Benzochem PDF
Benzochem PDF
Benzochem PDF
2015
Form I
M/S Benzo Chem Industries Pvt.
Ltd.
2
BenzoChemIndustriesPvt.Ltd. 2015
APPENDIX 1
(See paragraph - 6)
FORM I
3
BenzoChemIndustriesPvt.Ltd. 2015
Nearest town is Jalgoan. It is 4 Km
11. Nearest Town, City, District Headquarters away from project site.
along with distance in kms.
4
BenzoChemIndustriesPvt.Ltd. 2015
Forest land involved (hectares)
23. No
(II) Activity
1. Construction, operation or decommissioning of the Project involving Actions,
which will cause physical changes in the locality (topography, Land use,
changes in water bodies, etc.
5
BenzoChemIndustriesPvt.Ltd. 2015
Hazardous solids
Stored separately in demarcated area
Facilities for treatment or disposal of
1.15 Yes and is disposed to CHWTDS.
solid waste or liquid effluents?
Liquid effluent
Effluent will be treated in upgraded
Effluent treatment plant, Stripper
Column & MEE. Treated effluent will
be reused.
6
BenzoChemIndustriesPvt.Ltd. 2015
Water supply facilities are provided by
Abstraction or transfers of water form
1.23 No Jalgaon MIDC.
ground or surface waters?
Not Applicable. Closed drainage system
Changes in water bodies or the land
1.24 No is provided by Jalgaon MIDC.
surface affecting drainage or run-off?
Transport of personnel or materials for
By existing roads provided by the
1.25 construction, operation or Yes
Jalgaon MIDC.
decommissioning?
Long-term dismantling or
1.26 decommissioning or restoration No Not Applicable
works?
Ongoing activity during
1.27 decommissioning which could have an No Not Applicable
impact on the environment?
Influx of people to an area in either
1.28 No Not Applicable
temporarily or permanently?
Project is located in Jalgaon MIDC.
1.29 Introduction of alien species? No
Loss of native species or genetic
1.30 No Project is located in Jalgaon MIDC.
diversity?
Project is located in Jalgaon MIDC.
1.31 Any other actions? No
7
BenzoChemIndustriesPvt.Ltd. 2015
Forests and timber (source
2.5 No Not Applicable
MT)
Electricity Supplied by: MSEDCL
8
BenzoChemIndustriesPvt.Ltd. 2015
9
BenzoChemIndustriesPvt.Ltd. 2015
through local Municipal Disposal
Facility
10
BenzoChemIndustriesPvt.Ltd. 2015
6. Generation of Noise and Vibration, and Emissions of Light and Heat:
11
BenzoChemIndustriesPvt.Ltd. 2015
Over flow of septic tank is
connected to ETP
Upgraded ETP will be provided;
From discharge of sewage or other
stripper column & Triple Effect
7.2 effluents to water or the land No
Evaporator are already provided
(expected mode of discharge)
for the treatment of effluent to
meet zero discharge.
Treated water will be reused.
Scrubbing system with sufficient
By deposition of pollutants emitted stack height is already provided.
7.3 No
to air into the land or into water
Not Applicable
7.4 From any other sources No
Not Applicable
8.2 From any other causes No
The project comes under an
Earthquake zone of India-Is
Could the project be affected by
1892:2002.
natural disasters causing
8.3 environmental damage (e.g. floods, Yes
The proposed project site
earthquakes, landslides, cloudburst
comes under Zone III in
etc)?
earthquake hazard zone.
So it can be affected slightly by
12
BenzoChemIndustriesPvt.Ltd. 2015
the earthquakes.
Other
13
BenzoChemIndustriesPvt.Ltd. 2015
(III) Environmental Sensitivity
14
BenzoChemIndustriesPvt. Limited. Jalgaon 2015
Consolidated Statement
Of
M/s Benzo Chem Industries Pvt.
Limited.
Jalgaon
BenzoChemIndustriesPvt. Limited. Jalgaon 2015
Quantity Means of
Physical and Source
List of raw (tones/ transportation
chemical of
materials to years ) full (source to
Raw materials (including nature of raw materia
Be used production storage site) with
process chemicals, material l
14 capacity justification
catalysts, & additives).
Proposed
Name of
activity
products, by Production
(new/modern Total Production
products and Existing
ization/expan (T/year)
intermediate (MT/year)
sion)
products
MT/Year.
EXISTING PROPOSED Total
NAME QTY NAME QT
MT/ Y
A MT
/A
Para choro meta cresol 60 Para chloro 60 120
(PCMC) meta cresol
(PCMC)
Sodium salt of para 1.20 Na salt of para 1 2.2
chloro meta cresol chloro meta
15 Production details cresol
4-Chloro thymol 1.20 4-Chloro 1 2.2
thymol
1-Chloro napthalene 6 1-Chloro 2 8
naphthalene
2:4 Di chloro benzyl 1.20 2:4-Dichloro 16 17.2
alcohol benzyl alcohol
Para choro benzyl 24 0*
cyanide(PCCN)
1-Chloro 2.40 1-Chloro 150 152.4
methylnapthalene methylnapthal
ene
Para chloro meta xylenol 1.20 1.2
Para chloro meta 1.20 1.2
cresol/liquid/protector-l
Ortho chloro phenyl 1.20 1.2
acetic acid
BenzoChemIndustriesPvt. Limited. Jalgaon 2015
Nitrile
Para Fluro Benzyl - 0*
Chloride
Para Fluro - 0*
Benzaldehyde
X Chloro Methyl Phenyl - 0*
Acetic Acid
3-ISO Chromanone - 0*
1- 4 4
Napthaldehyde
2-Amino-2- 20 20
phenyl butyric
acid
5-Chloro-2- 4 4
hydroxy
benzophenone
2- 6 6
Dimethylamin
o-2-phenyl-1-
butanol
4-Methoxy 100 100
phenyl acetone
dimethoxy-
1,3,5-triazine
1- 10 10
Acetylnapthale
ne
Para Hydroxy 2 2
phenyl acetic
acid
4-Methyl 5 5
benzyl
chloride
By-products By-products
Hydrochloric acid (HCl) 40 Hydrochloric 77 117
acid (HCl)
Chlorinated cressol / 0.04 Chlorinated 12 12.04
Cresylic acid cressol /
Cresylic acid
Sodium 30 30
bisulfite
(NaHSO3)
TOTAL 299.2 TOTAL 681 802.64
4 MT MT/A
MT/ /A
A
Note 0* indicates the production of these products has been stopped
Process details Detail of process are explained in EIA report submitted Chapter No 2
17
/manufacturing details Page No 2-5 to 2-30
Level of the Ground water table 30-40 mtr.
Rain Water Size and no of RWH tank(s) and Quantity 25 m3
18 Harvesting(RWH) Location of the RWH tank(s) :-
Size, nos of recharge pits and Quantity. Nil
Oil and Grease trap, neutralization tank, stripper column, settling tank,
24 Note on ETP technology Triple Effect Evaporator followed by oxidation tank and PSF and ACF
to be used for Zero discharge.
BenzoChemIndustriesPvt. Limited. Jalgaon 2015
Boiler
3 NOX 8236 Nm3/h 53 mg/Nm3
Pollutants
Emission standard Existing limit
(SPM,SO2,
limit (as per C.T.O) (mg/Nm3)
29 Emission Standard ect
SPM 150 mg/Nm3 124
SO2 108 Kg/day 33
Proposed
Pollutant Permissible standard concentration Remarks
(in g/m3)
Ambient Air Quality Data
PM 2.5 60 g/m3 28.40
30 As per
PM 10 100 g/m3 70.20 NAAQM
SO2 80 g/m3 23.40 limit
NOX 80 g/m3 38.00
BenzoChemIndustriesPvt. Limited. Jalgaon 2015
1
By Road
Under- Liquid Local
3 Toluene 15 KL 0.20 15 KL
ground 99% Purchase
Tank
By Road
Sodium 6 Solid Local
4 50 Kg 0.10 3.0 MT
Cyanide Drums 98% Purchase
1
Under- By Road
Sulphuric Local
5. ground MS 20 KL Liquid 0.4 5 KL
acid Purchase
Tank
By Road
Local
6. Chlorine Tonner 0.9 MT Gas 0.2 2.7 MT
Purchase
Date : 18.2.2015
To,
The Member Secretary
SEIAA, Maharashtra
Environment Department,
2nd Floor, Mantralaya,
Mumbai - 400 032.
Respected Sir,
The following conditions were suggested by SEAC-1
Sr.No. Points Suggested by SEAC-1 Clarification
1. Charging the raw materials in mechanized It is already complied.
closed feed system should be adopted.
2. All reactors should be provided with the It is already complied.
condensers and scrubbers
3. Boiler should be provided with the stack It is already complied.
height of 30 mt.
4. Multi cyclone dust collector must be It is already complied.
provided.
5. The project should be zero discharged At present the existing project is a zero
category discharge unit, the proponent will
continue the same trend for expansion
project.
6. Considering the hazardous and flammable Training records of employee conducted
nature of materials handled it is necessary in the plant premises is attached as
to impart adequate training to the annexure I
employees handling such materials.
7. Dispersion of chlorine needs to be studied The precautionary steps for handling
and precautionary steps should be taken. chlorine are in place. The precautionary
steps are displayed within the factory
premises in vernacular language. The
evidence of same attached herewith. The
Dispersion studies for Chlorine is also
studied and attached as annexure II
8. Handling of sodium cyanide a highly toxic Standard Operating Procedure followed
substance should be carried out with all in plant for handling sodium cyanide &
care and caution. Permission of Storage of sodium
cyanide is attached as annexure III
As per the GR the details of scrutiny fees submission area as mentioned below:
Thanking You,
What Is Aloha?
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6151
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
asymptomatic nonsensory effects. However, the effects are not disabling and are
transient and reversible upon cessation of exposure.
Chlorine Tonner
Details
Diameter - 0.7 Mtr
Height - 2.0 Mtr
Volume - 0.77m3
No. of Tonner - 01
Capacity of Tonner- 900 Kg
CHEMICAL DATA:
Chemical Name: CHLORINE Molecular Weight: 70.91 g/mol
AEGL-1 (60 min): 0.5 ppm AEGL-2 (60 min): 2 ppm
AEGL-3 (60 min): 20 ppm IDLH: 10 ppm
Ambient Boiling Point: -34.7 C
Vapor Pressure at Ambient Temperature: greater than 1 atm
Ambient Saturation Concentration: 1,000,000 ppm or 100.0%
SITE DATA:
Location: BENZOCHEM INDUSTRIES PVT LTD, INDIA
Building Air Exchanges Per Hour: 0.53 (unsheltered single storied)
Time: February 24, 2015 1551 hours ST (user specified)
SOURCE STRENGTH:
Direct Source: 0.9 tons/hr Source Height: 0
Release Duration: 60 minutes
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6152
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
THREAT ZONE:
Model Run: Gaussian
Red : 263 meters --- (20 ppm = AEGL-3 (60 min))
Orange: 866 meters --- (2 ppm = AEGL-2 (60 min))
Yellow: 1.8 kilometers --- (0.5 ppm = AEGL-1 (60 min))
kilometers
1
0.5
wind
0
0.5
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6153
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
kilometers
2
wind
0
2 0 1 2 3 4 5
kilometers
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6154
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
The probability of failure of the entire tank etc, which is considered in the above scenario is very
less. However to further reduce the same, following precautions would be taken by Benzo Chem
Industries Pvt. Limited.
2. Keep vapors away from work areas by fully or partially enclosing any process.
4. An exhaust located in an outside wall may be sufficient to ventilate an area where chlorine is
near the floor.
5. Chlorine cylinders and containers should be stored in cool, dry, relatively isolated areas
protected from weather and extreme temperature changes.
6. Store cylinder upright and secure them so that they do not fall down.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6155
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
8. Keep enough room between two containers so that all are accessible in case of emergency.
9. Do not store full and empty containers together and keep inventories as small as possible.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6156
BENZO CHEM
INDUSTRIES ENVIORNMENT MANAGEMENT
SOP NO EMS/SOP/
PVT.LIMITED. SYSTEM
JALGAON
STANDARD OPERATING ISSUE/REV
TITLE 1/0
PROCEDURE NO
EFFECTIVE
15/12/2014
EMS ISO-14001:2004/18001:2007 DATE
PAGE NO 1 OF 1
TITLE:- Issue & Transport of Sodium Cyanide From R.M. Stores to Plant storage.
To ensure required quantity of Hazardous material to be issued from
SCOPE:-
stores & safely shifted to Plant storage room.
TITLE:- Handling & Use of Sodium Cyanide for the reaction in the work place.
SCOPE:- To ensure safe handling & use of NaCN for the reaction purpose.
TITLE:- Standing instructions before handling Sodium Cyanide for the reaction.
To ensure & cultivate total awareness related to handling hazardous
SCOPE:-
chemical.
Under Cat: B1
M/s SADEKAR ENVIRO ENGINEERS PVT.LTD.
Jan 2015
CHAPTERS CONTENTS PAGE NO
CHAPTER -1 1-9
INTRODUCTION
CHAPTER -2 2-33
PROJECT DESCRIPTION
CHAPTER - 4 4-24
ANTICIPATED ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT
& MITIGATION MEASURES
4.1 Introduction 4-1
4.2 Air Environment 4-1
4.3 4-10
Noise Environment
4.4 4-13
Water Environment
4.5 SHW Environment 4-19
4.6 Land Environment 4-21
4.7 Soil Environment 4-21
4.8 Biological Environment 4-21
4.9 Socio Economic Environment 4-21
4.10 Odour Environment 4-22
4.11 Occupational Health Environment 4-23
CHAPTER 5 5-3
ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING PROGRAM
CHAPTER 6 6-149
Risk Assessment
6.1 Risk Assessment 6-1
6.2 Hazop Study 6-8
6.3 Disaster Management Plan 6-76
CHAPTER 7 7-1
PROJECT BENEFITS
CHAPTER 8 8-16
ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT PLAN
8.1 Introduction 8-1
8.2 Description of Administrative Aspect 8-2
8.3 Environmental Mitigation Measures for the Project 8-3
8.4 Plantation Programme 8-5
8.5 CSR Activity 8-14
8.6 Rain Water Harvesting 8-16
8.7 Quality Policy 8-16
CHAPTER 9 9-1
CONCLUSION 9-1
CHAPTER 10 10-4
DISCLOSURE OF CONSULTANT
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited 11
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited 12
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
19 Utilities 1 No. of D.G set of Existing D.G. set will 1 No. of D.G set of
320 KVA be used 320 KVA
20 EMP budget 77 lakh 20 Lakh 97 Lakh
21 Project cost 5.72 Crore 2.0 crore 7.72 crore
22 Hazardous Waste Management Membership of Maharashtra Enviro Power
Limited (Ranjangaon)
22 Sensitive Zone Not Present in 10 Km radius of the Proposed
Project
23 Reserved Forest Not Present in 10 Km radius of the Proposed
Project
24 Archaeological Monument Not Present in 10 Km radius of the Proposed
Project
3. Justification of Project
M/s. Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. has proposed expansion of intermediate for API at
MIDC Jalgaon, it will help in gaining valuable foreign exchange by exporting the product in
international market.
4. Baseline Environmental Status:
The study area is 10 km radial distance from centre of existing plant site. All the monitoring has
been completed in various locations within the study area during the period of March 2014
May 2014. The findings of the baseline environmental status on land (topography, soil quality,
land use pattern), meteorology (Temperature, Humidity, rainfall, wind speed), air (ambient air
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited 13
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
quality- PM10, PM2.5, SO2, NOX), noise level, ecological environment (flora and fauna), socio
economic conditions, are presented in the report and interpreted with reference to environment
standards.
4.1 Ambient Air Quality: The maximum value of PM10 was 70.20 g/m3, PM2.5 was 28.40
g/m3 whereas for NOx and SO2 was 38.0 and 23.40 g/m3 respectively. It was observed that
the recorded values of air pollutants are well within the allowable limit of Maharashtra pollution
control board limit (MPCB) & CPCB.
4.2 Ambient Noise level: The ambient noise levels monitored at five different locations indicate
that they were within the limits. The Leq were recorded at project site was the maximum i.e. 67.9
dB(A) during day and 51.2 dB(A) during night time.
4.3 Water Quality: Water monitoring was carried out at five different locations i.e 3 samples for
surface water and 2 sample for GW, it was observed that all the parameters of surface & ground
water were well within the permissible limits except bacteriological parameter in SW of Manyar
Khede Talav observed to be 30 org/100ml, Mehrun Lake was 26.5 Org/100ml & Geerana River
was found to be 33 Org/100ml. The total coliform of all the surface water samples were on the
higher side of the prescribed limit. The predicted reason for the presence of total coliform in the
SW may be due to the anthropogenic activity around the surface water. The analysis indicates
that the ground water is not severely affected by pollution as all the parameters were under the
limit as per IS (10500) 2012.
4.4 Soil Quality: Soil samples were collected from two different locations. It has been observed
that the pH of the soil in the study area ranged from 7.38 -7.59 which indicate the soil is slight
alkaline in nature. The soil type is mostly in the form of sandy loam. The Phosphorus values
range between 9-12.75 kg/ha, indicating that the Phosphorus content in the study area is falling
under less category. The potassium value ranges to 180 kg/ha to 222 kg/ha falls under medium
category. The nitrogen values ranges between 105 to 142.5 Kg/ha which falls under medium
category. On the basis of chemical analysis of soils, the soils can be classified as per standard
soil classification and is found to be medium low fertile soil according to Hand Book of
Agriculture, ICAR, New Delhi.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited 14
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
4.5 Ecology: There are no ecologically sensitive receptors or endangered species within the 10
kms of the study area. The area is developed by M.I.D.C for industrial use, no clustered green
belt is found in the vicinity, hence there will not be any kind of deforestation. No rare or
endangered species of flora and fauna are present in the immediate vicinity as well as the study
area. Thus, there will not be any adverse negative impact on flora and fauna.
4.6 Socio-economic: The project will provide positive impact on the economic development of
the region in terms of employment opportunities.
5. Prediction of Impacts and its Mitigation:
Due to project activity two types of impact is envisaged, temporary impact during
construction phase and permanent impact during operational phase. Based on the impact
analysis, it is predicted that there will be minimal impact on environment during construction
phase as it is a minor construction activity. The permanent impact will be mitigated by providing
appropriate pollution control devices. The sources and mitigation for construction and
operational phase is explained in the below table:
A) Minor Construction Phase
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited 15
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
B) Operational Phase
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited 16
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited 17
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
manufacturing activity will not create any major air, water & noise pollution problems. The
hazardous waste generated from ETP would be send to CHWTSDF at Ranjangaon. Overall it can
be said that the proposed expansion project will not cause any adverse environmental impact if at
all it will have positive socio-economic impacts around the project area by generating
employment for the local people.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited 18
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited Chapter11
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
modern & versatile plant, with glass lined & stainless steel reactors, pressure reactors etc.
capable of carrying out various different kinds of reactions under different conditions.
1.3. Brief description of Nature, Size, Location of the project
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited Chapter12
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
capacity Thermic Fluid heater : be used, only the fuel Thermic Fluid heater :
8 lakh Kcal/Hr requirement will be 8 lac Kcal/Hr
increased to meet the
steam demand for new
expansion activity.
