Trade Relations Between India and EU
Trade Relations Between India and EU
Trade Relations Between India and EU
Index
Acknowledgement ....................................................................................................................................... 3
Introduction .................................................................................................................................................. 4
India EU Relations ........................................................................................................................................ 5
Some facts ................................................................................................................................................. 6
Institutional Interactions........................................................................................................................... 7
Dismantling Trade barriers in India ........................................................................................................... 8
Strategic Partnership................................................................................................................................. 9
Free Trade Agreement ............................................................................................................................ 12
Indias approach to EU ............................................................................................................................ 14
Trade proceedings................................................................................................................................... 15
Economic and Commercial Relations ...................................................................................................... 16
Joint Working groups .............................................................................................................................. 17
India-EU forum ........................................................................................................................................ 18
Conclusion ............................................................................................................................................... 19
Analysis ....................................................................................................................................................... 20
Imports and Exports ................................................................................................................................ 21
Mineral fuels, lubricants and other related materials ............................................................................ 22
Manufactured goods classified chiefly by material ................................................................................ 23
Machinery and transport equipment ..................................................................................................... 24
Miscellaneous manufactured articles ..................................................................................................... 25
Share of Exports and Imports ................................................................................................................. 26
India Top Trading Partners ...................................................................................................................... 27
Europe Top Trading Partners .................................................................................................................. 29
Future Trends ............................................................................................................................................. 31
Bibliography................................................................................................................................................ 32
Acknowledgement
This research is made possible through the help and support from everyone. Especially, please allow us
to dedicate our acknowledgement of gratitude towards the following significant advisors and
contributors:
We would like to thank my teacher Dr. Kumar Bijoy for his exemplary guidance, mentoring and
constant encouragement throughout the course of this project. We extremely grateful to him for
providing us with such a great project and guidance.
Finally, we sincerely thank to parents, family and friends who helped us a lot in finishing this project
within the limited time.
The product of this research paper would not be possible without all of them.
Team Members
Bharti Babbar
Devesh Revankar
Gautam Rai
Introduction
Considered natural allies in a wide range of global issues by both parties, diplomatic relations
between India and the EU were established in the early 1960s. Since the 1990s, cooperation
between the two increased and their relationship was institutionalised. In 2004, the European
Commission (Commission) proposed the establishment of an ambitious strategic partnership
between the EU and India. The EU identified India as a strategic partner, as it increasingly
strengthened its position on the international scene, was booming economically and
encompasses a vast territory and population. These strategic partnerships have become one
of the key features of European foreign policy as a way for the EU to assert itself while allowing
emerging powers like India to build up their status as global players. In the context of this
partnership, the EU seeks to deepen economic ties with India through bilateral dialogue on
intellectual property rights, trade defence instruments, technical barriers to trade, sanitary and
phytosanitary measures, and customs cooperation.
The strategic partnership called for an EU-India Action Plan. This plan was presented at the EUIndia summit in 2005. Both parties agreed to several commitments, including some aimed at
developing trade and investment since, while trade and investment flows between India and
the EU have been increasing, they remain below potential. Therefore, negotiations towards a
broad-based FTA expanded the strategic partnership.
This project will shed light on the historical relations of India with EU and analyse the trade
relations of India and EU using data from European Commission (All data in million Euros).
Some Facts
European Economic Community was born in 1958 which later came to be known as European
Union
Bilateral relations between the European Union (EU) and the Republic of India date back to the
1960s, when India was one of the first countries to establish relations with what is now the
European Union. The most recent cooperation agreement was signed in 1994 and an action plan
was signed in 2005. They concluded another round of negotiations on the proposed free trade
agreement (FTA) at Brussels.
First agreement cooperation agreement signed in 1994, after the end of cold war and India was
looking for getting more space in the liberation period. Now negotiating broad based trade
agreement BTIA, which is a part of cooperation agreement (in 1994).
The 27-nation EU is Indias largest trading partner. India was EUs 8th largest trading partner in
2010. EU investment in India more than tripled between 2003 and 2010: going from 759million
in 2003 to 3 billion in 2010.
