3 Radiative Transfer-3 PDF
3 Radiative Transfer-3 PDF
3 Radiative Transfer-3 PDF
Transport of energy:
radiation
specific intensity, radiative flux
optical depth
absorption & emission
equation of transfer, source function
formal solution, limb darkening
temperature distribution
grey atmosphere, mean opacities
4 r F (r ) const . L
2
F is the energy flux per unit surface and per unit time. Dimensions: [erg/cm2/sec]
The energy transport is sustained by the temperature gradient.
The steepness of this gradient is dependent on the effectiveness of the energy
transport through the different atmospheric layers.
2
Transport of energy
Mechanisms of energy transport
a. radiation: Frad (most important)
b. convection: Fconv (important especially in cool stars)
c. heat production: e.g. in the transition between solar
cromosphere and corona
d. radial flow of matter: corona and stellar wind
e. sound waves: cromosphere and corona
We will be mostly concerned with the first 2
mechanisms: F(r)=Frad(r) + Fconv(r). In the outer
layers, we always have Frad >> Fconv
3
dE = I (cos ) cos dA d d dt
([I ]: erg cm2 sr1 Hz1 s1 )
I =
c
I
2
dE = I (cos ) cos dA d d dt
dE0 = I0 (cos 0 ) cos 0 dA0 d 0 d dt
dE = dE0
and
d =
projected area
distance2
d 0 =
and
dE = I (cos ) cos dA d d dt
dE0 = I0 (cos 0 ) cos 0 dA0 d 0 d dt
I = I0
dA0 cos 0
r2
dA cos
r2
In TE: I = B
6
dA
r2
4r 2
Total solid angle = 2 = 4
r
dA = (r d)(r sin d)
d = sin d d
define = cos
d = sin d
d = sin d d = d d
Radiative flux
How much energy flows through surface element dA?
dE ~ I cos d
integrate over the whole solid angle (4):
F =
4
astrophysical flux
I (cos ) cos d =
Radiative flux
The monochromatic radiative flux at frequency gives the net rate of energy
flow through a surface element.
dE ~ I cos d integrate over the whole solid angle (4):
F =
astrophysical flux
I (cos ) cos d =
F = F+ F =
/2
/2
F d = Frad
10
Stellar luminosity
At the outer boundary of atmosphere (r = Ro) there is no incident radiation
Integral interval over reduces from [0,] to [0,/2].
F (Ro ) =
F+ (Ro )
2
0
/2
This is the monochromatic energy that each surface element of the star
radiates in all directions
If we multiply by the total stellar surface 4R02
monochromatic stellar luminosity at frequency
and integrating over
total stellar luminosity
4Ro2
4Ro2 F (Ro ) = L
F+ (Ro )d = L (Luminosity)
11
Observed flux
What radiative flux is measured by an observer at distance d?
integrate specific intensity I towards observer over all surface elements
note that only half sphere contributes
Z
Z
E =
dE = t
1/2 sphere
I (cos ) cos dA
1/2 sphere
E =
t Ro2
/2
F+
because of spherical symmetry the integral of intensity towards
the observer over the stellar surface is proportional to F+, the
flux emitted into all directions by one surface element !!