12 Effluent 3.5 CMD 9.2 CMD 12.7 CMD
generation
13 ETP capacity 15 CMD Up gradation :- 15 CMD
Physico chemical
treatment followed by
oxidation with the
help of H2O2 dosing
& tertiary (PSF, ACF)
14 Hazardous Distillation residue : Distillation residue : Distillation residue :
waste 0.5 MT/M 1.0 MT/M 1.5 MT/M
Generation ETP sludge: 0.8 MT/M ETP sludge: 0.8 ETP sludge: 1.6
MT/M MT/M
Process Residue & Process Residue & Process Residue &
waste: 0.01 MT/M waste: 0.04 MT/M waste: 0.05 MT/M
15 Non Discarded Container : Empty Drums : 100 Discarded Container :
hazardous 50 Nos. /M Nos. M 50 Nos. /M
waste Paper Bags : 100 Empty Drums : 100
generation Nos./M Nos. M
Paper Bags : 100
Nos./M
16 Stack height 30 mtr for boiler 30 mtr for boiler 30 mtr for boiler
3 mtr for D.G set 3 mtr for D.G set 3 mtr for D.G set
above the roof above the roof above the roof
17 Man power 28 nos. 14 nos. 42 nos.
18 Fuel Coal /Biomass : 5 TPD Coal /Biomass : 5 Coal /Biomass : 10
requirement TPD TPD
Diesel : 200 L/D Diesel : 200 L/D Diesel : 400 L/D
19 Utilities 1 No. of D.G set of Existing D.G. set will 1 No. of D.G set of
320 KVA be used 320 KVA
20 EMP budget 77 lakh 20 Lakh 97 Lakh
21 Project cost 5.72 Crore 2.0 crore 7.72 crore
22 Hazardous Waste Management Membership of Maharashtra Enviro Power
Limited (Ranjangaon)
22 Sensitive Zone Not Present in 10 Km radius of the Proposed
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited Chapter13
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Project
23 Reserved Forest Not Present in 10 Km radius of the Proposed
Project
24 Archaeological Monument Not Present in 10 Km radius of the Proposed
Project
The aim of the project is to manufacture Intermediate for API which will be subsequently
serving the local & international market. Major Indian populations stand in rural areas. The
project proponent is justifying his aim to serve the country in terms of helping to reduce the cost
of medicine and also gain valuable foreign exchange by exporting the product in international
market. Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. offers excellent opportunities for tapping the
export market for these products.
The application has been submitted to SEAC, dt. 05-03-2013 along with all necessary
documents. The baseline data collection was carried out in the period of March 2014 to May
2014 according to the provision of EIA Notification, 14th sept.2006. i.e if the TOR are not
finalized and conveyed to the applicant within sixty days of the receipt of Form-I, the TOR
suggested by the applicant shall be deemed as the final terms of reference approved for the EIA
studies. Therefore the proponent has decided to go along with the model TOR . On 20th June of
2014 the 81st meeting of SEAC was conducted in which the Additional TOR for the preparation
of EIA was given. Hence the EIA preparation has been performed based on Model TOR and
Additional TOR given by SEAC below
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited Chapter14
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Reconnaissance survey was undertaken within the study area to collect information regarding
topography of the study area, meteorological features of the area and other features relevant to
the air environment. Reconnaissance survey enables the selection of sampling sites and design of
air quality monitoring network. The criteria pollutants like PM2.5, PM10, SO2 and NOx were
identified to assess the existing air quality in the impact zone. The study was conducted for
summer season.
The location of the Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. is spread over an area of 12150 Sq.mt.,
at Jalgaon MIDC, Jalgaon. The study area was 10 km radial distance from the plant site. The
identified impact zone is covered by wasteland, market places, and other rurally inhabited
localities. Within the study area there are some other big and small industries. Five ambient air
quality- monitoring sites were selected based on the ambient air quality monitoring network
design. A reconnaissance was undertaken to identify sampling locations to establish baseline
status of ground water and surface water quality in the study area during March 2014-May 2014.
Two sampling locations were selected to establish the baseline status of soil quality in the study
area. Noise levels were measured using precision integrated sound level meter. Background
noise levels measured in number of villages at different times and locations.
Ecology & Biodiversity survey includes: Collection of information on flora and fauna in the
study area and identification of endangered species. Identification of ecologically sensitive areas
such as biosphere reserves, wildlife sanctuary, national park etc. near project site.Assessment of
impact on endemic /endangered flora & fauna due to proposed project.Design of greenbelt and
identification of suitable native plant species.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited Chapter15
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Risk Assessment and Hazop study will be carried out depending on the raw materials used and
products to be manufactured. Also the risk is estimated of some events which if occurred during
plant operational stage can cause severe environmental and physical damage. The severity of the
event is calculated so that its occurrence can be reduced by applying appropriate safety
measures.
Disaster management plan will also be made to provide an action plan for the workers during
mishap in the plant during operational phase. Quantitative Risk Assessment also estimated using
Aloha, DOW Index and Monds Index
Air Environment
Ambient Air Quality monitoring to measure the levels of PM2.5, PM 10, SO2 and NOx
Collection of surface meteorological data, viz wind speed, wind direction, relative
humidity and temperature.
Noise Environment
Measurement of noise levels in residential, commercial and industrial zones in the study
area
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited Chapter16
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Prediction of impacts due to increase in noise levels arising out of the proposed project
Water Environment
Study of ground water (dug wells / tube wells) and surface water resources with respect
to study area.
Identification of waste water treatment plant technology and suggest any modifications
or additional recommendations, if any
Land Environment
Biological Environment
Collection of information on flora and fauna in the study area and identification of
endangered species.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited Chapter17
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Collections of information on cultural and aesthetic attributes in the study are including
places of historical / archaeological importance.
Projection of anticipated changes due to the proposed project and delineation of measures
to minimize the impacts.
Prediction of impacts
Environmental Management Plan (EMP) will be drawn after identifying and predicting
the significant impacts on each component of the environment.
EMP will be delineated incorporating control technologies, safe guards etc for mitigation
of adverse negative impacts.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited Chapter18
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited Chapter21
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited Chapter22
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Fig No. 2.2: Google earth image for the proposed expansion project site
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited Chapter23
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Toposheet No: 46 P9
Scale : 1: 50000
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited Chapter24
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited Chapter25
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited Chapter26
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
31 Hexamine 3.90
32 Methanol 11.00
33 Para toluene sulphonic acid 0.03
34 Cyclohexane 1.00
35 Propiophenone 20.00
36 Ammonium bicarbonate 12.50
37 Benzyl cyanide 2.25
38 Ethyl bromide 2.10
39 Tri ethyl benzyl ammonium chloride 0.10
40 Mono methyl amine 40 % 4.05
41 Tri ethyl amine 00.10
42 Para chloro phenol 2.40
43 Ortho di chloro benzene 3.00
44 Di methyl sulphate 2.50
45 Formic acid 1.30
46 Formaldehyde solution 37% 1.95
47 Synhydride 3.75
48 Tetra chloro ortho xylene 3.80
49 Per chloro ethylene 10.00
50 3,5 xylenol 07.00
51 Copper sulphate 0.10
52 Benzoyl chloride 2.50
53 Ortho chloro phenyl acetic acid 102.00
54 Bromine 46.00
55 Sodium thio sulphate 5.00
56 Acetyl chloride 5.60
57 Tetra butyl ammonium bromide solution 0.60
58 Cyanuric chloride 5.70
59 Sodium bicarbonate 5.30
60 N-bromo succinimide 15.10
61 Chloro benzene (MCB) 20.20
62 Sodium hydrosulphide 0.10
63 Sodium thio sulphate 0.10
Total 1138.58
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited Chapter27
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited Chapter28
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited Chapter29
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
By-products By-products
Hydrochloric acid (HCl) 40 Hydrochloric acid (HCl) 77 117
Chlorinated cressol / Cresylic acid 0.04 Chlorinated cressol / Cresylic acid 12 12.04
Sodium bisulfite (NaHSO3) 30 30
TOTAL 299.24 TOTAL 681 802.64
MT/A MT/A MT/A
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited Chapter210
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
2.7.2- The list of equipments stalled or being installed in this project is given in table below:
Table No 2.3: List of Equipments
After
Sr.no Name Of the Equipment Capacity Existing
expansion
SS REACTION KETTLE 1000 LTR 1 1
WITH COLUMN & 2000 LTR 2 2
1
CONDENSER 3000 LTR 2 2
5000 LTR -- 1
GLASS LINE 500 LTR 1 1
DISTILITION KETTEL 1000 LTR 2 2
WITH COLUMN, 2000 LTR 1 1
2
CONDENSER AND
RECIEVER. 2 Nos 3000 LTR 3 4
750 LTR 1 1
SS CRYSTALIZER
8 1500 LTR 1 1
2000 LTR 1 1
SS CENTRIFUGE 24 1 1
9
36 2 3
FBD SS DRYER 100 KGS 1 1
10
120 KGS 1 1
11 SS SPARKLER FILTER 10 KGS 1 1
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited Chapter211
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited Chapter212
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited Chapter213
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited Chapter214
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited Chapter215
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited Chapter216
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited Chapter217
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited Chapter218
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited Chapter219
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited Chapter220
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited Chapter221
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited Chapter222
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited Chapter223
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited Chapter224
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited Chapter225
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited Chapter226
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited Chapter227
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited Chapter228
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited Chapter229
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited Chapter230
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited Chapter231
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
2.9: Importance of EIA- Schematic representation of the feasibility drawing which give information
about importance of EIA is shown below:
RESOURCECONSUMPTION POWERCONSUMPTION
RAWMATERIAL
PRODUCTIONACTIVITY
WASTEGENERATION FINISHEDPRODUCTS
POLLUTION
EMPLOYMENT MARKET
ECONOMY
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited Chapter232
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
2.10 Description of Mitigation Measures Incorporated into the proposed expansion Project
Mitigation measures will be adopted to meet the environmental standards prescribed by the
MPCB/CPCB.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited Chapter233
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
B) Operational Phase
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Limited Chapter234
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
The location of the plant is spread over an area of12150 sq. mts., at Jalgaon MIDC, Jalgaon .The
study area was10 km radial distance from the proposed plant site. Period survey: The study was
conducted for summer season (March 2014 May 2014).
3.1 Meteorology data for Jalgaon District
3.1.1 -Introduction
The basic information presented in this section is from secondary data provided by IMD Mumbai and
meteorology data collected from primary survey. The Meteorology station was fixed at the air
monitoring site for collection of meteorology data. The Data was crossed verified by the data from
Jalgaon District Gazetteer.
3.1.2- Meteorology of Jalgaon district
In collection of the meteorological data, historical data play important role in identification of general
meteorological condition of particular region. The climate is generally dry except in monsoon season.
In India, the year has been divided into four seasons.
1. Winter Season : December to February
2. Summer Season : March to May
3. Monsoon Season : June to September
4. Post Monsoon Season : October to November
3.1.3 -Geographical Location
Jalgaon district is located between 20 and 21 North latitudes and 74 55' to 76 28' East longitudes, in
the northern part of the state. The District has geographical area of 11,765 sq km (Jalgaon City: 68.78
Sq.km) and an altitude of 213 m. Jalgaon district is bound by North Satpuda Hills, South Aurangabad
and Nashik, East State Madhya Pradesh and District Buldhana and WestDhule.The landscape of Jalgaon
district is distributed triangularly in northen Maharashtra at the foothills of the Satpuda Mountains.
Jalgaon district forms a part of the tropical monsoon land and therefore shows a significant seasonal
variation in temperature as well as rainfall conditions. Climate of this region is extreme hot and cold.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter31
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
3.1.4- Rainfall
Owing to the geographical conditions within the district, the rainfall is unevenly distributed. Jalgaon
receives about 700 mm rainfall during monsoons, which is followed by pleasant temperature in winter.
Most of this rain is brought by the southwest monsoon winds during the summer and about 80% of
rainfalls during the monsoon months. The monsoon arrives in the month of June, with the maximum
intensity of rainfall during the month of July, August, September & October.
Table No 3.1: Mean Rainfall of Jalgaon District (in mm)
Sr.
Month Rainfall (in mm)
No.
1 January 8.9
2 February 3.1
3 March 4.1
4 April 0.0
5 May 10.7
6 June 128.8
7 July 249.7
8 August 164.1
9 September 148.6
10 October 37.3
11 November 22.1
12 December 7.4
Total 784.8
** Source: IMD Mumbai
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter32
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter33
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Relative Humidity
Month
0830 hrs 1730 hrs
% %
January 60 30
February 49 23
March 41 18
April 43 18
May 56 22
June 72 44
July 86 68
August 86 68
September 86 65
October 69 42
November 64 33
December 65 34
Annual 65 38
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter34
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Fig No. 3.3: Monthly variation in Relative Humidity for Jalgaon District
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter35
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
7 July 9 17
8 August 5 19
9 September 3 14
10 October 2 16
11 November 1 14
12 December 0 10
Average 3 16
**Source: IMD Mumbai
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter36
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter37
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter38
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter39
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter310
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
PM2.5 is 28.40 g/m3 SO2 is 23.4 g/m3 & NOx is 38 g/m3. All the pollutants level measured was
found to be below the NAAQ Limits.
3.3.1.1 Monitoring
A) Boiler Stack Monitoring
Stack Details
Stack No. 1
Steam Boiler (3 T/Hr) &
Thermic fluid Boiler (8
Stack Attached to. Lakh Kcal/Hr)
MOC M.S
Height 30
Diameter 0.8
Shape Round
Type of fuel Coal/Agro Waste
Quantity of fuel t/d 5.0
Duration of
sampling 11 to 12 h
Parameter Unit Results Limit Method Reference
Flue gas
o
Temperature C 130 IS 11255 (part 3): 2008
Flue gas velocity m/s 6.54 IS 11255 (part 3): 2008
Total gas Quantity Nm3/h 8236 IS 11255 (part 3): 2008
IS 11255 (part 1): 1985
PM mg/Nm3 124 150 RA 2003
IS 11255 (part 2): 1985
SO2 mg/Nm3 33 - RA 2003
NOx mg/Nm3 53 - IS 11255(part 7): 2005
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter311
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Stack Details
Stack No. 1
Stack attached to Scrubber No. 1
MOC PVC
Duration Of
Sampling 15.00 to 15.30 h
Parameter Unit Results Limit Method Reference
APHA Method 201, Page No.
HCL mg/Nm3 13.7 35 379
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter312
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Data Interpretation:
Monitoring of the existing utilities in the industry was performed. The monitoring results convey
that the control equipment system adopted in the industry is effective. The efficiency of PCE is
satisfactory i.e cyclone dust collector is efficiently working. Hence the pollutants emitted from the
source is below the limits provided by the MPCB in their Consent to Operate.
3.3.2 Noise Environment
Location of Map Showing Noise Monitoring Locations
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter313
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Project location
N1 Benzochem Ind. 2058'51.98"N 7535'10.03"E Centre 0.1
Pvt. Limited.
N2 Shiroligaon 2055'9.90"N 7531'34.64"E SW 9.1
N3 Near Sagar Nagar 21 0'54.81"N 7535'20.65"E N 3.82
Near Pimpale
N4 2055'5.80"N 7536'13.70"E SE 7.17
Village
N5 Beli 2057'55.45"N 7540'23.10"E EES 9.34
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter314
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Limit during Day time < 75. (Day time shall mean from 6.00 am to 10.00 pm.)
Limit during Night time < 70. (Night time shall mean from 10.00 pm to 6.00 am.)
Data Interpretation:
The maximum noise level was found to be in the company premises. Maximum noise during day time is
67.9 dB (A) where as minimum noise estimated is 50.5 dB (A). Maximum noise estimated during night
time is 51.2 dB (A) and minimum it was about 39.9dB (A).
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter315
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter316
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Ground
Location 21 7535'46.4
4. Water Patil Nagar N 3.35 Km
GW1 0'12.96"N 2"E
(Open well)
Ground Near
Location 7535'31"
5. Water Dhanwad 2057'0"N S 2.95 m
GW2 E
(Bore well) Village
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter317
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Chemical Parameters
IS desirable
Sr. Limit (As
Parameter Result Unit Method
No. per IS
10500)
GW-1 GW-2 SW-1 SW-2 SW-3
APHA 4500
1 pH 6.745 7.21 6.68 6.72 6.595 - 6.5 - 8.5
H+ - B
APHA 2130
2 Turbidity 1.39 1.125 1.835 1.705 2.18 NTU 1
-B
APHA 2160
3 Taste Agreeable Agreeable Agreeable Agreeable Agreeable - Agreeable
-B
Hazen APHA 2120
4 Color <1.00 <1.00 <1.00 <1.00 <1.00 5
units -B
APHA 2150
5 Odour Agreeable Agreeable Agreeable Agreeable Agreeable - Agreeable
-B
6 Total 56 45 41 48 42 mg/lit 200 APHA-
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter318
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Alkalinity 2320-B
Total
APHA 2540
7 Dissolved 308 265 150 166.5 136 mg/lit 500
-C
Solids
Chlorides as APHA 4500
8 -
62.56 54.05 11.51 10.51 13.51 mg/lit 250
Cl Cl- - B
Sulphate as APHA 4500
9 3.16 5.38 6.165 7.82 6.89 mg/lit 200
SO4- SO42 - E
IS:3025-
10 Sulfides <0.01 <0.01 <0.01 <0.01 <0.01 mg/lit 0.05
1964
Total
APHA
11 Hardness as 151 100 58 57 47 mg/lit 200
2340 - C
CaCO3
Trivedi
12 Ammonia <0.10 <0.10 <0.10 <0.10 <0.10 mg/lit 0.5
&Goel
APHA-
13 Nitrate as NO3 2.445 1.30 1.93 1.805 2.165 mg/lit 45
NO3-B
APHA-
14 Fluoride as F- <0.10 <0.10 <0.10 <0.10 <0.10 mg/lit 1
4500-F- - D
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter319
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Phenolic APHA-5530
15 <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 mg/lit 0.001
compound -C
APHA 4500
16 Cyanide <0.01 <0.01 <0.01 <0.01 <0.01 mg/lit 0.05
CN- - D
Anionic APHA-5540
17 <0.10 <0.10 <0.10 <0.10 <0.10 mg/lit 0.2
Detergents -C
Metal Analysis
Aluminium as APHA-
18 <0.02 <0.02 <0.02 <0.02 <0.02 mg/lit 0.03
Al 3111-D
APHA-
19 Arsenic as As <0.01 <0.01 <0.01 <0.01 <0.01 mg/lit 0.01
3114-B
APHA-
20 Barium as Ba <0.03 <0.03 <0.03 <0.03 <0.03 mg/lit 0.7
3111-D
APHA-
21 Boron as B <0.02 <0.02 <0.02 <0.02 <0.02 mg/lit 0.5
3111-D
APHA-
22 Calcium as Ca 30.055 24.04 7.21 9.21 8.015 mg/lit 75
3111-D
Cadmium as APHA-
23 <0.003 <0.003 <0.003 <0.003 <0.003 mg/lit 0.003
Cd 3111-B
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter320
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
APHA-
24 Iron as Fe <0.02 <0.02 <0.02 <0.02 <0.02 mg/lit 0.3
3111-B
APHA-
25 Lead as Pb <0.01 <0.01 <0.01 <0.01 <0.01 mg/lit 0.01
3111-B
Magnesium as APHA-
26 18.51 12.425 9.755 8.29 6.58 mg/lit 30
Mg 3111-B
Manganese as APHA-
27 <0.01 <0.01 <0.01 <0.01 <0.01 mg/lit 0.1
Mn 3111-B
APHA-
28 Mercury as Hg <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 mg/lit 0.001
3112-B
Molybdenum APHA-
29 <0.02 <0.02 <0.02 <0.02 <0.02 mg/lit 0.07
as Mo 3111-B
APHA-
30 Nickel as Ni <0.02 <0.02 <0.02 <0.02 <0.02 mg/lit 0.02
3111-B
APHA-
31 Silver as Ag <0.01 <0.01 <0.01 <0.01 <0.01 mg/lit 0.1
3111-B
Selenium as APHA-
32 <0.01 <0.01 <0.01 <0.01 <0.01 mg/lit 0.01
Se 3111-B
33 Zinc as Zn 2.045 1.685 1.565 1.56 1.51 mg/lit 5 APHA-
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter321
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
3111-B
Microbiological Parameters
Total
coliforms at Org/100m APHA-
34 Absent Absent 26.5 30 33 Absent
370C for 48 l 9221-B
hrs.
E.coli at
Org/100m APHA-
35 44.50C for Absent Absent Absent Absent Absent Absent
l 9221-F
24hrs.
*Monitoring & Analysis performed by Sadekar Enviro Engineers Pvt. Ltd, Laboratory.
Data Interpretation:
Water monitoring was carried out at five different locations i.e 3 samples for surface water and 2 sample for GW, it was observed that
all the parameters of surface & ground water were well within the permissible limits except bacteriological parameter in SW of
Manyar Khede Talav observed to be 30 org/100ml, Mehrun Lake was 26.5 Org/100ml & Geerana River is found to be 33 Org/100ml.
