Back to the Root:

An Urban River Revitalization Plan

Presented by the Root River Council and River Alliance of Wisconsin

July 2008
 Back to the Root: An Urban River Revitalization Plan (July 2008)
Table of Contents
Root River Council Members 3 Root River Council Members
Acknowledgments 4 The members of the Root River Council provided
Executive Summary 5 hundreds of volunteer hours working on this effort.
Thank you for caring so much about the future of the
Introduction 7 Root River and the City of Racine!
Project Scope 8
Connecting People to the River 9 Chris Flynn, Owner, DP Wigley
Listening to the Community 10
Root River Councils Recommendations 11 Susan Greenfield, Executive Director, Root-Pike
Create a Sense of Place 11 Watershed Initiative Network
Stimulate Economic Growth 12
Allow Public Access and Interaction 15
Improve Water Quality 18 Reva Holmes, Board Member, Root-Pike Watershed
Initiative Network
Implementation 19
Appendices 21 Rep. Cory Mason (Assembly District 62), and Board
Appendix A: Survey and Discussion Member, River Alliance of Wisconsin
Questions 21
Appendix B: Survey Results 23
Donna Peterson, Southeast Gateway Group
Appendix C: River Walk and Bike Path
Recommendations 28 Sierra Club
Appendix D: Belle Harbor Concept 6 29
Appendix E: Park Recommendations 31 Bonnie Prochaska, Owner, Ginkgo Leaf Consulting
Appendix F: Publications Reviewed 33
Figures Thomas Schnaubelt, Dean for Community
Figure 1: Proposed Urban River Planning Engagement and Civic Learning, University of
Boundary with Paths 6 Wisconsin-Parkside
Figure 2: Project Scope 8
Figure 3: Urban River Planning
Melissa Warner, Coordinator Weed Out! Racine, and
Boundary 11
Figure 4: Belle Harbor Concept 6 14 Vice Chair, Southeast Gateway Group Sierra Club
Figure 5: Proposed Root River
Pathway Route 16 Allison Werner and Helen Sarakinos, River Alliance of
Wisconsin staff

Cover and page five: The image is a conceptual

drawing of the river looking downstream from 6th
306 E. Wilson Street #2W
Street. The renderings throughout the document were
Madison, WI 53703
created by UW-Milwaukee Community Design
608.257.2424
Solutions student Anna Grosch.
www.backtotheroot.org

Back to the Root: An Urban River Revitalization Plan (July 2008) 

Acknowledgments
Many people provided guidance and input for this UW-Milwaukees Community Design Solutions
plan. We greatly appreciate all of their thoughtful (CDS) provided planning, facilitation and design
comments and time. support throughout this project. CDS is a program that
gives graduate and undergraduate students real world
Several City of Racine Staff worked closely with us on planning experience. The main students involved in
this project. We are looking forward to continuing our this project were:
partnership with the city as we move forward on the
next phase of this plan. Anna Grosch, Graphic Design
Larry Kilmer, Assistant Manager
City of Racine Staff Alison Kopyt, Project Manager
Rick Jones, Public Works
Julie Kinzelman, Health
Jim Luelloff, Development
Brian OConnell, Development
Donnie Snow, Parks, Recreation and Cultural Services

Dan Williams and Cassie Goodwin from consulting

firm JJR provided many conceptual images and
waterfront development guidance for this plan.

A big thanks to River Alliance of Wisconsin interns

Aubin Maynard and Amy Singler for their great work
on this project.

This project was made possible thanks to the generous support from the following contributors.

 Back to the Root: An Urban River Revitalization Plan (July 2008)

Executive Summary
Back to the Root: An Urban River Revitalization Plan Economic Growth Recommendations
is intended to guide and inform the redevelopment and Create continuous public access along the
revitalization of the Root River in the City of Racine. riverfront combining river walk, pathway and
The vision to create an identity for the river took recreational access points
shape over two years of public conversations with Sustainably redevelop Belle Harbor Marina
residents, stakeholders and the City staff. The plan
brings together the best elements of existing plans and Public Access and Interaction
lays out a holistic vision for the future of the river that Recommendations
ensures water quality improvement and public access Provide access points for public fishing, boating,
and brings beauty and functionality to the riverfront. and viewing the river
Draw people to the river by placing signs directing
Four goals guided this planning process: them to recreational opportunities along the river
1) reorient the city to its river Move the Mound Avenue section of the Root River
2) prompt robust, innovative development and growth Pathway off the street between 6th and Marquette
with a mix of residential, retail and recreational projects Streets
3) champion redevelopment efforts that will improve Improve the Water Street retaining wall by placing
and protect natural habitat and water quality of the river public art over the wall
4) promote the participation of citizens and good Connect the river walk to downtown by
public process in decisions affecting redevelopment of improving the 4th Street stairs and adding
the waterfront matching access on the Park Avenue side of the
Water Street retaining wall
Our recommendations for the Root River fall under
four interconnected categories: Water Quality Recommendations
Create a sense of place All new development within the urban planning
Stimulate economic growth boundary must incorporate best management
Allow public access and interaction practices to control stormwater runoff
Improve water quality Maintain vegetative buffers along the rivers edge
in the river parks
Sense of Place Recommendation
Define a unified urban river planning boundary The proposed urban river planning boundary, river walk
highlighting the rivers assets and creating an and bike path are shown in Figure 1, on page six.
identity that connects people to the river

Back to the Root: An Urban River Revitalization Plan (July 2008) 

Figure 1: Proposed Urban River Planning Boundary,
River Walk and Bike Path

 Back to the Root: An Urban River Revitalization Plan (July 2008)

