30 4 Nutrition
30 4 Nutrition
30 4 Nutrition
FARMING
MATTERS
Reclaiming
nutrition
ANNOUNCEMENT
www.farmingmatters.org
Follow us:
@agriculturesnet @ileia_NL
www.facebook.com/agricultures
ADVERTISEMENT
FARMERS IN FOCUS
Nutrition from
diversity
CONTENTS
8
12
16
20
4 | Farming Matters | December 2014
Farmers in focus
Rural-urban linkages
When directly engaging with farmers, citizens play an active
role in shaping the way their food is produced. Involvement
ranges from direct purchase via farm shops and box schemes,
to talking with farmers about what to produce and how, to
providing inputs such as labour, seeds, knowledge or finance.
Many such initiatives are driven by young people. Some are
institutionalised, as in public purchasing programmes or food
policy councils. Chefs also play a role in strengthening these
linkages as they seek fresh, local produce.
As a result, new agroecological practices have developed and
the nutrient cycles are closing, leading to healthier farming
systems and fewer food miles. Food cultures are developing
around territoriality, seasonality, freshness and fair prices.
These emerging ideas are even challenging architects and
city planners to rethink the design of sewerage and recycling
systems, under the concept of urban-rural metabolism.
This trend goes against what many academics and politicians
say are the effects of the industrialisation and globalisation
of agrifood systems. They believe that rural societies will
disappear, both in demographic and cultural terms, and
family farmers will either move out of agriculture, or operate
only as large enterprises. In this view, family farming is
not seen as a social, cultural and political category in its
own right, as a way of life, but merely as a professional
sector that must be integrated into agri-business chains.
But these prophecies remain unconfirmed. Although ruralurban relations have radically altered, what we are seeing
is a reaffirmation of ways of living that are typical of the
countryside and the peasantry. These local responses to
globalisation are based on principles of agroecology and
multifunctionality, rather than the logic of business and
finance. They show that family farmers remain a determining
force in the 21st century, forging promising pathways together
with citizens to tackle the food, environmental and climate
crises.
Issue 31.2 of Farming Matters will focus on relations between
the rural and urban worlds. We are looking for stories on
groundbreaking initiatives on how family farmers and
citizens collaborate. How do family farmers respond to
changing urban consumption patterns? How is knowledge
about food and farming co-created between rural and urban
communities? What is the role of youth and of women? Are
there examples of successful marketing strategies to promote
food from family farms in the cities? What difficulties were
faced and what responses were found? We look forward to
your insightful stories and practical evidence.
Articles for the June 2015 issue of Farming Matters
should be sent to the editors before 1 March 2015.
Email: info@farmingmatters.org
back to
the future
Nutrition has become one of the buzz words of the year, like resilience, and
landscapes. What they have in common is that they refer to complex situations
with political forces competing over the backs of rural and urban communities.
The nutrition challenge is clear with a billion hungry people on this planet
and another two billion overweight it is time to act. Persistent hunger and
undernutrition are inexcusable in a world of plenty. But the crucial question is:
who should act and how?
Edith van Walsum
Linking
family
nutrition
Traditional varieties of potato are back on the menu again, each with their own distinctive taste.
Photo: EkoRural
Photos: EkoRural
Nutrition
from innovation,
and taste
from waste
Finding a way
out of the
maize
Kenyan mothers are the key actors in family farming. Photo: Bozena Baluchova
But so much has changed today. Horticultural knowhow, supermarket convenience and even food fashions
dominate our world. These influence our choices when it
comes to what we find on our plates, though the possibility
of bringing back more diversity is ever present. We talk
about conserving biological diversity and agrobiodiversity,
but the crucial next step is surely to incorporate this into
our eating habits. We need to introduce the genes of these
multiple species to our own genes, and so help our bodies
to adapt and evolve within our changing world. We need
dietary diversity.
Last year I attended a meeting in Uganda with Slow Food
International that launched the 10,000 Gardens in Africa
project. We attended training courses in various small
villages where the great Ankhole-Watusi longhorn cattle
roam. Our meals, be it breakfast, lunch or dinner, had at
least seven species per plate. Sometimes double that. Each
meal was also accompanied by a local and very bitter variety
of eggplant that aids digestion. And on every plate there
was something to satisfy every taste.
