Equity Analysis at Ventura Securities
Equity Analysis at Ventura Securities
Equity Analysis at Ventura Securities
MANISH KUMAR
Roll No. CUJ/I/2013/IMBA/038
CERTIFICATE
DECLARATION
I hereby declare that the work incorporated in this report entitled A study on
Equity analysis at Ventura securities,Patna is the outcome of original
study undertaken by me Carried out under the Business Administration
Department Central University Of Jharkhand.
I further declare that the matter in this report has not been submitted by me as a
whole or in part at any other University or Institution for the award of any Degree
or Diploma.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
Accomplishment of a task with desired success calls for dedication towards work
and prompting guidance, co-operation and deliberation from seniors. At the
outset, I would like to Thanks Mr. J.P Verma and Mr. Vijay kumar sharma,
Assistant Professor, Central University of Jharkhand for his support
and professional approach in guiding me through the careful details of the
project.
I am very grateful to my company guides, Mr. Mukesh kumar and Mr.
Abhishek kumar who not only helped me on this topic but also helped me to
understand the nuances of capital market. In spite of having a very busy
schedule, they made sure in every way that we acquire the best possible
exposure and knowledge during our project.
I would be failing in my duty if I do no express my deep sense of gratitude to Sri
A.K Sarkar H.O.D. and all the faculty members for their valuable advice and
guidance in this project.
I am also thankful to our Branch head, Mr Afroz Sir.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
CHAPT
ER
TITLE
Executive Summary
Pg.
No.
5
6-7
Introduction
8-11
Research Methodology
12-27
2.1 Introduction
2.2 Fundamental Analysis
2.2.1 Economic Analysis
2.2.2 Industrial Analysis
2.2.3 Company Analysis
2.2.4 Financial Analysis
2.3 Technical Analysis
3
28-50
51-53
Bibliography
54
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The automobile industry, one of the core sectors, has undergone
metamorphosis with the advent of new business and manufacturing
practices in the light of liberalization and globalization. The sector
seems to be optimistic of posting strong sales in the couple of year
in the view of a reasonable surge in demand. The Indian automobile
market is gearing towards international standards to meet the
needs of the global automobile giants and become a global hub.
Equity
The Indian Equity Market is more popularly known as the
Indian Stock Market. The Indian equity market has become the third
biggest after China and Hong Kong in the Asian region. According to
the latest report by ADB, it has a market capitalization of nearly
$600 billion. As of March 2009, the market capitalization was around
$598.3 billion (Rs.30.13 lakh crore) which is one-tenth of the
combined valuation of the Asia region. The market was slow since
early 2007 and continued till the first quarter of 2009. A stock
exchange has been defined by the Securities Contract (Regulation)
Act, 1956 as and organization, association or body of individuals
established for regulating, and controlling of securities.
Commodity
Indian markets have recently thrown open a new avenue for retail
investors and traders to participate: commodity derivatives. For
those who want to diversify their portfolios beyond shares, bonds
and real estate, commodities is the best option. Till some months
ago, this wouldnt have made sense. For retail investors could have
done very little to actually invest in commodities such as gold and
silver or oilseeds in the futures market. This was nearly
impossible in commodities except for gold and silver as there was
practically no retail avenue for punting in commodities.
Currency Futures
Currency futures are contracts to exchange a certain amount of a
particular currency at a specific exchange rate on a specified date.
It is exactly like a futures contract on Nifty. Here the underlying
commodity is a currency exchange rate, such as an Indian Rupee to
US Dollar exchange rate. Up to now currency swap and currency
options were not traded on recognized stock exchanges
DERIVATIVES
The introduction of risk management instruments in India gained
momentum in the last few years due to liberalization process and
Reserve Bank of Indias (RBI) efforts in creating currency forward
market. Derivatives are an integral part of liberalization process to
manage risk. NSE gauging the market requirements initiated the
process of setting up derivative markets in India.
Directors:
Sajid Malik:
Co-promoter of Ventura and Director A chartered accountant by
qualification, Sajid Malik is also the Promoter and Managing Director
of Genesys International, a company with focus on GIS mapping and
engineering designing services, listed on the NSE and BSE.
Hemant Majethia
Co-promoter of Ventura, CEO and Director With over 2 decades of
experience in capital market intermediation and equity research
Hemant Majethia is well connected and respected in market circles
for his technocratic approach to stock broking. He is a chartered
accountant by qualification and has been instrumental in the
development of the online platform "POINTER".
Juzer Gabajiwala
Director A member of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
and The Institute of Company Secretaries of India, heads the HR and
operations functions at Ventura. He initiated the launch of the
alternate products platforms for mutual fund distribution and
insurance. He also spearheaded the wealth management and NRI
cell. Prior to joining Ventura, has been associated with the IIT group
and the TATA group
CHAPTER. 1
INTRODUCTION
INTRODUCTION
India is a developing country. Nowadays many people are interested
to invest in financial markets especially on equities to get high
returns, and to save tax in honest way. Equities are playing a major
role in contribution of capital to the business from the beginning.
