SECOND LAW of Thermodynamics
SECOND LAW of Thermodynamics
SECOND LAW of Thermodynamics
The differences between the two forms of energy, heat and work, provide some insight into
the second law. In an energy balance both work and heat are included as simple additive terms,
implying that one unit of heat, a joule is equivalent to the same unit of work. Although this is true
with respect to an energy balance, experience teaches that there is a difference of kind between
heat and work.
Work is readily transformed into other forms of energy: for example, into potential energy
by elevation of weight, into kinetic energy by acceleration of a mass, into electrical energy by
operation of generator. These process can be made to approach a conversion efficiency of 100%
by elimination of friction, a dissipative process that transform work into heat. Indeed, work is
readily transformed completely into heat, as demonstrated by Joules experiments.
On the other hand, all efforts to devise a process for the continuous conversion of heat
completely into work or into mechanical or electrical energy have failed. Regardless of
improvements to the devices employed, conversion efficiencies do not exceed about 40%.
Evidently, heat is a form of energy intrinsically less useful and hence less valuable than an equal
quantity of work or mechanical or electrical energy.
Through our experiences, we know that the flow of heat between two bodies always takes
place from the hotter to the cooler body, and never in the reverse direction. This fact is of such
significance that its restatement serve as an acceptable expression of the second law.
Statement 1 does not say that heat cannot be converted into a work: only that the process cannot
leave both the system and its surroundings unchanged. If an ideal gas in a piston/cylinder assembly
expands reversibly and isothermally to a lower pressure. Example is equation 2.3, requires that
Ut = Q+W. For an ideal gas, Ut = 0, and therefore, Q = -W. The heat absorbed by the gas from
the surroundings is equal to the work transferred to the surroundings by the reversible expansion
of the gas. This might seem a contradiction of statement 1, because in the surroundings the result
is the complete conversion of heat into work. However this statement requires in addition no
change in the system, a requirement that is not met owing to change in pressure.
The process is limited in another way, because the pressure of the gas ultimately reaches that of
the surroundings and expansion ceases. Therefore the continuous production of work from heat
are impossible.
If the original state of the system is restored so as to comply with the requirements of statement 1,
energy from the surroundings in the form of work is needed to compress the gas back to its original
pressure.
At the same time energy as heat is transferred to the surroundings to maintain the constant
temperature.
This reverse process require at least the amount of work gained from the expansion; hence no
network is produced.
Evidently statement 1 may be expressed in an alternative way:
Statement 1a: It is impossible by a cyclic process to convert the heat absorbed by a system
completely into work done by the system.
The word cyclic requires that the system be restored periodically to its original state. In the case of
gas in a piston/cylinder assembly, an initial expansion may be followed by steps that restore the
original state, thus producing a complete cycle.
If the process is repeated, it becomes a cyclic process. The restriction to a cyclic process in a
statement, amounts to the same limitation as that introduced by the words only effect in statement
1.
Therefore, the second law of thermodynamics does not prohibit the production of work from feat,
but it does place a limit on how much of the heat directed into a cyclic process can be converted
into work done by the process.
With the exception of water and wind power, the partial conversion of heat into work is the basis
for nearly all commercial production of water. The development of a quantitative expression for
the efficiency of this conversion is the next in the treatment of the second law.
The second law of thermodynamics states that the total entropy of an isolated system can only
increase overtime. It can remain constant in ideal cases where the system is in steady state
(equilibrium) or undergoing a reversible process. The increase in entropy accounts for the
irreversibility of natural processes, and the asymmetry between future and past.
Historically, the second law was an empirical finding that was accepted as an axiom of
thermodynamic theory. Statistical thermodynamics, classical or quantum, explains the
microscopic origin of the law.
The second law has been expressed in many ways. Its first formulation is credited to the French
scientist Sadi Carnot in 1824, who showed that there is an upper limit to the efficiency of
conversion of heat to work in a heat engine.
The term entropy was first used by Rudolf Clasius to state the second law of
thermodynamics.