The total coliform of all the surface water samples were on the higher side of the prescribed limit. The predicted reason for the
presence of total coliform in the SW may be due to the anthropogenic activity around the surface water. The analysis indicates that the
ground water is not severely affected by pollution as all the parameters were under the limit as per IS (10500) 2012.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter322
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter323
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Chemical Parameters
Results
Sr.
After
No Parameters Raw After After MEE Units Method
neutraliza
. effluent striper Treatment
tion
1. pH 6.08 8.42 7.44 7.54 - APHA-4500 H+
2. COD 28000.0 25200.00 7600.0 240-300 mg/lit APHA-5220-B
3. BOD (270C 3 day) 13784.8 9122.10 3162.3 80-110 mg/lit APHA-5210-B
4. SS 3868.00 2539.00 579.00 65.00 mg/lit APHA-2540-D
5. TDS 64644.0 10138.00 994.00 340.00 mg/lit APHA-2540-C
6. O&G 16.00 13.20 10.00 6.60 mg/lit APHA-5520-B
7. Chlorides as Cl - 13514.8 12263.47 10511. 20.02 mg/lit APHA 4500 Cl- -
8. Sulphate as SO4- 1439.79 837.87 650.76 172.23 mg/lit APHA 4500 SO4
9. Electrical 98.9 14.7 1.53 0.52 mS/c APHA-2510-B
10. Phenolic 741.50 530.92 81.93 39.86 mg/lit APHA-5530-C
11. Ammonical 24.08 29.96 26.60 11.48 mg/lit APHA-4500-
12. Sulfide as S2- 26.00 68.20 13.20 Nil mg/lit APHA-4500-S2--
13. Arsenic as As 27.64 26.68 14.20 <0.01 mg/lit APHA-3114-B
14. Cadmium as Cd <0.003 <0.003 <0.003 <0.003 mg/lit APHA-3111-B
15. Mercury as Hg <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 mg/lit APHA-3112-B
*Monitoring & Analysis performed by Sadekar Enviro Engineers Pvt. Ltd, Laboratory.
Data Interpretation
The Outlet of MEE further treated by physicochemical treatment followed by Oxidation with the help of
H2O2 addition and followed by tertiary scheme comprises of PCF & ACF so as to achieve the desirable
quality for reusing the water to maintain the zero discharge.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter324
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
The treatability study of MEE effluent has been carried out and the above scheme is in implementation
stage. The scheme adopted by the proponent after MEE treatment seems to be adequate on basis of the
treatability studies to maintain the zero discharge in the unit.
3.3.4 Soil Environment
Location of Map Showing Soil Monitoring Locations
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter325
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Sr.
Monitoring Locations Lat Long Distance Direction
No
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter326
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
12. Nitrate as NO3- 15.34 11.54 mg/kg Analytical Techniques Manual CPCB
13. Nitrite as NO2- 4.78 3.08 mg/kg Analytical Techniques Manual CPCB
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter327
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
*Monitoring & Analysis performed by Sadekar Enviro Engineers Pvt. Ltd, Laboratory.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter328
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Data Interpretation:
It has been observed that the pH of the soil in the study area ranged from 7.38 -7.59 which indicate the
soil is slight alkaline in nature. The soil type is mostly in the form of sandy loam. The Phosphorus
values range between 9-12.75 kg/ha, indicating that the Phosphorus content in the study area is falling
under less category. The potassium value ranges to 180 kg/ha to 222 kg/ha falls under medium category.
The nitrogen values ranges between 105 to 142.5 Kg/ha which falls under medium category.
On the basis of chemical analysis of soils, the soils can be classified as per standard soil classification
and is found to be medium low fertile soil according to Hand Book of Agriculture, ICAR, New Delhi.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter329
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Very high > 1.00 > 700 > 80.0 > 360
High 0.81- 1.00 561 700 64 80 301 360
Medium 0.61-0.80 421 560 48 64 241 300
Medium Low 0.41-0.60 281 420 32 48 181 240
Low 0.21-0.40 141 280 16 32 121 180
Very Low < 0.20 < 140 < 16.0 < 120
Source : Tondon H.L.S.( 2005 )
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter330
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter331
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Drainage Pattern:
Interpretation:
JALGAON DISTRICT
AREA IN
LANDUSE SqKm
Airpiort 0.8924
Barren Rocky Surface 396.2698
Built Up 578.0644
Crop Land 622.6226
Crop Land in hilly area 0.2928
Fallow Land 802.7784
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter332
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Industry 189.3809
Land with Scrub 534.4252
Land without Scrub 274.1900
Low Dense Forest 6.7557
Medium Dense Forest 61.6802
Mining Area 704.3448
Plantation 310.8007
River 2.6430
Tank 499.7771
Under
Development/Construction 0.1646
Up Land 218.3784
Up Land/Rocky
Surface/Sheet Rock 5.3159
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter333
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
The main objective of ecological survey is to collect the baseline terrestrial biodiversity status regarding
flora and fauna in the Project Influenced Area.
Jalgaon situated between 20.997984N & 75.566711E is a city in western India, to the north of
Maharshtra state in Jalgaon District, which itself is located on the northern Deccan plateau.
Jalgaon District is located in the north-west region of Maharashtra. It is bounded by Satpuda mountain
ranges in the north, Ajanta mountain ranges in the south, Jalgaon is rich in volcanic soil which is well
suited for cotton production.
Located within the productive, irrigated agricultural region of Khandesh, Jalgaon has a diverse climate.
It is exceptionally hot and dry during summer with temperatures reaching as high as 47 degrees Celsius
within period of May end to June mid. Jalgaon receives about 700 mm rainfall during monsoons, which
is followed by pleasant temperature in winter.
The main crops of the region are Banana (Musa sp.), Wheat (Triticum sp.), Groundnut (Arachis
hypogea), Cotton (Gossypium hirsutum) & Sugar cane (Saccharum officinarum)
The terrestrial ecosystem of the study area is dominated mostly by scrubs/grass land/secondary
woodlands, plains & farms lands. Three surface water bodies are present around the project site viz.
Mehroon lake, Manyarkheda Lake & Zipru Anna Maharaj Lake at an approximate distance of 2 km, 3
km & 5 km respectively towards East & West direction from the project site. The details of assessment
techniques are given below:
The main objective of ecological survey is to collect the baseline terrestrial biodiversity status regarding
flora and fauna in the Project Influence Area.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter334
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Macrophyte:
To protect and conserve this rich bio-diversity it is necessary to enlist the bio-diversity of various
habitats. Present study is an attempt to document the macrophyte of the said study area so as to know the
present ecological status.
The Benzochem Pvt. Limited has already developed the green belt in and around the factory premises,
the details of vegetation in the green belt are as follows:
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter335
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter336
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Observations:
Table No. 4.14 The floral diversity in and around the core & buffer zone of the project area is
as follows:
Sr. Botanical Name Habit Family Local Names IUCN status
No.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter337
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter338
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter339
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter340
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter341
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter342
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter343
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
pendula
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter344
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Avian Diversity
The avifaunal diversity in and around the core & buffer zone of the project area is as follows:
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter345
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Concern ver
3.1
Least
4 Bubulcus ibis Ardeidae Cattle Egret Concern ver
3.1
Least
5 Accipiter badius Accipitridae Shikra Concern ver
3.1
Least
6 Milvus migrans Accipitridae Black Kite Concern ver
3.1
Least
7 Vanellus indicus Charadriidae Red-wattled Lapwing Concern ver
3.1
Least
8 Columba livia Columbidae Blue Rock Pigeon Concern ver
3.1
Least
Psittacula
9 Psittacidae Rose-ringed Parakeet Concern ver
krameri
3.1
Least
10 Cuculus canorus Cuculidae Common Cukoo Concern ver
3.1
Least
Centropus
11 Cuculidae Greater Coucal Concern ver
sinensis
3.1
12 Cypsiurus Apodidae Asian Palm Swift Least
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter346
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter347
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
The Lepidopterian diversity in and around the core & buffer zone of the
project area is as follows:
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter348
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
The diversity of spiders in and around the core & buffer zone of the project area is as
follows:
Phylum - Arthropoda
The Mammals observed in and around the core & buffer zone of the project area is
as follows:
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter349
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Reptiles
The Reptilian diversity in and around the core & buffer zone of the project area is
as follows:
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter350
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter351
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Conclusion:
The observations of ecology & biodiversity study reveal that out of 136 floral, 27 avifaunal, 3
lepidopterian, 3mammalian, 1 reptilian & 4 arthropoda species none belong to the vulnerable,
threatened, endangered & critically endangered categories as defined by the International Union for
Conservation of Nature (IUCN).
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter352
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter353
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Jalgaon Tehsil, Jalgaon District, child population in the age group 0 to 6 figures for 2011
Rural Urban TOTAL
Boys . 14,732 . 28,548 43280
Girls 11,655 22,996 34651
TOTAL 26,387 51,544 77,931
Source: Census of India, 2011
Total child population(In age group of 0 to 6) of Jalgaon Tehsil is 77931. Population of girl child is
lower than the population of boys for both rural and urban areas.
Sex ratio of Population and Child Population in the age-group 0-6 Jalgaon Tahsil, 2011
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter354
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Jalgaon
85.78 91.42 79.68 78.84 87.31 69.76 88.96 93.30 84.26
Source: Census of India, 2011
Literacy rate is more in urban areas than in rural areas and male population is more literate than female
population both in urban as well as in rural areas.
Information regarding Primary schools
Tehsil Total Schools
No of Students
Particulars Distribution No of No of No of No of Schools having
Schools Teachers Boys girls sanitary
facilities
Jalgaon Primary Total 248 1480 34775 30165 244
Schools For Girls 22 150 0 4311 22
Secondary Total 82 948 20760 15733 82
School For Girls 4 75 0 2587 4
Higher Total 21 562 13095 13030 21
Secondary For Girls 2 89 0 3640 2
Source: District Social and Economic Survey of Jalgaon District, 2011
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter355
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
There are 248 schools providing primary education while 82 and 21 schools providing secondary and
higher secondary education respectively. Total number of students learning in higher secondary school
is considerably lower than the no of students in primary schools indicating many people leave their
education after primary or secondary schooling.
Gross/Net District Domestic Product and Per Capita Net District Income Jalgaon district
At Current Prices (Rs in Crore) At Constant (2004-05) Prices (Rs Per Capita Net
in Crore) District Domestic
Product
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter356
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
In Jalgaon Tehsil there are 86 villages with 14 group grampanchayat and 56 independent
grampanchayat. In Jalgaon Taluka there are 67 villages with drinking water supply facility, 74 villages
with availability of roads and none of the villages are without connectivity of roads, there are 3 villages
availing prime minister gramsadak yojna.
Basic Amenities
Tehsi No. of No. of No. of No. of No. of No. of No. of No. of No. of
l villages villag villages village village villages droug villag villages
with es with s with s with with ht es with
electrificati with commer prima health anganwa prone with primary
on S.T ce bank ry related di village post agricultur
bus office school faciliti s office al supply
facilit es institutes
y
Jalgao 86 86 10 82 86 86 19 40 61
n
Source: District Social and Economic Survey of Jalgaon District, 2011
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter357
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
In Jalgaon Tehsil all villages (86) has electricity and all villages (86) are provided with state transport
services. There are 10 villages with commerce bank office and 82 villages are having primary school.
All 86 villages are provided with health related facilities. Anganwadi are there in all villages. Out of 86
villages 19 villages are prone to draught. Near about 40 villages have post offices. 61 villages have
primary agricultural supply facility.
Public food supply
Tehsil No. of ration shops No of ration card holders
In Jalgaon Taluka there are 207 working ration shops. There are 22775 ration card holders who are
below poverty line and 91397 ration card holders who are above poverty line. In Jalgaon there are 3
government warehouse with total capacity of 1340 metric tons.
Revenue generated through various governmental sources (in thousands)
Tehsil Land Land Total Wavers Terminated Amount Actual No. of
revenue revenue demand pending to be obtained farmer
total pending amount obtained amount who are
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter358
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
ongoing members
demand
Jalgaon 277184 0.00 277184 0.00 0.00 277184 240686.5 27913.00
Jalgaon 60 0 60 65 0 65
Source: District Social and Economic Survey of Jalgaon District, 2011
There are total of 60 established saving groups and 65 saving groupsare connected to banks for people
with below poverty line but none for people those are above poverty line.
Attitude towards Proposed Project
Jalgaon taluka is in a very close proximity to Jalgaon city, only 4 km away from the Jalgaon railway
station. People in this area already know the Benzo Chem industries Pvt. Limited as this is an existing
plant. Further, people also believe that the proposed expansion of project will not have any negative
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter359
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
impact on their health, transport and on any kind of intrusion on their society as a whole; they do not
look this industrial development as objectionable. Instead they believe that there will be an increased job
opportunity for skilled and non skilled people.
Social Commitments
The project proponent would employee majority of local peoples to fulfill the need of increased man
power. The proponent contributes on CSR activity. The company gives appropriate support to the
nearby schools, and organizes medical camps for the local peoples and free medical help to the local
needy persons.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter360
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Prediction of probable sources of pollution from the expansion activity is the most important
component in environmental impact assessment process. The quantitative prediction of sources is
also essential to delineate pragmatic environmental management plan (pollution control
measures) for implementation during construction and operation stages of proposed activities for
minimizing the adverse impacts on environmental quality. The predictions are estimated which
are superimposed on the baseline value for achieving the resultant value.
a. Operational Phase
1. Identification of Source
Operational phase will lead to permanent air pollution having negative impact on the air quality.
The three pollutant of main concern are particulate matter, SO2 and NOx. The sources identified
which will be responsible for above mentioned pollutant are Boiler and D.G set. As the emission
is excepted from the fixed locations hence, it is considered under point source.
2. Prediction of Impact
Components Existing
Fuel Coal/Biomass: 5TPD
Requirement
Boiler Boiler Capacity Ht. Fuel
Steam Boiler 3 T/Hr 30 Mtr Coal/Biomass
ThermicFluid 8 Lakh 30 Mtr Coal /Biomass
Heater Kcal/Hr
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter41
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
The Steam Boiler & thermic fluid Boiler is connected to the same stack which is considered for
air modeling. The stack attached to D.G set is not considered, as the D.G set will be operated
during power failure only.
Aermod 8.2.0 has been used for predicting the maximum incremental concentration of
pollutants dispersion from the point source.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter42
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter43
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter44
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter45
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Interpretation
Proposed Mitigation
In the proposed expansion project, PM 10, NOx and SO2 will be the major air pollutants from fuel
burning units. Therefore for the mitigation measures for PM cyclone dust collector is installed to
the boiler. For proper dispersion of pollutant appropriate stack height is provided. The
calculation for stack height is shown below,
Boiler
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter46
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Fugitive Emission
Probable Source: The usage of below given solvents and acid are the probable sources
for fugitive emission.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter47
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Physica
Maximum
l and consumpti Means
Capacit Quantity of Source
Sr. Number of Chemic on of
Name y storage at of
no storages al (in TPD) transpor
any point supply
compos t-ation
of time
ition
Local
12 Liquid By
1 Methanol 200 lit 0.10 2 KL Purchas
Barrels 99% Road
e
Local By
9 Liquid
2 Hexane 200 Lit 0.50 2 KL Purchas Road
Barrels 99%
e
1
Local By
Under- Liquid
3 Toluene 15 KL 0.20 15 KL Purchas Road
ground 99%
e
Tank
Local By
Sodium 6 Solid
4 50 Kg 0.10 3.0 MT Purchas Road
Cyanide Drums 98%
e
1
Local By
Sulphuric Under-
5. 20 KL Liquid 0.4 5 KL Purchas Road
acid ground MS
e
Tank
Local By
6. Chlorine Tonner 0.9 MT Gas 0.2 2.7 MT Purchas Road
e
Predicted Impact
The amount of quantity stored for toluene in the site is around 15 KL , from which VOC can be
generated. Acid vapours can be generated from the use of sulphuric and hydrochloric acid stored
in barrels. It can lead to unhealthy and unsafe condition in the working area of the industry.
Proposed Mitigation
For the process closed feed system is provided for the raw materials to reduce the fugitive
emission. Loading of the solvent is done in the closed pipes. Also the reactors are connected to
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter48
SEEPL/EEIA/F/
Benzo
o Chem
m Indusstries Pvt.
P Limmited. IND/BIPLL/001/
2014-15/00
process scrubber
s for reducing thee fugitive em
mission. There are storagge tanks in thhe project sitte for
acids andd solvents. Due
D care is taken
t in desiigning of stoorage facilitiies at each stage
s to miniimize
the fugittive emission
ns. Existingg Storage tanks is provided with proper
p dykess for safety.. The
storage capacity off individual Solvent orr Acid tankks is higheer than the usage capaacity.
Accordinngly the fugitive emissioon from stoorage tanks is
i expected to be minim
mal includinng the
resultant impacts on air environm
ment. Truckk movements in proposeed project arre not signifficant
and thereefore the emiissions from
m truck moveements are noot considereed.
SadekarEn
nviroEngineeersPvt.Ltd Chap
pter49
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
a. Operational phase
Probable Sources
The plant noise sources include turbo-generators, air compressors, feed pumps, condensate
pumps, reflux pumps, recycle pumps, air blowers, I.D. Fans, cooling towers etc.
Impact Prediction
Noise level monitoring has been carried out at 6 different locations in immediate vicinity of plant
site and measured noise levels are listed below in Table 4.3.
Sr.
No Location Sound Level dB (A)
1 Near Main Gate 47.4
2 Near Office 55.2
3 Near ETP 69.2
4 Boiler House 72.6
5 Production Room 71.3
6 Laboratory 61.5
*Monitoring & Analysis performed by Sadekar Enviro Engineers Pvt. Ltd, Laboratory.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter410
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
n
SPLT = 10Log 10 SPLi
10
i=1
= 10 x 7.62 dB
= 76.2 dB
To calculate the drop in combined sound level generated during the operational phase the
following equation has been used,
Where X is the distance from the center of the proposed site (m)
Table No.4.5: Resultant Noise Level at particular distance from the source
76.2 dB 18 dB 58.2 dB
It is predicted that noise levels inside the plant will not be exceeding 75 dBA by the major noise
sources listed in these plant units. However, exposure to noise to individual workers will be
below 90 dBA (for 8 hours shift). The workers will be exposed to these levels for a short
duration also the prediction is for worst case scenario as no barriers or sound absorbers are
considered during the calculation of noise level prediction.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter411
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Proposed Mitigation
The usage of the D.G set will be only during the power failures. The noise generated due to the
traffic is mitigated by plantation around the area of the site and transportation or traffic
management. The transportation will be done only by the PUC certified vehicles. Even the D.G
set will be covered with proper instrument like acoustic enclosure so that large amount of noise
cannot be generated during the working period of the D.G sets. The green belt area is present
around the four boundaries of the company. The thick green belt or shelter belt will act as the
barrier for cutting the noise generated in the factory premises.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter412
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
a. Operational Phase
Probable Source
During the operational phase of the project (existing+proposed), the quantity of water consumed
for industrial and domestic purpose will be around 62 m3/d. The source of water supply will be
Jalgaon MIDC.The sources of waste water generation during operational phase are from
manufacturing process including water from the reaction vessel, cleaning of the reactors, floor
washing, during purifying the final product, utilities and domestic uses. The waste water
generated will be around 12.7CMD which will be treated in 15 m3/d capacity of ETP followed
MEE for Zero Discharge. The water table is given below, for proper segregation of water
consumption and wastewater generated in the operational phase.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter413
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Existing Water Budget Drift & Evaporation loss 0.5
Domestic2CMD Domesticeffluent1.5CMD
Jalgaon MIDC
Evaporationloss 0.7 CMD
Industrialeffluent1.8CMD
Process 2.5CMD
Evaporationloss3CMD
Blowdown0.2CMD
Raw Water Boiler 9.5CMD Condensate6.3CMD 1.8+0.2+1.5=
22 CMD
3.5CMDtoETP
Condensate Reuse 6.3 CMD
Evaporationloss1CMD
losses5CMD
2 CMD
Garden 5CMD
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter414
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Proposed Water Budget Drift & Evaporation loss 0.5 CMD
Domestic3CMD Domesticeffluent2.5CMD
Jalgaon MIDC
Evaporationloss 0.8 CMD
Industrialeffluent3.7CMD
Process 4.5CMD
Evaporationloss3CMD
Blowdown3CMD
Raw Water Boiler 20CMD Condensate14CMD 2.5+3.7+3=9.2
40 CMD
CMDtoETP
Condensate Reuse 14 CMD
losses5CMD
5 CMD
Garden 5CMD
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter415
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Predicted Impact
Untreated wastewater discharge will affect the surface water in the nearby area. Due to the
discharge also the ground water and soil can be affected when it will percolate through the soil
surface.