Since the introduction of shares concept, large numbers of investors
are showing interest to invest in stock market. In an industry
plagued with scepticism and a stock market increasingly difficult to
predict and contend with, if one looks hard enough there may still
be a genuine aid for the Day Trader and Short Term Investor. The
price of a security represents a consensus. It is the price at which
one person agrees to buy and another agrees to sell. The price
at which an investor is willing to buy or sell depends primarily on his
expectations. If he expects the security's price to rise, he will buy it;
if the investor expects the price to fall, he will sell it. These simple
statements are the cause of a major challenge in forecasting
security prices because they refer to human expectations.
As we all know first
hand, humans expectations are neither easily
quantifiable nor predictable. If prices are based on investor
expectations, then knowing what a security should sell for (i.e.,
fundamental analysis) becomes less important than knowing
what other investors expect it to sell for. That's not to say that
knowing what a security should sell for isn't important--it is. But
there is usually a fairly strong consensus of a stock's future earnings
that the average investor cannot disprove Fundamental analysis
and technical analysis can co-exist in peace and complement each
other. Since all the investors in the stock market want to make the
maximum profits possible, they just cannot afford to ignore either
fundamental or technical analysis.
1.1
RESEARCH OBJECTIVE
A study on Equity analysis in Indian stock market at Ventura
Securities, Patna
The objective of this project is to deeply analyse our Indian
Automobile Industry for investment purpose by monitoring
the growth rate and performance on the basis of historical
data. The main objectives of the Project study are:
Detailed analysis of Automobile industry which is geari
ng towards international standards
Analyze the impact of qualitative factors on industrys
and companys prospects
Comparative analysis of three tough competitors TATA
Motors, Maruti Suzuki and Mahindra and Mahindra
through fundamental analysis.
Suggesting as to which companys shares would be
best for an investor to invest.
1.2
1.3
The entire data used in the report had been collected from the
secondary sources; as such there were no need of any data from
the primary sources. The following sources have been sought for
the preparation report:
Tata Motors annual report, its available financial database for
the investors in its official website.
Maruti Suzuki annual report, its available financial database
for the investors in its official website.
Mahindra and Mahindra annual report, its available financial
database for the investors in its official website.
The data collected for the technical analysis derived from the
websites
likewww.moneycontrol.com
and
www.investopaedia.com
The data collected for the economic analysis was mainly
derived from the government bodies website, such as
website of RBI, Ministry of Statistics and Programme
Implementation.
Also website of some international bodies has been
extensively consulted for the purpose of collecting facts, such
as International Automotive Association and Society of Indian
Auto Manufacturers (SIAM).
Also, various text books on Security analysis and portfolio
management (like Punithavathy Pandian, S. Kevin), Financial
Management (M.Y.Khan, Prasanna Chandra and I.M.Pandey)
were consulted for the topic.
1.6 LIMITATIONS
CHAPTER. 2
RESEARCH
METHODOLO
GY
1.1INTRODUCTION
Equity Analysis is the analysis of critical factors that affect the value
of a stock. The intrinsic value of a stock depends on a plethora of
factors. Investment Analysis is a combination of fundamental and
technical analysis, constituting attributes which have an effect on
the investors before he invests on some stock.
Investment success is pretty much a matter of careful selection and
timing of stock purchases coupled with perfect with matching to an
in individual risk tolerance. In order to carryout selection, timing and
matching actions an investors must conduct deep security analysis.
Investors purchase equity shares with two basic objective:
To make capital profits by selling shares at higher prices.
To earn dividend income.
Fundamental analysis examines all the dimensions of risk exposure
and the probabilities of return, and merges them with broader
economic analysis and greater industry analysis to formulate the
valuation of a stock.
Equity
Analysis
Fundament
al Analysis
Economic
Analysis
Industry
Analysis
Technichal
Analysis
Company
analysis
Traditional
Modern
company
conditions
value of a companys stock.
in an effort
to determine the
1.Economic
analysis
2. Industry
analysis
3. company
analysis
Declinestage
Maturity and
stabilization
stage:
Rapid growth
stage:
Pioneering
stage
Market share:
The market share of the annual sales helps to determine a
companys relative competitive position within the industry. If the
market share is high, the company would be able to meet the
competition
successfully.
The
companies in the market should be compared with like product grou
ps otherwise, the results will be misleading.
Growth of sales
The rapid growth in sales would keep the shareholder in a better
position than one with stagnant growth rate. Investors generally
prefer size and growth in sales because the larger size companies
may be able to with stand the business cycle rather than the
company of smaller size.
Stability of sales
If a firm has stable sales revenue, it will have more stable earnings.
The fall in the market share indicates the declining trend of
company, even if the sales are stable. Hence the stability of sales
should be compared with its market share and the competitors
market share.
Earnings of the company:
Sales alone do not increase the earnings but the costs and
expenses of the company also influence the earnings. Further,
earnings do not always sin crease with increase in sales. The
companys sales might have increased but its earnings per share
may decline due to rise in costs. Hence, the investor should not only
depend on the sales, but should analyze the earnings of the
company.
2.2.4 Financial analysis:
The best source of financial information about a company is its own
financial statements. This is a primary source of information for
evaluating the investment prospects in the particular companys
stock. Financial statement analysis is the study of a companys
financial statement from various viewpoints. The statement gives
the historical and current information about the companys
operations.