Understanding the health of the individual requires an
understanding of the context of family, community and
culture. How do we view health and how does nutrition
fit into this? Africa is rich in heritage and full of diversity,
of species, cultures, languages and recipes. These instill a
sense of identity within each individual, especially important
during post-colonial confusion. Yet we are now living in a
time where ocean and land grabbing are huge threats,
and corporate control is usurping local knowledge and
giving us only cut and paste solutions to our many current
problems. Our identity should give us cultural pride and
remind us what it is we are fighting for. We are fighting for
diversity, reconnecting with our history, and fostering a new
custodianship with our land.
From
biodiversity
to dietary
diversity
Guinea pigs
small livestock
with big potential
Guinea pigs
The guinea pig (Cavia porcellus) is neither from
Guinea nor a member of the pig family. This
rodent, also known as cuy, cobayo and cavy in Latin
America, was domesticated in pre-Columbian
times, and is a well-known source of meat in Peru,
Ecuador, Bolivia and southern Colombia. There are
an estimated 36 million guinea pigs in this region,
where they are an important source of food as well
as having spiritual and medicinal value. They are
also reports of increasing interest in guinea pigs as
a potential source of meat elsewhere in the world.
As herbivores, guinea pigs naturally feed on large
quantities of forage such as grasses, legumes,
weeds and herbs. But they can also be fed on
kitchen scraps and are very good processors of
waste. Adult guinea pigs weigh between 1 and 2
kg and can provide a familys protein needs for a
day, though the meat is enjoyed for its taste as well
as its nutritional value. The meat contains more
than 20% protein, which is higher than in chicken,
beef, lamb or pork. And with only about 8% fat,
it is also leaner than most other common meats.
It is also rich in Omega 3 fatty acids and Vitamin
B, and as such is a healthier as well as cheaper
alternative to other meats.
Compared to raising other livestock, breeding guinea pigs is a relatively easy venture to get off the ground.
Photo: Eduardo Lopez Rosse A
India
The
Gambia
I
Collective milk and manure
n 1997, falling groundnut yields and prices led
60 families in the Upper River Region of the
Gambia to start the Misera Livestock Farmers
Association (MLFA). Seeking to increase their
incomes, they began to collectively manage a farm,
supported by the Womens Bureau, the Department
of Livestock Services, and the Livestock and
Horticulture Development Project. Membership has
grown to 100 families and besides farming together,
a communal spirit is thriving thanks to social and
religious gatherings. Their focus on local breeds of
sheep and goats has also led to other benefits. This
initiative not only improves our income, it is also
improving the quality of our diets, says Tida Danso.
Income is generated from live animal sales, while up
to two litres of milk per day became available for the
Afghanistan
East Timor
Food
fairs
revive local food
and improve nutrition
n Ghana as in many other countries, government policies tend to give far greater support to
the production of cash crops for export, than to
local food crops that play a vital role for good
nutrition and food security. This is especially
marked in the more arid northern regions of
Ghana that are most affected by climate change and
declining soil fertility. This has led to the paradoxical
situation where the country is experiencing increasing
economic growth generated by agriculture, based on
export crops such as cocoa, pineapples and bananas,
while at the same time food and nutrition insecurity in
rural households in the drier regions of the north are
also on the rise.
To advocate for the production of more food to feed
the family, to diversify crops to include local foods for
nutrition, and to reduce risks caused by climate
change, CIKOD organised a traditional food fair in
June 2011 in the district of Lawra in Upper West
Region. More than three hundred women farmers, led
by their traditional female leaders and hundreds of
men and children from the Lawra and Nandom areas,
participated in an exhibition of indigenous foods and
seeds.
Proudly displaying nutritious traditional dishes at the food fair. Photo: Groundswell International
The socio-cultural setting of the fair was also important. The local tradition of having a fair, being familiar
to the many farmers who attended, made people feel
comfortable. The fair was based on local knowledge
and local resources which added to a sense of ownership by the men and women farmers who attended.
Morale at the fair was boosted by the wide publicity
provided through radio, television and print media.
This was possible because of CIKODs good relationships with journalists. Various publications all had
positive captions encouraging everyone to patronise
traditional crops and food.
Women celebrate the benefits of agroecology and healthy food. Photo: Groundswell International
Gastronomy
is a search for tasty, local,
nutritious food
Promoting the holistic nature of nutrition and its links
with gastronomy is Luis Ginocchios bread and butter
as the expression goes. For Perus former minister of
Agriculture, who also authored the book Small farming
and food, it is an overriding interest. Gastronomy
is defined as the practice of choosing, cooking, and
eating good food, or the cookery of a particular region.