12
Observed flux
Solid angle of telescope at distance d:
= A/d2
+
E = t Ro2 F+ (Ro )
Fobs
radiative energy
Ro2
=
= 2 F+ (Ro )
area frequency time
d
R
0
obs
F ,
d = 1.36 K W/m 2
13
mean intensity
I d
radiation energy
1
u =
=
volume
c
I d =
4
J
c
energy density
1
p =
c
I cos2 d
pressure =
radiation pressure
(important in hot stars)
force
d momentum(= E/c) 1
=
area
dt
area
14
1
J =
4
1
I d =
4
2
0
1
d
I d =
2
1
1
H =
4
1
I cos d =
2
1
K =
4
1
I cos2 d =
2
I d =
1
1
1
I d
1
F
4
I 2 d =
0th moment
c
p
4
1st moment
(Eddington flux)
2nd moment
15
ds
dI = I ds
: absorption coecient
[ ] = cm1
microscopical view: n
Over a distance s:
s
o
I(s)
I (s) =
Io
:=
Zs
0
Rs
ds
optical depth
ds
or:
(dimensionless)
d = ds
16
optical depth
I (s) =
Io
Io
' 0.37 Io
if = 1 I =
e
= 1 =
Zs
ds
17
expectation value
< >=
p( ) d
I( )
Io I( )
I( )
=
= 1
Io
Io
Io
I( )
= e
Io
dI
I( )
= d
18
< >=
p( ) d =
d = 1
xex dx = (1 + x) ex
= s s = s =
19
20
radiative acceleration
In the absorption process photons release
momentum E/c to the atoms, and the
corresponding force is:
force =dfphot =
momentum(=E/c)
dt
Z
0
I cos d d dA dt ds =
F d dA dt ds
21
radiative acceleration
dfphot
=
c
F d
dt
dA dt ds = grad dm
grad =
(dm = dA ds)
F d
22
emission of radiation
ds
d
dA
dV=dA ds
energy added by emission processes within dV
dEem = dV d d dt
: emission coecient
[ ] = erg cm3 sr1 Hz1 s1
23
= I +
differential equation
describing the flow of
radiation through
matter
24
dx = cos ds = ds
d
d
=
ds
dx
(,x)
dIdx
= I (, x) +
25
dr
= cos
ds
r d = sin ds (d < 0)
(as in planeparallel)
d
sin
=
ds
r
=
= sin
sin2
1 2
=
=
+
=
+
ds
r
r
r
r
r I (, r)
12
r I (, r)
= I (, r) +
26
dI (,x)
dx
= (x) I (, x) + (x)
dx = d
Zx
= dx
Ro
dI (, )
d
S =
= I (, ) S ( )
source function
dim [S] = [I]
=
S =
1
ds s s
S =
= B (T )
Kirchhoffs law
photons are absorbed and
re-emitted at the local
temperature T
28
sc
d
dEabs =
I d
dI = I ds
=
incident = scattered
sc
sc
d =
Z
I d
d =
I d
sc
1
I d
S = J
29
c. mixed case
+ sc
sc
S =
=
+
+
+
+
+ sc
S =
=
B +
J
+
+
+
30
dI
= I S
d
I e
i 2
1
Z2
S e
dt
31
I e
i 2
1
Z2
S e
dt
I (1 , ) = I (2 , ) e
2 1
Z2
S (t) e
t1
dt
32
I (1 , ) = I (2 , ) e
2 1
Z2
S (t) e
t1
dt
Boundary conditions
solution of RT equation requires
boundary conditions, which are
different for incoming and outgoing
radiation
a. incoming radiation: < 0 at 0
usually we can neglect irradiation from outside: I( 0, < 0) = 0
Iin ( , )
Z0
S (t) e
dt
33
I (1 , ) = I (2 , ) e
2 1
Z2
S (t) e
t1
dt
Boundary conditions
b. outgoing radiation: > 0 at = max
We have either
I (max , ) = I+ ()
or
lim I (, ) e / = 0
finite slab or
shell
semi-infinite
case (planar
or spherical)
Iout ( , ) =
S (t) e
dt
I ( ) = Iout ( ) + Iin ( )
34
Emergent intensity
from the latter emergent intensity
= 0, > 0
I (0, ) =
S (t) e
dt
35
Emergent intensity
suppose that S is linear in (Taylor expansion around = 0):
S ( ) = S0 + S1
emergent intensity
Z
t dt
= S0 + S1
I (0, ) = (S0 + S1 t)e
xex dx = (1 + x) ex
I (0, ) = S ( = )
Eddington-Barbier relation
36
Emergent intensity
= 1 (normal direction):
I (0, 1) = S ( = 1)
= 0.5 (slanted direction):
37
Line formation
simplify: = 1, 1=0 (emergent intensity), 2 =
S independent of location
I (0) = I ( ) e + S
et dt = I ( ) e + S (1 e )
38
Line formation
Optically thick object:
I (0) = I ( ) e + S (1 e ) = S
I (0) = I ( ) + [S I ( )]
exp(-) 1 -
39
I = S = ds S
e.g. HII region, solar corona
enhanced
independent of , no line
(e.g. black body B)
I (0) = I ( ) + [S I ( )]
40
From Ruttens web notes
41
X
dn B
S (t) =
(t )n /n!