Proposed Mitigation
The waste water generated from industrial and domestic activities are treated in ETP followed by
MEE for Zero discharge. Maximum water is recycled and reused to decrease the water
consumption by the proposed expansion. The design and ETP layout is given below,
Table No. 4.8: Dimension of the Different Units of wastewater Treatment Plant
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter416
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Fig No. 4.5: ETP Layout Plan for the Proposed Project
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter417
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Results
Sr.
Paramete After MEE After After
No Raw After Units Method
rs neutralizati Outlet Flocculatio PSF &
. effluent striper
on effluent n and ACF
1. pH 6.08 8.42 7.44 7.54 7.2 7.0 - APHA-4500 H+ - B
2. COD 28000.00 25200.00 7600.00 250-300 210 190 mg/lit APHA-5220-B
3. BOD 13784.80 9122.10 3162.36 80-110 70 63 mg/lit APHA-5210-B
4. SS 3868.00 2539.00 579.00 65.00 62 56 mg/lit APHA-2540-D
5. TDS 64644.00 10138.00 994.00 340.00 310 292 mg/lit APHA-2540-C
6. O&G 16.00 13.20 10.00 6.60 4.0 3.8 mg/lit APHA-5520-B
7. Chlorides 13514.85 12263.47 10511.55 20.02 19.4 18.1 mg/lit APHA 4500 Cl- - B
8. Sulphate 1439.79 837.87 650.76 172.23 167.12 164.37 mg/lit APHA 4500 SO4 E
9. SO
Electrical 98.9 14.7 1.53 0.52 0.50 0.41 mS/cm APHA-2510-B
10. Phenolic 741.50 530.92 81.93 39.86 37.24 35.8 mg/lit APHA-5530-C
11. Ammonic 24.08 29.96 26.60 11.48 10.90 10.14 mg/lit APHA-4500-NH3-C
12. Sulfide as 26.00 68.20 13.20 Nil Nil Nil mg/lit APHA-4500-S2--F
13. Arsenic as 27.64 26.68 14.20 <0.01 <0.01 <0.01 mg/lit APHA-3114-B
14. Cadmium <0.003 <0.003 <0.003 <0.003 <0.003 <0.003 mg/lit APHA-3111-B
15. Mercury <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 mg/lit APHA-3112-B
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter418
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
The total amount of water consumed at first is around 62 m3/d, The total water recycle is around
12.7 CMD. Hence after the plant is achieved zero discharge the plant water consumption is
reduced to 49.3 CMD.
The Outlet of MEE further treated by physicochemical treatment followed by Oxidation with the
help of H2O2 addition and followed by tertiary scheme comprises of PCF & ACF so as to
achieve the desirable quality for reusing the water to maintain the zero discharge. The treatability
study shown above of effluent after MEE treatment clearly indicates that the parameters are
reduced to the permissible limit. Hence the scheme adopted by the proponent after MEE
treatment seems to be adequate to maintain the zero discharge in the unit. Hence, no negative
impacts are expected during operation phase of the project.
4.5 Solid & Hazardous waste
a. Operational Phase
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter419
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Form
Existing Proposed
Sr. no Source (sludge/Dry/slu
Qty(TPM ) Qty(TPM )
rry etc.)
Empty Drums (Non
1. 50 No./M 100 No./M Dry
Hazardous)
Paper Bags
2. (Non Hazardous) - 100 No./M Dry
Recommendations:
If the hazardous waste is not handled and stored properly at site, it can result into deterioration of
environmental conditions by contaminating the Soil, Water and Air. It should be disposed off, at
the earliest from the date of generation and collection. The practice of record maintaining shall
be continued for the disposal of hazardous waste in Form no. 13 and annual return in Form 4 and
Half Yearly return in Form 6 (for Battery Waste).
The waste shall not be stored more than 90 days as per HW Rules 2008 in condition. During
monsoon, the waste shall be protected from the rain water and shall be kept at designated place.
The solid waste identified and addressed in above table shall be handled and disposed off on
timely manner.
Conclusion:
The industry is following the Hazardous Waste Management practices as per the Hazardous
Waste Rules, 2008 and amendment Rules. It has provided the separate area for the storage of
different types of waste with proper identification. During the rainy season as the mechanical
sludge dryer will be used like centrifuge handling of solid waste will not be a problem. The
chemical sludge generated from the ETP is handled properly and disposed off through
CHWTSDF, Ranjangaon.
The regular training is also provided by the SHE Dept. to increase the awareness among the
employee and contractors regarding generation and management of Solid Waste.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter420
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
The effluent generated from process will be treated in the ETP and the treated water will be
reused in the plant operations itself to maintain the zero discharge. The hazardous waste
generated due to the ETP process will be disposed to CHWTSDF.
The entire liquid waste as well as solid waste would be taken care of scientifically therefore there
is no contamination of land due to liquid effluent as well solid hazardous.
There will be no discharge of waste water onto land as it is zero discharge unit. The solid wastes
shall be segregated according to their properties, packed, transported and stored in a separate
impervious storage area demarcated for them. They will then be disposed off according to the
requirements of statutory authorities to CHWTSDF at Ranjangaon. Also since the expansion
project is located within the notified industrial area, it will not have any major affect on the soil
environment.
There is no reserved forest or any sensitive zone around the 10 Km area of the project. No
adverse impact is predicted due to air pollutants from the proposed expansion project.
No endangered species listed on the IUCN Red data list is found or spotted in the proposed study
area of 10 Km.
The liquid wastes will be generated during expansion will be treated efficiently in the existing
plant. As the project is in the notified MIDC area no major ecological impact is predicted due to
its activity.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter421
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
impacts on socio-economic environment due to immigration of population from nearby areas for
jobs.
Table No. 4.12: Prediction of Qualitative Impacts on Socio-Economic Environment.
Employment + + + + * +
Income + + + + * +
Transport + * + * * +
Medical facilities + * + * * +
Communication + + + * * +
Housing + * + * * +
Health * * * * * *
Recreation + + * + * +
Agriculture * * * * * *
Cost of living * * * + * +
Business + + + * * *
Per capita Income + + + * * *
Pollution * * * * * *
+ : Positive Impact
: Negative Impact
* : Insignificant
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter422
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
operational phase sources which will lead to the generation of odour are leakage of
solvent/chemical from the storage tank/pipeline/reactors, evaporation of acid as acid fumes,
domestic waste, handling of raw materials, also handling of sludge and reaction process etc.
Predicted Impacts
Unhealthy working condition will be generated in the plant premises. Workers will be exposed to
harmful diseases. It will affect the plant working and efficiency, indirectly affecting the product
quality.
Proposed Mitigation
Volatile Organic Carbon and acid mist are the fugitive emission generated during the process of
the plant operation. VOC will be controlled by providing proper ventilation in the storage area .
Emissions from process will be directed towards scrubbers for treatment. Solvent will be
recovered by distillation and stored separately.
4.11 Occupational Health Environment
For the safety of workers at site, engaged at the strategic location/dust generation points like,
Processing, loading and unloading points etc. dusk mask is provided. Dust mask would prevent
the inhalation of suspended thereby reducing the risk of lung disease and other respiratory
disorders. Along with that safety goggles, safety shoes and helmet is provided to the workers.
To protect the workers from high sound level during operational phase of the proposed
expansion project like Machine Activity, Reactors, D.G set the following measures is adopted.
Provision of protective device like ear muffs/ear plugs to the worker who cannot be
isolated from the source of high intensity noise.
Confining the noise by isolating the source of noise.
Reducing the exposure time of workers to higher noise levels by rotation system.
Staff training ensures that employees receive appropriate environmental awareness training. This
is achieved through a variety of methods including induction training, formal presentations, and
meetings. It involves awareness/procedure as mentioned below :
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter423
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Specifically, requires that employees, contractors and visitors are aware of:
Their roles and responsibilities (including environmental incident reporting);
The environmental impacts, potential or actual, of their activities on site;
Natural hazards such as poisonous and venomous animals;
The potential consequences of poor environmental performance; and
Site emergency procedures.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter424
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
5.1 Introduction
Environmental monitoring Program is an essential tool for sustainable development an environmental
monitoring Program provides a delivery mechanism to address the adverse environmental impacts of
a project during its execution, to enhance project benefits, and to introduce standards of good practice
to be adopted for all project works. An environmental monitoring program is important as it provides
useful information and helps to:
Assist in detecting the development of any unwanted environmental situation, and thus,
provides opportunities for adopting appropriate control measures.
Define the responsibilities of the project proponents, contractors and environmental monitors
and provides means of effectively communicating environmental issues among them.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter51
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter52
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
5.3 Monitoring Parameters & Frequency:
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter53
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
6.1 Introduction
As indicated in the earlier chapter the expansion facility to manufacture intermediate for
Active Pharmaceutical Ingredients (APIs) poses various types of hazards due to storage,
handling and manipulation of different chemicals, which are indicated in Chapter no. 2
(Section No.2.6.4).
In order to study the risks envisaged by the activities, the following methodology was
adopted.
6.1.2 The factory would be manufacturing about 26 different products. It was indicated by
the factory officials that out of these 26 products, the main products which would be
manufactured on a larger / regular scale would be 6. Other products will have low
volume and would be manufactured on campaign basis. A study of the
manufacturing processes for these six products indicated that almost all the
hazardous chemicals which would be used by the factory would be covered under
these processes.
Rapid Hazop Study was done by a team comprising of members from Sadekar
Enviro engineers and Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. Mr. S. Navale , Sr. GM
Technical agreed that the recommendations of the Hazop. Team will be implemented
during installation, commissioning and running of the plant. The Hazop Study is
given in Section 6.2 below .
6.1.3 A detailed scrutiny of various chemicals which would be stored on the site was done.
The details about the storage tanks are given in Table No. 6.1 below-
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter61
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
The transfer pump capacity for all the above tanks is 4.5 liter/sec.
6.1.4 A Quantitative Risk Assessment based on the software ALOHA Area Locations of
Hazardous Atmospheres was carried out. Details of ALOHA and various terms used
in the calculations are given in Section 6.3 below. Three failures are considered for
Toulene of the flammable solvent storage tanks failure of the tank and the entire
contents of the tank getting accumulated in the dyke enclosure and leakage of the
solvent from 20% of the area during pumping from storage tanks to day tanks ( i.e. at
the rate of 20% of 4.5 lps = 0.9 lps)
The basic data used for calculations is given in Section 6.4 below.
The assumptions made while running the software are given in Section 6.5 below.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter62
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SOURCE - TANK
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter63
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SOURCE : PUDDLE
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter64
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
5 KW/m2 19.2024
2 KW/m2 27.432
SOURCE : DIRECT
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter65
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Based on the unsafe distances identified by the software output and the failure frequency data
given in Table 6C below , the MCLS (maximum credible loss scenario) for the factory works
out to about 74 meter (Scenario No. Toluene 11).
The probability of failure of the entire tank etc, which is considered in the above scenario is
very less. However to further reduce the same, following precautions would be taken by
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited.
The tanks will be fabricated taking into account the corrosion resistance properties of the
material of construction.
The tank will be provided with water sprinkler arrangement so as to cool the same in summer
season
The tanks will be provided with breather valves and will have nitrogen blanketing
arrangement wherever required
Dyke wall of adequate volume (110%) capacity of the tank will be constructed around the
tanks.
Regular inspection of the tank, transfer pipelines and dyke will be done visually and records
maintained.
Wherever required, the tanks would be covered under a license under Petroleum Rules from
PESO.
The gas cylinders would be stored under a shed, not exposing these directly to sunrays.
It would be ensured that the cylinders, when not in use would have valve protection caps.
Chlorine / ammonia kit would be provided near the cylinder storage area.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter66
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Shell
25 30.0
40 10.0
50 7.5
100 4.0
150 3.0
(*Failure frequency expressed in No. per met length per 106 years)
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter67
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
6.2.1. PREFACE:
The Hazop study was carried out in two stages at M/S BENZO CHEM INDUSTRIES
PVT.LIMITED E-13,14,15, M.I.D.C.,
Area, Jalgaon Tal- Dist-Jalgaon
Stage-I
Part study was conducted at the plant site in consultation with the technical personnel of
production and maintenance,
Suggestions and comments from the and experience in Fabrication work from them formed an
important part of the
entire exercise.
Stage-II
An internal exercise at the office of BENZOCHEM IND.PVT.LIMITED. Was carried out after
scrutinizing the piping and instrumentation diagrams in details.
The scope of the hazop study is to analyze all possible deviations from the design intent and based
upon the type of effect, remedial measures have been worked out. In the present exercise equipments
in the Unit and SOLVENT storage Tank and REACTION VESSEL have been thoroughly evaluated
in order to find out the effects of failures/non performance and faults. After getting to know the
consequences of deviation, practicable remedies have been suggested to counter any possible
damaging efforts. The important places where the HAZOP study would dig out some dangerous
possibilities have been presented in the report. Hazop worksheet have also been included for the
same in order to improve presentation .The important process unit which has been presented
herewith is
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter68
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Since it is practically difficult to present all the Hazop work sheet in the report, the findings only of
other process units which have been evaluated are also presented. Recommendations have also been
given for the said findings.
6.2.3 METHODOLOGY :
INTRODUCTION.
Primarily, safety in the design of a plant relies on the application of various codes of
practice or design codes which are based on the wide experience and knowledge of professional
experts and specialists in the industry. Such application is backed up by the experience of local plant
managers and engineers who have been involved in similar plants and who have had direct
experience in their operation.
All new projects embody some element of change but in the case of storage of hazardous
materials the degree of change from one plant to the next is often considerable. It is important to
recognize that the body of established experience expressed in codes, etc. is limited by the extent of
existing knowledge and can only be relevant to the extent to which it is possible to apply it to new
products, new plants and new methods of operation involved in the new design. It has become
increasingly clear in recent years that although codes of practice are extremely valuable, it is
particularly important to supplement them with an imaginative anticipation of hazards when new
projects involve new technology.
The need to check designs for errors and omissions has been recognized for a long
time, but this has traditionally been done on an individual basis. Experts have usually applied their
special skills or experience to check particular aspects of design. For example the instrument
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter69
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
engineer would check the control systems and having satisfied him self that the systems were
satisfactory would put his mark of approval on the design and pass it to the next expert.
This kind of individual, provided it is carried out conscientiously, will obviously improve the
design but clearly it has little chance of detecting hazards concern with the interaction of a no. of
functions or specialists. These hazards are likely to result from the unexpected interaction of
seemingly safe components of methods of operations under exceptional conditions. If it is wished to
study such interactions in new designs, the combined skills of a group of experts are required. Their
total knowledge and informed imaginations can be used to anticipate whether the plant will operate
as intended under all possible circumstances.
This report provides a method of working for such a group so that they can carry out
their task systematically and thoroughly.
THE PRINCIPLES OF HAZOP STUDY.
Because the Hazop Study is the fundamental part of a Hazard and operability study, it is highlighted
and described separately in this chapter.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter610
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
considered to decide how it could caused and what would be the consequences. Some of the causes
may be unrealistic and so the derived consequences will be rejected as not meaningful. Some of the
consequences may be trivial and would be considered no further. However, there may be some
deviations with both causes that are conceivable and consequences that are potentially hazardous.
These potential hazards are then noted for remedial action.
Having examined one part of the design and recorded any potential hazards associated
with, the study progresses to focus on the next part of the design .The examination is repeated until
the whole plant has been studied.
The purpose of the Hazop Study is to identify all possible deviations from the way the
design is expected to work and all hazards associated with these deviations .In addition, some of the
hazards can be resolved. If the solution is obvious and is not likely to cause adverse effects on other
part of the design, a decision can be taken and the design will be modified on the spot. This is not
always possible ------for example, it may be necessary to obtain further information. Thus the output
from Hazop Study normally consist of a mixture of decisions and questions for answering at
subsequent meetings.
Although the approach as described may appear to generate many hypothetical deviations
in a mechanistic way, the success or failure depends on four aspects.
1) The accuracy of drawings and other data used as a basis for study.
2) The technical skills and insights of the team.
3) The ability of the team to use the approach as an aid to their imagination in
visualizing deviations, causes and consequences.
4) The ability of the team to maintain a sense of proportion, particularly when
assessing the seriousness of the hazards which are identified.
Because the examination is so systematic and highly structured, it is necessary that those
participating use certain terms in a precise and disciplined way. The most important of these terms
are
Intention: - The intension defines how the part is expected to operate. This can take a number of
forms and can be either descriptive or diagrammatic. In many cases it will be a flow sheet or line
diagram.
Deviations: - These are departures from the intension which are discovered by systematically
applying the guide words.
Causes: - These are the reasons why deviations might occur. Once a deviation has been shown to
have a conceivable or realistic cause, if can be treated as meaningful.
Consequences: - These are the results of the deviations should they occur.
Hazards: - These are consequences which can cause damage, injury or loss.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter611
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Guide words:- These are simple words which are used to qualify the intention in order to guide
and stimulate the creative thinking process and so discover deviations.
Table list of Guide words:-
Guide words are applied to the design intension.
The design intension tells us what the equipment is expected to do
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter612
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
i) To check a design.
ii) To decide whether and where to build.
iii) To decide whether to buy piece of equipment.
iv) To obtain a list of questions to put to a supplier.
v) To check running instructions.
vi) To improve the safety of existing facilities
It is also necessary to decide the types of hazard to be considered, for example
i) To people working in the plant
ii) To plant and equipment
iii) To or from product quality
iv) To the general public
v) To the environment
The physical limits of the plant to be studied must be decided and whether interactions with
neighboring units or buildings should be included. Any time or financial constraints must be
specified. It will also be necessary to state whether any aspect such as the civil engineering or the
chemistry can be taken for granted and deliberately excluded. The general objects for a study are
normally set by the person responsible for the project or for the plant:
for example the Project Manager ,Project Engineer or the Plant Manager .He is usually assigned in
the definition by a study leader .The study will be carried out by a team and the degree of authority
given to that team must be decided.
The definition is made easier if the Manager has an appreciation of the approach.
6.2.7 Team Composition
Hazard and operability studies are normally carried out by Multidisciplinary teams. There are two
types of team member Namely those who will make a technical contribution and those who play
supporting and structuring role.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter613
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
The study leader has a role to play throughout a study . He should help whoever has commissioned
the study to define its scope. He may help with the selection and training of the team. He will advice
on the assembly of the necessary data and may help convert this into a suitable form. However his
most obvious role emerges during the examination sessions where he guides the systematic
questioning and he must be thoroughly trained for this job. It is not desirable the he should be
responsible for making a major technical contribution. If possible, he should not have been closely
associated with the subject of the study as there is danger of developing blind spots failing to use the
technical objectively. But he should have sufficient technical knowledge to be able to understand ad
control the team discussions.
In addition to the study leader it is sometimes desirable to have a further supporting member of the
team to make the note of the hazards as they are detected .This person is known as the study
secretary or scribe. It may appear extravagant to employ two people in a supporting role
.However experience indicates that this arrangement greatly increase the rate of working of the team
as a whole. It is better to employ seven people for two days rather than six people for four days on a
given study.
TEAM MEMBER:-
Sr. First Last Title Company Expert Email ID
No Name Name
Sr.GM.- nawal
1. Sunil Nawal Head Office Plant, Engg
Tech @benzochem.co.in
AnilKu Fact. Plant Plant, Legal &
2. V.S. anil@benzochem.co.in
mar Manager In charge Quality System
Maint. Plant Maint & dhakepp@rediffmail.c
3. Praful Dhake Plant
Engg. Engg. om
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter614
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
1. Begin Study:-
The follow-up to the examination sessions is generally straightforward. If decisions have been taken
concerning changes in design or operating methods ,these must be communicated to those
responsible. Any outstanding problems must be resolved by obtaining more information followed by
action and there must be some form of progress chasing.