Introduction
We perceive the transformation of urban waterfronts Yet for all the good planning, redevelopment,
in North America...playing a major role in ongoing monitoring and restoration that is happening along
efforts to restore the centers of our cities to economic parts of the river, no comprehensive plan exists
and social health. Waterfronts: Cities Reclaim Their that ties together all the separate valuable efforts to
Edge (Breen and Digby, 1994). establish priorities for the Root River within the City
of Racine, and to promote it as the asset and treasure it
Racine is a city in the midst of reinventing itself from can be. And despite major improvements in the water
a manufacturing center to a Great Lakes business, quality of the river over the last 30 years (as evidenced
recreational and cultural destination. Perched on the by the big increase in salmon fishing in the river),
shores of Lake Michigan and bisected by the Root many still perceive the Root River as dirty, industrial,
River, much of the redevelopment and revitalization contaminated, in the words of one resident.
of the city has focused on the lakefront, but is
increasingly moving to the riverfront. Increased focus
is now being placed on another valuable resource in
the City of Racine - the namesake Root River - and the
potential to make it a key component in revitalization
plans for the City of Racine.

The City has adopted several plans for the

management and redevelopment of city areas that
touch on portions of the Root River, including the
2005 Downtown Plan and Park and Open Space Plan.
Close to 58% of the land along the Root River in the
City of Racine is publicly owned. In 2004, the City
completed the Root River Pathway, a bike path along
the Root River in Racine, allowing for non-motorized
access to the rivers shore for over four miles, through
both parks and urban areas.

There has been increasing interest in evaluating and

improving the water quality of the river over the
last several years. In 2005, the City commissioned
an assessment of the erosion control problems
associated with storm sewer outfalls and hydrological
modifications along the Root River to guide future
restoration and upgrading efforts. Southeast Wisconsin
Regional Planning Commission (SEWRPC) has
updated its Regional Water Quality Management Plan
for the Root. The City of Racine Health Department
has been monitoring select open water and storm
water discharge pipes on the Root River for over
twenty years. Future comprehensive water quality
assessments will establish a baseline by which
improvements may be gauged.
Top: Paddler traveling downstream toward DP Wigley
Bottom: West 6th Street Bridge

Back to the Root: An Urban River Revitalization Plan (July 2008) 

Several recent redevelopment plans include portions Project Scope
of the river within their boundaries, but there is a
growing desire to address riverfront redevelopment in
Racine more holistically. Since June 2006, engaged The geographic area covered in this plan is the urban
residents and organizations from Racine have been Root River corridor from Horlick Dam to the mouth of
coming together to strategize how the Root River can the river at Lake Michigan, approximately five miles
be a key asset in the revitalization of the city. downstream, as shown in Figure 2 below.

Over the course of several conversations, the group The rivers course has a natural evolution through
has identified the need for a comprehensive plan that the city meandering through nine city parks, two
will focus on the Root River specifically to: 1) reorient county parks and two golf courses and residential
the city to its river; 2) prompt robust, innovative neighborhoods. At the Union Pacific Railroad bridge,
development and growth with a mix of residential, the course changes, and its historic commercial and
retail and recreational projects; 3) improve habitat manufacturing character predominates. While the
and water quality along the river; and 4) promote the plan addresses the entire river scope, the majority
participation of citizens and good public process in of recommendations focus on the redevelopment
decisions affecting redevelopment of the waterfront. potential in the lower reaches of the river.

Figure 2: Project Scope

Horlick Dam

Belle Harbor Marina

Lincoln Park

Union Pacific Railroad Bridge

 Back to the Root: An Urban River Revitalization Plan (July 2008)

Connecting People to the River
River communities have historically turned their
backs on their hard-working rivers, and Racine, in
its treatment of the Root River downtown, was no
exception. The Root River Council made it a priority
to help residents reconnect with the Root River in
order to better understand it and to envision a new
future for the river. In the last two years, several
public events were organized to bring residents back
to the Root.

Running the Root, an annual canoe trip.

A bike ride along the Root River Pathway from

Colonial Park to North Beach. (This event, held
in August of 2007 when the river was high,
demonstrated the important function of the
floodplain.)

A community park walk from Island Park to Root

River Environmental Education Community
Center (REC) was led by Racine Parks Director
Donnie Snow.

A fall motor boat trip, made possible thanks to

Captain Monte Osterman.
Root River Environmental Education

Community Center
A public forum at which City of Racine
Microbiologist Dr. Julie Kinzelman presented the
REC will continue to have a key role in
results of the City Health Departments 2007 Root
drawing positive attention to the Root River
River study.
by providing educational and recreational
programming and connecting the residents to the
The May 2008 grand opening of UW-Parksides
natural world in the neighborhood.
REC which celebrated the Root River and
provided an opportunity for public comments
about this plan.

A web site (www.backtotheroot.org) provided

online access to information about events and
resources about the Root River planning effort.

Citizen Comments
We would use the river more if the:
Area around the river can be cleaned up
Water quality was increased Top: Paddlers at Union Pacific Railroad bridge during
the 2007 Running the Root
Middle: Cyclists learning about REC in August 2006
Bottom: REC ribbon cutting on May 3, 2008

Back to the Root: An Urban River Revitalization Plan (July 2008) 

Listening to the Community
One of the central goals of the Root River planning
process was to meaningfully engage residents in a
public dialogue about the role of the Root River in
a revitalized urban center. The Root River Council
worked directly with many different stakeholders
who have an interest in the river: neighborhood
associations and churches, local businesses,
developers, recreational, fishing and environmental
groups, local schools, Root-Pike WIN, members of
Common Council whose districts incorporate the
Root River, and staff from the City Departments
of Public Works, Parks, City Development and the
Mayors office.

