Microarrays: Biotechnology's Discovery Platform For Functional Genomics
Microarrays: Biotechnology's Discovery Platform For Functional Genomics
Microarrays: Biotechnology's Discovery Platform For Functional Genomics
Advances in microarray technology enable massive parallel mining of biological data, with biological chips providing
hybridization-based expression monitoring, polymorphism detection and genotyping on a genomic scale. Microarrays
containing sequences representative of all human genes may soon permit the expression analysis of the entire human genome
in a single reaction. These genome chips will provide unprecedented access to key areas of human health, including disease
prognosis and diagnosis, drug discovery, toxicology, aging, and mental illness. Microarray technology is rapidly becoming a
central platform for functional genomics.
B
iological research can be viewed as an information set of tools that allow researchers to link hypothesis
science. Understanding the methodological testing and data (Fig. 1a). In the appropriate method-
architecture on which the discipline operates ological context, data from chip-based experiments can
facilitates the efficient gathering of biological infor- provide significant quantitative information about
mation (data). This hierarchy can be arranged in the important cellular pathways and processes. Microarrays
form of an epistemological pyramid, with the tiers allow the accumulation of large amounts of functional-
demarcated according to their degree of conceptual genomic information by enabling the global ordering
abstraction (Fig. 1a). In biological research, hypotheses of molecules in a parallel fashion (Fig. 1c). Proper
are formulated using the most abstract components of experimental design allows the delineation of respec-
the pyramid, such as world view and theory, and then tive internal and external contributions to the physio-
tested using a large body of rules that govern the selec- logical state (Fig. 1c).
tion and use of methods and tools best suited for All microarray assays contain five discrete experi-
addressing a particular biological question (Fig. 1a). mental steps biological query, sample preparation,
Hypothesis testing ultimately results in the accumu- biochemical reaction, detection and data visualization
lation of data, which, in turn, reshape the world view and modelling1. Under appropriate experimental con-
and theory, leading to subsequent rounds of hypothesis ditions1, chips can provide a quantitative measure of the
formulation and testing, and an enhanced understanding molecules present in biochemical extracts. Microarrays
of a biological question. of complementary DNA (cDNA) sequences, for
One aspect of world view focuses on the notion that example, allow hybridization-based expression moni-
an ecosystem contains interactive components that can toring of the cognate genes26. In these assays, steady-
be arranged according to their biochemical complex- state mRNA levels are deduced from the fluorescence
ity (Fig. 1b). The biochemical-complexity hierarchy intensity at each position on the microarray26.
helps to underscore the fact that biological systems are
highly interactive. Complex organisms such as humans, Advantages of chip assays
for example, exist as a culture that is part of a much Microarray assays are rooted in early biochemical
larger ecosystem; importantly, phenotype is deter- experiments on solid surfaces79. Although reminiscent
mined by a combination of genetic and environmen- of filter-based assays10, chip assays are a fundamental
tal factors (Fig. 1b). Understanding human behaviour, departure from techniques that employ porous mem-
disease and other health issues thus requires more than branes. Chips allow true parallelism, miniaturization,
just a knowledge of genes and genomes: one must multiplexing and automation, and these key features
understand the cellular, physiological, cultural and eco- provide a set of performance specifications26 that
logical context in which genomic instructions are being cannot be achieved with the earlier technologies.
read. Microarray assays allow massive parallel data acquisi-
The rate at which biological information is acquired tion and analysis. Parallelism greatly increases the speed
depends, in part, on the research tools employed. Other of experimental progress and allows meaningful com-
factors being equal, better tools yield better data. parisons to be made between the genes or gene prod-
Microarray technology represents a powerful new ucts represented in the microarray. Microarray assays
may eventually allow the analysis of the entire human
genome in a single reaction, and recent gene-expression
M. Schena and R. W. Davis are at the Department of Biochemistry,
Beckman Center, Stanford University Medical Center, Stanford, CA
experiments in yeast represent an important step
94305, USA. R. A. Heller is at Roche Bioscience, 3401 Hillview towards this goal1113.