Sometimes the output from examination session consist largely or exclusively of questions to be
answered later. A list of these may be complied by the study leader ( or secretary) and circulated to
the team members. After an interval the team the reconvenes in what are called Evaluations and
action sessions At these each question is reviewed ,progress is reviewed and where possible ,
decisions taken . One evaluation and action session can usually deal with the output of two or three
examination sessions .
Once a hazard has been discovered ,the kind of action needed to provide a safe system will usually
be agreed quite quickly because in many cases there is an obvious to hand. However in some cases it
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter615
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
will become apparent that there are a no. of possible actions and team may have some difficulty in
agreeing which is the most effective course to take. Actions to take hazards are generally of four
kinds
i) A change in the process (recipe, materials, etc.)
ii) A change in process conditions ( Pressure ,Temperature, Etc.)
iii) An alteration to the physical design .
iv) A change of operating method.
It is important to consider a wide range of possible actions and not to accept that every hazard can be
contained merely by the alteration to the physical design. When choosing between the no. of
possible actions it may be useful to put them into two categories.
i) Those actions which remove the cause of the hazard.
ii) Those actions which reduce the consequences.
In general it is better and more and more effect to remove the hazard and provided the study is
carried out at the design stage this will be done without undue expenditure. If there will be no
reasonable prospect of removing the hazard the team will have to consider what can be done to
protect people and plant if the accident takes place.
To illustrate the kind of reasoning which may be applied, consider a reaction vessel where in an
examination session it was discovered that if an impurity was to be introduced with one of the raw
materials there might be a sudden evolution of and pressure will develop in the vessel.
Let us assume that the hazard might be contained by taking one or three actions.
i) Eliminating the possibility of gas evolution by changing the raw material
ii) Eliminating the possibility of gas evolution by altering one of the process conditions.
iii) Fitting an appropriate pressure relief and vent system to protect the plant.
Solution i) will be 100 % effective and should be the first choice.
Solution ii) has to be considered with care, because its adequacy will depend on the reliability of the
control system which governs the process conditions.
Solution iii) is only adequate if the vent system can be designed to cope with gas evolution and a
reliability of such a system is acceptable.
When it has been decided to alter a design, operating methods etc. it is often necessary to subject the
new design intension to a second round of examination to make sure that the change has not
introduced a new and unsuspected hazard.
Finally it must be emphasized that follow up work is not complete until all the acknowledged
hazards have been dealt with by implementation of all the agreed actions.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter616
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
2. Nodes:-
Sr.
Nodes Type Design Condition/ Parameters Equipment ID
No
1. H2SO4 Storage Tank MS 15 KL Storage tank. H2SO4 ST- 01
Tank is received from tanker &
stored for use.
2. Toluene Storage Tank Underground 15 KL storage ST- 02
tank tank, properly earthed &
vented. Toluene is received
from tanker load &stored for
use
3. HDPE Chemical Tank 5 KL vertical shape storage ST- 03
Grade Tanks 1&2 tank having proper earthen &
Storage Tank vent with fencing around.
4. Chlorination Reactors Four glass lined reactors having GLK-1
Reactors Heat Exchangers capacity of 3.0 & 5.0 KL each GLK-2
Connect to HCL connected through vertical GLK-3
Scrubbing System mounted heat exchangers for GLK-4
internal reflux. All Heat GLK-5
exchangers further vented to GLK-6
HCL/SO2 Scrubbing system GLK-7
GLK-8
GLK-9
5. HCl Scrubbing Scrubbing System Three stage scrubbing system HCL Scrubbing
System. with Pumps & having capacity 700 Kgs/hr System
Heat Exchangers
6. GL Distillation Reactors Four glass lined reactors having GDT-1
kettle Heat Exchanger capacity of 3.0 & 5.0 KL each GDT-2
connected through horizontally GDT-3
Connect to High
mounted heat exchangers on the GDT-4
Vacuum System
other side of long heighted GDT-5
column which are having GDT-6
structural packing for internal GDT-7
reflux & distillation. All GDT-8
distillation reactors are
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter617
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter618
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
3. Deviations:-
Node No:- 01 HCl Storage Tank
Type: - Tank
Design Condition/Parameter: - HMHDPE Tank having Capacity 5.0 KL
Equipment ID:- ST-03
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter619
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter620
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter621
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Node No: - 10
Separation vessel
Type: - Conical Bottom Reactor
Design Condition/Parameter: - 1.0 & 1.7 KL SS Reactor having utility connection like Steam &
cooling
Equipment ID: - SST-01; SST-02
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter622
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
2. As Well as
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter623
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Type: - Tank
Design Condition / Parameter: - SS-316 Tank having Capacity 1.0 & 1.7 KL
Equipment ID:- SST-01; SST-02.
Sr.No Deviation Guide Word Parameter
1. More More Level
2. As well as Leakage/Spillage
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter624
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Severity (S):-
1 Unlikely to be any harm to personnel requiring a first aid or lost time incident. No
lasting damage to environment. No impact on public
2 Harm to personnel requiring a first aid, or a lost time incident, but no serious harm.
Release to environment that may have localized long term impacts. Impact on public
is nuisance.
Likelihood (L):-
1 Not likely to occur in plant lifetime
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter625
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
4. Work Sheet:-
Node No:- 01 HCl Storage Tank
Type: - Tank
Design Condition/Parameter: - HMHDPE Tank having Capacity 5.0 KL
Equipment ID:- ST-03
Deviation:- 1. More
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter626
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
N es Matrix ons le
o
1 Level More S L RR Ensure before Regular Maint. Comp
Indicator Material 2 2 3 unloading sufficient calibration & Departme leted
Failed gets over space should be verification of nt
flows & loss available in the tank the level
could occur indicator
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter627
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter628
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter629
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter630
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter631
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter632
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter633
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter634
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
N es Matrix ons le
o
1 Hot oil Reaction S L RR 1.Operator to On job training Productio Comp
connection mixture will 2 2 3 ensure that to the operator n leted
valve open splash out in appropriate to handle the Departme
more than fractionatin temperature profile process of nt
required g in vertical is reached for the distillation &
column & distillation process parameter as
may be as the Standard prescribed in
overflows Operating the SOP.
Procedure
.2 Polymeriza Sudden 2 2 3 2. Before starting Productio Comp
. tion of the thermal new product batch Operator n leted
reaction shock to in the reactor Training Departme
due to glass ensure that existing nt
other column & distillation vessel
contaminati condenser is thoroughly clean
on resulting in as per cleaning
breakage SOP
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter635
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter636
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
the product
& increase
in the time
cycle of
batch
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter637
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
N es Matrix ons le
o
1 Leakage Direct Skin S L RR Ensure before On job training Productio Comp
in Contact will 3 2 3 wearing the suit to the operator n leted
Charging occur of there should not be to handle the Departme
Suit/Hand such a toxic a minor leakage toxic material nt
gloves raw material during handling
Sodium Cyanide
2. Spillage Exposure to 3 2 3 For charging of SOP to be Productio Comp
during toxic & Sodium Cyanide made & n leted
charging hazardous always use trained displayed near Departme
material personnel & the location in nt
displayed Sodium local language
Cyanide handling
SOP in Local
language
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter638
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter639
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Type: - Reactor
Design Condition/Parameter: - SS reactor having capacity of 1.5 KL & 1.7 KL connected through
vertical mounted heat exchanger for internal reflux. Heat exchanger further vented to Cyanide
Scrubbing system
Equipment ID: - Cyanide Solution Tank Deviation: - 1. Exposure
Sr Causes Consequenc Risk Safeguard Recommendati Responsib Status
N es Matrix ons le
o
1 Failure of 1.Toxic S L RR 1.Ensure before 1. Preventive Productio Comp
Scrubbing vapors 3 1 3 starting sodium maintenance of n leted
system release in cyanide reaction critical Departme
during atmosphere scrubber system is equipments nt/Mainte
reaction 2. Health well condition& 2.In case of gas nance
hazards on displacement of poisoning what departmen
the positive air is within to do SOP to t
associated required condition. be made &
people 2. Sodium Cyanide displayed near
antidote should be the location in
available local language
2. Spillage Exposure to 3 2 3 1. For such critical 1.SOP to be Productio Comp
toxic & reactions always made & n leted
hazardous use trained displayed near Departme
material personnel & the location in nt
displayed Sodium local language
Cyanide handling 2. Location of
SOP in Local Spill Control
language Kit & how to
2. Spill Control kit use of kit
should be available should
available
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter640
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter641
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter642
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter643
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter644
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter645
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter646
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Design Condition/Parameter: - Stainless Steel reactors having capacity of 1.5 & 5.0 KL each
connected through horizontally mounted heat exchangers on the other side of long heighted column
which are having structural packing for internal reflux & distillation. All distillation reactors are
connected with Hot Oil connection to separate the reaction mixtures
Equipment ID:- SDR-1; 2; 3; 4; 5; 6.
Deviation: - 3. High Pressure
Sr Causes Consequenc Risk Safeguard Recommendati Responsib Status
N es Matrix ons le
o
1 Hot oil Reaction S L RR 1.Operator to On job training Productio Comp
connection mixture will 2 2 3 ensure that to the operator n leted
valve open splash out in appropriate to handle the Departme
more than fractionatin temperature profile process of nt
required g in vertical is reached for the distillation &
column & distillation process parameter as
may be as the Standard prescribed in
overflows Operating the SOP.
Procedure
.2 Polymeriza Sudden 2 2 3 2. Before starting Productio Comp
. tion of the thermal new product batch Operator n leted
reaction shock to in the reactor Training Departme
due to glass ensure that existing nt
other column & distillation vessel
contaminati condenser is thoroughly clean
on resulting in as per cleaning
breakage SOP
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter647
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
N es Matrix ons le
o
1 Leakages Toxic , S L RR Ensure that joints 1. On job Productio Comp
of reaction hazardous & 3 1 3 are properly training to the n leted
mixtures flammable tightened to ensure operator to Departme
from vapors may that there is no handle the nt
reactor & be released leakage of reaction process of
column mixture vapors in distillation.
Joint the surrounding
gaskets
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter648
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter649
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter650
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter651
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter652
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
o
1 Failure of Sufficient S L RR Calibration of such Calibration date Maintenan Comp
Air pressure 3 1 3 critical devices & due date tag ce leted
Control will not should be should be departmen
switch develop in completed with in displayed near t
the system speculated time by the
period instrument
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter653
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
List of Recommendations:-
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter654
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter655
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
1. Nodes :- 16
2. Deviations :- 67
3. Causes :- 101
4. Consequences :- 103
5. Safe guard :- 113
6. Recommendation :- 106
Breakdown by Node:-
Number of Study Item
SN Node
Deviations Causes Consequences Safeguards
1. HCL Storage Tank 2 2 3 3
2. Toluene Storage tank 2 3 3 3
3. Sulfuric Acid Storage Tank 2 3 3 3
4. Chlorination Reactors 6 11 11 13
5. HCl Scrubbing System 2 2 2 2
6. GL Distillation Reactors 4 7 7 6
7. High Vacuum Ejector System 3 4 4 5
8. Sodium Cyanide solution 3 6 6 6
preparation vessel
9. Sodium cyanide reaction Vessel 4 7 9 9
10. Separation Vessel 3 5 5 5
11. Sodium Cyanide scrubbing 2 2 2 2
system
12. SS Distillation Reactor 4 7 7 8
13. SS Reaction Kettle 4 7 7 8
14. Centrifuge 4 7 7 11
15. Fluidized Bed Dryer 5 5 5 5
16. Turbo Shifter 2 2 2 2
Breakdown by Deviation:-
Number of Study Items
S.No Node Deviation Causes Consequence Safeguar
s ds
1. HCl Storage Tank More 1 1 1
As well as 1 2 2
2. Toluene Storage tank More 1 1 1
As well as 1 2 2
3. Sulfuric Acid Storage More 1 1 1
Tank
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter656
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
As well as 1 2 2
4. Chlorination Reactors Low Temperature 1 1 1
High Temperature 2 2 3
High Pressure 2 2 3
Less Material 1 1 1
charged
More material 1 1 1
Charged
Leakage 4 4 4
5. HCl Scrubbing System High Temperature 1 1 1
Low Temperature 1 1 1
6. Glass Lined Reactor Low Temperature 2 1 1
High Temperature 1 2 1
High Pressure 2 2 2
Leakage 2 2 2
7. High Vacuum ejector High Temperature 1 2 2
system
Low Pressure 1 1 1
As well as 2 2 2
8. Sodium cyanide Exposure 2 2 2
preparation vessel
High Temperature 2 2 2
Leakage 2 2 2
9. Sodium cyanide reaction Exposure 2 4 4
vessel
High Temperature 2 2 2
Low Temperature 1 1 1
Leakage 2 2 2
10. Separation Vessel High Temperature 2 2 2
Low Temperature 1 1 1
Leakage 2 2 2
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter657
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter658
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
CAMEO consists of three parts viz. CAMEO (which is basically a data base), ALOHA and
MARPLOT (Mapping Applications for Response, Planning, and Local Operational
Tasks).
ALOHA allows the user to estimate the downwind dispersion of a chemical cloud based on
the toxicological/physical characteristics of the released chemical, atmospheric conditions,
and specific circumstances of the release. Graphical outputs include a "cloud footprint" that
can be plotted on maps with MARPLOT to display the location of other facilities storing
hazardous materials and vulnerable locations, such as hospitals and schools. Specific
information about these locations can be extracted from CAMEO information modules to
help make decisions about the degree of hazard posed.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter659
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
The thermal radiation effects that people experience depend upon the length of time they are
exposed to a specific
thermal radiation level. Longer exposure durations, even at a lower thermal radiation level,
can produce serious
physiological effects. Below are some effects at specific thermal radiation levels and
durations (on bare skin):
2 kW/(sq m) -- people will feel pain after 45 seconds and receive second-degree burns after 3
minutes;
5 kW/(sq m) -- people will feel pain after 13 seconds and receive second-degree burns after
40 seconds; and
10 kW/(sq m) -- people will feel pain after 5 seconds and receive second-degree burns after
14 seconds.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter660
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
zones: Red: 8.0 psi (destruction of buildings); Orange: 3.5 psi (serious injury likely);
and Yellow: 1.0 psi (shatters glass).
6.4.3.1 Details
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter661
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SOURCE STRENGTH:
Leak from hole in vertical cylindrical tank
Flammable chemical escaping from tank (not burning)
Tank Diameter: 1.94 meters Tank Length: 5.07 meters
Tank Volume: 15 cubic meters
Tank contains liquid Internal Temperature: 30 C
Chemical Mass in Tank: 8670 kilograms
Tank is 67% full
Circular Opening Diameter: 0.04 inches
Opening is 0 meters from tank bottom
Ground Type: Concrete
Ground Temperature: equal to ambient
Max Puddle Area: 18 square meters
Release Duration: ALOHA limited the duration to 1 hour
Max Average Sustained Release Rate: 0.0573 pounds/min
(averaged over a minute or more)
Total Amount Released: 2.20 pounds
Note: The chemical escaped as a liquid and formed an evaporating puddle.
The puddle spread to a diameter of 0.7 yards.
THREAT ZONE:
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter662
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SOURCE STRENGTH:
Leak from hole in vertical cylindrical tank
Flammable chemical escaping from tank (not burning)
Tank Diameter: 1.94 meters Tank Length: 5.07 meters
Tank Volume: 15 cubic meters
Tank contains liquid Internal Temperature: 30 C
Chemical Mass in Tank: 8670 kilograms
Tank is 67% full
Circular Opening Diameter: 0.04 inches
Opening is 0 meters from tank bottom
Ground Type: Concrete
Ground Temperature: equal to ambient
Max Puddle Area: 18 square meters
Release Duration: ALOHA limited the duration to 1 hour
Max Average Sustained Release Rate: 0.0573 pounds/min
(averaged over a minute or more)
Total Amount Released: 2.20 pounds
Note: The chemical escaped as a liquid and formed an evaporating puddle.
The puddle spread to a diameter of 0.7 yards.
THREAT ZONE:
SOURCE STRENGTH:
Leak from hole in vertical cylindrical tank
Flammable chemical escaping from tank (not burning)
Tank Diameter: 1.94 meters Tank Length: 5.07 meters
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter663
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
THREAT ZONE:
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter664
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
THREAT ZONE:
SOURCE STRENGTH:
BLEVE of flammable liquid in vertical cylindrical tank
Tank Diameter: 1.94 meters Tank Length: 5.07 meters
Tank Volume: 15 cubic meters
Tank contains liquid
Internal Storage Temperature: 30 C
Chemical Mass in Tank: 8670 kilograms
Tank is 67% full
Percentage of Tank Mass in Fireball: 100%
Fireball Diameter: 130 yards Burn Duration: 9 seconds
THREAT ZONE:
Threat Modeled: Thermal radiation from fireball
Red : 275 yards --- (10.0 kW/(sq m) = potentially lethal within 60 sec)
Orange: 389 yards --- (5.0 kW/(sq m) = 2nd degree burns within 60 sec)
Yellow: 607 yards --- (2.0 kW/(sq m) = pain within 60 sec)
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter665
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
yards
750
250
wind
250
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter666
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SOURCE STRENGTH:
Evaporating Puddle (Note: chemical is flammable)
Puddle Area: 18 square meters Puddle Mass: 8670 kilograms
Ground Type: Concrete Ground Temperature: 30 C
Initial Puddle Temperature: 30 C
Release Duration: ALOHA limited the duration to 1 hour
Max Average Sustained Release Rate: 2.64 pounds/min
(averaged over a minute or more)
Total Amount Released: 155 pounds
THREAT ZONE:
Model Run: Gaussian
Red : less than 10 meters(10.9 yards) --- (4500 ppm = AEGL-3 (60 min))
Note: Threat zone was not drawn because effects of near-field patchiness
make dispersion predictions less reliable for short distances.
Orange: less than 10 meters(10.9 yards) --- (1200 ppm = AEGL-2 (60 min))
Note: Threat zone was not drawn because effects of near-field patchiness
make dispersion predictions less reliable for short distances.
Yellow: 17 yards --- (200 ppm = AEGL-1 (60 min))
Note: Threat zone was not drawn because effects of near-field patchiness
make dispersion predictions less reliable for short distances.
SOURCE STRENGTH:
Evaporating Puddle (Note: chemical is flammable)
Puddle Area: 18 square meters Puddle Mass: 8670 kilograms
Ground Type: Concrete Ground Temperature: 30 C
Initial Puddle Temperature: 30 C
Release Duration: ALOHA limited the duration to 1 hour
Max Average Sustained Release Rate: 2.64 pounds/min
(averaged over a minute or more)
Total Amount Released: 155 pounds
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter667
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
THREAT ZONE:
SOURCE STRENGTH:
THREAT ZONE:
SOURCE STRENGTH:
Burning Puddle / Pool Fire
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter668
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
THREAT ZONE:
yards
30
10
wind
10
30 20 0 20 40 60
yards
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter669
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SOURCE STRENGTH:
Direct Source: 0.9 liters/sec Source Height: 0
Source State: Liquid
Source Temperature: equal to ambient
Release Duration: 60 minutes
Release Rate: 102 pounds/min
Total Amount Released: 6,138 pounds
THREAT ZONE:
THREAT AT POINT:
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter670
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
yards
100
50
wind
50
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter671
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SOURCE STRENGTH:
Direct Source: 0.9 liters/sec Source Height: 0
Source State: Liquid
Source Temperature: equal to ambient
Release Duration: 60 minutes
Release Rate: 102 pounds/min
Total Amount Released: 6,138 pounds
THREAT ZONE:
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter672
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
yards
40
20
wind
20
40 20 0 20 40 60 80 100
yards
greater than 6600 ppm (60% LEL = Flame Pockets) (not drawn)
greater than 1100 ppm (10% LEL)
wind direction confidence lines
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter673
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SOURCE STRENGTH:
Direct Source: 0.9 liters/sec Source Height: 0
Source State: Liquid
Source Temperature: equal to ambient
Release Duration: 60 minutes
Release Rate: 102 pounds/min
Total Amount Released: 6,138 pounds
THREAT ZONE:
Threat Modeled: Overpressure (blast force) from vapor cloud explosion
Type of Ignition: ignited by spark or flame
Level of Congestion: uncongested
Model Run: Heavy Gas
Red : LOC was never exceeded --- (8.0 psi = destruction of buildings)
Orange: LOC was never exceeded --- (3.5 psi = serious injury likely)
Yellow: LOC was never exceeded --- (1.0 psi = shatters glass)
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter674
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
A) The amount of water required for firefighting purpose can be estimated by the below formula:
A) The total area in sq.mtr of all Floors including galleries in all building of the Factory
B) The total area in sq.mtr of all Floors and galleries including open spaces in which combustible
materials
C) The total area in sq.mtr of all Floors over 15 mtr above ground level
D) The total area in sq.mtr of all floors of buildings other than those of fire resisting construction of
various floors is so certified by any fire association or fire insurance company
= 702.96 lit/min
The quantity of firefighting tank is 50000 liter. Therefore the capacity is justified. As the back-up
water supply will last for 71.12 min
Time (min) = [Total water in fire fighting tank (ltrs)]/water required ltr/min
= 50000/702.96
= 71.12 min
The pump capacity in the plant is 750 ltrs/min, therefore according to the discharge capacity of the
pump installed. The back-up time by which the tank will be empty is calculated below,
Time (min) = [Total water in fire fighting tank (ltrs)]/discharge capacity (ltr/min)
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter675
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Disaster Management Plan (DMP) will consider all the factors responsible for management of any
small or big disaster. Emergency prevention through good design, operation, maintenance and
inspection are essential to reduce the probability of occurrence. However, certain operation and
practices may lead to unwarranted situation wherein disaster scenario can emerge. The DMP,
therefore, addresses to mitigate the effects of such situation with a view to bring restoration of
normality at the earliest.
