Project Report of Idea
Project Report of Idea
Project Report of Idea
1.1 OBJECTIVE
The objective of this document is to give a brief overview of the Global System of Mobile
Communication (GSM) and describe in detail the RF design consideration, methodology
and RF simulation results for the coverage area of a Model City and. RF design parameters
that are considered are described in this report and results of the simulations conducted to
ascertain coverage are also included.
1.2 INTRODUCTION
The GSM system design process consists of several levels or phases. These levels range
from an initial budgetary design to a final design used to implement the system. The amount
of time and effort required to complete a design increases as one moves from a budgetary
design to a final design. However, this additional time and effort results in a more accurate
system design & predictions.
The design of a wireless system revolves around three main requirements. Those principles
are coverage, capacity and quality and all three of these quantities are interrelated.
• The coverage of a system relates to the area within the network that has sufficient signal
strength to provide for a call of acceptable quality.
• The capacity of a system relates to the ability of the system to support a given number of
users
• The quality of the system reflects the degree of naturalism or reproduction of speech &
data and ease of two-way communication
This report starts with an overview of the GSM 900 network. It is worth mentioning that DCS
1800 is also a part of the GSM standard. Hence the general concepts of GSM 900 can also
be applied to DCS 1800. In India both these systems are used either separately or together.
In this report GSM is explained using the GSM 900 and then a shift is gradually made to the
1800 band.
2 INTRODUCTION TO GSM
Global System for Mobile Communication (GSM)
2.1 Definition
Global system for mobile communication (GSM) is a globally accepted standard for digital
cellular communication. GSM is the name of a standardization group established in 1982 to
create a common European mobile telephone standard that would formulate specifications
for a pan-European mobile cellular radio system operating at 900 MHz. It is estimated that
many countries outside of Europe will join the GSM partnership.
2.2 Introduction
The concept of cellular service is the use of low-power transmitters where frequencies can
be reused within a geographic area. The idea of cell-based mobile radio service was
formulated in the United States at Bell Labs in the early 1970s. However, the Nordic
countries were the first to introduce cellular services for commercial use with the introduction
of the Nordic Mobile Telephone (NMT) in 1981.
At this moment it would be important to mention here the need to use a lower frequency for
uplink. The reason is, since this carries the information from the MS to the BTS over the Air
Interface, using a higher frequency means higher attenuation. Secondly to compensate for
the attenuation we need to send the signal at a higher power, which consumes more battery,
power and leading to a smaller talk time.
Each carrier frequency is then divided according to time using a TDMA scheme. Each of the
carrier frequencies is divided into a 120ms multiframe. A multiframe is made up of 26 frames.
Two of these frames are used for control purposes, while the remaining 24 frames are used
for traffic as shown below.
Speech Coder: Rapid Pulse Excitation linear Predictive Coder coding at 13kbps
In modern landline telephone systems, digital coding is used. The electrical variations
induced into the microphone are sampled and each sample is then converted into a digital
code. The voice waveform is then sampled at a rate of 8 kHz. Each sample is then converted
into an 8 bit binary number representing 256 distinct values. Since we sample 8000 times
per second and each sample is 8 binary bits, we have a bit rate of 8kHz X 8 bits = 64kbps.
This bit rate is unrealistic to transmit across a radio network since interference will likely ruin
the transmitted waveform. In GSM speech encoding works to compress the speech
waveform into a sample that results in a lower bit rate using RPE-LPC. The actual process
will be discussed later in the section, where the journey from speech to radio waves is
considered.
Over The Channel Bit Rate: 22.8kbps
These were a few of the specification that were described by GSM for the network. However
the MS manufactures also had to adhere to certain specific standards which are discussed
as below: There are various types of mobile handsets that are used, namely:
1. Vehicle Mounted: Attached to a vehicle and operate on all power ranges and the
antenna is physically mounted on the vehicle.
2. Portable: This equipment can be hand carried or vehicle mounted and the antenna is
not connected to the Mobile Termination unit, which is MS minus the antenna.
3. Hand-held: This is the normal piece of equipment that we see generally being carried by
people.
E-GSM: This represents an extension of the lower end of the two sub blocks by
10MHz adding 50 More ARFCN’s to the Primary GSM (P-GSM).
Uplink Frequency: 880MHz-915MHz
Downlink Frequency: 925MHz-960MHz
DCS 1800: At a late stage in GSM development the existing technology was modified to
meet the need for PCN networks. This involves changes to the radio interface, which
moves spectrum allocation up to around 1.8 GHz. More spectrum is available in this
frequency range, for two sub-blocks of 75Mhz with duplex spacing of 95Mhz, giving a
total of 374 carriers.
Uplink Frequency: 1710Mhz-1785Mhz
Downlink Frequency: 1805Mhz-1880Mhz
PCS 1900: Used in the USA. The FCC has split the designated spectrum into six duplex
blocks. The USA has been divided into 51 Major Trading Areas and 493 Basic Trading
Areas. An MTA is broadly equivalent in size to a state, whilst a BTA approximates to a
large city. Each MTA has access to 3x15MHz block and each BTA has access to
3x5MHz blocks.
GSM is divided into two separate entities the Switching System (SS) and the Base Station
System. Each of these contains a number of functional units, where all systems functions
are realised. These functional units are implemented into various hardware components.