Both one-on-one interviews and facilitated group

meetings were used to get public input. Interviews
were designed to determine how stakeholders perceive
and use the river and what they believe is needed to
make the river a more central resource for the city.
The public visioning process for the Root River
Plan was carried out as a group of three Root River
Conversations held in the fall of 2007 and facilitated
by UW-Milwaukees Community Design Solutions.
These working meetings were designed for small
group discussions and visioning and allowed residents
to learn about the current condition of the Root River
and share their opinions about its future.

Additionally, the Root River Council distributed

surveys to Racine area residents. The survey responses
and meeting discussions shaped the recommendations
in this plan. The list of the survey questions and
responses are in Appendix A and B respectively.

Citizen Comments
We love the Root River because:
It is a natural gem in an urban area
I love the calming effect of being near water
Each time I visit it is growing cleaner

Top: Residents annotate a map of the Root River

Bottom: Citizens sketches for Root River corridor
redevelopment

10 Back to the Root: An Urban River Revitalization Plan (July 2008)

Root River Councils Recommendations
From our interviews, surveys and conversations with Figure 3: Urban River Planning
citizens and stakeholders, the Root River Council
makes these recommendations, which fall under four Boundary
interconnected categories:

Create a sense of place

Stimulate economic growth
Allow public access and interaction
Improve water quality

Create a Sense of Place

The 2005 Downtown Plan created seven districts
which it envisioned as an assembly of distinct and
varied districts that create a unified and coherent
whole a place where people will want to live, work,
shop and play. While several downtown districts
touch on the riverfront, there is no unified river
district that would help create an identity around
the river, lay out consistent development guidelines
and public access requirements, and generally help
develop a sense of place tied to Racines namesake
river. To unify the Root River corridor in the urban
section we have created a river planning boundary
(Figure 3 below and Figure 1 on page six). We will
use this boundary as a guide as we further develop our
recommendations. Sense of Place Recommendation

Steps need to be taken to create a sense of place or Define a unified urban river planning
identity within this boundary. This can begin with boundary highlighting the rivers assets
creating a logo and signs for the entire river corridor and creating an identity that connects
that highlight the character of both the park and people to the river
urban sections of the river and unify the Root River
within the city.

The Root River and the Racine community are

fortunate that city officials had the vision to create so
much park land along the river. (For example, Island
Park is an urban gem created by renowned landscape
designer Jens Jensen.) However, the park section
abruptly ends at the Union Pacific Railroad bridge. As
the urban river corridor redevelops, adding more green
space will better connect these sections.

Back to the Root: An Urban River Revitalization Plan (July 2008) 11

Stimulate Economic Growth
As stated in the 2005 Downtown Plan, Development
that authentically reflects Racines history of
innovation and reconnects to its geographical features
Lake Michigan and the Root River will reinforce
its unique qualities.

The river can be a destination and attract multiple uses

such as housing, retail, restaurants, concerts, festivals,
and recreation. All of these activities need an attractive
setting with green spaces and good water quality.

While almost all of the recommendations in this report

will make the river a more desirable place for people
to be, two are key to catalyzing economic growth:
1) creating continuous public access along the
riverfront combining river walk, pathway and
recreational access points, and 2) sustainable
redevelopment of the Belle Harbor Marina.

Many Wisconsin cities have revitalized their

riverfronts. The photos on the right show examples of
how Milwaukee and Waupaca have made their rivers
an economic asset. From top to bottom:

Public performance spaces, like this pavilion on

the Milwaukee riverfront, provide an amenity for
both pedestrians and river users.

The Waupaca River is an asset to housing in

Waupaca. The buildings are oriented to both the
river and the street, and offer river views and easy
access to the water.

The Rock Bottom Brewery in Milwaukee is one of

many businesses that lures customers looking for a
table with a view.

Citizen Comments
The economic changes Id like to see:
Developed more with an overall plan, yet
keep it as natural as possible
Top: A musical gathering place on the Milwaukee River
Middle: Fishing access adjacent to riverfront housing
Bottom: Rock Bottom Brewery draws riverfront business

12 Back to the Root: An Urban River Revitalization Plan (July 2008)

River Walk

...Pedestrian-oriented high-density residential district

oriented toward riverfront. 2005 Downtown Plan Citizen Comments
The river walk should:
A river walk is an economic asset and amenity to When I look up from the water, I should see as
new and existing development and a destination for few buildings as possible
Use the natural beauty to enhance the river
recreation and entertainment. Most importantly, it is a
public space. The river walk should be a focal point in
the Downtown District.

A Racine river walk should be located along the

rivers southeast edge from 6th Street to Main Street
and then connect with the existing lakefront walkway,
as shown on Figure 1, page six.

In its call for pedestrian-oriented high-density

residential district oriented toward the riverfront,
Racines 2005 Downtown Plan recognizes the
benefit of a river walk to many other communities.
Chicago, Cleveland, Detroit, Milwaukee, Oshkosh
and Sheboygan have all incorporated a river walk with
their riverfront redevelopment. While each of these
communities is unique, they offer many lessons for
Racine.