n
d
n=0
B (t) = B ( ) +
dB
(t )
d
Z
dB
dt
Iout ( , ) = [B ( ) +
(t )]e(t )/
d
42
Z
dB
dt
Iout ( , ) = [B ( ) +
(t )]e(t )/
d
Substituting:
tu=
t
dt = du
uk eu du = k!
Iout ( , ) =
[B ( ) +
Iin ( , ) =
dB
dB
u]eu du = B ( ) +
d
d
Z /
[B ( ) +
dB
u]eu du
d
diffusion approximation:
I (0,)
I (0,1)
B (0)+ dB
d
center-to-limb variation of
intensity
B (0)+ dB
d
B (t) = B (0) +
dB
d t
= a+bt =
2h 3
1
2
h/kT
(t) 1
c
e
44
45
S (t) e
dt
I (0, ) = S ( = )
R. Rutten,
web notes
Unsoeld, 68
46
Eddington approximation
B (t) = B ( ) +
Iout ( , ) = B ( ) +
Iin ( , ) =
Z /
dB
d
[B ( ) +
>> 1
0<<1
dB
u]eu du
d
I ( , ) = B ( ) +
-1 < < 0
dB
d
47
Eddington approximation
1
J =
2
I d = B ( )
1
1
F
=
H =
4
2
1
K =
2
1 dB
I d =
3 d
1
1
I d = B ( )
3
1
2
K =
1
3
1 dB dT
1 1 dB
=
3 dx
3 dT dx
flux F ~ dT/dx
diffusion: flux ~ gradient (e.g.
heat conduction)
Eddington approximation
48
Schwarzschild-Milne equations
Iout ( , ) =
J =
1
2
Z1
I d =
1
2
J =
Z1
Iout d +
1
2
substitute w =
J =
Iin d
Iin ( , ) =
S (t)e(t )/
dt
d
1
2
dw
w
= 1 d
Z Z
1
dt
S (t)e(t )w dt
Z0 Z
S (t)e(t )/
1 0
w = 1
dw
+
w
Z Z
1
Z0
S (t) e
dt
<0
>0
Z1 Z
S (t) e
1
2
Z0
dw
w
dt
d
= 1 d
S (t)e( t)w dt
dw
w
49
Schwarzschild-Milne equations
J =
1
2
S (t)
1
J =
2
e(t )w
dw
dt +
w
S (t)
Z
1
>0
Z
0
S (t)
Z
1
e( t)w
>0
dw
1
dt =
ew|t|
w
2
dw
dt
w
Schwarzschilds equation
50
Schwarzschild-Milne equations
where
E1 (t) =
Z
1
tx
dx
=
x
ex
dx
x
51
Schwarzschild-Milne equations
[f (t)] =
1
2
Z
0
f (t)E1 (|t |) dt
J ( ) = [S (t)]
Similarly for the other 2 moments of Intensity:
Milnes equations
52
Gray, 92
Schwarzschild-Milne equations
the 3 moments of Intensity:
ZZ
I cos d d =
0 4
F d = 4
H d
H d = const = L
H d = const
Z
0
4
H d = Te
54
4
H d = Te
55
Radiative equilibrium
1
2
Z1
dI
1
d =
dx
2
d 1
dx 2
Z1
Z1
dI
= ( + ) (I S )
dx
( + ) (I S ) d
I d = ( + ) (J S )
H
56
Radiative equilibrium
Z
0
Z
H d = ( + ) (J S ) d
0
const
Z
( + ) (J S ) d = 0
0
at each depth:
[J B (T )] d = 0
in addition:
s u b s t it u t e S =
Z
0
4
H d = Te
B +
J d = absorbed energy
B d = emitted energy
T(x) or T()
57
Radiative equilibrium
Z
[J B (T )] d = 0
4
H d = Te
T(x) or T()
The temperature T(r) at every depth has to assume the value for which the left
integral over all frequencies becomes zero.