Historical
financial statement helps to predict the future and the current infor
mation aids toanalyze the present status of the company. The two
main statements used in the analysis are Balance sheet and Profit
and Loss Account. It is better for the investor to avoid a company
with excessive debt component in its capital structure.
From the balance sheet, liquidity position of the company can also
be assessed with the information on current assets and current
liabilities.
Ratio analysis:
Ratio is a relationship between two figures expressed
mathematically. Financial ratios provide numerical relationship
between two relevant financial data. Financial ratios are calculated
from the balance sheet and profit and loss account. The relationship
can be either expressed as a percent or as a quotient. Ratios
summarize the data for easy understanding, comparison
and interpretations.
Ratios
for
investment
purposes
can
be classified into profitability ratios, turnover ratios, and leverage
ratios. Profitability ratios are the most popular ratios since investors
prefer to measure the present profit performance and use this
information to forecast the future strength of the company.
(ROI)
(Net
profit/Equity
As this ratio reveals how well the resources of a firm are being used,
higher the ratio, better are the results. The return on shareholders
investment should be compared with the return of other similar
firms in the same industry.
c) Earnings per Share (EPS)
This ratio determines what the company is earning for every share.
For many investors, earnings are the most important tool. EPS is
calculated by dividing the earnings (net profit) by the total number
of equity shares. The computation of EPS is as follows:
Earnings per
outstanding
share
Net
profit/Number
of
shares
g) Debt-to-Equity Ratio
Debt-Equity ratio is used to measure the claims of outsiders and the
owners against the firms assets.
Debt-to-equity ratio = Outsiders Funds / Shareholders Funds
The debt-equity ratio is calculated to measure the extent to which
debt
financing
has been used in a business.
It indicates
the proportionate claims of owners and the outsiders against the
firms assets. The purpose is to get an idea of the cushion available
to outsiders on the liquidation of the firm.
2.3 Industry profile of stock market
2.3.1 Financial market
Finance is the pre-requisite for modern business and financial
institutions play a vital role in the economic system. It is through
financial markets and institutions that the financial system of an
economy works. Financial markets refer to the institutional
arrangements for dealing in financial assets and credit instruments
of different types such as currency, cheques, bank deposits, bills,
bonds, equities, etc. Financial market is a broad term describing any
marketplace where buyers and sellers participate in the trade of
assets such as equities, bonds, currencies and derivatives. They are
typically defined by having transparent pricing, basic regulations on
trading, costs and fees and market forces determining the prices of
securities that trade. Generally, there is no specific place or
location to indicate a financial market.
Classification of Financial market
Financial
maket
Organised
market
Capital
market
Governmet
securities
market
long term
loan market
Industrial
securities
market
Primary
market
call money
market
Unorganise
d market
Money
market
Money
lenders,
Indigenuos
Bankers
commercial
market
Treasury bill
market
secondry
market
Capital Market
The capital market is a market for financial assets which have a long
or indefinite maturity. Generally, it deals with long term securities
which have a period of above one year. In the widest sense, it
consists of a series of channels through which the savings of the
community are made available for industrial and commercial
enterprises and public authorities. As a whole, capital market
facilitates raising of capital. Capital market consists of primary
market and secondary market.
Primary market:
Primary market is a market for new issues or new financial claims.
Hence it is also called as New Issue Market. It basically deals with
those securities which are issued to the public for the first time.
Secondary market:
Secondary market is a market where existing securities are traded.
In other words, securities which have already passed through new
issue market are traded in this market. Generally, such securities
are quoted in the stock exchange and it provides a continuous and
regular market for buying and selling of securities. This market
consists of all stock exchanges recognized by the government of
India.
Money Market
Money markets are the markets for short-term, highly liquid
debt
securities.
Moneymarket securities are generally very safe investments which r
eturn relatively lowinterest rate that is most appropriate for
temporary cash storage or short term time needs. It consists
of a number of sub-markets which collectively constitute the money
market namely call money market, commercial bills market,
acceptance market, and Treasury bill market.
Derivatives Market
The derivatives market is the financial market for
derivatives, financial instrument like futures contracts or options,
which are derived from other forms of assets. A derivative is a
security
whose price
is dependent upon
or derived from one or more underlying assets. The derivative itself
is merely a contract between two or more parties. Its value is
determined by fluctuations in the underlying asset. The important
financial derivatives are the following:
Forwards
Futures
Options
Swaps
.
Foreign Exchange Market
It is a market in which participants are able to
buy,
sell,
exchange
and
speculate
on
currencies. Foreign exchange markets are
made up of
banks, commercial
companies,
central
banks,
investment
management firms, hedge funds, and retail forex brokers and
investors. The forex market is considered to be the largest financial
market in the world. It is a worldwide decentralized over-thecounter financial market for the trading of currencies. Because the
currency markets are large and liquid, they are believed to be the
most efficient financial markets. It is important to realize that the
foreign exchange market is not a single exchange, but is
constructed of a global network of computers that connects
participants from all parts of the world.