Ginocchio links it directly to nutrition and local food
production systems.
Interview: Teobaldo Pinzs
OPINION
Will the
Green
Revolution
really
nutritionalise
Africa?
This annual collection of thoughts and figures on agriculture and agricultural production by the worlds leading organization devoted to food-related issues, is this
year dedicated to family farming. The annex tables are as informative as ever,
providing an overview of key information regarding trends in land holdings and
labour. But the meat is in the text. The pivotal role family farmers play in ensuring
that humanity is able to feed itself is clearly expressed. A very thorough review of
all recent and relevant literature tries to find out what strategy should be taken
towards small family farms? The findings stress the importance of recognizing
their diversity and the need to improve supplementary or alternative employment
and income. However, FAO continue to promote the possibility of sustainable
productivity growth for poverty reduction and improved food security. To achieve
this, it argues for two interrelated pathways: development and application of new
technologies and practices via farmer-led and formal research; and application
and adaptation of existing technologies and processes alongside traditional integrated farming systems. All in all it provides hope that we are beginning to see
the light, but ensuring that this light burns brightly and continuously is another
matter.
This excellent publication is full of essential reading and valuable figures on nutrition-related issues. It is aimed at nutrition champions and their allies. The authors
propose three types of complementary strategies to address challenges underlying malnutrition and hunger: nutrition-specific, nutrition sensitive, and enabling
environmental investments. The report concludes that these strategies can have
high human and economic returns. But the report fails to highlight the vital role of
family farmers, especially women, in combating hunger and malnutrition, a
notable omissionin a document that appears in the International Year of Family
Farming. Thereby, it overlooks the tremendous actual and potential contribution
of 500 million family farmers to local and global food and nutrition security.
Deep Roots
J. Griffiths (ed.), 2014. Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO),
Rome, Italy, and Tudor Rose, UK. 256 pages.
To celebrate the International Year of family Farming, FAO produced this extensive tome dedicated to stories surrounding the actual and potential future benefits of family farming. Deep Roots contains some 70 specially commissioned articles on diverse aspects of family farming from around the world, including regional overview papers that summarise the current situation and recent developments in each. ILEIA also contributed with an agroecological perspective in Unlocking the potential of family farmers with agroecology (pages 42-45), followed
by articles on gender and youth. FAOS Director General Jose Graziano da Silva
tells us that out of 570 million farms in the world, 500 million are family owned,
making the well-being of farm families inextricably woven into the overall wellbeing of societies, with tremendous implications for food production and sustainability. He also confirms the organisations commitment to supporting FAO
member states in shaping enabling policies and the knowledge environment for
family farming in the years to come. Many photos in the book, including the cover
photo, are entries in the AgriCultures Networks Family Farming Photo Competition.
For most of the last 50 years, food production has increased ahead of population
growth, with much of this coming from small scale family farms. Why then are such
households still disproportionately vulnerable to undernutrition? The report does
not address this question, as the real answer would indicate that more extreme
actions are needed than the general recommendations put forward. These are
that smallholder agricultural development can be an excellent way to reduce
poverty and tackle hunger, that patterns of agricultural development need steering towards more diversified food production, and that smallholder agricultural
programmes need backing up with primary health care, clean water and sanitation, female empowerment and other interventions. No-one may disagree with
any of these, but it appears that much more is required, and that would involve a
radical change in mindset regarding a rebalancing of power between family farms
and local food systems, and the farming for profit agri-business model that currently dominates.
The New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition (G8NA), was inaugurated in
2012 as a commitment by the governments of the G8, African countries and corporate sector partners to lift 50 million people out of poverty in ten years by unleashing the power of the private sector. Ten African countries have signed cooperation agreements and several domestic and international companies have
pledged to invest in areas relevant to food security and nutrition, amounting to
more than US$7 billion. The G8NA has been heavily criticized, however, and this
report adds to the discussion. Core problems with the initiative are highlighted,
including governance of the alliance, the dominance of large corporate actors,
and that it is poorly integrated into existing international processes and agreements. It concludes with a call halting the G8NA altogether unless radical changes
are implemented, such as greater transparency, more civil society participation,
and framing options within Committee on World Food Security principles and
guidelines.
