Engineering Future
Engineering Future
Engineering Future
/Part 1
Introduction to engineering
1.
What is engineering?
49
Edition:
ISBN:
Notes:
Subjecrs:
,.,'
Part 2
Skills development
95
3. Learning to be an engineer
4.
97
Understanding communication
134
179
Management.
Other Authors/Contributors:
Dewey Number:
Part 3
Part 4
11.
Communicating information
Information skills
233
Problem-solving tools
282
Sustainable engineering
Ethics in engineering
326
372
525
1098765432
527
461
414
231
xiv
xvii
Acknowledgements
xxi
A contemporary perspective
35
Engineering innovations
Learning objectives 3
Introduction 4
What is the role of an engineer? 5
A historical perspective 6
A contemporary perspective
Engineering disciplines 8
Electrical, electronics and telecommunications
engineering 11
Mechanical engineering
Civil engineering
12
13
15
15
44
Exercises
45
18
Engineering science
Systems thinking
24
25
v i
CONTENTS
90
Exercises
90
.;.
69
120
120
122
123
128
Key terms
129
Exercises
130
Project activity
130
4. Understanding communication
95
3. Learning to be an engineer
97
Learning objectives 97
Introduction 98
Understanding your motivation to study
engineering 100
101
103
103
68
,.,'
91
71
Documentation -
Key terms
Sources of inspiration
Resources
61
Levels of reRection
88
117
64
Project management
Scheduling 69
59
60
80
115
Project activity
52
Summary
49
112
79
46
Learning objectives 49
Introduction 50
The engineering method
Step 1. Research 52
14
Mining engineering
Key terms
14
Environmental engineering
43
Project activity
Summary
110
Competencies
74
78
Lifelong learning
40
Learning styles
73
Spotlight: Olympic Dam, South Australia keeping a yel/ow cake mine below amber 74
Reflective practice
39
Limitations of engineering
Risk management
Reporting
1. What is engineering?
Time-accuracy trade-off
108
134
137
139
141
71
CONTENTS
vii
Writing notes
150
Environments
154
Communication roles
The creator 164
The gatekeeper
The consumer
164
Being professional
168
1 72
176
The procedures
vii i
183
CONTENTS
Key terms
226
Exercises
226
210
Organising a meeting
Information skills
sources 262
\ Evaluating information sources
Evaluating information
Negotiation 215
The preparation process
211
214
236 .,;.
215
Approaches to negotiation
Colleagues
Publishing information
237
250
266
267
237
248
262
263
240
A literature review
269
269
270
243
261
233
211
260
228
Categories of information
210
256
207
253
256
Knowledge
252
255
224
222
Conflict resolution
Information
207
Exercises
203
207
The participants
177
2d1
Meetings 206
The purpose 206
The timing
6.
176
Listening
196
The style
173
219
193
195
251
221
Project activity
202
Key terms
5.
189
Stakeholders
Dispute resolution
Summary
189
219
The fundamentals of an
effective group 196
167
189
174
Project activity
188
Summary
Being responsible
162
161
184
246
273
275
276
Key terms
277
Exercises
278
Project activity
278
217
CONTENTS
i x
7. Problem-solving tools
282
Project activity
System goals
287
288
290
291
Brainstorming
291
294
300
304
306
321
Exercises
322
8.
322
Sustainable engineering
Economic theories
326
Summary
314
Exercises
366
9.
401
Personal liability
369
Ethics in engineering
Summary
372
406
375
339
376
378
342
381
344
347
348
351
355
389
Behavioural tests
395
407
408
Key terms
409
Exercises
410
Project activity
,J.
333
335
366
Corporate responsibilities
and loyalties 398
315
Key terms
396
363
364
Project activity
361
357
307
Key terms
Checking
320
304
Summary
298
Sensitivity analysis
TRIZ
318
quality assurance
411
414
418
420
""
CONTENTS
CONTENTS
xi
Communication contexts
The business context 463
439
440
Construction risks
444
444
445
447
Communities of practice
449
453
454
455
456
Key terms
458
Exercises
458
Project activity
xii
CONTENTS
461
Learning objectives
Introduction 528
The skills shortage
468
Management approaches
Career planning
527
529
532
533
Summary
550
Key terms
551
Exercises
552
Project activity
472
545
548
545
Continuing professional
development (CPD) 546
525
527
Glossary
536
538
Index
554
557
564
,...