This determines the local temperature.
58
equation of
transfer
J(x), H(x)
b. equation of radiation
transfer
(J B ) d = 0 ?
R
4
?
4 0 H d = Te
0
= g(x)
dI
= ( + ) (I S )
dx
c. radiative equilibrium
Z
[J B (T )] d = 0
d. flux conservation
4
4
H d = Te
e. equation of state
P =
kT
mH
59
[J B (T )] d = 0
[J B (T )] d = 0
With: J =
Z
0
J d
H=
H d
K=
Z
0
K d
B=
T 4
B d =
J =B
4
4H = Te
60
Grey atmosphere
We then assume LTE: S = B.
From
1
J ( ) = [S (t)] =
2
J() = [S(t)],
d
= dx
1
J ( ) = [J(t)] =
2
Z
0
Milnes equation
J (t)E 1(|t |) dt
with q monotonic
1
= 0.577 = q(0) q(
) q() = 0.710
3
dx
dH
=J B =0
d
(J = B)
4
Te
H = const =
4
dx
4
dK
Te
=H =
d
K(
) = H + constant
63
T 4 (
) =
3H
(
+ c)
T 4 (
) =
3 4
T (
+ c)
4 e
H=
4
T
4 e
T4 is linear in
Estimation of c
H (
= 0) =
1
3H
2
tE2 (t) dt + c
Z
0
1/3
E2 (t) dt
1/2
ts E n (t) d t =
s!
s + n
64
H(0) = H =
3
2
1
H(1 + c) c =
2
2
3
T 4 (
) =
3 4
2
Te (
+ )
4
3
T 4 (
) =
J() = [S(t)]
3 4
T [
+ q(
)]
4 e
q(
) : Hopf function
65
Selection of the appropriate
In the grey case we define a suitable mean opacity (absorption coefficient).
I =
I d
J =
non-grey
J d ...
grey
dI
dI
(I S)
Equation of transfer dx = (I S ) dx =
1st moment
2nd moment
dH = (J S ) dH
dx
dx
dK = H
dx
=
(J S)
dK =
H
dx
66
Selection of the appropriate
non-grey
grey
= (I S ) dI =
(I S)
dI
dx
dx
Equation of transfer
1st
moment
2nd moment
dH = (J S )dH
dx
dx
dK = H
dx
=
(J S)
dK =
H
dx
For each equation there is one opacity average that fits grey equations, however,
all averages are different. Which one to select?
For flux constant models with H() = const. 2nd moment equation is relevant
67
Flux-weighted mean
H d
R 1 dK
R
dx d = H d
0
0
dK = H
dx
1
=
R
0
1 dK
dx
1 dK
1 dK
d = H (grey)
= H
dx
dx
K
1
J , J B as
3
dK
1 dB
1 dB dT
=
dx
3 dx
3 dT dx
dK
dx
Ross
R
0
1 dB (T )
dT
R dB (T )
0
dT
70
T4 vs.
non-grey
numerical
71
T vs. log()
non-grey
numerical
grey: q() = exact
grey: q= 2/3
72
equation of
transfer
J(x), H(x)
b. equation of radiation
transfer
(J B ) d = 0 ?
R
4
?
4 0 H d = Te
0
= g(x)
dI
= ( + ) (I S )
dx
c. radiative equilibrium
Z
[J B (T )] d = 0
d. flux conservation
4
4
H d = Te
e. equation of state
P =
kT
mH
73