A Standard of Shinshu Faith
A Standard of Shinshu Faith
A Standard of Shinshu Faith
Ryosetsu Fujiwara
Published by
Bureau of Buddhist Education
TABLE OF CONTENTS
A STANDARD OF SHINSHU FAITH
Part I Preparatory knowledge of Shinshu ........ 3
Part II Amida Buddha ...................... .............. 7
Part III Function of the Name .........................11
Part IV Relation between Name and Vow ......15
Part V Nature of Faith .....................................20
Part VI Significance of Nembutsu ...................25
Part VII Effect of Faith ...................................29
EXAMPLES OF UNORTHODOX FAITH IN SHINSHU ...34
turmoil of the present world, we feel all the more that Shinshu is,
because of the simplicity of practice as well as the excellence of the
doctrine, the most immediate way to find the eternal, unhindered
peace of mind.
10. Who is the first master who called this teaching 'Shinshu' or 'Jodo
Shinshu'?
Shan-tao (Zendo), the fifth Patriarch, used the term 'Shinshu' in his
writing; and Honen, the seventh Patriarch, who exclusively
succeeded Shan-tao, organised his followers under the name of
'Jodoshu.' But it is Shinran himself who called this stream of
Nembutsu 'Jodo Shinshu.'
11. What did Shinran mean by 'Jodo Shinshu'?
Literally 'Jodo' means 'Pure Land'; 'Shin' means 'true' and 'shu' means
'essence,' 'teaching,' or 'sect.' He meant 'True Teaching of the Pure
Land School' or 'True Teaching of the Pure Land School.'
12. Then is it not the name of the sect founded by Shinran?
Not originally. Shinran himself only used this name for the 'True
Teaching' transmitted to him from Honen Shonin. His intention in
writing the Kyogyoshinsho was solely to clarify the essence of this
teaching. Therefore, he had no idea of founding a new sect. He
whole-heartedly respected Honen Shonin as the teacher and founder
of 'Jodo-Shinshu,' However, this self-effacing attitude of Shinran
brought about more respect among his followers, and spontaneously a
new order came into existence. Thus those followers began to regard
him as their founder and call the new order 'Jodo Shinshu.'
13. Since Shinran did not think of himself as a founder, how did his
later followers set the year of the founding of 'Jodo Shinshu' as new
denomination?
They gradually came to claim 1224 (The 1st Year of Gennin in the
reign of Emperor Gohorikawa) as the year of the start of 'Jodo
Shinshu.' In this year Shinran is assumed to have completed his main
work, Kyogyoshinsho, in which he used the term, 'Jodo Shinshu' and
revealed the Truth of this teaching.
14. In the process of the transmission of Shinshu, what is the standard
to judge whether a certain view is orthodox or not?
Broadly speaking, the standard should be the Shinshu Scriptures such
as the Three Basic Sutras, Commentaries of the Seven Patriarchs, the
Founder's writings and statements of the succeeding Patriarchs of the
Hongwanji. But the fundamental canon is the Larger Sutra and
Shinran's own writings.
15. Are there some special points which we should notice in
spreading Shinshu teachings?
Yes, for the better understanding of Shinshu and for the prevention of
unorthodox faith, the Nishi Hongwanji selected a certain number of
special topics for discussion of Doctrine and of Faith. The latter,
including 30 topics, is called 'Anjin Rondai' or 'Topics for Discussion
on Faith.' The original is not so easy to understand because of its
classical terminology and expressions. So the writer has tried to sum
up the main points of these topics and rearranged them with the hope
that it would become a helpful guide for those voluntarily working
for the spreading of Shinshu in the West.
10
14
15
The Vow is Amida's desire and resolution to save all beings. In this
Vow He selected the Name so that sentient beings can wholeheartedly believe in and easily recite it. After His sincere and hard
discipline, He brought this Vow to perfection, and thus the Name
became the only and best medium for common mortals to
communicate with the Buddha. In other words, the Name is the
fruition of the Vow. After all, the Vow refers to the 'cause,' while the
Name is the 'effect' of the Vow.
9. How do we understand the oneness of the Name and Vow?
Because of the reliability of the Buddha, His Name and His Vow
cannot be separated from each other. The Vow refers to Amida's
Compassionate Mind, through which the Name was accomplished as
the practical and expedient method to save all sentient beings. The
Name, on the other hand, can be meaningful only when it is recited
on the basis of True Faith in this Vow. Therefore, in Shinshu, to
believe in His Name is at once to believe in His Vow; to listen to the
significance of the Name is at once to listen to the significance of His
merciful Vow. After all, either the Name or the Vow may be
mentioned as the object of our 'Listening' and 'Faith.'
10. Are both the Vow and the Name necessary for Amida Buddha to
save us?