480
Project reports
484
Wikis
489
Web pages
489
Photography
491
503
459
Learning objectives
Introduction 462
520
Visual communication
Graphs 504
Exercises
545
451
519
466
Planning a communication
Approach 468
perspective
Key terms
465
448
Career management
Work to rule 545
518
Project activity
441
Summary
463
510
512
461
Engineering models
514
CONTENTS
xii i
DAVID DOWLING
DipLSurv, ARMIT, BAppSci, MSurvMap, FIEAust
Professor of Engineering Education, Coordinator Master of Engineering Practice
Faculty of Engineering and Surveying, University of Southern Queensland
avid Dowling is passionate about helping engineering students learn and achieve
their career goals and consequently much of his work and research is focused
on enhancing teaching and learning .environments. Specific areas include facilitating
student transition to university, identifying and addressing factors that influence
success at university, assessing workplace learning and defining graduate attributes and
embedding them into program curricula.
David worked as a surveyor for 12 years prior to accepting a lecturing position
at the University of Southern Queensland (USQ) in 1978. Over the next ten years
he developed numerous new subjects, taught many first-year courses, and developed
distance education materials for ten courses. David was appointed Head of Surveying
at USQ in 1989 and worked intensively with industry organisations to design, develop
and gain accreditation for three new distance education programs.
In 1995 he accepted the role of Associate Dean (Academic) in the Faculty of
Engineering and Surveying, a position he held until 2009. His major achievements
in this role included the successful accreditation of the first Australian Bachelor of
Engineering to be offered by distance education. More recently, David developed the
content, structure, and study materials for the innovative Master of Engineering Practice program. This distance education program is accredited by Engineers Australia and
enables experienced Engineering Technologists to become Professional Engineers by
using their workplace learning to demonstrate their competence.
David has been a member of the Australasian Association for Engineering Education
(AAEE) since 1998, served as an elected member of the Executive Committee from
2000 until 2007, and was President of AAEE during 2005 and 2006. David chaired
Engineers Australia's Engineering Technologist Accreditation Systems Working Party
during 2005 and 2006, and has been a member of Engineers Australia's National
Articulation Committee since 2006.
In 2006 David received the AAEE Excellence in Engineering Education Award
for Inclusive Teaching and in 2007 was awarded a USQ Citation for Outstanding
Contributions to Student Learning. In 2008 David received an Australian Learning
and Teaching Council (ALTC) Citation which read, For sustained leadership in using
graduate attributes to design and deliver programs, courses and resources that enhance students' learning and their achievement ofcareer goals.
xiv
ABOUT
THE
AUTHORS
~.
'T'
\~l
!J~:3-tr~'i
~~} -:-:,.'{
...
- ..
",~
1.'~
ANNA CAREW
BSc(Hons), PhD
Senior Lecturer, University of Tasmania
Australian Maritime College
nna Carew researches and supports the teaching and learning of undergraduate
.1""l.engineering. Her work encompasses many aspects of the undergr~duate curriculum
including mapping the teaching and assessment of graduate attributes in engineering,
supporting engineering curriculum review and renewal, engineering academics' and
students' conceptions of sustainability, key concepts in learning first-year mechanics
and transdisciplinary learning and research in engineering and engineering education.
She began working with engineers in 1996 as a water microbiologist researching
novel microbial indicators of water and wastewater quality. Following this, she worked
in industrial training at a private consultancy, engaging with engineers and operators in
chemical plants, metals refineries, and metals processing and manufacturing operations.
Between 1998 and 2000, Anna worked as a research
... consultant in sustainable water
and waste management with the Institute for Sustainable Futures, before undertaking
a PhD at the University of Sydney investigating the teaching and learning of sustain-
.;:.
ability in engineering.
Anna has supported major curriculum renewal and reaccreditation at four Australia
engineering faculties and attracted World Bank funding to assist engineering academics
in Chile to modernise curriculum (2007-08). She has also been the recipient of several
grants from the Australian Learning and Teaching Council, including leading a major
multi-institutional, cross-disciplinary project on the teaching and assessment of metaattributes in engineering (2006-08).