Functional units within the system are separated by interfaces. Such interfaces are the Air
interface (MS-BSS), the Abis interface (BTS-BSC) and the A interface (BSC-MSC). However
before undertaking to study the main functional components a brief overview of the complete
system is deemed necessary.
Databases
The above-mentioned units are all involved in carrying out speech connections between an
MS and for example a subscriber in a PSTN. If it were not for the possibility of making calls
to an MS we would not need any further equipment. The problem arises when we want to
make an MS terminated call. The originator hardly ever knows where the called MS is. Due
to this we need a number of databases in the network to keep track of the MS.
The most important of these databases is the Home Location Register (HLR). When
someone buys a subscription from one of the GSM operators, he will be registered in the
HLR of that operator; he will be registered in the HLR of that operator. The HLR contains
subscriber information, such as supplementary services and authentication parameters.
Furthermore, there will be information about the location of the MS, i.e. in which MSC area
the MS resides presently. This information changes as the MS moves around. The MS will
send location information to its HLR, thus providing means to make a call.
Authentication Centre (AUC) is connected to the HLR. The function of the AUC is provided
the HLR with authentication parameters and ciphering keys, both used for security reasons.
AUC provides authentication and encryption parameters that verify the user's identity and
ensure the confidentiality of each call. The AUC protects network operators from different
types of fraud found in today's cellular world.
The Visitor Location Register is a database containing information about all the MS’s
currently located in the MSC area. As soon as an MS roams into a new MSC area, the VLR
connected to that MSC would request data about the MS from the HLR. At the same time the
HLR will be informed in which MSC area the MS resides. If, later on the MS wants to make a
call, the VLR will have the information needed for the call set-up without having to interrogate
the HLR each time. The VLR can be seen as a distributed HLR. The VLR will also contain
more exact information about the location of the MS in the MSC area. The VLR is a database
that contains temporary information about subscribers that is needed by the MSC in order to
service visiting subscribers. The VLR is always integrated with the MSC. When a mobile
station roams into a new MSC area, the VLR connected to that MSC would request data
about the mobile station from the HLR. Later, if the mobile station makes a call, the VLR will
have the information needed for call set-up without having to interrogate the HLR each time.
Gateway
A gateway is a node used to interconnect two networks. The gateway is often implemented
in an MSC. The MSC is then referred to as the GMSC. If someone in a fixed network (PSTN)
wants to make a call to a GSM subscribe, the exchange in the PSTN will connect the call to
a gateway. The gateway is often realised in an MSC. It can be any one of the MSC in the
GSM network. The GMSC will have to find the location of the searched MS; interrogating the
HLR where the MS is registered can do this. The HLR will reply with the address to the
current MSC area. Now the GMSC can re-route the call of the current MSC. When the call
reaches that MSC, then the VLR will know in more detail where the MS is. The call can then
switched through.
Mobile Station
In GSM there is a difference between the physical equipment and the subscription. The
mobile station is piece of equipment, which can be vehicle installed, portable or hand-held. In
GSM there is a small unit called the Subscriber Identity Module (SIM), which is a separate
physical entity e.g. an IC-card, also called a smart card. SIM and the mobile equipment
together make up the mobile station. Without SIM, the MS cannot get access to the GSM
network, except for emergency traffic. While the SIM-card is connected to the subscription
and not to the MS, the subscriber can use another MS as well as his own. This then raises
the problem of stolen MS’, since it is no use barring the subscription if the equipment is
stolen. We need a database that contains the unique hardware identity of the equipment, the
Equipment Identity Register (EIR). The EIR is connected to the MSC over a signalling link.
This enables the MSC to check the validity of the equipment. An non-type-approved MS can
also be barred in this way. The authentication of the subscription is done by parameters from
AUC.
The Cell
A location area is divided into a number of cells. The cell is an area of radio coverage, which
the network identifies with the Cell Global Identity (CGI). The mobile station itself
distinguishes between cells using the same carrier frequencies by the use of the Base
Station Identity Code (BSCI).
Before we go on to discuss the various channels in GSM, it would be mandatory to list out all
the channels that are used in GSM communication.
Physical Channel
Logical Channel
Control Channel
• Broadcast Channels
• Common Control Channels
• Dedicated Control Channels
Traffic Channel
Random Access Channel: If listening to the PCH, the MS realises it is being paged.
The MS answers, requesting a signalling channel, on the random access channel,
RACH. RACH can also be used if the MS wants to get in contact with the network,
e.g. when setting up a call. RACH is transmitted on the uplink point-to-point.
Access Grant Channel: The network assigns a signalling channel (the stand alone
dedicated channel, SDCCH). This assignment is performed on the Access Grant
Channel, AGCH. AGCH is transmitted on the downlink, point-to-point.
3 INTRODUCTION TO PROPAGATION
3.1 PROPAGATION is a key process within every radio link. During propagation, many
processes act on the radio signal.
3.2 ATTENUATION
The signal amplitude is reduced by various natural mechanisms; if there is too much
attenuation, the signal will fall below the reliable detection threshold at the receiver.
Attenuation is the most important single factor in propagation.