Commodities Market
It is a physical or virtual marketplace for buying,
selling
and
trading
raw
or
primary products. For investors' purposes there are currently about
50 major commoditymarkets worldwide that facilitate investment tr
ade in nearly 100 primarycommodities. Commodities are split into
two types: hard and soft commodities. Hard commodities are
typically natural resources that must be mined or extracted (gold,
rubber, oil, etc.), whereas soft commodities are agricultural
products or livestock (corn, wheat, coffee, sugar, soybeans, pork,
etc.)
SEBI
SEBI is the regulator for the securities market in India. It is the apex
body to develop and regulate the stock market in India It was
formed officially by the Government of India in 1992 with SEBI Act
1992 being passed by the Indian Parliament. Chaired by C B
Bhave, SEBI is headquartered in the popular business district of
Bandra Kurla-complex in Mumbai and has Northern, Eastern,
Southern and Western regional offices in New Delhi , Kolkata,
Chennai and Ahmedabad. In place of Government Control, a
statutory and autonomous regulatory board with defined
responsibilities, to cover both development & regulation of the
market, and independent powers has been set up.
NSE.IT Ltd.
It is also a wholly owned subsidiary of NSE and is its IT
arm. This arm of the NSE is uniquely positioned to provide products,
services and solutions for the securities industry. NSE.IT primarily
focuses on in the area of trading, broker front-end and back-office,
clearing and settlement, web-based, insurance, etc. Along with this,
italso provides consultancy and implementation services in Data Wa
rehousing,
Business Continuity Plans, Site Maintenance and Backups, Stratus M
ainframeFacility Management, Real Time Market Analysis & Financial
News.
NSE Facts
o It uses
satellite communication technology
to energize participation from around 400 cities in India.
o NSE can handle up to 1 million trades per day.
o It is one of the largest interactive VSAT based stock exchanges in
the world.
o The NSE- network is the largest private wide area network in India
and the first extended C- Band VSAT network in the world.
o Presently more than 9000 users are trading on the real timeonline NSE application. Today, NSE is one of the largest exchanges
in the world and still forging ahead. At NSE, we are constantly
working towards creating a more transparent, vibrant and
innovative capital market.
OVER THE COUNTER EXCHANGE OF INDIA
OTCEI was incorporated in 1990 as a section 25
company under the companies Act1956 and is recognized as a
Help to spot current trends for buying and selling Indicate the
probable future action of the market by projection Show historical
movements Indicate the key areas of support and resistance A chart
represents of the demand and supply of a stock or commodity. The
horizontal axis represents time, with the price drawn as a line
connecting consecutive closing values. More sophisticated charts
will show more detail; bar charts also include the range from high to
low, candlestick charts include the open price along with a color and
fill which reflects change relative to the previous close. The basic
data on which the chart is drawn are
Date Price Band (Open, High, Low & Close) Volume
The different charts used in technical analysis are:
Line Chart
Bar chart
Candlestick Chart
Line chart
The most basic of the three charts is the line chart because it
represents only the closing prices over a set period of time. The line
is formed by connecting the closing prices over the time frame. Line
charts do not provide visual information of the trading range for the
individual points such as the high, low and opening prices. However,
the closing price is often considered to be the most important price
in stock data compared to the high and low for the day and this is
why it is the only value used in line charts.
Bar Chart
The bar chart expands on the line chart by adding several more key
pieces of information to each data point. The chart is made up of a
series of vertical lines that represent each data point. This vertical
line represents the high and low
for the trading period, along with
the closing price. The close and
open are represented on the
vertical line by a horizontal dash.
The opening price on a bar chart is
illustrated by the dash that is
located on the left side of the
vertical bar. Conversely, the close
is represented by the dash on the
right. Generally, if the left dash
(open) is lower than the right dash
(close) then the bar will be shaded black, representing an up period
for the stock, which means it has gained value. A bar that is colored
red signals that the stock has gone down in value over that period.
When this is the case, the dash on the right (close) is lower than the
dash on the left (open).
Fig Structure of a Bar Char
Candlestick Chart
Another type of chart used in technical analysis is the
candlestick chart, so called because the main component of
the chart representing prices looks like a candlestick, with a
thick body and usually a line extending above and below it,
called the upper shadow and lower shadow, respectively. The
top of the upper shadow represents the high price, while
The bottom of the lower shadow represents the low price.
Patterns are formed both by the body and the shadows.
Candlestick patterns are most useful over short periods of
time, and mostly have significance at the top of an uptrend or
the bottom of a downtrend, when the patterns most often
signify a reversal of the trend.
While the candlestick chart shows basically the same
information as the bar chart, certain patterns are more
apparent in the candlestick chart. The candlestick chart
emphasizes
opening
and
closing
prices.
The
top
and
bottom of the
real
body
represents
the
opening
and
closing
prices.
Whether the top
represents
the
opening
or
closing
price
depends on the
colour of the real
bodyif it is white/ blue/green, then the top represents the
close; black / red or some other dark colour, indicates that
the top was the opening price. The length of the real body
shows the difference between the opening and closing prices.
Obviously, white/green/blue real bodies indicate bullishness,
while black/red real bodies indicate bearishness, and their
pattern is easily observable in a candlestick chart.