ABOUT
THE
AUTHORS
XV
LJOOOOOOOL
ROGER HAD GRAFT
education must become more outward looking, more attuned to the real concerns
of the communities. Courses should promote environmental, economic and global
awareness, problem solving ability, engagement with information technology, self-directedlearning and life long learning, communication, management and teamwork skills, but on
a sound base ofmathematics and engineering technology. ' The report contained a series of
recommendations that changed the way engineering was taught and-learned over the
following decade.
One of the key changes was the adoption by Engineers Australia of an outcomesfocused accreditation system for undergraduate degrees, based on a set of graduate
attributes that Engineers Australia defined through industry consultation. Over the last
decade, engineering schools have adapted their curriculum to ensure that engineering
students have opportunities to acquire these graduate attributes, in addition to those
defined by their own university. Many of the graduate attributes are introduced in firstyear subjects and students then practise and enhance those skills in subjects and projects
in the later years of their programs.
.,;,
The consultations undertaken for the Engineers for the Future project2 found that
industry supports this explicit focus on graduate attributes. It also reported on engineeringspecific graduate outcomes and attributes. They formed the view from their consultations
that 'engineers do their work by having knowledge and skills in varying combinations of
the following thematic areas: the engineering life-cycle ofconcept, design, implementation,
operation, maintenance and retirement (with increasing emphasis on uncertainty and risk
assessment as well as systems thinking, and integrating ideas and technologies); managing
complex engineeringprojects; mathematical modelling; andscientific knowledge ofestablished
and emerging areas.'2
This book is designed to provide first-year engineering students in Australia and New
Zealand with a solid grounding in many ofthese generic and engineering-specific graduate
attributes, as well as many of the tools and techniques that facilitate the application of
those skills in real engineering work and study. The book may be used as the text for one
course, or as a resource for two or more courses.
Numerous historic and contemporary Australian, New Zealand and international
examples are used to illustrate the principles that are discussed in the text, and to highlight
many of the important innovations that have built the reputation of Australian and
New Zealand engineers. The examples are drawn from a range of current engineering
disciplines, from emerging disciplines, and from a range of organisations and projects,
large and small. These examples will enable students to explore engineering and how it
oge~ Ha~graft is a ~ivil engineer wit~ more than 15 yea~s involvemen.t in impr~ving
~ngllleenng education. He has published many papers III the area, With a particular
focus on problem- and project-based learning, and the use of online technology to
support learning in this way. He was instrumental in introducing a project-based
curriculum into civil engineering at Monash University, commencing in 1998. From
2002 until 2006, his work at RMIT was in curriculum renewal to embed graduate
capabilities, specifically through a stream of project-based courses and subjects in civil,
chemical and environmental engineering, with special emphasis on new, project-based
subjects in first year.
PREFACE
"r'
-----------------------J------------------------xvi
ABOUT
THE
AUTHORS
PREFACE
xvii
11:1
rI
rI
I:lI
11:1
rI
11:1
rI
11:1
xviii
PREFACE
l:I
PREFACE
xix
rJOOOOOOO~
engineering professionals and academics to the development of this Australasian text:
Armando Apan, Ron Ayers, Lyn Brodie, Joellen Brook, Darren Burrowes, Gunilla
Burrowes, Peter Butcher, Tristram Carfrae, Roland Clift, Sandra Cochrane, Ron Coomer,
Shey Dimon, Elissa Dowling, Kristian Downing, Andrew Hoey, Kristy Jay-Baker, Brett
Kensett-Smith, Usa Kuiper, Jill Lawrence, Ian Little, Nicole Lubach, Sally Male, Cynthia
Mitchell, Matthew Preston, Steve Mogridge, David Russell, Alistair Taylor, and Helen
Williams.
The authors also want to acknowledge the important contribution of our editors.