INFLUENCE OF WAVELENGTH
ON PROPAGATION
The wavelength of a radio signal determines many of its propagation characteristics eg:
• Antenna elements size are typically in the order of 1/4 to1/2 wavelength.
• Objects bigger than a wavelength can reflect or obstruct RF energy.
• RF energy can penetrate into a building or vehicle if they have apertures a
wavelength in size, or larger.
Therefore, space diversity is applied only on the “uplink”, i.e. reverse path
• There isn’t room for two sufficiently separated antennas on a mobile or handheld.
Antenna pair within one casing can be V-H polarized, or diagonally polarized
duplexing OK
Between two antennas, on the same exact frequency, path loss is the same in both
directions
1. Reduce Interference
2. Prevent “Overshoot”
• Improve coverage of nearby targets far below the antenna otherwise within
null” of antenna pattern
4 RF Planning
4.1RF PLANNING
The GSM/DCS system design process consists of several levels or phases. These levels
range from an initial budgetary design to a final design used to implement the system. The
amount of time and effort required to complete a design increases as one moves from a
budgetary design to a final design. However, this additional time and effort results in a more
accurate system design & predictions.
The design of a wireless system revolves around three main criteria. Those principles are
coverage, capacity and quality and all three of these quantities are interrelated.
Initially, neither the capacity nor the coverage requirements are known to the planners. The
planning is based on projections given by the customer. The customers may specify the
maximum number of sites they desire in the city or the total number of subscribers that need
to be catered to. Based on either of these inputs the planning process begins.
City survey report is procured from the map vendors. It comprises of the following:
1. Map
2. Land use cover
3. Heights
4. Vectors
This data is then fed into the NetPlan tool.
4.2.1Link Budget
Link budget spreadsheet is used to make the "first attempt" at system design. The link
budget provides an estimate of the cell radius for a given coverage reliability and thus
provides an estimate of the number of cells required to cover a certain area.
Mobile
• Transmit Power = 1 watt (30 dBm)
• Sensitivity = -102 dBm
• Body Loss = 3dB
• Tx/Rx Antenna Gain = 0 dBi
• Cable Loss = 3 dB
Base Station
• Transmit Power = 16 watt (42dBm +/-1 dBm )
• Sensitivity = -110dBm (This is the typical sensitivity of nokia BTS)
• Tx/Rx Gain = 17.0/18 dBi
• Diversity Gain = 3 dB
• Cable Loss (Feeder) = 3 dB (This is of course is dependent on the length of
the feeder which varies from site to site depending on the height the antenna is
mounted, but here an approximation has been made)
• Interference Degradation Margin = 3 dB (This is margin for other interference
sources)
Allowable Path Loss = [MS transmit power – Body Loss] – [BTS Sensitivity + BTS Cable
Loss – BTS Receive antenna gain – Diversity gain + Duplexer loss + Fading Margin +
Interference degradation margin]
Once provided with the map and the population density, the process involves selection on
the basis of the following considerations:
Population density in the area
Type of Land clutter
• Dense Urban
• Urban
• Suburban
• Suburban with dense vegetation
• Rural
• Industrial area
• Utilities (marshalling yards, docks, container depots etc.)
• Quasi open area
• Forest
• Water
Significance of area (markets, business center, airport, VIP areas etc.)
Permission to install site
For this design, the k739495 (Kathereine) antenna was chosen, which has the following
specifications:
• Gain of 15.85 dBd
• Horizontal Beam width of 65o
• Vertical Beam width of 7 o
• Less power radiation from the back lobe of the antenna
• Electrical tilt of 0 o , 2 o
Antenna parameters of height, orientation and tilt are so chosen to obtain the best possible
coverage with the least possible signal suppression.
Height: Height ranges from 20m to 30m (for rooftop antennas) and 35m to 50m (for ground
base towers) depending upon the height of clutter and the area in vicinity.
Orientation: Orientation of the antennas is the direction at which the specified area to be
covered. The orientation angle for the sectors is taken in the clockwise direction considering
north as the reference at 0°.
Tilt: This is done to carry out the process of either decreasing or increasing the coverage
area of a sector. This is done to avoid interference arising out of the fact that the sector
under consideration is radiating out of the desired area of its coverage and hence affecting
other neighboring sectors.
Tilt is given by the following means:
• Electrical tilt: This tilt is given by changing the phase relations in between various
elements of an antenna. If a down tilt is being given electrically, then there will be
a down tilt in both the front and the back lobe of the antenna.
• Mechanical tilt: This tilt is given manually by changing the angle antenna makes
with the vertical. If a down tilt is being given mechanically, then there will be a
down tilt in the front lobe but an up tilt in the backlobe.
Mechanical tilt is more often used than electrical tilt.
After simulating the above inputs planning tool can be used to generate various images to
check the resultant network. Some of the important images that are used to analyze the
network are as follows:
• Downlink best Server/Sector: Different antennas of the site are called sectors. With
the help of this image an RF engineer can visualize the amount of signal that is being
released by each sector of the site.
The initial stage of planning and designing the network is followed by a second stage of
optimization of network.
For example, let there be 12 sites with 3 sectors each and channels given be 12 (32 to 43),
then we categorize channels as follows:
A1 A2 A3 A4
32 33 34 35
36 37 38 39
40 41 42 43
Now allocation is done so that the antennas of a particular site are allotted channels from
one group out of A1, A2, A3 and A4.