Approved zoning that clearly lays out the

requirements and creates a level playing field for all
development along the river walk is highly desired
by developers. And better that those requirements
are laid down before development starts. In some
communities, riverfront zoning was adopted after
development began, leading to problems, such as
significant differences in elevation of the river walk
from one property to the next. That, in turn, led to a
neighboring development having to spend additional
money to connect their river walk to the higher river
walk section next door. Top: Conceptual image of the Detroit RiverWalk in Detroit,
Michigan
Natural vegetation needs to be included with the river Bottom: Conceptual image of the Oshkosh, Wisconsin
Riverwalk. Images provided by JJR.
walk design. Vegetation can filter runoff, provide
habitat for birds and animals, offer shade, and
generally provide a pleasing visual aspect. Plants
suited for riverfront landscaping will accomplish these
needs. The wider such vegetative buffers are, the
greater their benefit.

Back to the Root: An Urban River Revitalization Plan (July 2008) 13

Belle Harbor Marina

The Racine Lakefront Plan Update from August 25,

2006, points out the many challenges for this site to
continue to operate as a marina. These include siltation,
excess marina space in this area, and the high cost of
repairing the dock walls. The lakefront plan provides
three suggestions for the future use of the property.

Our preference for this site aligns closer to Concept 6

(Figure 4 below and in Appendix D), which includes
a riverfront park and public plaza. These uses fit with
the Downtown Plan and this plan. However, Concept
6 also includes a housing tower. Since details have
not been created for the concept, we are uncertain Above: Belle Harbor Marina June 2008
if the tower is a good fit for the site and the goals of
this plan. We prefer see the entire space be park and
open space, including a public non-motorized and Economic Growth Recommendations
motorized boat launch, with boat slips remaining
along the outside wall. Create continuous public access along the
riverfront combining river walk, pathway
We plan to work with the City of Racine, Racine and recreational access points
County and the Downtown Racine Corporation to
Sustainably redevelop Belle Harbor Marina
further develop the redesign of this location.

Figure 4: Belle Harbor Concept 6

14 Back to the Root: An Urban River Revitalization Plan (July 2008)

Allow Public Access and Interaction
The navigable waters of Wisconsin shall be common
highways and forever free... Article IX, Section Citizen Comments
1, Wisconsin State Constitution (the Public Trust Increase opportunities for all to experience
the river
Doctrine)

The Root River is a treasure that runs through the

city and should be accessible by all residents. More
opportunities for residents to safely reach and interact
with the Root River are needed. Public access includes
fishing, walking and cycling near the rivers edge,
boating and viewing the river from the shoreline.

Among the chief recommendations to emerge from

the public input sessions was the need to establish
continuous public access along the riverfront. The
river walk will provide walking, viewing and access to
the river in the downtown area. It will be an amenity
for residents of river apartments, condominiums
and/or townhouses and for businesses such as cafs
and restaurants. Public access does not eliminate
or conflict with the current boating opportunities
along the river. The conceptual images on the right
demonstrate how boat slips and a public river walk
can coexist.

The Root River Pathway is a great access point into

the river parks. While the pathway is well marked,
many of the city parks are in need of signs indicating
that the Root River is accessible at the park. The signs,
with a newly created logo, should be placed at major
intersections near each of the river parks.

Access and view points should also be established

in each park along the river for fishermen and non-
motorized boaters. In general, non-motorized boat
launches should be reasonably priced and require low
maintenance for the city. Specific recommendations Top : Conceptual image of paddlers and pedestrians using
the Root River in downtown
for each park are listed in Appendix E.
Bottom: Conceptual image of the Oshkosh, Wisconsin
Riverwalk. Image provided by JJR.

Back to the Root: An Urban River Revitalization Plan (July 2008) 15

Bike Path Safety

During our August 2007 bike ride we received

comments about improving the bike path from the Citizen Comments
cyclists that were echoed in our surveys and interviews. We would like to see the pathway:
The users of the Root River Pathway want a safer route Continuous, safe, walking and riding path
along Mound Avenue. Traffic on Mound Avenue moves Better crosswalks, more signs, and less bike
quickly and without a designated bike lane, cyclists do path on streets
not feel safe. Turning left onto the path against traffic
from Mound Avenue is dangerous. The intersection the busy street will also keep this section of the river as
at Mound Avenue, Marquette and Liberty Streets is green space. This is the last large area of green space
confusing to out-of-town and local residents alike. in the urban area, and wildlife like the black-crowned
night-heron, fox, and beaver are frequently found here.
We want to see the route of the Root River Pathway The existing and proposed bike path routes are shown
amended to be off-street along Mound Avenue, as below and details can be found in Appendix C.
shown in Figure 5 below. Moving the bike path off of

Figure 5: Proposed Root River Pathway Route

16 Back to the Root: An Urban River Revitalization Plan (July 2008)

Water Street Retaining Wall

Improving the appearance of the large steel retaining

wall along Water Street will draw positive attention to Public Access and Interaction
the river. Of the many options, we prefer fabric murals Recommendations
because they can be mounted over the existing wall
and changed periodically. Public art can be printed Provide access points for public fishing,
on the fabric murals, which could be made from boating, and viewing the river
parachutes or sail material. One citizens suggestion Draw people to the river by placing
was to use the fabric to create a movie screen and hold signs directing them to recreational
a special movie night on the river. opportunities along the river

This project can also engage the community. Move the Mound Avenue section of
Organizations such as the Racine Arts Council and the Root River Pathway off the street
local artists could help implement this idea. between 6th and Marquette Streets
Improve the Water Street retaining wall
The refurbished wall and the adjacent Sam Azarian
by placing public art over the wall
Park should become a focal point that can connect the
river with downtown. To create easier access between Connect the river walk to downtown by
the river and downtown, the stairs at 4th Street need to improving the 4th Street stairs and adding
be improved and matching pedestrian access needs to matching access on the Park Avenue side
be added on the Park Avenue side of the wall. of the Water Street retaining wall