1.0] Acknowledgement
a) To control and contain the incident/ accident and if possible, eliminate it and
The report is prepared based on available information gathered at the site during the survey.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter676
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Fax No : 022-24320924
Email : gcpl@bom3.vsnl.net.in
A. Identifying the disaster potential scenario and advance planning to combat and minimize
the damage
B. Disaster Phase i.e. Warning & protective action like evacuation of the personnel from the
emergency
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter677
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
D. Rescue, Relief assistance to the people affected in the work/community effectively &
efficiently based on the actual needs & on the information collected locally both in the
advance of disaster & as soon as possible after the disaster occurred.
E. Finally when the situation is contained, efforts are to be return back to normal condition.
6. SCOPE OF STUDY :
Emergency planning is the integral & essential part of loss prevention strategy. The type of
emergency is
preliminary considered here is the major emergency which may be defined as one which
has the potential
to cause serious danger to person and or to the property which tends to cause disruption
inside and or
outside of site & may be required outside resources.
2. Maharashtra Factories (Control of Industrial Major accident Hazards) rule 2003 Schedule-6 [
Rule 12 ( 1 ) ]
3. Manufacturing, Storage & Imports of Hazardous chemicals rule 1989 rule 13 (1),Schedule Xi
KEY PERSONNEL:
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter678
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
v. Technical team
FIRST OBSERVER:
- He will try to handle the situation using facilities, available to him. If situation is beyond his
control, he will press nearby hooter button and inform immediately to his shift production officer
(SPO).
- If SPO is not available in the vicinity, he can directly phone to Security on Emergency Phone
Number giving information
- GENERAL SHIFT - Officer on duty under whose charge the area of incidence comes will act as
incidence controller.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter679
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
- SILENT HOURS - Some of the sections of various departments work only during General shift
and close their working at after 18.00 hrs.
- In case of such areas the responsibility of incidence controller, if any emergency arises in that the
Shift In charge will take up area during silent hours.
- SHIFT INCHARGE: Security Officer on Duty displays Names of the SPO on duty at Gate. Factory
premise must be divided into zones to fix the area of responsibility for these Shift In-charges, in case
of emergency.
- After receiving the information of the emergency he will reach to the spot of incidence.
- Assess the emergency situation and instruct the workforce to bring the plant operations in
shutdown mode, if required.
- Give continuous feedback to the main controller and receive his instructions.
- Once the emergency is brought under control, inform the main controller.
MAIN CONTROLLER
- On hearing siren, he is to reach near the site and take over the charge of the situation.
- Ask for and to get Mutual Aid from other industries, if required.
- Give feed back to the site controller during or after the emergency is brought under control.
- Instruct communication team to declare all clear by sounding ALL CLEAR siren once the
emergency is brought under control.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter680
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
ADVISORY TEAM
- To assemble around Main controller for consultation & providing essential information and render
all help required.
- Act under the instruction of Main Controller to mitigate the emergency situation.
- On hearing siren, take position in Security office. Telephone board should be continuously
manned.
- On the instructions from the main controller, communicate concern personnel as well as outside
agencies and authorities (fire brigade, ambulance, hospitals, other industries, and site controller),
Government officials.
- Restrict the vehicles from coming inside the factory except the vehicles of the emergency
organization members. Also to remove the vehicles, if required from inside.
- On the instruction from the Main Controller open the additional exits.
- Send one security guard to the emergency site with Main controllers helmet & other PPE sets.
- As per the instructions of main controller, they will inform about status of emergency to all people
present in the premises.
- They will sound ALL CLEAR siren once they get signal from the main controller.
EMERGENCY SQUAD:
- After hearing the siren & information about the emergency, they will give charge of their jobs to
the SPO or other employees as per the SPO's instructions.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter681
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
- After reaching the spot, to act as per the instructions of the Incident Controller.
a. Fire fighting
b. Area cordoning
c. Rescue operation
d. Traffic control
After handling the emergency, to be engaged in salvage operation if required, otherwise in normal
case to go back to the plant and resume the work.
- After receiving the information, the doctor and medical assistant to remain in Occupational Health
Centre only.
- First Aiders to go to the site. If required provide first aid treatment, Remove the casualties from the
place, shift them to OHC for required treatment
EVACUATION TEAM:
- Guide them towards the assembly points. Carry out head count operation.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter682
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
- In case of Off-site implications, Government officials, Police, and other officials shall be informed
immediately.
TECHNICAL TEAM:
- Utility Operator to provide assistance for use of extinguishers, and other fire fighting facilities.
- Maintenance Engineer shall go to the emergency spot & give necessary support as per the Incident
controller's instructions.
- Electrical Engineer / Electrician: if required, cut off electrical supply of that area on the instructions
of Incident / Main Controller and provide portable lights / extension lights.
- Boiler attendant: not to leave boiler-house till he receives further instructions from Incident / Main
controller and act accordingly.
- Should lead emergency squad & control the emergency in co-ordination with Incident Controller.
- Co-ordinate the activities & help from technical team members as per the requirement.
- After controlling emergency, safety officer should carry out salvage operations under the guidance
of Manager (Safety).
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter683
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
TYPE OF ACCIDENTS:
FIRE/EXPLOSION:
- Release of flammable liquid / vapor which is stored in tank farm / catches fire when it comes in
contact with source of ignition (e.g. Small spark from tanker exhaust, spark due to static charge etc.).
- Spillage of flammable liquids such as , Methanol, and Toluene in large quantity inside the plants
/while loading by tankers and catches fire either by spark, reacting with oxidizing materials etc.
- Release of flammable gases from storage / process, or release of flammable liquid above its boiling
point from process to atmosphere, forming vapor cloud.
TOXIC DISPERSION:
- Leakage & dispersion of toxic gases like Chlorine and Ammonia & Cyanide from process vessels.
- Human-error
HAZARDS:
- Release of toxic or / and flammable / explosive gas affecting the people on site.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter684
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
- Release of toxic / flammable gas & if Ignition source is available then lead to fire / explosion
leading to property damage.
- Rupture discs & safety release valves are provided on such vessels. Various systems interlocks
provided. Rapture Disk & Safety Release Valves vents taken to disaster vessel for holding the toxic /
explosive gases resulting due to rupture & popping up of Rapture Disk & Safety Release Valves
respectively.
- Correct material of construction is provided, for both, the gasket & the vessels.
- Automatic process control with emergency handling arrangements, high safety margins and
inherently safe designs to autoclaves shall be provided soon.
- Safe designs & maintenance practices, periodic inspections of systems are done. Safety work
permit system, work area monitoring, accident reporting systems, Hazop analysis, safety audits,
- Adequate factor of safety; design for extreme conditions, follows standard codes.
- Various controls and alarms interlocked with the operating system are provided to make the system
intrinsically safe. Also various sensors must be provided to detect the presence of toxic and / or
flammable gases.
- Rupture disks and safety release valves are provided in the system
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter685
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
- Disaster vessels (Collecting tank / dump tank) are provided to collect the toxic / flammable gases
from Rupture discs & safety release valves vents.
Fire fighting:
- Fire fighting devices like fire extinguishers, water & foam are also made available. Hydrant system
shall be made available shortly.
Hazard Identification & risk assessment of each activity, Internal and external audits, Hazop studies,
fire & Explosion indices (DOW Index) etc. are carried out to assess and identify the hazard.
Committee meetings must be held to identify the probable causes of hazards. Safety inspection is
carried out by safety function to identify the hazards.
- Equipments are selected based on process requirements with sufficient safety margins. In built
safety features are insisted at the time of purchase.
- Detail on Site Emergency plan is prepared & revised time to time when there is any change in
process/ product/ operating conditions.
- M.S.D.S. (Material safety data sheets) of all chemicals used in BENZOCHEM Premises available
for ready reference. Abstracts of the MSDS are displayed in plants in local language.
- Mock drills are to be conducted periodically to practice the plan and to refresh the emergency
handling procedures.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter686
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
GENERAL INFORMATION
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
------ -----------
What is fire?
Fire is a major hazard in any industry but is also a very necessary servant in the industry for
imparting heat energy for the various process streams. As helpful as fire is, when properly
controlled, it can destroy both men and material when uncontrolled. Fire is a chemical reaction
between oxygen and carbon in which heat and light energies are released. Three things are required
before a fire can occur. These are fuel, oxygen and source of ignition. This is referred to as the fire
triangle.
If all the three of these necessary elements are present in proper proportions, fire will occur. If any
one of the three is removed, fire is impossible. It is, however, more advisable to remove at least two
sides, only the fuel and oxygen sides of fire triangle can be easily removed. Fuel may consist carbon
or hydrocarbon. The fuel side of the fire triangle is removed by removing the combustible materials,
or by preventing hydrocarbon from leaking or spilling into an atmosphere of air. This will prevent
open fire.
The oxygen side of the fire triangle is removed by preventing air from getting into system containing
combustible materials, carbon or hydrocarbon. The ignition side of the fire triangle is controlled to
some extent by proper guarding and a number of other mean, but there are so many sources of
ignition that it must be assumed that this side of the triangle is always present.
Types of Fire: Fire has been classified into fire categories A, B, C, D, E & K
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter687
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
K Fires that involve cooking oils or fats are designated "Class K"
Fire fighting first aids comprise of water or sand buckets, portable fire extinguishers and hose reels.
These from the first line of defenses and are useful only in the initial stages of a fire. Water and sand
should be used judiciously so as not to further harm the machinery / equipment. Portable fire
extinguishers are mainly of 6 types.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter688
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Signal
1. Water Signal Red A
Red
All the dangerous substances are stored in the underground tank / go down as per the approval from
the respective licensing authorities.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter689
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
All key personnel i.e. Site Controller, Main Controller, Key persons, Advisory Team members are
available at site.
Following material is readily available in side of the Factory Premises to be used in Emergency:
- Factory Layout.
- Wiring material
- Safety Helmets/Gloves/Goggles
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter690
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Address with telephone numbers and key personnel, and essential employees, Government agencies,
neighboring industries and sources of help, outside experts, chemical fact sheets.
Emergency Control Centre is located at the Security Gate which is at safe distance from process
plants. In case of Emergency all activities can be controlled from ECC.
Raw materials
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter691
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
22 Toluene 16.00
23 Zinc chloride 3.25
24 Acetic acid 9.70
25 Methyl 2- chloro propionate 79.50
26 Para anisaldehyde 87.50
27 Tetra ethyl ammonium bromide 0.70
28 Ethyl acetate 0.50
29 2,4 Dichloro benzyl chloride 18.50
30 Tetra butyl ammonium hydrogen sulphate 0.20
31 Hexamine 3.90
32 Methanol 11.00
33 Para toluene sulphonic acid 0.03
34 Cyclohexane 1.00
35 Propiophenone 20.00
36 Ammonium bicarbonate 12.50
37 Benzyl cyanide 2.25
38 Ethyl bromide 2.10
39 Tri ethyl benzyl ammonium chloride 0.10
40 Mono methyl amine 40 % 4.05
41 Tri ethyl amine 00.10
42 Para chloro phenol 2.40
43 Ortho di chloro benzene 3.00
44 Di methyl sulphate 2.50
45 Formic acid 1.30
46 Formaldehyde solution 37% 1.95
47 Synhydride 3.75
48 Tetra chloro ortho xylene 3.80
49 Per chloro ethylene 10.00
50 3,5 xylenol 07.00
51 Copper sulphate 0.10
52 Benzoyl chloride 2.50
53 Ortho chloro phenyl acetic acid 102.00
54 Bromine 46.00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter692
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
* For Toxicological Data, Transformation if any which could occur of the chemicals, please
refer material safety data sheet attached as annexure
Release of flammable liquid / vapour which is stored in Explosive /Petroleum Tank Farm and
catches fire when it comes in contact with source of ignition. Leakage is possible from ;
- Leakage from body of the tank, Drain/ sampling point kept in open position
- Lightning,
- Smoking,
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter693
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Spillage of flammable liquids such as O-Xylene, & Toluene inside the plants and catches fire either
by spark, reacting with oxidizing materials etc.
Release of flammable gases from storage/ process, or release of flammable liquid above its boiling
point from process to atmosphere, forming vapor cloud.
Combustible material comes in contact with hot surfaces, which rises temperature of the material at
ignition point and catches fire. (e.g. hot oil pipeline comes in contact with cotton, wood etc.).
During Hydrolysis operation, Ammonia gas is evolved, the gas is scrubbed to form anhydrous
ammonia. Failure of Ammonia scrubber could result in accumulation of gas in the column and
thereby by escaping to the atmosphere.
The Stress/Strain effects of normal operation results in weakening of the metallic components, apart
from the normal wear & tear. The pressurization & depressurization can aggravate the stress &
corrosion can make the final blow to rupture the metallic components in the process plant area &
handling area .The thermal stresses due to cyclic heating ,cooling are expected to cause stresses in
the system
These may affect the life of the gaskets, nut, bolts & lead to the oozing followed by leakages. The
process cooling is expected to cause thermal process due to sudden cooling.
A : Component failure:
- Inappropriate design against internal pressure, external forces, corrosive media & temperature.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter694
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
- Failure of control systems (pressure & temperature sensors, level controllers, flow meters, control
units, process computers).
- Failure of safety systems (safety valves, bursting discs, pressure relief systems,).
Following failures can occur, leading to deviations from normal operating conditions:-
- Failure in the monitoring of crucial process parameters (pressure, temperature, flow, quantity,
mixing ratios and in the processing of these parameters.
- No electricity
- No nitrogen
- No instrument air
- Failures in the shut down or start up procedures, which could lead to an explosive atmosphere
within the plant.
C : Other reasons
- Communication errors
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter695
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
D : Natural forces:
- All the Autoclaves are designed for 20 kg/cm & 240 c. where as operating pressure &
temperature is maximum 15-16 kg/cm & 200c respectively.
ii) Effects of Fire & Explosion inside the plant & Effect, if any, of Fire, Explosion outside
1. Toluene 01 15 KL
2. Sulfuric Acid 01 15 KL
3. HCl (Commercial) 01 5 KL
4. HCl (White) 01 5 KL
b] Effects/ Consequences:
Most of the chemicals have tendency to catch fire whenever ignition source will available to them,
Fire on small quantity of spillage and at preliminary stage can be easily extinguished by portable fire
extinguishers but if fire spreads and gets more fuel from surrounding, it will rapidly accelerate and
lead to disaster. Fires can take several different forms, including jet fires, pool fires, flash fires.
Boiling Liquid Expanding Vapour Explosions (BLEVEs) are unlikely, because no flammable
pressurized gases used at site.
A jet fire would appear as a long narrow flame produced, for example, from an ignited gas pipeline
leak. A pool fire would be produced, e.g. if a release of flammable liquid from a storage tank into a
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter696
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
dyke ignited. A flash fire could occur if an escape of gas reached a source of ignition and rapidly
burns back to the source of release.
The BLEVE, sometimes referred to as a fire ball is generally far more serious than the other fires. It
is a combination of fire & explosion with an intense radiant heat emission within relatively short
time interval. It occurs within a vessel or tank in which a liquefied gas is kept above its atmospheric
boiling point. Such a scenario is unlikely to occur.
If a pressure vessel fails as a result of a weakening of its structure, the contents are instantaneously
released from the vessel as a turbulent mixture of liquid & gas, expanding rapidly and dispersing in
air as a cloud. When this cloud is ignited, a fireball occurs causing enormous heat radiation intensity
within a few seconds.
Health effects arising from exposure to the fumes generated as a result of fire are also to be
considered during fire fighting. Also effects of fire on people take the form of skin burns due to
exposure to thermal radiation.
c] Preventive Measures:
- Security guard ensures that, the Spark arrestors (mufflers) are attached to the smoke exhaust pipes
of the vehicles.
- Earthing is always connected to a tanker while unloading to take care of static electricity.
- Lightning arrestors is provided to cover entire tank farm area as well as whole factory area.
- Dike walls are constructed around the tank to contain material in case of puncture/leak.
- No activities like hammering, chiseling, cutting, welding by which spark can occur will be carried
out without safety permits.
- Adequate fire extinguishers & foam monitor are provided in the vicinity.
- Trained personnel are employed in the tank farm for the loading & unloading operation.
- The transferring is generally carried out by pump instead of compressed air so that equipment is
not
Required to be pressurized and subsequent leakage through equipment can be avoided. Both
equipments are equalized during transferring so that overflow in to atmosphere can be prevented.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter697
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
- Vent of all tanks and reactors extended 2 meters above the terrace so that flammable vapours can
be dispersed easily and accumulation of vapours inside the plant avoided.
- Loose handling of flammables (in buckets, drums) are as far as possible avoided.
- Immediately stop the leakage from source by closing isolation valve or applying vacuum.
- Spray absorbent like KCC (Kerala China Clay) or Sand. If quantity of spill is large, recover
from drains and pits, do not allow it to outside the plant because most of the flammable in the plants
are lighter than water and can be easily spread through drain and flash back if source is available
anywhere even very far away from the plant.
- Use DCP/ foam extinguishers when fire is at preliminary stage. If fire is big it is better to use
hydrant system and same time cool the surrounding area.
- Connect foam monitor with hydrant hose and apply over pool of spillage.
The effects are not expected to reach off-site after implementation of above mentioned
recommendations like preventive measures and normal emergency procedures are followed.
Since factory is situated far away from main road & isolated off site area is quite safe .
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter698
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Emergency sirens:
Safety systems:
Breathing Air Sets are provided at various locations for emergency use. They are generally of 207
bar air pressure (1200 litre air). It can be used in all type of toxic gas leakage even at higher
concentrations.
- Wind Socks
For showing the direction of wind. To evacuate people, it will guide to which direction one should
go.
It is very necessary to have the blood group of individuals in case of emergency. For this list of
blood group of all employees is available with Occupational Health Centre.
- Emergency addresses
List of present address of employee and address of the persons to who should inform in case of
emergency shall be made available with personnel and safety depts. It also mentions of other family
members.
These are systems, which, on the basis of sensors, allow the plant people to determine the causes of a
malfunction as soon as it has occurred. Such alarm systems must be made available for:
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter699
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
- Monitoring process parameters (pressure, temperature, flow rate, quantity, level, mixing ratio etc.).
- Leakage of toxic & flammable gases like Chlorine, Ammonia, Hydrogen chloride, etc.
- Detection of failures of safety related component like pumps, compressors, stirrers, blowers etc.).
- Besides giving alarm, if the necessary steps are not taken, secondary control systems will initiates
actions automatically to bring the operation in safe mode & to control the hazards. Even though, if
the process could not come under control then operation goes to safe shut down mode.
- On hearing alert siren and announcement, all key personnel present in the premises, EMT
members, and other team members will rush to their nominated location and take position for further
action.
- The Incident controller (Shift In charge) of the Plant/area will remain at the spot of emergency. He
will act as Main Controller also if EMT members/Main controller is not available.
