Reviews: Circulating Micrornas As Novel Biomarkers For Diabetes Mellitus
Reviews: Circulating Micrornas As Novel Biomarkers For Diabetes Mellitus
Introduction
Diabetes mellitus affects >350million people worldwide
and makes a considerable contribution to morbidity and
mortality globally.1 In industrialized countries, diabetes
mellitus is the leading cause of blindness, renal failure
and nontraumatic lower limb amputations. Patients
with diabetes mellitus also have an increased risk of
developing cardiovascular disorders and having a stroke,
which means that this disease is a heavy socioeconomic
burden.2 Unfortunately, the prevalence of diabetes mel
litus is increasing at a dramatic pace both in children and
in adults as a result of changes in lifestyle (reduced physi
cal activity and increased overnutrition and obesity),
but also as a consequence of population ageing. Indeed,
according to estimates from the International Diabetes
Federation, 552million people are expected to have
diabetes mellitus in 2030.1
This Review focuses on type1 diabetes mellitus
(T1DM) and type2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM), the two
principal forms of the disease. T1DM is an autoimmune
disorder in which pancreatic cells are attacked and
eliminated by the immune system. During the immune
response, leucocytes infiltrating the pancreatic islets
secrete proinflammatory cytokines that recruit cyto
toxic Tlymphocytes and contribute to cell dysfunction
and death.3 The immune reaction leads to progressive
destruction of cells, which results in severe or com
plete insulin deficiency. T1DM generally develops during
Competing interests
The authors declare no competing interests.
University of Lausanne,
Department of
Fundamental
Neurosciences, Rue
duBugnon 9, 1005
Lausanne, Switzerland
(C. Guay, R. Regazzi).
Correspondence to:
R. Regazzi
romano.regazzi@unil.ch
REVIEWS
Key points
New biomarkers are needed to improve the identification of individuals at risk
of developing diabetes mellitus and its associated complications, monitor
disease progression and assess the efficacy of therapeutic interventions
Circulating microRNAs (miRNAs) are attractive biomarker candidates as they
can be easily collected, are stable under different storage conditions and can
be measured using assays that are specific, sensitive and reproducible
Pioneering studies have identified characteristic changes in blood levels of
miRNAs in samples from a range of cohorts of patients with diabetes mellitus
However, definitive miRNA signatures for type1 diabetes mellitus, type2 diabetes
mellitus or their associated complications remain to be defined and agreed upon
Although measuring circulating miRNAs is a promising approach in individuals
at risk of developing diabetes mellitus, several key issues still need to
be addressed, including the determination of the most appropriate blood
sampling protocols
www.nature.com/nrendo
2013 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved
REVIEWS
Thus, early and lifestyle-independent predictive factors
are currently required to enable physicians to recognize
individuals at risk of developing T2DM.
miRNAs
miRNAs are small non-coding RNA molecules of 2123
nucleotides that function as translational repressors by par
tially pairing to the 3' untranslated region of target mRNAs
(Box2). These regulators of gene expression were first dis
covered in Caenorhabditis elegans,14,15 and then in verte
brates and plants.16 According to the latest estimates, the
human genome encodes >1,600 miRNA precursors, gener
ating up to 2,237 mature miRNAs,17 each of which has the
potential to control hundreds of targets. Now, miRNAs are
universally recognized as major regulators of gene expres
sion and key controllers of several biologic and pathologic
processes.18 They are produced from stem-loop precursor
RNAs that are generated from independent transcriptional
units or from introns of genes that encode proteins (Box2).
These primary transcripts (pri-miRNAs) are initially pro
cessed to produce short RNA molecules (pre-miRNAs)
and are then exported to the cytosol where they are
further cleaved to generate the mature forms of miRNAs
(Figure1). The mature miRNAs can either be included in
the RNA-induced silencing complex to guide translational
repression of target mRNAs or bereleasedbythe cells.
Ifthey are to be released, the miRNAs become attached to
proteins or lipoproteins or are loaded inside vesicles that
are released into the extracellular space during plasma
membrane blebbing or after fusion of multivesicular bodies
with the plasma membrane (Figure1).
Drosha
2
Exportin-5
pri-miRNA
pre-miRNA
Dicer
Nucleus
Multivesicular bodies
RISC
4
miRNA
mRNA target
Argonaute-2
HDL
Protein complex
Lipoproteins
Microvesicles
Exosomes
REVIEWS
RNA-binding protein
Lipoprotein
Exosome
Blood
vessel
1
HDL
Receiving cells
Fusion
Receptors
Endocytosis
Figure 2 | Blood and other body fluids contain active miRNAs. miRNAs can
bereleased or shed by cells and are found in a stable form in body fluids.