It is taken from a Greek word tropee which means transformation.
Defined as the quantitative measure of disorder or randomness in a system. The
concept comes out of thermodynamics, which deals with the transfer of heat energy
within a system.
Unit of measurement is J/K (Joule per degree Kelvin).
Entropy is denoted by S, while specific entropy is denoted by s in all
mathematical calculations.
delta-S = Q/T
In any reversible thermodynamic process, it can be represented in calculus as the
integral from a process initial state to its final state of dQ/T.
In a more general sense, entropy is a measure of probability and the molecular disorder
of a macroscopic system. In a system that can be described by variables, there are a
certain number of configurations those variables may assume. If each configuration is
equally probable, then the entropy is the natural logarithim of the number of
configurations, multiplied by Boltzmanns constant.
S=KB In W
therefore
(dS)iso 0
For a reversible process: (dS) iso = 0
Or
S = constant
For an irreversible process: dS) iso > 0 or entropy increases.
Thus it may be concluded that entropy of an isolated system can never decrease. It always
increases with every irreversible process and remains constant when the process is reversible.
This is known as principle of entropy increase or in other words the entropy of principle.
3.0 SAMPLE PROBLEMS
3.1 What is the change in entropy when 100 grams of ice at 0 o C melt into 100 grams of water
at 0 o C?
Solution:
Using the 8,000 calories calculated above and converting the temperature of 0 o C into 273 K,
we find temperature change in the heat of the system change in entropy =
3.2 Calculate the standard-state entropy of reaction for the following reactions and explain the
sign of S for each reaction.
Solution:
(a) Using a standard-state entropy data table, we find the following information:
Compound S(J/mol-K)
Hg(l) 76.02
Hg(s) 174.96
The balanced equation states that 1 mole of mercury vapor is produced for each mole of liquid
mercury that boils. The standard-state entropy of reaction is therefore calculated as follows:
So = So(products) - So(reactants)
= 98.94 J/K
The sign of So is positive because this process transforms a liquid into a gas, which is
inherently more disordered.
(b) Using a standard-state entropy data table, we find the following information:
Compound S(J/mol-K)
NO2(g) 240.06
N2O4(g) 304.29
In this equation, 1 mole of N2O4 is formed for every mole of NO2 consumed, and the value
of So is calculated as follows:
So = So(products) - So(reactants)
3.3 Determine if the entropy change will be positive or negative for the following reactions:
Solution:
Entropy of a reaction refers to the positional probabilities for each reactant. An atom in gas
phase has more options for position than the same atom in a solid phase. This is why gases
have more entropy than solids.
In reactions, the positional probabilities must be compared for all the reactants to the
products produced.
If the reaction involves only gases, the entropy is related to the total number of moles on
either side of the reaction. A decrease in the number of moles on the product side means
lower entropy. An increase in the number of moles on the product side means higher entropy.
If the reaction involves multiple phases, the production of a gas typically increases the
entropy much more than any increase in moles of a liquid or solid.
Reaction A
The reactant side contains only one mole where the product side has six moles produced.
The was also a gas produced. The change in entropy will be positive.
Reaction B
There are 3 moles on the reactant side and only 2 on the product side. The change in entropy
will be negative.
Reaction C
There are more moles on the product side than on the reactant side, therefore the change in
entropy will be positive.
ANSWERS:
= -175.83 J/K
The sign of So is negative because two molecules combine in this reaction to form a larger,
more ordered product.
(c) Using a standard-state entropy data table, we find the following information:
Compound S(J/mol-K)
NO(g) 210.76
N2(g) 191.61
O2(g) 205.14
The balanced equation for this reaction indicates that 2 mole of NO are produced when 1
mole of N2 reacts with 1 mole of O2 . Thus, the standard-state entropy of reaction is
calculated as follows:
So = So(products) - So(reactants)
205.14 J/mol-K]
= 24.77 J/K
So for this reaction is small but positive because the product of the reaction (NO) is slightly
more disordered that the reactants ( N2 and O2).