Fig. Structure of a Candlestick Chart
CHAPTER. 3
DATA ANALYSIS
&
INTERPRETATIONS
caus
es
On the other hand
caus
es
GDP
auto market. Major names among these are General Motors, Skoda
Auto and Mercedes-Benz. These companies have major plans lined
up for India auto industry. These are few signs of the revolutionized
auto industry after recession.
Inflation
The rise in inflation will have adverse impact on the industry
that will not only see interest rates getting further hardened but
also a drop in demand due to the squeeze in purchasing power. The
effect of inflation has affected every sector which is related to car
manufacturing and production. The increase in the price of fuel and
the steel due to inflation has led to a slower growth rate of the car
industry in India.
Inflation typically results in the following;
High raw material cost Non availability of cheap credit due to rise in
interest rates.
Low earnings
Fig. Inflation Rate for the period(May 2015-April2016)
Interest Rates
Interest Rates have a direct impact on the economy. The base rate
of banks affects the cost of borrowed funds. The base rate is the
minimum rate of interest at which banks lend to anyone. It is the
floor rate below which the RBI will not allow banks to lend.
Fig. Interest rate chart for private banks, w.e.f. January 2015
Foreign Direct Investment
The definition of Foreign Direct Investment includes different
elements, namely equity capital ,reinvested earnings of foreign
companies, inter-company debt transactions, short and long term
loans ,financial leasing, trade credits, investment made by Foreign
venture capital investors and so on. FDIs help in the upgrading of
technology, skills and managerial capabilities and bring the much
Inflows (million
USD)
Mauritius
50,164
Singapore
11,275
USA
8,914
UK
6,158
Netherlands
4,968
FDI : inflow in India in 2015
Inflow %
42.00
9.00
7.00
5.00
4.00
Balance of Payment
The balance of payments is the record of a countrys money
receipts from abroad and payments to foreign countries. The
difference between receipts and payments may be a surplus or
deficit. Balance of payments is a measure of the strength of the
rupee on the external account. If the deficit increases, the rupee
value may depreciate against other currencies, thereby affecting
the cost of imports. A favourable balance of payment has a positive
effect on the stock market.
B. Industrial Analysis
An analysis of the performance, prospects and problems of
an industry of interest is known as industry analysis. The economic
analysis gives an indication about the direction of the economy and the
stock market. Industry analysis is required because the return and risk
level of industries differ. The risk factors in an automobile industry differs
that from those of the IT or telecom industries. Consumer spending have
greater impact on the automobile industry than on the IT industry. Thus
concentrating on the Automobile industry we discuss about the following
factors
Global Automobile Industry.
The automotive industry is a wide range of companies and
organizations
involved
in
the design, development, manufacture, marketing,
and selling of motor vehicles. It is one of the world's most
important economic sectors by revenue. The automotive industry
does not include industries dedicated to the maintenance of
automobiles following delivery to the end-user, such as automobile
repair shops and motor fuel filling stations. Today, the modern
global
automotive
industry
encompasses
the
principal
manufacturers, General Motors, Ford, Toyota, Honda, Volkswagen,
and Daimler Chrysler, all of which operate in a global competitive
marketplace. It is suggested that the globalization of the
automotive industry, has greatly accelerated during the last half of
the 1990's due to the construction of important overseas facilities
and establishment of mergers between giant multinational
automakers.
o
o
o
o
o
o
weaknesses
Low labor productivity High interest
strengths
Large domestic market
Sustainable labor cost advantage
Competitive auto component vendor
base
Government incentives for
manufacturing plants
Strong engineering skills in design etc
Threats
Ignorance of Research & development
Rising interest rates
Cut throat competition
opportunities
Increasing challenges in consumer
demands, technology
development, and globalization.
Heavy thrust on mining and
construction activity
Increase in the income level
Cut in excise duties
C. COMPANY ANALYSIS
The company analysis shows the long-term strength of the
company that what is the financial position of the company in the
market, where it stands among its competitors and who are the key
drivers of the company, what are the future plans of the company,
what are the policies of government towards the company and how
these take of the company divested among different groups of
people.
Here, I have taken three companies namely
TATA Motors, Maruti Suzuki and Mahindra and Mahindra for the
purpose
of
Fundamental
analysis.
Tata Motors Limited is India's largest automobile company, with con
solidated revenues of Rs. 92,519 crores (USD 20 billion) in 2009-10.
It is the leader in commercial vehicles in each segment, and among
the top three in passenger vehicles with winning products in the
compact, midsize car and utility vehicle segments. The company is
the world's fourth largest truck manufacturer, and the world's
second largest bus manufacturer. Maruti Suzuki is a subsidiary of
Suzuki Motor Corporation Japan. More than half the numbers of cars
sold in India wear Maruti Suzuki badge. They offer a full range
of cars from entry level Maruti 800 & Alto to stylish hatchback
Ritz, A star, Swift, Wagon R, Estillo and sedans Dzire, SX4 and
Sports Utility Vehicle Grand Vitara. Since inception, it has produced
and sold over 7.5 million vehicles in India and exported over
500,000 units to Europe and other countries. Its turnover for the
fiscal2008-09 stood at Rs. 203,583 Million & Profit after Tax at Rs.
12,187 Million.