Trade in commercial services tripled during the same time period, going from 5.2billion in 2002
to 17.9 billion in 2010
Total trade in 2010 increased by 28% to Euro 67.78 billion (Indian exports of Euros 32.99 billion:
Indian imports of Euro 34.79 billion) as compared to 2009 figures. In the first eight months of
2011, trade between India and EU grew at 23%. During this period, Indias exports to the EU
were Euro 26.7 billion and imports were Euro 26.9 million. In 2010, total Indian exports to the
EU in different services sector were Euros 8.7 billion whereas total Indian services imports from
the EU were Euros 10.9 billion.
The EU is one of the largest sources of FDI for India. FDI inflows from the EU to India declined
from Euro 3.4 billion in 2009 to Euro 3.0 billion in 2010. Indias investment into EU has also seen
a marginal decline from Euros 0.9 billion in 2009 to Euros 0.6 billion in 2010. The most important
countries in the EU for FDI into India are Germany, UK, France and Italy.
2004(Hungary along with 9 other countries joined EU called Big Bank Enlargement,( different
countries joined in the enlargement process)
INSTITUTIONAL INTERACTIONS
India and the EU have held thirteen rounds of negotiations for a bilateral Broad-based Trade and
Investment Agreement. Negotiations commenced in 2007 and cover
Trade in goods,
and Technical Barriers to Trade,
Investment
Intellectual Property Rights and Geographical Indications
Competition Policy,
Customs and Trade Facilitation,
Trade Defence,
Dispute Settlement.
The last round of negotiations took place in New Delhi from 31 March to 5 April 2011.
Two trade barriers were fully removed in 2012: export restrictions on cotton and security
requirements for telecommunication equipment.
Progress has also been achieved with regard to sanitary and phyto-sanitary rules.
No positive movement has been seen in the area of equity caps.
India's industrial policies contain trade-restrictive elements.
The report also identified India's national manufacturing policy as a key priority for reform.
Access to each other's markets, for goods, services and to public procurement contracts,
The framework for investment
Strategic Partnership
Strategic partnership: Party with which a long-term agreement is reached for sharing of physical
and/or intellectual resources in achievement of defined common objective.
Strategic partnership between Europe and India
The EU and India already enjoy a close relationship based on shared values and mutual respect.
In recent years, the relationship has developed exponentially in terms of shared vision, goals
and challenges. Against this background the Commission proposes a new strategy based on the
following objectives:
Economic partnership
The EU is India's largest trading partner and main source of foreign inward investment, whereas
India is only the EU's 14th trading partner. India needs to further open up its market and
accelerate market reform to realise the potential of its market. It must address such matters as
customs tariffs and the many non-tariff trade barriers, as well as considerably improving its
infrastructure.
The strategic dialogue should address regulatory and industrial policy to improve business
competitiveness on both sides. India and the EU should also promote cooperation on the
world's major environmental challenges such as biodiversity, climate change and the depletion
of the ozone layer.
In many areas, dialogue with India has already made considerable progress. Strategic sectorial
dialogues should be developed in the following areas:
energy;
biotechnology;
the Galileo programme (the European global satellite navigation system);
A space partnership.
The EU and India must start dialogue on investment, intellectual property rights and trade
defence instruments. The EU has an interest in enhancing cooperation with India on technical
barriers to trade and sanitary and phytosanitary issues. The EU-India customs cooperation
agreement should also be exploited and sustainable development and South Asian regional
cooperation should be promoted.
There is enormous potential for EU-India collaboration in science and technology. Indian
researchers should be encouraged to participate in the EU's 6th Framework Programme.
The EU should invite India to regularly attend ministerial level consultations on subjects of
mutual interest in the field of monetary and financial policy.
Development cooperation
The EU must help India to meet the Millennium Development Goals (MDG). Coordination with
other EU donors needs to be improved. The EU could also share its experience of social security
systems.
Mutual understanding
The European and Indian Parliaments are considering organising regular, institutionalised
parliamentary exchanges. In terms of culture, cooperation in all disciplines should be
reinforced. All Member States and institutions should cooperate and coordinate their activities
to inform Indian public opinion. The Government of India should be encouraged to visit EU
institutions as often as possible and devise its own communications strategy.
Institutional architecture
EU-Indian partnership is based on the 1994 Cooperation Agreement and the Joint Political
Declaration of 1993. The first Lisbon summit of 2000 was also key to the development of
bilateral relations. The Commission proposes a number of initiatives to streamline the structure
of the partnership.