Certainly. Without the Vow, the Name would be empty; and without
the Name, the Vow would be fruitless. For the Accomplishment of
salvation, the Vow and Name are of vital necessity on the part of the
Savior, and the Faith and the Nembutsu are their reflections on the
side of the devotee.
11. It is usually said that Amida's Compassion is unlimited and
immeasurable. It seems to be so as far as we refer to the first sentence
of the Eighteenth Vow. However, the remaining part of the passage
impresses us that He will not save those beings who have committed
17
such evils as the Five Deadly Sins or the Abuse of Right Dharma.
Why is it so?
Apparently it seems to exclude those grave sins. However, according
to Shan-tao (Zendo), this is not eternal exclusion but is only the
warning which He has given for those who have the potentiality of
committing such grave sins; therefore when those sins have been
actually committed, Amida, far from forsaking them, will save those
people without any hesitation. The warning comes from His Wisdom,
and the universal salvation is due to His Compassion.
12. Did Shinran have the same idea too?
Yes, he expanded Shan-tao's theory. He paid special attention to the
fact that the 'exclusion' appears only in the Eighteenth Vow and that
this Vow was primarily for those persons who might easily commit
such grave sins. Thus he stated in His writing, Songo-ShinzoMeimon, that this 'exclusion' only shows for what kind of beings the
Eighteenth Vow was made, and that it paradoxically tells us that even
such evil persons, being the very object of Amida's concern, will be
saved without fail. After all, this warning shows Amida's unlimited
concern for all beings instead of His real and eternal exclusion of
such evil persons.
13. Are there any other important vows besides the Eighteenth Vow?
The Eleventh, Twelfth, Thirteenth, Seventeenth, and Twenty-second
Vows are also important ones. The Eleventh Vow is the vow in which
those who have Faith are assured of unfailing attainment of Nirvana.
The Twelfth and Thirteenth Vows respectively promise the
unlimitedness of His Light and Life. This means that the light and life
of anyone who has attained Buddhahood are also unlimited. The
Seventeenth Vow promises that Amida's Name shall be praised and
widely proclaimed by all Buddhas. The Name is, indeed, the object of
our Faith and recitation as taught in the Eighteenth Vow. These five
vows constitute the whole process - from the first listening to the
18
19
Faith is the true cause for being born in the Pure Land and attaining
to Nirvana. Shinran strongly emphasised the merits of Faith
perticularly from this point.
8. Why can Faith be the cause for the Pure Land and Nirvana?
Faith is awakened when one receives Amida's Compassionate and
Sincere Mind. At that moment His absolute virtues become one's own
through the Sacred Name, 'Namo-Amida-Butsu,' thus assuring one
the highest state of Nirvana.
9. If Buddha's virtues bring our Enlightenment, it appears to differ
from the Buddhist theory of 'self-cause, self-effect.' What is the
relationship between the Law of Causality and Amida's salvation?
His salvation is in accord with the fundamental ideas of Mahayana
Buddhism, e.g. 'compassionate activities,' 'benefiting others,' 'mertittransference,' etc., and certainly such activities are done within the
framework of 'cause and effect.'
Amida accomplished the Name for our sake as the decisive seed for
Nirvana. If it were not transferred to us, and we were still brought to
Buddhahood, then Amida's salvation would be a miracle which
transcends the law of causality. The reality is, however, that His pure
virtue is accepted by Faith within ourselves and it becomes our own
cause to bear such fruition. So it is not against the law of 'self-cause,
self-effect.'
10. Why does Shinshu not teach a miracle?
Amida Buddha is the manifestation of Dharma-nature (ultimate Law)
itself. And theories of 'Cause and effect,' 'Inter-dependence of all
existences,' 'Void,' 'Impermanency,' 'Egolessness' etc. are the most
fundamental truths of the universe clarified by Buddhism. If Amida
showed a miracle contrary to the Laws of 'Cause and effect,' it would
mean the death of Amida himself.
22
11. If Faith is the true cause, is any other practice necessary for
liberation?
According to the Shinshu doctrine, no other practice is required. The
Tannisho explains the reason by saying, 'If we have Faith in the
Original Vow, no other good is needed because there is no good
surpassing the Nembutsu. Nor should evil be feared, because there is
no evil capable of obstructing Amida's Original Vow,' (Chap. 1) The
Kyogyoshinsho also says 'The True cause fir Nirvana is Faith alone'.
(Vol. of Faith)
12. What is the meaning of 'Nishu-jinshin' (The Twofold Profound
Conviction) taught by Shan-tao (Zendo)?
The teaching of 'Nishu-jinshin' is to demonstrate the twofold
conviction contained in Shinshu Faith. The twofold conviction are:
1) deep conviction that we are foolish beings of karmic evils who
have passed through many illusory lives from the remote past, and
have no hope for self-deliverance; thus we are destined only to hell;
and
2) deep comprehension that the Forty-eight Vows of Amida Buddha
will save us without any discrimination and those who believe in the
Vows will be born unfailingly.