The Mahindra Groups Automotive Sector is in the business of
manufacturing and marketing utility vehicles and light commercial
vehicles, including three-wheelers. Itis the market leader in utility
vehicles in India since inception, and currently accounts for about
half of Indias market for utility vehicles. The Automotive Sector
continues to be a leader in the utility vehicle segment with a diverse
portfolio that includes mass transport as well as new generation
vehicles like Scorpio, Bolero and the recently launched Xylo and tuv
300
D. Financial analysis
RATIO ANALYSIS OF TATA MOTORS, MARUTI SUZUKI ANDMAHINDRA &
MAHINDRA
1. EPS
Fig. Earning per
share chart
Interpretations
EPS measures the
profit available to
the
equity
shareholders
per
share, that is, the
amount that they
can get on every
share held. EPS of
TATA it is continuously decreases from 2011 to 2015 and Maruti had a rising EPS.
The effect is more on Tata motors because of the slump in domestic and
international markets and sharp fall in sales and net profits which resulted in low
EPS. Mahindra is not much affected as its sales have increased from the previous
year. But as trend shows Mahindra motors has potential so a shareholder can
expect better in future. So for investment Maruti is good .
2. SALES
Fig.
sales
chart
Interpretations
Maruti and Mahindra show a positive trend in sales over the past five years.
Though slowdown in the economy brought hurdles but these companies have
potential
to
grow in future as lots of products are still to add in their portfoli. Moreover increa
sed demand in foreign market also seems to be a positive signal for
better future. TATA has witnessed a decline in sales of each segment. Maruti and
Mahindra are going swiftly
3. OPERATING PROFIT MARGIN
Fig Operating Profit
Ratio trend chart
Interpretations
Here we can see that this graph shows that operating profit of TATA declines year
to year and Maruti and Mahindra has little fluctuation in operating profit, it
means these both companies comes in growth situation in the future . These
both companies are supportive to investors.
4. RETURN ON CAPITAL EMPLOYED (ROCE)
7. DEBT-EQUITY RATIO
Fig Debt to Equity ratio
trend chart
Here
TATA
has
increasing trend and
Mahindra and Maruti
has decreasing trend.
It means TATA not
recover debt rapidly
compared with Maruti
and Mahindra. Maruti
and
Mahindra
is
supportive
to
investors.
8. CURRENT RATIO
Fig. Current
trend chart
Ratio
The
company
has
gradually reduced its
currents liabilities, ,it
can be seen that the
company is dependent
mostly on long term
funds to finance its
current assets and as a
result current liabilities
have largely reduced
and use of long term
liabilities
have
increased, which can be
said as a wise decision from the company.
As
the
company
has
ignored debt financing and
has
reduced
interest
paying, it has gradually
increased
its
dividend
paying capabilities to hold
shareholders
trust
over
them, in a bad situation like
this.it has moved on to
become unleveraged and
has opted to remit huge dividends in order to attract & hold shareholders.
DATA ANALYSIS
1. MARUTI SUZUKI
DTAE
9/5/201
6
10/5/20
16
11/5/20
16
12/5/20
16
13/5/20
16
16/5/20
16
17/5/20
16
18/5/20
16
19/5/20
16
20/5/20
16
23/5/20
16
24/5/20
16
25/5/20
16
26/5/20
16
27/5/20
16
30/5/20
16
31/5/20
16
1/6/201
6
2/6/201
6
3/6/201
6
6/6/201
6
7/6/201
6
8/6/201
6
9/6/201
6
10/6/20
16
OPEN
PRICE
(RS)
HIGH
PRICE
(RS)
LOW
PRICE
(RS)
CLOSE
PRICE
(RS)
3833.3
0
3856.3
0
3800
3877
3829.4
5
3836.4
5
3790
3856.2
0
3846.9
5
3889.8
5
3862.9
5
3844.6
0
3880.3
0
3949.1
5
3914.2
0
3926.8
5
3947.0
5
3911.5
5
3917.5
0
4053.6
0
4117.1
5
4141.3
5
4073.1
5
4167.9
0
4161.6
5
4183.8
5
4220.1
0
4135.1
5
4143.2
0
4169.4
5
4169.4
5
4152.4
0
3861.4
0
3865
3875
3885.3
0
3910
3856.2
0
3899
3908.0
5
3879.9
5
3892
3950
3968.4
5
3935.1
0
3942.3
0
3958.9
0
3965
3930
3937
3942.1
5
4055
4065
3900
3890
4118
4141
4073
4175
4156.5
0
4200
4214
4160
4150
4142.1
5
4161
4127.9
5
4158.3
0
4152.0
5
4184.7
5
4199
3845.6
0
3830.5
5
3844.0
5
3885.3
0
3808
3880
3885
3900
3891.4
0
3941.1
0
4030
4093
4055.1
0
4058.3
6
4151
4189.0
5
4231.3
0
4224
4127.2
5
4179.0
5
4121
4188.8
0
4171.6
5
4190.5
0
4192
4122.8
0
4124.1
5
4138
4150
MOVIN
G
AVERA
GE OF
CLOSI
NG
PRICE
3834.1
0
3836.7
5
3860.4
5
3863.0
2
3863.5
0
3860.6
8
3892.8
5
3915.7
3
3930.7
3
3928.8
2
3928.4
7
3927.6
7
3966.3
3
4034.3
8
4108.5
2
4112.1
2
4126.6
5
4132.9
0
4171.2
0
4186.0
5
4171.7
7
4154.7
7
4145.9
2
4154.9
7
4146.9
2
VOLU
ME
46053
39266
72028
19098
0
70785
29865
55189
14768
1
51188
47830
28752
23677
61439
82422
52734
41971
6242
58362
37135
63352
51197
0
30404
32367
73221
69759
and
graph
INTERPRETATION
The movement of opening
and
closing
price
indicates a steadiness and
slight increase during the
study period and the
situation is good from the
investors point of view,
as the overall market
capitalization of Maruti Suzuki is increasing during the study period.