Avenue, Palo Alto, CA 94304, USA. T. P. Theriault, K. Konrad Miniaturization of conventional assays is a general
and E. Lachenmeier are at Incyte Pharmaceuticals, 3174 Porter Drive, trend in biomedical research14. Microscale assays reduce
Palo Alto, CA 94304, USA. reagent consumption, minimize reaction volumes,
TIBTECH JULY 1998 (VOL 16) Copyright 1998, Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved. 0167 7799/98/$19.00. PII: S0167-7799(98)01219-0 301
REVIEWS
a M2
Shine X X
M1 M1
light Couple Repeat
X X X X X X X X A A
Microarray
b
Touch Move
surface pins Repeat
Microarray
c
Deliver Move
drop jets Repeat
Microarray
Figure 2
Microarray technologies; three approaches to microarray manufacturing are depicted. (a) Photolithography: a glass wafer modified with
photolabile protecting groups (X) is selectively activated for DNA synthesis by shining light through a photomask (M1). The wafer is then
flooded with a photoprotected DNA base (AX), resulting in spatially defined coupling on the chip surface. A second photomask (M2) is used
to deprotect defined regions of the wafer. Repeated deprotection and coupling cycles enable the preparation of high-density oligonucleotide
microarrays. (b) Mechanical microspotting: a biochemical sample is loaded into a spotting pin by capillary action, and a small volume is
transferred to a solid surface by physical contact between the pin and the solid substrate. After the first spotting cycle, the pin is washed
and a second sample is loaded and deposited to an adjacent address. Robotic control systems and multiplexed printheads allow automated
microarray fabrication. (c) Ink jetting: a biochemical sample is loaded into a miniature nozzle equipped with a piezoelectric fitting (rectan-
gles) and an electrical current is used to expel a precise amount of liquid from the jet onto the substrate. After the first jetting step, the jet
is washed and a second sample is loaded and deposited to an adjacent address. A repeated series of cycles with multiple jets enables rapid
microarray production.
nucleic acid for hybridization. Future modifications of premade biochemical substances onto solid surfaces
the Affymetrix approach, such as the use of acid-resist (Fig. 2b). Printing is accomplished by direct surface
technology, may allow microarray manufacturing with- contact between the printing substrate and a delivery
out the need for photomasks (J. Beecher, pers. com- mechanism that contains an array of tweezers, pins or
mun.). Steady improvements in coupling efficiency, capillaries that serve to transfer the biochemical sam-
density and biochemical diversity will ensure the via- ples to the surface (Fig. 2b).
bility of the Affymetrix platform in a competitive Some of the advantages of the microspotting tech-
micorarray marketplace. nologies include ease of prototyping and therefore rapid
implementation, low cost and versatility. One disad-
Mechanical microspotting vantage of microspotting is that each sample must be
A second robust set of technologies are the mechan- synthesized, purified and stored prior to microarray
ical microspotting approaches, an original version of fabrication. The microspotted microarrays currently
which was developed by Shalon and Brown2,16 and later manufactured at Synteni contain as many as 10 000
commercialized at Synteni (Fremont, CA, USA). groups of cDNAs in an area of ~3.6 cm2; each cDNA
Microspotting, a miniaturized version of earlier DNA- feature permits the expression monitoring of its cog-
spotting techniques10, encompasses a family of related nate human gene. A set of four Synteni microarrays
deposition technologies that enable automated should thus allow the expression monitoring of
microarray production by printing small quantities of ~40 000 human genes, the number of unique expressed
Affymetrix Santa Clara, CA, USA GeneChip technology, microarray contract services, complete
microarray systems
Alphagene Woburn, MA, USA AlphaGenomics, full-length cDNAs, microarray contract services
Amersham Amersham, UK CyDye fluorescent-labelling reagents
Biodot Irvine, CA, USA Ink-jetting technology, microarray instrumentation
CLONTECH Labs Palo Alto, CA, USA Technology Access Program, gene-expression reagents
General Scanning Watertown, MA, USA Confocal-scanning instrumentation
Genetix Dorset, UK Microspotting instrumentation
Genome Systems St Louis, MO, USA Expressed-sequence-tag (EST) libraries
Genometrix The Woodlands, TX, USA Microarray technology platform, contract services
Genomic Instrumentation Services Menlo Park, CA, USA Development Partners Program, microarray instrumentation
Hewlett-Packard Palo Alto, CA, USA GeneArray, confocal-scanning instruments (Affymetrix)
Hyseq Sunnyvale, CA, USA HyChip products, genomics platform, contract services
Incyte Pharmaceuticals Palo Alto, CA, USA LifeSeq database, GeneJet and GEM technology, microarray