Once the frequency planning is over, the next step is neighbour planning. A mobile station
keeps track of its six nearby BTS so that it can undergo Handover when required.
Now of the numerous BTS sites that a mobile station may be looking at, we have to define at
least six neighbours, i.e. the most probable BTS to which a call handover process may take
place.
This process of defining the handover candidates is called as Neighbour Planning.
Main considerations-:
1. The neighbouring cell must be neither a Co-channel nor an Adjacent channel to our
serving cell.
2. The handover candidate of first layer (generally in city center and urban areas) is not
very far (600-1000m) from the mobile station as the signal strength is very important
for successful handover.
3. Second and third layers candidates (for less urban and suburban areas) are also
marked, though they are a little far (1000-6000m) but that is just to avoid congestion
in the network at certain times.
4. Also in outskirts of cities and on highways the handover candidates can be as far as
10km or more.
However as the losses in case of 1800 MHz network is more , the cell radius decreases
considerably , thus the above stated values for neighbor site distance also decreases and is
approximately half of that in a 900MHz network.
Idea cellular Pvt. Ltd. has emerged as the global leader in Radio Frequency (RF) Planning
for the Cellular operators. This is carried out using the highly acclaimed idea RF planning
tool namely “Network Planning (Netact Plan)” tool which is based on Sun Solaris platform.
The planning tool takes input data in the form of land use cover sets, heights and vectors
(roads and railways etc) from vendors and follows already fed in path loss algorithms to
simulate a virtual network based on which real time networks are implemented.
Radio frequency planning is carried out using the idea proprietary Netact Plan tool.
This tool enables RF Engineers to carry out exhaustive analysis prior to actual installation of
network components, which are Base Transceiver Stations (BTS). Its fruitions are evident
from the overwhelming response Nokia receives from cellular operators worldwide.
Once data has been procured in the form of land use cover sets, heights and vectors from
vendors, the ideaRF team can provide efficient and good capacity network based on the
customer requirement.
An overview how to use this tool for planning a MODEL CITY is given below:
• Clutter
• Elevation
• Vectors (roads etc)
Identify the areas for sites to be placed on the basis of user density
The next step involves studying the clutter data so that sites could be placed on the map of
the city.
The downlink signal strength in the coverage area should be –90 dbm or better in 90% of the
coverage area.
In order to define predicted signal strength in outdoors, following values may be
considered for penetration loss of different clutter profiles:
The following figure shows the clutter (i.e, type of population in a particular area).
Once the sites are placed with all the antenna parameters the image of this analysis is
created so as to have an idea of the predicted coverage in the city
Here the image is being created using the XLOS Propagation model that is a proprietary of
Nokia and gives fairly accurate results . Extensive resources have been employed to test,
calibrate and validate the accuracy of the algorithms of Xlos. To provide maximum flexibility
when conducting certain propagation studies, Netact Plan also incorporates the COST 231
Hata, Walfish-Ikegami, and JTC Microcell propagation models.
Due to the complexities of simulating real world phenomena, no prediction model will be
completely accurate all of the time, thus Netact Plan has some additional features like:
Fig: Creating the Downlink Best Signal Strength Image (Courtesy Nokia)
Fig: The beginning and end of creation of the image for best signal strength.(Courtesy Nokia)
Fig: The Coverage Plot with Sites and Map (Courtesy Nokia)
The various site parameters can be viewed and modified if required. These
include -:
• Latitude
• Longitude
• Site Id
• Site Name
• Antenna Model
• Antenna height ,bore and tilt
• Parameter set that defines Propagation Model, and other losses etc.
o Though we can go for automatic frequency plan but as it suffers from few
limitations, we plan it manually and then feed it in NetPlan.
o The frequencies are loaded as ARFCNs and then they can be marked as
BCCH and also they are locked so as to prevent any accidental change in
the frequencies assigned.
Fig: A typical channel assigner Window with the Network Analysis window (courtesy Nokia)
Once we have assigned the frequencies to the various sites we can easily take a look at
Co-Channel
Adjacent Channel Channels along with
The handover Candidates for any site.
Fig: Sites with Frequencies along with the Co-Channel and Adjacent Channels marked in
Red and Yellow while handover Candidates are in Blue.
Once we have assigned frequencies to the sites we can also go for generating Co Channel
and Adjacent Channel C/I image.
The image thus created gives us a fair idea about the areas at which we have interference
so that we could mark those areas and induce the necessary changes in the frequency plan.
Generally the search ring for a site in city center is about 50m and outside the city it is up to
150m. If we go beyond that, there is a probability that what we predicted would not be
available to us on the field
For site surveys and feasibility of a location there is a site survey form that gives us a fair
idea about the situation at a particular site.
During site survey the engineer locates the best building or plot where a tower can be put
and then a detailed survey of the surrounding area is done and compiled. A sample RF
survey form is depicted here to give a better understanding of the whole procedure.
After the survey is complete and compiled then the acquisition team has the responsibility to
proceed with the legal formalities regarding the acquisition of the building or plot . Various
requirements such as the strength of the building etc. must also be taken into account .