CANDLESTICK CHART:
Fig.Candlestick
chart
INTERPRETATION
Its shows stock has
good opening price
at
maximum
numbers of days
compare to closing
price on the same
day of the study
period.
It
represents a clear
picture of stock
price at which the
investors
will
decide to invest (since the black body and the white bodies show trend),thus
we predict the investment decisions.
REPRESENTATION OF LINE CHART-TOTAL VOLUME W.R.T. DAYS
2. TATA MOTORS
Table-. Historical Data analysis chart of TATA Motors (9-52016 to 10-6-2016) (BSE)
DATE
OPEN
PRICE
(RS)
HIGH
PRICE
(RS)
LOW
PRICE
(RS)
CLOSE
PRICE
(RS)
VOLUM
E
403.35
MOVIN
G
AVERAG
E OF
CLOSIN
G PRICE
397.75
9/5/201
6
10/5/20
16
11/5/20
16
12/5/20
16
13/5/20
16
16/5/20
16
17/5/20
16
18/5/20
16
19/5/20
16
20/5/20
16
23/5/20
16
24/5/20
16
25/5/20
16
26/5/20
16
27/5/20
16
30/5/20
16
31/5/20
16
1/6/201
6
2/6/201
6
3/6/201
6
6/6/201
6
7/6/201
6
8/6/201
6
9/6/201
6
10/6/20
16
401
405.25
395.55
401
401.85
387.20
388.90
396.98
748851
386
391.90
376.05
380.10
390.78
1034617
384
388
380
387.20
385.40
575091
390
393.80
385.85
390
385.77
803589
393.80
396.75
389.60
392.55
389.92
500083
391.50
395
387.30
389.90
390.82
554187
384
387.40
381.80
385
389.15
935847
385.25
393.15
383.10
387.70
387.53
1297826
386.25
392.50
383.30
384.55
385.75
591312
388
389.90
380.55
382.75
385
523527
384.40
392
382.35
389.25
385.52
541437
393.55
399.70
393.55
397
389.67
507837
399
401.70
396.85
399.30
395.18
318249
400
404.65
395.95
403.50
399.93
672984
405.40
421.90
401.60
420.55
407.78
1171008
456.30
463.90
444.15
458.20
427.42
48511
455.70
458.20
446.25
449.20
442.65
720409
445
460.30
443.95
453.20
453.52
1105284
456.55
461.75
452.30
453.90
452.10
784791
457.25
464.90
450.50
460.75
455.95
608593
466.95
467
458.65
463.05
459.23
1169024
465
468.70
462.95
466.30
463.37
3469132
467.80
470.25
464.75
466.70
465.35
473127
467.90
467.90
458.10
458.95
463.40
255395
749845
Fig.
Volume
graph
volatility
INTERPRETATION
The above chart shows the
huge volatility in demand
volume sales of the share as
a result of which the price
the price is also little bit
volatile, as it is visible from
the line chart of opening &
closing price w.r.t. days
CANDLESTICK CHART
Fig. Candlestick chart
INTERPRETATION
Its shows stock has lower
opening
price
at
maximum numbers of
days compare to closing
price on the same day of
the study period. It
represents not a clear
picture of stock price at
which the investors will
decide to invest (since
neither the black body
nor the white bodies show any trend),thus we cannot predict the investment
decisions.