Image: Conceptual drawing of murals on the retaining wall Inset: Existing condition of the retaining wall

Back to the Root: An Urban River Revitalization Plan (July 2008) 17

Improve Water Quality
Address the health of downtown in a holistic manner, In 2007 the health department prepared the report
considering environmental quality and long-term Baseline Assessment of Root River Water Quality.
benefits to downtown activity and vitality. 2005 The results showed high E.Coli levels at several sites.
Downtown Plan Turbidity (murkiness) of the water was above average
at all of the sites. Detergents were also detected
The number one improvement the public wants for frequently. The City of Racine Health Department will
the Root River is high water quality. Over the last 100 be continuing this study in 2008. Having long-term
years this river worked hard and was treated poorly. data about the health of the river will help prioritize
We now have the opportunity to reverse these actions. ways to continue to improve the rivers water quality.
Our economic activities should improve rather than
degrade water quality.

In this urban setting, the main water quality issue to

address is stormwater. Stormwater carries pollutants,
such as bacteria, sediment, nutrients, and detergents
as it runs over roofs, driveways, and streets. New
developments are required to create and implement
stormwater and erosion plans to reduce the stormwater
leaving the site during and after construction.
Techniques for reducing stormwater impacts include
green roofs, rain gardens, rain harvesting devices (rain
barrels or cisterns), and permeable pavements.

One technique to reduce the impacts of stormwater

in the river parks is a vegetative buffer. A vegetative
buffer absorbs rain water, reduces soil erosion,
provides habitat for wildlife, and also deters geese.
The City of Racine Parks Department already
increased the vegetative buffer along the Root River
by eliminating mowing of the grass along the rivers
edge. We applaud this effort. We understand that
to some citizens a vegetative buffer is not visually Top: This vegetative buffer was installed in Island Park by
appealing or limits access to the river. To address these Earth Tech
issues we recommend maintenance of the buffers to Bottom: Carthage College student Tristan Begotka collects
remove weeds such as thistles and non-native plants water for testing from an outfall at Washington Park.
such as buckthorn. We acknowledge that City Park Photo provided by Dr. Julie Kinzelman
staff may not have enough resources to provide the
labor to accomplish this work. The citys Adopt-a- Water Quality Recommendations:
River program should work with the new Weed Out!
Racine program to train volunteers to assist in the All new development within the urban
removal of nonnative plants and weeds. A public planning boundary must incorporate
education effort should also take place to explain the best management practices to control
benefits of the vegetative buffer. stormwater

Fortunately, several studies have been completed Maintain vegetative buffers along the
and are still being conducted by the City of Racine rivers edge in the river parks
to determine the current water quality in the river.
18 Back to the Root: An Urban River Revitalization Plan (July 2008)
Implementation
Creating a vision for the Root River is only the first The projects that citizens could organize around in the
step. Implementing the recommendations is a long- near future include:
term effort and relies on several next steps:
Retaining wall mural design and installation
Adopt the plan Vegetative buffer maintenance in parks
Continue to involve city staff Public education about buffers
Pursue funding opportunities New boat launches in parks
Pursue catalyst projects New benches and viewing places in parks
Continue to involve citizens
Participation of community groups will be key to
We will request that the Racine City Council and realizing the revitalization of the Root River. Some of
appropriate committees adopt this plan in concept. the key partners include:

Success relies on the continued close partnership with 21st Century School
city staff. In the immediate future, we will jointly Adopt-a-River
pursue funding from the Department of Commerce to Downtown Racine Corporation
further refine and carry out recommendations. Historic Sixth Street Association
Hoy Audubon Society
Funding is obviously a key requirement to Kenosha Racine Bike Club
implementing this plan. There are many federal and Leadership Racine
state programs that could support portions of the plan. Racine Arts Council
Root-Pike Watershed Initiative Network
While it may take a number of years for the riverfront Root River Chapter of Wild Ones
to redevelop, several projects can begin right Root River Environmental Education Community
away. These projects can become catalysts for the Center
redevelopment of the Root River. Salmon Unlimited
Southeast Gateway Group Sierra Club
The projects best suited for city staff leadership are: St. Catherines High School Environmental Club
UW-Parkside
Bike Path improvements along Mound Avenue Walden III Environmental Club
Repair of stairs at 4th Street Weed Out! Racine
Belle Harbor redevelopment planning
Root River identity creation (i.e. logo and sign
design)
Promotion of the plan to developers

Back to the Root: An Urban River Revitalization Plan (July 2008) 19

Appendices
Appendix A: Survey and Discussion Questions
Root River Survey-Fall 2007

Thank you for sharing your comments about the Root River!

1. What are your experiences with the Root River? Please mark all that apply.
Fishing
Biking
Walking
Boating, what type ___________ (canoe, kayak, motor boat)
Bird watching
I live nearby the river
I work nearby the river
I own a business near the river
Other _______________________

2. What do you love about the Root River?

3. What changes would you like to see?

4. Later this fall we will be holding meetings to discuss the future of the Root River in the downtown and
upstream park areas (Island and Colonial, etc.). Would you be interested in attending a meeting to share your
concerns and help plan improvements for the Root River?
Yes
No

If yes, is a week night or Saturday better? Please check one.

Weeknight
Saturday morning
Saturday afternoon

Which location would be most convenient for you to attend the meeting? Please check one.
Downtown area
West 6th Street area
Lincoln Park area
Location does not matter

If no, may we ask why not?