The former is the deep insight into human nature as it is; the latter is
the single-hearted reliance on Amida's Compassion which never
forsakes any sentient being.
13. How are these two related to each other?
They are two attributes of one concerete Faith of Shinshu; they
cannot be separated.
23
14. Do they arise at the same time or one after another? By 'selfpower' or 'Other Power"?
They arise at the same time. The self introspection made by 'selfpower' is not perfect. Only through the second conviction wholehearted trust in Amida's Compassion - can one attain true
insight into human nature as it is. Both of them are awakened by the
Other-Power; these two are the vital attributes of a concrete Faith in
Shinshu.
15. Deep conviction concerning Amida's Vow may continue forever.
How about the conviction that we are foolish beings of karmic evils
destined for hell? Does it continue even after the Awakening of
Faith?
It lasts till the end of life, because human nature itself does not
change even after Faith, as a stone remains a stone even after it is
placed in a boat. The only change is that after Faith, we, being
illuminated by Amida's absolute Light, become more aware of our
own karmic evil and always express our feelings of repentance and
gratitude through the Nembutsu.
24
25
26
Nembutsu at all, because all the merits are embodied in the Sacred
Name itself, and not in the form of its recitation.
28
29
His Spiritual Light'; and 'Having welling Joy in mind' are some
examples to show how Shnshu Faith helps us enjoy a happy life.
9. Is there any benefit concerned with moral effect in the Ten
Benefits?
Amida's Compassion transcends even morality; He saves all beings
without any discrimination of good and evil. Besides, the purpose of
the Awakening of Faith is wholly to receive Amida's Compassion and
thus attain Enlightenment, not mere moral improvement. However, it
is also true that Shinshu Faith, far from being anti-moral, has a moral
influence on human life, although the devotee himself is not
necessarily conscious of it. For example, there is the Benefit of
'Turning evil into good.' To turn evil into good is indeed the highest
ideal in moral life and is the essence of Mahayana Buddhism.
Shinshu shows that it is practicable for all people through receiving
Amida's absolute good and virtue. The Benefits of 'Being awakened
to Amida's Benevolence and having a desire to repay what we owe';
'Always doing works of Great Compassion'; and 'Being possessed of
the Highest Virtue;' seem to be concerned with a moral effect
although they can be actualised only through Amida's working and
are not always perceptible to sentient beings. All those benefits, after
all, come from the 'Benefit of Abiding in the Rank of the Assured'
which is the basis of our feelings of hopefulness, relief, happiness,
joy or gratitude.
10. Where can Nirvana be obtained?
The self-power schools claim that Nirvana can be attained even in
this world if one accumulates pure good and awakens absolute
wisdom in oneself. The Pure Land schools realise Nirvana through
Amida's Compassion after Birth in the Pure Land. According to the
conviction of the latter school, it is difficult for man to accomplish
such saintly disciplines in this mundane world.
11. What is the significance of Birth in the Pure Land?
31
33
34
4) In Shinshu, the Vow and the Name should not be mixed up.
Which do you believe in, the Vow or the Name? Those who
believe in the Inconceivability of the Name and recite the Nembutsu
are considered lacking in true Faith. This is the self power faith,
while those who believe in the Inconceivability of the Vow will have
true Faith by the Other Power.
("Seimyo-besshu" or "Separation of Vow and Name")
Refer to Chapter 11 of the Tannisho; Standard IV-8, 9, 10
5) Amida promised to save all beings - even the most wicked person,
without any hesitation; such is Amida's absolute Compassion.
Therefore, it is permissible to say that we may commit any evil
that we wish to; Amida will be responsible for all our deeds.
("Zoaku-muge" or "Commiting evils not being wrong1"; "Hongwanbokori" or "Excessive reliance upon the Vow")
Refer to Standard IV-6, 11, 12
6) Although Amida promised to save all, without discrimination
between wise or ignorant, good and evil, He may still hesitate to
receive such ignorant and evil persons like us. Therefore, we must
try to be wise and good so that He will be sure to save us.
("Senju-kenzen" or "Necessity of Intelligence and Goodness")
Refer to Chapter 13 of Tannisho; Standard I-3; II-4; IV-12)
7) Amida proclaimed the "Ten utterances of the Nembutsu" in the
Eighteenth Vow. Honen also called this Vow "The Vow of Birth by
the Nembutsu". On the basis of this, we can say that the utterance of
Amida's Name is the condition for Birth in the Pure Land.
("Shomyo-shonin" or "The Utterance of His Name being the true
cause")
Refer to Standard IV-7, V-11; VI-1,2,3,6,9
8) If faith is necessary and doubt is the vital obstacle to Amida's
salvation, His Compassion would not be "absolute"; Amida's
Compassion could only be called "absolute" when He could save
even those who still have doubt and cannot attain Faith. Amida's
1
35
37
38