DTAE
OPEN
PRICE
(RS)
HIGH
PRICE
(RS)
LOW
PRICE
(RS)
CLOSE
PRICE
(RS)
VOLUM
E
1349.45
MOVIN
G
AVERAG
E OF
CLOSIN
G PRICE
1333.75
9/5/201
6
10/5/20
16
11/5/20
16
12/5/20
16
13/5/20
16
16/5/20
16
17/5/20
16
18/5/20
16
19/5/20
16
20/5/20
16
23/5/20
16
24/5/20
16
25/5/20
16
26/5/20
16
27/5/20
16
30/5/20
16
31/5/20
16
1/6/201
6
2/6/201
6
3/6/201
6
6/6/201
6
7/6/201
6
8/6/201
6
9/6/201
6
10/6/20
16
1335.1
1357
1330.50
1351.40
1352.95
1333
1350.40
1343.43
27250
1340
1353.95
1315.05
1346.15
1349.23
38531
1353
1363.85
1330.50
1331.80
1344.17
178922
1332
1332
1303
1313.10
1331.78
35705
1313
1321
1306
1318.30
1321.15
22071
1228.80
1351
1320
1341.40
1323.67
44918
1341.95
1342
1312.25
1320.10
1328.08
343874
1321.5
1328
1305.65
1309.35
1326.33
66586
1315.80
1322.40
1290
1294.05
1310.05
27062
1300.20
1301
1279.5
1286.35
1296.37
34512
1272.5
1303.55
1261.05
1296.25
1290.95
35826
1297.1
1318
1297.1
1312.15
1297.17
190220
1312.50
1343
1307
1337.10
1315.22
362396
1339.10
1361.95
1326
1335.15
1328.18
105270
1340
1351.20
1314.10
1331.80
1334.55
253340
1338.3
1344.0
1316.1
1324.70
1328.95
3492
1331
1349.70
1326
1333.85
1328.97
109067
1346.80
1346.80
1329.55
1332.70
1329.77
72513
1343
1359.25
1342
1353.45
1333.25
265621
1358
1386.40
1358
1369.60
1345.40
77915
1375
1386
1372
1377.85
1360.30
60981
1380
1397
1380
1384.70
1377.98
104817
1385.15
1392.75
1365
1376.65
1379.22
113148
1371
1404
1363.75
1382.9
1378.52
101083
39060
CANDLESTICK CHART
CHAPTER. 4
FINDINGS,
SUGGESATION
&
CONCLUSION
4.1FINDINGS
From the data analysis and interpretations of the ratios of three companies viz.
Tata Motors, Maruti Suzuki and Mahindra and Mahindra, the following findings
have been given:
o
o
o
o
o
4.2
The Maruti and Mahindra companies were performing well till 2015
with a positive trend in the earnings per share. But TATA had
downward trend. Especially, TATA has witnessed a steep fall till
2015.
The sales trend has been upward and positive in case of all the
three companies. The sales growth looks upward and positive till
2015, TATAs sales have declined whereas Maruti and Mahindra
have maintained the same upward positive trend.
The return on capital employed (ROCE) has been fluctuating since
2011 and the year 2015witnessed low returns in case of all the
companies amongst which TATA has the least rate of return.
Compared to the three companies, Maruti and Mahindra have good
rate of return.
In case of interest coverage ratio, TATA has decreasing trend but
Maruti and Mahindra have increasing trend till 2015.
In case of debtors turnover ratio TATA and Maruti have increasing
trend but Mahindra has decreasing trend during 2011 to 2105.
Maruti and Mahindra had a stable dividend payout ratio since 2011.
TATA has increased their payout ratio in which shows a higher
payout ratio.
By analysing the current trend of Indian Economy and Automobile
Industry I have found that being a developing economy there is lot
of scope for growth and this industry still has to cross many levels
so there are huge opportunities to invest in and this is being proved
as more and more foreign companies are setting up there ventures
in India .Increase in income level, increase in consumer demand,
technology development, globalization, foreign investments are few
of the opportunities which the industry has to explore for
developing the economy.
SUGGESTIONS
CONCLUSION
The automotive industry in India is one of the largest in the world with an
annual production of 23.37 million vehicles in FY 2014-15, following a growth
of 8.68 per cent over the last year. India emerged as Asias fourth largest
exporter of automobiles, behind Japan, South Korea and Thailand.
A runway inflation touching a high point of 12% early in the year, the tight
monetary policies followed by the authorities for most of the year to control
inflation with the consequent high interest rates and weak consumer demand,
have collectively had devastating effect on the automotive sector. Maruti
suzuki company has a trend of growth from till 215. TATA Motors, which was
trying to consolidate its leadership position in the market.
In spite of it being a tough year for all the companies across the globe and in
India, Mahindra has given a satisfactory performance. At present its shares
are undervalued giving it a potential for growth.
One factor favouring this point is that India has become a hot destination for
companies of diverse nature to invest in. Cut throat competition among top
companies, lots of new car and vehicle model launches at regular intervals
keeps
the
Indian
auto
sector
moving.
A continuous effort at cost cutting and improving productivity will help theco
mpanies in making reasonable profits despite the impact of higher commodity
prices and weaker rupee.
The analysis gives an optimistic view about the industry and its growth which
recommends the investors to keep a good watch on the major players to
benefit in terms of returns on their investments.
Bibliography
1. www.investopedia.com/technicalanalysis. (2014,
april 17). Retrieved april 17, 2014, from
www.investopedia.com.
2. www.moneycontrol.com/market/shareprice. (2014). Retrieved april 10, 2014, from
www.moneycontrol.com.
3. www.economictimes.indiatimes.com/prices.cms
4. www.wikipedia.com/automotiveindustry
5. (2011-15). Annual Report. Tata Motors Limited
6. (2011-15). Annual Report. Mahindra and Mahindra
7. (2011-15). Annual Report. Maruti suzuki
8. Avadhani, V. A. (2009). Investment Analysis. Mumbai:
Himalaya Publishing House
9. Pandian, P. (2013). Security Analysis and Portfolio
Management. New Delhi: Vikas Publishing House.
10.
S.Kevin. (2011). Security Analysis and Portfolio
Management. New Delhi: PHI.