Too busy
Not interested in meetings
Other____________________________________________

Thank you for taking the time to complete this survey!

If you would like to be contacted about future Root River meetings please provide us your contact information
on the page provided.
Back to the Root: An Urban River Revitalization Plan (July 2008) 21
Survey and Discussion Questions Continued

November 2007
Root River Conversation Questions

Conversation 1: Accessibility / River Experience

How can the root river be made easier to access?
How can the Root River play a bigger role in your daily life?
What activities are you most interested in participating in and along the river?
What do you feel is restricting peoples access to the river?
Where are do you think new river access points could be added?
How can existing access points be improved?

Conversation 2: Downtown District

How should the river look and feel as it flows through the downtown area?
What do you think should be the size and frequency of public access?
What should the functions of the buildings be that are adjacent to river?
Where should the entrances be located?
What should the character of river walk be?

December 2007
Root River Conversations Questions

Parks
What type of vegetation should be along the Root River in each of the parks?
How much of the river bank vegetation should be cleared for access/view?
Who should/could maintain the vegetation?
Where should boat launches be placed between the Quarry and REC Center?

River Walk
If there was a river walk along the downtown section of the river, where would it be placed?
What activities would talk place on or along a river walk?
What infrastructure would need to be created to have those activities and where should they be placed?

Retaining Wall
Should this wall:
Be Painted
Have vegetation planted (vines, etc.) that would trail down the wall
Be used a movie screen for public events
Be removed and terraced with an amphitheater

Downtown Connections
Where should connections be made from the river to downtown and what type of connections should they
be?

22 Back to the Root: An Urban River Revitalization Plan (July 2008)

Appendix B: Survey Results

2007 Root River Survey Results

83 Respondents

Question One: What activities/experiences have you had in or along the river?

Root River Activites

50

Boating
45

40

canoe
35
kayak

motor boat

30 dragon
boats
sail boat

25

20

15

10

0
Own business Work nearby Other Bird watching Live nearby Fishing Biking Boating Walking
nearby

Notes from those that checked other or added a comment:

Drive by the river
Past member/President of Root River Restoration
Grew up near the river
Crab fishing as a kid, for bait
Sitting by the river
Former sail boat owner that docked on the river
Friends that live on the river
Kayak dog park to lake, canoe Hwy 31 to lake, sail boat, Azarian to lake
Ice skating, X-country skiing, paintball on the ice
Former Rotarian involved with dragon boats on the river

Back to the Root: An Urban River Revitalization Plan (July 2008) 23

Survey Results Continued

2007 Root River Survey Results

Question Two: What do you love about the Root River?

What I love about the Root River

40

35

30

25

20

15

10

0
Horlick dam Photography Educational Getting Cleaner It is still here Beauty Serenity Recreation Urban Asset Nature/Wildlife
Opportunity

A sample of responses
The "wildness", seeing the birds and animals Good place to fish and sit and watch birds and relax.
Gentle, wild, meanders, shallow The salmon trap. I have sent several people from Illinois to see it
I like the greenery around the river this spring
A natural resource that can be shared by everyone in a sustainable fashion Serenity, the sounds of the river flowing-peacefulness
It helps to identify our city. Beauty, the natural beauty
Natural resource, beauty to compliment the urban environment The sound and the fact that it is here
Oasis in the middle of the city The quiet and the green space
Root River goes through heart of Racine How each time I visit it is growing cleaner
It is a nearby recreation resource and wildlife refuge I love that it (the river) is still here
It is fun to boat on That is it a river!
I love riding my bike along the bike path It's history
It runs throughout most of Racine-many opportunities for different
I like the opportunities it offers for various recreational activities as
schools to experience it.
well as photographic opportunities.
Living near water is important to me
Parks and bike paths are a gem, close to home, safe place to bike
Racine Horlick Dam
to work-off of city streets

24 Back to the Root: An Urban River Revitalization Plan (July 2008)

Survey Results Continued

2007 Root River Survey Results

Question Three: How would you like to see the river changed?

Changes to the River

30

25

20

15

10

ge ge ss h
an afe
r ed ) gs t ce as lity
ch Dr rs lan ve
ls din en Ac Tr ua
g/S rrie (P ng uil em ry es
No thin ba e wi Le B g he nit ov
e
re Q
Lig al or Flo at
er ss an
a Fis rtu em at
su M e Le d o R
Vi lop /F
re W m an pp e
W
e ve m se ion no ov
ov De da ea os tem tio pr
m e cr Er ys a
Re ov In os cre Im
em Ec
e re
R e or
nc M
ha
En

Back to the Root: An Urban River Revitalization Plan (July 2008) 25

Survey Results Continued: A summary of all of the written comments by category.
A Selection of Question Three Responses:

Improve Water Quality and Remove Trash

Anything that would make the water cleaner Buffering lands to protect/increase the water quality which will also
Improvement in water quality-most visible to me is turbidity, is this provide increased opportunities for recreation.
from runoff? More aquatic plants, more buffering
Cleaned up, both of debris and water quality Help stop erosion around the river, pollution, increasing fish
Cleaner, more frequented by citizens populations at least as long as it is healthy for the river
Keep it clean and natural I am a riparian nut, wishing to protect and restore the pristine
Kept clean and public nature of all rivers and streams
I would like to see if the area around the river can be cleaned up Fewer Buildings and Remove Visual Barriers
Clean up trash below the dam It should be maintained as spot of the wilds. When I look up from
Clean up! No fertilizer flowing in, garbage out. the water, I should see as few buildings as possible.
Recreation Remove some of the impinging homes and industry
Continuous, safe, walking and riding path Less building along it
Walking paths with benches. Balance between vegetative buffer and viewing the river
Places to rent boats/kayaks. Remove visual barriers
Better crosswalks, more signs, and fewer paths on streets for bike Continue to increase access to its shores for viewing
path, seating area and concessions along bike path What I don't want to see if condos all over the river banks.
More public outings, canoe hiking, biking paths Water Levels
Room for paddlers Return to its natural flow, protected from all types of pollution and
Canoe Rental Service not over used
Events along the river, concerts, fishing More water flowing in so as to be able to navigate it, that's up to
Increase opportunities for all to experience nature I guess
Access To be at proper level. Fallen trees removed
Great access, i.e. walkways perhaps Reporting on levels to plan trips down from Island Park
Add access, walkways, paths, etc. Restore a more consistent water level and flow rate, which was lost
More accessible recreationally for more people with the wetlands buffering action (impossible dream)
More public access and use Remove Dam
More entry places I would like to see the dam taken out and to see the river more
Non-motorized river access clear like it historically was.
Enhance Ecosystem and Fishery Developed with a plan
Developed more with overall plan yet keep it as natural as possible.
Remove invasive species, ask adopt-a river groups to help
I would like to see more gardens and parks around it Promoted.
Restored to natural setting as much as possible Restaurants with outdoor seating.
Remove invasive species; reduce upstream storm water flow, by It could be cleaner, developed more and promoted
Lighting/safer
installing things like rain gardens
Use the natural beauty to enhance it Safer
Continue to support Steelhead facility Perhaps, lighting around the bridges
No Change
Erosion Management
Shoreline management to control erosion and protect natural No changes Not changed, no development that takes away from
setting and control runoff (the river)
Seems fine as it is

26 Back to the Root: An Urban River Revitalization Plan (July 2008)

Survey Results Continued

This chart summarizes the top comments made in written surveys and during three Root River Conversations in 2007

River Love About the Changes to the River Restricting Use of Connect River and Parks
Activities River the River Downtown

Walking/hiking Nature/Wildlife Improve water quality Safety concerns (real River walk Balance riparian
and perceived) vegetation and
river views

Boating Urban Asset Remove trash Access points Access points, Pursue a new
stairs, etc. park at Belle
Harbor
Biking Recreation More recreational Water quality and Riverfront Fulfill Jens
opportunities and events cleanliness development Jensen's design
guidelines of Island Park

Fishing Serenity/Beauty Increase access, Lack of water depth Riverfront events More boat
including ADA and activities launches and
better signage

Bird watching Enhance ecosystem and Lack of signage Image and Access point to
fishery amenities: the river at
Appearance, Quarry Park
parking, restrooms
Increase signage and Improve retaining Teach fishing at
safety wall the steelhead
facility and
Horlick dam

Water Street as a
focal point

Back to the Root: An Urban River Revitalization Plan (July 2008) 27

Appendix C: River Walk and Bike Path Recommendations
River Walk Recommendations Root River Pathway Recommendations

The following are a few detailed recommendations The following are a few detailed recommendations
related to the river walk. related to the Root River Pathway.

A river walk will be created on the south side of The route of the Root River Pathway should
the river within the urban river planning boundary be amended to become off-street along Mound
(Figure 1, on page six), from the 6th Street Bridge Avenue.
to the Main Street Bridge.
The newly routed bike path will turn right before
The river walk should be no wider than 15 feet Mound Avenue as you are heading east from 6th
wide, meet all Americans with Disabilities Act Street, and continue along the top of the slope,
requirements, and minimize impervious surfaces. parallel to Mound Avenue, with a proper setback
to avoid erosion. (This will require purchase of
The elevation of the river walk will be consistent and/or easements from several properties). A
from property to property. No stairs, ramps or former parking lot has left a flat surface that is an
change in elevation should be necessary to connect appropriate distance from the top of the slope.
the river walk from one parcel to the next.
Have the newly routed path go under the
Fully vegetated buffers should extend from Marquette Street Bridge. There is more than 10
the river inland of the river walk and natural feet of height under the bridge, which is adequate
vegetation should extend from the river walk to for an underpass.
adjacent development.
The path could be routed onto city sidewalk and
Sams River Road will become multi-purpose with connect to the existing path.
shared space for the river walk and vehicles.
In the future, the bike path could be extended
There will be at least one public non-motorized along or near the river.
boat launch along the river walk.

The requirement of a river walk with specific

details will be placed in any future ordinance
or policy related to the river walk to ensure
uniformity.