Q j
ds
m isi m ese s gen
m
dt Tj
Qj
s m s
gen
Tj
Entropy can be transferred to or from a system by two mechanisms: heat transfer and mass
flow. Note that no entropy is transferred by work.
Entropy can be transferred to or from a system by two mechanisms: heat transfer and mass
flow. Note that no entropy is transferred by work.
Heat transfer to a system increases the entropy of the system, and heat transfer out of a
system decreases the entropy of the system.
During a process 1-2 of a system as defined above, If heat transfer Q happens at the system
boundary which has an absolute temperature T, the entropy transfer associated with this heat
transfer process is
If the entire boundary temperature remains as a constant T, the above equation can be
simplified as
Sheat = Q/T
When the temperature T is not a constant, but a function of its location, the entropy
change can be approximated as
where
Qk = heat transfer at boundary location k
Tk = temperature at boundary location k
6.2 Mass Transfer
Mass contains entropy as well as energy. Mass m, which has a specific entropy s, contains
a total entropy of ms. When a mass flows in a system, the entropy increase in the system
is ms. In the same manner, mass m flowing out of a system will result in a decrease of
entropy in amount of ms in the system.
Smass = ms
Assumptions:
1 The water in the pistoncylinder assembly is a closed system.
2 There is no heat transfer with the surroundings.
3 The system is at an equilibrium state initially and finally. PE = KE = 0.
Solution:
The network can be calculated by using the law:
U + KE + PE = Q W
That is simplifies to:
U = W
Using an entropy balance, the amount of entropy produced can be found. Since there is
no heat transfer,
Using Table A4
Sgen / m = 6.048 kJ / kg.K Ans.
6.2 Steam enters a turbine with a pressure of 3 MPa, a temperature of 400 C, and a
velocity of 160 m/s. Saturated vapor at 100 C exits with a velocity of 100 m/s. At
steadystate, the turbine develops work equal to 540 kJ/kg. Heat transfer between the
turbine and its surroundings occur at an average outer surface temperature of 350 K.
Determine the rate at which entropy is produced within the turbine per kg of steam
flowing, in kJ/kg.K. Neglect the change in potential energy between inlet and exit.
Assumptions:
1 Steady state operation in CV. PE = 0.
2 Turbine outer surface is at a specified average temperature.
Solution:
From the mass balance, we know that m = m1 = m2
Since the process is steadystate, one can write:
The heat transfer occurs at Tb = 350 K, the first term of the right hand side of the entropy
balance reduces to Q/ Tb
We need to calculate the rate of heat transfer. The first law (energy balance) can be used
to find the heat transfer rate. Combining the mass balance and the first law, one finds:
From Table A6, h1 = 3230.9 kJ/kg, and From A4 h2 = 2676.1 kJ/kg. After substitution,
and converting the units, one finds:
22.6 kJ / kg
From Table A4, s2 = 7.3549 kJ/kg.K and from Table A6, s1 = 6.9212 kJ/kg.K. Inserting
values into the expression for entropy production:
0.4983 kJ / kg Ans.
References:
Engineering Thermodynamics by P K Nag
https://www.thoughtco.com/entropy-definition-calculation-and-misconceptions-2698977
https://www.thoughtco.com/entropy-change-problem-609481
http://petrowiki.org/Second_law_of_thermodynamics
http://www.mdpi.com/journal/entropy
II. HEAT ENGINES AND REFRIGERATORS
A heat engine is composed of a high internal energy (high temperature) reservoir and a low
internal energy reservoir. The flow of heat from the high temperature reservoir to the low
temperature reservoir is used to do mechanical work. It's kind of like how the flow of water
downstream turns the wheel of a watermill, but not nearly as picturesque.