Implementation and follow-up
10
The Commission hopes that this Communication will be a starting point for collective reflection
on how to improve EU-India relations. The proposals emerging from such reflection could serve
as the basis for an action plan and a new EU-Indian joint political declaration. Both could be
endorsed at the Sixth EU-India Summit in 2005.
Context
India is an increasingly important international player and regional power with an impressive
economic growth rate. Since the first EU-India summit held in Lisbon in 2000, EU relations with
India have progressed in political, geopolitical, economic and trade terms.
11
First, Indias trade policy is influenced by demographics. More than half of Indias
population is under the age of 25, necessitating a growth strategy emphasizing job
creation and not just export promotion. These demographics and its education system
have provided India with a skilled, competitive, English-speaking work force, something
which Europe will be short of in the near future. Making gains from this workforce
through trade requires more than tariff reduction, which is why tariff reductions alone
will not make the EU-India FTA sufficiently interesting for India. Consequently,
negotiations included provisions for the abolition of non-tariff barriers such as standards
and mutual recognition or licensing requirements.
and subsidy support to its agricultural products for fear of EU exports displacing Indian
agricultural products once an FTA is signed. This issue could prove a significant
stumbling block in the ongoing negotiations.
The third issue is the reluctance of the Indian government to negotiate government
procurement issues. This is a priority issue for the EU and a bone of contention between
the parties. The EU has complained that the Indian government procurement practices
are often not transparent, discriminate against foreigners and often give preferences to
the locals. But given government procurement accounts for nearly 13 per cent of Indias
GDP, the Indian government insists it will not include public procurement in the EU
India FTA agenda. India is also discussing a data secure status for the country. At
present, India is not considered data secure by the EU. This obstructs the flow of
sensitive data, such as information about patents, under data protection laws in the EU.
The EU law mandates that European countries doing outsourcing business with
countries that are not certified as data secure have to follow stringent contractual
obligations, which increase operating costs and affects competitiveness.
Finally, there is a range of smaller matters that could derail negotiations if not managed
well. These include further opening up Indias insurance sector and increasing the
foreign direct investment limit to 49 per cent. A call from the EU for India to reduce its
import duty on passenger cars is also contentious.
Negotiating a resolution to these issues is in the interests of both India and the EU. But
the hurried pace of negotiations is becoming a cause for worry. In negotiating any
bilateral trade agreement with the EU the Indian government should tread cautiously so
as to safeguard domestic concerns and the public interest. The FTA will be the first of
Indias large trade agreements with a western bloc, with 27 economies. If structured
well, the agreement could push Indias growth for the next decade. If structured poorly,
it could derail it for just as long.
13
Indias approach to EU
Profile of EU
First India EU Summit level talks took place in Lisbon in June 2000 & marked a qualitative shift
in the Evolution of the relations. Since then, 12 annual summits have been held, last one in New
Delhi on 10th Feb 2012
PM Dr. Manmohan Singh led the Indian Delegation while the EU was represented by Mr.
Herman Van Rompuy, President of the European council & Mr. Jose Manuel Barroso, president
of European Commission
While there was no summit meeting in 2013, there will be summit level talks soon following the
national election process
EU has always been a priority in the foreign policies
Lower level 2 or more forums besides leaders on the top.
One is at the level of foreign ministry level since 1990
So lower functionary before PM is Finance Ministry
The last foreign Ministerial meeting took place in Brussels in Jan 2013, where both parties
foreign ministers met.
Meetings at senior level Foreign Office Consultations (FOCs),prepares
14
Trade Proceedings
India-EU entered into Strategic Partnership in 2004 and marked the tenth anniversary of
their strategic partnership in 2014
A Joint Action Plan (JAP) was envisaged in 2005. JAP has been held annually since May
2006.The sixth round of JAP was held in Brussels on 25th October at the secretary level.
Since May 2006 6 rounds of JAP were there but JAP is a body on Top it gives directives
for implementation doesnt go into integrities of implementation for that other groups
are there
Security Dialogue-Under the JAP, a Bilateral Joint Working Group on Counter Terrorism
as well as Dialogues on cyber security & counter policy have been constituted
Both sides have signed to setting up a Dialogue on Non-proliferation & Development
under the Umbrella of the Security Dialogue.
Annual India-EU Ad-hoc dialogue on Human Rights is held in New Delhi, the 8th meeting
of which took place on 27th November 2013
High level Dialogue on Migration & Mobility has been instituted at secretary level
between the Ministry Of Overseas Indian Affairs and DG, Home Affairs on the Indian side
and their EU counterparts. The third round of the Dialogue took place in Delhi on July 2,
2012.