- If they are available then, EMT member (senior), will act as a Main controller till the Main
controller arrives at site. He will take his position near the site but not on the spot of emergency
because he is assigned for overall functions. He has to monitor emergency and take further step
accordingly.
- The security guard will rush with Main controller's helmet and walkie-talkie sets and hand over to
EMT members and incident controller.
- The security officer will act as a communication team leader, he will inform to all key persons in
the factory. He will send vehicle to bring the key persons from residences.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6100
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
- All first aiders, fire fighters and technical team members will delegate their jobs to their co-
workers, which they were doing. They will rush to the spot of emergency and report to the Incident
controller.
- All other employees of the plant will stop their activities, bring the all operations in shut down
mode. They are not required to vacate the plant unless the incident controller /Main controller
instructs or conditions have become unbearable.
- The EMT member (senior) will continuously assess the situation by taking feed back from the
incident controller. Accordingly he will instruct communication team members. He will contact
advisory team members to get essential information but if required. In case, he does not require help
from advisory team, he can assign any other jobs to advisory team. The option is completely left to
the main controller.
- Once the emergency is brought under control, EMT member (senior) will inform to communication
team to sound `ALL CLEAR (siren and announce on PAS about completion of emergency.
- In the mean time if main controller and other team members arrived, they will replace the present
members and take charge of the emergency.
Evacuation Procedure :
Once the main controller realizes that the emergency is not controllable easily, he will instruct
communication team to sound siren (waning and waxing) and subsequently announcement for
evacuation on Public Address System or Megaphone. On hearing evacuation message on Public
Address System, Evacuation Team will guide personnel towards assembly point, which will be
declared, by communication team. After guiding the personnel to assembly point Team will
physically confirm evacuation then only they will leave for assembly point. At the assembly point
they will carry out HEAD COUNT (attendance) to ensure complete evacuation. It is essential that
they should know number of persons present in that area prior to the emergency.
Assembly Points
In the premises three assembly points are identified and declared as follows,
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6101
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Selection of assembly point in particular case of emergency will be entirely dependent on the nature
and gravity of the emergency as well as wind direction. Communication team will announce safe
assembly point after consulting the main controller.
As per the site plan and wind direction at the time of emergency, the likely affected area will be
identified and population within will be estimated.
- The police at Jalgaon MIDC police station will be informed so that incoming traffic can be
controlled from both the ends.
- The police force will be helpful in evacuation of personnel from surrounding factories or other
public place in the vicinity.
- The Fire Brigade will be informed and ambulances will be called and kept ready to meet any
- Eventualities
- The communication team members and evacuation team members will quickly move around the
likely affected area and will send message of evacuation through megaphone available in ECC. (All
Members Should keep PPE with them to avoid toxic gas exposure to them).
- Process variables like temperature, pressure, flow rate, mixing ratio of certain components, the rate
of temperature or an increase or decrease in pressure etc. are monitored & controlled by using
sophisticated instruments.
- Temperature/pressure/flow sensors: in the process initiates alarms & actions such as emergency
cooling, stopping the input of a reaction, starting the scrubbing system etc.
- System preventing overflow: Level controls prevent vessels from being overfilled; they cut off the
flow of material or divert it.
- Emergency shut down system: shut down the process (i.e. cut off pumps, close or open quick
acting valves, apply emergency cooling).
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6102
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
- Utilities: Safety related utility supplies, such as electricity supply to control systems, compressed
air for instruments or nitrogen supply as an inert gas have second source like generator supply, UPS,
buffer storage tank.)
- Pressure-relief systems: Rupture discs & safety valves are provided on the vessels operating or may
exceed the atmospheric pressure. Their outlets are connected to efficient scrubbing systems.
- To ensure continuous working of the instruments & control units, maintenance schedules are
prepared & documented, specifying the different maintenance intervals and the type of work to be
performed. Calibration of the instruments is carried out as per the set frequency. Skilled &
experienced technicians under competent supervision carry out servicing.
- Plant buildings are of RCC construction and stability certificates are renewed periodically. Well-
known approved Architects are engaged in the design.
- Equipment layouts are done as per internal standards of GCL taking into account
National/International standards.
- Drawings have been approved by statutory authorities such as MIDC, DISH etc.
- Equipments are selected based on process requirements with sufficient safety margins. In built
safety features are insisted at the time of purchase.
- The operations are continuously monitored by skilled workmen and supervised by qualified
officers/engineers.
- Process change/modifications are authorised by senior officers before implementing in the plant.
Detail Hazop study is carried out & suggestions came through it are implemented.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6103
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
- Operations are under supervision even during the scheduled tea, lunch break & shift change.
Operators are trained in more than one operation for this purpose.
- In coming, in process & final product sampling plans are prepared & strictly followed to monitor
the process.
- All the equipments, raw materials, intermediates, utilities are adequately identified.
- Standard operating procedures, Dos & Donts, start up & shut down procedures are prepared &
made known to all operating people.
- Material transfer operations are continuously monitored & confirmed by checking the quantity at
both the sides.
- Safety department is having control over the inspection, maintenance & repair work of safety
equipments/ systems & ensures that maintenance of safety equipments/systems is carried out as per
the schedule to ensure that those are in working condition all the time.
- Detail documented procedures for maintenance & repair work is jointly prepared & made available
in separate manual.
-All safety equipments namely SCBA sets, safety showers, fire extinguishers, fire hydrant points,
Emergency communication/warning facilities namely hooter, sirens, walkie-talkie sets, telephones,
are inspected periodically & records maintained. Nonconformities observed are corrected
immediately through engineering/maintenance department.
- Safety interlocks of critical process equipments in production plant are checked periodically as per
the checklists of respective plants & records maintained.
- Process control instruments, pressure relief valves, sensors etc are inspected/calibrated periodically
for their effective working.
- Daily, weekly, fortnightly, monthly, quarterly, six monthly & yearly inspection schedules to
inspect and maintain the various process equipments/safety equipments /systems all over factory
premises are prepared & documented.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6104
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
- Safety work permit systems are strictly followed while carrying out maintenance & repair work.
- Reference standards; national & international, manufacturers instruction manuals are also referred
while carrying out maintenance & repair work. Recent copies of such standards are made available
in the library.
9.0 Lit 25
2. Mechanical Foam
50.0 Lit 02
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6105
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
A well-equipped occupational health centre with highly trained personnel shall be operating all 24
hours. In addition to monitoring the health and wellbeing of the employees, the centre is always in
readiness to take care of any emergency arising out of our manufacturing activities. People shall be
trained on first aid, taking care of toxic effects, minor and major accidents, arranging experts help,
imparting training to employees etc.
The Centre is ideally located near the Quality Control Lab, close to the entrance.
(0257)-
3. Civil Hospital Jalgaon General Practitioner
2226641/42/43/44
Skin contact:
- Wash skin with large amounts of normal water using mild soap.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6106
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
- Dust the affected area with Antiseptic Powder; wash the affected area again with normal running
water.
- Dry the skin very gently using a clean and soft towel.
- Do not apply oil or oily ointment without doctors advice. Incase of burns (inflammation, blisters)
Eye contact:
- Flush eye immediately with normal water for at least 15 minutes or longer, keeping eye lids open.
- - If the pain remains, repeat washing the eye for 15 minutes or longer.
- Do not use any oil or oily ointment with out doctors advice.
Note: The medical service will refer the victim to an ophthalmologist and inform him about the
nature of the accident
Inhalation:
- Remove the victim from the affected area and take him to well ventilated area.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6107
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
- Place the patient on his back with head and beak elevated.
- Rest is a must.
- If the victim coughs a great deal, make his inhale a gauze pad soaked with a little Ethyl Alcohol or
a few drops of Ether.
- Place the patient in a comfortable position with and trunk elevated to 45 position.
- Administer medical oxygen under low pressure using a pulmotor or similar type of vital equipment.
- Immediately administer medical oxygen under low pressure using a pulmotor or similar type of
vital equipment.
- As the victim begins to breathe unladed or to move, lay him down with his body raised and
continue to administer medical oxygen.
- The physician will keep the victim under medical supervision for at least 48 hrs as acute pulmonary
edema or microbial infection may be caused.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6108
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Ingestion:
- Immediately remove him from the affected area immediately to a well ventilated area.
- Ask the patient to drink copious amount of lime water or milk of magnesia or calcined magnesia in
water or table oil or fresh eggs.
- Rest is a must.
- If the victims face has become blue, lay him down on his back with head turned to one side.
- Administer medical oxygen under low pressure using a pulmotor or similar type of vital equipment.
Do not administer mixture of oxygen and carbon dioxide (Carbogen).
- Administer medical oxygen under low pressure using a pulmotor or similar type of vital equipment.
Do not administer carbogen.
- Immediately lay him down and begin artificial respiration or mouth to mouth resuscitation.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6109
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
- Continue to administer medical oxygen under low pressure using a pulmotor or similar type of vital
equipment till the victim begins to breathe unladed.
Therapy for specific physiological disturbances For the guidance and attention of medical
profession.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
------------
PULMONARY EDEMA:
- Intermittent positive pressure breathing apparatus set to deliver positive pressures of 5-15 cm of
water in the respiratory cycle is valuable in reducing the formation of edema.
- The use of diuretics and antibiotics should be considered to reduce edema and protection against
secondary pulmonary infection.
BRONCHOSPASM:
- The exposure is associated with acute symptomatology requiring supportive therapy. Early
treatment is the most effective.
- Broncho-dilators nebulized into the intermittent positive pressure gas steam are often beneficial.
- Isoproterenol hydrochloride
- The commonly employed single treatment dosage for each drug is 0.3 cc. This may be altered
according to clinical needs.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6110
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
1. Government Officials:-
(0257)-2222261 to
2. Jalgaon Municipal Corporation District, Jalgaon
2222265
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6111
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Co ordinator
4. Mr. S. G. Nehete 09890467183
(QMS/EMS/OHSAS)
Production
5. P. M. Rane 09420791019
Manager
Production
9. Mr. G. R. Zope 09403387957
Supervisor
Co Ordinator
2. Mr. S. G. Nehete 135
(QMS/EAMS/OHSAS)
Director of the
6. Director Cabin 151
Factory
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6112
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
EC. No.
TYPES OF
HAZARD ACUTE HAZARDS / FIRST AID / FIRE
PREVENTION
SYMPTOMS FIGHTING
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6113
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Wash with a
disinfectant soap
Use appropriate
Hazardous in case of skin and cover the
Skin PPEs Like Hand
contact (irritant), contaminated skin
gloves
with an anti-
bacterial cream
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6114
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
anything by mouth
to an unconscious
Person Loosen tight
clothing such as a
collar tie, belt or
waistband
Corrosive liquid. Stop leak if without risk. Corrosive & Irritant, Hazardous
Absorb with DRY earth, sand or other non- material, Marine pollutant, Seal tight
combustible material. Do not get water inside closed container with proper hazardous
container. Do not touch spilled material. Use label
water spray curtain to divert vapor drift.
Prevent entry into sewers, basements or
confined areas; dike if needed. Eliminate all
ignition sources. Call for assistance on
disposal. Finish cleaning by Spreading water
on the contaminated surface and allow to
evacuate through the sanitary system .Waste
must be disposed of in accordance with
federal, state and local environmental control
regulations.
See & Follow Transport Emergency Card Moisture sensitive. Light sensitive. Store
available with Driver in light-resistant containers. Keep
container tightly closed. Keep container
in a cool,Well-ventilated area.
IMPORTANT DATA
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6115
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
The vapour is heavier than air and may travel A harmful contamination of the air can be
along the ground; distant ignition possible reached rather quickly on evaporation of
this substance
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6116
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6117
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
EC. No.
TYPES OF
HAZARD ACUTE HAZARDS / FIRST AID / FIRE
PREVENTION
SYMPTOMS FIGHTING
immediately flush
Avoid the skin with plenty of
Contact with Skin water for at least 15
& body parts and minutes
May cause eye, skin, and
Exposure always use
respiratory tract irritation. while removing
Personal
contaminated
Protective
clothing
Equipments
and shoes.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6118
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Wash with a
disinfectant soap
Use appropriate
Hazardous in case of skin and cover the
Skin PPEs Like Hand
contact (irritant), contaminated skin
gloves
with an anti-
bacterial cream
minutes
Do NOT induce
vomiting
The substance is toxic to
. Never give
lungs. Repeated or
anything by mouth
prolonged exposure to the In all Cases to an unconscious
Ingestion Substance can produce target consult the doctor
immediately Person Loosen tight
organs damage. Repeated or
clothing such as a
prolonged contact with spray
collar
mist may produce chronic eye
tie, belt or
waistband
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6119
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Avoid generating dusty conditions. Remove all Corrosive & Irritant, Hazardous
sources of ignition. Provide ventilation. DO material, Marine pollutant, Seal tight
NOT CLEAN-UP OR DISPOSE OF, EXCEPT closed container with proper hazardous
UNDER SUPERVISION OF A SPECIALIST. label
Use only non-sparking tools and equipment..
See & Follow Transport Emergency Card Keep away from heat, sparks, and flame.
available with Driver Keep away from sources of ignition.
Store in a tightly closed container. Store
in a cool, dry, well-ventilated area away
from incompatible substances.
IMPORTANT DATA
The dust is Corrosive & Irritant A harmful contamination of the air can be
reached rather quickly on dusting of this
substance
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6120
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
ENVIORMENTAL DATA
PHYSICAL PROPERTIES
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6121
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6122
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
DOCTOR!
Ingestion
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6123
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Do NOT let this chemical enter the S: (1/2-)9-45-61 UN Hazard Class: 2.3
environment.
UN Subsidiary Risks: 8
IMPORTANT DATA
The Gas is heavier than Air A harmful contamination of the air can be
reached rather quickly on dusting of this
substance
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6124
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6125
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
CAS#: 140-53-4
RTECS: AL8250000
Chlorophenyl)acetonitrile
Contact Information:
Sciencelab.com, Inc.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6126
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
US Sales: 1-800-901-7247
1-800-424-9300
Composition:
Toxicological Data on Ingredients: 4-Chlorobenzyl cyanide: ORAL (LD50): Acute: 50 mg/kg [Rat].
Very hazardous in case of ingestion. Hazardous in case of skin contact (irritant, permeator), of eye
contact (irritant), of
DEVELOPMENTAL TOXICITY: Not available. The substance may be toxic to lungs, skin, central
nervous system (CNS).
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6127
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Repeated or prolonged exposure to the substance can produce target organs damage. Repeated
exposure to a highly toxic
material may produce general deterioration of health by an accumulation in one or many human
organs.
Eye Contact:
Check for and remove any contact lenses. In case of contact, immediately flush eyes with plenty of
water for at least 15
Skin Contact:
In case of contact, immediately flush skin with plenty of water for at least 15 minutes while
removing contaminated clothing
and shoes. Cover the irritated skin with an emollient. Wash clothing before reuse. Thoroughly clean
shoes before reuse. Get
Wash with a disinfectant soap and cover the contaminated skin with an anti-bacterial cream. Seek
immediate medical
attention.
Inhalation:
If inhaled, remove to fresh air. If not breathing, give artificial respiration. If breathing is difficult,
give oxygen. Get medical
attention immediately.
Serious Inhalation:
Evacuate the victim to a safe area as soon as possible. Loosen tight clothing such as a collar, tie, belt
or waistband. If
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6128
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
breathing is difficult, administer oxygen. If the victim is not breathing, perform mouth-to-mouth
resuscitation. WARNING: It may
be hazardous to the person providing aid to give mouth-to-mouth resuscitation when the inhaled
material is toxic, infectious or
Ingestion:
If swallowed, do not induce vomiting unless directed to do so by medical personnel. Never give
anything by mouth to an
unconscious person. Loosen tight clothing such as a collar, tie, belt or waistband. Get medical
attention immediately.
Products of Combustion: These products are carbon oxides (CO, CO2), halogenated compounds.
of heat.
Risks of explosion of the product in presence of mechanical impact: Not available. Risks of
explosion of the product in
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6129
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SMALL FIRE: Use DRY chemical powder. LARGE FIRE: Use water spray, fog or foam. Do not
use water jet.
Small Spill: Use appropriate tools to put the spilled solid in a convenient waste disposal container.
Large Spill:
Poisonous solid. Stop leak if without risk. If the product is in its solid form: Use a shovel to put the
material into a convenient
waste disposal container. If the product is in its liquid form: Do not get water inside container.
Absorb with an inert materialp. 3
and put the spilled material in an appropriate waste disposal. Do not touch spilled material. Use
water spray to reduce vapors.
Prevent entry into sewers, basements or confined areas; dike if needed. Eliminate all ignition
sources. Call for assistance on
disposal. Be careful that the product is not present at a concentration level above TLV. Check TLV
on the MSDS and with local
authorities.
Precautions:
Keep locked up.. Keep away from heat. Keep away from sources of ignition. Empty containers pose
a fire risk, evaporate
the residue under a fume hood. Ground all equipment containing material. Do not ingest. Do not
breathe dust. Wear suitable
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6130
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
immediately and show the container or the label. Avoid contact with skin and eyes. Keep away from
incompatibles such as
Storage: Keep container tightly closed. Keep container in a cool, well-ventilated area. Do not store
above 23C (73.4F).
Engineering Controls:
Use process enclosures, local exhaust ventilation, or other engineering controls to keep airborne
levels below recommended
exposure limits. If user operations generate dust, fume or mist, use ventilation to keep exposure to
airborne contaminants
Personal Protection:
Splash goggles. Lab coat. Dust respirator. Be sure to use an approved/certified respirator or
equivalent. Gloves.
Splash goggles. Full suit. Dust respirator. Boots. Gloves. A self contained breathing apparatus
should be used to avoid
inhalation of the product. Suggested protective clothing might not be sufficient; consult a specialist
BEFORE handling this
product.
Exposure Limits:
TWA: 5 (mg/m3) from OSHA listed under Cyanide Anion) (PEL) [United States] Consult local
authorities for acceptable
exposure limits.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6131
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Odor: Odorless.
Conditions of Instability: Excess heat (temp. above 40 C., excess dust generation, incompatible
materials.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6132
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Incompatibility with various substances: Reactive with oxidizing agents, reducing agents, acids,
alkalis.
Chronic Effects on Humans: May cause damage to the following organs: lungs, skin, central nervous
system (CNS).
Very hazardous in case of ingestion. Hazardous in case of skin contact (irritant, permeator), of
inhalation.
Acute Potential Health Effects: Skin: May caue skin irritation. May be harmful if absorbed through
skin. May affect behavior
and respiration. May be metabolized to cyanide which inhibits cytochrome oxidase impairing
cellular respiration. Most nitrile
compounds are well absorbed through intact skin and may cause delayed onset of symptoms
following exposure by this route.
Eyes: May cause eye irritation. Inhalation: Dust may cause respiratory tract irritation. May be
harmful if inhaled. Inhalation
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6133
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
may result in symptoms similar to cyanide poisoning which include abnormally rapid or deep
breathing, and difficult breathing
followed rapidly by respiratory depression. Pulmonary edema may occur. Ingestion: Poison by
ingestion. Harmful if swallowed.
May be fatal. May cause digestive tract irritation. Metabolsim may release cyanide, which may
affect metabolism, respiration
(dyspnea), behavior and central nervous system (headache, dizziness, weakness, collapse,
unconsciousness and possible
death), nervous system (peripheral nerve and sensation). Chronic Potential Health Effects: May be
metabolized to cyanide
which inhibits cytochrome oxidase impairing cellular respiration. Exposure to samll amounts of
cyanide compounds over long
periods of time is reported to loss of appetite, headache, weakness, dizziness, nausea, and irritation
of respiratory tract and
eyes.
Products of Biodegradation:
Possibly hazardous short term degradation products are not likely. However, long term degradation
products may arise.
Toxicity of the Products of Biodegradation: The products of degradation are as toxic as the product
itself.
Waste Disposal:
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6134
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Waste must be disposed of in accordance with federal, state and local environmental control
regulations.
Other Regulations:
OSHA: Hazardous by definition of Hazard Communication Standard (29 CFR 1910.1200). EINECS:
This product is on the
Other Classifications:
WHMIS (Canada): CLASS D-1A: Material causing immediate and serious toxic effects (VERY
TOXIC).