ThemiRNAs present in the blood are associated with protein complexes such
asArgonaute2 or with HDL particles, or are transported inside membrane-bound
vesicles such as exosomes (1). Evidence suggests that circulating miRNAs can be
taken up in active form through different mechanisms, including receptor-mediated
capture, endocytosis or fusion of exosomes with the plasma membrane of
receiving cells (2). Transfer of miRNAs between distantly located cells constitutes
a potentially new communication mode. Abbreviation: miRNA, microRNA.
Box 3 | Exosomes
Exosomes are microvesicles of 30120nm that were first observed to be
released by reticulocytes in the 1980s.9698 Since then, exosomes have been
detected in the culture media of most cell types and are abundant in several
body fluids, such as blood, urine, saliva and breast milk.43 The concentration
of exosomes in the blood has been estimated to be ~3million per l.99 These
vesicles display a characteristic size, form and lipid bilayer structure that can be
visualized by electron microscopy. Exosome markers, such as the tetraspanins
CD63 and CD81 and the Escort proteins Alix and Tsg101, are also routinely used
to distinguish exosomes from other vesicles secreted by cells. Detailed analysis
of the exosome content revealed that they can carry proteins and nucleic acids
(such as mRNAs, microRNAs and long non-coding RNAs).39,100 The interest in
exosomes has increased dramatically in the past 5years, following the discovery
that their cargo can be transferred in active form to recipient cells,39,101,102 which
led to the exciting concept of exosomes as messengers of a new cell-to-cell
communication mode. However, the precise mechanisms leading to exosome
release and/or uptake remain to be elucidated. Exosomes are produced inside
cells via the multivesicular endosomal pathway,97,98 but very little is known about
the selective packaging of nucleic acids and proteins composing the exosome
cargo. An improved understanding of these mechanisms might reveal new biologic
roles for exosomes in the healthy state, but also in pathophysiological conditions.
www.nature.com/nrendo
2013 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved
REVIEWS
Table 1 | Blood miRNA changes associated with diabetes mellitus
Study
Study design
Source
Method of analysis
miRNAs identified
Observations
Zampetaki
etal.
(2010)50
Plasma
Microarray profiling
(confirmed by qPCR)
miR15a, miR28-3p,
miR29b, miR126 and
miR223
Kong etal.
(2011)51
56 individuals with
health conditions
related to diabetes
mellitus
Serum
qPCR on specific
miRNAs
Deregulated in T2DM
Karolina
etal.
(2012)52
Blood
Microarray profiling
(confirmed by qPCR)
miR150, miR192,
miR27a, miR320a
andmiR375
Correlation between
raised levels of fasting
glucose and altered levels
of miR27a and miR320a
Nielsen
etal.
(2012)53
Serum
Microarray profiling
(confirmed by qPCR)
miR24, miR25,
miR26a,miR27a,
miR27b, miR29a,
miR-30a-5p, miR148a,
miR152, miR181a,
miR200a and miR210
miR25 negatively
correlated with residual
cell function
Sebastiani
etal.
(2012)54
20 patients newly
diagnosed with
T1DM
Serum
Microarray profiling
(confirmed by qPCR)
Deregulated in T1DM
Salas-Perez
etal.
(2012)56
20 patients with
T1DM
PBMCs
qPCR on specific
miRNAs
Underexpressed in T1DM
Sebastiani
etal.
(2011)57
19 patients with
T1DM
Lymphocytes
qPCR on specific
miRNAs
miR326
T2DM
T1DM
Abbreviations: T1DM, type1 diabetes mellitus; T2DM, type2 diabetes mellitus; miRNA, microRNA; PBMC, peripheral blood mononuclear cell; qPCR, quantitative
real-time PCR.
REVIEWS
(miR31, miR146a, miR155, miR181a and miR199a)
or of cells (miR9 and miR34a). A miRNA abundantly
expressed in the islets of Langerhans, miR375, has been
proposed as a suitable biomarker to detect cell death and
to predict the development of T1DM in animal models.55
Indeed, massive cell loss elicited by administration of
streptozocin caused a dramatic rise in circulating levels
ofthis miRNA.55 Moreover, plasma levels of miR375 were
considerably increased in NOD mice 2weeks before the
onset of T1DM.55 The changes in levels of miR375 con
sequent to cell death were short-lived (<1week). Thus,
these promising findings obtained in mice will need to
be verified in humans, as the decline in cell mass takes
much longer in humans than in NOD mice.