PERSPECTIVES >
hunger
and
malnutrition!
REFLECTIONS > A
T THE CLOSE OF THE INTERNATIONAL
YEAR OF FAMILY FARMING
Towards
stronger
family farms
1. Cross-sectoral approaches
Discussions on family farming should also address urbanisation, rural infrastructure, traditional and indigenous knowledge and culture, education and support
services, and youth development. A cross-sectoral and
territorial approach was emphasised, such as in integrated rural development programmes. Diversified
agroecological practices that use local knowledge
should be promoted as the basis for climate resilience,
and the importance of expanding income opportunities in rural areas were also highlighted, including off
farm income and agritourism.
2. Agrarian reform
Improving access to land and water should be prioritised through special land use and water management
programmes. The right of farmers to produce, reproduce, exchange and sell their seeds must be protected,
because without land, water and seeds, no peasant
family farming is possible. Land grabbing was condemned, and there was a call for a moratorium on
industrial agrofuel production. Overwhelming worldwide support was expressed for governments to implement the Voluntary Guidelines on Responsible Governance of Tenure of Land, Fisheries and Forests, considered as the best way to guarantee access to natural
resources for small scale family farmers, especially
women, youth and indigenous peoples.
Trade agreements and trade policies should be reformed or reconsidered, in order to better serve family
farmers. Governments and other actors must guarantee the human, economic, social and cultural rights of
small scale family farmers and food workers, and
strengthen their access to markets and ensure fair
prices, for example through the promotion of local
markets, public purchasing from family farmers, and
improved storage and transport. The value of food
from family farming can be enhanced by establishing
rules of origin, creating specific family farming labels,
and providing information on its nutritional and
health value.
The generation and gender gaps are the biggest threats to family farming. Photos: Claudia Calder.
6. Gender equity
7. Stronger farmer
organisations
The importance of producer organisations was emphasised, to balance the economic and political power of
other actors, and to consolidate the voice of family
farmers in policy making processes. Key areas were the
need for governments to include farmer organisations
in dialogue and decision making, capacity building
programmes that are family farmer-centred, owned and
led, climate change adaptation and value addition.
Proposed activities included education and training
A synthesis of
recommendations
Throughout 2014, regional dialogues, civil society
consultations, regional conferences and other
events explored issues related to family farming.
Many of these were (co-)organised by the Food
and Agriculture Organization of the United
Nations, the lead agency for the International Year
of Family Farming. Across the regions,
a set of key, common building blocks
were identified to better support family
farmers, raised by representatives of
farmer organisations, governments,
academia, international institutions
and NGOs, amongst others. These
are summarised in this article,
adapted from the publication
Towards stronger family farms.
Voices in the International Year of
Family Farming (ILEIA/FAO, October 2014). It is
available in three languages at www.ileia.org.
9. Attracting youth
This is
our year
Groundbreaking
Agroecology
Symposium
Promoting climate
resilience in West
Africa
Landscapes in Lima
COLOPHON
Farming Matters
Address
P.O. Box 90, 6700 AB,
Wageningen, the Netherlands
Farming Matters is
published quarterly by
ILEIA
Visitors address
Lawickse Allee 11, 6701 AN
Wageningen, the Netherlands
Tel: +31 (0)317 760 010
E-mail: ileia@ileia.org
www.ileia.org
Experiences in family
farming and agroecology
www.farmingmatters.org
Layout
Yvonne Dijkshoorn Twin Media bv,
Culemborg,
the Netherlands
Printing
Koninklijke BDU Grafisch
Bedrijf B.V., Barneveld,
the Netherlands.
Funding
ILEIA is grateful for the
support of Sida, the Swedish
International Development
Cooperation Agency.
Cover photo
Taken in Guatemala by
Roberto Luna.
When nourishing
ourselves and
eating with our
family, friends,
and community,
we reaffirm our
cultural identities,
interdependence
with nature, control
of our life course and
human dignity.
Civil society declaration to the ICN2 Nutrition
Conference, Rome, 21 November 2014, page 36
Farming Matters is published by ILEIA, the Centre for Learning on Sustainable Agriculture.
ILEIA is a member of AgriCultures, a global network of organisations that share knowledge
and provide information on small scale, sustainable agriculture worldwide.
www.farmingmatters.org