There is also a Delhi-based Joint Working Group on consular Issues. Migration from
developing to developed Nations. A dialogue Mechanism has been established on the
sensitive issue of mobility.
A delegation for relations with India (D-IN) was formally constituted in the European
Parliament (EP) in 2007.The D-IN has 28 regular and 22 substitute members drawn from
various political groups in accordance with their numerical strength in the EP. The D-IN
is currently chaired by Sir Graham Watson, a liberal Democrat MEP from the UK. The DIN selects members to pay an orientation visit to India every year. The last visit of D-IN
MEPs to India took place from 29th April to 3 May 2013
The parliament from India visit EU regularly, a forum on the Indian side has not yet
been formalized.
General point: Negotiations become too tough In India and EU as they both belong to 2
different continents
15
Cooperation in the field of Science & Technology Steering committee meets annually to
discuss cooperation in the area. The science and technology committee held its 9 th
meeting in Brussels on 9th October 2013. Besides meetings took place at the Group of
Senior Officials (GSO) level in person as well as through video conferencing.
A dialogue on Information & communication Technology (ICT) has been set up. The last
such dialogues took place in Brussels on 3-4 September 2013.
Energy
India-EU have set up an Energy Panel in 2005 to enhance cooperation in the critical
sector of energy and energy security. The last meeting of the Panel was held in Brussels
on 27th march 2014. This was held at Secretary Level.
Separate Sub-groups have been set up dealing with coal & clean coal conversion
technologies, energy efficiency &renewable energy etc. The joint working group on
clean coal technologies last met from 17-19 June 2013 in Brussels & the India-EU coal
JWG had its 8th meeting on 28th November 2013 in Chennai.
India dependent on oil & gas, as clean technology is mastered by Europe.
17
The India-EU forum has emerged as an important track 2 forum for discussion between
policy analysts on both sides. It is led by the Pans-based European Union Institute for
security studies(EUISS) and the Indian council of World Affairs(ICWA) & includes
participation from academics, think-tanks & even policy makers
The 4th India-EU forum was jointly organized by EUISS & ICWA in cooperation with the
Spanish think-tank FRIDE in Brussels on 23-24 October 2012.
Bilateral Agreements
Besides joint declarations, statements in other areas have also been signed.
18
Conclusion
India-EU relations have come a long way from being economy focused & have matured
sufficiently today with being a holistic, multi-tiered, architectural relationship,
converging the highest levels on both sides.
India & EU are natural partners with relations based on the shared values of democracy,
rule of law & respect for human freedom.
They have started a strategic partnership for a decade
Constant interaction on between the government, parliament & civil society at the
highest levels have made India-EU relations one of the most important & broad
visioned in a world of multi-polar relationships, a relationship which can withstand
financial crisis as well as political upheavals.
19
Analysis
The analysis of this project is based on the Import Export data of past 10 years and specific
data from previous 5 years. Each graph shows the absolute figures for the imports and exports
in the particular product group from years 2009-13.
20
30,000
25,000
20,000
15,000
10,000
5,000
0
-5,000
2004
2005
2006
2007
Balance
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
Imports
17,155
21,250
24,241
29,181
31,356
27,499
34,891
40,582
38,543
35,874
2008
2009
Imports
Exports
16,408
19,114
22,637
26,666
29,632
25,503
33,464
39,927
37,447
36,809
2010
2011
2012
2013
Exports
Balance
-747
-2,136
-1,604
-2,515
-1,724
-1,996
-1,427
-655
-1,096
935
The balance (Exports Imports) has been negative, touching a high of 2515 million euros, until recently
in 2013. In 2013 there was trade surplus of 935 million euros. The graph shows a consistent growth
except for 2008-09, where the worldwide trade depression had a negative effect on the trade between
India and European Union.
21
4737
5057
5066
4968
4000
3000
2000
1947
1000
0
263
165
313
340
241
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
Exports
Imports
1. India is one of the highest exporters of minerals in the world and EU imports minerals from
India. India produces Iron Ore in high quantity but it is graphite that is imported the highest.
2. There was a sudden jump in the exports from India to EU (imports for EU) in 2009, though
imports were not affected by much.