Instead of analysing plasma samples, other studies have
focused their attention on blood cells and measured the
expression of specific miRNAs that are thought to have
important roles in the immune reaction that leads to T1DM.
Salas-Prez etal.56 observed diminished expression of
miR21a and miR93 in peripheral blood mononuclear cells
(PBMC) of patients with T1DM compared with healthy
control individuals. The reduction of miR21a (but not
of miR93) expression could be reproduced by incubating
PBMC from control individuals in a medium containing
25mmol/l of glucose, suggesting that the reduced levels of
miR21a might be the consequence of chronic hypergly
caemia. Finally, Sebastiani and colleagues analysed miRNA
expression in blood lymphocytes from patients with T1DM
and observed a rise in levels of miR326 that correlated with
the timing of the islet autoimmune attack.57 The primary
goal of the latter two studies was to identify miRNAs that
could be involved in the development of T1DM. However,
as a large proportion of miRNAs in serum are released by
blood cells, it is possible that the miRNA changes in PBMC
and/or lymphocytes observed in these two studies might
yield detectable differences in plasma levels that would
enable the autoimmune reaction to be monitored.
www.nature.com/nrendo
2013 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved
REVIEWS
Gestational diabetes mellitus
Circulating miRNAs could in principle also be used
to identify women at increased risk of developing
gestational diabetes mellitus. Most screening protocols
are currently based on a glucose challenge test performed
around weeks2428 of gestation. Therefore, interven
tions such as diet, exercise or medication are sometimes
started as late as 32weeks of gestation. In a multistage
retrospective study, the miRNAs in serum of women at
1619weeks of gestation were screened. Three miRNAs
(miR29a, miR122 and miR132) were identified that
were deregulated in women developing gestational dia
betes mellitus before changes in blood levels of glucose
became detectable.80 Placental-specific miRNAs can also
be detected in maternal serum.44,81 Thus, it is possible
that gestational diabetes mellitus might lead to changes
in the levels of miRNAs in blood that differ from those
of T1DM or T2DM.
Future directions
The findings described in this article confirm that
miRNAs are attractive novel biomarkers for diabetes
mellitus. Indeed, changes in the levels of a subset of these
small RNA molecules in body fluids promise to provide
new clues for early identification of individuals at risk of
developing diabetes mellitus and the complications asso
ciated with this disorder, for following disease progression
and for assessing the efficacy of therapeutic interventions.
However, major scientific and technical advances need to
be made before these goals can be achieved.
On the basis of the current data, circulating miRNAs
should be able to be used to substitute or complement
other routine measurements in the future. Thus, their
efficacy in predicting the occurrence of diabetes mellitus
or its complications needs to be systematically compared
with biomarkers that are already available. In particu
lar, it will be essential to scrutinize whether miRNAs
are indeed able to provide earlier and/or more precise
detection of individuals at risk of developing the disease
or its long-term complications than current biomarkers.
Thesituation will hopefully evolve in the future; however,
there is currently no obvious advantage to replacing
other traditional biomarkers with measurements of levels
of circulating miRNAs.
Different papers have reported changes in levels of
miRNAs that are associated with diabetes mellitus or its
complications but, for various reasons, we are still very
far from a consensus about the most relevant miRNAs
to be measured. This lack of agreement can in part
be attributed to the heterogeneity of the approaches
selected by investigators. Some of the published studies
carried out systematic profiling of a large number of
miRNAs,50,52,53 whereas others focused on a small group
of selected miRNAs that were supposedly most likely
to be affected in patients with diabetes mellitus.51,5557
These approaches yielded a large number of potentially
interesting candidate biomarkers, but most of them still
awaitconfirmation by independent researchers and/or
in larger cohorts. Standardized protocols for sample
preparation, RNA extraction and miRNA analysis are
REVIEWS
Conclusions
miRNAs are emerging as important regulators of gene
expression and central players in many physiological and
pathological processes. Their presence in extracellular
fluids in astonishingly stable forms has led to the idea
of using them as biomarkers for a variety of diseases.