DSCL (EEC):
R23/24/25- Toxic by inhalation, in contact with skin and if swallowed. S28- After contact with skin,
wash immediately with
plenty of water. S36/37/39- Wear suitable protective clothing, gloves and eye/face protection. S45-
In case of accident or if you
feel unwell, seek medical advice immediately (show the label where possible).
HMIS (U.S.A.):
Health Hazard: 2
Fire Hazard: 1
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6135
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Reactivity: 0
Personal Protection: E
Health: 3
Flammability: 1
Reactivity: 0
Specific hazard:
Protective Equipment:
Gloves. Lab coat. Dust respirator. Be sure to use an approved/certified respirator or equivalent. Wear
appropriate respirator
The information above is believed to be accurate and represents the best information currently
available to us. However, we
Note : This on site emergency plan has been prepared on the basis of information made available by
client, available resources and experience of maker. As the facilities available, manufacturing
process/product, or any other criteria changes so will change the onsite emergency plan. So it is
strongly recommended to review this plant periodically so as to make it perfect. Further
effectiveness of this plan is beyond control of maker of this plan for oblivious reasons.
DOW INDEX
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6136
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6137
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
From the above storages a list of flammable substances stored was prepared which is given in above
Table . It is seen that about 139 barrels (each of 200 Liter ) would be stored in the factory at any
given time.
An estimation of Dow Fire and Explosion Index was done assuming that all barrels contain the
maximum flammable material (from flash point of view) i. e. Cyclohexane
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6138
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
The calculations for Dow Fire and Explosion Index is given and from the calculations it is seen that
the storage will have a Dow Index of 86.56 indicating Moderate hazard potential
Preventive & Protective Fire & Explosion Index Number Index for the present case
Features
0- 20-40 40- 60-75 75- >90 86.56
20 60 90
Suggest Recom Feature
ed mended required
1) Fireproofing 1 2 2 3 4 4
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6139
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
2) Water spray
a) directional 1 2 3 3 4 4
b) area 1 2 3 3 4 4
c) curtain 1 1 2 2 2 4
3) Special
instrumentation
a) temperature 1 2 3 3 4 4
b) pressure 1 2 3 3 3 4
c) flow control 1 2 3 4 4 4
5) Internal examination 1 2 3 3 4 4
6) Combustible gas
monitors
a) signal alarm 1 1 2 3 2 4
b) actuate equipment 1 1 2 2 2 4
7) Remote operation 1 1 2 3 2 4
8) Diking, (Not 1 4 4 4 4 4
Applicable as barrel
storage)
In order to reduce the probability of fire occurring in the storage the following precautions would be
taken. Mr. S. Navale, G. M. Technical agreed that the these precautions will be taken during
installation, commissioning and running of the solvent storage facility.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6140
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
While designing the shed consideration would be given to the sitting facilities like control
room, amenity buildings and access routes, to reduced the number of people who may be
present in the potentially hazardous area.
Installation will be designed with adequate mean of escape for personal and with facilities
for containing and fighting fires (such as built in fires extinguisher equipment )
Wherever required, the storage would be covered under license from PESO under Petroleum
Rules, maintaining safe distances, as required under the rules.
The storage area would not be sited immediately uphill of a process area or other area in
which sources of ignition will be present
The site will be supplied with drainage facilities adequate for all emergency water usage and
provided with interceptor chamber, designed to exclude the flammable liquid from storm
water storage drainage or main sewer system.
Fire hydrants will be provided in at least two locations on or near the site and so located that
they will be usable under all foreseeable conditions of fire and wind directions.
NOC would be taken from MIDC officials for the storage from fire point of view.
Adequate free space (ullage ) should be left above the liquid to allow the thermal expansion
In all circumstances drums would be stored in an orderly manner which allows access to all
parts of store and store area. stack of filled drums will be limited in height to four drums and
the stack would be on pallets
The barrels would be marked to shown the exact contents of the same.
MONDS INDEX
Introduction
The principle and general approach used in the DOW method of hazard evaluation have been further
developed by ICI Mond Division, Their revised Mond fire, explosive and toxicity index is a series of
papers by lewis (1979). The main development made to the DOW Index in the Mond Index are:
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6141
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
3. A calculation procedure is included to allow for the off-setting effects of good design and
control and safety instrumentation
5. Separate indices are calculated to acess the hazards of fire, internal explosion and aerial
explosion.
SULPHURYL 340x304x5 3 -
60 Ltr 5.0 MT 0.10
CHLORIDE 60
900 Kg 762x202 4 1
CHLORINE 3.6 MT 1.54
(Toner) 6L
SODIUM 609x914x1 3 -
50 Kg.bag 5.0 MT 0.55
HYDROXIDE 52
406x609x1 2 10
NAPHTHALENE 50 kg Bag 10.0 MT 0.247
52
ETHYLENE DI 2 50
200 Ltr 0.6 MT 0.36 600x900
CHLORIDE
THIONYL 3 -
200 Ltr 1.0 MT 0.36 600x900
CHLORIDE
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6142
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
MONO METHYL 2 -
200 Ltr 0.6 MT 0.36 600x900
AMINE 40 %
PARA CHLORO 2 -
200 Ltr 0.6 MT 0.36 600x900
PHENOL
DI METHYL 4 1
200 Ltr 1.5 MT 0.36 600x900
SULPHATE
355x228.6 3 5
FORMIC ACID 50 Ltr carboy 1.5 MT 0.081
x457
FORMALDEHYDE 3 5
200 Ltr 2.0 MT 0.36 600x900
SOLUTION 37%
PER CHLORO 2
200 Ltr 3.0 MT 0.36 600x900
ETHYLENE
500x800x1 2
COPPER SULPHATE 50 kg bag 0.2 MT 0.40
50
BENZOYL 355x228.6 2 1
50 Ltr carboy 0.6 MT 0.081
CHLORIDE x457
305x432x2 3 0.1
1 Ltrx6 0.131
BROMINE 3.0 MT 80
Bottle box (1 box)
(1 box)
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6143
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
CHLORIDE 7.2
CHLORO BENZENE 2
200 Ltr 5.0 MT 0.36 600x900
(MCB)
According to the Health Hazard Index from the MSDS it was found to be that chlorine and
dimethyl sulphate has the highest health hazard rating and lowest threshold limit values out of
the total hazardous raw materials used in the factory premises.
Hence the Monds Index will be performed for Chlorine and Dimethyl sulphate.
100
Th (Toxicity Factor): For Chlorine will be 325 from the table no. 2 as the Nh factor for chlorine is 4
Ts (Correction Factor): For Chlorine will be 125 from the table no. 3 as the MAC is 1 ppm
Toxicity Factor
NFPA Index Number
(Th)
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6144
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
0 0
1 50
2 125
3 250
4 325
Between 5 and 50 75
50 and more 50
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6145
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
_____inerted ______noninerted
1. Tank farm storage flammable 0.50 0.00
2. Process upset or purge failure 0.30 0.00
3. Combustible solids in storage. Dust 0.80 0.00
iDust Explosion 0.25 to 2.00 0.00
Pressure Operating pressure psig 0.00
Low temperature 0.20 to 0.30 0.00
Quantity of flammable / unstable
1. Liquids or gases in process 0.00
7.8 x10 ^9 2. Liquids or gases in storage 0.0
3. Combustible Solids in Storage, Dust 0.00
in Process
Corrosion & Erosion 0.10 to 0.75 0.10
Leakage - Joints & Packing 0.10 to 1.50 0.10
Use of Fired Equipment 0.00
Hot oil heat exchange system 0.15 to 1.15 0.00
Rotating Equipment 0.50 0.00
Special Process Hazard Factor ( F2 ) 2.0
Therefore from the above table the GPH and SPH is coming to be around 1.70 and 2.0 respectively.
100
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6146
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
1-5 Light
6-9 Moderate
10-up High
The Toxicity Index for Chlorine is calculated to be around 9.1 which indicate that the degree of
hazard is high from table no. 5.
Th (Toxicity Factor): For Dimethyl Sulphate will be 325 from the table no. 2 as the Nh factor for
Dimethyl Sulphate is 4
Ts (Correction Factor): For Dimethyl Sulphate will be 125 from the table no. 3 as the MAC for
Dimethyl Sulphate is 1 ppm
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6147
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Therefore from the above table the GPH and SPH is coming to be around 1.95 and 2.1 respectively.
100
The Toxicity Index for Dimethyl Sulphate is calculated to be around 9.5 which indicate that the
degree of hazard is high from table no 5.
1. The toxic chemicals will be stored according to the compatibility with other chemicals.
2. Proper colour and tag name system will be followed for the storage purpose.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6148
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
For fire load calculation all the raw materials classified as flammable according to the MSIHC rule is
calculated. Definition of FIRE LOAD:
The fire loading of a compartment is a way of establishing the severity of a fire and the measurement
(kj) is related to the heat output. As stated by Drysdale (1985) the formula for calculating the fire
loading is noted as:
Calorific Value x Mass (or volume)/ Floor Area = Area Fire Loading Kj/m2
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6149
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Raw Material Tank / Flash Calorific No of Quantity 1 drum Total Fire Area Fire
Drum Point (O Value drum/Bag/ at any area (Sq. Drum Load Kj Loading
Capacity C) (kJ/kg) Box time (Kg) m.) Area (Kj/m2 )
Ltr Sq.m
Naphthalene 50 kg bag 78.8889 38844.2 200 Bag 10000 0.03 6 388442000 64740333.33
Ethylene di chloride 200 ltr 13.3333 10699.6 3 Drum 600 0.54 1.62 6419760 7379034.483
Acetic acid 200 ltr 39.4444 13025.6 3 Drum 600 0.54 1.62 7815360 8983172.414
Ethyl acetate 200 ltr -4.44444 23492.6 3 Drum 500 0.54 1.62 11746300 13501494.25
Methanol 200 ltr 11.1111 20003.6 8 Drum 1500 0.54 4.32 30005400 12933362.07
Cyclohexane 200 ltr -20 43496.2 3 Drum 600 0.54 1.62 26097720 29997379.31
Ethyl bromide 200 ltr 13025.6 5 Drum 1000 0.54 2.7 13025600 8983172.414
Tri ethyl amine 200 ltr -8.88889 41402.8 2 Drum 400 0.54 1.08 16561120 28553655.17
Para chloro phenol 200 ltr 63.8889 21399.2 3 Drum 600 0.54 1.62 12839520 14758068.97
Di methyl sulphate 200 ltr -48 30703 8 Drum 1500 0.54 4.32 46054500 19851077.59
Benzoyl chloride 50 ltr 72.2222 29307.6 12 Carboy 600
carboy 0.08 0.96 17584560 5053034.483
Bromine 1 ltrx6 0 500 Box 3000
Bottle
box 0.03 15 0 0
Acetyl chloride 200 ltr 4.44444 5815 3 Drum 500 0.54 1.62 2907500 3341954.023
Chloro benzene 200 ltr 28.8889 25353.4 25 Drum 5000
(mcb) 0.54 13.5 126767000 17485103.45
57.6 706266340 235560842
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter6150
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
M/s. Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. has proposed an expansion plant of intermediate for
API at MIDC Jalgaon, Maharashtra. The Proposed expansion has direct & indirect positive
impact on surrounding area which is mentioned below:
Thus a significant benefit to the socio-economic environment is likely to be created due to the
project.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter71
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
8.1 Introduction
Environment Management Plan (EMP) is the key to ensure a safe and clean environment. A
project may have identified proper mitigation measures but without a management plan to
execute it, the desired results may not be obtained. The Environment Management Plan
envisages proper implementation of mitigation measures to reduce the adverse impacts arising
out of the project activities.
Ensure the expansion implementation with minimal impacts on all environment attributes
Minimize the impacts on socio- economic indicators of the local and adjoining regions
Maintain the highest level of readiness for meeting the needs of any deviation in
sustainability practices
Systematic implementation with adequate manpower, budget and action plan for EMP
Use EMP to demonstrate the effectiveness of its workability along with the project
proponents commitment.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter81
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Sr. Cost of environmental protection Recurring Cost per Capital Cost (Rs.)
measures annum (Rs.)
No.
1,00,000/- 6,00,000/-
1 Air Pollution Control
2,00,000/- 8,98,260/-
2 Water Pollution Control
3 30,000/- 1,00,000/-
Noise Pollution Control
Environment monitoring 30,000/- 1,00,000/-
4
and Management
Reclamation borrow/mined area ---- -----
5
(if applicable )
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter82
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
20,000/- 20,000/-
6 Occupational health
10,000/- 30,000/-
8 Solid waste management
4 lacs 20 lacs
Total Cost
The total project cost of the proposed expansion project is 2 Cr, Out of which 20 lacs will be
spend for the environmental pollution control. Approximately 4 lacs will be the recurring cost
which will be used for maintenance purpose like machine repair, ETP repair etc.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter83
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Operation Phase
Environmental Phase Project Activity Potential Impacts Mitigation
Component Measures
Air Operation Transportation Increase in Air Smooth flow of
Phase inside the plant Pollutant traffic, Regulation of
premises Concentration in air pollution by
some locations. legislation and public
awareness.
Boiler and DG Air Pollution Dust Collector is
Set given to the boiler
operation/produc Also appropriate
tion stack height is
provided.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter84
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Operation
Phase
Even after taking precautions if soil is found to be contaminated, it shall be removed and disposed off
to authorized site.
Ecology
Operation Operation Increase exposure to Enactment and
Phase anthropogenic activities. enforcement of laws
regulating human
intrusions.
Introduction:
A green belt will be developed to minimize the air pollution & noise pollution at the project site.
Development of green belt not only minimizes these impacts but also improves the aesthetic
environment of the region. Therefore a Green Belt Development plan has been proposed at the
project site in general and along the project components in particular using the local flora.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter85
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Green belt planning has been done with the ecological perspective of API Intermediate
Manufacturing Plant for Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited., taking into consideration nature
of pollutants, availability of space and dominant wind directions. Benzo Chem Industries Pvt.
Limited is an API intermediate producing unit. The project is located at Plot No. E- 13, E- 14,
E-15, MIDC, Industrial Area, Jalgaon, MIDC, State - Maharashtra.
Extensive survey in the project area was undertaken to observe the structure and composition of
vegetation. The soil characteristics were also kept in mind. Based on this survey and the CPCB
guidelines native plant species have been proposed for the green belt development plan. The
green belt is proposed to be developed within the project site (approx. 33% of the total plant
area). The general considerations involved while proposing the green belt plan are:
Local/ Native fast growing trees & shrubs will be used for plantation
They should not have any noticeable effect on the plant yield due to gaseous pollutants
The planting should be in appropriate alternate rows around the proposed site to prevent
lateral pollution dispersion.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter86
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
A reconnaissance survey was conducted during which sites/blocks were identified for the
proposed plantation scheme & same are plotted on the plot layout. The proposed plantation
scheme will be executed on an area of 1,000 sq.m. & plantation will be carried out in 1 phase
viz. Phase I - January 2015. The details of the identified sites/blocks during the site visit are as
follows:
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter87
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter88
The following parameters were considered while developing the plantation strategy:
Noise Generation
I Point Sources:
Plant operation will lead to permanent air pollution having negative impact on the air quality.
The three pollutant of main concern are particulate matter, SO2 and NOx. The sources identified
which will be responsible for above mentioned pollutant are Boiler and D.G set. As the emission
is expected from the fixed locations hence it is considered under point source.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter89
1. Boiler 30.0
II Fugitive
Emissions:
The major component of fugitive emissions like VOC will be from the processes & also the
volatile organic compounds storage in tanks/drums in the plant site
Noise Generation
Probable Source:
The plant noise sources include turbo-generators, air compressors, feed pumps, condensate
pumps, reflux pumps, recycle pumps, diluents pumps, tempering pumps, air blowers, I.D. Fans,
cooling towers etc.
Table 3: The details of Noise Level monitored in the plant premises are as follows:
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter810
Sr.
No Location Sound Level dB (A)
1 Near Main Gate 47.4
2 Near Office 55.2
3 Near ETP 69.2
4 Boiler House 72.6
5 Production Room 71.3
6 Laboratory 61.5
76.2 dB 6 dB 70.2 dB
76.2 dB 12 dB 64.2 dB
76.2 dB 15 dB 61.2 dB
76.2 dB 18 dB 58.2 dB
It is predicted that the cumulative noise levels inside the plant will be exceeding 75 dBA hence
the proposed green belt is designed to suppress the same.
The prevailing prominent wind direction in the project area is from North to South.
Plantation Strategy:
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter811
developed the green belt in the East & West direction around the factory premises comprising of
large evergreen trees. Also industry has planted small shrubs & flowering plants around various
utilities. A one tiered plantation comprising of large evergreen trees will be planted towards
Northern periphery of the company. Shrubs will be planted in B & C block & two tiered
plantation comprising of large evergreen trees will be done D block. The boiler chimneys are
located towards south form the main gate & the proposed plantation block identified around
these utilities is block D.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter812
Table 2: Action plan for the proposed plantation Phase I- January, 2015:
3 To Provide good Soil and Fertilizers for the plants 2,66 38 10,108.00
TOTAL 2,51,740.00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter813
The main principles involving corporate social responsibility involve economic, legal, ethical
and discretionary policy aspects. A corporation needs to generate profits, while operating within
the laws of the state. The corporation also needs to be ethical, but has the right to be discretional
about the decisions it makes. Levels of corporate social responsiveness to an issue include being
reactive, defensive, responsive and interactive. All terms are useful in issues management.
Selecting when and how to act can make a difference in the outcome of the action taken.
M/s. Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. are involved in corporate social responsibility activity.
The project proponent would employee majority of local peoples as permanent employees of the
company to fulfill the need of increased manpower. M/s. Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited
provides appropriate support to the nearby school, organizes the medical camps for local people
and provides free medical help to the local needy people.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter814
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter815
Hence the proponent is opting for Roof top Rain water harvesting tank and not for
artificial recharge of groundwater.
Amount of Rain water collected (Approx) : Annual rainfall (mm) X Roof Area (sq.m) X
0.9 (Run off Coefficient) = 784.8 X 1957 X 0.9 = 1382268.2 ltrs/A
The rain water harvested will be used for gardening, boiler intake and cooling tower intake
purpose. Currently Coal shed roof area is used for rain water harvesting purpose. In the coming
future it can be planned to use the roof top area of old as well as of the new boiler for RHW. So
that the water management in the plant site during the rainy season can be increased.
Abide by applicable legislation and others relevant requirements and emphasis on the
continual improvements and preventive measures for environment, health and safety.
Aim to eliminate all incidents and injuries.
Minimize the risk when handling storage, processing of products.
Continuously evaluate, control and minimize the wastages of groups resources and
energy consumption.
Be obligated to inform interested parties about our activities and products.
This policy shall be reviewed periodically made available to all interested parties in line with
continual improvement of organizational safety, health and environmental performance.
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter816
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
CHAPTER 9: CONCLUSION
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter91
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
DeclarationbyExpertscontributingtotheEIAM/sBenzochemIndustriesPvt.Limited
I, hereby, certify that I was a part of the EIA Team in the following, capacity that developed the above EIA
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter101
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter102
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter103
SEEPL/EEIA/F/
Benzo
o Chem
m Indusstries Pvt.
P Limmited. IND/BIPLL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEn
nviroEngineeersPvt.Ltd Chaptter104
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
Signature :
Name : Mr. P.R Sadekar
Designation : Director
Name of the EIA Consultant Organization : M/s Sadekar Enviro Engineers Pvt. Ltd.
310, Dempo Towers, EDC Patto, Panaji 403001
Goa State India
NABET Certificate No. & Issue Date : NABET/EIA/SA/258 dated 20th Jan 2015
Sr. Functional
Complete Name of the Functional Areas
No. Area/s (Code)
1 AP Air Pollution Prevention, Monitoring & Control
2 WP Water Pollution Prevention, Control & Prediction of Impacts
3 SHW Solid Waste and Hazardous Waste Management
4 SE Socio-Economics
5 EB Ecology and Biodiversity
6 HG Hydrology, Ground Water & Water Conservation
7 GEO Geology
8 SC Soil Conservation
9 AQ Meteorology, Air Quality Modeling & Prediction
10 NV Noise /Vibration
11 LU Land Use
12 RH Risk Assessment & Hazard Management
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter105
SEEPL/EIA/F/
Benzo Chem Industries Pvt. Limited. IND/BIPL/001/
2014-15/00
SadekarEnviroEngineersPvt.Ltd Chapter106