Above: Former parking lot that could be the location

of the bike path along Mound Avenue

28 Back to the Root: An Urban River Revitalization Plan (July 2008)

Appendix D: Belle Harbor Concept 6

Back to the Root: An Urban River Revitalization Plan (July 2008) 29

30 Back to the Root: An Urban River Revitalization Plan (July 2008)
Appendix E: Park Recommendations
This section provides recommended river edge the river in this park need to have limited foot traffic.
maintenance and public access for each park along the An educational effort needs to take place to increase
Root River. awareness of this issue with fishermen, especially in
peak fishing seasons in spring and fall when many out-
Quarry Park of-state fisherman utilize the river.
This Racine County Park is the first park below the
Horlick Dam. This is a destination kayaking site, To increase viewing opportunities in this park, a bench
however, there is no designated boat launch. Repeated should be placed upstream of the steelhead facility.
boat launching can cause bank erosion.
We recommend a boat launch in this park. Brose Park
Only a short piece of Root River goes through Brose
Colonial Park Park. One side is privately owned, and stabilized with
This park is the most ecologically sensitive park along stones or a wall. The other side is rocky with difficult
the river. There are ongoing efforts to remove boating access. However, it is suitable for fishing
non-native and invasive species and several plant access and has a nice pavilion for the public.
restoration projects in this park. The river edge is
already vegetated and includes many trees. This park Island Park
should have no formal boat or viewing access. In the non-recreation areas (ball fields), it is important
that vegetative buffers are maintained in this park,
Lincoln Park especially along the western branch of the river. In
The Department of Natural Resources steelhead August 2007 and June 2008, when the river was over
facility creates a challenge in Lincoln Park. To help its capacity, the park land demonstrated its function for
boaters portage around the weir the existing, but handling flood waters. Without vegetation on the river
unused, DNR boat ramp upstream of the weir needs banks, it is likely that the bank and soil would have
to be modified. The large rocks at the end of the ramp been washed away during the flood.
need to be rearranged to both stabilize the bank and
allow easier access by boaters. A boat launch could be added near the north parking
lot. This could also be a good location for a buffer/
Downstream of the weir a simple boat launch needs rain garden to address parking lot runoff. We suggest
to be created, similar to the one in Clayton Park to contacting the Root Pike WINs Rain Garden Initiative
allow for safe access to the river. There is a section and requesting information on being a demonstration
of the bank currently used by paddlers that can be site for 2009.
modified with a launch. The launch should be kept
within the no fishing zone section of the river Riverside Park and Horlick Drive
to alleviate conflicts with fishermen. This park is There is a lot of honeysuckle (a non-native and
used by fisherman daily because of the location of invasive species) in this area. It should be cut and the
the steelhead facility. Therefore, a high amount of stumps should be painted with glyphosate (herbicide).
fishing access should be made available in this park. Leave the roots, in order to avoid destabilizing the
However, consideration needs to be made for bank banks. Removing honeysuckle will open the views
stabilization. to the river. If it seems too open, other native shrubs
could be planted. In some areas the banks are being
Sedimentation is one of the largest water quality issues undercut and need stabilization. The DNR should be
for the Root River. Excessive foot traffic on river consulted for recommendations. Hard materials such
banks can cause soil erosion, which is harmful to fish. as rip rap should only be used if softer methods
A large section of bank fell into the river several such as bio-logs are not adequate stabilization for that
years ago and the bank had to be stabilized at great section of the river.
expense. To avoid this situation, certain sections of
Back to the Root: An Urban River Revitalization Plan (July 2008) 31
Park District Recommendations Continued

Cedar Bend Park The park is in need of new volunteers to maintain the
We need to go back to this park before vegetation, which should include early season mowing
recommendations are made. The bike path stays along to reduce the weeds and encourage the native plants.
the edge of the park and city streets. It is also a small Prescribed burning can accomplish this as well, but
park. can be more difficult to arrange and manage in an
urban setting.
Clayton Park
There is a nice simple boat launch in this park, but Suggested native shrubs
few people know about it. This is an example of why
new River Park District signs need to be created. The Ninebark Physocarpus apulifolia
launch area also doubles as fishing access. Witch hazel Hamamelis virginiana
Nannyberry Virburnum lentago
This park should have one bench for viewing added American highbush cranberry V. trilobum
between the boat launch and the bike pathway railing Blackhaw viburnum V. prunifoilum
as shown in the conceptual drawing. Hazelnut Corylus americanum
Black chokeberry Aronia melanocarpa
Barbee Park Elderberry Sambucus canadensis
This park was created when the bike pathway was Red osier dogwood Cornus stolonifera
constructed. It was dedicated to the late Alderman Eastern wahoo Euonymus atropurpurea
Bob Barbee. The park is intended to be an urban
green space and had been maintained by volunteers.

32 Back to the Root: An Urban River Revitalization Plan (July 2008)

Appendix F: Publications Reviewed
The following is a sample of publications the Root River Council reviewed to provide background to this plan.

Baseline Assessment of Root River Water Quality Within the City of Racine
http://www.cityofracine.org/Depts/health/root_river_assessments.aspx

City of Racine Root River Pathway Bike Path

http://www.cityofracine.org/Depts/public_works/bicycle_paths.aspx

DNR State of the Basin Report, 2002

http://www.dnr.state.wi.us/org/gmu/rootpike/watersheds/rootriver.htm

EPA 303d Designation

http://dnr.wi.gov/org/water/wm/wqs/303d/303d.html

MMSD Water Quality Initiative

http://www.mmsd.com/wqi/publications.cfm#rootriver v

Racine 3rd District-Neighborhood Revitalization, Jude Gagliano, Sustainable Racine, 2000

Racine Downtown Plan
www.racinedowntown.com/d-plan.html

Racine Outfall Assessment Report

http://www.cityofracine.org/depts/public_works/storm_sewers_drains.aspx

Racine Park and Open Space Plan, 2003

http://www.sewrpc.org/publications/capr/capr-270_park_plan_city_racine.pdf

Reconnecting Racine: Transforming and Industrial Riverfront Into a Neighborhood, Jill Matthews Thesis- 1999

Re-Rooting, Richard Pipeks Thesis

SEWRPC Regional Water Quality Management Plan Update

http://www.sewrpc.org/waterqualityplan/

Suggested Highway and Streetscape Concepts for the Highway 20/Sixth Street Reconstruction and
Enhancement Project

Back to the Root: An Urban River Revitalization Plan (July 2008) 33