After the survey and acquisition is complete then the construction of the tower and tower
shelter starts . The BTS is installed and commissioned. Various sites are linked with each
other using microwave links or fiber cables.
Once the sites have been commissioned and interconnected to the BSC the are made to
radiate. The site is then said to be on air
4.6 RF Optimization :
Once the sites are acquired and everything installed, the next most important process is that
of optimization.
I Optimization is done to check the performance of the network, just after it is made
operational and to get best possible quality of service. The objective of optimisation
procedure is:
a) To check whether the network meets the customer’s given requirements, on the basis of
which network was designed.
b) To check whether the parameters and configurations are defined correctly or not.
c) To find out and suggest changes in the defined parameters and configurations to achieve
best possible quality of service.
Drive Test system comprises of a test mobile phone, software to control and log data from
the phone and a Global positioning system receiver for position information as shown in
figure (1). A drive test system can only indicate the type of problem in the network that exists,
it doesn’t indicate cause of the problem but with the help of knowledge of possible reasons of
a problem, one can trace the cause. Following steps are taken to fulfill the objective of
network optimization using a drive test tool.
Drive test involves setting up a call to best carrier and driving along the roads. While driving
the radio parameters and air interference signal data are collected as a log file. In general
following parameters are checked during the drive test for different categories of terrains like
dense urban, sub-urban, rural, highways and for different clutters like in building, residential
areas, commercial areas, industrial areas etc.
1. Rx Level.
2. Rx Quality
3. Timing Advance
4. Handover parameters
5. Data of six best neighbor cells.
6. Layer 2 and layer 3 messages.
From the data collected various information can be extracted which depict the performance
of BTS sites and the network as a whole. Following information can be extracted from this
drive test data.
Edge Probability:
To get an idea of coverage area, coverage boundary of all the cells based on received signal
level (RXLEV), is obtained and is plotted over the geographical map of the area. The
coverage boundary of a cell is considered to be made up of equal received level points on
the field.
With the help of this coverage plot the edge probability or the probability of getting a signal
level better than a specific value over the boundary of all cells is obtained which helps in
determining the performance of the network with respect to coverage boundary requirements
given by the customer.
Area Probability:
The obtained signal levels from the cells at all the points of the network, are then used to
make, a best server plot. This best server plot is drawn by categorizing it on the basis of in
building coverage, in car coverage and on street coverage. These categories are defined on
the basis of the coverage area where a good quality conversation is required. The details
about threshold defined for these categories are discussed in ‘coverage planning report’.
Speech Quality:
Speech quality is a very important aspect for determining the quality of service for whole of
the network. Speech quality is inferred by the RXQUAL measurements during the drive test.
RXQUAL, is the Bit error rate (BER) derived from the 26 bits midamble on TDMA burst. Its
level characterizes speech quality where 0 indicates the highest quality and 7 the worst.
Thus during drive test, poor quality areas can be found and marked by looking over the
quality on the scale of 0 to 7. RXQUAL can be poor due to poor RXLEV, Co-channel
interference, adjacent channel interference or multi-path. RXQUAL is measured and tested
for all the categories of clutter and terrain.
With the help of collected data 6 best serving neighbours of all the cells can be determined.
The drive test window of the antenna system gives details of 6 best neighbors at an
instance.
Handover details:
There are certain other very important parameters which has to be checked during drive test
as these parameters directly reflects on the performance of the network, like handover
margin, handover threshold, values of handover timers, offset and penalty for the handovers.
With a call established, and measuring on the cell edge, we can display the phone
measurements of serving and neighbor cells. The difference between the RXLEV of the
server and that of neighbors can be monitored on the amplitude and time scale. At some
point on the drive-test route, one of the neighbor’s RXLEV will become stronger than the
server’s signal level and when this difference of the two exceeds the handover margin, for at
least a timing set in the ‘handover required’ counter in BSS, a handover will occur. Thus by
simultaneously monitoring RXQUAL during the handover, the value of the handover margin
can be determined and a decision can be made whether that value is appropriate for the
quality of service desired.
The information extracted from the collected data is then analyzed to compare it with the
agreed benchmarks related to coverage, quality, handover success rate etc and is used to
infer the cause of the deviation from given requirements and set benchmarks. It is also used
to infer cause of detected problem in the network if there is any.
There are special coverage requirement which are discussed in ‘coverage planning report’
under ‘special coverage category’ these specific coverage requirements are matched to find
out whether the requirement of customer is taken care of or not.
RXQUAL is also matched with the given requirement. If RXQUAL is poor and RXLEV is
sufficiently good it can reasonably be deducted that the cause is interference. Generally a
test frequency which has no adjacent or Co channel present in that area is used to find out if
interference is because of multi-path. If it is not because of multi-path then spectrum
analyzer can be used to find out whether it is adjacent channel interference or it can be
deducted that it is Co channel interference.
A handover margin on the high side will result in a handover occurring after the user has
experienced some deterioration in quality. High handover margins can result in poor
reception and dropped calls, while very low values of handover margin can produce “Ping-
Pong” effects as mobile switches too often between cells.
With the help of collected data it can be found out weather uplink and downlink are balanced
or not. If even after having good RXLEV and RXQUAL, calls are dropping or even when
RXLEV and RXQUAL of serving cell is better than that of neighbor cell, handover is taking
place, it indicates that the link needs to be balanced.
