This document discusses differences between Turkish makam music and Arab music systems. It provides background on the development of the Turkish 29-tone system from earlier 24-tone systems. Some key differences noted are: 1) The Turkish system uses intervals smaller than quarter tones, while the Arab system is based mainly on quarter tones. 2) Turkish music allows for different performance styles ("attitudes") within a single makam, while Arab music does not. 3) Most makam and scale names originate from Arabic regions, though the systems have diverged.
This document discusses differences between Turkish makam music and Arab music systems. It provides background on the development of the Turkish 29-tone system from earlier 24-tone systems. Some key differences noted are: 1) The Turkish system uses intervals smaller than quarter tones, while the Arab system is based mainly on quarter tones. 2) Turkish music allows for different performance styles ("attitudes") within a single makam, while Arab music does not. 3) Most makam and scale names originate from Arabic regions, though the systems have diverged.
This document discusses differences between Turkish makam music and Arab music systems. It provides background on the development of the Turkish 29-tone system from earlier 24-tone systems. Some key differences noted are: 1) The Turkish system uses intervals smaller than quarter tones, while the Arab system is based mainly on quarter tones. 2) Turkish music allows for different performance styles ("attitudes") within a single makam, while Arab music does not. 3) Most makam and scale names originate from Arabic regions, though the systems have diverged.
This document discusses differences between Turkish makam music and Arab music systems. It provides background on the development of the Turkish 29-tone system from earlier 24-tone systems. Some key differences noted are: 1) The Turkish system uses intervals smaller than quarter tones, while the Arab system is based mainly on quarter tones. 2) Turkish music allows for different performance styles ("attitudes") within a single makam, while Arab music does not. 3) Most makam and scale names originate from Arabic regions, though the systems have diverged.
Turkish
Maqam
Music
is
a
unique
Near
Eastern
genre
founded
upon
the
crowning
achievements
in
art
and
the
culture
of
Islamic
Civizilation
,which
are
shared
by
Turks,Arabs,Persians,
and
Indians
alike.
Actually
Traditional
Turkish
Art
Muic
and
nowadays
Turkish
Art
Music
has
many
differences.
Today
we
are
using
29-tone
system
model.
How
we
find
this
29-tone
in
Turkish
Makam
Music?
Its
basically
:
between
them,
the
establishment
of
a
chain
of
five
natural(major)
big
3
fives
and
for
the
value
of
tradition
is
found
by
scanning..
In
the
tradition
system
we
used
for
24-tone
system
which
was
based
from
Arel-Ezgi- Uzdilek
system.
It
was
5
tone
less
and
in
system
had
many
fault.
They
nailed
some
makams
which
it
was
correct
in
theoretically
but
in
playing
some
makams
and
frequencies
was
crashing
between
each
other..
But
in
my
opinion
and
what
I
search
of
course,these
theorist/researcher/teachers
was
leading
the
Turkish
Art
Music
until
1930s..
Its
good
or
bad
they
grow
and
make
this
music
popular
on
their
time,thats
why
its
still
exist
and
popular
all
over
the
world..
I
would
like
to
continue
a
little
bit
more
specific
about
Makam
Music
with
some
details
and
numbers
then
I
would
like
to
say
a
bit
more
differences
between
Arab
and
Turkish
system.
In
modern
system,
we
divided
makams
basically
two
different
groups.
1-Simple
makams(
Basit
Makam
)
2-Compound
Makams(Birleik
Makam
)
Simple
Makams:
I
m
really
trying
to
tell
simple
way
of
simple
makam.
Simple
Makam;
it
consists
two
tetrachord.
First
tetrachord
has
4
notes,second
one
has
also
4
notes.
Basically
makam
music
can
seep
from
outside
with
their
Route
(in
Turkish
we
call
seyir)
Simple
makams
has
basically
goes
in
the
same
makam
and
goes
back
(sometime
one
way
or
return
)
Compound
Makams:
They
are
becoming
compound
with
minimum
2
different
makams
in
the
one
makam.
In
compound
makams
has
include
in
other
sub-topic
or
sub
makam
which
is
called
transposed
makam
.
Transposed
makams
which
as
the
name
implies
are
the
simple
makams
transposed
to
a
different
tonic.
As
I
see
and
research
some
theorists
are
count
transposed
makams
as
a
third
makam
but
many
of
them
also
make
it
into
compound
makams
sub-makam.
If
I
have
to
talk
more
with
number
in
makam
music.
Traditional
Turkish
Music
and
Arabic
music
based
on
and
common
with
frequency.
Big
difference
between
Western
Music
and
Makam
Music
is
;
Makam
music
uses
many
different
frequencies,western
music
nailed
tone
in
tampere.
But
still
Turkish
Makam
system
and
Arab
system
has
big
difference.
Arab
system
uses
mostly
quarter
tone
system
and
Turkish
music
has
less
than
quartet
tone
notes
in
the
makam
music.
Turkish
system
uses
less
frequency
than
Arabs.
This
makes
more
natural
and
more
possibilities
while
playing,
improvising.
(See
picture
1
below)
Also
in
Turkish
makam
music
even
between
differences
in
Turkish
players
while
playing.Some
areas
in
Turkey
,some
different
music
culture
in
Turkey
has
difference.This
makes
different
mood
even
in
the
same
makam
while
playing.
We
call
this
Attitude
(
Tavr
in
Turkish
)
.Same
makam
has
different
taksims,
perevs.
In
Arab
Makam
System
does
not
have
this
different
TAVIR
mood.
These
two
big
differences
shows
different
vibe
in
the
same
makam,music
quality.And
thats
why
it
divided
between
each
other,Turkish
Makam
and
Arab
Makam
music.
On
the
same
time
I
have
to
say
that,
almost
all
makams,scale
or
/and
tone
name
came
or
influence
from
Arabic
areas
to
the
Turkish
system(Persian,Iran,Suriye
etc.
)
(see
picture
2
below
)
PICTURE
1:
Turkish
system
divided
9
piece
in
one
major
2nd.
C#
C
D(re)
do
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
4.5
Koma
9
Koma
PICTURE
2:
Every
interval
has
100
cent.
On
octave
(8th
)
has
totally
1200
cent.
53
koma.
For
instance
C5-C6
is
1200
cent
and
53
koma
100
Cent
100
c
etc
1200
Cent.
C
C#
D
ETC.
C
12
TET
Of
course
this
is
really
really
huge
topic
and
I
have
to
say
many
things
about
Turkish
Traditional
and
Modern
Art
Music
(Makam
Music
)
but
I
really
tried
to
make
it
simple
.
Sorry
for
my
English,Its
also
really
hard
for
me
to
translate
my
Turkish
knowledge
about
this
complicated
topic
to
the
English
telling
Makam
Music.Some
terminology
,words
actually
not
nice
to
translate
into
the
English
In
Makam
Music
.But
I
tried
to
my
best.