www.womeneconroadmap.org/sites/default/files/Doss%20Bockius-Suwyn%20and%20DSouza_Supporting%20
Women%20Farmers.pdf
WHO, Addressing the Challenge of Womens Health in Africa, http://www.afro.who.int/en/downloads/doc_
download/8211-addressing-the-challenge-of-womens-health-in-africa-chapter-6.html
FSD Foundation for International Development (2015), Youth Education & Development Issues in Kenya,
http://www.fsdinternational.org/country/kenya/yeissues
USAID (2012), Adolescent and Youth Sexual and Reproductive Health: Taking Stock in Kenya, http://www.
fhi360.org/sites/default/files/media/documents/youth-sexual-reproductive-health-kenya-phase1.pdf
Storm, L. et al, (2010), Emerging guidelines for linking youth to financial services, http://www.mastercardfdn.
org/pdfs/Emerging%20Guidelines%20for%20linking%20youth%20to%20financial%20services.pdf
Njenga, P., et al(2012), Youth and Women Empowerment through Agriculture in Kenya, http://www.
vsojitolee.org/sites/vso_jitolee/files/documents/Reports/youth-and-women-empowerment-through-agriculture-2013.
pdf
AudienceScapes (2010), Young Africans Access to Financial Information and Services: Lessons from Surveys
in Kenya and Ghana, http://www.audiencescapes.org/sites/default/files/Youth%20and%20Financial%20Services_
Kenya%20and%20Ghana_Montez%20David.pdf
UN, Youth and ICT, http://www.un.org/esa/socdev/documents/youth/fact-sheets/youth-icts.pdf
Ministry of Youth Affairs (2006), Kenya National Youth Policy,
http://www.youthpolicy.org/national/ Kenya_2006_National_Youth_Policy.pdf
Grut, L., (2007), See me, and do not forget me: People with disabilities in Kenya, http://siteresources.
worldbank.org/DISABILITY/Resources/Regions/Africa/LCKenya2.pdf
Handicap International (2006), Good Practices for the Economic Inclusion of People with Disabilities in
Developing Countries, http://www.handicap-international.org/uploads/media/goodpractices-GB-2coul.PDF
86
Kirui, L (2012), Towards Innovation for Disability Friendly ICT Sector in Kenya, CCK, https://ncpwd.files.
wordpress.com/2012/06/towards-innovation-for-disability-friendly-ict-sector-in-kenya-final-cck.ppt
Leonard Cheshire Disability and Inclusive Development Centre, Disability and Urban Agriculture: An
innovative approach, https://www.ucl.ac.uk/lc-ccr/ccdrp/downloads/briefs/Urban_Agriculture_Background_Brief.
pdf
Chomba M. et al., (2014), Education for Students with Intellectual Disabilities in Kenya: Challenges and
Prospects, http://dsq-sds.org/article/view/3846/3793
Kanyingi, M., (2012) Accessibility Rights for Persons With Disabilities, http://eaclj.org/constitution/20constitution-feature-articles/44-accessibility-rights-for-persons-with-disabilities.html
Ouko, F., The Challenges towards Access to Health Services for Persons with Disabilities in Kenya, http://
www.haiafrica.org/index.php?option=com_docman&task=doc_download&gid=25&Itemid=106
CBM, Disability Inclusion: Health, http://www.cbm.org/article/downloads/78851/CBM_Disability_Inclusion_-_
Health.doc
FSD International, Environmental Sustainability Issues in Kenya, http://www.fsdinternational.org/country/kenya/
envissues
Ikaira M., et al., (2002), Impact of tourism on environment in Kenya: status and policy, Kenya Institute for
Public Policy Research and Analysis, http://www.eldis.org/go/home&id=21267&type=Document#.VRmQz-H_g0g
Mbogoh, B., Health and the Environment http://www.nema.go.ke/index.php?option=com_phocadownload&vie
w=category&download=57:ch8&id=80:state-of-the-environment
World Health Organisation (2005), Kenya (Ministry of Health) - HECA Seed Funds for Country
Implementation, http://www.who.int/heca/activities/kenya1/en/
87
Contacts
Sammy Onyango
C.E.O, Deloitte East Africa
Emmanuel Lubembe
Director, Public Sector
Tel :
Direct:
Email :
Physical Location
Deloitte Place
Waiyaki Way, Muthangari
P.O BOX 40092
Nairobi 00100 GPO
Kenya
Tel :
Direct:
Email :