BSIC for all the cells are also checked and verified with what is defined in the BSS. If same
BSIC is defined for cells having same BCCH frequency and these cells coexist in the
neighbor list then understandably lot of handovers will be unsuccessful.
Layer 2 and 3 messages can be used for analyzing cause of a particular handover failure,
call drop, very poor speech quality or any other abnormality in the performance of the
network.
After detection of the causes of the deviation from the requirement or network related
problems, measures are taken to improve the performance of the network and to match
customer’s requirement.
Hard Configuration:
The hard configuration parameters are aspects of base station configuration and include
antenna type, antenna gain, antenna orientation, and effective height of antenna radiation
centre, use of space diversity, antenna feeder loss and effective isotropic radiated power
(EIRP).
Changes in this configuration are made to meet the requirements and to deal with the
analyzed problems. For an example if certain area is affected by interference resulting in
poor quality then one of the way to reduce interference level is by shrinking the coverage
area. Shrinking of coverage area can be achieved by reducing EIRP that is by replacing the
existing antenna with a lower gain or narrower horizontal beam width antenna system and by
reducing transmitted power under limitation of not loosing the link balance. Most effective
solution used to shrink coverage area is by increasing antenna down tilt and/or reducing
antenna height. Similarly to improve coverage in certain areas the transmitted power of BTS
can be changed, antennas with different gain or beam width can be used and the height of
antenna system can be changed.
For further specific coverage and quality requirements Pico or micro cells can be installed
inside the residential places, commercial buildings, stadiums and car parks etc. A pico cell is
nothing but a cell with very low EIRP in comparison to a Macro Cell. Note that the neighbor
list for these pico cells is defined differently than that for normal Macro cells. Micro cell has
also got lesser coverage area than that of Macro cells.
Repeaters can also be used for providing coverage to specific areas. There can be Channel
selective or Band selective Repeaters where band selective repeaters amplifies the whole
GSM band and transmit it towards the area required to be covered while channel selective
repeaters receive power from selected channels of one or more than one parent cells,
amplify it and direct it towards the area required to be covered. In the similar way if capacity
requirement of certain area is more, then the coverage of a cell is to be compressed by any
of the means discussed above so that it may cater to lesser number of customers.
If the mentioned measures don’t work for matching coverage and capacity requirement then
relocation or addition of site can also be suggested. If interference is observed during drive
test then apart from reducing coverage area, frequency plan for the network can be
redefined and reuse distances can be increased.
After carefully studying the statistical data about the network performance if it is found that
congestion for some particular sites are more and call successful rate is less, then more
resources (TRX) can be added to improve availability of the traffic channels or additional
BTS sites can also be added but this addition has a limit because of limited available
frequency spectrum hence with higher number of sites or frequency used, reuse distance of
the sites will reduce which will increase interference and hence the quality will go poorer.
There are lots of other ways by which capacity can be increased without much affecting the
speech quality.
Every time TRXs are added in the network, frequency plan of the network or a portion of the
network has to be changed which will further require to analyze the network using drive test
system, to monitor the network’s performance. It is possible that after addition of certain
TRXs frequency reuse distance will decrease to such a level that it will introduce
unacceptable amount of interference and deployed frequency plan will require to be
redefined.
Soft Configurations:
Other parts of the system can be controlled with soft parameters. These affect operation of
algorithms within the system, and include categories such as common BTS parameters, cell
access parameters etc. GSM defines around 150 soft parameters. For an example if it is
found from the BSS statistics details that excessive handovers hence more utilization of
resources is taking place then reduction of overlap of the cell coverage areas can avoid
them.
Defined BSIC’s for the cells especially for cells transmitting same frequencies are set to be
different otherwise lot of unsuccessful handovers will take place. Even then, if it is found that
number of unsuccessful handover is high then redefining the neighbor list in BSS can control
it. Several neighbors for a serving cell can be defined in GSM. Usually, we want a handover
to be made to the strongest neighbor, but in some cases frequent handovers to this best
neighbor can result in congestion in this cell, affecting the users initiating calls from that cell.
The situation can also occur in reverse, when a handover required to the best neighbor can
result in a rejection due to unavailability of resources, causing the handover to be attempted
to the next best neighbor, which can delay the process and deteriorate the quality further.
Under certain circumstances, we may need to remove a potential neighbor from the neighbor
list and provide alternatives.
In the idle mode, the mobile always prefers to remain with or move to the best serving cell.
The best cell is decided on the basis of uplink and downlink path balance in the cells. This
balance is calculated by GSM defined C1 calculations. C1 calculations force the mobile to
move to the strongest cell. In certain cases, such as macro-micro cell architecture,
optimization may require that in certain areas the mobile not remain in the best cell, but
instead remain in a cell depending on traffic loading. C2 parameters provide the option of
adding fixed positive or negative offsets to the C1 calculation in each cell. So, although C1
might be better for a neighbor cell, the application of C2 parameters could delay reselection.
C2 parameters also allow the mobile to apply temporary offsets for a period known as
penalty time, which helps reduce Ping-Pong effects. With the help of carefully done drive test
these parameters like offset or penalty time for handovers can also be checked and verified.