contract services
Intelligent Automation Systems Cambridge, MA, USA Custom automation, microarray instrumentation, contract work
Life Technologies Gaithersburg, MD, USA Fluorescent-labelling reagents
Molecular Applications Group Palo Alto, CA, USA GeneMine Pro, data-analysis and -visualization software
Molecular Dynamics Sunnyvale, CA, USA Microarray Technology Access Program, complete microarray
systems
Nanogen San Diego, CA, USA APEX, electronic microarray technology, contract services
Norgren Systems Palo Alto, CA, USA CCD-based imaging, microspotting instrumentation
OncorMed Gaithersburg, MD, USA Cancer prognostics and diagnostics
Pangea Systems Oakland, CA, USA GeneWorld, data-mining, -analysis and -management software
Protogene Laboratories Palo Alto, CA, USA Ink-jetting technology, microarray contract services
Qiagen Hilden, Germany DNA- and RNA-purification systems
Research Genetics Huntsville, AL, USA GenePairs, primers and purified PCR products
Silicon Graphics Mountain View, CA, USA Computational hardware and software, data-visualization and
-mining tools
Synteni Fremont, CA, USA GEM technology, microarray contract services
TeleChem International San Jose, CA, USA ArrayIt, PCR purification systems, microspotting technology,
scanners
sequences currently in public databases. Although density of 10 000 spots cm2. Because ink jetting does
microspotting is unlikely ever to produce the densities not require direct surface contact, piezoelectric deliv-
of photolithography, improvements in mechanical- ery is theoretically amenable to very high throughput.
spotting technologies will eventually allow the auto- Improvements in sample loading and sample changing
mated production of chips containing 100 000 features should, coupled with the inherent high-density capa-
in an area of ~6.5 cm2. Because of the ease of use and bilities of this approach, eventually enable the manu-
affordability, microspotting may become the microarray facture of complex microarrays. Piezoelectric-based
technology of choice for the basic research laboratory. delivery of phosphoramidite reagents has recently been
used for the manufacture of high-density oligonu-
Ink jets cleotide microarrays21. The successful application of ink
A third group of microarray technologies, the drop- jetting in a gene-expression setting (Fig. 3) demon-
on-demand delivery approaches, provide another way strates the immediate utility of this technology for
to manufacture microarrays (Fig. 2c). The most genome analysis.
advanced of these approaches are adaptations of the ink-
jetting technologies1821, which utilize piezoeletric and Combinations
other forms of propulsion to transfer biochemical sub- In view of the growing interest in microarray tech-
stances from miniature nozzles to solid surfaces nology and its potential impact on drug development
(Fig. 2c). Similar to the microspotting approaches, and disease profiling, it is unrealistic to suggest that any
drop-on-demand technologies allow high-density single enabling technology will dominate this large and
gridding of virtually any biomolecule of interest, diverse industry. A more balanced view suggests that
including cDNAs, genomic DNAs, antibodies and each of the technologies described above, and perhaps
small molecules. Ink-jetting technology is being devel- others22,23, will be utilized for the purpose they per-
oped at several centres including Incyte Pharmaceuti- form best at and will assist collectively in the prolifer-
cals (Palo Alto, CA, USA) and Protogene (Palo Alto, ation of microarray assays. The burgeoning microarray
CA, USA). industry, complete with scientific, business, financial
Although ink jetting is not currently as robust as and legal components, will soon provide a complete
photolithography or microspotting, this approach has repertoire of technologies and services for the scientific
been used to prepare microarrays of single cDNAs at a community (Table 1).
Figure 3
Gene-expression monitoring with an ink-jetted microarray. This is a fluorescent scan of a high-density microarray printed using a GeneJet
(Incyte). Piezojet delivery of 200-pl droplets provides a density of 2500 cDNA groups cm 2. Coupling of the cDNAs to the chip surface
occurs via a succinimidyl-ester-displacement reaction. Array elements, printed as adjacent 9 12 subgrids, correspond to human cDNAs
selected from the LifeSeq database (http://www.incyte.com/), which contains approximately three million annotated expressed sequence
tags. The fluorescent sample was prepared from cultured human THP-1 cells by biotin incorporation into antisense RNA, followed by
secondary labelling with Cy-5 conjugated streptavidin (Molecular Probes, Eugene, OR, USA). Fluorescent intensities, represented in a
pseudocolour scale, reflect gene-expression levels.