A basic heat engine consists of a gas confined by a piston in a cylinder. If the gas is heated,
it expands, moving the piston. This wouldn't be a particularly practical engine, though, because
once the gas reaches equilibrium the motion would stop. A practical engine goes through cycles;
the piston has to move back and forth. Once the gas is heated, moving the piston up, it can be
cooled and the piston will move back down. A cycle of heating and cooling will move the piston
up and down.
A necessary component of a heat engine, then, is that two temperatures are involved. At one
stage the system is heated, at another it is cooled.
1. Heat is added. This is at a relatively high temperature, so the heat can be called QH.
2. Some of the energy from that input heat is used to perform work (W).
3. The rest of the heat is removed at a relatively cold temperature (QC)
An important measure of a heat engine is its efficiency: how much of the input energy ends
up doing useful work? The efficiency is calculated as a fraction (although it is often stated as a
percentage):
Work is just the input heat minus the rejected heat, so:
e = (QH-QC) / QH = 1- QC /QH
Note that this is the maximum possible efficiency for an engine. In reality there will be other losses
(to friction, for example) that will reduce the efficiency.
It must operate using reversible processes: a reversible process is one in which the system
and the surroundings can be returned to state they were in before the process began. If energy is
lost to friction during a process, the process is irreversible; if energy is lost as heat flows from a
hot region to a cooler region, the process is irreversible. The efficiency of an engine using
irreversible processes can not be greater than the efficiency of an engine using reversible processes
that is working between the same temperatures. This is known as Carnot's principle, named after
Sadi Carnot, a French engineer.
The Carnot cycle can be thought of as the most efficient heat engine cycle allowed by
physical laws. It consists of two isothermal processes and two adiabatic processes. When
the second law of thermodynamics states that not all the supplied heat in a heat engine can be used
to do work, the Carnot efficiency sets the limiting value on the fraction of the heat which can be
so used.
In order to approach the Carnot efficiency, the processes involved in the heat engine cycle
must be reversible and involve no change in entropy. This means that the Carnot cycle is an
idealization, since no real engine processes are reversible and all real physical processes involve
some increase in entropy.
For the ideal case of the Carnot cycle, this efficiency can be written
The second law of thermodynamics says that heat can flow from high temperature
reservoir to low temperature reservoir only, however, if you want to move the heat from low
temperature to high temperature reservoir, then the external work has be supplied.
Refrigerators are devices that will transfer heat from a low temperature environment to a
high temperature environment. Normally, heat will only flow from a hotter environment to a
colder environment. This makes it seem like the concept of a refrigerator breaks the second law
of thermodynamics.
From the diagram it can be seen that a refrigerator consist of four basic components. These are:
-a compressor
-a condenser
-an expansion valve (also known as a throttling valve)
-an evaporator.
3.2 A Carnot cycle operates between thermal reservoirs at 55C and 560C. Calculate the
COP if it is a refrigerator. Determine if the COP is good or bad. Explain.
3.3 In the set-up, the heat lost is 25000kJ/kg and the COP is 1.6. Find
the net work in MW.
q - w = dh + dke + dpe
One-inlet-one-exit Nozzle
If the device undergoes an internally
reversible process, the heat transfer term q
can be replaced by dh - vdP since
qrev = Tds
Tds = dh - vdP (the second Tds relation)
Thus,
What is known:
Question
Approach
Assumptions:
where
P2 = 1.0 bar
= 1,000,000 W
1,000,000 = 1,029,000
= 0.97 m3/s
N= = 0.97/0.196 = 5
Schematic of a Compressor
C = Reversible isothermal
compressor work/Actual compressor
work
= wt/wa
Problem No. 4
What is known:
Approach
Solution:
A used pump must match the motor in Mr.
Williams' swimming pool. The power
required to run the pump needs to be
determined.
Assumptions:
v = 0.001 m3/kg
P2 - P1 = 300 kPa
Substituting the given efficiency, which is
85%, and the pressure difference above to
the definition of isentropic efficiency
gives,
h2 - h1 = v(P2 - P1)/ P
= 0.001(300,000)/0.85 = 352.9
J/kg
= -20/60(352.9) = -117.6 W