Optimization philosophy:
Setting the parameters that control mobility have equal importance to the frequency plan. In
GSM there are a series of parameters that control mobility. Tuning these parameters for
improved GSM operations, in terms of maximizing calls carried, improved handover
performance and increased call success rate, is termed ‘Optimization’.
The aim of optimization is to maximize the Quality of Service of the GSM network. In order
to do this you need to measure the QOS, compare the measured value with the desired
value, and then take steps to correct the causes of any deviations from the desired value.
It is typical that during optimization the choice of cell frequency, the neighbor list and any
margins/timers will be examined and optimized for improved performance.
Only Basic optimization can be done in the network, if the network does not have a
substantial amount of active subscribers. For statistical data to be used as in the advanced
optimization process, the network must be carrying a significant amount of traffic
Personnel Requirements
The intention here is to show the engineers required in the optimization process and not the
amount of engineers. The amount of engineers will depend on the size of the network, the
amount of area to be covered and the roll out schedule.
Once the above information is known a more precise proposal can be done detailing
specific numbers of people required.
The engineers required in the optimization process is as follows
A procedure to manage changes within the network is required to maintain the integrity and
quality of the network.
The procedure ensures all changes required to improve the quality of the network are valid
and that precautions against failure of the change have been considered.
This procedure below is the change control procedure and ensures changes on the network
have been fully evaluated before implementation and that each change has a test plan and
a back plan in case of failure..
Before drive testing is started drive test route need to be agreed with the operator. These
routes should cover the following points before agreement is reached.
• All sites and sectors should be tested within the drive test routes at least once.
• All major roads and highways should be tested at least twice within the agreed
routes.
• All cells should be tested for handout and hand in within the routes if possible.
The routes should be approximately 2 - 3 hours in duration. This is required to manage the
data collected.
Routes of major importance should be identified prior to starting and should be driven first.
i.e Airports to the city center
Before Optimization can begin the RF design and database parameters will be required.
This is normally presented in spreadsheets from the RF planning tools.
This information is required to help the drive test engineers to identify possible sources of
interference. The information is also used to evaluate possible changes to improve the
quality of service.
To aid in the optimization of the network a test number is required within the MSC. This is
required for the drive test teams to access from the test mobiles in the car, a test number in
the MSC is preferred as this removes any contact with the land system, so in the event of
any dropped or unavailable calls they will all be in the mobile network .
Timescales
The optimization process never comes to an end within a network, the process usually
evolves into the performance engineering department as the network evolves.
The rate of growth in most cellular networks means the network continues to expand with
new sites or more capacity with different RF design techniques, this will always mean that
optimization will be required to maintain and improve the quality of the network.
The initial optimization of a system is somewhat variable depending on many factors i.e
amount of sites, area to be optimized, road traffic density e.t.c. However as an indication
until the precise information is known on the network it takes approximately 2-4 weeks for
one drive test team to optimize a BSC, a BSC usually consists of about 14 - 18 sites at with
present software load.
If a faster optimization process is required more engineers will be required, another team
would see a reduction of 10 days in the process.
The optimization process starts immediately the network is brought into operational service
or an enhancement takes place on the network. During times of little change to the network
Performance Engineering monitor the quality of the network and will seek assistance from
Optimization Engineers if the quality of the network begins to fall.
The procedure below is the basic method for optimizing a system and can be modified to
each operator to maximize results.
• Before Optimization starts all of the pre-requisites must have been done or be in
place. There must be a change control procedure in place with the operator that
GSM vendor are familiar with, the RF design and Database parameters must be
presented to the Optimization control manager. All drive test teams must have test
mobiles and SIM cards provided by the operator. Note - The Optimization control
personnel are usually situated with the OMC personnel for maximum efficiency as
OMC and Optimization control are continually passing information between each
other.
• The drive test routes must be agreed with the operator and a priority set on the
routes for testing.
• The drive test teams make test calls on the network of 2 minute duration with a 15
second break between calls to the MSC test number with the Test Mobile
equipment (TEMS) and all data is logged to the computer, location information is
also taken using a GPS receiver to provide location information.
• The drive test routes are usually 3 - 4 hours in duration so that the data collected
can be managed.
• During or after completion of the drive test route analysis of the data collected is
done to find areas of dropped or noisy calls. This can either be done on the RF
planning tool .
• Should the analysis of the route indicate problems of either dropped or noisy
calls ,with the aid of the RF design and Database parameters an assessment is
made to identify the possible source of interference causing the noisy or dropped
call. If a call is dropped and no interference is present a retest is made in the same
area, if the scenario of the dropped call can be repeated, information of the problem
cell should be obtained, this will then be escalated to Optimization control to seek
assistance from the BSS maintenance engineers to investigate the cell dropping
calls.
• After conformation as to what is causing the problem with the drive test route, the
drive test engineer will attempt to find a solution to the problem. This can be one of
a number of possibilities i.e. Power Change to BTS, Frequency Plan change,
Neighbor addition required e.t.c.