3. Overall, the exports have been higher than imports by a considerable margin.
4. Annual average growth rate is 23.8% for exports and 18.1% for imports.
5. The majority of the exports constitutes of fuels, chiefly petroleum and its derivative products.
22
13,550
12,000
12,401
12,555
8,463
8,493
2012
2013
10,764
10,000
9,661
8,000
7,705
6,000
5,664
7,384
4,000
2,000
0
2009
2010
2011
Exports
Imports
1. Manufactured goods sector increased steadily from 2009-11, then dropped by a little(Exports)
2. India still has higher imports of manufactured goods than exports.
3. Average annual growth rate of various sub-categories of manufactures
a. Chemicals
i. Exports 17.0%
ii. Imports 9.9%
b. Textiles
i. Exports 1.8%
ii. Imports 10.1%
4. Overall growth rate
a. Exports 12.28%
b. Imports 14.55%
23
15,777
14,000
12,000
14,666
14,212
12,988
12,177
10,000
8,000
7,070
6,140
6,000
6,283
5,065
5,758
4,000
2,000
0
2009
2010
2011
Exports
2012
2013
Imports
24
8,686
8,000
7,000
7,972
8,038
2,694
2,675
2,631
2011
2012
2013
8,016
7,240
6,000
5,000
4,000
3,000
2,000
2,033
2,419
1,000
0
2009
2010
Exports
Imports
In 2013 the miscellaneous manufactured articles export growth rate was 0.8% while import was 1.6%.
The imports are falling (as massive unemployment was there, so the benefit of economies of scale
was lost as production decreased) while the exports have risen recently.
Constituents are:
Prefabricated buildings; sanitary, plumbing, heating and lighting fixtures and fittings,
Furniture, and parts thereof; bedding, mattresses, mattress supports, cushions and
similar stuffed furnishings
Travel goods, handbags and similar containers, Articles of apparel and clothing
accessories, Footwear, Professional, scientific and controlling instruments and
apparatus, Photographic apparatus, equipment and supplies and optical goods, watches
and clocks.
25
Primary Products
Manufactures
Other Products
Others
Primary Products
Manufactures
Other Products
Other
26
Export
S.No. Partner
World
1 European Union
2 USA
3 U.A.E.
4 China
5 Singapore
6 Hong Kong
7 Saudi Arabia
8 Japan
9 Bangladesh
10 Brazil
27
Total Trade
S.No. Partner
World
1 European Union
2 China
3 U.A.E.
4 USA
5 Saudi Arabia
6 Switzerland
7 Iraq
8 Hong Kong
9 Singapore
10 Indonesia
Value (Mio )
Share in the world
598,046
100.0
77,861
13.0
50,514
8.4
50,046
8.4
46,951
7.9
36,965
6.2
20,947
3.5
16,265
2.7
15,932
2.7
15,701
2.6
15,566
2.6
28
Exports
S.no. Partner
World
1 USA
2 Switzerland
3 China
4 Russia
5 Turkey
6 Japan
7 Norway
8 U.A.E.
9 Brazil
11 India
2.1
29
Total Trade
S.no. Partner
World
1 USA
2 China
3 Russia
4 Switzerland
5 Norway
6 Turkey
7 Japan
8 South Korea
9 Brazil
10 India
Value (Mio )
Share in the World (%)
3,420,553
100.0
484,361
14.2
428,392
12.5
325,926
9.5
263,871
7.7
140,289
4.1
128,156
3.7
110,641
3.2
75,808
2.2
73,140
2.1
72,683
2.1
30
Future Trends
Looking at the growth rate of Imports Exports of the various sectors, it can be
safely be assumed that trade will increase further. With a stable government at
the center, the trade relations will mature further.
31
Bibliography
http://www.eastasiaforum.org/2013/06/14/why-cant-india-and-the-eu-sign-an-fta/
http://eeas.europa.eu/delegations/india/eu_india/political_relations/strategic_partnership/ind
ex_en.htm
http://eeas.europa.eu/delegations/india/eu_india/political_relations/strategic_partnership/ind
ex_en.htm#
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/India%E2%80%93European_Union_relations
http://europa.eu/legislation_summaries/external_relations/relations_with_third_countries/asia
/r14100_en.htm
http://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php/Intra-EU_trade_in_goods_-_recent_trends
http://ec.europa.eu/trade/
32