John Coomer, the publishing editor, has journeyed with us from the start of this project
and kept us on track and on schedule. His faith in the project, and in our abilities, was
always encouraging and helped us through the hard times. His support was wide ranging
and immediate, even late on Saturday nights. Thanks John; without you the book
would not have been published. We also thank Jacqui Belesky who had the unenviable
task of editing the draft chapters into a common format and style. Her positive and
professional approach and encouraging words were always appreciated. Thanks also
to Kirsty Pedrazzini (copy editor), who saw the final drafts through production, and
Chris Harrison (copyright and image researcher). Finally, thanks to Kate Sherington
(publishing assistant) for coordinating the authoring of all of the instructor's resources.
We would also like to acknowledge the members of our families who lived the highs
and lows of this project with us. We know the many sacrifices you made to help us
meet the tight deadlines that accompany a project of this nature. Special thanks to Lyn
Dowling, Jeffrey Wright and Janice Hadgraft for their love and support.
Changing the Culture: Engineering Education into the Future, Report Summary, Institution of Engineers,
Australia, 1996, page 4.
2 Engineets fot the Future: addressing the supply and qualiry of Australian engineering graduates for the
21st century, Australian Council of Engineering Deans, 2008, p. 61. This project was funded by the
Australian Learning and Teaching Council.
1
XX
PREFACE
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
he authors and publisher would like to thank the following copyright holders,
organisations and individuals for their permission to reproduce copyright material in this book.
IMAGES
3, 282, 527: stockbyte 6: Corbis/ Chris Carroll 12: From 'The Managerial
Grid III' Blake and Mouton, Gulf Publishing, 1985. Reproduced With the permission
of Grid International 12: iStockphoto.com/ thelinke 14: Newspix / News Ltd
.28: Science Museum/ Science & Society 29: iStockphoto.com/Peter Mah 31:
Yegor Korzh, 2009 Used under license from Shutterstock.com 32: AAP/ AP
Photo/ New Zealand Herald/ Brett Phibbs 34: Snowy Hydro Limited 35: (c)
Viewfinder Australia Photo Library 36: Courtesy of Professor Yusuf Chisti, Massey
University, New Zealand 37: Newspix/ David Kapernick 38: Planetary Power
40, 115, 195,328: Digital Vision 49: Corbis 51: Reuters/ Picture Media
.53,418: PhotoDisc, Inc 61, 103: John Wiley & Sons Australia/ Photo by Renee
Bryon. 66: A composite weather satellite imagl!" from MTSAT-1R, 20 March 2006,
7.30am (eastern summer time), showing Tropical Cyclone Larry over the Queensland
coast. 68: Photolibrary/ SPL/ David Parker 74: Picture Media/ Reuters 77:
Townsville City Council 81: Engineers Australia, 2009 81: IPENZ 86:
Reproduced with the permission of Ford Motor Company of Australia Ltd 97:
iStockphoto.com/ Yuri Arcurs 98, 99: Parsons Brinckerhoff 101: Nicole Lubach
105: David Dowling 118: iStockphoto.com/ Andersen Oystein 134, 461:
Digital Vision 135: Fairfax Photo Library/ Ray Kennedy 151: Newspix/ Marc
McCormack 156: TrackStar Alliance Staff 179: iStockphoto.com/ deanm 1974
180: Image Source 187: Photolibrary/ Age fotostock/ Michael N Paras 192:
ATSA Defence Services 203: iStockphoto.com/ urbancow 214: Newspix/
Chris Mangan 220, 221: Aurecon Consulting Engineers 224: NSW Roads
and Traffic Authority 233: blue jean images 234: Engineers Without Borders
.252: AECOM 260: Getty Images/ Stone/ Erik Dreyer 265: NASA 271:
Newspix/ Marc Robertson 289: National Academy of Engineering 297: Photo
by Mikel024 297: iStockphoto.com/ Verity Johnson 298: Wilkinson Eyre
Architects 310: Shotover Jet, Queenstown, New Zealand 316: iStockphoto.
com/ Dainis Derics 319: SkyCity 326: iStockphoto.com/ inkastudio 332:
David Neilson 340: Ngarda Civil & Mining Pty Ltd 343: Dreamworld
347: City of Cockburn 356: Fairfax Photo Library/ Robert Pearce 362: Fairfax
Photo Library/ Rob Rough 372: iStockphoto.com/ Claudio Baba 386: Kirsten
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
xxi