• Once a possible solution to the problem has been found it may be possible in some
circumstances to immediately attempt the solution via the OMC, this usually relates
to minor database changes and adding neighbors. The solution is implemented and
proven immediately. If the problem is rectified the change remains in place and a
change request is raised for the solution for the purpose of keeping records of all
changes in the network. If the solution requires a major database change or
antennae work a change request must be raised via the Optimization Control
Engineers. After the solution is implemented a retest of the problem area is carried
out to confirm the problem has been solved.
• In the event of the problem not being solved alternative solutions may be attempted,
this process continues until it becomes impossible to find a solution. At this point the
problem is discussed with the operator as to the reasons that the problem cannot be
solved for example the solution may require a new cell to be built, clearly this is
beyond the scope of optimization. If the operator is in agreement this particular
problem will be removed from the drive tests until such time a solution is
implemented.
OMC
The OMC is an integral part of a GSM system, its relationship to the Optimization process is
to provide statistics for the quality metrics and information on the status of the network.
Tems
Tems is the drive test mobile and software from Erisoft. The kit consists of a laptop P.C, an
Ericsson GH688 test mobile and a GPS receiver for positioning information.
The first snapshot represents a simple drive test of a model city. It contains various
information about the Rx-Level , Rx-Qual, Serving Cell , neighbor list , speech quality index
SQI , and various other parameters.
An RF planning tool is required in the Optimization Process for displaying drive test routes
for analysis, modifications to the frequency plan and antennae azimuths and down tilt
changes.
Mapinfo
Mapinfo is a GIS software tool, it is used to display drive test data for analysis and to
produce Optimization reports in a clear and easy manner.
Test Mobiles
Test mobiles are an invaluable source of information; all field engineers should be equipped
with a test mobile to identify problem areas.
The test mobile should be capable of giving the received signal level, RXQual value, Cell
I.D and six neighbors with rxlevels.
Subscribers
To gather meaningful data for the advanced optimisation tools the network should have a
substantial amount of traffic being generated by subscribers on the network.
Personnel Requirements
The type of engineers required will remain the same as the requirements in the basic
optimization pre-requisites. There will however be a requirement for extra performance
engineers to analyze data gathered from the intelligent optimization tool, the Call Trace
Product Tool and the Cell Analysis Tool.
The requirement for drive test engineers will still be valid for verification purposes, but a
there should be a significant reduction in the amount of drive test engineers required.
The reduction will be based on the amount of advanced tools available in the network and
the timescales involved.
Drive Test -:
Once the network is up and running , we have to optimize the network so that what we
simulated could be matched with the actual field results .
For this process the most common and reliable method is Drive test.
The process involves the use of Tools like TEMS and Agilent Drive test tools.
Once the drive test is over we have to study the Statistics collected during the drive.
The log files recorded are processed and converted into text files that could be loaded on
NetPlan.
The two most important Parameters that are checked upon are
1. Rx level
2. Rx Quality.
Rx Level -: It is an indication of the signal strength in dbm that is available to a cell phone at
any point.
The interval used is same as that we have for generating the image of Rx Level .
This gives a fair idea about the efficiency and accuracy of our plan as now we can compare
the signal that we predicted at a point and what we are getting at that point.
The aim is to match field results with the predicted values and for that the process of
optimization is carried out.
Rx Quality -: This is another important parameter that gives us an idea about the signal
quality or the bit error rate called as BER. This indicates that out of out of the total number of
bits that were transmitted what was the percentage of the bits that got corrupted .The
calculation is done on the basis of the 26 bit training sequence that is transmitted along with
the voice data that is transmitted on the air interface .As the contents of this training
sequence is known to the mobile station the error in it is taken as the error in the data packet
transmitted and thus the percentage of the total data that got corrupted can be calculated.
0 :( BER<0.2%)
1 :( 0.2 %< BER<0.4%)
2 :( 0.4 %< BER<0.8%)
3 :( 0.8 %< BER<1.6%)
4 :( 1.6 %< BER<3.2%)
5 :( 3.2 %< BER<6.4%)
6 :( 6.4 %< BER<12.8%)
7 :( 12.8 %< BER)
5 Conclusion
RF PLANNING
Subscriber environment
System quality (voice quality, for example), system access and grade of service, as
perceived by the customer, are the most significant factors in the success of a cellular
network. The everyday subscriber neither knows or really cares about the high level of
technology incorporated into a cellular network. However, they do care about the quality
of their calls.
Frequency planning
The ultimate goal of frequency planning in a GSM network is attaining and maintaining
the highest possible C/I ratio everywhere within the network coverage area. A general
requirement is at least 12 dB C/I, allowing tolerance in signal fading above the 9dB
specification of GSM.
The actual plan of a real network is a function of its operating environment (geography,
RF, etc.) and there is no universal textbook plan that suits every network. Nevertheless,
some practical guidelines gathered from experience can help to reduce the planning
cycle time.
Site planning
The following information is required to plan each site.
Planning tools
In order to predict the signal strength in a cell area it would be necessary to make many
calculations, at regular intervals, from the BTS.
The result, is the necessity to perform hundreds of calculations for each cell. This would
be time consuming in practice, but for the intervention of the software planning tool.
This can be fed with all the details of the cell, such as:
Type of terrain.
Environment.
Heights of antennas.
Several planning tools are available on the market, such as Netplan or Planet, and it is
up to the users to choose the tool(s) which suit them best.