These properties have also attracted the attention of
diabetologists who have initiated the search for miRNAs
that enable early detection of T1DM and T2DM and
their associated complications. A number of scientific
and methodological issues need to be addressed before
circulating miRNAs can attain the status of biomarkers of
diabetes mellitus, but the available data suggest that they
will soon serve as valuable new blood parameters that will
help physicians to refine their therapeutic interventions.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
Review criteria
We systematically searched PubMed using different
combinations of the following words: diabetes, type1
diabetes, type2 diabetes, gestational diabetes,
diabetes complications, diabetic retinopathy,
diabetic nephropathy, cardiovascular complications,
biomarkers, microRNAs, circulating miRNAs
and exosomes. We also scrutinized the appropriate
references cited in the selected papers. Two abstracts
from the 2012 European Association for the Study of
Diabetes meeting held in Berlin were also included. Owing
to space limitations, not all original articles on the subject
could be listed in the present review. Whenever possible,
the most recent and complete reviews on the topic were
chosen. All selected articles are in English.
www.nature.com/nrendo
2013 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved
REVIEWS
46. Chen, X. etal. Characterization of microRNAs
inserum: a novel class of biomarkers for
diagnosis of cancer and other diseases.
CellRes. 18, 9971006 (2008).
47. Lawrie, C.H. etal. Detection of elevated levels
of tumour-associated microRNAs in serum of
patients with diffuse large Bcell lymphoma.
Br.J.Haematol. 141, 672675 (2008).
48. Alevizos, I. & Illei, G.G. MicroRNAs as
biomarkers in rheumatic diseases. Nat. Rev.
Rheumatol. 6, 391398 (2010).
49. Wang, J.F. etal. Serum miR146a and miR223
as potential new biomarkers for sepsis.
Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 394, 184188
(2010).
50. Zampetaki, A. etal. Plasma microRNA profiling
reveals loss of endothelial miR126 and other
microRNAs in type2 diabetes. Circ. Res. 107,
810817 (2010).
51. Kong, L. etal. Significance of serum microRNAs
in pre-diabetes and newly diagnosed type2
diabetes: a clinical study. Acta Diabetol. 48,
6169 (2011).
52. Karolina, D.S. etal. Circulating miRNA profiles
inpatients with metabolic syndrome. J. Clin.
Endocrinol. Metab. 97, E2271E2276 (2012).
53. Nielsen, L.B. etal. Circulating levels of
microRNA from children with newly diagnosed
type1 diabetes and healthy controls: evidence
that miR25 associates to residual beta-cell
function and glycaemic control during disease
progression. Exp. Diabetes Res. 2012, 896362
(2012).
54. Sebastiani, G. etal. MicroRNA expression
fingerprint in serum of type1 diabetic patients.
Diabetologia 55, S48 (2012).
55. Erener, S., Mojibian, M., Fox, J.K., Denroche,H.C.
& Kieffer, T.J. Circulating miR375 as a biomarker
of -cell death and diabetes in mice. Endocrinology
154, 603608 (2013).
56. Salas-Perez, F. etal. MicroRNAs miR21a and
miR93 are down regulated in peripheral blood
mononuclear cells (PBMCs) from patients with
type1 diabetes. Immunobiology 218, 733737
(2013).
57. Sebastiani, G. etal. Increased expression of
microRNA miR326 in type1 diabetic patients
with ongoing islet autoimmunity. Diabetes Metab.
Res. Rev. 27, 862866 (2011).
58. Winer, N. & Sowers, J.R. Epidemiology of
diabetes. J. Clin. Pharmacol. 44, 397405
(2004).
59. Fichtlscherer, S. etal. Circulating microRNAs in
patients with coronary artery disease. Circ. Res.
107, 677684 (2010).
60. Fish, J.E. etal. miR126 regulates angiogenic
signaling and vascular integrity. Dev. Cell 15,
272284 (2008).
61. Wang, S. etal. The endothelial-specific microRNA
miR126 governs vascular integrity and
angiogenesis. Dev. Cell 15, 261271 (2008).
62. Caporali, A. etal. Deregulation of microRNA503
contributes to diabetes mellitus-induced
impairment of endothelial function and
reparative angiogenesis after limb ischemia.
Circulation 123, 282291 (2011).
63. Creemers, E.E., Tijsen, A.J. & Pinto, Y.M.
Circulating microRNAs: novel biomarkers and
extracellular communicators in cardiovascular
disease? Circ. Res. 110, 483495 (2012).
64. van Empel, V.P., De Windt, L.J.
&daCostaMartins, P.A. Circulating miRNAs:
reflecting oraffecting cardiovascular disease?
Curr. Hypertens. Rep. 14, 498509 (2012).
65. Pambianco, G. etal. The 30-year natural history
of type1 diabetes complications: the Pittsburgh
Epidemiology of Diabetes Complications Study
experience. Diabetes 55, 14631469 (2006).